A new dynamometer measuring concentric and eccentric muscle strength in accelerated,decelerated, or isokinetic movements

Summary A new computerized dynamometer (the SPARK System) is described. The system can measure concentric and eccentric muscle strength (torque) during linear or nonlinear acceleration or deceleration, isokinetic movements up to 400° · s^–1, and isometric torque. Studies were performed to assess: I. validity and reproducibility of torque measurements; II. control of lever arm position; III. control of different velocity patterns; IV. control of velocity during subject testing; and, V. intra-individual reproducibility. No significant difference was found between torque values computed by the system and known torque values (p>0.05). No difference was present between programmed and external measurement of the lever arm position. Accelerating, decelerating and isokinetic velocity patterns were highly reproducible, with differences in elapsed time among 10 trials being never greater than 0.001 s. Velocity during concentric and eccentric isokinetic quadriceps contractions at 30° · s^–1, 120° · s^–1 and 270° · s^–1 never varied by more than 3° · s^–1 among subjects (N=21). Over three days of testing, the overall error for concentric and eccentric quadriceps contraction peak torque values for 5 angular velocities between 30° · s^–1 and 270° · s^–1 ranged from 5.8% to 9.0% and 5.8% to 9.6% respectively (N=25). The results indicate that the SPARK System provides valid and reproducible torque measurements and strict control of velocity. In addition, the intra-individual error is in accordance with those reported for other similar devices.     

Potentiation of concentric plantar flexion torque following eccentric and isometric muscle actions

In a stretch-shortening cycle (SSC) the concentric muscle action is enhanced by a preceding eccentric muscle action. The hypothesis of the present study is that a preceding isometric action can also have an effect on a following concentric action, but to a lesser degree. A KINetic-COMmunicator II dynamometer was used to test muscle strength of the plantar flexion of the right foot in 20 healthy women. Maximal voluntary torque measurements were made at different angular velocities (120^o s^-1 and 240^o s^-1) and the range of motion of the ankle joint was 78–125^o. The assessment was based on concentric torque output and EMG recording from the gastrocnemius muscle under three different types of testing conditions (concentric actions with and without preceding eccentric or isometric actions, all with maximal efforts). The results showed that preceding muscle actions led to greater concentric torque output (P < 0.01) between 90 and 99^o plantar flexion. However, the increase in the concentric action was significantly (P < 0.01) larger with eccentric than with isometric preceding action, regardless of velocity. The EMG activity of the concentric action showed unchanged or lower values when preceded by a muscle action. In this model our conclusion is that the main reason for larger concentric torque values after a preceding muscle action is that time is sufficient for maximal muscle tension development; in addition, elastic energy is stored, particularly during the preceding eccentric action. Our results show that the effect of preceding muscle actions should be taken into account when measuring isokinetic muscle strength at relatively small angular movements.     

Eccentric and concentric torque-velocity characteristics of the quadriceps femoris in man

Summary The primary purpose of this investigation was to study the eccentric and concentric torque-velocity characteristics of the quadriceps femoris in man using a recently developed combined isometric, concentric and eccentric controlled velocity dynamometer (the SPARK System). A secondary purpose was to compare the method error associated with maximal voluntary concentric and eccentric torque output over a range of testing velocities. 21 males (21–32 years) performed on two separate days maximal voluntary isometric, concentric and eccentric contractions of the quadriceps femoris at 4 isokinetic lever arm velocities of 0° · s^–1 (isometric), 30° · s^–1 120° · s^–1 and 270° · s^–1. Eccentric peak torque and angle-specific torques (measured every 10° from 30° to 70°) did not significantly change from 0° · s^–1 to 270° · s^–1 (p>0.05) (with the exception of angle-specific 40° torque, which significantly increased;p<0.05). The mean method error was significantly higher for the eccentric tests (10.6%±1.6%) than for the concentric tests (8.1%±1.7%) (p<0.05). The mean method error decreased slightly with increasing concentric velocity (p>0.05), and increased slightly with increasing eccentric velocity (p>0.05). A tension restricting neural mechanism, if active during maximal eccentric contractions, could possibly account for the large difference seen between the present eccentric torque-velocity results and the classic results obtained from isolated animal muscle.     

