Ovarian cancer identified through screening with serum markers but not by pelvic imaging

Abstract. Woolas RP, Oram DH, Jeyarajah AR, Bast RC Jr, Jacobs IJ. Ovarian cancer identified through screening with serum markers but not by pelvic imaging.
This study evaluated the possible role of 3 additional tumor markers to CA 125 among postmenopausal volunteers participating in a sequential multimodal ovarian cancer screening study. In 82 asymptomatic women the finding of a serum CA 125 level of > 30 U/ml precipitated pelvic ultrasound examination. Levels of CA15–3, CA72–4 and CA19–9 were subsequently determined in sera stored from the time of the CA 125 assay. Following ultrasound 29 women underwent surgery for benign conditions. The remaining 53 women underwent 2 years of surveillance. In 5 of these women a diagnosis of ovarian cancer was established between 6 and 10 months after their initial investigation. Elevated levels of at least one of the 3 additional tumor markers were present in the serum, prior to ultrasound abnormalities being detected, in 4 (80%) of the women who developed cancer. At least one of this 3-marker panel was elevated in 29% of the 48 women who have not developed cancer and 14% of the 29 women undergoing surgery for benign conditions. Information complementary to pelvic ultrasound examination for the preclinical detection of ovarian cancer could be obtained through multiple marker assay. Coordinated elevated serum levels of tumor markers could increase the sensitivity of this sequential screening protocol.     

Elevation of serum CA 125 prior to diagnosis of an epithelial ovarian carcinoma

In a single fortuitous case it has been possible to measure serum levels of CA 125 during 3 years preceding the diagnosis of an epithelial ovarian carcinoma. CA 125 levels were elevated 10-12 months prior to clinical detection of the malignancy. CA 125 deserves further evaluation as a marker for early detection of ovarian cancer.     

The value of CA 125 determination in the serum of patients with ovarian cancer

The circulating ovarian cancer associated antigen CA 125 was determined in serum of 63 patients with ovarian malignancies by radioimmunometric solid phase assay using the monoclonal antibody OC 125 as catcher and tracer. The results of 41 patients with 43 active tumour situations were compared with the CA 125 serum levels of 27 patients without recurrence after therapy of ovarian cancer and 49 benign ovarian tumours. Significant differences exist between these three groups (p less than 0.001) with elevated values (greater than 35 U/ml) in 84 per cent in ovarian carcinoma, 22 per cent in benign tumours and nought per cent in woman without recurrence in follow-up. The pre-operative sensitivity in ovarian cancer is 93 per cent (in epithelial carcinoma 96 per cent) with a distinct dependence of the CA 125 serum levels on the stage of the disease (stage III and IV versus stage I and II; p less than 0.01). A positive correlation of CA 125 values to clinical status was found in 82 per cent in follow-up. Increasing values of CA 125 can detect the recurrence any months earlier than the clinical examination. Decreasing serum levels in chemotherapy don't reflect the objective tumour remission in every case. Because of elevated values in benign and inflammatory adnexal tumours and the relative low sensitivity in borderline cases (three of seven patients greater than 35 U/ml) the CA 125 assay seems not be suitable for a screening method. However it is a substantial amplification in control of therapeutic success and an early detection of recurrence of ovarian cancer disease.     

Combination assay of CA125, TPA, IAP, CEA, and ferritin in serum for ovarian cancer

The levels of CA125, TPA, IAP, CEA, and ferritin in the serum were measured simultaneously in 68 healthy nonpregnant females and 133 patients with various gynecological diseases, and were subjected to statistical discriminant analysis for the diagnosis of ovarian cancer. The usefulness and the limits for diagnosis of various gynecological diseases were investigated for each tumor marker. Also, the diagnostic usefulness of the stepwise discriminant analysis employing the values of these five tumor markers in the serum in cases of ovarian cancer was compared with that of CA125 measurements alone. Because the frequency of cases with an elevated serum CA125 level increased more specifically in the ovarian cancer group than those of other tumor makers in the serum, this parameter was considered to be more useful for the diagnosis of ovarian cancer than the levels of the other tumor markers. The frequencies of cases with the elevated serum CA125 levels, however, also increased in the groups of patients with endometriosis and at an early stage of normal pregnancy more than in the group of healthy nonpregnant females. In the ovarian cancer patients, the discriminant analysis employing the values of CA125 and four other tumor markers in sera was more useful for early diagnosis, differential diagnosis, early detection of recurrences, and the determination of complete remission after therapy than the measurement of the serum CA125 level alone.     

