Lesions of T-Cell-Mediated Kidney Allograft Rejection in Mice Do Not Require Perforin or Granzymes A and B

Organ allograft rejection is strongly associated with the presence of alloreactive cytotoxic T cells but the role of cytotoxicity in the pathologic lesions is unclear. Previous studies showed that the principal lesions of kidney rejection - interstitial infiltration, tubulitis, and endothelial arteritis - are T-cell-dependent and antibody-independent. We studied the role of cytotoxic granule components perforin and granzymes A and B in the evolution of the T-cell-mediated lesions of mouse kidney transplant rejection. By real-time RT-PCR, allografts rejecting in wild-type hosts at days 5, 7, 21, and 42 showed massively elevated and persistent expression of perforin and granzymes A and B, but evolution of tubulitis and arteritis did not correlate with increasing granzyme or perforin expression. Allografts transplanted into hosts with disrupted genes for perforin or granzymes A and B showed no change in tubulitis, arteritis, or MHC induction. Thus the development of the histologic lesions diagnostic of T-cell-mediated kidney transplant rejection are associated with but not mediated by perforin or granzyme A or B. Together with previous graft survival studies, these results indicate that the granule-associated cytotoxic mechanisms of T cells are not the effectors of T-cell-mediated allograft rejection.     

Tubulitis and Epithelial Cell Alterations in Mouse Kidney Transplant Rejection Are Independent of CD103, Perforin or Granzymes A/B

One of the defining lesions of kidney allograft rejection is epithelial deterioration and invasion by inflammatory cells (tubulitis). We examined epithelial changes and their relationship to effector T cells and to CD103/E-cadherin interactions in mouse kidney allografts. Rejecting allografts showed interstitial mononuclear infiltration from day 5. Loss of epithelial mass, estimated by tubular surface area, and tubulitis were minimal through day 7 and severe by day 21. Tubules in day 21 allografts manifested severe reduction of E-cadherin and Ksp-cadherin by immunostaining with redistribution to the apical membrane, indicating loss of polarity. By flow cytometry T cells isolated from allografts were 25% CD103+. Laser capture microdissection and RT-PCR showed increased CD103 mRNA in the interstitium and tubules. However, allografts in hosts lacking CD103 developed tubulitis, cadherin loss, and epithelial deterioration similar to wild-type hosts. The loss of cadherins and epithelial mass was also independent of perforin and granzymes A and B. Thus rejection is characterized by severe tubular deterioration associated with CD103+ T cells but not mediated by CD103/cadherin interactions or granzyme-perforin cytotoxic mechanisms. We suggest that alloimmune effector T cells mediate epithelial injury by contact-independent mechanisms related to delayed type hypersensitivity, followed by invasion of the altered epithelium to produce tubulitis.     

Heterogeneity in the Evolution and Mechanisms of the Lesions of Kidney Allograft Rejection in Mice

The natural history and pathogenesis of the pathologic lesions that define rejection of kidney transplants have not been well characterized. We studied the evolution of the pathology of rejection in mouse kidney allografts, using four strain combinations across full major histocompatibility complex (MHC) plus nonMHC disparities, to permit more general conclusions. Interstitial infiltrate, MHC induction, and venulitis appeared by day 5, peaked at day 7-10, then stabilized or regressed by day 21. In contrast, tubulitis, arteritis, and glomerulitis were absent or mild at days 5 and 7, but progressed through day 21, indicating separate regulation and homeostatic control of these lesions. Edema, hemorrhage, and necrosis also increased through day 21. All lesions were T-dependent, failing to develop in T-cell-deficient hosts. Allografts into immunoglobulin-deficient hosts manifested typical infiltration, MHC induction, and tubulitis at days 7 and 21, indicating that these lesions are alloantibody-independent. However at day 21 kidneys rejecting in immunoglobulin-deficient hosts showed decreased edema, arteritis, venulitis, and necrosis. Thus the three groups of lesions are: T-cell-mediated interstitial infiltration, MHC induction, and venulitis, which develops rapidly then stabilizes; slower but progressive T-cell-mediated tubulitis and arteritis; and late antibody-mediated endothelial injury, which contributes to late edema, arteritis, and venulitis.     