Modeling energy expenditure associated with isometric, concentric, and eccentric muscle action at the knee

This study was designed to derive and test a model of energy expenditure (dE/dt) during different modes of human muscle actionin vivo dE/dt for the quadriceps muscle was expressed as: dE_quad/dt=K1(ω)+K2(Tiso)+dW/dt, where K1 and K2 are constants, (ω) is joint angular velocity (^o/sec), (Tiso) represents the knee extension torque that could be developed by the active muscle if the muscle action were isometric (N-m), and (dW/dt) is the rate of work performed (W). Volunteers performed a series of repetitive 2- to 4-min knee extension exercises, while varying either the knee extension torque or velocity. The average joint torque, angular velocity, rate of work performed, and net energy expenditure (E) above resting and dE/dt were determined for each muscle action. The best fit values for K1 and K2 for concentric, eccentric, and isometric muscle actions were 0.044, −0.55, and 0 W/^c/sec, and 4.14, 5.28, and 2.17 W/N-m, respectively. The coefficients of determination (r ²) for the model predictions of dE_quad/dt for the three modes of muscle action were 0.78, 0.71, and 0.71, respectively. The correlation coefficient between predicted and experimental dE/dt for all modes of muscle action combined was 0.93. These findings indicate the model provides a useful tool for predicting the rate of energy expenditure associated with cyclic knee extension efforts.     

Acoustic myography reflects force changes during dynamic concentric and eccentric contractions of the human biceps brachii muscle

Summary The relationship between acoustic myography (AMG), electromyography (EMG) and force during submaximal dynamic contractions was examined in the biceps brachii muscles of eight healthy males (aged 17–26 years). Different weights were lifted and lowered at a constant speed, using a wall pulley system, to perform concentric and eccentric contractions, respectively. Integrated AMG (iAMG) and integrated EMG (iEMG) activity both increased linearly with force during concentric (iAMGr=0.94; iEMGr=0.99) and eccentric (iAMGr=0.90; iEMGr=0.94) contractions. The slopes of the concentric regression lines were significantly different from the eccentric slopes (P<0.01) for both iAMG and iEMG with concentric contractions showing greater levels of activity. The results indicated that AMG can be used to detect changes in force during dynamic contractions which has important implications for the use of AMG in rehabilitation. The differences in iAMG activity between concentric and eccentric contractions are discussed in relationship to the origin of the AMG signal.     

Internal work and physiological responses during concentric and eccentric cycle ergometry

Summary Internal mechanical work during cycling, required to raise and lower the legs and change their velocities, is shown to be an important factor when interpreting physiological responses to cycle ergometer exercise. The internal work required to move the legs during concentric and eccentric cycle ergometry at different speeds and workloads was calculated from segmental energy changes determined using cinematography and directly using an eccentric ergometer. The mean internal work rates obtained at pedal frequencies of 30, 60 and 90 min⁻¹ were 11.5, 20 and 62 W respectively. When these estimates were added to the external work rates, they increased concentric and decreased eccentric work rates. The largest differences were seen at low work rates and high pedal frequencies during which concentric work rates increased by 51% and eccentric decreased 60% by the inclusion of internal work. When comparisons of concentric and eccentric cycling at equal uncorrected work rates were made, neglecting to include internal work introduced errors ranging from 12 to 97%. The calculated estimates of internal work agreed well with the power supplied by the eccentric ergometer to move the legs passively. The investigations show that the inclusion of internal work is important when comparing physiological responses during concentric and eccentric ergometry, especially when pedal frequences exceed 60 min⁻¹ and when work rates are small.     

Interrelationships among various measures of upper body strength assessed by different contraction modes

