Ultrasound is a reliable measure of muscle thickness in acute stroke patients, for some, but not all anatomical sites: a study of the intra-rater reliability of muscle thickness measures in acute stroke patients

This prospective, blinded study investigates the test retest reliability of measures of muscle thickness made by one sonographer across two cohort groups (n = 29) of people hospitalised with acute stroke. Reliability was assessed in cohort one (n = 14) for measurements made bilaterally at the anterior and posterior upper arms, the anterior and posterior thighs (total of eight measurements) and in cohort two (n = 15), for measurements made bilaterally at the lateral forearms, the anterior abdominal wall and the anterior and lower legs (total of eight measurements). Reliability estimates varied between measurement sites; intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs) ranged from -0.26 (lateral forearm, paretic side) to 0.95 (anterior thigh, nonparetic side), percent mean differences ranged from 0.42% (posterior upper arm, nonparetic side) to 14.68% (anterior lower limb, nonparetic side) and method error ranged from 1.08 (abdomen, nonparetic side) to 9.69 mm (posterior lower limb, nonparetic side). Only four measurement sites (anterior upper arm, posterior upper arm, abdomen and anterior thigh) were within the acceptable ranges (ICC 0.60 to 1.00, mean percent difference range 0%-5% and method error range 0-5 mm) and considered reliable to use for measures of muscle thickness in people hospitalised with acute stroke.     

An evaluation of the hemiplegic patient based on the Bobath approach: a reliability study.

The intra- and inter-rater reliability of a motor function evaluation of stroke patients, based on the Bobath approach, was studied. The intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) was used to determine the degree of agreement between repeated measurements on the same patient taken by the same rater and between measurements taken by three raters on the same patient. In the intra-rater study, each of 19 patients was evaluated in three different sessions by one of 19 raters. In the inter-rater study 18 patients were each evaluated by three different raters. The intra-rater data were highly reliable, with ICCs of 0.95 and 0.97 for the upper and lower limbs respectively. For the inter-rater study, the ICCs were 0.79 and 0.77 for the upper and lower limbs respectively. It can therefore be concluded that this instrument, previously demonstrated to quantify patient progress, is also reliable both in intra- and inter-rater dimensions.     

Goniometric reliability in a clinical setting. Shoulder measurements

The purpose of this study was to examine the intratester and intertester reliabilities for clinical goniometric measurements of shoulder passive range of motion (PROM) using two different sizes of universal goniometers. Patients were measured without controlling therapist goniometric placement technique or patient position during measurements. Repeated PROM measurements of shoulder flexion, extension, abduction, shoulder horizontal abduction, horizontal adduction, lateral (external) rotation, and medial (internal) rotation were taken of two groups of 50 subjects each. The intratester intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs) for all motions ranged from .87 to .99. The ICCs for the intertester reliability of PROM measurements of horizontal abduction, horizontal adduction, extension, and medial rotation ranged from .26 to .55. The intertester ICCs for PROM measurements of flexion, abduction, and lateral rotation ranged from .84 to .90. Goniometric PROM measurements for the shoulder appear to be highly reliable when taken by the same physical therapist, regardless of the size of the goniometer used. The degree of intertester reliability for these measurements appears to be range-of-motion specific.     

Reliability and comparison of weight-bearing ability during standing tasks for individuals with chronic stroke

