The pathogenesis and treatment of pruritus and fatigue in patients with PBC.

The pathogenesis of the pruritus that complicates cholestasis in patients with primary biliary cirrhosis (PBC) is uncertain. The limited and inconsistent efficacy of conventional empiric therapies, such as anion exchange resins and rifampicin, has led to inconclusive trials of invasive experimental therapies, such as plasmapheresis, charcoal haemoperfusion and partial external diversion of bile. However, some double-blind, placebo-controlled trials that used a subjective primary efficacy end-point (the perception of pruritus) have suggested that certain drugs that affect the metabolism of many compounds, for example rifampicin, may be efficacious. The potential mechanisms by which such drugs may mediate a beneficial effect have not been determined. There is a paucity of data to indicate whether peripheral events, such as the accumulation of bile acids in interstitial fluid of the skin, initiate the neural events which mediate this form of pruritus. Recent findings suggest that central events in the brain, specifically an increase in neurotransmission/ neuromodulation mediated by endogenous opioid agonists (increased opioidergic tone), may be implicated. This hypothesis is supported by three lines of evidence. (1) Opioid receptor ligands with agonist properties (e.g. morphine) mediate pruritus. (2) Endogenous opioid-mediated neurotransmission/neuromodulation in the central nervous system (CNS) is increased in cholestasis. (3) Controlled trials have shown that opiate antagonists induce ameliorations of the behavioural consequence of the pruritus of cholestasis (scratching activity). In such trials, measurements of scratching activity independent of limb movements constituted an objective quantitative primary efficacy end-point. Potent opiate antagonists, that are bioavailable when given by mouth, such as nalmefene and naltrexone, may have a place in the long-term management of pruritus in patients with PBC. Evidence that increased serotoninergic neurotransmission also contributes to the pruritus is at present less strong than that implicating an involvement of the opioid system, and further investigation is needed to determine whether specific serotonin receptor subtype ligands have a place in the treatment of pruritus in patients with PBC. There is some evidence which suggests that increased serotoninergic neurotransmission in the CNS contributes to fatigue of central origin, but whether there is a causal relationship between altered serotoninergic neurotransmission and the profound fatigue that occurs in many patients with PBC is currently uncertain.     

Fatigue Complicating Chronic Liver Disease

Fatigue is common and can be profound in patients with chronic liver diseases, such as primary biliary cirrhosis (PBC) and chronic hepatitis C. The pathogenesis of fatigue in such patients is unknown; it may be related to infection with the hepatitis C virus or the pathophysiology of cholestasis in PBC, to a psychological reaction to knowledge of the diagnosis, or to the presence of chronic liver disease. A major problem in evaluating a treatment for fatigue in a randomized controlled trial is the inherent subjectivity of fatigue and the lack of a satisfactory objective quantitative primary efficacy endpoint. Experimental studies in rats and male athletes have implicated the serotonin neurotransmitter system in fatigue of central origin. Administration of the 5-HT3 serotonin receptor subtype antagonist, ondansetron, has been associated with substantial sustained clinical ameliorations of profound fatigue in at least some patients with chronic liver disease.     

Ondansetron and pruritus in chronic liver disease: a controlled study

BACKGROUND/AIMS: Increased central opioidergic neurotransmission, mediated by endogenous opioid peptide agonists, contributes to the pruritus of cholestasis. There are interrelationships between the opioid and serotonin neurotransmitter systems. The serotonin 5-HT3 receptor subtype antagonist, ondansetron, has been reported to ameliorate centrally-mediated pruritus induced by exogenously administered opiates. This study was designed to determine whether long-term oral administration of ondansetron is efficacious in ameliorating pruritus complicating chronic liver disease. METHODOLOGY: Seventeen patients with severe pruritus complicating established chronic liver disease were randomized to receive, double-blind, ondansetron (8 mg) or a placebo orally; each was administered thrice daily for a 4-week period. Endpoints were subjective scores of pruritus and objective 24-hour measurements of scratching activity. Analysable data were generated in 13 of the patients. RESULTS: Ondansetron therapy was associated with ameliorations of pruritus that appeared to be clinically significant in 5 patients (38%); in these 5 patients the mean decrease in a subjective score of pruritus was 27% of the scale of the score. However, these apparent ameliorations were not associated with robust decreases in scratching activity. For the whole group of 13 patients mean scratching activity during ondansetron therapy was not significantly less than that during treatment with placebo (p = 0.19). The total time that patients were not scratching was similar during treatment with ondansetron and placebo (p = 0.57). CONCLUSIONS: The findings suggest that serotoninergic neurotransmission, in neurons bearing receptors of the 5-HT3 subtype, plays no more than a minor role in the mediation of pruritus complicating chronic liver disease. The lack of an association between the results of applying subjective scores of pruritus and scratching activity emphasizes the need to include an objective quantitative efficacy endpoint in the design of trials of new therapies for pruritus.     

