Measuring the mind: assessing cognitive change in clinical drug trials

Genetic variation of SLC6A4, HTR1A, MAOA, COMT and BDNF has been associated with depression, variable antidepressant drug responses as well as impacts on brain regions of emotion processing that are modulated by antidepressants. Pharmacogenetic studies are using psychometric outcome measures of drug response and are hampered by small effect sizes that might be overcome by the use of intermediate endophenotypes of drug response, which are suggested by imaging studies. Such an approach will not only tighten the relationship between genes and drug response, but also yield new insights into the neurobiology of depression and individual drug responses. This article provides a comprehensive overview of pharmacogenetic, imaging genetics and drug response studies, utilizing imaging techniques within the context of antidepressive drug therapy.     

Age-associated functional impairments of specific neurotransmitter systems: detection by pharmacological brain metabolism studies and criteria for design of human investigations

Although brain aging is accompanied by measurable deficits in cognitive and motor function, and frequently by selective loss of neurons, neurotransmitters and their receptors, resting brain energy metabolism, purported to reflect neural function, undergoes little or no quantitative change during aging in experimental animals or in man. A method is described for assessing the functional capacity of aging neurotransmitter systems in rats by measuring changes in regional cerebral metabolic rates for glucose in response to drug administration. Preliminary studies identified the pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic factors that determine cerebral metabolic responses to drugs, and established a relation between those responses and altered brain function. In awake, aged Fischer-344 rats, cerebral metabolic responses to the dopaminergic agents haloperidol and bromocriptine and to the serotonergic agonist m-chlorophenylpiperazine were reduced when compared to responses in young adult rats, despite similar or greater concentrations of drug in the brains of older animals. The metabolic response to arecoline, a muscarinic cholinergic agonist, was age-invariant. It was concluded that the cerebral metabolic response to drug administration is a useful measure of the functional capacity of neurotransmitter systems. Pharmacological brain metabolism studies demonstrated selective functional impairments in certain transmitter systems of the aged rat brain that were not detected by metabolic measurements in the resting state, nor predicted by changes in transmitter receptors. Specific criteria are proposed for pharmacological brain metabolism studies in man, using in vivo imaging, to identify functionally impaired neurotransmitter systems in aging and neurodegenerative diseases.     

Sex Differences in Animal Models of Depression and Antidepressant Response

Abstract: Many stress‐related mental disorders, including depression and post‐traumatic stress disorder occur more often in women than in men. While social and cultural factors certainly contribute to these differences, neurobiological sex differences seem to also play an important role. A rapidly burgeoning literature from basic and clinical research documents sex differences in brain anatomy, chemistry and function, as well as in stress and drug responses. For example, some clinical studies have reported that women may have a better outcome when treated with selective serotonin re‐uptake inhibitors, in comparison to tricyclic antidepressants. Furthermore, relatively limited basic research has been devoted to developing animal models and consequently describing drug treatments which are sensitive to sex differences. In this MiniReview, we discuss sex differences in behavioural aspects, as well as neurochemical, neurobiological and pharmacological findings that we have collected from several different animal models and tests of depression. These are the forced swim test, the chronic mild stress and the learned helplessness models, the Flinders sensitive line rats, which is a genetic model of depression and the lipopolysaccharide‐induced sickness behaviour, a putative inflammatory model of depression. Collectively, our data have shown that in all animal models assayed, serotonergic neurochemical responses were differently affected in males and females, ultimately producing sex‐dependent behavioural effects. In addition, Flinders sensitive line rats exhibited a sexually dimorphic response to chronic antidepressant treatment. These sex‐differentiated neurochemical and behavioural alterations lend support to a major role of serotonin in the mediation of sexually dimorphic responses.     

