Townes-Brocks syndrome: twenty novel SALL1 mutations in sporadic and familial cases and refinement of the SALL1 hot spot region

Townes-Brocks syndrome (TBS) is an autosomal dominant malformation syndrome characterized by renal, anal, ear, and thumb anomalies caused by SALL1 mutations. To date, 36 SALL1 mutations have been described in TBS patients. All but three of those, namely p.R276X, p.S372X, and c.1404dupG, have been found only in single families thereby preventing phenotype-genotype correlations. Here we present 20 novel mutations (12 short deletions, five short duplications, three nonsense mutations) in 20 unrelated families. We delineate the phenotypes and report previously unknown ocular manifestations, i.e. congenital cataracts with unilateral microphthalmia. We show that 46 out of the now 56 SALL1 mutations are located between the coding regions for the glutamine-rich domain mediating SALL protein interactions and 65 bp 3' of the coding region for the first double zinc finger domain, narrowing the SALL1 mutational hotspot region to a stretch of 802 bp within exon 2. Of note, only two SALL1 mutations would result in truncated proteins without the glutamine-rich domain, one of which is reported here. The latter is associated with anal, ear, hand, and renal manifestations, indicating that the glutamine-rich domain is not required for typical TBS.     

Multigene deletions on chromosome 20q13.13-q13.2 including SALL4 result in an expanded phenotype of Okihiro syndrome plus developmental delay

Okihiro syndrome results from truncating mutations in the SALL4 locus on the chromosome 20q13.13-q13.2. Deletions of the whole SALL4 coding region as well as single exon deletions are also a common cause of Okihiro syndrome and indicate haploinsufficiency as the disease causing mechanism. The phenotypes caused by SALL4 deletions are not different from those caused by point mutations. No multigene deletion including SALL4 has been documented to date. Here we report the detection and molecular characterization of four novel, overlapping microdeletions, all spanning SALL4 and flanking genes, in four unrelated cases with features of Okihiro syndrome and variable degrees of psychomotor delay. All deletions were first identified and mapped by quantitative Real Time PCR. Subsequently, three of four deletions were mapped in further detail by high-resolution array CGH (244k oligo-arrays). All cases had larger deletions of varying size (1.76-1.78 Mb, 2.01-2.05 Mb, 2.16-2.17 Mb, and 1.3-2.8 Mb, respectively), which included SALL4 plus 3 to 7 additional functional genes. While three cases with largely overlapping deletions are mildly developmentally delayed, the only patient with a more centromeric deletion is clearly mentally retarded. In this patient, four genes (MOCS3, DPM1, ADNP, BCAS4) are deleted, which were not affected in the other three cases, suggesting that the deletion of one or more of these genes contributes to the mental retardation. Since two of the four cases presented with choanal atresia, large deletions including SALL4 should be considered in the differential diagnosis of children with suspected CHARGE syndrome but without detectable CHD7 mutations.     

Hypoparathyroidism,deafness, and renal dysplasia syndrome: 20 Years after the identification of the first GATA3 mutations

The hypoparathyroidism, deafness, and renal dysplasia (HDR) syndrome is an autosomal dominant disorder caused by heterozygous mutations of the GATA3 gene. In the last 20 years, since the identification of the genetic cause of the HDR syndrome, GATA3 mutations have been reported in 124 families (177 patients). The clinical aspects and molecular genetics of the HDR syndrome are reviewed here together with the reported mutations and phenotypes. Reported mutations consist of 40% frameshift deletions or insertions, 23% missense mutations, 14% nonsense mutations, 6% splice‐site mutations, 1% in‐frame deletions or insertions, 15% whole‐gene deletions, and 1% whole‐gene duplication. Missense mutations were found to cluster in the regions encoding the two GATA3 zinc‐finger domains. Patients showed great clinical variability and the penetrance of each HDR defect increased with age. The most frequently observed abnormality was deafness (93%), followed by hypoparathyroidism (87%) and renal defects (61%). The mean age of diagnosis of HDR was 15.3, 7.5, and 14.0 years, respectively. However, patients with whole‐gene deletions and protein‐truncating mutations were diagnosed earlier than patients with missense mutations.     