OBJECTIVES: To determine the test-retest reliability over 2 separate days for weight-bearing ability during standing tasks in individuals with chronic stroke and to compare the weight-bearing ability among 5 standing tasks for the paretic and nonparetic limbs. DESIGN: Prospective study using a convenient sample. SETTING: Free-standing tertiary rehabilitation center. PARTICIPANTS: Fifteen community-dwelling stroke individuals with moderate motor deficits; volunteer sample. INTERVENTIONS: Not applicable. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Weight-bearing ability as measured by the vertical ground reaction force during 5 standing tasks (rising from a chair, quiet standing, weight-shifting forward, backward, laterally). RESULTS: The weight-bearing ability was less for the paretic limb compared with the nonparetic limb, but the intraclass correlation coefficients were high (.95-.99) for both limbs between the 2 sessions for all 5 tasks. The forward weight-shifting ability was particularly low in magnitude on the paretic side compared with the other weight-shifting tasks. In addition, the forward weight-shift ability of the nonparetic limb was also impaired but to a lesser extent. Large asymmetry was evident when rising from a chair, with the paretic limb bearing a mean 296N and the nonparetic side bearing a mean 458N. The weight-bearing ability during all 5 tasks correlated with one another (r range,.56-.94). CONCLUSIONS: Weight-bearing ability can be reliably measured and may serve as a useful outcome measure in individuals with stroke. We suggest that impairments of the hemiparetic side during forward weight shifting and sit-to-stand tasks presents a challenge to the motor systems of individuals with stroke, which may account for the poor balance that is often observed in these individuals.     

Reliability of lower extremity girth measurements after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

The purpose of this study was to determine the intra- and inter-rater reliability of lower extremity girth measurements in patients recovering from anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstructive surgery. Nine subjects, within several months of their surgery, volunteered. Circumferential measurements were taken of the involved and uninvolved legs at the following locations: 15 cm inferior to the joint line; 5, 10 and 15 cm superior to the joint line; at the joint line; and at mid-thigh. All subjects were supine with the knee in extension whilst a specially designed device, formulated to make circumferential measurements at locations around the knee, was applied to the extremity. Three physical therapists each repeated all measurements on two occasions, in random order, during the same test session. Intra-tester intraclass correlation (ICCs) calculated showed high coefficients (0.82–1.0) for both the involved and uninvolved sides for all locations of the measurement. Inter-tester ICCs ranged from 0.72 to 0.97. The measurements established sufficiently high reliability to justify their use both within and between examiners for subjects recovering from surgery of the ACL. Copyright © 1996 Whurr Publishers Ltd.     

Obtaining reliable measurements of knee extensor torque produced during maximal voluntary contractions: an experimental investigation.

The purpose of this study was to develop and test a protocol that could be used to obtain reliable measurements of knee extensor torque produced during maximal voluntary contractions. On each of 3 days, 10 subjects performed six consecutive maximal voluntary contractions, in the same randomized order, for each of the following 10 conditions: concentric isokinetic contractions at velocities of 30 degrees, 90 degrees, 120 degrees, and 180 degrees/s; eccentric isokinetic contractions at velocities of 30 degrees, 90 degrees, 120 degrees, and 180 degrees/s; and isometric contractions at 40 and 60 degrees of knee flexion. The peak torques produced were examined to determine on which day and during which contraction subjects produced the greatest torques for each condition. This information was used to develop a practice protocol. Fifteen different subjects were tested following this protocol. Subjects participated in two practice sessions, a test session, and a retest session. Intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs) were calculated to determine the degree of agreement between torques for the test and retest sessions. The ICCs ranged from .87 to .98. The protocol developed appears to be useful for obtaining reliable measurements of knee extensor torque.     

Reliability of clinical measurements of forward bending using the modified fingertip-to-floor method

The purpose of this study was to examine the intratherapist and intertherapist reliability of measurements obtained with a modified version of the fingertip-to-floor method of assessing forward bending. With the modified fingertip-to-floor (MFTF) method, patients stand on a stool and forward bend so that measurements can be taken on patients who are able to touch the floor or reach beyond the level of the floor. Randomly paired physical therapists took repeated MFTF measurements on 73 patients with low back pain. Intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs) were calculated for intratherapist and intertherapist reliability. The ICC value for intratherapist reliability was .98, and the ICC value for intertherapist reliability was .95. The results of this study suggest that measurements of forward bending obtained on patients with low back pain using the MFTF method are highly reliable.     

