Influences of un-modulated acoustic inputs on functional maturation and critical-period plasticity of the primary auditory cortex

Sensory experiences contribute to the development and specialization of signal processing capacities in the mammalian auditory system during a "critical period" of postnatal development. Earlier studies have shown that passive exposure to tonal stimuli during this postnatal epoch induces a large-scale expansion of the representations of those stimuli within the primary auditory cortex (A1) [Zhang LI, Bao S, Merzenich MM (2001) Persistent and specific influences of early acoustic environments on primary auditory cortex. Nat Neurosci 4:1123-1130]. Here, we show that exposing rat pups through the normal critical period epoch and beyond to continuous, un-modulated, moderate-level tones induces no such representational distortion, and in fact disrupts the normal development of frequency response selectivity and tonotopicity all across area A1. The area of cortex responding selectively to continuously exposed sound frequencies was actually reduced, when compared with rats reared in normal environments. Strong exposure-driven plasticity characteristic of the critical period could be induced well beyond the normal end of the critical period, by simply modulating the tonal stimulus. Thus, continuous tone exposure, like continuous noise exposure [Chang EF, Merzenich MM (2003) Environmental noise retards auditory cortical development. Science 300:498-502], ineffectively induces critical period plasticity, and indefinitely blocks the closure of a normally-brief critical period window. These findings again demonstrate the crucial role of temporally structured inputs for inducing the progressive cortical maturational changes that result in the closure of the critical period window.     

Tonotopic and heterotopic projection systems in physiologically defined auditory cortex

Combined physiological and connectional studies show significant non-topographic extrinsic projections to frequency-specific domains in the cat auditory cortex. These frequency-mismatched loci in the thalamus, ipsilateral cortex, and commissural system complement the predicted topographic and tonotopic projections. Two tonotopic areas, the primary auditory cortex (AI) and the anterior auditory field (AAF), were electrophysiologically characterized by their frequency organization. Next, either cholera toxin beta subunit or cholera toxin beta subunit gold conjugate was injected into frequency-matched locations in each area to reveal the projection pattern from the thalamus and cortex. Most retrograde labeling was found at tonotopically appropriate locations within a 1 mm-wide strip in the thalamus and a 2-3 mm-wide expanse of cortex (approximately 85%). However, approximately 13-30% of the neurons originated from frequency-mismatched locations far from their predicted positions in thalamic nuclei and cortical areas, respectively. We propose that these heterotopic projections satisfy at least three criteria that may be necessary to support the magnitude and character of plastic changes in physiological studies. First, they are found in the thalamus, ipsilateral and commissural cortex; since this reorganization could arise from any of these routes and may involve each, such projections ought to occur in them. Second, they originate from nuclei and areas with or without tonotopy; it is likely that plasticity is not exclusively shaped by spectral influences and not limited to cochleotopic regions. Finally, the projections are appropriate in magnitude and sign to plausibly support such rearrangements; given the rapidity of some aspects of plastic changes, they should be mediated by substantial existing connections. Alternative roles for these heterotopic projections are also considered.     

Background sounds contribute to spectrotemporal plasticity in primary auditory cortex

The mammalian auditory system evolved to extract meaningful information from complex acoustic environments. Spectrotemporal selectivity of auditory neurons provides a potential mechanism to represent natural sounds. Experience-dependent plasticity mechanisms can remodel the spectrotemporal selectivity of neurons in primary auditory cortex (A1). Electrical stimulation of the cholinergic nucleus basalis (NB) enables plasticity in A1 that parallels natural learning and is specific to acoustic features associated with NB activity. In this study, we used NB stimulation to explore how cortical networks reorganize after experience with frequency-modulated (FM) sweeps, and how background stimuli contribute to spectrotemporal plasticity in rat auditory cortex. Pairing an 8–4 kHz FM sweep with NB stimulation 300 times per day for 20 days decreased tone thresholds, frequency selectivity, and response latency of A1 neurons in the region of the tonotopic map activated by the sound. In an attempt to modify neuronal response properties across all of A1 the same NB activation was paired in a second group of rats with five downward FM sweeps, each spanning a different octave. No changes in FM selectivity or receptive field (RF) structure were observed when the neural activation was distributed across the cortical surface. However, the addition of unpaired background sweeps of different rates or direction was sufficient to alter RF characteristics across the tonotopic map in a third group of rats. These results extend earlier observations that cortical neurons can develop stimulus specific plasticity and indicate that background conditions can strongly influence cortical plasticity     

