Flow-induced platelet activation in a St. Jude mechanical heart valve, a trileaflet polymeric heart valve, and a St. Jude tissue valve

Polymer heart valves have been under investigation since the 1960s, but their success has been hampered by an overall lack of durability mainly due to calcification of the leaflets and a relatively high rate of thromboembolic complications. A new polymer (Quatromer) trileaflet design was tested for its thrombogenic potential and was compared to that of existing prosthetic heart valves routinely implanted in patients: a St. Jude Medical bileaflet mechanical heart valve (MHV) and a St. Jude porcine bioprosthetic tissue valve. The valves were mounted in a left ventricular assist device and the procoagulant activity of the platelets was measured using a platelet activation state (PAS) assay. The PAS measurements indicated that the platelet activation level induced by the polymeric valve was very similar to that induced by the St. Jude Medical MHV and the St. Jude tissue valve. No significant difference was observed between the three valves, indicating that they have a comparable thrombogenic potential.     

St. Jude Medical prosthetic aortic valve malfunction due to pannus formation.

According to the literature, the incidence of pannus formation with the St. Jude Medical prosthetic aortic valve has been reported at 0.03% and 0.14% (per patient-year), with no case report of St. Jude Medical prosthetic aortic valve malfunction due to pannus formation. Between 1980 and 1999, 1,186 patients underwent aortic valve replacement at our institute. We encountered 2 aortic valve malfunctions due to pannus formation, including the case of a 53-year-old woman who suffered a St. Jude medical aortic valve malfunction 13 years after the initial operation. A second aortic valve replacement was successful and the postoperative course was uneventful. The possibility of pannus formation on St. Jude Medical aortic valves must thus be considered and its mechanism clarified.     

Hemodynamic and hemolytic features of the St. Jude Medical valve prostheses

We performed valvular replacement in 86 cases (108 valves, 43 males, 43 females) from July 1978 to July 1981 with St. Jude Medical valves which utilize two discs made of pyrolytic carbon and employ a bileaflet central opening system. Ages ranged from 13 to 68 years (average 42.3). For all cases in this study, we performed anti-coagulant therapy. The incidence of thromboembolic complication was zero. With regard to postoperative clinical evaluation on valve function and chronic hemolysis, we compared the cases of St. Jude Medical valves with those of Starr-Edwards (S.E.) valves (aortic: Model 2320, mitral: Model 6400), Carpentier-Edwards (C.E.) valves and cases of open mitral commissurotomy. As for valve function such as left atrioventricular diastolic pressure gradient, mitral effective orifice area both at rest and on exercise, the St. Jude Medical valve yielded best results. Next was the C.E. and third was the S.E. The results of the St. Jude Medical valve group and those of the open mitral commissurotomy group were equivalent. In comparison with ball type cardiac valve prostheses and bioprostheses, the St. Jude Medical valve has excellent hemodynamic characteristic. Concerning hemolysis, the St. Jude Medical was below only the C.E., however the degree of hemolysis was so low that the St. Jude Medical valve holds great promise as central flow mechanical valve prostheses.     

Mitral and mitro-aortic valve replacement with Sorin Bicarbon valves compared with St. Jude Medical valves