Reliability and responsiveness of elbow trajectory tracking in chronic poststroke hemiparesis

This study established the reliability of a novel upper-limb trajectory-tracking task for assessment of perceptual motor control in hemiparetic adults. Eleven persons with chronic poststroke hemiparesis (mean 58.6 months) and eleven nondisabled control subjects performed an elbow flexion-extension task against a low-resistance isotonic load at three speeds: 25 degrees/s, 45 degrees/s, and 65 degrees/s. Both arms (paretic and nonparetic or dominant and nondominant) were tested during two identical sessions separated by 1 week. Relative reliability (intraclass correlation coefficient [ICC]) ranged from 0.5 to 0.8 and absolute reliability (standard error of measurement [SEM%]) ranged between 19% to 36% across both subject groups. No systematic errors between test sessions were revealed. Smallest real differences (SRDs) were determined to be +/- 2 degrees to 3 degrees in nondisabled, +/- 2 degrees to 5 degrees in nonparetic and +/- 9 degrees in paretic arms. Responsiveness ratios derived with the use of the SRDs ranged between 1.91 to 2.45, indicating that this instrument is sensitive to clinically important change and suitable for demonstrating effects on upper-limb motor performance following clinical intervention.     

Decreased shoulder range of motion on paretic side after stroke

The purposes of this investigation of patients with stroke were to 1) determine and compare shoulder lateral rotation range of motion (SLRROM) measured at the threshold of pain on the paretic and nonparetic sides; 2) establish the intrarater and interrater reliability of the measurements; and 3) determine the relationship between SLRROM measurements and the independent variables of age, sex, and time since onset of stroke. Subjects were 25 rehabilitation inpatients. The two investigators each measured the patients' SLRROM twice on both the paretic and nonparetic sides using a gravity goniometer. An analysis of variance (ANOVA) demonstrated that SLRROM was significantly less on the paretic side than on the nonparetic side (F = 28.98, p less than .001). The ANOVA demonstrated no difference in the two raters' measurements of SLRROM. The intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC[3,1]) and interrater reliability coefficients were all good to high (.874-.989). The SLRROM on the paretic side correlated significantly with time since onset of stroke (r = -.538, p less than .01). As a consequence of this study, we concluded that 1) patients with stroke tend to lose SLRROM on the paretic side, 2) SLRROM tends to decrease with time, and 3) measurements of SLRROM obtained with a gravity goniometer are reliable and sensitive.     

Navicular drop measurement in people with rheumatoid arthritis: interrater and intrarater reliability

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Navicular drop (ND) measurement may be a valuable examination technique for patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA). However, no data exist on reliability for this technique in patients with RA. The purposes of this study were: (1) to determine interrater and intrarater reliability of ND measurements in people with RA, (2) to compare ND values of people with RA with published normative data, and (3) to investigate ND measurement error associated with the use of skin markings. SUBJECTS: Ten women (20 feet) with RA consented to participate. METHODS: Patients completed demographic and function questionnaires. Navicular height (NH) measurements were taken by 2 physical therapists and 1 physical therapist student, following four 1-hour training sessions, using standardized methods and a digital height gauge. Four different NH measurements were taken 3 times on each foot by each of the 3 examiners during a morning session and then repeated during an afternoon session on the same day. Navicular drop values were calculated, including ND1 (as reported in the literature), ND2 (compensating for skin error), and ND3 (single-limb stance). Intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs) and standard errors of measurement (SEMs) were used to establish reliability. RESULTS: Means (+/-SD) for each ND measure for sessions 1 and 2, respectively, were as follows: ND1=8.36+/-5.29 mm and 8.29+/-5.24 mm, ND2=9.95+/-5.44 mm and 9.57+/-5.37 mm. The ICCs (2,1 and 2,k, respectively) for all interrater measurements ranged from .67 to .92 (SEM=2.0-3.3 mm) and from .85 to .97 (SEM=1.1-2.0 mm). The ICCs (2,1 and 2,k, respectively) for intrarater measurements ranged from .73 to .95 (SEM=1.3-2.8 mm) and from .90 to .98 (SEM=0.7-1.6 mm). Paired t tests showed the means of ND1 and ND2 for each examiner and for both sessions were significantly different. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION: The results suggest that ND measurements for people with RA can be taken reliably by clinicians with varied experience. The ND values for our subjects were slightly greater than reported normal values of 6 to 8 mm. Error associated with skin markings was statistically significant for all sessions and examiners.     