Summary Two studies were conducted in 83 college men to determine the degree of generality of individual differences in upper body muscular strength assessed by different testing modes. In study 1 (N=43), correlations were computed between four measures of upper body strength using the bench press movement, maximal isokinetic (0.09 rad·s^–1), maximal fast (0.126 m·s^–1) and slow (0.037 m·s^–1) hydraulic, and one repetition maximum (1-RM) free weight bench press (BP). Compared to free weight BP, maximal strength during isokinetic and slow hydraulic BP was 29% and 8% larger, and fast hydraulic BP strength was 63% lower (p<0.05). Simple linear regression of isokinetic BP on 1-RM BP yieldedr=0.79, error of prediction (SE)=12%, and generality=81%. The corresponding averaged values for the regression of slow and fast hydraulic BP on free weight 1-RM BP werer=0.77, SE=13.5%, and generality=84%. In Study 2 (N=40), testing included maximal isokinetic concentric and eccentric arm flexion and extension at 0.524, 1.570, and 2.094 rad·s^–1. The ratio of concentric to eccentric torque at the 3 speeds averaged 0.68 (flexion) and 0.70 (extension), and eccentric torques were 32% and 30% greater than concentric torques (p<0.05). The linear regression between concentric vs. eccentric flexion and extension torques at the three velocities yielded an averager=0.80, SE=13.7%, and generality=73%. The findings from both studies provide evidence for generality of concentric muscle forces obtained during isokinetic, hydraulic, and 1-RM BP movement, and concentric and eccentric torque measured at 3 velocities for simple arm flexion and extension. Thus, individuals who performed well (or poorly) on one type of upper body strength test were able to achieve the same relative level of performance when tested by different contraction modes.     

Muscle activation during maximal voluntary eccentric and concentric knee extension

Summary The aim of this investigation was to study the relationships among movement velocity, torque output and electromyographic (EMG) activity of the knee extensor muscles under eccentric and concentric loading. Fourteen male subjects performed maximal voluntary eccentric and concentric constant-velocity knee extensions at 45, 90, 180 and 360° · s^–1. Myoelectric signals were recorded, using surface electrodes, from the vastus medialis, vastus lateralis and rectus femoris muscles. For comparison, torque and full-wave rectified EMG signals were amplitude-averaged through the central half (30°–70°) of the range of motion. For each test velocity, eccentric torque was greater than concentric torque (range of mean differences: 20%–146%,P < 0.05). In contrast, EMG activity for all muscles was lower under eccentric loading than velocity-matched concentric loading (7%–31%,P < 0.05). Neither torque output nor EMG activity for the three muscles changed across eccentric test velocities (P > 0.05). While concentric torque increased with decreasing velocity, EMG activity for all muscles decreased with decreasing velocity (P < 0.05). These data suggest that under certain high-tension loading conditions (especially during eccentric muscle actions), the neural drive to the agonist muscles was reduced, despite maximal voluntary effort. This may protect the musculoskeletal system from an injury that could result if the muscle was to become fully activated under these conditions.     

Muscle strength and myoelectric activity in prepubertal and adult males and females

The purpose of this investigation was to compare children and adults of both genders with respect to torque-velocity, electromyogram (EMG)-velocity and torque-EMG relationships during maximal voluntary knee extensor muscle actions. Four groups of ten subjects each were studied comprising 11-year-old girls and boys and female and male physical education students (22–35 years). Maximal voluntary eccentric (lengthening) and concentric (shortening) actions of the knee extensors were performed at the constant velocities of 45, 90 and 180° · s^–1. Average values for torque and EMG activity, recorded by surface electrodes from the quadriceps muscle, were taken for the mid 40° of the 80° range of motion. The overall shapes of the torque- and EMG-velocity relationships were similar for all four groups, showing effects of velocity under concentric (torque decrease and EMG increase) but not under eccentric conditions. Eccentric torques were always greater than velocity-matched concentric ones, whereas the eccentric EMG values were lower than the concentric ones at corresponding velocities. Torque output per unit EMG activity was clearly higher for eccentric than for concentric conditions and the difference was of similar magnitude for all groups. Thus, the torque-EMG-velocity relationships would appear to have been largely independent of gender and to be fully developed at a prepubertal age.     

Eccentric and concentric torque-velocity relationships during arm flexion and extension

