Osteogenesis imperfecta type III: mutations in the type I collagen structural genes, COL1A1 and COL1A2, are not necessarily responsible.

Most forms of osteogenesis imperfecta are caused by dominant mutations in either of the two genes, COL1A1 and COL1A2, that encode the pro alpha 1(I) and pro alpha 2(I) chains of type I collagen, respectively. However, a severe, autosomal recessive form of OI type III with a comparatively high frequency has been recognised in the black populations of southern Africa. We preformed linkage analyses in eight OI type III families using RFLPs associated with the COL1A1 and COL1A2 loci to determine whether mutations in the genes for type I collagen were responsible for this form of OI. Recombination between the OI phenotype and polymorphic markers at both loci was shown in three of the eight families investigated. The combined lod scores for the eight families were -10.6 for COL1A1 and -11.2 for COL1A2. Further, we examined the type I procollagen produced by skin fibroblast cultures derived from 15 affected and 12 unaffected subjects from the above eight families plus one further family. We found no evidence for defects in the synthesis, structure, secretion, or post-translational modification of the chains of type I procollagen produced by any of the family members. These results suggest that mutations within or near the type I collagen structural genes are not responsible for this form of OI.     

Thirty-three novel COL1A1 and COL1A2 mutations in patients with osteogenesis imperfecta types I-IV

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is a heritable disease of bone characterized by low bone mass and bone fragility. Six different types of OI have been described to date, based on clinical phenotype and histological findings. The genetic defect in many patients with OI types I-IV is due to mutations in the genes encoding type I collagen, while patients with OI types V and VI show no evidence of mutations in the COL1A1/COL1A2 genes. Here we report thirty-three novel mutations in patients with types I-IV OI. Sixteen mutations were in COL1A1 and seventeen were in COL1A2. Most mutations resulted in substitutions for glycine: one of these, a doublet GG>CC transversion, created a unique Gly-->Pro missense mutation in the triple helical domain of COL1A2. Two rare triple helical Gly-->Glu substitutions in COL1A2 are also described. In addition, there were six single-base deletion mutations resulting in frameshifts, seven splice junction mutations, and a 9-bp triple helix insertion associated with a severe (OI II) phenotype. The variety of mutations described in the COL1A1/COL1A2 genes giving rise to an OI phenotype is in accordance with the clinical heterogeneity of the disease. Hum Mutat 17:434, 2001.     

Osteogenesis imperfecta: prospects for molecular therapeutics

Osteogenesis Imperfecta (OI) is a dominant negative disorder of connective tissue. OI patients present with bone fragility and skeletal deformity within a broad phenotypic range. Defects in the COL1A1 or COL1A2 genes, coding, respectively, for the alpha1 and alpha2 chains of type I collagen, are the causative mutations. Over 150 mutations have been characterized. Both quantitative defects, such as null COL1A1 alleles, and qualitative defects, such as glycine substitutions, exon skipping, deletions, and insertions, have been described in type I collagen. Quantitative and structural mutations are associated with the milder and more severe forms of OI, respectively. A more detailed relationship between genotype and phenotype is still incompletely understood; several models have been proposed and are being tested. Transgenic and knock-out murine models for OI have previously been created. We have recently generated a knock-in murine model (the Brittle mouse) carrying a typical glycine substitution in type I collagen. This mouse will permit a better understanding of OI pathophysiology and phenotypic variability. It will also be used for gene therapeutic approaches to OI, especially mutation suppression by hammerhead ribozymes. The present review will provide an update of OI clinical and molecular data and outline gene therapeutic approaches being tested on OI murine models for this disorder.     