OBJECTIVE: We assessed the clinical results of two bileaflet mechanical valves: the St. Jude Medical (SJM) and the Sorin Bicarbon (Sorin Bicarbon) used either in single mitral valve replacement (MVR) or in double, aortic and mitral, valve replacement (DVR). METHODS: Between September 1990 and November 1995, 217 patients received either a St. Jude Medical (n=134) or a Sorin Bicarbon (n=86): 136 mitral valve replacement with 83 St. Jude Medical and 53 Sorin Bicarbon and 84 double valve replacement with 51 St. Jude Medical and 33 Sorin Bicarbon. There was no difference between both St. Jude Medical and Sorin Bicarbon cohorts in respect of mitral valve physiopathology, etiology of valve disease, associated lesions, echocardiographic and hemodynamic data. The only significant preoperative difference was the age of patients within the double valve replacement group and the size of implanted valves within the mitral valve replacement group. Follow-up was 100% complete with a mean of 39+/-18 months, ranging between 6 and 68 months. The total follow-up was 657 patient-years (pt-y): 396 pt-y in the mitral valve replacement group and 274 pt-y in the double valve replacement group. RESULTS: Hospital mortality (St. Jude Medical: 2.2%; Sorin Bicarbon: 6.9%) and late mortality (St. Jude Medical: 8.4%; Sorin Bicarbon: 6.3%) were not significantly different. Ten deaths were considered valve-related (St. Jude Medical 6, Sorin Bicarbon 4). The estimated 4-yr overall survival, including hospital mortality, was for St. Jude Medical--mitral valve replacement: 89+/-4% and St. Jude Medical--double valve replacement: 93+/-4%, and for Sorin Bicarbon--mitral valve replacement: 87+/-5% and Sorin Bicarbon--double valve replacement: 91+/-5%. The linearized incidence (% per pt-y) of valve-related complications was 6.39 in the St. Jude Medical cohort and 9.2 in the Sorin Bicarbon cohort. The linearized incidence (% pt-y) of the prevalent complication, valve thromboembolism and bleeding, was for St. Jude Medical-mitral valve replacement: 3.41, St. Jude Medical--double valve replacement: 3.16 and for Sorin Bicarbon--mitral valve replacement: 2.17 and Sorin Bicarbon--double valve replacement: 3.67. The differences between each group of an estimated 4-yr freedom from combined thromboembolism and bleeding were not significant (St. Jude Medical--mitral valve replacement: 90+/-4%, St. Jude Medical--double valve replacement: 84+/-6%, and for Sorin Bicarbon--mitral valve replacement: 94+/-3% and Sorin Bicarbon--double valve replacement: 75+/-17%). CONCLUSIONS: In this clinical non-randomized study, there was no evidence of any significant difference between St. Jude Medical and Sorin Bicarbon valves over a 4-yr follow-up.     

Experience with St. Jude Medical valve prosthesis in children. A word of caution regarding right-sided placement

Thirty-six children aged 6 months to 18 years, underwent insertion of 37 St. Jude Medical cardiac prostheses. In 20, the valve was placed in the aortic or mitral position, and in 16 in the pulmonary or tricuspid position. There was one (2.8%) hospital death. All patients received maintenance doses of salicylates and dipyridamole after the operation. Follow-up data are available for all patients for 12 to 24 postoperative months. There was no incidence of valve dysfunction or thromboembolic complication in any of the 20 patients with valves in the systemic (left) side of the circulation, and all manifested improvement in their functional class. In contrast, six (37%) of the 16 patients with valves in the pulmonary (right) side of the circulation developed dysfunction of the prosthesis 1 to 6 months after insertion. Prosthesis failure was associated with fibrous tissue growing into the struts, leading to leaflet immobilization. At 2 years, the actuarial functional life was 100% for mitral and aortic valves and 70% for pulmonary and tricuspid valves. The data illustrate the excellent hemodynamic function of the St. Jude Medical valve in children. The absence of thromboembolic complications warrant continued implantation of the prosthesis in the left side without warfarin anticoagulation therapy, but the high incidence of valve dysfunction in the pulmonary position does not justify its continued use in the right side.     

Long-term follow-up of St. Jude Medical valve

St. Jude Medical bileaflet valve replacement was performed on 182 patients--aortic in 90, mitral in 70, both sites in 20 and tricuspid in two. The 30-day mortality was 4.3%, and was related to poor preoperative condition (NYHA class III or IV). The late mortality during observation up to 8 years was 9.3%, with actuarial survival 87.4% at 5 years and 86.3% at 8 years. For aortic, mitral and double valve replacement the respective 8-year figures were 88, 87.3 and 76.2%. Late death was associated with high preoperative pulmonary vascular resistance in five cases, dysrhythmia in four, myocardial infarction in two, thromboembolism, paravalvular leakage, prosthetic endocarditis or bleeding, each in one case, and was accidental in two cases. Calculated per 100 patient years the incidence of late thromboembolic events was 1.0, of bleeding complications 0.9 and of prosthetic valve endocarditis and paravalvular leak 0.26 (8, 7, 2 and 2 cases). The NYHA class in the 144 cases available for follow-up was I in 63%, II in 27% and III in 10%. The St. Jude Medical prosthesis thus was reliable, with good long-term performance.     