Summary Forty men were tested with a computerized dynamometer for concentric and eccentric torques during arm flexion and extension at 0.52, 1.57, and 2.09 rad·s^–1. Based on the summed concentric and eccentric torque scores, subjects were placed into a high strength (HS) or low strength (LS) group. The eccentric and concentric segments of the torque-velocity curves (TVCs) were generated using peak torque and constant-angle torque (CAT) at 1.57 and 2.36 rad. Angle of peak torque was also recorded. Compared to LS, HS had significantly greater estimated lean body mass (+ 10.2 kg) and approximately 25% greater average torque output. Reliability of the peak torque scores on 2 days in 20 subjects wasr0.85. The difference between observed torques and the mathematically computed criterion torque scores averaged 1% for three validation loads that ranged from 11.4 to 90.4 kg. Statistical analysis revealed that torque output in LS plateaued at low concentric velocities and was also flattened with increasing eccentric velocities. Conversely, torque ouptput for HS increased with decreasing concentric velocities and increased with increasing eccentric velocities. The method of plotting the TVCs for peak or CAT did not influence the pattern of TVC. Eccentric flexion peak torque occurred at a significantly shorter muscle length (1.88 rad) than concentric torque (2.12 rad). This difference was also present for extension; it was 1.88 rad for eccentric and 2.03 rad for concentric torque. These findings are discussed in terms of study design, neural inhibition, activation history, muscle-tendon elasticity, muscle fiber types, muscle architecture, and methodological considerations. The present results illustrate the importance of strength level to explain individual differences in TVC.     

Effect of prior isometric muscle action on concentric torque output during plantar flexion

The influence of different levels of prior isometric muscle action on the concentric torque output during plantar flexion was examined at two angular velocities (60°·s^–1 and 120°·s^–1) in ten healthy female subjects. The levels of the prior muscle actions were 25%, 50%, 75% and 100% of the maximal voluntary isometric contraction (MVIC). A KINetic-COMmunicator II dynamometer was used to measure torque output during plantar flexion within a range of motion of 78°-120° of the ankle joint. Simultaneous recordings of electromyograms (low-pass filtered and rectified) were obtained from the gastrocnemius medialis muscle and the soleus muscle. Torque-angle curves were made for the plantar flexions using different prior muscle actions. Up to 75% of MVIC, the torque output in the first part of the range of motion increased with the level of the prior isometric muscle action; at higher levels of MVIC the torque did not appear to increase any further. Later in the range of motion, after 24° in the plantar flexion at a velocity of 60°·s^–1 and 31° at 120°·s^–1, the prior muscle actions had no further influence. No increase was found in the electromyograms, with one exception, during the concentric movements when preceded by higher levels of MVIC. It would seem therefore that the increase in torque output early in the range of motion cannot be explained on the basis of differences in electrical muscle activation in this study.     

The effect of strength training on the apparent inhibition of eccentric force production in voluntarily activated human quadriceps

Ten male and ten female young adults trained the knee extensors of one leg eccentrically and those of the other concentrically for 6 weeks, using a gymnasium leg-extension machine. Before and after training, both legs of each subject were tested isometrically for maximum voluntary knee-extensor force, and in both eccentric and concentric isokinetic modes at 30–250° · s⁻¹. All limbs showed improvements in mean eccentric force (ranging from 18% in the concentrically trained legs of the females to 31% in the eccentrically trained legs of the males, P < 0.01–0.001). Upward trends in isometric and concentric forces were smaller and less- or non-significant. In three of the four groups, mean eccentric forces after training were significantly greater than mean isometric forces, a difference that was not evident before training. Ten further subjects of each gender, not trained but tested isometrically and isokinetically three times in 2 weeks, showed no significant improvement over the series of tests. The explanation suggested is that the increased percentage activation (“decreased inhibition”), often regarded as the main mechanism of strength gain in the early weeks of training, had been displayed particularly in the subjects' eccentric performance. This implies that the activation-shortfall, which is reduced by the initial phase of strength training, is largely or completely the same as that responsible for the fact that untrained, voluntary eccentric force is less than that of isolated muscle. Accepted: 18 February 2000     

Knee extension torque and intramuscular pressure of the vastus lateralis muscle during eccentric and concentric activities

