Occlusal forces promote periodontal healing of transplanted teeth and prevent dentoalveolar ankylosis: an experimental study in rats

The process of healing periodontal ligaments (PDL) after transplantation has been widely examined, but the mechanism for preventing dentoalveolar ankylosis is still unclear. In this study, we focused on the role of mechanical stimuli in preventing ankylosis using an animal model of tooth transplantation assessed by histologic observation and evaluation of proliferating PDL cells. Five-week-old Sprague-Dawley male rats were divided into occluded and nonoccluded groups. The right maxillary first molars were replanted in both groups, and histologic observations were carried out after one or two weeks. The proliferative activity of PDL cells was also examined by assessing the distribution of 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine (BrdU). After two weeks in the nonoccluded group, ankylosis was clearly detected and PDL stricture was obvious, whereas no severe bone or root resorption was observed. On the other hand, the occluded group showed an enlarged and thickened PDL with extensive root resorption, but no ankylosis. Based on these findings, the replanted teeth were given a one-week healing period and then occlusion recovery was assessed, which resulted in decreased ankylosis and root resorption. The proliferative activity of PDL cells in the occluded group was generally higher than in the nonoccluded group. The activity of PDL cells in the recovery group was also higher than that of the nonoccluded group. These results suggest that occlusal stimuli promoted the regeneration of the PDL and prevented dentoalveolar ankylosis, whereas excessive initial force might cause severe root and bone resorption.     

Immediate replantation of maxillary incisors in rats: effects of tooth immersion in sodium fluoride and subsequent removal of the periodontal ligament

The advantages and disadvantages of maintaining the periodontal ligament (PDL) in immediate replantation as well as chemical treatment of the root surface have been a matter of discussion because the vitality of such tissue in surgery is always questioned. This study evaluated the effects of conserving the tooth in sodium fluoride and the removal of the PDL before replantation of incisors in rats. There was more cementum-dentin resorption in the group with the PDL. The group without the PDL showed more discreet resorption, repair occurred through the newly formed bone tissue in the PDL space and ankylosis was more extensive than in the group with the PDL.     

Treatment of replacement resorption with Emdogain® − a prospective clinical study

The present clinical study investigated the outcome of intentional replantation using Emdogain for periodontal healing following trauma‐related ankylosis. Sixteen ankylosed teeth affected by replacement resorption were treated as follows: After tooth extraction, the root canal was obturated with a retrograde titanium post. Emdogain was applied to the root surface and into the extraction socket with subsequent replantation of the tooth. Evaluation parameters included horizontal and vertical Periotest scores, percussion sound and periapical radiographs. All findings were compared to those of the adjacent teeth. The mean follow‐up period was 15 months (range 4–24 months). Eleven teeth showed no signs of recurrence of ankylosis: they were in full function and exhibited no pathological clinical findings. Four severely traumatized teeth demonstrated a recurrence of ankylosis after a mean period of 6 months, one tooth was lost in a second accident after 7 months. The estimated probability of 1 year without recurrence of ankylosis was P = 0.66 (95% confidence interval [0.40; 0.94]). The mean survival time was 10.2 months (SD 1.1). The results indicate that treatment of replacement resorption following light to moderate trauma with replantation and Emdogain appears to prevent or delay recurrence of ankylosis in many cases.     

Treatment of replacement resorption with Emdogain®– preliminary results after 10 months

Abstract – Ankylosis of traumatized teeth in children and adolescents may inhibit further development and growth of the corresponding jawbone. Therefore, ankylosed teeth should be removed. As an alternative treatment option to autotransplantation of a premolar, intentional replantation using Emdogain^® may be considered, provided the ankylosis is detected at an early stage or has only affected a small area of the root. Eleven ankylosed teeth presenting with replacement resorption were treated as follows: after tooth extraction, the root canal was treated extraorally and obturated by retrograde insertion of a titanium post. Emdogain was applied to the root surface and into the extraction socket with subsequent replantation of the tooth. During a mean follow-up period of 6.3 months, no signs of recurrence of ankylosis were noted. The horizontally and vertically measured Periotest scores were identical to those obtained on the adjacent teeth. These results suggest that intentional replantation using Emdogain may prevent or delay ankylosis of these replanted teeth.     

