Two ankle joint laxity testers: reliability and validity

Two test devices were manufactured to objectively measure ankle joint laxity: the dynamic anterior ankle tester (DAAT) and the quasi-static anterior ankle tester (QAAT). The primary aim was to analyse the reliability of both testers; The secondary aim was to assess validity in correlation with TELOS stress test and manual anterior drawer test. Twenty-four normal subjects and 14 patients 1 year after acute lateral ankle ligament injury were included. Both ankles were tested with the DAAT and QAAT by two different observers; one experienced orthopaedic surgeon performed the manual test; the TELOS stress X-rays were evaluated by one observer. Intra observer reliability for the DAAT varied between 0.81 and 0.94; for the QAAT between 0.71 and 0.94. Inter observer reliability for the DAAT varied between 0.84 and 0.94; for the QAAT between 0.76 and 0.82. Concurrent validity showed fair correlation between DAAT and QAAT for the first couple observers (0.71); however, a poor correlation was observed for the second couple (0.42). No significant correlations were found between neither DAAT and the TELOS and the manual test, nor QAAT and the TELOS and the manual test. In conclusion, reliability of both testers is high. Validity of the testers needs further investigation.     

Early mobilization versus immobilization after ankle ligament stabilization

Functional outcome, stability at radiographic investigation and ankle joint torque after anatomical reconstruction of the lateral ankle ligaments were evaluated in patients with early postoperative mobilization versus those with cast immobilization. Thirty patients with chronic lateral ligament instability of the ankle underwent anatomical reconstruction of the ligaments. Postoperatively the patients were randomly allocated to two groups: Group A (n=15) were immobilized in a below-knee plaster for 6 weeks and Group B (n=15) underwent early controlled range of motion training using an Air-Cast ankle brace. The functional results were evaluated using a scoring scale and objective results using standardized stress radiographs. Also eccentric and concentric muscle torque at 60 degrees/s was measured in plantar flexion and dorsiflexion, respectively. The functional results were satisfactory in 12/15 ankles in Group A and 14/15 in Group B (n.s.). All the patients with satisfactory results regained normal range of motion. Patients with unsatisfactory results had either residual pain or recurrent instability. In Group B, the strength measurements revealed significantly higher peak torque values after three months in plantar flexion at 60 degrees/s. Six months postoperatively, the torque values did not differ significantly between the groups. Also, there was no group difference in the laxity of the ankle joint, including both anterior talar translation test and talar tilt test, at the two-year follow-up. One patient had a superficial wound infection. We conclude that after the reconstruction of chronic lateral ligament instability of the ankle the functional and stability results were equally good with early postoperative mobilization and 6-week immobilization. However, using early mobilization plantar flexion strength was regained earlier than with cast immobilization, without any risk of short- or medium-term complications, such as increased ankle laxity. We recommend early mobilization after anatomical reconstruction of the lateral ankle ligaments.     

Early range of motion training after ligament reconstruction of the ankle joint

Early range of motion training after ligament reconstruction of the ankle ligaments for chronic ankle joint instability was evaluated. Forty patients were operated on with anatomic reconstruction of the lateral ankle ligaments, i.e. shortening, imbrication and reinsertion. The patients were randomized postoperatively between two groups: (1) immobilization for 6 weeks in a plaster cast and (2) early range of motion training, in a Walker-Boot. Both groups underwent an identical rehabilitation program. with peroneal strengthening and co-ordination training after 6 weeks. The functional results were evaluated using a scoring scale and the mechanical stability with standardized stress radiographs. The minimum follow-up was 2 years. The functional results were satisfactory in 16 (80%) of the patients in group I, and 19 (95%) in group II. The mean values of anterior talar translation and talar tilt were not significantly different between the groups preoperatively nor at follow-up. The mean time period for sick leave was significantly shorter for group II, 6.5±1.6 weeks compared with 8.5±1.8 weeks for group I. The mean time period for return to sports activity was significantly shorter for group II, 9.5±2.2 weeks, compared with 12.5±2.6 weeks for group I. Early range of motion training is recommended after ligament reconstruction of the ankle, as it will enable earlier return to sports activities, shorter sick leave and preserved mechanical stability.     

