Poor correspondence between predicted and experimental binding of peptides to class I MHC molecules

Naturally processed peptides presented by class I major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules display a characteristic allele specific motif of two or more essential amino acid side chains, the so-called peptide anchor residues, in the context of an 8-10 amino acid long peptide. Knowledge of the peptide binding motif of individual class I MHC molecules permits the selection of potential peptide antigens from proteins of infectious organisms that could induce protective T-cell-mediated immunity. Several methods have been developed for the prediction of potential class I MHC binding peptides. One is based on a simple scanning for the presence of primary peptide anchor residues in the sequence of interest. A more sophisticated technology is the utilization of predictive computer algorithms. Here, we have analyzed the experimental binding of 84 peptides selected on the basis of the presence of peptide binding motifs for individual class I MHC molecules. The actual binding was compared with the results obtained when analyzing the same peptides by two well-known, publicly available computer algorithms. We conclude that there is no strong correlation between actual and predicted binding when using predictive computer algorithms. Furthermore, we found a high number of false-negatives when using a predictive algorithm compared to simple scanning for the presence of primary anchor residues. We conclude that the peptide binding assay remains an important step in the identification of cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) epitopes which can not be substituted by predictive algorithms.     

Machine learning reveals a non‐canonical mode of peptide binding to MHC class II molecules

MHC class II molecules play a fundamental role in the cellular immune system: they load short peptide fragments derived from extracellular proteins and present them on the cell surface. It is currently thought that the peptide binds lying more or less flat in the MHC groove, with a fixed distance of nine amino acids between the first and last residue in contact with the MHCII. While confirming that the great majority of peptides bind to the MHC using this canonical mode, we report evidence for an alternative, less common mode of interaction. A fraction of observed ligands were shown to have an unconventional spacing of the anchor residues that directly interact with the MHC, which could only be accommodated to the canonical MHC motif either by imposing a more stretched out peptide backbone (an 8mer core) or by the peptide bulging out of the MHC groove (a 10mer core). We estimated that on average 2% of peptides bind with a core deletion, and 0·45% with a core insertion, but the frequency of such non‐canonical cores was as high as 10% for certain MHCII molecules. A mutational analysis and experimental validation of a number of these anomalous ligands demonstrated that they could only fit to their MHC binding motif with a non‐canonical binding core of length different from nine. This previously undescribed mode of peptide binding to MHCII molecules gives a more complete picture of peptide presentation by MHCII and allows us to model more accurately this event.     

Attachment of oligosaccharides to peptide antigen profoundly affects binding to major histocompatibility complex class II molecules and peptide immunogenicity

To investigate the immunogenicity of glycopeptides, a peptide fragment from hen egg lysozyme, HEL(81–96)-Y (here named 1) which is immunogenic in H-2^k mice and known to bind to the murine major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecule E^k, was synthesized in five different glycosylated forms. The N-terminal serine of HEL(81–96)-Y was derivatized with D -glucose (2), maltotriose (3), and a branched D -glucose pentasaccharide (4). Furthermore, 1 was prepared with a central serine or asparagine derivatized with the branched D -glucose pentasaccharide (5) and GlcNAc (6), respectively. The ability of the five glycopeptides and the non-glycosylated peptide, labeled with ¹²⁵I, to bind to the two MHC class II molecules, A^k and E^k, was studied using a gel filtration assay. None of them could bind to A^k. Neither 5 nor 6 were able to bind to E^k. Surprisingly 2, 3 and 4 bound better to E^k than did the non-glycosylated peptide 1. The increased binding varied depending on the type of oligosaccharide attached to the N terminus of the peptide. The better binding to E^k of glycopeptide 4 was found to be due to an increased association rate. The binding of 1 as well as 4 was optimal at pH 5.0. Functional studies showed that 4 was able to elicit a heteroclitic proliferative response from T cells of mice immunized with the native non-glycosylated peptide. Circular dichroism studies of 1 and 4 indicated a more unordered structure of 4 and a predominant α-helical conformation of 1, suggesting that the MHC class II molecule may bind to peptides which are in a non-α-helical conformation. These results demonstrate that glycosylation has considerable influence on peptide immunogenicity for T lymphocytes.     