Delayed replantation after submucosal storage in order to prevent root resorption after replantation. An experimental study in monkeys

The purpose of this study was to determine the root resorption pattern of teeth autotransplanted to a submucosal site and to determine whether root resorption after replantation could be prevented by delayed replantation of teeth after submucosal storage in order to regenerate damaged periodontal ligament. Permanent teeth were extracted in green Vervet monkeys. One group of teeth was transplanted to a submucosal site and examined histologically in situ. Another group of teeth was autotransplanted to submucosal sites, recovered and replanted either 2 or 6 weeks later. The animals were sacrificed 8 week after replantation and examined histometrically. The following histologic parameters were registered: surface resorption, inflammatory resorption, replacement resorption (ankylosis), periapical inflammatory changes and downgrowth of pocket epithelium. Teeth autotransplanted to submucosal sites developed surface and inflammatory resorption. In half of the cases where teeth were transplanted with a vital periodontal ligaments new formation of bone took place adjacent to the transplant. Delayed replantation after submucosal burial was not found to inhibit the development of ankylosis, but changed the resorption type from direct apposition of bone upon the root surface to apposition of bone after initial resorption.     

Decoronation for the management of an ankylosed young permanent tooth.

Replacement resorption rate is a variable process, and is dependent on age, basal metabolic rate, extra-alveolar time, treatment prior to replantation, amount of root dentin, severity of trauma, and extent of periodontal ligament necrosis. In patients 7-16 years old a tooth is lost 3-7 years after the onset of root resorption. The complications that may develop as a consequence of ankylosis of a permanent incisor in children are due to the inevitable early loss of the traumatized tooth and local arrest of alveolar bone development. An ankylosed tooth should be removed before the changes become so pronounced that they compromise future prosthetic treatment. The treatment options may involve: interceptive regenerative treatment, early extraction of the ankylosed tooth, orthodontic space closure, intentional replantation, extraction of the ankylosed tooth followed with immediate ridge augmentation/preservation, auto-transplantation, single tooth dento-osseous osteotomy, and decoronation. The purpose of this article was to review the considerations involved in the decision-making concerning the use of the decoronation technique for the treatment of a permanent incisor diagnosed as ankylosed.     

Progression of root resorption following replantation of human teeth after extended extraoral storage

Avulsed human permanent teeth subjected to a minimum of 1 h dry extraoral storage before replantation were followed radiographically for an average of 4.8 years. The depth of root resorption cavities was assessed using a radiographic index, and the rate of root resorption was defined as the index change over time. The frequency of inflammatory and replacement resorption was determined at each observation time. Replacement resorption increased in frequency with time in all patients. In teeth endodontically treated within 3 weeks of replantation, minimal inflammatory resorption was found regardless of the age of the patients. In teeth where endodontic treatment was performed more than 3 weeks after replantation, the frequency of inflammatory resorption was significantly higher in young patients but not in older patients, up to more than 3 years after replantation. The rate of root resorption was found to be related to age. In patients 8-16 years old at the time of avulsion the rate of root resorption was significantly higher compared with patients 17-39 years old. Age had a higher impact on the rate of root resorption compared with the delay in endodontic treatment after replantation. It was concluded that a tooth replanted with a necrotic periodontal membrane will become ankylosed and resorbed within 3-7 years in young patients, whereas a tooth replanted under similar conditions in older patients may remain in function for a considerably longer time.     