Evaluation of central serotonergic function in affective and related disorders by the fenfluramine challenge test: a critical review

Plasma prolactin levels following oral administration of the serotonin (5-HT) releasing agent, fenfluramine hydrochloride, have been extensively used to evaluate central serotonergic function in affective and related disorders. Cortisol responses to fenfluramine have generally been a less informative measure. In healthy subjects, prolactin release by fenfluramine is dose-dependent, blocked by antagonists of serotonin receptors of the 5-HT-2a/2c type, negatively correlated with age and increased in young females. In major depression, a preponderance of studies have found blunted prolactin responses compared to matched normal controls. Although a significant minority of studies have not found blunting, increased prolactin release has not been observed. The blunted prolactin release is not due to a deficient secretory capacity of pituitary lactotrophs and is congruent with other evidence for reduced central serotonergic function in major depression. Blunting of the prolactin response may be associated with severity of depression and with elevated baseline cortisol levels. Treatment with antidepressant drugs and electroconvulsive therapy has been reported to increase the prolactin response but this has not been replicated in all studies. Blunted prolactin responses to fenfluramine have been fairly consistently associated with impulsive aggression in different personality disorders and with severity of suicide attempts in depressed patients. A number of studies employing the fenfluramine challenge test (FCT) have been conducted in obsessive compulsive disorder but their results have been variable. Prolactin responses to fenfluramine may be enhanced in panic disorder and chronic fatigue syndrome but the number of studies in these conditions is small as is the case for seasonal affective disorder. Since the therapeutic administration of fenfluramine as an appetite suppressant has been suspended because of reports of cardiac complications, further use of this compound as a challenge agent is not anticipated. Future studies are likely to employ agents acting on specific serotonin receptors and should apply methodological insights from the use of the FCT, which are considered in this review. Use of concomitant brain imaging to evaluate the central effects of challenge agents directly is likely to become more prevalent and may supplant neuroendocrine challenge paradigms such as the FCT which have been remarkably heuristic but are limited in scope and methodologically complex.     

Lamotrigine augmentation in unipolar depression

A significant number of patients with unipolar depression fail to achieve remission after one or a series of antidepressants. We present the results of a retrospective chart review of the efficacy and tolerability of lamotrigine as an augmentation drug in treatment-resistant unipolar depression. A previous absence of a response was defined as the clinically significant presence of depressive symptomatology after 6 weeks of treatment with an antidepressant, with at least 3 weeks at the maximum dose tolerated by the patient. The patients were rated retrospectively using the Clinical Global Impression rating scale. Seventy-six percent of the patients improved. Gender, age, basal severity of the episode and degree of previous non response were not statistically significantly associated with response to lamotrigine augmentation. Comorbidity showed a tendency to be negatively related with response to lamotrigine. Three patients abandoned the treatment with lamotrigine due to side-effects. Complaints were excessive somnolence, headache, dizziness, nausea and malaise. Data suggest that lamotrigine is a promising drug for treatment-refractory unipolar depression. Double-blind studies are necessary to confirm its use as an augmentation agent.     

Brain-derived neurotrophic factor and antidepressant action: another piece of evidence from pharmacogenetics

EVALUATION OF: Gratacòs M, Soria V, Urretavizcaya M et al.: A brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) haplotype is associated with antidepressant treatment outcome in mood disorders. Pharmacogenomics J. 8, 101-112 (2008). The neurotrophin hypothesis of depression and antidepressant drug action postulates that reduced activity of neurotrophic factors, particularly brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF), plays an important role in the pathogenesis of major depression, and that its restoration may represent a critical mechanism underlying antidepressant therapeutic effect. This hypothesis is supported by numerous animal studies; however, evidence from clinical studies is lacking. This study is the first to use both single-marker as well as haplotype analysis to test the effect of genetic variants of BDNF on the therapeutic effects of antidepressant treatment in mood disorder. Among eight BDNF TagSNPs tested, one allele (rs908867) is associated with antidepressant response, with heterozygote carriers showing a better response than homozygous analog. The authors also identified a haplotype associated with the therapeutic response. This study provides clinical evidence to support the role of BDNF in antidepressant therapeutic mechanisms. However, further work is needed to confirm the findings, for several reasons. First, the study included not only major depression but also bipolar disorder patients; second, various antidepressants were used in this study, which could affect patients' responses; third, the frequency of the haplotype associated with treatment response is rare; and fourth, previous studies of the effects of single BDNF polymorphisms on antidepressant action have reported conflicting findings. Several suggestions for further work are discussed below.     