Identification of MHC class II restricted T-cell-mediated reactivity against MHC class I binding Mycobacterium tuberculosis peptides

Major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I restricted cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) are known to play an important role in the control of Mycobacterium tuberculosis infection so identification of CTL epitopes from M. tuberculosis is of importance for the development of effective peptide-based vaccines. In the present work, bioinformatics technology was employed to predict binding motifs of 9mer peptides derived from M. tuberculosis for the 12 HLA-I supertypes. Subsequently, the predicted peptides were synthesized and assayed for binding to HLA-I molecules in a biochemically based system. The antigenicity of a total of 157 peptides with measured affinity for HLA-I molecules of K(D) ≤ 500 nM were evaluated using peripheral blood T cells from strongly purified protein derivative reactive healthy donors. Of the 157 peptides, eight peptides (5%) were found to induce T-cell responses. As judged from blocking with HLA class I and II subtype antibodies in the ELISPOT assay culture, none of the eight antigenic peptides induced HLA class I restricted CD8(+) T-cell responses. Instead all responses were blocked by pan-HLA class II and anti-HLA-DR antibodies. In addition, CD4(+) T-cell depletion before the 10 days of expansion, resulted in total loss of reactivity in the ELISPOT culture for most peptide specificities. FACS analyses with intracellular interferon-γ staining of T cells expanded in the presence of M. tuberculosis peptides confirmed that the responsive cells were indeed CD4(+). In conclusion, T-cell immunity against HLA-I binding 9mer M. tuberculosis-derived peptides might in many cases turn out to be mediated by CD4(+) T cells and restricted by HLA-II molecules. The use of 9mer peptides recognized by both CD8(+) and CD4(+) T cells might be of importance for the development of future M. tuberculosis peptide-based vaccines.     

Novel methods to rapidly and sensitively analyze antigenic peptide binding to MHC class II molecules.

One of the important steps for antigen presentation by MHC class II molecules involves binding of a peptide fragment of the antigen to the class II molecule followed by recognition of the resulting complex by T cells. The most commonly used methods for studying binding of peptide to MHC II are: equilibrium dialysis, gel filtration chromatography, HPLC and polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Each of these methods has some limitations and is time consuming. In addition, each requires a considerable amount of native MHC class II, which is always difficult to obtain. In this report, we describe three different sensitive methods using radiolabeled peptide to study peptide binding to murine MHC class II molecules. These are: nitrocellulose filter binding, thin-layer chromatography (TLC) using plate-supported silica gel or PEI cellulose, and paper electrophoresis using Sepraphor cellulose polyacetate paper. All three methods are rapid, highly sensitive and require only ng quantities of affinity pure MHC class II molecules and peptides. These methods can be used to calculate the peptide occupancy of MHC class II molecules.     

Lipid‐mediated presentation of MHC class II molecules guides thymocytes to the CD4 lineage

Previous studies on the MHC class‐specific differentiation of CD4⁺CD8⁺ thymocytes into CD4⁺ and CD8⁺ T cells have focused on the role of coreceptor molecules. However, CD4 and CD8 T cells develop according to their MHC class specificities even in these mice lacking coreceptors. This study investigated the possibility that lineage is determined not only by coreceptors, but is also guided by the way how MHC molecules are presented. MHC class II molecules possess a highly conserved Cys in their transmembrane domain, which is palmitoylated and thereby associates with lipid rafts, whereas neither palmitoylation nor raft association was observed with MHC class I molecules. The generation of CD4 T cells was impaired and that of CD8 T cells was augmented when the rafts on the thymic epithelial cells were disrupted. This was due to the conversion of MHC class II‐specific thymocytes from the CD4 lineage to CD8. The ability of I‐A^d molecule to associate with rafts was lost when its transmembrane Cys was replaced. The development of DO11.10 thymocytes recognizing this mutant I‐A^dm was converted from CD4 to CD8. These results suggest that the CD4 lineage commitment is directed by the raft‐associated presentation of MHC class II molecules.     