Preservation of alveolar bone of un-restorable traumatized maxillary incisors for future

Anterior maxillary implantation is a challenging treatment for both the surgeon and prosthodontist due to high esthetic demands in this area. However, it is the most traumatized and most exposed region to habits. Prompt and appropriate management can significantly improve prognosis of many dentoalveolar injuries, especially in young patients. Unfortunately, many traumatized teeth are overtreated or left untreated, which lead to a much more complicated treatment at the time of permanent restoration at adulthood. The facial cortical plate over the roots of the maxillary teeth is thin and porous. Periapical infections, as well as prolonged and stubborn surgical treatments (repeated root end surgeries) can cause resorption of the labial plate, migrate to a more palatal position, and may later require an augmentation procedure prior to implant placement. The treatment-options of traumatized, anterior maxillary, un-restorable fractured root and ankylosed infraocluded teeth, in relation to preservation of the adjacent alveolar bone for future use of dental implantation will be discussed. The recommended treatment of crown-root fracture of permanent incisor includes removal of the coronal fragment and supragingival restoration of the fractured root. In severe cases in which the fracture line positions deeply under the gingival margin, this treatment may be supplemented by gingivectomy and/or osteotomy, as well as surgical or orthodontic extrusion of the root. In young patients, use of these treatment options as temporary treatment to preserve the facial cortical plate is important. Preservation of alveolar dimension will enable implantation after the completion of growth and development. Dento-alveolar ankylosis accompanied by replacement resorption is a serious complication following severe injury to the periodontal membrane. This complication develops mainly following avulsion and intrusion but also following lateral luxation and root fracture. Replacement resorption develops after severe damage to the periodontal ligament cells that cover the root surface. As a result of this damage, the periodontal ligament is replaced by bone tissue, causing ankylosis between bone and tooth. Following ankylosis, resorption of cementum and root dentin occurs. These processes eventually result in replacement of the entire root by bone. In young children it could arrest the growth of the alveolar process and create an infra-occluded tooth, resulting in a severe bony defect that is difficult to correct. In addition, loss of the maxillary incisor leads to serious esthetic and restorative problems, particularly when the trauma occurs at a young age. Therefore, ankylosed teeth should be treated as soon as diagnosed. Alternative treatments include intentional extraction and immediate replantation of the ankylosed tooth to its socket after embedding the tooth and the socket in Emdogain. This treatment is indicated only when the ankylosis or the replacement resorption is diagnosed at an early stage or has affected only a small area of the root. When the resorption is diagnosed at a later stage, auto transplantation of first lower pre-molar to the anterior region or decoronation of the ankylosed tooth may be considered. Decoronation is a simple and safe surgical procedure for preservation of alveolar bone prior to implant placement. It should be considered as a treatment option for teeth affected by replacement resorption. The alternative treatment of surgical extraction of an ankylosed tooth often leads to considerable bone loss and reduced bone volume in the oro-facial dimension. This may later necessitate an augmentation procedure. CONCLUSION: Scrupulous diagnosis of teeth and the alveolar bone after a traumatic injury is necessary. Treatment is multidisciplinary, requiring endodontic, surgical, orthodontic, operative and prosthetic compliance. An individual treatment plan for each patient is necessary. General rule do not apply. Periodic check-up is essential.     

Progression of root resorption following replantation of human teeth after extended extraoral storage

Abstract Avulsed human permanent teeth subjected to a minimum of 1 h dry extraoral storage before replantation were followed radiographically for an average of 4.8 years. The depth of root resorption cavities was assessed using a radiographic index, and the rate of root resorption was defined as the index change over time. The frequency of inflammatory and replacement resorption was determined at each observation time. Replacement resorption increased in frequency with time in all patients. In teeth endodontically treated within 3 weeks of replantation, minimal inflammatory resorption was found regardless of the age of the patients. In teeth where endodontic treatment was performed more than 3 weeks after replantation, the frequency of inflammatory resorption was significantly higher in young patients but not in older patients, up to more than 3 years after replantation. The rate of root resorption was found to be related to age. In patients 8–16 years old at the time of avulsion the rate of root resorption was significantly higher compared with patients 17–39 years old. Age had a higher impact on the rate of root resorption compared with the delay in endodontic treatment after replantation. It was concluded that a tooth replanted with a necrotic periodontal membrane will become ankylosed and resorbed within 3–7 years in young patients, whereas a tooth replanted under similar conditions in older patients may remain in function for a considerably longer time.     