CA125 expression at clinical diagnosis by ovarian carcinoma not detected through antecedent serum CA125 screening

At the time of clinical presentation with ovarian carcinoma, 85% of women have an elevated serum level of the CA125 antigen, but the duration of the preclinical phase of expression of CA125 is unknown. From the database of The Royal London Hospital ovarian cancer screening project, 19 women were identified who had a serum CA125 level <30 IU ml⁻¹, measured between 2 and 24 months prior to their clinical diagnosis of ovarian cancer. Histological sections of tumor removed from these women were reviewed. In 17 cases tumor tissue was immunocytochemically stained for CA125 expression. Tumor blocks of 40 women presenting clinically with ovarian cancer with known preoperative CA125 levels were also stained for CA125 expression. The serum CA125 level at the time of diagnosis was available in six of the 19 screening study cases, four of which had levels> 30 IU ml⁻¹. In five of the 13 cases with unknown serum CA125 levels, ovarian tumor tissue expressed CA125. Among the 40 controls, 24 tumors expressed CA125 and all 24 had a serum level greater than 47 IU ml⁻¹. An annual screening test using serum levels of CA125 at a cut-off of 30 IU ml⁻¹, cannot detect all cases of ovarian cancer that express the antigen at the time of clinical diagnosis. The development of a panel of complementary tumor markers will be necessary to provide a test with a higher sensitivity for the detection of preclinical ovarian cancer.     

CA125 and transvaginal ultrasound monitoring in high-risk women cannot prevent the diagnosis of advanced ovarian cancer

OBJECTIVES: The main objective of screening is to identify cases of ovarian cancer in early stages. However, screening of women in the general population is ineffective due to a failure of detecting early-stage disease and high false positive rates of CA125 and transvaginal ultrasound (TVU) monitoring. The purpose of this study is to evaluate ovarian cancer screening by means of pelvic examination, serum CA125 and TVU in a consecutive series of high-risk women. METHODS: Clinical data were collected from 132 BRCA1, 20 BRCA2 germ line mutation carriers, 72 members of hereditary breast and ovarian cancer (HBOC) families and 88 breast cancer patients from a hereditary breast cancer (HBC) family, seen between January 1996 and December 2002. RESULTS: Among 10 women with an elevated CA125 level and a positive TVU, three screening carcinomas (one FIGO stage IC, one stage IIIB and one stage IV) and one interval carcinoma (stage IV) were detected. Five occult ovarian/fallopian tube carcinomas (two stage IA, one stage IC, one stage IIIB and one stage IV) after bilateral prophylactic (salpingo-) oophorectomy (BP(S)O) have been found in 152 women. The sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive values (PPV and NPV) of the combination of CA125 and TVU were the highest (40%, 99%, 40% and 99%) followed by CA125 alone (50%, 96%, 13% and 99%), pelvic exam (40%, 98%, 21% and 99%) and TVU, separately (40%, 90%, 6% and 99%). CONCLUSION: By combining CA125 with TVU results, a PPV of 40% was achieved. However, the diagnostic tools appear to be only sensitive in detecting ovarian cancer at an advanced stage, while three of four tumors with early-stage disease in this series had normal screening tests prior to the diagnosis.     