Sex differences in sensory gating of the thalamus during auditory interference of visual attention tasks

Men and women have different cognitive abilities that might reflect sex-specific neural organization. Here we studied sex effects on brain function using functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) with variable acoustic noise (AN) to modulate the cognitive challenge and enhance the sensitivity for the detection of sex differences in brain activation. During the performance of a visual attention (VA) task that requires the tracking of multiple moving objects and has graded levels of difficulty, women (n=15) but not men (n=13) had shorter reaction times for "Loud" than for "Quiet" scans. Men activated more than women in the superior prefrontal and occipital cortices and the anterior thalamus. The latent connectivity of the prefrontal cortex was higher with the anterior thalamus but lower with the auditory cortex for men than for women. Increases in activation with visual attention load were larger for men than for women in the superior parietal and auditory cortices. Increased AN reduced brain activation in the parietal cortex and the anterior thalamus for men but not for women. Together, these sex-specific differences in brain activation during the VA task, at different cognitive and acoustic levels suggest differences in auditory gating of the thalamus for men and women.     

Spatial interaction between spectral integration and frequency gradient in primary auditory cortex

Primary sensory cortical areas are characterized by orderly and largely independent representations of several receptive field properties. This is expressed in multiple, spatially overlaying parameter distributions, such as orientation preference, spatial frequency, and ocular dominance maps in the primary visual cortex. In the auditory cortex, two main and presumably independent representational parameters are the center frequency and the frequency extent of spectral tuning curves. Here we demonstrate interactions between cortical tonotopic gradient and spectral bandwidth modules in cat primary auditory cortex (AI). First, the spatial representation of spectral integration is not equally expressed across the whole frequency range in AI. Narrow-bandwidth modules are found only in the mid-frequency region (5-20 kHz). Thus spectral integration properties delineate three frequency regions (<5, 5-20, and >20 kHz) in cat AI. Second, the extent of spectral integration covaries with the local tonotopic gradient in the low- and mid-frequency ranges. Regions with a shallow frequency gradient tend to have narrower spectral integration than those with a steep gradient. These relationships between spectral selectivity and frequency gradient constrain forebrain models of thalamo- and corticocortical convergence and connectivity and may reflect the processing of behaviorally relevant stimulus constellations.     

大鼠听皮质NMDA受体亚单位NR2B蛋白质的年龄-依赖性表达

目的：研究sD大鼠生后发育过程中,听皮质神经元NMDA受体亚单位NR2B蛋白质的表达规律。方法：采用免疫组织化学反应和蛋白质印迹技术,分别检测生后1、2、3周和成年动物听皮质神经元NMDA受体亚单位NR2B蛋白质的表达。结果：NR2B阳性神经元在生后第1周密度最高,随着生后周龄增长,NR2B阳性神经元密度递减．3周龄后降至成年动物的低表达水平。结论：大鼠生后发育过程巾．听皮质NR2B亚单位蛋白质呈现年龄-依赖性表达,此结果与mRNA水平上的表达趋势一致。     

Development of human visual cortex: a balance between excitatory and inhibitory plasticity mechanisms

Formation of neural circuitry in the developing visual cortex is shaped by experience during the critical period. A number of mechanisms, including N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptor activation and gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA)-mediated inhibition, are crucial in determining onset and closure of the critical period for visual plasticity. Animal models have shown that a threshold level of tonic inhibition must be reached for critical period plasticity to occur and that NMDA receptors contribute to Hebbian synaptic plasticity in the developing visual cortex. There are a number of developmental changes in these glutamatergic and GABAergic mechanisms that have been linked to plasticity; however, those changes have been shown only in animal models, and their development in the human visual cortex is not known. We have addressed this question by studying the expression of the major glutamatergic receptors, GABA(A) receptors, and glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD) isoforms during the first 6 years of postnatal development of human visual cortex. There are significant changes in the expression of these proteins during postnatal development of human visual cortex. The time course of the changes is quite prolonged and suggests that it may set the pace for the prolonged critical period in human visual development. The changes also affect the nature of spatial and temporal integration in visual cortical neurons and thereby contribute to the maturation of visual functions.     