Periodontal and pulpal healing of monkey incisors preserved in tissue culture before replantation.

The effect of delayed replantation and tissue culture as a prevention against root resorption was examined in green Vervet monkeys (Cercopithecus aethiops). Extracted incisors were kept in tissue culture medium (Eagle's medium) for 5--14 days before replantation. The extra-alveolar dry period before tissue culture ranged from to 0 to 60 min. Incisors not subjected to tissue culture served as controls. The animals were sacrificed 8 weeks after replantation. The following histologic parameters were registered for each tooth: surface resorption, inflammatory resorption, replacement resorption (ankylosis), downgrowth of pocket epithelium, and periapical inflammatory changes. The evaluation of the pulp included the extent, recorded in mm, of pulp survival. Histometric evaluation showed that teeth immediately placed in tissue culture medium for 5--14 days showed improved periodontal healing, exhibiting significantly less inflammatory resorption than control teeth immediately replanted. Also the extent of pulp survival was significantly increased in teeth replanted after tissue culture. Teeth bench-dried for 60 min and thereafter placed in tissue culture medium also showed a significant reduction in the amount of inflammatory resorption and increased amount of pulp survival compared with control teeth replanted after the 60-min dry extra-alveolar period. Replacement resorption (ankylosis) was found in all teeth in both groups.     

Decoronation – a conservative method to treat ankylosed teeth for preservation of alveolar ridge prior to permanent prosthetic reconstruction: literature review and case presentation

Abstract –  Avulsed teeth that are stored extraorally in a dry environment for >60 min generally develop replacement root resorption or ankylosis following their replantation due to the absence of a vital periodontal ligament on their root surface. One negative sequelae of such ankylosis is tooth infra-positioning and the local arrest of alveolar bone growth. Removal of an ankylosed tooth may be difficult and traumatic leading to esthetic bony ridge deformities and optimal prosthetic treatment interferences. Recently a treatment option for ankylosed teeth named 'de-coronation' gained interest, particularly in pediatric dentistry that concentrated in dental traumatology. This article reviews the up-to-date literature that has been published on decoronation with respect to its importance for future prosthetic rehabilitation followed by a case presentation that demonstrates its clinical benefits.     

Periodontal healing of replanted monkey teeth prevented from drying

Root resorption of replanted teeth is dependent on the duration of the extra-alveolar period and on the storage environment. In the present investigation the significance of preserving the humidity of the periodontal ligament (PDL) during the extra-alveolar period was tested on isolated PDL cells and on replanted monkey teeth. The isolated PDL cells were tested with respect to cell viability (trypan blue exclusion test) and to cell recovery (number of cells after additional cultivation). About 70% of the cells were viable and 44% recovered after 1 h in a humid atmosphere. Practically no cells were viable or recovered after 1 h of drying. Replanted teeth that had been wrapped in plastic foil for 1 h before replantation showed no more resorption than immediately replanted teeth. This is in contrast to teeth dried in air for 1 h before replantation. They showed extensive root resorption on almost all root surfaces. Thus, prevention of evaporation of tissue fluid from the PDL must be considered a primary goal if the tooth cannot be replanted immediately.     

Periodontal healing after replantation and autotransplantation of incisors in monkeys

The effect of injury to the cemental or alveolar part of the periodontal ligament upon periodontal healing after replantation and autotransplantation of teeth was studied in green Vervet monkeys. Sixty-six maxillary central incisors were replanted or autotransplanted after extra-alveolar periods of 18 min. saline storage or 120 min. dry storage. The animals were sacrificed after 8 weeks and the teeth examined histometrically. Identical healing was found in the following experimental groups: replantation or autotransplantation after 18 min. and replantation with or without removal of periodontal ligament in the alveolus. A significant increase in replacement resorption (ankylosis) compared to the 18 min. replantation group was found in the following groups: replantation and autotransplantation after 120 min., replantation after removal of periodontal ligament on the root surface and autotransplantation after 120 min. to a socket where the tooth was extracted 18 min. earlier. Autotransplantation after 18 min. to a socket where a tooth had been extracted 120 min. earlier led to a significant increase in the amount of replacement resorption compared to transplantation to an 18 min. socket. Based on these findings, it is concluded that the presence of an intact and viable periodontal ligament on the root surface is the most important factor in assuring healing without root resorption. The length of the extra-alveolar period also seems to exert some influence upon the socket, enhancing the development of ankylosis.     

