Unemployment, health and health services in German-speaking countries

The links between unemployment and health are manifold: Employment may lead to illness: health problems (that may lead to unemployment) often result from unfavourable working conditions of the (previous) employment. Another factor is job insecurity: fear of job loss increases the incidence of disease, and this applies not only to people who are emotionally unstable. Illness may lead to unemployment: in many cases, unemployment is caused by previous health impairments, which, to a considerable extent, also explain the duration of unemployment. Unemployment may lead to illness: there is evidence that unemployment not only reinforces existing physical disease but also acts as a risk factor for new ones. This seems particularly true for problem groups such as the unemployed elderly as well as for infants and children of unemployed people. The relations between unemployment and mental health are strong, mainly in terms of depression and alcoholism. Unemployment may lead to health: short-time work and short-term unemployment may improve health by reducing previous stress, caused by employment or by an overload with social roles. Even in the case of long-term unemployment there are some positive health effects as long as a minimum of social security and alternative social roles are available and useful activities--minor agricultural jobs, illicit work--can be carried out. The links between unemployment, work and society can considerably be loosened by a number of social factors and personal characteristics of the people affected. Existing health services are not in a position to deal with disease stemming from employment or unemployment except through symptomatical and curative therapies. In addition to general medical care, which is guaranteed by the German health insurance system for the unemployed, too, therapeutical measures are especially important in cases of depression and alcoholism. As a rule, the medical profession has no knowledge of the links between health, work and unemployment; such knowledge, however, would facilitate prevention. Individual prevention and rehabilitation measures are of great importance to problem groups suffering from cumulative or indirect unemployment, i.e. to unemployed elderly as well as to children of unemployed parents. Since the unemployed tend to isolate themselves, extramural services are useful. Specific services for the unemployed only are certainly not as helpful as multi-functional social services, such as those being already rendered by some self-help organizations, churches and trade-unions.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Unemployment and health care utilization

OBJECTIVES: This study attempted to determine whether prior use of health services predicts a subsequent risk of unemployment and also to describe the acute effects of exposure to unemployment on the use of health care services. MATERIAL AND METHODS: The 1986 census records were linked with comprehensive health care information for the period 1983-1989 for over 44629 randomly selected residents of Manitoba, Canada. All cause and cause-specific rates of hospital admission and ambulatory physician contacts were compared between 1498 unemployed and 18272 employed persons across 4 consecutive time periods related to the onset of unemployment. RESULTS: The adjusted rates of hospital admission and physician contacts were higher among the unemployed across all 4 periods. When persons with a history of mental health treatment were excluded, health care use in the period prior to the onset of unemployment was equivalent among the employed and unemployed. When a history of mental health treatment was controlled for, all-cause and cause-specific health care use was elevated among the unemployed during the unemployment spell. CONCLUSIONS: Unemployed persons had increased hospitalization rates before their current spell of unemployment. Much of this difference was due to the subgroup with prior mental health treatment. For persons without prior mental health care, hospitalization increased after a period of unemployment.     

Unemployment and health: an analysis of "Canada Health Survey" data

This paper provides a cross-sectional analysis of the physical and emotional well-being of employed and unemployed workers. The data used consists of a sub-sample (N = 14,313) drawn from the Canada Health Survey's national probability sample (N = 31,688). The analysis indicates substantial health differences between employed and unemployed individuals. The unemployed showed significantly higher levels of distress, greater short-term and long-term disability, reported a large number of health problems, had been patients more often, and used proportionately more health services. Consistent with these measures, derived from self-reported data, physician-diagnosed measures also indicate a greater vulnerability of unemployed individuals to serious physical ailments such as heart trouble, pain in heart and chest, high blood pressure, spells of faint-dizziness, bone-joint problems and hypertension. While these health differences between the employed and unemployed persisted across socio-economic and demographic conditions, further analysis indicated strong interaction effects of SES and demographic variables on the association of employment status with physical and emotional health. Females and older unemployed individuals reported more health problems and physician visits whereas the younger unemployed (under 40) reported more psychological distress. The blue-collar unemployed were found to be considerably more vulnerable to physical illness whereas the unemployed with professional background reported more psychological distress. The low-income unemployed who were also the principal family earners, were the most psychologically distressed. A regional look at the data showed that the low-income unemployed suffered the most in terms of depressed mood in each region of the country. It is apparent that unemployment and its health impact reflect the wider class-based inequalities of advanced industrial societies. The need for social policies that effectively reduce unemployment and the detrimental impact of unemployment is clear.     