In vivo hemodynamics of prosthetic St. Jude Medical and Ionescu-Shiley heart valves analyzed by computer

Using a method of our own design, we evaluated intraoperatively the function of prosthetic heart valves. The changing hemodynamics induced by a stress test were assessed by simultaneously measuring the mean transvalvular pressure gradient and the stroke volume. The effective orifice area (EOA) of the valves was determined for each stroke by computer analysis, and this value was compared with the actual orifice area. Data were collected from 19 patients undergoing aortic or mitral valve replacement or both with 17 St. Jude Medical and 12 Ionescu-Shiley valves. The mean pressure gradient increased with tachycardia and an increase in mean left atrial pressure in the mitral position, but decreased with a decrease in cardiac output and peak left ventricular pressure in the aortic position. The St. Jude Medical valve had a smaller mean pressure gradient than the Ionescu-Shiley bioprosthesis. For both valves, the EOA increased with valve size. The St. Jude Medical valve had a greater EOA than the Ionescu-Shiley bioprosthesis, regardless of the valve size (p less than 0.005). However, the performance of prosthetic leaflets was better with the Ionescu-Shiley bioprosthesis than with the St. Jude Medical mechanical valve (p less than 0.001). This method involving computer analysis of each cardiac cycle proved to be useful for evaluating prosthetic heart valve function in the presence of changing hemodynamics.     

Evaluation of valve sound and its effects on ATS prosthetic valves in patients' quality of life

BACKGROUND: We interviewed patients and carried out frequency analyses to compare the closing sounds of ATS and St. Jude Medical (SJM) prosthetic valves. METHODS: Forty-five patients undergoing valve replacements using ATS valves were investigated. We interviewed patients at 1 month and 1 year after the operation, and carried out frequency analysis to investigate the prosthetic valve's closing sound. RESULTS: According to the results of the interviews, 84.4% of patients with ATS valves were not aware of the valve sounds. ATS valves scored significantly lower than SJM valves on audibility of the valve sound, disturbance during daytime, sleep disturbance, request for replacement with a soundless prosthetic valve, audibility to others, and noise index. According to the frequency analysis on the prosthetic valve's closing sound, the sound peak of the ATS valves was around 1.2 kHz, and the sound pressure of the ATS valves was significantly lower than that of the SJM valves. CONCLUSIONS: Though a further long-term observation on thromboembolism and hemolysis is needed for evaluation of prosthetic valves, the ATS valve is presently considered to impart a better quality of life.     

Ten-year follow-up after valve replacement with the St. Jude Medical prosthesis in children

Since 1979, 50 children, 4 months to 15 years of age, have successfully undergone cardiac valve replacement with the St. Jude Medical prosthesis (St. Jude Medical, Inc., St. Paul, Minn.). There were 24 boys and 26 girls. The valve replaced was mitral in 28 children, aortic in 15, mitral and aortic in 1, and mitral and tricuspid in 1. A left-sided tricuspid valve was replaced in 3 children. Anticoagulant therapy was maintained in all children; 40 children were treated with warfarin, whereas 10 children who underwent aortic or mitral valve replacement were on a regimen of aspirin combined with dipyridamole. The follow-up period, comprising 224 patient-years, ranged from 1 to 10 years. There were four valve-related complications: one from thromboembolism, two from valve thrombosis, and the other one from prosthetic valve endocarditis. Actuarial rate free from all valve-related complications at 10 years was 84.7%. There were four late deaths: one from valve thrombosis and the others from non-valve-related complications. Actuarial survival rate at 10 years was 90.8%. All surviving children are in functional class I, and no child so far has needed replacement of a prosthesis because of somatic growth. These results indicate that the St. Jude Medical prosthesis is a cardiac valve substitute of choice for valve replacement in children.     