Neural markers of symptomatic improvement during antidepressant therapy in severe depression: subgenual cingulate and visual cortical responses to sad, but not happy, facial stimuli are correlated with changes in symptom score

Resting state activity in the ventral cingulate may be an important neural marker of symptomatic improvement in depression. The number of task related functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) studies correlating blood oxygenation level dependent (BOLD) response with symptomatic improvement is limited and methodologies are still evolving. We measured BOLD responses to sad and happy facial stimuli in 12 severely depressed individuals in the early stages of antidepressant treatment (Time 1) and 12 weeks later (Time 2) using event-related fMRI. We calculated correlations between temporal changes in BOLD response and changes in symptom scores. Most subjects improved markedly by Time 2. At Time 1, depression severity correlated positively with responses to sad stimuli in the right visual cortex, subgenual cingulate, anterior temporal pole and hippocampus and correlated negatively with responses to happy stimuli in left visual cortex and right caudate. Decreases in individual effect sizes of right subgenual cingulate and right visual cortical responses to sad, but not happy, facial stimuli were correlated with decreases in symptom scores. There are contrasting cortical and subcortical responses to sad and happy stimuli in severe depression. Responses to sad stimuli show the strongest correlates of clinical improvement, particularly in the subgenual cingulate.     

性别差异对精神药物作用影响的研究进展

流行病学调查显示精神障碍的患病率、发病率和症状表现等受到性别因素的影响。临床应用中男女患者对精神药物的反应有所不同,以至于有研究反映抑郁症患者中存在性别特定的精神药物使用模式。本文对精神药物因男女生理差异所致药代动力学性别差异进行总结,同时整理了目前临床主流精神药物的药效学相关研究,其中特别关注性激素对精神药物治疗反应的影响。本文对治疗药物监测在临床处理精神药物性别差异反应时的具体作用与必要性进行探讨,以期为个体化合理用药提供参考。     

Clonidine challenge testing of alpha-2-adrenoceptor function in man: the effects of mental illness and psychotropic medication

The clonidine challenge test is a means of assessing alpha-2-adrenoceptor sen sitivity in man. We review studies which have used this test to investigate central alpha-2- adrenoceptor changes in psychiatric illness, and to determine receptor changes after adminis tration and withdrawal of psychotropic treatments. Patients with severe depression show evidence of reduced alpha-2-adrenoceptor sensitivity, especially a reduced growth hormone response to clonidine. This may delineate a subgroup of patients with severe depressive illness from those with milder depression, and may even provide a trait marker for some depressed patients. Patients with panic disorder show evidence of subsensitivity to some and supersensitivity to other clonidine-induced responses. Other disorders, although less well investigated, may have abnormal test responses which may provide additional information about their cause and treatment. Changes in response after drug treatment have provided important information on the mode of action of antidepressants, and have suggested that noradrenergic function is altered by a variety of different antidepressants.     

Using positron emission tomography to facilitate CNS drug development

Positron emission tomography (PET) is a non-invasive technology of nuclear medicine that has sensitivity for tracing low picomolar concentrations of radiolabeled molecules in the human body. Radiolabeling a new drug to high specific radioactivity facilitates a detailed mapping of its distribution to crucial organs in humans after the administration of a "microdose" (< 1 microg), for which limited toxicology documentation is required. For drugs directed at the CNS, this method is particularly useful for confirming exposure to the brain. A different approach is to develop suitable radioligands for quantitative PET studies of drug binding to target proteins and subsequently to correlate receptor occupancy with pharmacodynamic responses. To follow disease progression and to monitor the outcome of new treatments, PEt also facilitates longitudinal studies of biomarkers of pathophysiology such as amyloid plaque load in Alzheimer's disease. Finally, combining genomic knowledge with PET neuroreceptor imaging is expected to facilitate the search for genetic predictors of drug response.     