TCR‐induced alteration of primary MHC peptide anchor residue

The HLA‐A*02:01‐restricted decapeptide EAAGIGILTV, derived from melanoma antigen recognized by T‐cells‐1 (MART‐1) protein, represents one of the best‐studied tumor associated T‐cell epitopes, but clinical results targeting this peptide have been disappointing. This limitation may reflect the dominance of the nonapeptide, AAGIGILTV, at the melanoma cell surface. The decapeptide and nonapeptide are presented in distinct conformations by HLA‐A*02:01 and TCRs from clinically relevant T‐cell clones recognize the nonapeptide poorly. Here, we studied the MEL5 TCR that potently recognizes the nonapeptide. The structure of the MEL5‐HLA‐A*02:01‐AAGIGILTV complex revealed an induced fit mechanism of antigen recognition involving altered peptide–MHC anchoring. This “flexing” at the TCR–peptide–MHC interface to accommodate the peptide antigen explains previously observed incongruences in this well‐studied system and has important implications for future therapeutic approaches. Finally, this study expands upon the mechanisms by which molecular plasticity can influence antigen recognition by T cells.     

Mechanistic understanding and significance of small peptides interaction with MHC class II molecules for therapeutic applications

Major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecules are expressed by antigen-presenting cells and stimulate CD4⁺ T cells, which initiate humoral immune responses. Over the past decade, interest has developed to therapeutically impact the peptides to be exposed to CD4⁺ T cells. Structurally diverse small molecules have been discovered that act on the endogenous peptide exchanger HLA-DM by different mechanisms. Exogenously delivered peptides are highly susceptible to proteolytic cleavage in vivo; however, it is only when successfully incorporated into stable MHC II–peptide complexes that these peptides can induce an immune response. Many of the small molecules so far discovered have highlighted the molecular interactions mediating the formation of MHC II–peptide complexes. As potential drugs, these small molecules open new therapeutic approaches to modulate MHC II antigen presentation pathways and influence the quality and specificity of immune responses. This review briefly introduces how CD4⁺ T cells recognize antigen when displayed by MHC class II molecules, as well as MHC class II–peptide-loading pathways, structural basis of peptide binding and stabilization of the peptide–MHC complexes. We discuss the concept of MHC-loading enhancers, how they could modulate immune responses and how these molecules have been identified. Finally, we suggest mechanisms whereby MHC-loading enhancers could act upon MHC class II molecules.     

Impaired expression of MHC class II molecules in response to interferon-gamma (IFN-γ) on human thymoma neoplastic epithelial cells

A human thymoma is a neoplasm derived from the thymic epithelial cell, and is well known for its association with autoimmune diseases, especially myasthenia gravis. The neoplastic epithelial cells of thymoma clearly retain thymic epithelial functions, but the development of T cells in thymoma is somewhat impaired. In this study, we quantified by flow cytometry the in vitro expression of MHC molecules on neoplastic epithelial cells precultured with IFN-γ. While MHC class I expression was comparable with that on normal thymic epithelial cells, the level of MHC class II molecules on neoplastic epithelial cells was lower than in controls, and also varied greatly from case to case. Additionally, there was a significant positive correlation between the expression level of MHC class II and the proportion of mature CD3⁺ cells in the CD4⁺CD8^? subset. Thus, accumulation of CD3^?CD4⁺CD8^? cells in thymoma may result from impaired expression of the MHC class II molecules, suggesting that the function of the neoplastic epithelial cells might determine the maturation and the positively selected repertoire of T cells in thymomas.     