Test–retest reliability of the IDEEA system in the quantification of step parameters during walking and stair climbing

The aim of this investigation was to evaluate the inter‐ and intra‐session reliability of spatio‐temporal gait variables collected during walking and stair climbing with the Intelligent Device for Energy Expenditure and physical Activity (IDEEA) accelerometer‐based system. Eighteen healthy subjects (10 men, 8 women) completed a standardized indoor circuit comprised of walking and stair climbing. Intra‐and inter‐session reliability was investigated for several pertinent spatio‐temporal gait variables using intraclass correlations [ICC (3,1)]. Intra‐session reliability during walking showed a high reliability of the IDEEA with ICCs ranging between 0·84 (number of steps) and 0·97 (single limb support/double limb support). The ICCs for stair climbing were slightly lower than those during walking with values ranging between 0·74 (step duration) and 0·92 (number of steps). Inter‐session reliability during walking showed a high reliability of the IDEEA between all trials, with values ranging between 0·87 (speed) to 0·98 (step duration). The ICCs of stair climbing were again lower than those during walking with values ranging from 0·64 (swing duration) to 0·79 (number of steps). The IDEEA accelerometer‐based system provided a highly reliable measurement of spatio‐temporal variables, in healthy subjects, during walking with moderately reduced correlations during stair climbing.     

Reliability of knee flexor peak torque measurements from a standardized test protocol on a Kin/Com dynamometer.

The test-retest reliability of a specific test protocol for the measurement of peak torque of the knee flexors using a Kin/Com dynamometer was evaluated. The maximum voluntary torque generated by the left knee flexors during constant velocity resisted-muscle shortening (RMS) and muscle lengthening (RML) was measured in a sitting position in 11 healthy women with no history of knee pathology. Each subject performed two tests at each of two velocities (30 degrees/sec and 180 degrees/sec) in a single session. All subjects repeated these four tests one week later. A test consisted of four complete RMS/RML cycles through a range of 65 degrees. The peak torque generated from each test was used to measure test-retest reliability. All data were gravity compensated. Intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs) were calculated from ANOVA tests for RML and RMS at both velocities. The within sessions ICCs ranged from .94 to .98 for 30 degrees/sec and from .92 to .97 at 180 degrees/sec. The ICCs between sessions were generally lower and ranged from .79 to .90 for 30 degrees/sec, and from .75 to .88 for 180 degrees/sec. It is concluded that using these test protocols, peak torques for both RMS and RML can be measured with a high degree of reliability at two commonly used velocities.     

Reliability of safe maximum lifting determinations of a functional capacity evaluation

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Functional capacity evaluations (FCEs) are measurement tools used in predicting readiness to return to work following injury. The interrater and test-retest reliability of determinations of maximal safe lifting during kinesiophysical FCEs were examined in a sample of people who were off work and receiving workers' compensation. SUBJECTS: Twenty-eight subjects with low back pain who had plateaued with treatment were enrolled. Five occupational therapists, trained and experienced in kinesiophysical methods, conducted testing. METHODS: A repeated-measures design was used, with raters testing subjects simultaneously, yet independently. Subjects were rated on 2 occasions, separated by 2 to 4 days. Analyses included intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs) and 95% confidence intervals. RESULTS: The ICC values for interrater reliability ranged from.95 to.98. Test-retest values ranged from.78 to.94. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION: Inconsistencies in subjects' performance across sessions were the greatest source of FCE measurement variability. Overall, however, test-retest reliability was good and interrater reliability was excellent.     

What change in isokinetic knee muscle strength can be detected in men and women with hemiparesis after stroke?