IVIC syndrome is caused by a c.2607delA mutation in the SALL4 locus

The IVIC syndrome described in 1980 in a large Venezuelan family, is an autosomal dominant condition characterized by upper limbs anomalies (radial ray defects, carpal bones fusion), extraocular motor disturbances, congenital bilateral non-progressive mixed hearing loss; other less consistent malformations include heart involvement, mild thrombocytopenia and leukocytosis (before age 50), shoulder girdle hypoplasia, imperforate anus, kidney malrotation or rectovaginal fistula. Since 2002, mutations in the SALL4 locus have been reported producing phenotypic features quite similar to those in IVIC syndrome; this gene was thus proposed as a candidate for the condition. A segregation analysis of four SNPs in exon 2 (c.1520T > G, c.1860A > G, c.2037C > T, and c.2392A > C) was carried out in 14 affected and in 15 normal family members. Haplotype T;A;C;A was found to always segregate with the disease. Sequencing the whole coding regions revealed one heterozygous base deletion in exon 3 (c.2607delA) causing a premature stop signal 44 codons downstream (p.Q869fsX44) which segregates with the phenotype, being absent in controls. The large number of affected individuals presumably carrying the same mutation (n = 26) with quite different degrees of involvement allowed a discussion about possible mechanisms for the SALL4 action. The finding of a SALL4 mutation in a family with such a wide pleiotropic spectrum proves that at least Okihiro, acro-renal-ocular and IVIC syndromes are allelic entities.     

Townes-Brocks syndrome with craniosynostosis in two siblings

This report describes a novel truncating c.709C > T p.(Gln237*) SALL1 variant in two siblings exhibiting sagittal craniosynostosis as a unique feature of Townes-Brocks syndrome (TBS, OMIM #107480). TBS is a rare autosomal dominant syndrome with variable phenotypes, including anorectal, renal, limb, and ear abnormalities, which results from heterozygous variants in the SALL1 gene, predominantly located in the 802 bp “hot spot region” within exon 2. Recent studies have suggested that aberrations in primary cilia and sonic hedgehog signalling contribute to the TBS phenotypes. The presence of the novel c.709C > T p.(Gln237*) SALL1 variant was confirmed in both the siblings and their father, whereas no mutations currently associated with craniosynostosis were detected. We hypothesise that the truncating c.709C > T p.(Gln237*) SALL1 variant, which occurs outside the “hot spot region” and inside the glutamine-rich domain coding region, could interfere with ciliary signalling and mechanotransduction, contributing to premature fusion of calvarial sutures. This report broadens the genetic and phenotypic spectrum of TBS and provides the first clinical evidence of craniosynostosis as a novel feature of the syndrome.     

Expanding the spectrum of TBX5 mutations in Holt-Oram syndrome: detection of two intragenic deletions by quantitative real time PCR, and report of eight novel point mutations

Mutations in the gene TBX5 cause Holt-Oram syndrome (HOS), an autosomal dominant disorder characterized by anterior (i.e., radial ray) upper limb malformations and congenital heart defects and/or cardiac conduction anomalies. The detection rate for TBX5 mutations in HOS patients has been given as 30-35% in most reports. However, a detection rate of 74% was reported when strict clinical inclusion criteria for HOS were applied prior to TBX5 analysis. Still, in a significant proportion of typical HOS cases no mutation can be found within the TBX5 coding region and flanking intronic sequences. One explanation could be that large but submicroscopic deletions of TBX5 could cause HOS, yet only one such TBX5 deletion has been reported to date. We developed a quantitative Real Time PCR strategy to detect large, submicroscopic deletions in TBX5. Using this assay, we screened a total of 102 TBX5 mutation negative patients and discovered two novel intragenic deletions. One deletion of 7756 bp removes exon 6 and a considerable part of the neighboring intronic sequences, and the other of 3695 bp removes exon 9 with the stop codon and the 3'UTR completely as well as a part of the preceding intron 8. We conclude that quantitative Real Time PCR is a reliable method to detect submicroscopic deletions within TBX5. However, such deletions explain only approximately 2% of the TBX5 mutational spectrum in HOS cases. In addition, we also present eight novel TBX5 mutations (three nonsense, one splice mutation, four short deletions) as detected by direct sequencing in 21 families not previously analyzed for mutations.     