Serum sICAM-1 (soluble intercellular adhesion molecule-1) and M-CSF (macrophage colony-stimulating growth factor) throughout monitoring of 34 non-serous ovarian cancers

PURPOSE: Evaluation of serum ICAM-1 (soluble intercellular adhesion molecule-1) and M-CSF (macrophage colony-stimulating growth factor) determinations for monitoring patients with non-serous ovarian cancers. METHODS: ELISA assay of sICAM-1 (cut-off 235 ng/ml) and M-CSF (cut-off 450 pg/ml) in 190 blood samples from 34 patients. RESULTS: In pre-treatment sera (n=17), sICAM-1 was over the cut-off in 12/17 (70.6%), M-CSF in 14/17 (82.4%) and CA 125 in 12/16 (75%). sICAM-1 was related only to age at diagnosis (p=0.0008). M-CSF was positively correlated to FIGO stage (p=0.04) CA 125 was elevated in 90.9% of adenocarcinomas (p=0.033 vs other). None of the 3 biological markers were related to other clinico-pathological criteria. Among disease-free patients, higher median concentrations of sICAM-1 and M-CSF were recorded under adjuvant treatment than without (p=0.014, and p=0.08, respectively). After relapse, the highest levels of sICAM-1, M-CSF and CA 125 were observed in progressive disease (46/53, 86.8% (p=0.014), 51/53 96.2% (p=0.008) and 46/52 88.5% (p>0.05), respectively). CONCLUSION: In non-serous ovarian cancers, sICAM-1 although elevated in most cases, is not useful for monitoring. Serum M-CSF is a valuable marker when ovarian tumours do not express CA 125.     

Evaluation of the novel serum markers B7-H4, Spondin 2, and DcR3 for diagnosis and early detection of ovarian cancer

OBJECTIVE: Early detection through regular screening could significantly reduce mortality from ovarian cancer. Advances in biomarkers and imaging continue to improve the sensitivity and specificity of cancer detection, but further improvements are still needed. In this study, we identified and evaluated three new serum biomarkers that may be used to improve detection of ovarian cancer. METHODS: Through genomic analysis, we identified B7-H4, Spondin 2, and DcR3 as over-expressed genes in ovarian cancer tissues. Sensitive sandwich ELISAs were developed to analyze the level of these novel markers in 68 serum samples from patients with ovarian cancer (16 early stage, 52 late stage) and 108 control samples, and 20 healthy women from which two serum samples were collected 1 year apart. CA125 levels were measured in all samples. RESULTS: Markers were evaluated for their ability to identify clinical disease. The three novel markers and CA125 were elevated in serum of ovarian cancer patients as compared to normal controls. B7-H4 showed the highest specificity, with the lowest frequency of elevation in all control groups. When all cases were compared against all controls, CA125, Spondin 2, B7-H4, and DcR3 showed areas under the ROC curve of 0.87, 0.78, 0.74, and 0.71, respectively. CA125 and B7-H4 showed the best diagnostic performance for early-stage, with AUCs of 0.90 and 0.80, respectively. CONCLUSION: This study demonstrates that B7-H4, Spondin 2, and DcR3 are promising new ovarian cancer markers that may improve early detection of cancer when used in combination with traditional diagnostic tests.     

Tumour-associated antigen CA 125 in patients with ovarian cancer

The serum levels of antigen CA 125 expressed by epithelial ovarian carcinoma were measured in 27 postmenopausal women with ovarian tumours and in 16 controls. Increased serum levels of CA 125 were found in nine (75%) out of 12 patients with ovarian cancer; in three with stage I disease levels were not elevated. No significant difference was found in the concentration of CA 125 detected in peripheral or ovarian venous blood. Decreased antigen levels were found 6-30 weeks after radical operation and cytostatic chemotherapy in the ovarian cancer group. The results indicate the value of measuring CA 125 as a tumour marker in the follow-up of ovarian cancer.     

Ultrasound, physical examination, and CA 125 measurement for the detection of recurrence after conservative surgery for early borderline ovarian tumors

BACKGROUND: Borderline ovarian tumors often affect women of childbearing age and the prognosis is outstanding. Given the young age of several patients and the good prognosis, fertility-sparing surgery is considered adequate for stage I tumors. However, women treated conservatively have a relatively small but well-defined risk of recurrence and no study has specifically addressed the optimal follow-up technique. METHODS: From 1981 to 1997, 164 women underwent fertility-sparing surgery for stage I borderline ovarian tumor and were followed prospectively. After surgery all women underwent physical examination and ultrasound examination every 3 months for 2 years after first diagnosis and every 6 months thereafter. Measurement of serum CA 125 levels was planned every 6 months in patients with a serous tumor. RESULTS: With a median follow-up of 71, months 28 women treated with fertility-sparing surgery (28/164 = 17%) had either recurrence of borderline tumor (23) or recurrence with carcinoma. Complete details of follow-up procedures are available for 24 women and they represent the study population. An abnormal adnexal mass was detected in 18 of 19 women with recurrent borderline tumor. One patient had diagnosis due to persistent free fluid. All five women with invasive carcinoma had diagnosis of a complex adnexal mass. Gynecologic examination was suspicious (palpable mass) in 7 cases and obviously abnormal (large mass or nodules) in another 7. CA 125 serum levels were elevated in 8 cases. CONCLUSION: Transvaginal ultrasound is currently the most effective diagnostic technique for the follow-up of young patients treated conservatively for early borderline ovarian tumor.     