The effect of estradiol and progesterone on knee and ankle joint laxity

BACKGROUND: Female athletes suffer a higher incidence of anterior cruciate ligament injuries compared to their male counterparts, and they appear to be at increased risk for these injuries when they have increased anterior-posterior knee laxity and at specific phases of the menstrual cycle. Although the mechanism by which these factors combine to increase injury risk is unclear, studies suggest that cyclic variations in joint laxity produced by hormone fluctuation during the menstrual cycle predispose an athlete to increased risk of ligamentous injury. Little is known about whether joint laxity varies cyclically during the menstrual cycle and if so, whether it is modulated by cyclic variations of estradiol (E2) and progesterone (P4). HYPOTHESIS: Increased serum estradiol (E2) and progesterone (P4) levels are associated with increased ankle and knee joint laxity. STUDY DESIGN: Cohort study. Level of evidence, 2. METHODS: Ankle laxity, anterior-posterior knee laxity, and serum concentrations of estradiol (E2) and progesterone (P4) were measured during the menstrual cycle in women and at corresponding time intervals in men (controls). Ankle laxity was measured from stress radiographs and included anterior talar translation relative to the tibia and talar tilt relative to the tibia; anterior-posterior knee laxity was measured with the KT-1000 arthrometer. RESULTS: Women had greater knee and ankle laxity values compared to men. There was, however, no change in knee and ankle laxity over the normal menstrual cycle in women and no change over time in men. There was no relationship between estradiol and progesterone fluctuation and ankle and knee joint laxity. CONCLUSIONS: Knee and ankle joint laxities are greater for women compared to men; however, the cyclic estradiol and progesterone fluctuations that occur during the menstrual cycle do not produce cyclic fluctuations of joint laxity. Studies using joint laxity to identify a subject at risk for ligamentous injury need only consider making measurements at a specific point in time, such as during a preseason screening evaluation.     

慢性踝关节外侧不稳定的手术治疗

报告了１５例慢性踝关节外侧不稳定的病例。结果表明，跟腓韧带、距腓前韧带松弛引起踝关节反复扭伤、疼痛，提示外踝关节不稳定，距骨斜角超过５°则提示外踝韧带断裂。介绍了一种修补外踝韧带的手术方法，术后效果较佳。     

Ankle instability: evaluation of the lateral ligaments

Bilateral ankle stress testing was performed on 25 subjects in a device which controlled position of the foot and the amount of force applied during the examination. Both inversion testing in the anteroposterior plane and anterior drawer testing in the lateral plane were performed in the same group of symptom-free patients. The reproducibility of the test was demonstrated. Previous history of injury, left vs. right handedness, side and anthropometric measurements did not affect the test. There was no difference in the inversion test between ankles tested in neutral and plantar flexion. In functionally normal ankles, the range of inversion "talar tilt" was 0 to 18 degrees while the maximum of anterior displacement on drawer testing was 3 mm. The effective stiffness of the anterior talofibular ligament was thus computed as 65 +/- 34 N/m. Anterior drawer testing appears to evaluate lateral ligamentous integrity of the ankle more critically than the talar tilt test.     

A radiological analysis of lateral ligament injuries of the ankle

Patients who presented within 5 days of an inversion injury to the ankle joint, were clinically selected for early radiological investigation and diagnosis of rupture of the lateral ligament of the ankle. Stress tenography was performed in 142 cases, and normal ranges for talar tilt and anterior draws were established in 216 normal ankles. In addition 38 cadaveric ankles were examined by peroneal tenography. No normal connection between the tendon sheath and the ankle joint was demonstrated. Sixty-five patients had positive peroneal tenograms; nine of these were positive only after manipulation. No complications occurred. Surgery was performed on 20 patients and demonstrated that common peroneal tenography was 95% accurate in diagnosing rupture of the calcaneo-fibular ligament. Of the 19 patients with proven calcaneo-fibular ligament rupture, six had a positive anterior draw sign, and nine had talar tilt. In this series both the talar tilt and anterior draw signs were found to be inaccurate. Common peroneal tenography is recommended as the method of choice for demonstrating acute rupture of the calcaneo-fibular component of the lateral ligament.     