MHC class II-associated invariant chain peptide replacement by T cell epitopes: engineered invariant chain as a vehicle for directed and enhanced MHC class II antigen processing and presentation

Proteolysis of the invariant chain (Ii) leads to the generation of abundant MHC class II-associated invariant chain peptides (CLIP), which bind in the MHC class II binding groove via supermotifs in a manner similar to that of antigenic peptides. We have engineered an Ii vector with the capacity to express any antigenic peptide of interest instead of CLIP, for T cell stimulation. When peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) were pulsed with Ii hybrids encoding T cell epitopes of tetanus toxin or acetylcholine receptor, stimulation of T cells was dramatically enhanced compared to stimulation after priming with either the native or recombinant proteins. Site-specific insertion of antigenic sequences into the CLIP region promoted enhanced antigenicity of Ii hybrids which were shown to be processed intracellularly in a chloroquine-sensitive compartment. Naturally processed T helper epitopes were visualized directly on the surface of PBMC and identified as analogs of CLIP associated with MHC class II molecules. This novel Ii vector provides a flexible and efficient system for the delivery of defined peptide epitopes to T cells which might be useful in the development of specific vaccines and in the study of intracellular processing.     

Labeling antigen-specific CD4(+) T cells with class II MHC oligomers

Class I MHC-peptide oligomers (MHC tetramers) have become popular reagents for the detection and characterization of antigen-specific CD8⁺ T cells. Class II MHC proteins can be produced by expression in Escherichia coli followed by in vitro folding, or by native expression in insect cells; biotin can be introduced by site-specific chemical modification of cysteine, or by enzymatic modification of a peptide tag; and a variety of fluorescent streptavidin preparations can be used for oligomerization. Here we review methodologies for production of fluorescent oligomers of soluble class II MHC proteins and discuss their use in analysis of antigen-specific CD4⁺ T cells. We explore the experimental conditions necessary for efficient staining of CD4⁺ T cells using oligomers of class II MHC proteins, and we establish a standard protocol. Finally, we consider complications and challenges associated with these reagents, discuss the interpretation of staining results, and suggest future directions for investigation, in particular the use of MHC oligomers for the study of T cell avidity modulation.     

ADAM metallopeptidase domain 17 (ADAM17) is naturally processed through major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I molecules and is a potential immunotherapeutic target in breast, ovarian and prostate cancers

Selection of suitable antigens is critical for the development of cancer vaccines. Most desirable are over-expressed cell surface proteins that may serve as targets for both antibodies and T cells, thus maximizing a concerted immune response. Towards this goal, we characterized the relevance of tumour necrosis factor-α-converting enzyme (ADAM17) for such targeted therapeutics. ADAM17 is one of the several metalloproteinases that play a key role in epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) signalling and has recently emerged as a new therapeutic target in several tumour types. In the present study, we analysed the expression profile of ADAM17 in a variety of normal and cancer cells of human origin and found that this protein is over-expressed on the surface of several types of cancer cells compared to the normal counterparts. Furthermore, we analysed the presentation of a human leucocyte antigen (HLA)-A2-restricted epitope from ADAM17 protein to specific T cells established from normal donors as well as ovarian cancer patients. Our analysis revealed that the HLA-A2-restricted epitope is processed efficiently and presented by various cancer cells and not by normal cells. Tumour-specific T cell activation results in the secretion of both interferon-γ and granzyme B that can be blocked by HLA-A2 specific antibodies. Collectively, our data present evidence that ADAM17 can be a potential target antigen to devise novel immunotherapeutic strategies against ovarian, breast and prostate cancer.     

A sensitive fluorometric assay for quantitatively measuring specific peptide binding to HLA class I and class II molecules

A sensitive, highly reproducible assay was developed for measuring binding of peptides to various HLA class I and II alleles. The assay is based on competition for binding to HLA between a peptide of interest and a fluorescent labelled standard peptide. This mixture is incubated with HLA to obtain equilibrium binding, and subsequently separated on an HPLC size-exclusion column in (i) a protein fraction containing HLA and bound peptide and (ii) a free peptide fraction. Each assay uses only 100 fmol labelled peptide and approximately 10 pmol of HLA. The analytical system contains an autosampler that samples from 96-well microtiter plates. Injections and data recording/evaluation is fully automated. Typical analysis time is 10–12 min per sample. The fluorescence in the HLA-bound peptide and free peptide containing fractions is measured on-line. The ratios of fluorescence signal in protein and peptide fractions at various concentrations of the peptide of interest are determined. IC₅₀ values are calculated from the binding curve as obtained by curve fitting of the data. Here we show results for peptide binding to HLA-DR1 and -DR17 molecules purified from detergent solubilized cell lysates, and for recombinant HLA-A^* 0201 and HLA-A^* 0301 expressed in E. coli.