Analysis of cytotoxic T lymphocyte response in rejecting allografted canine kidneys

The involvement of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) in the rejection process of allografted canine kidneys was studied. The frequency of donor-specific (precursor) CTL was determined with a sensitive limiting dilution assay. Longitudinal sampling of peripheral blood and kidney aspiration biopsies were used to obtain information on the CTL response toward the graft. An accurate analysis of CTL kinetics in both kidney and peripheral blood of allografted dogs appeared to be technically possible. During the first days after transplantation precursor CTL (CTLp) frequencies decreased in both blood and kidney. A minimum CTLp frequency of 5-15% of the pretransplant value was reached in the peripheral blood at day 4 after transplantation. The cause of this decrease, which was observed in all 5 allografted dogs is discussed. CTLp frequencies increased after day 4 and showed an exponential rise in the kidney before serum creatinine increased due to loss of kidney function caused by rejection. The data obtained with the quantitative study of CTL show that rejection of a canine kidney allograft is accompanied by a rise in CTL numbers in the kidney. The methodology developed permits extensive functional analysis of cellular processes in allografted organs.     

Donor Fas Is Not Necessary for T‐Cell‐Mediated Rejection of Mouse Kidney Allografts

It is important to resolve whether T‐cell‐mediated rejection (TCMR) is mediated by contact‐dependent cytotoxicity or by contact‐independent inflammatory mechanisms. We recently showed that the cytotoxic molecules perforin and granzymes A and B are not required for TCMR of mouse kidney transplants. Nevertheless, TCMR could still be mediated by cytotoxicity via Fas on donor cells engaging Fas ligand on host T cells. We examined whether the diagnostic TCMR lesions would be abrogated if donor Fas was absent, particularly in hosts deficient in perforin or granzymes A and B. Kidneys from Fas‐deficient donors transplanted into major histocompatibility complex (MHC)‐ mismatched hosts developed tubulitis and diffuse interstitial infiltration indistinguishable from wild‐type (WT) allografts, even in hosts deficient in perforin and granzymes A and B. Gene expression analysis revealed similar molecular disturbances in Fas‐deficient and WT allografts at day 21 transplanted into WT, perforin and granzyme A/B‐deficient hosts, indicating epithelial injury and dedifferentiation. Thus, donor Fas is not necessary for TCMR diagnostic lesions or molecular changes, even in the absence of perforin–granzyme mechanisms. We propose that in TCMR, interstitial effector T cells mediate parenchymal injury by inflammatory mechanisms that require neither the perforin–granzyme nor the Fas–Fas ligand cytotoxic mechanisms.     

Direct killing of xenograft cells by CD8+ T cells of discordant xenograft recipients

BACKGROUND: Long-term pig xenografts in monkeys demonstrated the infiltration of CD8 T cells into pig cartilage xenografts, transplanted into monkeys. The objective of the present study was to determine in an experimental animal model whether CD8 T cells in pig xenograft recipients exert any direct cytotoxic effect on pig cells. METHODS: The killing of xenograft cells by CD8 T cells, obtained from xenograft recipients, was studied in alpha1,3galactosyltransferase knockout mice that were repeatedly injected intraperitoneally with pig kidney membranes. The pig kidney cell line PK15, which shares many antigens with pig kidney membranes, served as a model for xenograft target cells in cytotoxicity assays. Cell lines from other species were also studied as target cells. RESULTS: Lymphocytes obtained freshly from spleens of mice immunized with pig kidney membranes failed to display significant cytotoxic activity against pig cells. However, incubation of these lymphocytes with irradiated PK15 cells and addition of recombinant interleukin (IL)-2 (100 U/mL), on the third day of incubation, resulted in extensive proliferation and expansion of CD8 cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL). These CTL, obtained after 12 days of incubation, killed nonspecifically pig, human, and mouse normal and malignant cells. These CTL were not generated in cultures in the absence of stimulatory pig cells or in the absence of IL-2. These CTL could not be generated in cultures of lymphocytes from naive mice that were incubated with PK15 cells and IL-2. CONCLUSIONS: The data obtained imply that CD8 T cells from xenograft recipients can be stimulated in vitro by xenoantigens and IL-2 to differentiate into highly reactive nonspecific CTL that are capable of killing a large variety of xenogeneic and syngeneic cells. Similar in vivo microenvironmental conditions within the xenograft may induce the local differentiation of infiltrating CD8 T cells into CTL that can destroy nonspecifically adjacent xenograft cells. Such cells may not be active outside the xenograft because of the absence of IL-2 in sufficiently high concentrations.     