Update on the treatment of the pruritus of cholestasis

The pruritus of cholestasis is a difficult clinical problem to manage. It can be severe and interfere with sleep. Clinical behavioral studies have confirmed that the pruritus is mediated at least in part by endogenous opioids. Other neurotransmitter systems may be involved in the mediation of pruritus. Work continues to identify the mechanisms that mediate the pruritus and to develop specific drugs to treat this often maddening symptom.     

Central mu-opioid receptors are down-regulated in a rat model of cholestasis.

Ameliorations of the pruritus of cholestasis by opioid antagonists are consistent with this form of pruritus being centrally mediated by the opioid system. To determine whether the central opioid system is altered in cholestasis, the specific binding of a selective mu-opioid receptor ligand, 3H-DAMGO, to mu-opioid receptors was studied in rats with acute cholestasis due to bile duct resection. Using whole brain membranes and subcellular mitochondrial-synaptosomal fractions the density of mu-receptor sites was 30% (p less than 0.01) and 22% (p = 0.03) less in bile-duct-resected rats than in sham-resected rats. Using membranes from individual brain regions specific binding of 3H-DAMGO was reduced by 43-53% in the cerebral cortex, hippocampus and caudate nucleus of bile-duct-resected rats. Thus mu-opioid receptors in the brain are down-regulated in a classical model of cholestasis. This alteration of the central opioid system could be a consequence of increased exposure of opioid receptors to endogenous opioids in cholestasis and may reflect an important mechanism in the pathogenesis of the pruritus of cholestasis.     

An approach to the management of the pruritus of cholestasis

The cause of the pruritus of cholestasis is unknown. It is inferred that pruritus results from the accumulation in plasma of substances that are made in the liver and excreted in bile under physiologic conditions. The idea of neurotransmitters as important mediators in the pruritus of cholestasis has evolved over the past several years. There is evidence to suggest that endogenous opioids contribute to the pruritus of cholestasis and, for the first time, specific treatment for the pruritus has been instituted. The deficiency of studying pruritus with subjective methodology alone has been overcome with the development of objective methodology to study the behavioral manifestation of pruritus, scratching behavior. The use of this tool allows the definition of clear objective end-points, scratching activity, for inclusion in clinical trials.     

Pathogenesis and treatment of pruritus in patients with cholestasis

The pathogenesis of initiating the pruritus in patients with cholestasis is still not completely understood. One hypothesis is, that the cause for initiating the pruritus in patients with cholestasis is the activation of nerves in the skin. The activating substances are unknown, probably they are substances who accumulate in patients with cholestasis. Therefore one of the conventional approaches to treat pruritus is to remove pruritogenic substances from the body. Examples of this approach include the administration of anion exchange resins as cholestyramine or the administration of hepatic enzyme-inducing drugs such as rifampicin or phenobarbital. None of these drugs has been conclusively shown to be efficacious. A new hypothesis is the association of pruritus with altered central neurotransmission. Altered opioid concentrations probably play a central role in the pathogenesis of pruritus. This hypothesis is corroborate by the possibility of treating pruritus in patients with cholestasis with opiate antagonists such as naloxone or nalmefene. The treatment with ondansetron may also have effects on the pruritus of patients with cholestasis. A completely new treatment strategy is the application of dronabinol (r-9-tetrahydrocannabinol).     

Florid opioid withdrawal-like reaction precipitated by naltrexone in a patient with chronic cholestasis

Findings consistent with the hypothesis that increased central opioidergic tone contributes to the pruritus of cholestasis provide a rationale for treating this form of pruritus with opiate antagonists. However, initiation of therapy with an opiate antagonist in a cholestatic patient may precipitate a transient opioid withdrawal-like reaction. A woman with chronic cholestasis and disabling pruritus experienced severe transient opioid withdrawal-like reactions after oral administration of 12.5 and 2 mg naltrexone. Subsequently, naloxone was administered by intravenous infusion. Initially, the infusion rate was low and subtherapeutic. It was gradually increased to a rate known to be effective in inducing opioid antagonism. Oral naltrexone was then reintroduced without any reaction occurring. During the ensuing 12 months, while taking naltrexone, 25 mg daily, the patient has been completely free from pruritus. These observations strongly support the hypothesis that increased central opioidergic tone is a component of the pathophysiology of cholestasis.     