The St. Jude experience

This paper covers our experience with the use of the St. Jude prosthetic heart valve from November 1979 through August 1983 in 91 patients operated on for aortic and mitral valve replacement. Nonfatal complications included hemorrhagic sequela due to anticoagulation, with an annual rate of 1 percent (1.4 percent per 100 patient years), thromboembolism with an annual rate of 0.8 percent (0.87 percent per 100 patient years), sternal infection 1 percent, operative cardiovascular accident 1 percent, and pericardial tamponade 1 percent.Operative mortality was 1 percent, early mortality (within 30 days) was 3 percent, and late mortality was 3 percent, with a total overall mortality of 7 percent. Excluding two patients who died from noncardiac causes, the overall mortality was 5 percent. The mortality rate per year was 2 percent. The survival rate 3.8 years postoperatively was 89 percent for mitral valve replacement patients and 93 percent for aortic valve replacement patients, for an overall 38 year survival rate of 92 percent. All patients were anticoagulated with warfarin. There were no instances of valve failure, replacement, or serious hemolysis. Eighty-three percent were active or working with a New York heart functional class I.In our experience, the complication rate with the St. Jude valve is as low or lower than that for any other mechanical prosthetic cardiac valve available in the world today.     

Assessment of effective orifice area of prosthetic aortic valves with Doppler echocardiography: an in vivo and in vitro study

OBJECTIVES: We sought to evaluate the Doppler assessment of effective orifice area in aortic prosthetic valves. The effective orifice area is a less flow-dependent parameter than Doppler gradients that is used to assess prosthetic valve function. However, in vivo reference values show a pronounced spread of effective orifice area and smaller orifices than expected compared with the geometric area. METHODS: Using Doppler echocardiography, we studied patients who received a bileaflet St Jude Medical valve (n = 75; St Jude Medical, Inc, St Paul, Minn) or a tilting disc Omnicarbon valve (n = 46; MedicalCV, Incorporated, Inver Grove Heights, Minn). The prosthetic valves were also investigated in vitro in a steady-flow model with Doppler and catheter measurements in the different orifices. The effective orifice area was calculated according to the continuity equation. RESULTS: In vivo, there was a wide distribution with the coefficient of variation (SD/mean x 100%) for different valve sizes ranging from 21% to 39% in the St Jude Medical valve and from 25% to 33% in the Omnicarbon valve. The differences between geometric orifice area and effective orifice area in vitro were 1.26 +/- 0.41 cm(2) for St Jude Medical and 1.17 +/- 0.38 cm(2) for Omnicarbon valves. The overall effective orifice areas and peak catheter gradients were similar: 1.35 +/- 0.37 cm(2) and 25.9 +/- 16.1 mm Hg for St Jude Medical and 1.46 +/- 0.49 cm(2) and 24.6 +/- 17.7 mm Hg for Omnicarbon. However, in St Jude Medical valves, more pressure was recovered downstream, 11.6 +/- 6.3 mm Hg versus 3.4 +/- 1.6 mm Hg in Omnicarbon valves (P =.0001). CONCLUSIONS: In the patients, we found a pronounced spread of effective orifice areas, which can be explained by measurement errors or true biologic variations. The in vitro effective orifice area was small compared with the geometric orifice area, and we suspect that nonuniformity in the spatial velocity profile causes underestimation. The St Jude Medical and Omnicarbon valves showed similar peak catheter gradients and effective orifice areas in vitro, but more pressure was recovered in the St Jude Medical valve. The effective orifice area can therefore be misleading in the assessment of prosthetic valve performance when bileaflet and tilting disc valves are compared.     