Apoptosis and expression of cytotoxic T lymphocyte effector molecules in renal allografts.

Cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) mediated apoptosis is thought to play a major role in the rejection of renal allografts following transplantation, however, the CTL effector mechanism that is primarily responsible for immunological rejection is unknown. The two major effector pathways of CTL killing which lead to apoptosis involve the Fas/Fas ligand (Fas L) lytic pathway, and the perforin/granzyme degranulation pathway. The expression of CTL effector molecules which influence these pathways include Fas, Fas L and TiA-1 (cytotoxic granule protein). This study has investigated apoptosis by in situ terminal deoxytransferase-catalysed DNA nick end labelling (TUNEL), and the expression of CTL effector molecules by immunohistochemistry, in renal allograft biopsies obtained from patients following kidney transplantation. Renal biopsies were classified into three histological groups; acute cellular rejection, chronic rejection, or no rejection. The extent of T-cell infiltration of renal tissues was assessed by immunohistochemical staining with an anti-CD3 monoclonal antibody. Numerous TUNEL positive cells were detected in all transplant biopsies examined; these consisted mainly of renal tubular cells and infiltrating cells, with some TUNEL positive cells also detected in the glomeruli. In the case of normal kidney tissue, renal cells also stained positive for TUNEL but there was no lymphocytic infiltration. There was significantly more T-cell infiltration observed in acute rejection biopsies compared to the no rejection biopsies. In the case of Fas L expression, there was little expression in all three biopsy groups, apart from one case of chronic rejection. Conversely, although there were no significant differences in TiA-1 expression between the three biopsy groups, TiA-1 expression was more prominent in acute rejection biopsies. Furthermore, Fas expression was significantly decreased in acute rejection biopsies when compared to those of chronic and no rejection in which Fas was predominantly localized in the renal tubular cells. These results indicate that the mechanism of CTL killing leading to the rejection of renal allografts may be different in acute and chronic rejection. Moreover, our data indicate the potential for cytotoxic granule-based CTL killing in acute renal allograft rejection but not in chronic rejection.     

Expression of the SART3 tumor rejection antigen in renal cell carcinoma

PURPOSE: We recently reported that SART3 tumor rejection antigen is recognized by HLA class I restricted cytotoxic T lymphocytes from patients with esophageal cancer. We now investigate the expression of SART3 antigen in renal cell carcinoma to identify an appropriate molecule that may be used in specific immunotherapy of renal cell carcinoma. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Renal cell carcinoma and nontumorous kidney tissues were obtained at surgery. A section of each sample was minced with scissors and stored at -80C until use. SART3 antigen expression was examined in uncultured renal cell carcinoma and nontumorous kidney tissues. We also evaluated the ability of derived peptides to include cytotoxic T lymphocytes in peripheral blood mononuclear cells from patients with renal cell carcinoma. RESULTS: The SART3 antigen was detected in all renal cell carcinoma cell lines, primary cultures of renal cell carcinoma and nontumorous kidney tissues, and in the cytosol of 57% and 15% of renal cell carcinoma and nontumorous kidney tissues, respectively. HLA-A2402 restricted and tumor specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (KE4) used in cloning of the SART3 gene were significantly cytotoxic to cells from renal cell carcinoma cell lines and primary cultures of renal cell carcinoma tissue but they did not lyse normal cells, including those from primary cultures of nontumorous kidney tissue. The SART3 peptides derived from positions 109-118 and 315-323 induced HLA-A24 restricted cytotoxic T lymphocytes to renal cell carcinoma cells from peripheral blood mononuclear cells of patients with renal cell carcinoma. CONCLUSIONS: The SART3 antigen and derived peptides may be applied to the specific immunotherapy of HLA-A24+ renal cell carcinoma.     