Evolving concepts of the pathogenesis and treatment of the pruritus of cholestasis.

The site of the pathogenic events responsible for initiating the pruritus of cholestasis has been assumed to be the skin. This assumption cannot be excluded but is not supported by convincing data. Empirical therapies such as anion exchange resins and rifampicin often appear to be partially efficacious. Recent evidence suggests that altered neurotransmission in the brain may contribute to this form of pruritus. In particular, the hypothesis that increased central opioidergic tone is involved is supported by three observations: opiate agonists induce opioid receptor-mediated scratching activity of central origin, central opioidergic tone is increased in cholestasis and opiate antagonists reduce scratching activity in cholestatic patients. Apparent subjective ameliorations of pruritus following intravenous administration of ondansetron to cholestatic patients suggest that altered serotoninergic neurotransmission may also contribute to this form of pruritus.     

Latest and Emerging Therapies for Primary Biliary Cirrhosis and Primary Sclerosing Cholangitis

Primary biliary cirrhosis (PBC) and primary sclerosing cholangitis (PSC) are the two most common causes of chronic cholestatic liver disease in adults. In PBC, therapy with ursodeoxycholic acid (UDCA) is safe and has been associated with tangible biochemical, histologic, and survival benefits. However, a need for different or adjuvant therapies remains for specific subsets of PBC patients, including those who do not respond to UDCA and those who have advanced histologic disease at presentation. Similarly, beneficial therapies for disease-related symptoms that do not typically respond to UDCA (eg, fatigue and pruritus) are still needed. In contrast to PBC, no medical therapy of proven benefit has been identified for patients with PSC. In PBC and PSC, adequate management of complications of chronic cholestasis is important. For both diseases, liver transplantation is the only curative option.     

Extrahepatic manifestations of cholestasis

Pruritus, fatigue and metabolic bone disease represent three major extrahepatic manifestations of chronic cholestatic liver disease that considerably affect the patient's quality of life. The present article reviews pathogenetic aspects of and current therapeutic approaches to extrahepatic manifestations of cholestatic liver disease. Pathogenesis of pruritus of cholestasis remains poorly understood. The involvement of putative peripherally acting pruritogens, such as bile acids or endogenous opioids, is being discussed. More recently, central mechanisms, including an increased central opioidergic tone and pertubations in the serotonergic system have been proposed. Treatment of the underlying disease is beneficial also for the control of cholestasis-associated pruritus. Current therapeutic recommendations include ursodeoxycholic acid, cholestyramine, rifampicin and opioid antagonists. Liver transplantation may be indicated when severe pruritus is refractory to medical treatment. Fatigue is being recognized as the most frequent and one of the most disabling complaints in chronic cholestasis. Fatigue is presumably of central origin and its association with other neuropsychiatric disorders (e.g. depression, obsessive-compulsive disorders) is consistent with defective central neurotransmission. No specific therapies are currently available and a healthy lifestyle, regular sleep and avoidance of unnecessary stress and other precipiting factors are recommended. Antidepressant therapy may be warranted in selected patients. Osteopenia and osteoporosis are common in chronic cholestatic liver disease, whereas osteomalacia is rare. The pathophysiology of cholestasis-associated metabolic bone disease is regarded as multifactorial. Therapeutic recommendations include regular exercise, calcium and vitamin D supplementation in late stage disease, hormone replacement therapy in postmenopausal women and bisphosphonates.     

Role of plasmapheresis in the treatment of severe pruritus in pregnant patients with primary biliary cirrhosis: case reports.