Detection of heterozygous SALL1 deletions by quantitative real time PCR proves the contribution of a SALL1 dosage effect in the pathogenesis of Townes-Brocks syndrome

Townes-Brocks syndrome (TBS) is an autosomal dominantly inherited disorder characterized by ear, anal, limb, and renal malformations, and results from mutations in the gene SALL1. All SALL1 mutations previously found in TBS patients create preterminal termination codons. In accordance with the findings of pericentric inversions or balanced translocations, TBS was initially assumed to be caused by SALL1 haploinsufficiency. This assumption was strongly contradicted by a Sall1 mouse knock-out, because neither hetero- nor homozygous knock-out mutants displayed a TBS-like phenotype. A different mouse mutant mimicking the human SALL1 mutations, however, showed a TBS-like phenotype in the heterozygous situation, suggesting a dominant-negative action of the mutations causing TBS. We applied quantitative real time PCR to detect and map SALL1 deletions in 240 patients with the clinical diagnosis of TBS, who were negative for SALL1 mutations. Deletions were found in three families. In the first family, a 75 kb deletion including all SALL1 exons had been inherited by two siblings from their father. A second, sporadic patient carried a de novo 1.9-2.6 Mb deletion including the whole SALL1 gene, and yet another sporadic case was found to carry an intragenic deletion of 3384 bp. In all affected persons, the TBS phenotype is rather mild as compared to the phenotype resulting from point mutations. These results confirm that SALL1 haploinsufficiency is sufficient to cause a mild TBS phenotype but suggest that it is not sufficient to cause the severe, classical form. It therefore seems that there is a different contribution of SALL1 gene function to mouse and human embryonic development.     

GATA3 abnormalities and the phenotypic spectrum of HDR syndrome

We report on GATA3 analysis and the phenotypic spectrum in nine Japanese families with the HDR syndrome (hypoparathyroidism, sensorineural deafness, and renal dysplasia) (MIM 146255). Fluorescence in situ hybridisation and microsatellite analyses showed heterozygous gross deletions including GATA3 in four families. Sequence analysis showed heterozygous novel mutations in three families: a missense mutation within the first zinc finger domain at exon 4 (T823A, W275R), an unusual mutation at exon 4 (900insAA plus 901insCCT or C901AACCCT) resulting in a premature stop at codon 357 with loss of the second zinc finger domain, and a nonsense mutation at exon 6 (C1099T, R367X). No GATA3 abnormalities were identified in the remaining two families. The triad of HDR syndrome was variably manifested by patients with GATA3 abnormalities. The results suggest that HDR syndrome is primarily caused by GATA3 haploinsufficiency and is associated with a wide phenotypic spectrum.


Keywords: GATA3; HDR syndrome; phenotypic spectrum; mutation analysis     

High proportion of large genomic STK11 deletions in Peutz-Jeghers syndrome

Germline mutations in the STK11 gene have been identified in 10-70% of patients with Peutz-Jeghers syndrome (PJS), an autosomal-dominant hamartomatous polyposis syndrome. A second locus was assumed in a large proportion of PJS patients. To date, STK11 alterations comprise mainly point mutations; only a small number of large deletions have been reported. We performed a mutation analysis for the STK11 gene in 71 patients. Of these, 56 met the clinical criteria for PJS and 12 were presumed to have PJS because of mucocutaneous pigmentation only or bowel problems due to isolated PJS polyps. No clinical information was available for the remaining three patients. By direct sequencing of the coding region of the STK11 gene, we identified point mutations in 37 of 71 patients (52%). We examined the remaining 34 patients by means of the multiplex ligation-dependent probe amplification (MLPA) method, and detected deletions in 17 patients. In four patients the deletion extended over all 10 exons, and in eight patients only the promoter region and exon 1 were deleted. The remaining deletions encompassed exons 2-10 (in two patients), exons 2-3, exons 4-5, or exon 8. When only patients who met the clinical criteria for PJS are considered, the overall mutation detection rate increases to 94% (64% point mutations and 30% large deletions). No mutation was identified in any of the 12 presumed cases. In conclusion, we found that approximately one-third of the patients who met the clinical PJS criteria exhibited large genomic deletions that were readily detectable by MLPA. Screening for point mutations and large deletions by direct sequencing or MLPA, respectively, increased the mutation detection rate in the STK11 gene up to 94%. There may be still other mutations in the STK11 gene that are not detectable by the methods applied here. Therefore, it is questionable whether a second PJS locus exists at all.     