Long-term results after intentional tooth reimplantation in monkeys.

The purpose of this study was to evaluate histologically the long-term response to intentional tooth reimplantation in six rhesus monkeys. The study revealed that cervical and apical root resorption is a universal complication after tooth reimplantation and that arrested areas of resorption will show repair by deposition of cementum. A highly cellular periodontal membrane usually will develop. Periodontal fibers will reattach to reparative bone and cementum but seldom regain functional orientation. Partial or complete ankylosis may result. A further complication is progressive undermining resorption of the ankylosed teeth. Long-term studies are mandatory to evaluate the response to intentional tooth reimplantation.     

Treatment of replacement resorption by intentional replantation, resection of the ankylosed sites, and Emdogain®– results of a 6-year survey

Abstract –  The present clinical study investigated the outcome of intentional replantation using resection of the ankylosed sites of the root, extraoral endodontic treatment using titanium posts and Emdogain^® for periodontal healing following trauma-related ankylosis. During an evaluation period of 6 years, 16 ankylosed teeth affected by replacement resorption were treated as described. Evaluation parameters before treatment and during the follow-up period included Periotest^® scores, percussion sound and periapical radiographs. All findings were compared to those of the adjacent teeth. In a second accident, one tooth was lost after 7 months and was excluded as a dropout. Ankylosis did not recur in seven replanted teeth, which were observed for an average of 52.3 months (range: 24–68 months). Ankylosis recurred in eight teeth after an average period of 12 months (range: 4–26 months). An infraocclusion, normal or only slightly reduced Periotest^® scores and normal percussion sound were preoperatively found in six of seven successfully replanted teeth, which corresponded to a relatively small area of ankylosis. The majority of the teeth showing recurrent ankylosis preoperatively presented with normal position, negative Periotest^® scores and a high percussion sound which corresponded to an extended area of ankylosis. Statistically significant relationship between preoperative findings and the treatment outcome ( P  = 0.031) have become apparent. The results indicate that the treatment of minor areas of ankylosis by intentional replantation, resection of the ankylosed sites and Emdogain^® appeared to prevent or delay the recurrence of ankylosis in 7 of 15 teeth.     

Emdogain® does not prevent progressive root resorption after replantation of avulsed teeth: a clinical study

Abstract –  Emdogain^® has been shown in clinical and experimental studies to promote regeneration of all periodontal tissues: cementum with anchoring fibres, a functional, periodontal ligament and alveolar bone in connection with treatment of marginal periodontitis.
The intention of this study was to analyse whether this regenerative capacity upon the periodontal ligament also worked in a trauma situation where a significant number of PDL cells have been eliminated because of unphysiologic storage or actual damage during avulsion or replantation. Furthermore if ankylosis sites already established because of earlier replantation after avulsion could be surgical removed and application of Emdogain^® could revert the ankylosis stage to a normal PDL situation. The first treatment situation was tested in seven patients with a total of 16 avulsed teeth with varying time of extra oral storage. The teeth were extra-orally endodontically treated and the root and socket covered with Emdogain^® before replantation. All teeth demonstrated subsequent ankylosis, primarily diagnosed by a percussion test. The second treatment situation where an ankylosis was already established constituted of seven patients with a total of 11 teeth because of previous replantation after avulsion. These teeth were all extracted, the ankylosis sites removed and the root and socket treated with Emdogain^®. After 6 months all teeth showed recurrence of ankylosis. It is concluded that Emdogain^® was not able to prevent or cure ankylosis.     