Parvalbumin and calbindin are differentially distributed within primary and secondary subregions of the mouse auditory forebrain

The calcium binding proteins parvalbumin and calbindin are thought to differentially regulate physiological functions and often show complementary distributions in the CNS. Our goal was to determine parvalbumin and calbindin distributions in the different subdivisions of mouse auditory thalamus and auditory cortex. Following fixation, FVB mouse brains (postnatal days 38-80) were sectioned along coronal and horizontal planes, then processed for parvalbumin and calbindin immunohistochemistry (antibodies: parvalbumin pa-235, calbindin-d-28k cl-300). Strong complementary differences in calcium binding protein distributions were found in mouse auditory thalamus. The ventral division of the medial geniculate, which is the principal relay to primary auditory cortex, exhibited dense parvalbumin but weak calbindin immunoreactivity. In contrast, most of the 'secondary' auditory thalamic regions surrounding the ventral division showed strong calbindin and lighter parvalbumin levels. Thus, the mouse auditory thalamus is composed of a parvalbumin positive 'core' surrounded by a calbindin positive 'shell'. Parvalbumin immunoreactivity was also more prominent in the primary auditory cortex than in the secondary belt auditory cortex. Calbindin immunoreactivity in auditory cortex was less clearly divided along primary/secondary lines, especially in supragranular layers. However, within infragranular layers, there was heavier staining in belt areas than in primary auditory cortex. In auditory thalamus, parvalbumin labeling was largely confined to the neuropil, whereas calbindin labeling involved somata and neuropil. In auditory cortex, somata and neuropil were positive for both proteins.In summary, the calcium binding proteins parvalbumin and calbindin were found to be differentially distributed within the primary and non-primary regions of mouse auditory forebrain. These differences in protein distribution may contribute to the distinct types of physiological responses that occur in the primary vs. non-primary areas.     

Non-plastic reorganization of frequency coding in the inferior colliculus of the rat following noise-induced hearing loss

It is well established that restricted mechanical lesions of the cochlea result in reorganization of the tonotopic map in the auditory thalamus and cortex, but it is unclear whether acoustic trauma produces similar effects at earlier stages of the auditory pathways. To test whether the tonotopic map is reorganized after acoustic trauma at the midbrain level, i.e. the inferior colliculus (IC), we exposed rats to an acoustic trauma and let them survive for at least 5 weeks to ensure that we produced a permanent threshold shift. Experiments were carried out in urethane-anesthetized animals 35-296 days after the traumatic exposure. The acoustic lesions were assessed by measuring the compound action potential. We mapped the frequency organization of the IC using multiunit recordings. In addition, we recorded frequency response areas (FRAs) when a single unit was isolated (N=142). The results show that acoustic trauma produces a persistent reorganization of the tonotopic map and that the normal stepwise representation of sound frequency in the IC is profoundly disrupted. Although the reorganization in the IC is similar to that previously described in the cortex and thalamus in that the affected area appears to be invaded by the adjacent normal frequencies, changes in thresholds and FRAs in these regions are different from those in the forebrain. We conclude that most of the changes can be explained by the residual-response hypothesis [Irvine DR, Rajan R, Smith S (2003) Effects of restricted cochlear lesions in adult cats on the frequency organization of the inferior colliculus. J Comp Neurol 467:354-374]. Plastic reorganization of frequency response areas and tonotopic organization does not seem to occur at the midbrain level following acoustic trauma in adult animals in a manner similar to that previously shown in the auditory cortex. Maintaining the stability of the neuronal circuitry for frequency coding in the IC may be important for the treatment of noise-induced hearing loss.     