Identification of WASP mutations in 14 Spanish families with Wiskott‐Aldrich syndrome

The Wiskott‐Aldrich syndrome (WAS) is an X‐linked immunodeficiency caused by mutations in the WASP gene. The disease is known to be associated with extensive clinical variability, and mutation studies indicate that genotypes are also highly variant among WAS patients. In this study, we performed mutation analysis of the WASP gene in 14 unrelated Spanish families by single strand conformation analysis (SSCA) and sequencing, resulting in the identification of a novel mutation and nine known mutations. No mutation was identified in one family. The ten different mutations include point mutations resulting in amino acid substitutions, stop codons, and small deletions and insertions causing frameshifts. Missense mutations were preferentially located in the amino‐terminal part of the protein, exons 2 and 4, whereas stop and frameshift mutations were located in the carboxyl‐terminal region, exons 10 and 11. However, in two families, two missense mutations in exon 11 were identified. Our study demonstrates that WASP genotypes have some concordance with the patients' phenotypes, although mutation 1019delC, identified in a family with several affected members, resulted in high intrafamilial clinical variability. © 2001 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Analysis of CBP (CREBBP) gene deletions in Rubinstein-Taybi syndrome patients using real-time quantitative PCR

Rubinstein-Taybi syndrome (RTS) is a well-defined syndrome characterized by facial abnormalities, broad thumbs, broad big toes, and growth and mental retardation as the main clinical features. RTS was shown to be associated with disruption of the CREB-binding protein gene CBP (CREBBP), either by gross chromosomal rearrangements or by point mutations. Translocations and inversions involving chromosome band 16p13.3 form the minority of CBP mutations, whereas microdeletions occur more frequently (about 10%). Most deletion studies in RTS are performed by FISH analysis, and five cosmids must be used to cover the whole of the CBP gene, which spreads over 150 kb. Here we report the design of gene dosage assays by real-time quantitative PCR that are targeted on three exons located respectively at the 5' end (exon 2), in the middle (exon 12), and at the 3' end (exon 30) of the CBP gene. This technique proved to be efficient and powerful in finding deletions and complementary to the other available techniques, since it allowed us to identify deletions at the 3' end of the gene that had been missed by FISH analysis, and to refine some deletion breakpoints. Our results therefore suggest that real-time quantitative PCR is a useful technique to be included in the deletion search in RTS patients.     

Gross rearrangements in the MECP2 gene in three patients with Rett syndrome: implications for routine diagnosis of Rett syndrome

Since 1999, many laboratories have confirmed that mutations in the MECP2 gene are the primary cause of Rett syndrome (RTT or RS) and identified mutations in 70 to 90% of the sporadically affected girls. Most of the screenings are PCR-based and restricted to the coding part of the gene and therefore prone to miss gross rearrangements. By Southern blot analysis we identified large deletions (>1 kb) in three female patients with classical, severe Rett syndrome. Further characterization by semi-quantitative PCR and amplification of junction fragments confirmed the presence of a 7.6-kb deletion in one patient and an 8.1-kb deletion in the other patient, both including exon 3 and the coding part of exon 4. The exact nature of the rearrangement in the third patient remained elusive. These results underline the importance of screening for major genomic rearrangements in Rett syndrome. Hum Mutat 22:116-120, 2003.