Tumour-associated antigen CA 125 in patients with ovarian cancer

Summary. The serum levels of antigen CA 125 expressed by epithelial ovarian carcinoma were measured in 27 postmenopausal women with ovarian tumours and in 16 controls. Increased serum levels of CA 125 were found in nine (75%) out of 12 patients with ovarian cancer; in three with stage I disease levels were not elevated. No significant difference was found in the concentration of CA 125 detected in peripheral or ovarian venous blood. Decreased antigen levels were found 6–30 weeks after radical operation and cytostatic chemotherapy in the ovarian cancer group. The results indicate the value of measuring CA 125 as a tumour marker in the follow-up of ovarian cancer.     

Prospective evaluation of serum CA 125 levels in a normal population, phase I: The specificities of single and serial determinations in testing for ovarian cancer

To determine the potential efficacy of the CA 125 assay as one component of a strategy for early detection of ovarian malignancy, serum CA 125 levels were determined in 1082 women 40 years of age or older in Stockholm. Initial serum CA 125 levels exceeded 35 U/ml in 36 women (3.3%) and 65 U/ml in 11 women (1.0%), placing the exact 95% upper confidence limits on false positive rates for a single screen at 4.3 and 1.7%, respectively. Follow-up CA 125 levels were obtained for those women with initially elevated levels and a group of age-matched controls. Mean CA 125 levels declined significantly for women with initially elevated levels (P = 0.0014). Interindividual variation and variation within individual subjects over the entire follow-up period were 52 and 35%, respectively. Of the 36 subjects with initially elevated serum CA 125 levels, only 2 showed a doubling of these levels; in only 1 of these 2 was this increase sustained. Intensive clinical follow-up with pelvic examination and ultrasonography, with investigators blinded to CA 125 results, led to the diagnosis of Stage III ovarian cancer in the latter individual. Diagnosis was made 21 months after the initially elevated serum CA 125 measurement and 15 months after the first measured doubling of that level. Because no other malignancies were identified at entry or during the follow-up period (median 560 days) in the women with elevated CA 125 levels, the specificity of the assay over that time period would have been 99.9% using the doubling of an initially elevated value as the criterion for determining positivity and 100% using as the criterion a sustained increase in level for those with initially elevated levels that doubled. These results support the continued investigation of longitudinally collected CA 125 levels to identify individuals at high risk for ovarian malignancy.     

Serum levels of six tumor markers in patients with benign and malignant gynecological disease

Summary We studied the pretreatment serum levels of 6 tumor markers in gynecological patients with and without malignant disease. The tumor markers were carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA), tissue polypeptide antigen (TPA), ferritin, Schwangerschaftsprotein 1 (SP₁), Schwangerschaftsprotein 3 (SP₃) and cancer antigen 125 (CA125). The results were as follows: (1) Serum CA125 and TPA levels were raised in 81% and 57% of patients with ovarian serous cystadenocarcinoma: CEA and SP₃, in 52% and 43% respectively of patients with ovarian mucinous cystadenocarcinoma; CA125, TPA and SP₃, in 76%, 48% and 48% respectively of patients with other ovarian malignancies; and TPA and SP₃, in 56% and 40% respectively of patients with endometrial carcinoma. (2) Serum levels of TPA, ferritin and CA125 were more often raised with advancing stages of malignant disease. (3) Serum TPA levels were elevated in 55% of patients with stage I endometrial carcinoma, and serum SP₃ levels were elevated in 35% of patients with a stage I malignant ovarian neoplasm and in 45% of patients with endometrial carcinoma. (4) One of the 6 tumor markers showed a raised level in 84% of patients with gynecologic malignancy as against 56% in those with benign gynecologic diseases.     