OBJECTIVE: To assess the intra-rater (between occasions) test-retest reliability of isokinetic knee muscle strength measurements in subjects with chronic poststroke hemiparesis and to define limits for the smallest change that indicates real (clinical) improvements for stroke patients. SUBJECTS: Fifty men and women (mean age 58 +/- 6.4 years) 6-46 months post stroke, able to walk at least 300 m with or without a unilateral assistive device. METHODS: Maximal concentric knee extension and flexion contractions at 60 degrees/s and 120 degrees/s, and maximal eccentric knee extension contractions at 60 degrees/s, with the paretic and nonparetic limbs, were performed seven days apart using a Biodex dynamometer. MEASURES: Reliability of the maximum peak torque measurements was evaluated with the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC(2,1)), the Bland and Altman analyses, the standard error of measurement (SEM and SEM%) and the smallest real difference (SRD and SRD%). RESULTS: Test-retest agreements were high (ICC(2,1) 0.89-0.96) with no discernible systematic differences between limbs, angular velocities and modes. The SEM%, representing the smallest change that indicates a real (clinical) improvement for a group of subjects, was relatively small (8-20%). The SRD%, representing the smallest change that indicates a real improvement for a single subject ranged from 26% to 33% for concentric knee extension, from 39% to 55% for concentric knee flexion, and from 22% to 25% for eccentric knee extension. CONCLUSION: Isokinetic knee muscle strength can be reliably measured and used to detect real improvements following an intervention for single subjects as well as for groups of subjects with chronic mild to moderate hemiparesis after stroke.     

Reliability of goniometric measurements and visual estimates of knee range of motion obtained in a clinical setting

The purpose of this study was to examine the intratester and intertester reliability for goniometric measurements of knee flexion and extension passive range of motion (PROM). In addition, parallel-forms reliability for PROM measurements of the knee obtained by use of a goniometer and by visual estimation was examined. The intertester reliability for visual estimates of the PROM of the knee was also examined. Repeated measurements were obtained on 43 patients in a clinical setting. The intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs) for intratester reliability of measurements obtained with a goniometer were .99 for flexion and .98 for extension. Intertester reliability for measurements obtained with a goniometer was .90 for flexion and .86 for extension. The ICCs for parallel-forms reliability for measurements obtained with a goniometer and by visual estimation ranged from .82 to .94. The intertester reliability for measurements obtained by visual estimation was .83 for flexion and .82 for extension. Results suggest clinicians should use a goniometer to take repeated PROM measurements of a patient's knee to minimize the error associated with these measurements.     

Reliability of new software in measuring cervical multifidus diameters and shoulder muscle strength in a synchronized way; an ultrasonographic study

OBJECTIVES:

This study was conducted with the purpose of evaluating the inter-session reliability of new software to measure the diameters of the cervical multifidus muscle (CMM), both at rest and during isometric contractions of the shoulder abductors in subjects with neck pain and in healthy individuals.

METHOD:

In the present study, the reliability of measuring the diameters of the CMM with the Sonosynch software was evaluated by using 24 participants, including 12 subjects with chronic neck pain and 12 healthy individuals. The anterior-posterior diameter (APD) and the lateral diameter (LD) of the CMM were measured in a resting state and then repeated during isometric contraction of the shoulder abductors. Measurements were taken on separate occasions 3 to 7 days apart in order to determine inter-session reliability. Intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC), standard error of measurement (SEM), and smallest detectable difference (SDD) were used to evaluate the relative and absolute reliability, respectively.

RESULTS:

The Sonosynch software has shown to be highly reliable in measuring the diameters of the CMM both in healthy subjects and in those with neck pain. The ICCs 95% CI for APD ranged from 0.84 to 0.94 in subjects with neck pain and from 0.86 to 0.94 in healthy subjects. For LD, the ICC 95% CI ranged from 0.64 to 0.95 in subjects with neck pain and from 0.82 to 0.92 in healthy subjects.

CONCLUSIONS:

Ultrasonographic measurement of the diameters of the CMM using Sonosynch has proved to be reliable especially for APD in healthy subjects as well as subjects with neck pain.     