CRTAP and LEPRE1 mutations in recessive osteogenesis imperfecta

Autosomal dominant osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is caused by mutations in the genes (COL1A1 or COL1A2) encoding the chains of type I collagen. Recently, dysregulation of hydroxylation of a single proline residue at position 986 of both the triple-helical domains of type I collagen alpha1(I) and type II collagen alpha1(II) chains has been implicated in the pathogenesis of recessive forms of OI. Two proteins, cartilage-associated protein (CRTAP) and prolyl-3-hydroxylase-1 (P3H1, encoded by the LEPRE1 gene) form a complex that performs the hydroxylation and brings the prolyl cis-trans isomerase cyclophilin-B (CYPB) to the unfolded collagen. In our screen of 78 subjects diagnosed with OI type II or III, we identified three probands with mutations in CRTAP and 16 with mutations in LEPRE1. The latter group includes a mutation in patients from the Irish Traveller population, a genetically isolated community with increased incidence of OI. The clinical features resulting from CRTAP or LEPRE1 loss of function mutations were difficult to distinguish at birth. Infants in both groups had multiple fractures, decreased bone modeling (affecting especially the femurs), and extremely low bone mineral density. Interestingly, "popcorn" epiphyses may reflect underlying cartilaginous and bone dysplasia in this form of OI. These results expand the range of CRTAP/LEPRE1 mutations that result in recessive OI and emphasize the importance of distinguishing recurrence of severe OI of recessive inheritance from those that result from parental germline mosaicism for COL1A1 or COL1A2 mutations.     

Consortium for osteogenesis imperfecta mutations in the helical domain of type I collagen: regions rich in lethal mutations align with collagen binding sites for integrins and proteoglycans

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is a generalized disorder of connective tissue characterized by fragile bones and easy susceptibility to fracture. Most cases of OI are caused by mutations in type I collagen. We have identified and assembled structural mutations in type I collagen genes (COL1A1 and COL1A2, encoding the proalpha1(I) and proalpha2(I) chains, respectively) that result in OI. Quantitative defects causing type I OI were not included. Of these 832 independent mutations, 682 result in substitution for glycine residues in the triple helical domain of the encoded protein and 150 alter splice sites. Distinct genotype-phenotype relationships emerge for each chain. One-third of the mutations that result in glycine substitutions in alpha1(I) are lethal, especially when the substituting residues are charged or have a branched side chain. Substitutions in the first 200 residues are nonlethal and have variable outcome thereafter, unrelated to folding or helix stability domains. Two exclusively lethal regions (helix positions 691-823 and 910-964) align with major ligand binding regions (MLBRs), suggesting crucial interactions of collagen monomers or fibrils with integrins, matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs), fibronectin, and cartilage oligomeric matrix protein (COMP). Mutations in COL1A2 are predominantly nonlethal (80%). Lethal substitutions are located in eight regularly spaced clusters along the chain, supporting a regional model. The lethal regions align with proteoglycan binding sites along the fibril, suggesting a role in fibril-matrix interactions. Recurrences at the same site in alpha2(I) are generally concordant for outcome, unlike alpha1(I). Splice site mutations comprise 20% of helical mutations identified in OI patients, and may lead to exon skipping, intron inclusion, or the activation of cryptic splice sites. Splice site mutations in COL1A1 are rarely lethal; they often lead to frameshifts and the mild type I phenotype. In alpha2(I), lethal exon skipping events are located in the carboxyl half of the chain. Our data on genotype-phenotype relationships indicate that the two collagen chains play very different roles in matrix integrity and that phenotype depends on intracellular and extracellular events.     

Mutation analysis of COL1A1 and COL1A2 in patients diagnosed with osteogenesis imperfecta type I-IV

Osteogenesis Imperfecta (OI) is a heterogeneous group of inherited disorders characterized by increased bone fragility, with clinical severity ranging from mild to lethal. To date, seven types of OI have been described, based on clinical phenotype and histological findings. Most patients with a clinical diagnosis of OI type I-IV have a mutation in the COL1A1 or COL1A2 genes which encode the two alpha chains of type I collagen, the major component of the bone matrix. Analysis of COL1A1 and COL1A2 in a cohort of 83 unrelated patients with OI type I-IV identified a total of 62 mutations. Thirty-eight appear novel, 26 in COL1A1, and 12 in COL1A2, and these are described here. The largest group consists of point mutations affecting glycine residues in the triple helical domain of the two alpha chains, predicted to disrupt protein folding and structure. This is in accordance with previously published data. A doublet GC deletion, an unusual 398 base deletion predicted to completely remove exon 20 of COL1A2, and a point mutation resulting in substitution of a conserved cysteine in the C-terminal propeptide are described. In addition rare mutations at the cleavage sites of the C-propeptide and the N-terminal signal peptide are described.     