The assay reported is sensitive and reproducible. It is non-radioactive and is non-labor intensive due to the high degree of automation.     

An integrative approach to CTL epitope prediction: a combined algorithm integrating MHC class I binding, TAP transport efficiency, and proteasomal cleavage predictions

Reverse immunogenetic approaches attempt to optimize the selection of candidate epitopes, and thus minimize the experimental effort needed to identify new epitopes. When predicting cytotoxic T cell epitopes, the main focus has been on the highly specific MHC class I binding event. Methods have also been developed for predicting the antigen-processing steps preceding MHC class I binding, including proteasomal cleavage and transporter associated with antigen processing (TAP) transport efficiency. Here, we use a dataset obtained from the SYFPEITHI database to show that a method integrating predictions of MHC class I binding affinity, TAP transport efficiency, and C-terminal proteasomal cleavage outperforms any of the individual methods. Using an independent evaluation dataset of HIV epitopes from the Los Alamos database, the validity of the integrated method is confirmed. The performance of the integrated method is found to be significantly higher than that of the two publicly available prediction methods BIMAS and SYFPEITHI. To identify 85% of the epitopes in the HIV dataset, 9% and 10% of all possible nonamers in the HIV proteins must be tested when using the BIMAS and SYFPEITHI methods, respectively, for the selection of candidate epitopes. This number is reduced to 7% when using the integrated method. In practical terms, this means that the experimental effort needed to identify an epitope in a hypothetical protein with 85% probability is reduced by 20-30% when using the integrated method.The method is available at http://www.cbs.dtu.dk/services/NetCTL. Supplementary material is available at http://www.cbs.dtu.dk/suppl/immunology/CTL.php.     

Fine epitope mapping within the pathogenic thyroglobulin peptide 2340-2359: minimal epitopes retaining antigenicity across various MHC haplotypes are not necessarily immunogenic

We have previously reported that the 20-mer peptide p2340 (amino acids 2340-2359), of human thyroglobulin (Tg) has the unique feature that it causes experimental autoimmune thyroiditis (EAT) in mouse strains bearing high-responder (HR) or low-responder (LR) MHC haplotypes in Tg-induced EAT. In this study, we have employed fine epitope mapping to examine whether this property of p2340 is the result of recognition of distinct or shared minimal T-cell epitopes in the context of HR or LR MHC class II molecules. Use of overlapping peptides showed that a core minimal 9-mer epitope (LTWVQTHIR, amino acids 2344-2352) was recognized by p2340-primed T cells from both HR (H2(k,s) ) and LR (H2(b,d) ) strains, whereas a second 9-mer epitope (HIRGFGGDP, amino acids 2350-2358) was antigenic only in H2(s) hosts. Truncation analysis of LTWVQTHIR and HIRGFGGDP peptides delineated them as the minimal epitopes recognized by p2340-primed T cells from the above strains. Subcutaneous challenge of all mouse strains with the 9-mer core peptide LTWVQTHIR in adjuvant elicited specific lymph node cell proliferative responses and mild EAT only in HR hosts, highlighting this sequence as a minimal pathogenic Tg peptide in EAT. The 9-mer peptide HIRGFGGDP was not found to be immunogenic in H2(s) hosts. These data demonstrate that minimal T-cell epitopes, defined as autoantigenic in hosts of various MHC haplotypes, are not intrinsically immunogenic. Activation of naive autoreactive T cells may require contributions from flanking residues within longer peptide sequences encompassing these epitopes.     