Rapid eye movement sleep deprivation revives a form of developmentally regulated synaptic plasticity in the visual cortex of post-critical period rats

The critical period for observing a developmentally regulated form of synaptic plasticity in the visual cortex of young rats normally ends at about postnatal day 30. This developmentally regulated form of in vitro long-term potentiation (LTP) can be reliably induced in layers II-III by aiming high frequency, theta burst stimulation (TBS) at the white matter situated directly below visual cortex (LTPWM-III). Previous work has demonstrated that suppression of sensory activation of visual cortex, achieved by rearing young rats in total darkness from birth, delays termination of the critical period for inducing LTPWM-III. Subsequent data also demonstrated that when rapid eye movement sleep (REMS) is suppressed, thereby reducing REMS cortical activation, just prior to the end of the critical period, termination of this developmental phase is delayed, and LTPWM-III can still be reliably produced in the usual post-critical period. Here, we report that for approximately 3 weeks immediately following the usual end of the critical period, suppression of REMS disrupts the maturational processes that close the critical period, and LTPWM-III is readily induced in brain slices taken from these somewhat older animals. Insofar as in vitro LTP is a model for the cellular and molecular changes that underlie developmental synaptic plasticity, these results suggest that mechanisms of synaptic plasticity, which participate in brain development and perhaps also in learning and memory processes, remain susceptible to the effects of REMS deprivation during the general period of adolescence in the rat.     

A new form of synaptic plasticity is transiently expressed in the developing rat visual cortex: a modulatory role for visual experience and brain-derived neurotrophic factor.

Synaptic plasticity has been implicated in the mechanisms contributing to the shaping of the cortical circuits responsible for the transmission of the visual input in the rat primary visual cortex. However, the degree of plasticity of the thalamocortical synapse may change during development, perhaps reflecting the degree of stabilization of the circuitry subserving it. We have chosen the ability of this synapse to be first depressed and then potentiated as a specific indicator of its plasticity. In this study we have investigated how this parameter changes during development and the factors controlling it. Extracellular field potentials in cortical layers 2/3 were evoked by stimulation of the white matter in rat primary visual cortex slices prepared at different postnatal ages. Low-frequency stimulation (900 pulses at 1 Hz) of the white matter was used to induce long-term depression of field potential amplitude, whereas long-term potentiation was evoked by high-frequency stimulation consisting of three trains at 100 Hz. We provide evidence that while it is possible to potentiate previously depressed synapses soon after eye opening (postnatal day 17) this synaptic characteristic decreases rapidly thereafter. The decrease in this form of cortical synaptic plasticity closely matches the stabilization of the cortical circuitry towards an adult pattern of connectivity and function. Depressed cortical synapses cannot be potentiated in normal rats at postnatal 23, but they can be potentiated in rats reared in the dark from postnatal days 17 to 29. Moreover, application of brain-derived neurotrophic factor, known to be expressed in an activity-dependent manner, was able to restore the ability of synapses to be potentiated after long-term depression, thus indicating its important modulatory role in brain development.     

猫视皮层17区一氧化氮合酶阳性神经元的生后发育

用ＮＡＤＰＨ ｄ 黄递酶组化技术观察了生后不同年龄段猫视皮层１７ 区中一氧化氮合酶阳性神经元的生后发育状况。结果显示： 生后１ 周内,一氧化氮合酶阳性细胞仅出现于皮层的第５／６ 层以及皮质下板（白质）中,皮质板中极少;生后２ 周时,一氧化氮合酶阳性细胞见于２／３ 和４ 层;在随后的发育中,２／３ 层与４ 层中阳性细胞逐渐增多,第５ 周时呈现与成年动物相似的分布模式。一氧化氮合酶阳性细胞的发育模式反映了皮质板的形成过程,即“由内向外”的皮层片层成熟模式;成年动物的皮层１７ 区中一氧化氮合酶阳性细胞远远高于幼年。猫视皮层１７ 区中一氧化氮合酶阳性细胞发育的时空表达模式与猫视皮层发育的关键期无明显吻合关系,推测视皮层中内源性一氧化氮与视皮层的眼优势柱的可塑性无关,为Ｒｅｉｄ 等和Ｒｕｔｈａｚｅｒ 等的电生理学研究结果提供了形态学证据。     