Unemployment and self-rated health: Neighborhood influence

This work contributes to the study of the relationship between health, work and context by investigating the interaction between them in Brazil, a country with great social inequalities. It investigates whether unemployment and socioeconomic characteristics of the neighborhoods in which people live are associated with poor self-rated health after adjustment for individual sociodemographic characteristics, behavioral risk factors and health status. Moreover, it tests whether living in an area of socioeconomic deprivation modifies the association between unemployment and self-rated health.     

Unemployment and health in the context of economic change

Evidence relating unemployment to health is found at every level of social science analysis from national population rates to individual psychophysiological stress response. At the population level of analysis, increase in the unemployment rate indicates recession and/or structural economic decline. At the individual level, unemployment is interpreted as a stressful life event. In both cases, inverse associations are found between measures of unemployment and indicators of health. We identify social science literatures associating health indicators with each of the following: economic growth, socioeconomic status, sociocultural change, economic instability, the status of being unemployed, social stress and work stress. Outstanding research issues include the requirements to identify and measure the effects of conditional factors and control variables in multivariate analysis and to examine a broader range of both severity of unemployment and severity of health outcomes. A research agenda proposes studies at the macro, meso and micro levels of analysis. We urge such research for its potential contribution both to analytic social science and to economic and social policy.     

Unemployment and health: contextual-level influences on the production of health in populations

While there is a large and growing literature investigating the relationship between an individual's employment status and health, considerably less is known about the effect on this relationship of the context in which unemployment occurs. The aim of this paper is test for the presence and nature of contextual effects in the ways unemployment and health are related, based on a simple underlying model of stress, social support and health using a large population health survey. An individual's health can be influenced directly by own exposure to unemployment and by exposure to unemployment in the individual's context, and indirectly by the effects these exposures have on the relationship between other health determinants and health. Based on this conceptualization an empirical model, using multi-level analysis, is formulated that identifies a five-stage process for exploring these complex pathways through which unemployment affects health. Results showed that the association of individual unemployment with perceived health is statistically significant. Nevertheless, this study did not provide evidence to support the hypothesis that the association of unemployment with health status depends upon whether the experience of unemployment is shared with people living in the same environment. Above all, this study demonstrates both the subtlety and complexity of individual- and contextual-level influences on the health of individuals. Our results caution against simplistic interpretations of the unemployment-health relationship and reinforce the importance of using multi-level statistical methods for investigation of it.     

Unemployment and self-assessed health: evidence from panel data

We examine the relationship between unemployment and self-assessed health using the European Community Household Panel for Finland over the period 1996-2001. Our results show that the event of becoming unemployed does not matter as such for self-assessed health. The health status of those that end up being unemployed is lower than that of the continually employed. Therefore, persons who have poor health are being selected for the pool of the unemployed. This explains why, in a cross-section, unemployment is associated with poor self-assessed health. All in all, the cross-sectional negative relationship between unemployment and self-assessed health is not found longitudinally.     

Unemployment and ill health: understanding the relationship.