Osteogenesis imperfecta: clinical, biochemical and molecular findings

Mutations in COL1A1 and COL1A2 genes, encoding the alpha1 and alpha2 chain of type I collagen, respectively, are responsible for the vast majority of cases of osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) (95% of patients with a definite clinical diagnosis). We have investigated 22 OI patients, representing a heterogeneous phenotypic range, at the biochemical and molecular level. A causal mutation in either type I collagen gene was identified in 20 of them: no recurrent mutation was found in unrelated subjects; 15 out of 20 mutations had not been reported previously. In two patients, we could not find any causative mutation in either type I collagen gene, after extensive genomic DNA sequencing. Failure of COL1A1/COL1A2 mutation screening may be due, in a few cases, to further clinical heterogeneity, i.e. additional non-collagenous disease loci are presumably involved in OI types beyond the traditional Sillence's classification.     

Mutational spectrum of type I collagen genes in Korean patients with osteogenesis imperfecta

Mutations in the type I collagen genes COL1A1 and COL1A2 are responsible for the dominantly inherited connective tissue disorder osteogenesis imperfecta (OI). The severity of OI is diverse, ranging from perinatal lethality to a very mild phenotype that is characterized by normal stature and the absence of deformities. Although there have been several studies on the mutational spectra of COL1A1 and/or COL1A2 in Western populations, very few cases have been reported from Asia. In this study, we investigated 67 unrelated Korean probands with OI and used nucleotide sequence analysis to detect COL1A1 and COL1A2 mutations. Thirty-five different mutations were identified in the two genes, including 24 novel mutations. Among the 35 kinds of detected mutations, 15 were glycine substitutions (seven in COL1A1 and eight in COL1A2), one was a nonsense mutation, four were frameshift mutations in COL1A1, three were in-frame duplications in COL1A2, and 12 were splice site mutations (seven in COL1A1 and five in COL1A2). Until now, mutations in the COL1A1 and COL1A2 genes known to cause OI were unique and rarely repeated in other families. Interestingly, the c.982G>A (p.Gly328Ser) mutation in COL1A2 was found recurrently and was the causative mutation in five independent OI probands. Haplotype analysis of the COL1A2 gene revealed that four probands from five independent OI probands with c.982G>A (p.Gly328Ser) had a common haplotype. Our clinical data showed the heterogeneity even within a specific genotype, which suggested the complex expression of this disease.     

Absence of mutations in the promoter of the COL1A1 gene of type I collagen in patients with osteogenesis imperfecta type I.

Osteogenesis imperfecta type I results from decreased production of structurally normal type I collagen as a result of a COL1A1 "null" allele. Steady state amounts of COL1A1 mRNA are reduced in both the nucleus and cytoplasm of dermal fibroblasts from most affected subjects. Mutations involving key regulatory sequences in the COL1A1 promoter, such as the TATAAA and CCAAAT boxes, could alter steady state levels of mRNA, and therefore lead to this phenotype. To determine the frequency of such mutations in OI type I cell strains, we used PCR amplified genomic DNA in conjunction with denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) and SSCP, to screen the 5' untranslated domain, exon 1, and a small portion of intron 1 of the COL1A1 gene. In addition, direct sequence analysis was performed on an amplified genomic DNA fragment that included the TATAAA and CCAAAT boxes. Forty unrelated probands with OI type I, in whom no causative mutation was known, were included in the study. No mutations were included in the study. No mutations were identified in either the TATAAA or CCAAAT boxes in any of the affected people. In addition, there was little evidence of sequence diversity among any of the 40 subjects. These data suggest that mutations in the COL1A1 promoter do not play a significant role in the aetiology of OI type I.     