Bone morphology after delayed tooth replantation – case series

The purpose of this report was to describe the morphological changes in the alveolar bone after delayed replantation of avulsed teeth using three dimensional cone‐beam computed tomography in 11 during the time period 2003–2012. The radiographic observations revealed the following: Delayed replantation results in ankylosis‐related replacement root resorption; the resorption is delayed or arrested around the cervical area superior to the alveolar crest. The buccal bone is reduced in thickness but not the palatal bone. The buccal bone resorption of the alveolar crest progresses approximately to the root canal space of the ankylosed root. Delayed replantation does not completely maintain the bone volume. The buccal profile of alveolar bone in the maxillary anterior region is depending on teeth with viable periodontal ligament.     

Complete replacement resorption after replantation of maxillary incisors: report of case.

This article describes the treatment of a 17-year-old patient with complete root resorption of the maxillary permanent central and lateral incisors following avulsion and replantation seven years ago. The most important factor influencing the prognosis of replanted teeth is the status of the periodontal ligament (PDL). As a result of replantation, the PDL cells necrosed and tooth replacement resorption occurred. The main factors, which affected the resorption after replantation and survival of PDL cells, could be summarize as; dry extraoral time greater than 30 minutes, the kept tooth in a dry environment, touching the cementum surface, and splint treatment for a prolonged time. Since complete root resorption was found in our case, these factors probably also occurred.     

Dynamics of dentoalveolar ankylosis and associated root resorption

Abstract The present experimental studies in monkeys were undertaken to study the initiation and progression of dentoalveolar ankylosis of replanted teeth and associated root resorption. Maxillary and mandibular lateral incisors were extracted and replanted after an extraoral period of 15 min or 1 h. Teeth with an extraoral period of 1 h were endodontically treated. Half the number of monkeys were given antibiotics at the time of replantation. The observation periods varied from 2 days to 40 weeks. Irrespective of the length of the extraoral period, initial root resorption and minor areas of ankylosis were found 1 week after replantation. The initial ankylosis was not preceded by root resorption. In teeth replanted after an extraoral period of 15 min the ankylotic area did not increase with increasing time after replantation. Instead the periodontal membrane was re-established, separating the root surface from the alveolar bone. In teeth replanted after an extraoral period of 1 h, the initial ankylotic area increased with increasing time after replantation. Eight weeks and more after replantation, most of the periodontal membrane was replaced by bone covered by osteoblasts and occasional osteoblasts that were in continuity with the endosteal cells outlining the marrow spaces of the alveolar bone. The cementum and dentin were then gradually resorbed with increasing time after replantation. Antibiotics given at the time of replantation reduced the initial inflammation in the periodontal membrane and the inflammatory root resorption after all observation periods and it also seemed to some extent to prevent bacteria from entering the necrotic pulp tissue. Based on the present results it is suggested that root resorption associated with dentoalveolar ankylosis is initiated by endosteal osteoblasts and is thus a hormonally regulated process. This is in contrast to inflammatory root resorption, which seems to be triggered by inflammatory cells.     

Preapplication of orthodontic forces to the donor teeth affects periodontal healing of transplanted teeth

OBJECTIVE: To investigate how the preapplication of orthodontic forces to the donor teeth affects the periodontal healing after transplantation. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The orthodontic force (1.5 cN) was applied to the maxillary right molars of 6-week-old male Spraque-Dawley rats (n = 21) in the experimental side, and the left side of the same animals was used as the control. After 7 days, both right and left maxillary second molars were extracted or replanted. Periodontal conditions were evaluated in the histological specimens 7 days after applying orthodontic force (before and after extraction) and 14 days after replantation. RESULTS: The application of orthodontic force for 7 days significantly increased the periodontal ligament (PDL) space and also the width of the alveolar socket, which resulted in a rich attached PDL to the root surface of the extracted teeth. Significantly more root resorption was also detected in the control side without preapplication of orthodontic force 14 days after replantation. This root resorption might involve in the disruption of the PDL. CONCLUSION: These results suggested that the preapplication of orthodontic force to the donor teeth increased the PDL width and eased the extraction, which might decrease root resorption after replantation.