OBJECTIVE--To review research relevant to understanding the psychological, social, and biological pathways by which unemployment may affect health risk; to consider the importance of four specific mechanisms; and to indicate some directions for future research. CRITERIA FOR INCLUSION AND EXCLUSION OF PUBLISHED STUDIES--Studies were chosen to illustrate the development of four major hypotheses regarding the relationship between unemployment and ill health, as well as the present state of knowledge. The review therefore includes some much-cited "classics" drawn from a long time span. Where recent reviews already exist relevant to individual mechanisms, these are referred to. Recent (since 1987) reports were sought by searching the BIDS data base. Particular effort was made to locate studies which enabled alternative hypotheses to be evaluated, and to point out where existing evidence is inconsistent or incomplete, indicating the need for further research. CONCLUSIONS--To understand the relationship between unemployment and ill health and mortality, four mechanisms need to be considered: the role of relative poverty; social isolation and loss of self esteem; health related behaviour (including that associated with membership of certain types of "subculture"); and the effect that a spell of unemployment has on subsequent employment patterns.     

Unemployment and health in Spain: The influence of socio-economic environment

We present the results of a study on the association betweenunemployment and health and the use of health services, exploringthe influence of the socio-economic environment on these relationships.With this aim, data from the Spanish National Health Survey(SNHS) were used. Health was measured by subjective health status,presence of chronic illnesses and psychological symptoms. Theuse of health services was measured by drug consumption (overthe counter and/or prescribed drugs), doctor consultation, hospitaladmission and casualty attendance. A total of 13,344 individualsaged between 16 and 65 years were included. Results were analysedfor all of Spain and for 3 regions with different socio-economiclevels: Andalusia, Catalonia and the Basque Country. Althoughin Spain as a whole there was a relationship between unemployment,ill health and more use of health services, this relationshipvaried for the selected regions. Thus, in Catalonia and theBasque Country, where unemployment rates have dramatically increasedin recent years, this relationship was maintained, while inAndalusia, where high unemployment rates have been a long-standingphenomenon, the relationship was less clear. It is suggestedthat the economic and social environment might be critical indetermining the relationship between unemployment and health.     

Unemployment causes ill health: the wrong track

It is not unemployment per se that causes ill health. It can be a very desirable state. There are no diseases specific to unemployment. Contrast this with employment. Unemployment shares with all other socio-environmental situations risk of exposure to common physical, social and psychological stressors that predispose to disease. Focus for action and research should be on reducing such stressors and not on provision of full employment. The former is likely to be possible and beneficial. The latter is likely to be impossible and carries a risk of making matters worse. As an immediate first step, that will reduce 'cratogenic' disease, people in authority should stop misleading the public into believing that unemployment is the cause of ill health.     

Unemployment and health in the German population: results from a 2005 microcensus

Background  

Although the health sciences have been observing the negative impact of mass unemployment on health for some time now, health reporting remains fragmentary.     

Unemployment and mortality: a small area analysis.

It has been claimed that unemployment affects the health and thus the mortality of the unemployed, their families, and other members of their communities. This paper examines the relation between mortality and the unemployment experiences of small areas which vary in the extent to which their unemployment levels have changed in recent years. Quarterly numbers of unemployed, classified by age, sex, duration of unemployment, and unemployment office for 1977-81, have been aggregated to correspond to Family Practitioner Committee areas (FPCs), for which population and mortality data had been collected for a different study. There was little variation in long term (greater than 6 months) unemployment trends prior to July 1980, but subsequently there were large variations between FPCs in the rate of increase in unemployment rates. Mortality data for suicide, ischaemic heart disease, cerebrovascular disease, and all causes were examined for the period 1975-83. When the mortality trends of FPCs with different unemployment experiences were compared, no statistically significant differences in trends were found, although areas with greater increases in unemployment appeared to have slightly worse mortality trends for suicide, ischaemic heart disease, cerebrovascular disease, and total mortality for men in the younger age groups. If changes in the level of unemployment do have an effect on changes in trends in mortality levels, this effect is not of sufficient magnitude to be statistically significant with the sample available, in spite of the fact that it included the whole of England and Wales.