The objectives of this study were to determine whether the occurrence of delayed onset muscle soreness (DOMS) for the vastus lateralis muscle was associated with elevated intramuscular pressure (IMP); and to assess, whether high eccentric forces occurred at an increased muscle length (as determined by joint angle). Therefore, peak knee extension torque, peak IMP of the vastus lateralis muscle, and the joint angle at which peak torque (JAPT) occurred were determined in eight male subjects during repetitive eccentric and concentric activities until fatigue occurred. Peak torque was significantly higher for eccentric compared to concentric activity (P < 0.01) and declined significantly for both activities (P < 0.01) throughout the protocols. When comparing the start (prior to fatigue) to the end (fatigue state), mean torque for eccentric activity declined from 191 to 147 (N · m) and for concentric activity declined from 166 to 104 (N · m). In contrast, peak IMP was not significantly different between the types of activity and did not change significantly with time. At the start and the end, the mean IMP remained constant for eccentric activity at 54 mmHg (7.2 kPa) but for concentric activity was 78 mmHg (10.4 kPa) and 96 mmHg (12.8 kPa), respectively. All the subjects, however, experienced DOMS of the vastus lateralis muscle exclusively for the eccentric activity leg. The JAPT was not different between activity types and did not change significantly with time; however, a significant interaction between activity type and time was observed (P = 0.01). For eccentric activity JAPT (0° = fully extended leg) was 81° (1.38 rad) and 79° (1.34 rad) and for concentric activity was 76° (1.29 rad) and 83° (1.41 rad) at the start and the end, respectively. From our studies we concluded that during eccentric activity the magnitude of IMP for the vastus lateralis muscle did not reflect the high muscles forces; therefore it would appear that IMP was not an etiologic indicator of DOMS, and that JAPT measurements did not offer an explanation for the high forces which were associated with eccentric activity.     

Gender-specific knee extensor torque,flexor torque,and muscle fatigue responses during maximal effort contractions

The purpose of this study was to examine gender differences in knee extensor and flexor peak torque, work, power, and muscle fatigue during maximal effort isokinetic contractions. Subjects included 19 healthy male and 20 healthy female volunteers. Following a dynamic warm-up period, subjects performed 30 reciprocal, concentric maximal knee extension and flexion contractions at a pre-set angular velocity of 3.14 rad·s^–1 on the Biodex Isokinetic Dynamometer. Values for knee extensor peak torque, work, and power were calculated for each repetition over an angular displacement of 1.05 rad for each repetition. The single highest repetition value for knee extensor and flexor peak torque, work, and power was then calculated relative to body mass (N·m·kg^–1, J·kg^–1, W·kg^–1) and allometric-scaled (N·m·kg^{– n} , J·kg^{– n} , W·kg^{– n} ) units. The allometric-scaled units were derived from a log–log transformation and linear regression analysis to calculate the exponent to which body mass is raised. The rate of quadriceps femoris muscle fatigue was calculated as the decline in each isokinetic variable by the linear slope from the single highest repetition value through the 30th repetition, and by two different fatigue indexes. The results demonstrate higher knee extension and flexion peak torque, work, and power in absolute, relative, and allometric-scaled units for males compared to females. Males exhibited higher fatigue rates for both muscle groups of each isokinetic variable than females, as described by the slope and the fatigue index, except when adjusted for peak values via analysis of covariance. The findings suggest that during maximal-effort muscle contractions, males exhibit a higher susceptibility to muscle fatigue than females, a phenomenon that may be related to an inherent ability to generate higher knee extensor and flexor torque. Electronic Publication     

Muscle strength and electromyogram in boys and girls followed through puberty

The main purpose of this study was to investigate the changes in anthropometric measures and muscle strength that occur during puberty in children from the age of 11 to 16 years. Special attention was paid to possible gender- and muscle action-type-specific alterations in torque/velocity and EMG/velocity characteristics. Sixteen children participated in the study (9 boys and 7 girls). Eccentric and concentric muscle strength was measured on an isokinetic dynamometer at angular velocities of 45, 90 and 180° · s⁻¹. Simultaneously, a surface electromyogram (EMG) was recorded from the quadriceps muscle. At the age of 11, the boys and girls exhibited equal anthropometric measures and strength performance. In both genders, body measures and muscle strength increased significantly during the 5-year period, with larger increases being recorded for the boys. In addition, the boys increased selectively their eccentric torque per body mass, indicating an action-type-specific change in muscle quality. The general shape of the torque/velocity relationship exhibited an adult-like pattern both before and after puberty, and did not differ between genders. Both pre- and postpuberty, myoelectric activity was generally lower during eccentric than concentric actions, the highest values occurring for both genders in the concentric 180° · s⁻¹ test. Ratios of eccentric to concentric torque per EMG, which reflect electromechanical efficiency, showed no significant changes with age. A significant velocity- and gender-specific change in electromechanical efficiency was observed at the highest speed at postpuberty, where the ratio for the girls was higher than for the boys. Accepted: 13 June 1999     