Inherited disorders of collagen gene structure and expression

As a result of investigations completed during the last 15 years, the molecular bases of most form of osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) and of some forms of the Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (EDS) are now known. Most forms of OI result from point mutations in the genes (COL1A1 and COL1A2) that encode the chains of type I procollagen or mutations that affect the expression of these genes. Less frequently, mutations that affect the size of the chain can also result in these phenotypes. The phenotypic presentation appears to be determined by the nature of the mutation, the chain in which it occurs, and, for point mutations, the position of the substitution and the nature of the substituting amino acid in the protein product. Similar mutations in the gene (COL3A1) that encodes the chains of type III procollagen result in the EDS type IV phenotype. Mutations which result in deletion of the cleavage site for the aminoterminal procollagen protease result in the EDS type VII phenotype and other mutations which affect the structure of the triple-helical domain by deletions and alter the conformation of the substrate at the site of proteolytic conversion can produce mixed phenotypes. Alterations in post-translational processing of collagenous proteins can result in the EDS type VI and EDS type IX phenotypes. Linkage analysis and study of type II collagen proteins from individuals with a variety of skeletal dysplasias suggest that similar mutations in these genes also result in clinically apparent phenotypes. Mutations in the majority of the 20 known collagen genes have not yet been identified.     

Two novel distinct COL1A2 mutations highlight the complexity of genotype–phenotype correlations in osteogenesis imperfecta and related connective tissue disorders

Osteogenesis imperfecta is a heritable connective tissue disorder characterized by variable symptoms including predisposition to fractures. Despite the identification of numerous mutations, a reliable genotype–phenotype correlation has remained notoriously difficult. We now describe two patients with osteogenesis imperfecta and novel, so far undescribed mutations in the COL1A2 gene, further highlighting this complexity. A 3-year-old patient presented with features reminiscent of a connective tissue disorder, with joint hypermobility, Wormian bones, streaky lucencies in the long bones and relative macrocephaly. The patient carried a heterozygous c.1316G > A (p.Gly439Asp) mutation in the COL1A2 gene located in a triple-helix region, in which glycine substitutions have been assumed to cause perinatal lethal OI (Sillence type II). A second family with type I osteogenesis imperfecta carried a heterozygous nonsense mutation c.4060C > T (p.Gln1354X) within the last exon of COL1A2. Whereas other heterozygous nonsense mutations in COL1A2 do not lead to a phenotype, in this case the mRNA is presumed to escape nonsense-mediated decay. Therefore the predicted COL1A2 propeptide lacks the last 13 C-terminal amino acids, suggesting that the OI phenotype results from decelerated assembly and overmodification of the collagen triple helix. The presented COL1A2 mutations exemplify the complexity of COL1A2 genotype–phenotype correlation in genetic counselling in OI.     

Phenotypical features of an unique Irish family with severe autosomal recessive Osteogenesis imperfecta

Severe Sillence type II/III Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is a lethal or severely crippling disease with either autosomal dominant or recessively inherited type I collagen mutations. Here we describe the detailed clinical features of a thin-ribbed OI variant with deformed limbs. The three consecutively affected children showed no genetic linkage with either of the two type I collagen genes, which implies that a novel mechanism causes this clinical phenotype. It can be prevented using ultrasound to diagnose affected foetuses.     

COL1 C-propeptide cleavage site mutations cause high bone mass osteogenesis imperfecta