Talocrural and subtalar joint instability after lateral ankle sprain

PURPOSE: Recurrence of lateral ankle sprain (LAS) is common among recreational and competitive athletes. Talocrural (TC) joint laxity has traditionally been seen as the cause of mechanical instability after LAS. The purpose of this study was to examine the use of stress fluoroscopy and physical examination in the assessment of TC and subtalar (ST) instability in subjects with and without a history of LAS. METHODS: Twelve subjects with a history of unilateral LAS and eight healthy controls were examined by two blinded examiners. The first examiner performed physical examination on each ankle by using the anterior drawer (AD), talar tilt (TTPE), and medial subtalar glide (MSTG) tests. Laxity in each ankle was assessed on a 4-point scale. The second examiner performed stress fluoroscopy taking AP views with and without a manually applied supination stress to assess TC laxity and a sidelying modified Broden view with and without stress to assess ST laxity. Subjective examination of the images was used to determine excessive TC and ST laxity. RESULTS: Seventy-five percent of previously injured subjects demonstrated unilateral laxity differences of the TC joint using stress fluoroscopy. Of the nine with excessive talar tilt on fluoroscopy, 78% demonstrated excessive laxity with the AD and MSTG tests, and 67% demonstrated laxity with the TTPE test. Sixty-seven percent of those with TC laxity also demonstrated either excessive unilateral or bilateral laxity of the ST joint under stress fluoroscopy. CONCLUSIONS: These data suggest the existence of a subpopulation of patients with a history of LAS who demonstrate a pattern of combined TC and ST laxity.     

Fatal complication following pure ankle dislocation in a domestic setting: case report and review of the literature

Pure ankle dislocation is a rare event that primarily results from high-energy trauma. Predisposing anatomical factors such as talar hypoplasia, ligament laxity, and previous sprains may play a key role. This report presents the case of a 55-year-old man with fatal anterior and posterior tibial artery tears following a pure anterolateral dislocation of the right ankle. To the best of our knowledge, no such cases have previously been reported in the English-language literature.     

Graded stress radiography in acute injury to the lateral ligaments of the ankle

The diagnostic accuracy of graded stress radiography in 26 patients with acute injury to the lateral ankle ligaments has been compared with findings at arthrography and surgery. Measuring talar tilt angles and anterior talar displacement over a range of pressures applied to the distal tibia using a commercially available stress device allows diagnostic distinction between isolated anterior talofibular ligament injury and a combined lesion that involves the calcaneofibular ligament. The results compare well with arthrographic and surgical findings.     

改良Broström法结合带线锚钉治疗陈旧性踝关节外侧副韧带损伤的疗效分析

 目的 探讨改良Broström法结合带线锚钉治疗陈旧性踝关节外侧副韧带损伤的临床疗效。方法 选取2013-02至2016-08陈旧性踝关节外侧副韧带损伤30例,均在武警湖北总队医院行改良Broström法结合带线锚钉治疗,比较患者术前与术后6个月疼痛视觉模拟评分(VAS)、距骨前移距离、距骨倾斜角度及AOFAS评分,评价治疗效果。结果 全部患者均获随访6~24个月。VAS评分:术前(7.63±1.31)分,术后6个月(2.23±1.22),差异有统计学意义(P<0.05);距骨前移距离:术前(10.62±2.24)mm、术后6个月(3.21±1.12)mm,差异有统计学意义(P<0.05);距骨倾斜度:术前(11.45°±2.64°)、术后6个月(4.32°±1.21°),差异有统计学意义(P<0.05);AOFAS评分:术前(64.98±6.07)分,术后6个月(92.08±3.22)分,差异有统计学意义(P<0.05),踝关节功能评级:优20例,良8例,优良率93.33%。结论 改良Broström法结合带线锚钉修复术操作简单、创伤小、疗效显著、安全性高,是治疗陈旧性踝关节外侧副韧带损伤的有效方法。     