T Cell‐mediated Rejection of Kidney Transplants: A Personal Viewpoint

In kidney allografts, T cell mediated rejection (TCMR) is characterized by infiltration of the interstitium by T cells and macrophages, intense IFNG and TGFB effects, and epithelial deterioration. Recent experimental and clinical studies provide the basis for a provisional model for TCMR. The model proposes that the major unit of cognate recognition in TCMR is effector T cells engaging donor antigen on macrophages. This event creates the inflammatory compartment that recruits effector and effector memory CD4 and CD8 T cells, both cognate and noncognate, and macrophage precursors. Cognate T cells cross the donor microcirculation to enter the interstitium but spare the microcirculation. Local inflammation triggers dedifferentiation of the adjacent epithelium (e.g. loss of transporters and expression of embryonic genes) rather than cell death, via mechanisms that do not require known T‐cell cytotoxic mechanisms or direct contact of T cells with the epithelium. Local epithelial changes trigger a response of the entire nephron and a second wave of dedifferentiation. The dedifferentiated epithelium is unable to exclude T cells, which enter to produce tubulitis lesions. Thus TCMR is a cognate recognition‐based process that creates local inflammation and epithelial dedifferentiation, stereotyped nephron responses, and tubulitis, and if untreated causes irreversible nephron loss.     

In vivo and in vitro induction of class II molecules on canine renal cells and their effect on the mixed lymphocyte kidney cell culture

Canine renal cortical cells were obtained by collagenase extraction from allogeneic haploidentical, donor-recipient beagle littermate pairs and from unrelated mongrels. Peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) of the mongrels, as well as of one member of the beagle pair that exhibited high mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) reactivity against the other were also stimulated by renal cortical cells derived from both normal and rejected transplanted kidneys in mixed lymphocyte kidney cell culture (MLKC). A moderate autologous MLKC reactivity occurred in response to normal renal cortical cells. However, rejected kidney cortical cells were markedly more stimulatory than normal renal cortical cells in both allogeneic and autologous MLKC reactions. Lymphocytes from donor animals responded more strongly to autologous cortical cells isolated during rejection of the transplant than to cortical cells from normal allogeneic kidneys. Recipient infiltrating lymphocytes and propagated T cell lines extracted from the rejected kidney also responded more strongly than PBL to cortical cells from this kidney. Gradient purification of the stimulating cortical cells resulted in one virtually pure preparation of distal tubular epithelial cells, as demonstrated by immunohistochemical stains and electron microscopy, which caused enhanced stimulation in MLKC. Class II marker analysis of the canine renal cells from rejected kidneys revealed the presence of these molecules on tubular cells that were absent on normal kidney cells. A 16-hr coculture of normal renal cortical cells not exhibiting class II surface markers in the presence of allogeneic or autologous lymphocytes induced the expression of these molecules, associated with an increased stimulatory capacity. This also occurred to a lesser extent with MLC (and MLKC) cell culture media supernatants. However, the low level of class II expression by all the various gradient-purified fractions in the absence of rejection or coculture, and the increased but equivalent expression on all fractions after coculture did not correlate with the preferential stimulatory capacity of the purified distal tubular cell layer. We conclude that two signals are necessary for the MLKC reaction, one involving tissue (kidney)-associated epitopes (the nominal antigen demonstrated in this study to be present in normal distal tubular cells), the other involving class II molecules as costimulatory (amplification) moieties.     

Lymphocyte adhesion molecules in T cell-mediated lysis of human kidney cells.

The complementary adhesion molecules LFA-1 (CD11a, 18)/ICAM-1 (CD54) and LFA-2 (CD2)/LFA-3 (CD58) have been shown to be important in T cell interaction with lymphoid target cells. The role of these ligand pairs in cytotoxicity against somatic cells is less well established. While LFA-3 is expressed by all cells in the kidney, ICAM-1 expression is low in normal kidneys but is increased in allograft rejection. An in vitro cytotoxicity assay was used to examine the relative importance of the two adhesion ligands in immune damage against kidney cells in rejection. HLA-A2 specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) recognition of cultured human kidney cells (HKC), of predominantly renal tubular cell origin, was studied. Immunofluorescence studies showed that both induced and uninduced HKC target cells expressed ICAM-1, MHC class I and LFA-3, but only MHC class I and class II antigens and ICAM-1 were significantly upregulated by cytokine induction. Effector cells expressed LFA-1 and LFA-2 but little or no ICAM-1 and LFA-3. Cytokine induction of ICAM-1 expression on HKC target cells increased their susceptibility to lysis. Monoclonal antibody against ICAM-1 or LFA-1 produced the greatest inhibition of HKC lysis, and their effects were not additive. Antibody against LFA-2 (CD2) or LFA-3 also produced significant inhibition, but to a lesser degree, and no additive effect was found.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)