Aortic and mitral valve replacement with the St. Jude Medical prosthesis

From April 1, 1979 to August 31, 1983, 228 patients underwent isolated aortic (AVR) (118) or mitral (MVR) (90) valve replacements with a new tilting disc valve prosthesis, the St. Jude prosthesis, at the Medical University of South Carolina. Age ranged from 6 to 84 years (mean 49.1 +/- 19.2 AVR, 44.5 +/- 16.5 MVR). Male sex predominated in the AVR group (68%) and female sex in the MVR group (68%). Thirty-five patients (16.8%) had associated coronary bypass surgery (AVR 23.7%, MVR 7.8%). There were seven deaths (3.4%) occurring during the same hospitalization (AVR: 3/118, 2.5%; MVR: 4/90, 4.4%). Follow-up is 97.6% complete and ranges from 1 to 54 months (mean 19.6 +/- 12.4). In the AVR group, nine late deaths have occurred and actuarial survival at 42 months is 86.7 +/- 3.8%. Three patients have sustained thromboembolic episodes for a linearized rate of 1.6% patient-year, and the probability of remaining free of thromboembolism at 42 months is 96.9 +/- 1.8%. The mean improvement in functional class from preoperative to postoperative is 3.1 +/- 0.7 to 1.2 +/- 0.4 (p less than 0.001). In the MVR group, there have been four late deaths, and the actuarial survival at 42 months is 89.3 +/- 3.8%. Two patients have sustained thromboembolic complications for a linearized rate of 1.2%/patient-year, and the probability of remaining free of thromboembolism at 42 months is 97.2 +/- 2%. The mean improvement in functional class from before to after surgery is 3.2 +/- 0.7 to 1.3 +/- 0.5 (p less than 0.001). There have been no thromboses of the St. Jude valve in the mitral or aortic position, no mechanical failures, and no patient has had significant valve-related hemolysis. Because of this experience, the St. Jude Medical heart valve prosthesis is our prosthesis of choice for any patient undergoing valve replacement with a mechanical prosthesis.     

Surgical treatment of the prosthetic valves in reoperation

Surgical treatment and problems in patients required reoperation for malfunctioning prosthetic valves are reviewed in our institute. The cinefluoroscopy and pulse doppler echocardiography were helpful for diagnosis of artificial valve dysfunction. In recent two decades valve replacement were performed in 382 cases and number of re-implanted valve were 469. Among them the cases of reoperation were 21 and reimplanted valves were 25 (5.6%); 4.7% in aortic, 5.0% in mitral, 6.7% in tricuspid position. Three cases of those patients had three operations. Main causes of reoperation were primary tissue failure in Carpentier-Edwards porcine xenograft (6 cases, 23%) and cloth wear in Starr-Edwards ball valve (9 cases, 38%) and thrombosis in St. Jude Medical bi-leaflet valve (3 cases, 15%). In most cases St. Jude Medical valve were chosen for the alternative prosthetic valve in reoperation. We applied IABP support to seven patients for severe low cardiac output syndrome after the operation and overall mortality was 24% in reoperation. It concluded that St. Jude Medical valve may be most reliable because of low incidence of postoperative complication in our institute.     

Clinical comparison of St. Jude and porcine mitral valve prostheses

One hundred and six consecutive patients who had mitral valve replacement with either a St. Jude or porcine heterograft prosthesis were prospectively studied. The 2 groups are similar with respect to 67 clinical and operative factors and allow comparison of valve performance as an independent variable. Total follow-up is 3,312 patient-months (mean 36 months, range 2-57 months, 94% complete). There are no statistical differences in symptomatic improvement or mortality by life table analysis. Valve-related complications expressed as percent per patient-year are: reoperation: 1.8 St. Jude and 3.8 porcine; endocarditis: 1.2 and 1.9; regurgitant murmur: 2.3 and 1.9; hemolysis: 1.8 and 0.0; late thromboembolism: 1.8 and 1.0; hemorrhage: 2.9 and 2.9; and valve failure: 0.0 and 1.0. There were no significant differences found. Actuarial survival at 3 years was 78% in St. Jude and 81% in porcine patients. Forty-six percent of patients with St. Jude valves and 55% of patients with porcine valves were alive and free of all complications at latest follow-up. The clinical performance of St. Jude and porcine mitral valves are similar over this period of intermediate follow-up.     

Mitral valve replacement using bileaflet mechanical prosthetic valve in the first year of life.

