Cationic lipids containing cyclen and ammonium moieties as gene delivery vectors

In this study, two novel cationic lipids containing protonated cyclen and quaternary ammonium moieties were designed and synthesized as non-viral gene delivery vectors. The structures of the two lipids differ in their hydrophobic region (cholesterol or diosgenin). Cationic liposomes were easily prepared from the lipids individually or from the mixtures of each cationic lipid and dioleoylphosphatidylethanolamine. Several studies including DLS, gel retardation assay, and ethidium bromide intercalation assay suggest that these amphiphilic molecules are able to bind and compact DNA into nanometer particles which can be used as non-viral gene delivery agents. Our results from in vitro transfection show that in association with dioleoylphosphatidylethanolamine, two cationic lipids can induce effective gene transfection in human embryonic kidney 293 cells, although the gene transfection efficiencies of two cationic lipids were found to be lower than that of lipofectamine 2000(TM) . Besides, different cytotoxicity was found for two lipoplexes. This study demonstrates that the title cationic lipids have large potential to be efficient non-viral gene vectors.     

Current status of non-viral gene therapy for CNS disorders

ABSTRACT

Introduction: Viral and non-viral vectors have been used as methods of delivery in gene therapy for many CNS diseases. Currently, viral vectors such as adeno-associated viruses (AAV), retroviruses, lentiviruses, adenoviruses and herpes simplex viruses (HHV) are being used as successful vectors in gene therapy at clinical trial levels. However, many disadvantages have risen from their usage. Non-viral vectors like cationic polymers, cationic lipids, engineered polymers, nanoparticles, and naked DNA offer a much safer option and can therefore be explored for therapeutic purposes.

Areas covered: This review discusses different types of viral and non-viral vectors for gene therapy and explores clinical trials for CNS diseases that have used these types of vectors for gene delivery. Highlights include non-viral gene delivery and its challenges, possible strategies to improve transfection, regulatory issues concerning vector usage, and future prospects for clinical applications.

Expert opinion: Transfection efficiency of cationic lipids and polymers can be improved through manipulation of molecules used. Efficacy of cationic lipids is dependent on cationic charge, saturation levels, and stability of linkers. Factors determining efficacy of cationic polymers are total charge density, molecular weights, and complexity of molecule. All of the above mentioned parameters must be taken care for efficient gene delivery.     

Cationic transfection lipids in gene therapy: successes,set-backs,challenges and promises

The clinical success of gene therapy is critically dependent on the development of efficient and safe gene delivery reagents, popularly known as "Transfection Vectors". The transfection vectors commonly used in gene therapy are mainly of two types: viral and non-viral. The efficiencies of viral transfection vectors are, in general, superior to their non-viral counterparts. However, the myriads of potentially adverse immunogenic aftermaths associated with the use of viral vectors are increasingly making the non-viral gene delivery reagents as the vectors of choice. Among the existing arsenal of non-viral gene delivery reagents, the distinct advantages associated with the use of cationic transfection lipids include their: (a) robust manufacture; (b) ease in handling & preparation techniques; (c) ability to inject large lipid:DNA complexes and (d) low immunogenic response. The present review will highlight the successes, set-backs, challenges and future promises of cationic transfection lipids in non-viral gene therapy.     

非病毒载体在肿瘤基因治疗领域的研究进展

随着肿瘤基因治疗领域的研究进展，临床应用逐渐增多。载体是癌症基因治疗的主要难题。当前广泛使用的病毒载体存在的安全问题越来越受到人们的重视，已经有多种非病毒载体用于肿瘤基因治疔，如：裸DNA直接注射、阳离子脂质、阳离子聚合物。研究非病毒载体的目标是：它能像靶向的合成病毒载体那样对肿瘤组织表现出高度特异性；具有很高的转染效率；潜在的安全性问题能够被控制。     

Novel cationic lipids possessing protonated cyclen and imidazolium salt for gene delivery

In this study, two novel protonated cyclen and imidazolium salt-containing cationic lipids differing only in their hydrophobic region (cholesterol or diosgenin) have been designed and synthesized for gene delivery. Cationic liposomes were easily prepared from each of these lipids individually or from the mixtures of each cationic lipid and dioleoylphosphatidyl ethanolamine (DOPE). Several studies including DLS, gel retardation assay, ethidium bromide intercalation assay, and TEM demonstrated that these amphiphilic molecules are able to bind and compact DNA into nanometer particles that could be used as non-viral gene delivery agents. Our results from in vitro transfection showed that in association with DOPE, two cationic lipids can induce effective gene transfection in HEK293 cells. Furthermore, the gene transfection efficiencies of two cationic lipids were dramatically increased in the presence of calcium ion (Ca²⁺). It is notable that the gene transfection abilities of two cationic lipids were maintained in the presence of 10% serum. Besides, different cytotoxicity was found for two lipoplexes. This study demonstrates that the title cationic lipids have large potential to be efficient non-viral gene vector.     