半腱肌移植重建踝关节外侧副韧带及踝关节不稳

目的 探讨半腱肌移植修复陈旧性踝关节外侧副韧带损伤及踝关节不稳的有效性.方法 选择陈旧性踝关节外侧副韧带损伤患者2例,其中男1例,女1例;男25岁,女17岁.左侧1例,右侧1例.患者入院前均有2年以上反复踝部旋后位扭伤的病史.踝部损伤为Ⅲ度(美国足踝外科学院分度);前抽屉试验及距骨倾斜试验阳性.应力X线片显示距骨倾斜平均21°,且在侧位片显示距骨前脱位.2例均采用同侧自体半腱肌肌腱移植重建踝关节外侧副韧带.结果 2例平均随访8个月.患足局部无肿痛,行走正常,踝关节主动活动与被动活动良好,患足前抽屉试验及距骨倾斜试验阴性,应力X线片检查显示距骨无前脱位,距骨倾斜角＜5°.根据Mazur疗效评分标准,优1例,良1例.患者对踝关节功能主观满意.结论 (1)踝关节外侧副韧带损伤是导致慢性踝关节不稳,甚至踝关节骨性关节炎的常见原因;(2)Brostr(o)m法仍不失为修复新鲜踝关节外侧副韧带损伤的有效方法,但对陈旧性损伤无效.(3)采用自体半腱肌肌腱修复重建陈旧性踝关节外侧副韧带的方法简单,有效,对于治疗踝关节不稳、防止踝关节骨性关节炎的发生具有重要的作用.     

Diagnostic value of stress radiography in lesions of the lateral ligaments of the ankle

The diagnostic accuracy of inversion and anterior stress radiography in rupture of the lateral ligaments of the ankle joint was assessed in 56 patients undergoing surgery. In inversion stress radiography, 58 per cent of the patients with confirmed rupture of the lateral ligaments of the ankle had a talar tilt of 10 degrees or more, allowing a predictive value of a positive test of 94 per cent. In anterior stress radiography, 53 per cent of the patients had a posterior tibiotalar distance of 9 mm or more, allowing a predictive value of a positive test of 81 per cent. In measurements of talar tilt and anterior displacement of the talus values higher than normal in the injured ankle may be a sign of a rupture of the lateral ligament.     

Anatomic reconstruction of the anterior talofibular and calcaneofibular ligaments using a semitendinosus tendon allograft and interference screws

Purpose

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the functional and radiographic outcomes of a novel surgical technique devised to treat chronic lateral ankle instability. The technique involves direct repair of the anterior talofibular ligament and anatomic reconstructions of the anterior talofibular ligament (ATFL) and the calcaneofibular ligament (CFL) using a free semitendinosus tendon allograft and interference screws.

Methods

This retrospective study involved a review of the records of 27 patients (28 ankles) with chronic lateral ankle instability treated from 2007 to 2009. VAS pain scores, AOFAS scores, Karlsson–Peterson ankle scores (24 ankles), and patient satisfaction were evaluated at median of 19 (12–26)?months postoperatively. Radiographically, talar tilt angles and anterior talar translation were assessed in pre- and postoperative ankle stress views.

Results

Median patient age at surgery was 36.5 (16–57)?years. Median VAS pain score decreased from 6 (3–9) to 2 (0–4) (P?P?P?P?Conclusions The described technique, which involves anatomic reconstruction of the ATFL and CFL using the semitendinosus tendon and interference screws with direct repair of the capsule, is a viable option for treating lateral ankle instability with stable tendon fixation and provides satisfactory clinical outcomes.

Level of evidence

Case-series, Level IV.     