Unravelling the development of the visual cortex: implications for plasticity and repair

The visual cortex comprises over 50 areas in the human, each with a specified role and distinct physiology, connectivity and cellular morphology. How these individual areas emerge during development still remains something of a mystery and, although much attention has been paid to the initial stages of the development of the visual cortex, especially its lamination, very little is known about the mechanisms responsible for the arealization and functional organization of this region of the brain. In recent years we have started to discover that it is the interplay of intrinsic (molecular) and extrinsic (afferent connections) cues that are responsible for the maturation of individual areas, and that there is a spatiotemporal sequence in the maturation of the primary visual cortex (striate cortex, V1) and the multiple extrastriate/association areas. Studies in both humans and non‐human primates have started to highlight the specific neural underpinnings responsible for the maturation of the visual cortex, and how experience‐dependent plasticity and perturbations to the visual system can impact upon its normal development. Furthermore, damage to specific nuclei of the visual cortex, such as the primary visual cortex (V1), is a common occurrence as a result of a stroke, neurotrauma, disease or hypoxia in both neonates and adults alike. However, the consequences of a focal injury differ between the immature and adult brain, with the immature brain demonstrating a higher level of functional resilience. With better techniques for examining specific molecular and connectional changes, we are now starting to uncover the mechanisms responsible for the increased neural plasticity that leads to significant recovery following injury during this early phase of life. Further advances in our understanding of postnatal development/maturation and plasticity observed during early life could offer new strategies to improve outcomes by recapitulating aspects of the developmental program in the adult brain.     

Environmental enrichment enhances directional selectivity of primary auditory cortical neurons in rats

Environment enrichment (EE) has an important role in brain plasticity. Previous research has shown that EE increases the response strength of auditory cortical neurons, but it remains unknown whether EE can affect the directional selectivity of auditory neurons. In this study, rats were exposed to EE conditions during the developmental critical period (EE1) or after the critical period (EE2). By in vivo extracellular recording, we found that EE enhanced the directional selectivity of primary auditory cortical neurons in EE1 rats, which showed a sharper azimuth selectivity curve of auditory cortical neurons compared with normal rats. However, there was no significant difference in directional selectivity between the EE2 rats and age-matched control rats. Our findings indicate that early exposure to EE enhances the directional sensitivity of primary auditory cortical neurons. These results provide an insight into developmental plasticity in the auditory system.     

Plasticity in the adult brain: lessons from the visual system

While cortical circuits display maximal sensitivity to sensory experience during critical periods of early postnatal development, far less plasticity is present in the mature brain. Ocular dominance shift of visual cortical neurons in response to eye occlusion and recovery of visual functions from a period of sensory deprivation are two classical models in the study of critical period determinants in the visual cortex. Recent papers employing various pharmacological and environmental strategies have shown that it is possible to reinstate much greater levels of plasticity in the adult visual cortex than previously suspected. These studies point toward intracortical inhibition as a crucial determinant for critical period regulation in the visual system and have a great potential for therapeutic rehabilitation and recovery from injury in the adult brain. M. Spolidoro and A. Sale have equally contributed to this work.     

Persistent and specific influences of early acoustic environments on primary auditory cortex.

This study demonstrates that the adult form of 'tonotopic maps' of sound frequency in the rat primary auditory cortex (A1) arises from parallel developmental processes involving two cortical zones: the progressive differentiation and refinement of selectively tone-responsive receptive fields within an initially broadly-tuned posterior zone, and the progressive loss of tone-evoked, short-latency response over an initially large, very broadly tuned anterior zone. The formation of tonotopic maps in A1 was specifically influenced by a rat pup's early acoustic environments. Exposure to pulsed tones resulted in accelerated emergence and an expansion of A1 representations of those specific tone frequencies, as well as a deteriorated tonotopicity and broader-than-normal receptive fields. Thus, auditory experiences during early postnatal development are important in shaping the functional development of auditory cortical representations of specific acoustic environments.     