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is most often caused by mutations in the type I procollagen genes (COL1A1/COL1A2). We identified two children with substitutions in the type I procollagen C-propeptide cleavage site, which disrupt a unique processing step in collagen maturation and define a novel phenotype within OI. The patients have mild OI caused by mutations in COL1A1 (Patient 1: p.Asp1219Asn) or COL1A2 (Patient 2: p.Ala1119Thr), respectively. Patient 1 L1-L4 DXA Z-score was +3.9 and pQCT vBMD was+3.1; Patient 2 had L1-L4 DXA Z-score of 0.0 and pQCT vBMD of -1.8. Patient BMD contrasts with radiographic osteopenia and histomorphometry without osteosclerosis. Mutant procollagen processing is impaired in pericellular and in vitro assays. Patient dermal collagen fibrils have irregular borders. Incorporation of pC-collagen into matrix leads to increased bone mineralization. FTIR imaging confirms elevated mineral/matrix ratios in both patients, along with increased collagen maturation in trabecular bone, compared to normal or OI controls. Bone mineralization density distribution revealed a marked shift toward increased mineralization density for both patients. Patient 1 has areas of higher and lower bone mineralization than controls; Patient 2's bone matrix has a mineral content exceeding even classical OI bone. These patients define a new phenotype of high BMD OI and demonstrate that procollagen C-propeptide cleavage is crucial to normal bone mineralization.     

Lack of correlation between the type of COL1A1 or COL1A2 mutation and hearing loss in osteogenesis imperfecta patients

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is caused by mutations in COL1A1 and COL1A2 that code for the alpha1 and alpha2 chains of type I collagen. Phenotypes correlate with the mutation types in that COL1A1 null mutations lead to OI type I, and structural mutations in alpha1(I) or alpha2(I) lead to more severe OI types (II-IV). However, correlative analysis between mutation types and OI associated hearing loss has not been previously performed. A total of 54 Finnish OI patients with previously diagnosed hearing loss or age 35 or more years were analyzed here for mutations in COL1A1 or COL1A2. Altogether 49 mutations were identified, of which 41 were novel. The 49 mutations represented the molecular genetic background of 41.1% of the Finnish OI population. A total of 38 mutations were in COL1A1 and 11 were in COL1A2. Of these, 16 were glycine substitutions and 16 were splicing mutations in alpha1(I) or alpha2(I). In addition, 17 null allele mutations were detected in COL1A1. A total of 32 patients (65.3%) with a mutation had hearing loss. That is slightly more than in our previous population study on Finnish adults with OI (57.9%). The association between the mutation types and OI type was statistically evident. Patients with COL1A1 mutations more frequently had blue scleras than those with COL1A2 mutations. In addition, patients with COL1A2 mutations tended to be shorter than those with COL1A1 mutations. However, no correlation was found between the mutated gene or mutation type and hearing pattern. These results suggest that the basis of hearing loss in OI is complex, and it is a result of multifactorial, still unknown genetic effects.     

Molecular heterogeneity in osteogenesis imperfecta type I

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) type I is characterized by bone fragility without significant deformity, osteopenia, normal stature, blue sclerae, and autosomal dominant inheritance. Dermal fibroblasts from most affected individuals produce about half the expected amount of type I collagen, suggesting that the OI type I phenotype results from a variety of mutations which alter the apparent expression of either COL1A1 or COL1A2, the genes encoding the chains of type I collagen. Short-pulse labeling of dermal fibroblasts with [³H]proline from affected individuals in 19 families indicates that most have alterations in the expected 2:1 synthetic ratio of proα1(I): proα2(I), with most having decreased production of proα1(I). Ratios of COL1A1:COL1A2 mRNA from these individuals, using slot-blot hybridization, indicate that they fall into different groups, but that most have decreased COL1A1 mRNA levels, compared with controls. These data suggest that most of our OI I families have COL1A1 mutations. Copy number and size of the COL1A1 gene by restriction endonuclease analysis of genomic DNA from affected individuals are normal in the families examined. We have identified one 3 generation family in which all affected members have one normal COL1A1 allele and another with a 5 base-pair deletion near the 3′ end of the gene. The deletion creates a shift in the translational reading-frame and predicts the synthesis of an elongated proα1(I) chain. In a second family, a father and a son have a single exon deletion that results from a splicing mutation. Chemical cleavage analysis of amplified cDNA from affected individuals in different regions of the COL1A1 gene, including the promoter, suggests that several individuals have point mutations within the coding region of the gene, while one individual may have a small deletion within the α1(I) carboxyl-terminal propeptide region. Our data provide evidence for significant molecular heterogeneity within the OI type I phenotype and indicate that a variety of mutations can result in decreased synthesis of type I collagen.     