BACKGROUND: Primary biliary cirrhosis (PBC) may be associated with pruritus and, when present, may be accentuated during pregnancy. Several therapeutic modalities have been used to control itching caused by cholestasis, with variable responses. Drug therapies are ill-advised, particularly in early pregnancy. Plasmapheresis has been successful in controlling pruritus in patients with cholestasis. The use of plasmapheresis to alleviate severe life-threatening pruritus during pregnancy is reported in two patients with PBC. CASE PRESENTATIONS: Two patients with PBC presented during their second trimester of pregnancy with severe pruritus that did not respond to the anion exchange resin cholestyramine. Their symptoms were disabling to the point that one patient had suicidal ideation. Given the severity of their symptoms, multiple sessions of plasmapheresis were instituted with good control of pruritus. Both patients tolerated the procedure well and delivered healthy babies. CONCLUSION: Plasmapheresis is a relatively safe and rapidly effective treatment for severe pruritus during pregnancy in patients with PBC.     

The pruritus of cholestasis: evolving pathogenic concepts suggest new therapeutic options

Pruritis is a distressing symptom experienced by a large proportion of patients with cholestasis. The cause of this form of pruritus is unknown, and therapy tends to be empirical and unsatisfactory. This article discusses the emerging role of the brain and neurotransmitter systems in the pathogenesis of the pruritus of cholestasis and emphasizes the importance of the application of quantitative methodology in clinical trials of therapies for the pruritus of cholestasis.     

Pruritus in chronic liver disease: Mechanisms and treatment

Pruritus is a complication of liver disease. It can have a marked negative impact on quality of life; when intractable, it is an indication for liver transplantation. The cause of this type of pruritus is unknown. There is, however, evidence to suggest that the pruritus associated with liver disease is mediated, at least in part, by endogenous opioids. A central mechanism has been proposed. Therapeutic interventions have concentrated on the removal of presumed and unknown pruritogens from the circulation, hepatic enzyme induction, and, over the past decade, opiate antagonists, the first specific treatment for the pruritus of cholestasis. Other pharmacologic interventions that change neurotransmission have recently been reported to decrease the pruritus in patients with liver disease, as has a newly developed system that applies albumin-based dialysis. These interventions are promising, but they must be tested in properly controlled behavioral trials.     

Treatment options for primary biliary cirrhosis and primary sclerosing cholangitis

Opinion statement Primary biliary cirrhosis (PBC) and primary sclerosing cholangitis (PSC) are chronic cholestatic liver diseases that affect 0.5 to 40 per 100,000 and 1 to 6 per 100,000 Americans, respectively. Prompt recognition and management of the clinical manifestations of these diseases is essential for the patients’ well-being and ultimate outcome. Ursodeoxycholic acid (UDCA), 13 to 15 mg/kg per day, is the standard therapy for PBC and should be offered to every patient. It has been shown to slow progression of the disease and prevent the need for liver transplantation, which is the last recourse for patients with end-stage disease. However, there is no effective therapy for PSC yet. Patients are managed symptomatically, with surgical or endoscopic interventions as needed in cases of significant biliary obstruction. Complications of chronic cholestasis are seen in both PBC and PSC, with pruritus and fatigue being the most common complaints. The first choice for the treatment of pruritus is still cholestyramine, starting at 4 g/d. The pathogenesis of fatigue is poorly understood in this population; unrecognized hypothyroidism should be excluded. The use of antidepressants is currently under evaluation, but there is no specific therapy for fatigue as of yet. For prevention of severe osteoporosis, we recommend supplementation with 800 IU vitamin D and 1500 mg calcium/d. In patients with PBC and established osteoporosis, the use of alendronate and vitamin K appears to cause an increase in bone mineral density. Further studies are necessary before either of these drugs is routinely recommended. Finally, fat-soluble vitamin deficiencies are noted with more advanced disease. We recommend that serum levels be checked in high-risk patients, and that vitamins are replaced as appropriate with water-soluble supplements. However, other causes of malabsorption must be ruled out, including pancreatic insufficiency and celiac sprue.     

Pruritus and fatigue in primary biliary cirrhosis.

Pruritus is experienced by about 80% of patients with primary biliary cirrhosis. It can have a marked negative impact on the quality of life of patients, and it can be an indication for liver transplantation. There is evidence to suggest that the pruritus of cholestasis is mediated, at least in part, by endogenous opioids. A central component has been proposed. Behavioural data have shed light on the pathogenesis of this form of pruritus. Fatigue affects the majority of patients with primary biliary cirrhosis. It interferes with work performance and family life. An idea is emerging that suggests that fatigue in primary biliary cirrhosis also may be mediated centrally. Research tools need to be developed to study fatigue objectively in patients with primary biliary cirrhosis.     