OBJECTIVE: The operative management and long term outcome of mitral valve replacement in infancy remain a therapeutic challenge. The selection of a prosthetic valve for this particular age group might affect the clinical outcome. Here we present our experience of mitral valve replacement in 6 infants using small bileaflet mechanical prosthetic valves. METHODS: Between January 1994 and August 1997, 6 infants (their age ranged from 3 months to 11 months, and their body weight from 2978 g to 7403 g) underwent mitral valve replacement using a mechanical valve prosthesis (16 mm CarboMedics prosthetic valve in 5, and 17 mm St. Jude Medical prosthetic valve Hemodynamic Plus in 1). The preoperative morphological features of the mitral valve were stenosis in 1, regurgitation in 3, and a combination of these in 2. The prosthesis was fixed at the annulus in 3, and at the supra-annular position in 3. Anticoagulation was performed using warfarin. RESULTS: There was no operative mortality. Postoperative catheterization revealed an acceptable wedge pressure in the pulmonary arteries, ranging from 10 to 12 mmHg. During the mean follow-up period of 36 months, late death due to residual pulmonary hypertension occurred in 1 patient at 10 months after surgery. Excluding this patient, all remaining patients are doing well with no need for repeated operation with no thromboembolic complication. The actuarial survival rate and the reoperation free rate at 70 months are 83 +/- 15% and 100%, respectively. CONCLUSION: Mitral valve replacement using a small size bileaflet mechanical prosthetic valves in infancy can be performed with low operative mortality and with satisfactory mid-term results.     

Early Results of Valve Replacement with the Björk-Shiley Convexoconcave Prosthesis

The Björk-Shiley convexoconcave prosthetic valve has design characteristics that may result in a lower incidence of thromboembolic complications than the conventional spherical Björk-Shiley prosthesis. We evaluated the results of valve replacement with the convexoconcave prosthesis in 248 patients receiving 301 prosthetic valves between March, 1979, and June, 1981. One hundred thirteen patients had aortic valve replacement (AVR), 73 had mitral valve replacement (MVR), and 62 had multiple valve replacement. Two hundred nine (84%) were in New York Heart Association Class III or IV. The median duration of follow-up was 13 months, and follow-up information was available for 246 (99%) of the patients. The actuarial incidence of freedom from thromboembolism at two years was 98% in the AVR group, 97% in the MVR group, and 87% in the group having multiple valve replacement. There were no documented episodes of valve thrombosis or mechanical failure and no fatal thromboembolic complications. The absence of valve thrombosis is in marked contrast to the results reported with the spherical disc valve. Although longer follow-up is necessary, it appears that the convexoconcave design represents a major improvement in the Björk-Shiley prosthesis.     

St. Jude Medical prosthesis: valve-related deaths and complications

Despite the hemodynamic improvement in cardiac valve prostheses, valve-related deaths and complications have remained a substantial source of morbidity and mortality. This follow-up study was carried out in April, 1986, in a group of 816 patients who received 876 St. Jude Medical prostheses between October, 1977, and October, 1984. One hundred fifty-five patients (37%) of the 422 having aortic valve replacement (AVR) and 88 (29%) of the 300 having mitral valve replacement (MVR) had concomitant coronary artery bypass grafting, and 94 patients (12%) had miscellaneous procedures performed in addition to valve replacement. Sixty-three patients died within the operative period, an operative mortality of 7.7%. Follow-up was complete for 98% of the patients; the mean follow-up was 42 months. At that time, 87 more patients had died, a late mortality of 11.9%. There were 13 valve-related deaths (4 in the AVR group, 7 in the MVR group, and 2 in the miscellaneous group); the causes of death were thromboembolism (7), anticoagulant-related hemorrhage (2), valve thrombosis (2), prosthetic valve endocarditis (1), and perivalvular leak (1). There were 37 thromboembolic episodes (1.78/100 patient-years) and 67 anticoagulant-related hemorrhages (3.22/100 patient-years), 46% of which necessitated transfusion. The incidence of valve thrombosis was 0.6% (4 patients). Perivalvular leak and prosthetic valve endocarditis occurred in 7 patients (1.0%) and 5 patients (0.7%), respectively. Reoperation was carried out in 6 patients (0.8%), but only for perivalvular leak. There were no deaths, no complications, and no clinical evidence of malfunction of the prosthetic valve.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Prosthetic heart valves: Objective Performance Criteria versus randomized clinical trial