Real-time measurement of antigenic peptide binding to empty and preloaded single-chain major histocompatibility complex class I molecules

Cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) recognize peptides in association with major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I proteins, but how peptides bind to class I is not well understood. We used a fluorescence technique to measure antigenic peptide binding to a soluble, single-chain K^d (SC-K^d) molecule in which the K^d heavy chain was connected by a 15-residue link to β₂-microglobulin. Peptides were covalently labeled at their N terminus with dansyl, and binding of dansylated K^d-restricted peptides to SC-K^d resulted in significant fluorescence enhancement, which could be inhibited by unmodified K^d-restricted peptides. Real-time binding of a dansylated peptide could be followed by monitoring the fluorescence at 530 nm. The dansylated Plasmodium berghei circumsporozoite (PbCS) 263–260 peptide bound to “empty” SC-K^d with an association rate constant of 1140 M^?1s^?1, and the subsequent spontaneous dissociation of the SC-K^d-peptide complex was slow. The dissociation increased dramatically after addition of excess unlabeled PbCS 253–260 peptide, but with a slower association constant for unlabeled peptide, 77 M^?1s^?1. Thus, the K^d-peptide complex on the surface of antigen-presenting cells should be stable, but high concentrations of peptides in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) lumen would allow for peptide exchange on K^d before export to the surface. The apparent activation energy for PbCS 253–260 peptide binding to SC-K^d was 6.78 ± 0.64 kcal/mole, similar to values previously reported for antigen-antibody interactions.     

Extraordinary cross-reactivity of an autoimmune T-cell receptor recognizing specific peptides both on autologous and on allogeneic HLA class II molecules

A T-cell receptor's (TCR) recognition of a human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-peptide complex (pHLA) is normally described as being restricted by the HLA molecule and specific for the peptide. This is, however, not always true. Several TCRs have been described, which cross-react with other peptides bound to the restricting HLA molecule. This phenomenon has been considered a variant of molecular mimicry and is suggested to be one of the mechanisms behind autoimmunity. The positive selection of T cells in the thymus imposes low-affinity recognition of the TCRs toward self-pHLA, which increases the probability of the TCR to be promiscuous by nature, and further implies that the T-cell repertoire contains TCRs prone to be autoreactive and thus able to induce autoimmunity. We present an autoimmune TCR showing extreme cross-reactivity to several pHLA comprising both own HLA class II restriction element and allogeneic HLA class II restriction elements in complex with both self-derived and microbially derived peptides. The existence of such a significant cross-reactivity in the context of distinct HLA-DR molecules might be more common among autoimmune TCRs than previously anticipated and potentially reveals a new way of designing altered peptide ligands for therapeutic use.     

CD8 T cell autoreactivity to preproinsulin epitopes with very low human leucocyte antigen class I binding affinity

Beta cells presenting islet epitopes are recognized and destroyed by autoreactive CD8 T cells in type 1 diabetes. These islet-specific T cells are believed to react with epitopes binding with high affinity to human leucocyte antigen (HLA) expressed on beta cells. However, this assumption might be flawed in case of islet autoimmunity. We evaluated T cell recognition of the complete array of preproinsulin (PPI) peptides with regard to HLA binding affinity and T cell recognition. In a comprehensive approach, 203 overlapping 9-10mer PPI peptides were tested for HLA-A2 binding and subjected to binding algorithms. Subsequently, a high-throughput assay was employed to detect PPI-specific T cells in patient blood, in which conditional HLA ligands were destabilized by ultraviolet irradiation and HLA molecules refolded with arrays of PPI peptides, followed by quantum-dot labelling and T cell staining. Analysis of patient blood revealed high frequencies of CD8 T cells recognizing very low HLA binding peptides. Of 28 peptides binding to HLA-A2, a majority was predicted not to bind. Unpredicted peptides bound mainly with low affinities. HLA binding affinity and immunogenicity may not correlate in autoimmunity. Algorithms used to predict high-affinity HLA peptide binders discount the majority of low-affinity HLA binding epitopes. Appreciation that peptides binding HLA with very low affinity can act as targets of autoreactive T cells may help to understand loss of tolerance and disease pathogenesis and possibly point to tissue-specific immune intervention targets.