Manipulating critical period closure across different sectors of the primary auditory cortex

During early brain development and through 'adult' experience-dependent plasticity, neural circuits are shaped to represent the external world with high fidelity. When raised in a quiet environment, the rat primary auditory cortex (A1) has a well-defined 'critical period', lasting several days, for its representation of sound frequency. The addition of environmental noise extends the critical period duration as a variable function of noise level. It remains unclear whether critical period closure should be regarded as a unified, externally gated event that applies for all of A1 or if it is controlled by progressive, local, activity-driven changes in this cortical area. We found that rearing rats in the presence of a spectrally limited noise band resulted in the closure of the critical period for A1 sectors representing the noise-free spectral bands, whereas the critical period appeared to remain open in noise-exposed sectors, where the cortex was still functionally and physically immature.     

Controlling the critical period

Neuronal circuits are shaped by experience during 'critical periods' of early postnatal life. The ability to control the timing, duration, and closure of these heightened levels of brain plasticity has recently become experimentally possible. Two seemingly opposed views of critical period mechanism have emerged: (1) plasticity may be functionally accessed throughout life by appropriately modified stimulation protocols, or (2) plasticity is rigidly limited to early postnatal life by structural modifications. This overview synthesizes both perspectives across a variety of brain regions and species. A deeper understanding of critical periods will form the basis for novel international efforts to "nurture the brain".     

Tone frequency maps and receptive fields in the developing chinchilla auditory cortex

Single-unit responses to tone pip stimuli were isolated from numerous microelectrode penetrations of auditory cortex (under ketamine anesthesia) in the developing chinchilla (laniger), a precocious mammal. Results are reported at postnatal day 3 (P3), P15, and P30, and from adult animals. Hearing sensitivity and spike firing rates were mature in the youngest group. The topographic representation of sound frequency (tonotopic map) in primary and secondary auditory cortex was also well ordered and sharply tuned by P3. The spectral-temporal complexity of cortical receptive fields, on the other hand, increased progressively (past P30) to adulthood. The (purported) refinement of initially diffuse tonotopic projections to cortex thus seems to occur in utero in the chinchilla, where external (and maternal) sounds are considerably attenuated and might not contribute to the mechanism(s) involved. This compares well with recent studies of vision, suggesting that the refinement of the retinotopic map does not require external light, but rather waves of (correlated) spontaneous activity on the retina. In contrast, it is most probable that selectivity for more complex sound features, such as frequency stacks and glides, develops under the influence of the postnatal acoustic environment and that inadequate sound stimulation in early development (e.g., due to chronic middle ear disease) impairs the formation of the requisite intracortical (and/or subcortical) circuitry.     

Large-scale organization of ferret auditory cortex revealed using continuous acquisition of intrinsic optical signals

We have adapted a new approach for intrinsic optical imaging, in which images were acquired continuously while stimuli were delivered in a series of continually repeated sequences, to provide the first demonstration of the large-scale tonotopic organization of both primary and nonprimary areas of the ferret auditory cortex. Optical responses were collected during continuous stimulation by repeated sequences of sounds with varying frequency. The optical signal was averaged as a function of time during the sequence, to produce reflectance modulation functions (RMFs). We examined the stability and properties of the RMFs and show that their zero-crossing points provide the best temporal reference points for quantifying the relationship between the stimulus parameter values and optical responses. Sequences of different duration and direction of frequency change gave rise to comparable results, although in some cases discrepancies were observed, mostly between upward- and downward-frequency sequences. We demonstrated frequency maps, consistent with previous data, in primary auditory cortex and in the anterior auditory field, which were verified with electrophysiological recordings. In addition to these tonotopic gradients, we demonstrated at least 2 new acoustically responsive areas on the anterior and posterior ectosylvian gyri, which have not previously been described. Although responsive to pure tones, these areas exhibit less tonotopic order than the primary fields.