Pruritus in primary biliary cirrhosis: pathogenesis and therapy

Pruritus is a symptom experienced by patients who have primary biliary cirrhosis. It seems to result from pruritogens that (as a result of cholestasis) accumulate in plasma and other tissues, and which lead to altered neurotrasnmission. Administration of medications that change opioid neurotransmission (ie, opiate antagonists) results in relief of pruritus and its behavioral manifestation, scratching. Through unknown mechanisms, other centrally acting medications, including antidepressants, may have ameliorating effects on the pruritus of cholestasis. Stimulating endogenous detoxification pathways in the liver may also lead to the amelioration of pruritus. The removal of pruritogens through administration of nonabsorbable resins, nasobiliary drainage, biliary diversion, plasmapheresis, and various dialysis procedures is reported to decrease pruritus in liver disease, although the substances that are presumably removed are unknown.     

Management of primary biliary cirrhosis. The American Association for the Study of Liver Diseases practice guidelines

Primary biliary cirrhosis (PBC) is a presumed autoimmune disease of the liver, which predominantly affects women once over the age of 20 years. Most cases are diagnosed when asymptomatic (60%). The antimitochondrial antibody is present in serum in most, but not in all, patients with PBC. The disease generally progresses slowly but survival is less than an age- and gender-matched general population. The symptomatic patient may have fatigue, generalized pruritus, portal hypertension, osteoporosis, skin xanthomata, fat soluble vitamin deficiencies, and/or recurrent asymptomatic urinary tract infections. Many nonhepatic autoimmune diseases are found in association with PBC and may prompt initial presentation. To date, immunosuppressive therapy has not been shown to prolong survival in PBC. The hydrophilic bile acid, ursodeoxycholic acid (UDCA), has been shown when given in a dose of 13 to 15 mg/kg daily for up to 4 years to delay the time to liver transplantation or death. This therapy also causes a significant improvement of all the biochemical markers of cholestasis but has no beneficial effects on any of the symptoms or associated disorders. Treatment with UDCA does not obviate the need for liver transplantation. Therapies to prevent complications arising from malabsorption, portal hypertension, and/or osteoporosis are required as well. Good control of pruritus can be achieved in most patients. PBC is diagnosed with increasing frequency, but the agent(s) responsible for this slowly progressive destruction of the interlobular bile ducts remains elusive and hence a specific therapy remains unavailable.     

Treatment of primary biliary cirrhosis

Primary biliary cirrhosis is a chronic liver disease of unknown etiology, characterized by inflammation and destruction of the intrahepatic biliary ducts, resulting in chronic cholestasis and eventually cirrhosis. The main clinical manifestations consists of pruritus, jaundice, xanthomas, and the consequences of intestinal malabsorption, including vitamin deficiencies and osteodystrophy. Treatment of PBC is addressed at preventing or relieving the symptoms and clinical consequences of chronic cholestasis, and also at correcting the bile duct abnormalities by specific treatments. Pruritus is treated with cholestyramine, but in some cases other drugs, such as rifampicin or opioid antagonists are needed. Bisphosphanates are effective for increasing bone mass in osteopenic patients. Vitamin D and cAlcium supplements are also recommended, particularly in patients with severe cholestasis. Ursodeoxycholic acid (UDCA) has become the standard treatment (13-15 mg/kg/day), resulting in marked relieving of cholestasis. UDCA also prevents the histological progression of the disease, although the effects on survival are less apparent. Small trials of combination therapy using UDCA with methotrexate, colchicine, or prednisone, have been reported but have not shown any increased efficacy over UDCA therapy. Liver transplantation is the only treatment available when cholestasis progresses, with very good survival rates.     

Pruritus in chronic cholestatic liver disease

Pruritus is a troublesome complication in patients with cholestatic liver disease. Several links to its pathogenesis have been proposed, including the role of bile acids, endogenous opioid and serotonins, and lysophosphatidic acid. The management of pruritus in cholestasis is challenging. Medical treatment of the underlying cholestatic condition may provide benefit. Extracorporeal albumin dialysis can be pursued for those who have a poor quality of life and failed the various therapeutic interventions, while awaiting liver transplantation. Experimental interventions, and the management of pruritus in certain conditions such as intrahepatic cholestasis of pregnancy and benign recurrent intrahepatic cholestasis, are also briefly reviewed.