The concomitant determination of different serum tumor markers in epithelial ovarian cancer: relevance for monitoring the response to chemotherapy and follow-up of patients.

The levels of CA125, CA19.9, CA15.3 CA72.4, and TATI were serially measured during and after chemotherapy in 43 patients with epithelial ovarian cancer having elevated concentrations of one or more of the antigens before initial surgery. The value of 35 U/ml was chosen as cutoff level of CA125 for the monitoring of disease. Changes in the serum levels of CA125, CA19.9, CA15.3, CA72.4, and TATI correlated with the clinical course of disease in 87.4% of 215, 76.3% of 80, 71.3% of 122, 76.0% of 167, and 48.5% of 101 instances, respectively. After the sixth course of monthly primary chemotherapy, elevated antigen levels were strong predictors of persistent disease, while normal antigen values were associated with both positive and negative second-look findings. It is worth noting that antigen levels above the cut-off limits before the third course, but still in the normal range after the sixth course, seemed to be predictive of positive second-look findings. Among patients with elevated antigen levels at diagnosis, clinical detection of neoplastic progression after treatment was stopped was preceded by an elevation of serum CA125 in 93.3% of 15 patients, of serum CA19.9 in 80.0% of 5 patients, of serum CA15.3 in 66.7% of 9 patients, of serum CA72.4 in 81.8% of 11 patients, and of serum TATI in 40% of 10 patients. In patients with positive CA125 assay at diagnosis, the concomitant evaluation of the other antigens did not seem to be of additional benefit for monitoring epithelial ovarian cancer. However, the measurement of the other tumor markers could represent an interesting biochemical tool for the management of patients with negative CA125 assay. In particular the evaluation of serum CA19.9 or CA72.4 could be very useful in the monitoring of patients with mucinous ovarian cancer, which often fails to express CA125 antigen.     

CA125 in ovarian cancer: European Group on Tumor Markers guidelines for clinical use

CA125 is currently the most widely used tumor marker for ovarian epithelial cancer. The aim of this article is to provide guidelines for the routine clinical use of CA125 in patients with ovarian cancer. Due to lack of sensitivity for stage I disease and lack of specificity, CA125 is of little value in the detection of early ovarian cancer. At present, therefore, CA125, either alone or in combination with other modalities, cannot be recommended for screening for ovarian cancer in asymptomatic women outside the context of a randomized controlled trial. Preoperative levels in postmenopausal women, however, may aid the differentiation of benign and malignant pelvic masses. Serial levels during chemotherapy for ovarian cancer are useful for assessing response to treatment. Although serial monitoring following initial chemotherapy can lead to the early detection of recurrent disease, the clinical value of this lead-time is unclear. CA125 is the ovarian cancer marker against which new markers for this malignancy should be judged.     

CA 125, placental alkaline phosphatase, and tissue polypeptide antigen in the monitoring of ovarian carcinoma. A comparative study of three different tumor markers

Three different tumor markers, placental alkaline phosphatase (PLAP), tissue polypeptide antigen (TPA), and cancer antigen 125 (CA 125), were measured in serum samples obtained during chemotherapy in 57 ovarian carcinoma patients. At the start of chemotherapy, 37, 63, and 77% had elevated serum values of PLAP, TPA, and CA 125, respectively. During chemotherapy, changing PLAP serum levels reflected disease regression and, later, progression in only 2 patients. TPA serum levels reflected the disease course in 15 patients and CA 125 in 28 patients. Rising CA 125 values predicted disease progression in 12 patients for a median of 2 months. At second-look laparotomy, all 11 patients with pathological complete response were marker negative. In the remaining 46 patients with residual or progressive disease, 27, 50, and 61% had elevated serum levels of PLAP, TPA, and CA 125, respectively. None of the markers reflected microscopic disease or pure carcinomatosis. For management decisions, CA 125 was clearly the most useful of the markers. In this study no further information was gained from the other two markers.     