Estradiol induces partial desensitization of serotonin 1A receptor signaling in the paraventricular nucleus of the hypothalamus and alters expression and interaction of RGSZ1 and Gαz

Hyperactivity of hypothalamic-pituitary mediated hormone responses, such as to stimulation with a serotonin 1A (5-HT(1A)) receptor agonist, are a feature of depression which are normalized with clinical improvement during drug therapy. We previously reported that SSRIs induce desensitization of 5-HT(1A) receptor signaling in the paraventricular nucleus of the hypothalamus (PVN) while estradiol benzoate (EB) produces a more rapid, partial desensitization. In the current study, time course and dose-response experiments demonstrated that two once daily doses of EB is the minimum needed to induce the desensitization response as indicated by 5-HT(1A) receptor-stimulated release of oxytocin and that 10 μg/kg/day EB produces the maximal response, a partial desensitization of approximately 40%. The effects of two once daily injections of 10 μg/kg/day EB on Gαz and RGSZ1 proteins were examined as components of the 5-HT(1A) receptor signaling system, which mediates the release of oxytocin and adrenocorticotropic hormone. RGSZ1 appears to be a major target for EB-mediated responses in the 5-HT(1A) receptor signaling system. A 55 kD membrane-associate RGSZ1 protein was greatly increased in the PVN and rest of the hypothalamus and moderately increased in the dorsal hippocampus and amygdala after EB treatment as well as after an acute dose of a 5-HT(1A) receptor agonist. These results suggest that EB is a candidate for adjuvant therapy with SSRIs to hasten the therapeutic response and that RGSZ1 is a major target of EB therapy which could be explored as a target for novel therapeutic approaches for the treatment of depression.     

Stable bimodal response to cholinomimetic drugs in Alzheimer's disease. Brain mapping correlates.

We investigated quantitative EEG brain mapping as a physiologic marker of drug response while studying the stability of intersubject variability in patients with Alzheimer's disease (AD) who were receiving bethanechol through intracerebroventricular (ICV) shunts. Two of the patients had previously demonstrated cognitive and behavioral improvements on medication; the third had cognitive deterioration complicated by agitated depression. All three patients were reexamined in a dose-response paradigm. Serial brain mapping examinations were performed along with brief cognitive testing. All patients showed drug responses that were comparable with responses during their initial dose-response phase. There were strong linear correlations between global decreases in 2 to 6 Hz slow-wave activity and cognitive improvement. Brain mapping demonstrated that slowing decreased in magnitude and field with increasing dose until optimal dose was reached; with supra-optimal doses, the magnitude and field of the slowing increased dramatically. These results suggest that the quality of cholinomimetic drug responses are stable over time in individual patients, and that magnitude and pattern of slow-wave activity as measured by brain mapping may be useful in monitoring treatment with cholinomimetic agents.     

Abstinence-induced changes in self-report craving correlate with event-related FMRI responses to smoking cues.