Specific effects of eccentric and concentric training on muscle strength and morphology in humans

The purpose of this study was to compare pure eccentric and concentric isokinetic training with respect to their possible specificity in the adaptation of strength and morphology of the knee extensor muscles. Ten moderately trained male physical education students were divided into groups undertaking eccentric (ETG) and concentric (CTG) training. They performed 10 weeks of maximal isokinetic (90°?·?s^?1) training of the left leg, 4?×?10 repetitions – three times a week, followed by a second 10-week period of similar training of the right-leg. Mean eccentric and concentric peak torques increased by 18% and 2% for ETG and by 10% and 14% for CTG, respectively. The highest increase in peak torque occurred in the eccentric 90°?·?s^?1 test for ETG (35%) whereas in CTG strength gains ranged 8%–15% at velocities equal or lower than the training velocity. Significant increases in strength were observed in the untrained contra-lateral leg only at the velocity and mode used in ipsilateral training. Cross-sectional area of the quadriceps muscle increased 3%–4% with training in both groups, reaching statistical significance only in ETG. No major changes in muscle fibre composition or areas were detected in biopsies from the vastus lateralis muscle for either leg or training group. In conclusion, effects of eccentric training on muscle strength appeared to be more mode and speed specific than corresponding concentric training. Only minor adaptations in gross muscle morphology indicated that other factors, such as changes in neural activation patterns, were causing the specific training-induced gains in muscle strength.     

Concentric and eccentric muscle strength before,during and after fatigue in 13 year-old boys

Summary The purpose of this study was to investigate the force-producing characteristics of boys aged 13 years in relation to fatigue of elbow flexor muscles. Maximal voluntary force in elbow flexion was measured before and after a muscle endurance test (MET) by using an isokinetic dynamometer isometrically, concentrically and eccentrically at three velocities, i.e. 0.21, 0.52, and 1.05 rad · s^–1. The MET consisted of maximal concentric and eccentric muscle actions performed alternately at 0.52 rad · s^–1 for 50 consecutive trials. Muscle cross-sectional area (CSA) of elbow flexor muscles (biceps brachii and brachialis) was measured by a B-mode ultrasound apparatus. Although eccentric force showed significantly higher values than concentric force during MET, there was no significant difference in the rate of decline in force between the two actions. There was no significant difference in the rate of decline in force after MET for each velocity and muscle action. Isometric, concentric and eccentric force before MET was significantly related to muscle CSA whereas, after MET, concentric force significantly correlated with muscle CSA but there was no significant correlation between muscle CSA and isometric or eccentric force. From our study, it is therefore suggested that in development to maturity, isometric, concentric and eccentric force decrease at the same rate with advancing muscle fatigue; however, there might be differences among muscle actions in facors affecting force development.     

EMG differences between concentric and eccentric maximum voluntary contractions are evident prior to movement onset

This investigation addressed the question of whether the muscle activation signal prior to movement onset, as measured by surface EMG, differs if the contraction to be performed is concentric (shortening) or eccentric (lengthening). Specifically, the purpose was to determine if differences in knee extensor muscle EMG prior to voluntary maximum concentric and eccentric contractions and initiated from the same knee joint angle are evident at a time before muscle length changes could be influential. A protocol was designed using isokinetic knee extensions. The EMG of the vastus lateralis, vastus medialis, rectus femoris, and hamstrings muscles and the associated knee extension moment were measured during the isometric phase preceding the onset of dynamometer motion. During this isometric phase the muscles initially contracted under identical conditions, irrespective of whether the contraction was to be concentric or eccentric. The EMG of the eccentric contractions was significantly smaller than that of the concentric contractions. However, the rate of change of knee extension moment generally did not differ between the two conditions. This was found for both the monoarticular and multiarticular knee extensor muscles. The results suggest that initial differences between the EMG of maximum voluntary concentric and eccentric knee extensor contractions are selected a priori and support the contention that the central nervous system distinguishes between maximum eccentric and concentric contractions. The emergence of differences in activation prior to muscle length changes suggests supraspinal influences.