Screening for ovarian cancer using serum CA125 and vaginal examination: report on 2550 females

This study was undertaken to assess the effectiveness of using serum CA125 and vaginal examination as a screening test for ovarian cancer in apparently healthy females. Two thousand five hundred and fifty healthy females aged 40 and over were recruited to participate in a screening study involving a questionnaire, serum CA125 measurement and vaginal examination. Females with either an elevated CA125 level or abnormal vaginal examination had a pelvic ultrasound performed as a secondary procedure. The positive predictive values of an elevated serum CA125 level, and a combination of CA125 level measurement and vaginal examination for ovarian cancer, were 1/100 and 1/3, respectively. The specificities of serum CA125 levels, vaginal examination and both in combination were 96.1%, 98.5% and 99.9%, respectively. In postmenopausal females the positive predictive values were improved with CA125 measurement alone, giving a positive predictive value of 1/24. Seventeen females underwent operative procedure as a result of the screening—only one of these was for an ovarian cancer. The combination of serum CA125 measurement and vaginal examination is not an effective screening test in the general population, although in postmenopausal females it does achieve acceptable specificities and positive predictive values.     

Serum markers as prognostic factors in epithelial ovarian cancer: an overview

A comprehensive review of the literature and the authors' personal experience on serum determination of tumour markers in epithelial ovarian cancer can be summarised as follows: CA 125 is the most reliable marker for monitoring the course of epithelial ovarian cancer; CA 125 assay is not an adequate screening test for this malignancy but it can represent an useful adjunct to clinical examination and ultrasound in the differential diagnosis of ovarian masses in postmenopausal women; Serial measurements of CA 125 are useful in monitoring the response to chemotherapy and follow-up. In patients with preoperative positive CA 125 assay, the concomitant determination of other tumour markers does not add further information when compared to CA 125 alone. Conversely in patients with preoperative negative assay the measurement of one or more of other antigens could be of clinical relevance.     

Meigs’ Syndrome with Elevated Serum CA 125 Levels: Two Case Reports and Review of the Literature

Two cases of Meigs’ syndrome in association with elevated serum CA 125 levels are reported. The significance of Meigs’ syndrome lies in the fact that neither ascites nor pleural effusion is necessarily an ominous sign in women with a pelvic tumor. Although there is a strong correlation between ovarian malignancy and elevated serum CA 125 levels, several benign conditions have been found to cause a rise in CA 125 levels. It is important to remember that a pelvic neoplasm in a woman presenting with hydrothorax, ascites, and elevated CA 125 levels might be benign and that this condition can rapidly be resolved with surgical removal. Neither ultrasound examination nor computed tomography can reliably offer a preoperative diagnosis.     

Monitoring human ovarian carcinoma with a combination of CA 125, CA 19-9, and carcinoembryonic antigen

CA 125 and CA 19-9 are antigenic determinants associated with human epithelial ovarian carcinomas. Murine monoclonal antibodies have been raised against these determinants, and immunoradiometric assays have been developed to monitor antigen levels in the serum of cancer patients. This study was undertaken to determine whether concomitant measurement of CA 125, CA 19-9, and carcinoembryonic antigen would provide a more precise correlation with tumor progression or regression than could be obtained with any single assay. Among 105 patients with surgically demonstrable epithelial ovarian carcinoma, serum CA 125 levels were elevated (greater than 35 U/ml) in 83%, CA 19-9, levels (greater than 37 U/ml) in 17%, and carcinoembryonic antigen levels (greater than or equal to 2.5 ng/ml) in 37%. Within individual samples, no correlation was found among values for the three markers, but patients with elevated CA 19-9 levels also had increased levels of CA 125. At least one of the three markers was elevated in 90% of the subjects. When 41 patients were monitored serially over 2 to 60 months, alterations in CA 125 levels correlated with disease progression or regression in 94% of instances, whereas alterations in CA 19-9 levels correlated in 33% and alterations in carcinoembryonic antigen levels in 25% of instances. Concomitant measurement of CA 125, CA 19-9, and carcinoembryonic antigen did not prove superior to measurement of CA 125 alone in the monitoring of patients with epithelial ovarian carcinoma.