Drug cues have been shown to activate brain regions involved in attention, motivation, and reward in addicted users. However, as studies have typically measured responses in only one state (ie drug abstinence), it is unclear whether observed activations represent amplification by abstinence or stable responses. Thus, the present study was designed to evaluate the stability of event-related responses to visual drug cues in dependent smokers (n=13) using event-related functional magnetic resonance imaging measures. Imaging was conducted following smoking as usual and following overnight abstinence, and self-reported craving measures were obtained before, during, and after scanning. Analysis of hemodynamic response (HDR) amplitudes in each of 13 regions of interest revealed larger responses to smoking compared to control cues in ventral anterior cingulate gyrus (vACG) and superior frontal gyrus. Responses to smoking cues in these and all other regions revealed no effects of abstinence/satiety, thus supporting the notion that cue-elicited brain responses are relatively stable. However, while the abstinence manipulation did not alter group-level responses to smoking cues, at the individual level, abstinence-induced changes in craving (abstinence minus satiety) were positively correlated with changes in HDR amplitude to smoking cues in frontal regions including left inferior frontal gyrus, left vACG, and bilateral middle frontal gyrus. These results suggest that brain responses to smoking cues, while relatively stable at the group level following short-term abstinence, may be modulated by individual differences in craving in response to abstinence-particularly in regions subserving attention and motivation.     

Promise and Progress for Functional and Molecular Imaging of Response to Targeted Therapies

Biomarkers to predict or monitor therapy response are becoming essential components of drug developer's armamentaria. Molecular and functional imaging has particular promise as a biomarker for anticancer therapies because it is non-invasive, can be used longitudinally and provides information on the whole patient or tumor. Despite this promise, molecular or functional imaging endpoints are not routinely incorporated into clinical trial design. As the costs of clinical trials and drug development become prohibitively more expensive, the need for improved biomarkers has become imperative and thus, the relatively high cost of imaging is justified. Imaging endpoints, such as Diffusion-Weighted MRI, DCE-MRI and FDG-PET have the potential to make drug development more efficient at all phases, from discovery screening with in vivo pharmacodynamics in animal models through the phase III enrichment of the patient population for potential responders. This review focuses on the progress of imaging responses to new classes of anti-cancer therapies targeted against PI3 kinase/AKT, HIF-1alpha and VEGF. The ultimate promise of molecular and functional imaging is to theragnostically predict response prior to commencement of targeted therapy.     

The effect of concomitant disorders in childhood depression on predicting treatment response

Children with pure depression or depression plus an anxiety-related disorder (n = 14) had a higher drug response rate (57%) and a lower placebo response rate (20%) when compared to children with depression plus a concomitant conduct or oppositional disorder (n = 17) (33% drug response rate and 67% placebo response rate). These findings could explain why studies of prepubertal-onset depression found no differences between drug and placebo treatment assuming that a large percentage of the studies' subjects had concomitant conduct or oppositional disorders. The children with pure depression or depression plus an anxiety-related disorder had different symptom clusters from those with depression plus a concomitant conduct or oppositional disorder. The former had more severe CDRS ratings on sleep, appetite disturbance, depressed feelings, and psychomotor retardation. In contrast, those with a concomitant conduct or oppositional disorder had shorter attention spans and were more likely to disturb other children (based on Conners scale scores).     

Prefrontal neuropsychological predictors of treatment remission in late-life depression.

Recent studies suggest that neuropsychological measures involving the prefrontal cortex are associated with treatment remission in late-life depression. To further explore this issue, we studied the neuropsychological performance of 110 depressed individuals aged 60 years and over who are participating in an ongoing pharmacologic treatment study. Participants were clinically depressed at entry to the study as rated by the Montgomery-Asberg Depression Rating Scale (MADRS > or = 15), at which time they also completed a neuropsychological assessment that included measures of prefrontal/executive functions. A geriatric psychiatrist treating the participant using a standardized pharmacologic treatment algorithm evaluated the participant at baseline and 3-month follow-up, completing a MADRS at both visits. Using logistic discriminative procedures to predict depression remission at 3 months while controlling for age, gender, education, ethnicity, and baseline MADRS severity, we found that perseverative responses during verbal initiation tasks significantly predicted remission status (MADRS < 7). This finding is consistent with previous single-agent treatment studies suggesting a relationship between prefrontal neuropsychological function and treatment response in late-life depression. The current results, however, appear to differentiate verbal perseveration from verbal initiation as the cognitive process that is most associated with poor treatment response. By extension, we suggest that orbitofrontal prefrontal cortex may play a role in sustaining perseverative processing in geriatric depression.     