Quantitative assessment of mechanical laxity in the functionally unstable ankle

PURPOSE: Delineating between functional and mechanical instability in those with chronic ankle dysfunction is a challenging task. Current methods of assessing ankle ligamentous laxity are subjective in nature and limit our ability to identify the site and extent of instability; therefore, a need exists for objective laxity measurements. The purpose of this study was to determine whether subjects with self-reported, functional ankle instability (FAI) demonstrated increased mechanical laxity when tested with instrumented arthrometry and stress radiography. METHODS: Both ankles were tested in 51 subjects with self-reported unilateral FAI. An instrumented ankle arthrometer measured ankle-subtalar joint motion for total anteroposterior (AP) displacement (mm) during loading at 125 N and total inversion-eversion (I-E) rotation (degrees of ROM) during loading at 4 N x m. The Telos GA-II/E device provided either anterior or lateral stress (15 kp) while fluoroscopic radiographs were recorded for anterior displacement (mm) and talar tilt (degrees). RESULTS: The arthrometry measurements of anterior and total AP displacement and the radiographic measurements of anterior displacement were greater (P < 0.05) in the FAI ankles when compared with the uninjured ankles. There were no differences in total I-E rotation, inversion rotation, or talar tilt between ankles when analyzed with either measurement technique. CONCLUSION: The ability to objectively measure mechanical instability in the functionally unstable ankle is important to understanding the nature and cause of the instability. Ankle arthrometry and stress radiographic measurements are objective assessment tools for mechanical laxity. Despite finding greater laxity in the functionally unstable ankle, the clinical significance of the observed displacement remains unanswered. Further research is needed to determine the amount of laxity that constitutes mechanical instability and how this relates to FAI.     

Surgical treatment of chronic lateral instability of the ankle joint. A new procedure

Sixty patients with chronic lateral functional and mechanical instability of the ankle joint were treated with shortening and reinsertion of the lateral ankle ligaments. All patients were followed prospectively for 2 to 5 years (mean, 3 years 6 months). We found the functional results to be excellent or good in 53 patients (88%). Patients with unsatisfactory results had either generalized joint hypermobility or long-standing ligament insufficiency. Anterior talar translation (ATT) and talar tilt (TT) were measured radiologically on standardized radiographs. Patients with excellent and good functional results had better mechanical stability, both ATT and TT, than those with fair and poor functional results. A good correlation was found between clinical, functional, and radiological results. In conclusion we found that reconstruction of the ankle stability by shortening and reinsertion of the lateral ankle ligaments is a safe and simple method and is a good alternative to other more complex methods of ligament reconstruction. The method should, however, be used with great care in patients with generalized joint hypermobility or in patients with long-standing ligament insufficiency.     

Diagnostic validity of alternative manual stress radiographic technique detecting subtalar instability with concomitant ankle instability

Purpose

To incorporate a diagnostic technique for measuring subtalar motion, namely “talar rotation”, into the manual supination-anterior drawer stress radiographs for evaluation of the severity of rotational instability, and to determine its clinical relevance.

Methods

Sixty-six patients with combined injuries of the anterior talofibular (ATFL) and calcaneofibular ligament (CFL) underwent three bilateral manual stress radiographs, and mean increments of anterior talar translation (mm), talar tilt (°), and talar rotation (%) in the injured ankle compared to the normal opposite side were measured with the technique. Intraobserver and interobserver reliability of each measure was assessed, and the difference in the degree of increments was compared according to the presence of additional cervical ligament insufficiency.

Results

Ankle stress radiographic intraobserver and interobserver agreement was ICC = 0.91 and 0.82 for talar rotation (%), ICC = 0.64 and 0.51 for anterior talar translation, and ICC = 0.78 and 0.71 for talar tilt angle, respectively. In group 2 including patients with combined injuries of the ATFL and CFL along with additional cervical ligament insufficiency, a significantly higher increment of talar rotation, mean 6.4 % (SD 3.4 %), was observed compared to that of talar rotation, mean 4.1 % (SD 2.7 %), in the other group (group 1) with an intact cervical ligament (p < 0.001).