The current Food and Drug Administration (FDA) heart valve guidance document uses an objective performance criteria (OPC) methodology to evaluate the clinical performance of prosthetic heart valves. OPC are essentially historical controls, but they have turned out to be an adequate, and perhaps optimal, study design in this situation. Heart valves have a simple open-and-close mechanism, device effectiveness is easy to document, and the common complications (thromboembolism, thrombosis, bleeding, leak, and infection) are well known and easily detected. Thus, randomized clinical trials (RCTs) have not been deemed necessary for the regulatory approval of prosthetic heart valves. The OPC are derived from the average complication rates of all approved heart valves. Studies based on OPC have been shown to work well; many different valve models have gained FDA market approval based on this methodology. Although heart valve RCTs are not required by the FDA, they have been done to compare valves or treatment regimens after approval. Recently, the Artificial Valve Endocarditis Reduction Trial (AVERT) was designed to compare a new Silzone sewing ring, designed to reduce infection, with the Standard sewing ring on a St. Jude Medical heart valve. This was the largest heart valve RCT ever proposed (4,400 valve patients, followed for as long as 4 years), but it was stopped prematurely because of a high leak rate associated with the Silzone valve. Examining the results showed that a much smaller, OPC-based study with 800 patient-years would have been sufficient to disclose this complication of the Silzone valve.     

Comparative Rest and Exercise Hemodynamics of Allograft and Prosthetic Valves in the Aortic Position

Background. Allograft aortic valve replacement has gained widespread acceptance. However, there is little information about in vivo allograft valve function at rest and during exercise.

Methods. Cardiac catheterization was performed to measure hemodynamic variables at rest and during supine bicycle exercise in 44 patients who had had aortic valve replacement using allograft valves or Bicer or St. Jude Medical prosthetic valves 19 to 27 mm in diameter. Sixteen patients received an allograft valve; 17, a Bicer valve; and 11, a St. Jude Medical valve. There were no significant differences between the three groups in age, body surface area, left ventricular end-systolic and end-diastolic volume indices, exercise cardiac index, exercise heart rate, or work load achieved. Left ventricular and ascending aortic pressures were measured simultaneously according to the transseptal method.

Results. The mean pressure gradient was generally higher for the Bicer and St. Jude Medical valves than for the allograft valves, both at rest and during exercise. Significant differences were obtained in patients with small-sized valves (21 and 23 mm); pressure gradients were higher in the prosthetic valve groups. In patients with large-sized prosthetic valves (25 mm), there were no significant differences between the three groups at rest and during exercise. However, there was no pressure gradient at all for allograft valves.

Conclusions. Exercise cardiac catheterization confirms that the allograft aortic valve is an ideal substitute from the hemodynamic aspect, particularly in patients with a small aortic root and in those who perform strenuous exercise.     

Tricuspid valve replacement with the St. Jude Medical valve: 19 years of experience.

OBJECTIVE: The choice of the valve substitute in the tricuspid position remains controversial. A St. Jude Medical valve is a choice of valve substitute and its lower thrombogenicity and excellent hemodynamic performance have been reported even in the tricuspid position. However, little is known of the long-term durability of the St. Jude Medical valve in the tricuspid position. Our long-term experience of tricuspid valve replacement showed the higher thrombogenicity than we had expected, therefore, this study was done to reconsider our strategy for valve choice. METHODS: This study reviewed 23 patient who underwent 25 tricuspid valve replacements with the St. Jude Medical valves from 1980 to 1997. The mean age was 40 years. Eleven patients (48%) were men. There were four in-hospital deaths (17%). The remaining 19 patients were all alive and followed from 2.2 to 19.0 years (mean 11.8 years). RESULTS: The overall survival, including hospital mortality, was 83%, 10 and 15 years after surgery. Valve thrombosis occurred in six patients. Freedom from valve thrombosis was 78 and 70%, 10 and 15 years after surgery, respectively. The linearized rate of the valve thrombosis was 2.9%/patient-years. Six patients required reoperation. The mean interval to reoperation was 9.5 years. Freedom from reoperation was 83% and 75%, 10 and 15 years after surgery, respectively. The linearized rate of the reoperation was 2.8%/patient-years. No structural valve deterioration was found. Echocardiographic study showed that the function of the St. Jude Medical valve without valve-related complications was well maintained. CONCLUSIONS: The higher thrombogenicity of the St. Jude Medical valve in the tricuspid position altered our choice of valve substitutes from the St. Jude Medical valve to a bioprosthesis which is lack of need for anticoagulant therapy except for juvenile patients who are able to maintain potent anticoagulant therapy.