Ergometrine and apomorphine as selective antagonists of dopamine in the canine renal vasculature

1 Increases in renal blood flow were produced by intra-arterial injections of dopamine (5-50 mug) in anaesthetized dogs pretreated with alpha- and beta-adrenoceptor antagonists.2 Intra-arterial administration of ergometrine (0.5 mg) or apomorphine (1 mg) produced a depression of the renal dilator responses to dopamine, without affecting renal dilatations in response to intra-arterial acetylcholine (0.1-1 mug) or histamine (2-50 mug).3 The depression of dopamine responses lasted 10-15 min, and was greater with ergometrine than with apomorphine.4 It is concluded that both ergometrine and apomorphine can be used as specific blocking agents at vascular dopamine receptors. Ergometrine is the preferred drug for this purpose.     

The effect of citalopram pretreatment on neuronal responses to neuropsychological tasks in normal volunteers: an FMRI study.

Changes in serotonin neurotransmission have also been implicated in the etiology and treatment of impulse control disorders, depression, and anxiety. We have investigated the effect of enhancing serotonin function on fundamental brain processes that we have proposed are abnormal in these disorders. In all, 12 male volunteers received citalopram (7.5 mg intravenously) and placebo pretreatment in a single-blind crossover design before undertaking Go/No-go, Loss/No-loss, and covert (aversive) face emotion recognition tasks during functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI). Blood oxygenation level dependent responses were analyzed using Statistical Parametric Mapping (SPM2). The tasks activated prefrontal and subcortical regions generally consistent with literature with lateral orbitofrontal cortex (BA47) common to the three tasks. Citalopram pretreatment enhanced the right BA47 responses to the No-go condition, but attenuated this response to aversive faces. Attenuations were seen following citalopram in the medial orbitofrontal (BA11) responses to the No-go and No-loss (ie relative reward compared with Loss) conditions. The right amygdala response to aversive faces was attenuated by citalopram. These results support the involvement of serotonin in modulating basic processes involved in psychiatric disorders but argue for a process-specific, rather than general effect. The technique of combining drug challenge with fMRI (pharmacoMRI) has promise for investigating human psychiatric disorders.     

A typological model for estimation of drug and placebo effects in depression

One reason for failure to find specific treatment effects in drug versus placebo trials with patients who have depression is an insufficient period of observation. Also, differentiating between early fleeting response and maintained response has been shown relevant to detecting specific drug action. A model in which various types of drug and placebo response are specifically stipulated and which takes advantage of a two-stage experimental design is proposed.Substantive findings when patients who have major depression with atypical features are studied are: 1) about 6% have only a fleeting response to placebo and no response to drug; 2) by week-10 about 28% of the population will respond even if no medication is given; and 3) specific response to imipramine (21%) can be determined by week-4 but specific response to fluoxetine (20%) cannot be determined until later (week-10 in this study).     

A therapeutic role for cannabinoid CB1 receptor antagonists in major depressive disorders

Cannabinoid receptors in the CNS have been implicated in the control of appetite, cognition, mood and drug dependence. Recent findings support the hypothesis that cannabinoid CB1 receptor blockade might be associated with antidepressant and anti-stress effects. A novel potential antidepressant drug class based on this mechanism is supported by the neuroanatomical localization of CB1 receptors and signal transduction pathways that are involved in emotional responses, together with the antidepressant-like neurochemical and behavioral effects induced by CB1 receptor antagonists. Selective CB1 receptor antagonists are in development for the treatment of obesity and tobacco smoking, and could be tested for antidepressant efficacy because recent results of clinical studies suggest that they would also treat comorbid symptoms of depression such as cognitive deficiencies, weight gain, impulsivity and dependence disorders. Thus, CB1 receptor antagonism might constitute an integrated pharmacotherapeutic approach that impacts the affective, cognitive, appetitive and motivational neuronal networks involved in mood disorders.