Conclusions

A new comprehensive stress radiographic technique for diagnosis of chronic lateral ankle instability presented in this study might be a reliable and representable measurement tool to assess additional injury or instability of the subtalar joint.

Level of evidence

Prospective cohort study, Level II.

     

Quantification of anterior translation of the humeral head in the throwing shoulder. Manual assessment versus stress radiography

Clinical evaluation of humeral head translation relies mainly on manual tests to measure laxity in the human shoulder. The purposes of this study were to determine whether side-to-side differences exist in anterior humeral head translation in professional baseball pitchers, to compare manual laxity testing with stress radiography for quantifying humeral head translation, and to test intrarater reliability of the manual humeral head translation and stress radiography tests. Twenty professional baseball pitchers underwent bilateral manual anterior humeral head translation and stress radiographic tests. Stress radiography was performed by imparting a 15-daN anterior load to the shoulder in 90 degrees of abduction with both neutral and 60 degrees of external rotation and recording the glenohumeral joint translation at rest and under stress in each position. Eight subjects were retested to assess the reliability of these methods. Results showed no significant difference between the dominant and nondominant extremity in the amount of anterior humeral head translation measured manually and with stress radiography, nor significant correlation between anterior humeral head translation measured manually and by stress radiography. Test-retest reliability was moderate-to-poor for the manual humeral head translation test and moderate for stress radiography.     

Three-dimensional bone kinematics in an anterior laxity test of the ankle joint

Questions addressed in this in-vitro study are (1) what are the actual three-dimensional kinematics of talus and calcaneus during an anterior drawer test as performed with the quasi-static anterior ankle tester (QAAT) (2) does laxity measurement with the QAAT represent the true anterior translation of talus relative to the tibia?. Simultaneous measurements were made with the QAAT and a three-dimensional kinematics analysis system in five specimens. The three-dimensional translations and rotations on three axes were analysed at 25, 50 and 100 N of applied anterior load, with increased ligament damage. For four out of five remaining specimens, anterior translation values of talus and calcaneus and values as measured with the QAAT show a significant increase with growing ligament damage and with higher loads. Skeletal motions of talus and calcaneus show great similarity in three different motion axes, with increased ligament damage and at any given load. Skeletal translations and rotations of talus and calcaneus show great similarity during an anterior drawer movement of the ankle joint. Anterior skeletal translation of the talus and calcaneus show fair correlation with the anterior displacements measurements of the QAAT. These QAAT measurements show an overestimation of the laxity value by more than 200% irrespective of the load applied.     

Reconstruction of the lateral ankle ligaments. A biomechanical analysis.

The purpose of this study was to perform a biomechanical analysis of several commonly performed operative procedures used to stabilize the lateral ankle. We performed the Evans, Watson-Jones, and Chrisman-Snook procedures on 15 cadaveric ankles and tested the ankles for stability, motion, and isometry of graft placement. The Evans procedure allowed increased anterior displacement, internal rotation, and tilt of the talus when compared to ankles with intact ligaments. Subtalar joint motion was restricted by the Evans procedure. The Watson-Jones procedure controlled internal rotation and anterior displacement of the talus, but was less effective in controlling talar tilt and also restricted subtalar joint motion. The Chrisman-Snook procedure allowed increased internal rotation and anterior displacement of the talus when compared to ankles with intact ligaments. The procedure was effective in limiting talar tilt, but restricted subtalar joint motion. Based on the biomechanical data obtained, we devised a lateral ankle reconstruction with bone tunnels that reproduce the anatomic orientation of both the anterior talofibular and calcaneofibular ligaments. This ankle ligament reconstruction resists anterior displacement, internal rotation, and talar tilt without restricting subtalar joint motion. Clinical relevance: We found considerable mechanical differences among the more commonly performed lateral ankle reconstructions. It is possible to locate bone tunnels and graft placement so that a more anatomic configuration is achieved.