The relationship between bilateral knee muscle strength and gait performance after stroke: the predictive value for gait performance

[Purpose] The purpose of this study was to assess the relationships between bilateral knee extension strengths and gait performance in subjects with poststroke hemiparesis and to predict gait performance by the paretic and nonparetic knee extension strength. [Subjects and Methods] This was a correlational study in which 238 consecutive inpatients with poststroke hemiparesis were enrolled. Knee extensor muscle strengths in paretic and nonparetic lower limbs were measured with a handheld dynamometer, and the presence or absence of impaired gait was also determined. [Results] The mean strength in the paretic lower limb was 0.90 Nm/kg, and that in the nonparetic lower limb was 1.24 Nm/kg. Discriminant analysis classified the difference between the possibility and impossibility of gait by knee extensor muscle strength (standardized discriminant coefficient: paretic, 1.32; nonparetic, 0.55). Thus, paretic and nonparetic knee extension strengths were integrated in the strength index. A threshold level of 2.0 provided the best balance between positive and negative predictive values for the strength index. [Conclusion] The results indicated that both paretic and nonparetic knee extension strengths were related to gait performance. The strength index deduced from bilateral knee extension strengths may serve as a clinically meaningful index for rehabilitation assessment and training.Key words: Stroke, Handheld dynamometer, Gait     

Criterion validity of the StepWatch Activity Monitor as a measure of walking activity in patients after stroke

Mudge S, Stott NS, Walt SE. Criterion validity of the StepWatch Activity Monitor as a measure of walking activity in patients after stroke.

Objectives

To test the validity of the StepWatch Activity Monitor (SAM) in subjects with stroke against 2 criterion standards, 3-dimensional gait analysis (3-DGA) and footswitches in a variety of indoor and outdoor walking conditions, including different speeds and different terrains, and to test the accuracy of the SAM when worn on the paretic limb.

Design

Criterion standard validation study.

Setting

Gait laboratory and outside course.

Participants

Twenty-five participants with physical disability after stroke.

Interventions

Not applicable.

Main Outcome Measures

The total step count measured simultaneously by SAM and either 3-DGA or footswitches for both paretic and nonparetic limbs.

Results

The total step count measured by the SAM and 3-DGA was highly correlated (nonparetic limb, r=.959; paretic limb, r=.896). The 95% limits of agreement (LOA) (derived from Bland-Altman analysis) between the SAM and 3-DGA were within ±10 steps for SAMs worn on either the nonparetic or paretic limb. The total step count measured simultaneously by the SAM and footswitches was also highly correlated for each limb (nonparetic, r=.999; paretic, r=.963). The 95% LOA between the SAM and footswitches were ±9 steps on the nonparetic limb but higher at ±57 steps on the paretic limb. Further analysis showed that the measurement differences occurred during the outdoor component of the combined walk. The 95% LOA between footswitches on both limbs were not more than ±9 steps for walking, suggesting that the error was accounted for by the SAM on the paretic limb, which both over- and underread the total step count in the outdoor walking conditions.

Conclusions

Criterion validity of the SAM to measure steps in both clinical and natural environments has been established when used on the nonparetic limb. However, more errors are apparent when the SAM is worn on the paretic limb while walking over a variety of outdoor terrains. Validation is recommended before use in patients with neurologic conditions affecting bilateral legs because there may be more error, particularly in outdoor activities.     

Validity and reliability of a hand-held dynamometer applied to adults with mental retardation.

The purpose of this study was to determine the validity and reliability of the Nicholas Manual Muscle Tester (MMT) as applied to ten adults with mild to moderate mental retardation between the ages of 18 to 39 years with an intelligence quotient (IQ) range of 36 to 69. Using stabilization techniques, isometric torque values were taken of knee extension and elbow flexion on separate days with the Nicholas MMT and a Cybex II dynamometer. Pearson product-moment correlations of these two instruments ranged from .64 to .76 (p less than 0.05). Based on 1 day of testing intrarater correlation coefficients for the Nicholas (MMT) ranged from .97 to .99 (p less than 0.05). In like fashion interrater generalizability coefficients were quite high (G = .97 - 98). Measurements of adults with mental retardation taken by two experienced evaluators with a Nicholas MMT seem to evaluate the component-isometric strength. Highly reliable measurements with stabilization techniques were obtained with this instrument.