OIM and related animal models of osteogenesis imperfecta

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is characterized by fragile bones, skeletal deformity, and growth retardation. This heritable disorder of connective tissue is the result of mutations affecting the COL1A1 and COL1A2 genes of type I collagen. Progress in OI research has been limited because of dependence on human fibroblast and osteoblast specimens and the absence of a naturally occurring animal model for this genetic disorder. Recent technology in molecular biology has led to the development of transgenic models of OI based on site directed mutagenesis of type I collagen genes. OIM is a naturally occurring model which incorporates both the phenotypic and biochemical defects of moderate to severe osteogenesis imperfecta. This powerful tool permits the development of models based on different type I collagen mutations. The collagen type I mutation in OIM is a C propeptide deletion which impairs the production of normal pro-alpha2(I). Tissues in OIM contain only [pro-alpha1(I)]3 homotrimer. Thus, although several animal models are now available for research in osteogenesis imperfecta few are viable or fully mimic human disease disorders. OIM duplicates the phenotype and biochemistry of human disease and has a normal life span.     

Genetic and biochemical analyses of Israeli osteogenesis imperfecta patients

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is clinically characterized by abnormal bone fragility, with most patients harboring heterozygote germline mutations in the COL1A1 or COL1A2 genes that encode the chains of type I procollagen, the major protein in bone. More than 250 mutations in both genes in OI patients have been reported, mostly missense mutations affecting glycine residues in the triple helical domains of the two chains. These mutations disrupt protein folding and structure, and their effects often can be detected by the analysis of proteins synthesized but cultured fibroblasts or, less often, osteoblasts. In this study, mutational analysis of all the COL1A1 and part of the COL1A2 was performed using exon-specific PCR amplification followed by denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) analysis and complemented by DNA sequencing in 57 Israeli OI patients from 55 unrelated families. Protein analysis was also performed using cultured fibroblasts obtained from a subset of these OI patients. Of 57 OI patients analyzed, 35 had OI type 1, 12 has OI type III, 8 had OI type IV, and 2 had OI type II. Fourteen different pathogenic mutations (10 novel) were identified in the COL1A1 gene: 3 missense, 5 nonsense, 3 insertion/deletion frameshift, 2 splice junction mutations, and 1 in frame deletion. We conclude that COL1A1 mutations underlie a subset of Israeli OI patients, that most commonly in OI type I, the mutations are contained within the COL1A1 gene, and that there are no predominant mutations in Jewish OI patients. Lastly, the use of protein analyses complements genetic analyses.     

CRTAP mutations in lethal and severe osteogenesis imperfecta: the importance of combining biochemical and molecular genetic analysis

Autosomal recessive lethal and severe osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is caused by the deficiency of cartilage-associated protein (CRTAP) and prolyl-3-hydroxylase 1 (P3H1) because of CRTAP and LEPRE1 mutations. We analyzed five families in which 10 individuals had a clinical diagnosis of lethal and severe OI with an overmodification of collagen type I on biochemical testing and without a mutation in the collagen type I genes. CRTAP mutations not described earlier were identified in the affected individuals. Although it seems that one important feature of autosomal recessive OI due to CRTAP mutations is the higher consistency of radiological features with OI type II-B/III, differentiation between autosomal dominant and autosomal recessive OI on the basis of clinical, radiological and biochemical investigations proves difficult in the affected individuals reported here. These observations confirm that once a clinical diagnosis of OI has been made in an affected individual, biochemical testing for overmodification of collagen type I should always be combined with molecular genetic analysis of the collagen type I genes. If no mutations in the collagen type I genes are found, additional molecular genetic analysis of the CRTAP and LEPRE1 genes should follow. This approach will allow proper identification of the genetic cause of lethal or severe OI, which is important in providing prenatal diagnosis, preimplantation genetic diagnosis and estimating recurrence risk.