Structure-activity relationship in cationic lipid mediated gene transfection

Non-viral synthetic vectors for gene delivery represent a safer alternative to viral vectors. Their main drawback is the low transfection efficiency, especially in vivo. Among the non-viral vectors currently in use, the cationic liposomes composed of cationic lipids are the most common. This review discusses the physicochemical properties of cationic lipids, the formation, macrostructure and specific parameters of the corresponding formulated liposomes, and the effect of all these parameters on transfection efficiency. The optimisation of liposomal vectors requires both the understanding of the biological variables involved in the transfection process, and the effect of the structural elements of the cationic lipids on these biological variables. The biological barriers relevant for in vitro and in vivo transfection are identified, and solutions to overcome them based on rational design of the cationic lipids are discussed. The review focuses on the relationship between the structure of the cationic lipid and the transfection activity. The structure is analysed in a modular manner. The hydrophobic domain, the cationic head group, the backbone that acts as a scaffold for the other domains, the linkers between backbone, hydrophobic domain and cationic head group, the polyethyleneglycol chains and the targeting moiety are identified as distinct elements of the cationic lipids used in gene therapy. The main chemical functionalities used to built these domains, as well as overall molecular features such as architecture and geometry, are presented. Studies of structure-activity relationships of each cationic lipid domain, including the authors', and the trends identified by these studies, help furthering the understanding of the mechanism governing the formation and behaviour of cationic liposomes in gene delivery, and therefore the rational design of new improved cationic lipids vectors capable of achieving clinical significance.     

Cationic lipids for transfection

Among other strategies, the use of cationic lipids as autoassembling vehicles for non viral DNA transfection has received considerable attention. An exponentially growing litterature has been published on this topic (over 700 hits for the past decade, including 400 in the last two years). The present review focuses on the main present strategies aiming at improving cationic lipids induced transfection, and on some of the frequently encountered problems that should be solved to apply these non-viral vectors for human health. The review contains several sections dealing with the chemistry, physico-chemistry, cell biology, in vivo biology, and targeting of cationic-lipid DNA complexes.     

Influence of physicochemical properties on pharmacokinetics of non-viral vectors for gene delivery

The influence of physicochemical properties on the in vivo pharmacokinetics of gene delivery vectors after systemic administration is reviewed based on our studies. We have been studying the development of DNA delivery systems, such as plasmid DNA complexed with cationic polymers (polyplexes) and cationic liposomes (lipoplexes). Even if target-recognizable ligand is incorporated into the system, the overall physicochemical properties, notably size and charge, are predominant factors influencing in vivo disposition characteristics of the vector. Based on this consideration, liver cell-specific carrier systems via receptor-mediated endocytosis were successfully developed by optimizing physicochemical characteristics. In conclusion, rational design of gene delivery vectors requires an understanding of their pharmacokinetics in relation to the physicochemical properties. Optimization of the physicochemical properties is important for successful in vivo gene delivery by non-viral vectors.     

Influence of Physicochemical Properties on Pharmacokinetics of Non-viral Vectors for Gene Delivery

The influence of physicochemical properties on the in vivo pharmacokinetics of gene delivery vectors after systemic administration is reviewed based on our studies. We have been studying the development of DNA delivery systems, such as plasmid DNA complexed with cationic polymers (polyplexes) and cationic liposomes (lipoplexes). Even if target-recognizable ligand is incorporated into the system, the overall physicochemical properties, notably size and charge, are predominant factors influencing in vivo disposition characteristics of the vector. Based on this consideration, liver cell-specific carrier systems via receptor-mediated endocytosis were successfully developed by optimizing physicochemical characteristics. In conclusion, rational design of gene delivery vectors requires an understanding of their pharmacokinetics in relation to the physicochemical properties. Optimization of the physicochemical properties is important for successful in vivo gene delivery by non-viral vectors.     

Chitosan-DNA nanoparticles as non-viral vectors in gene therapy: strategies to improve transfection efficacy.

Currently, the major drawback of gene therapy is the gene transfection rate. The two main types of vectors that are used in gene therapy are based on viral or non-viral gene delivery systems. The viral gene delivery system shows a high transfection yield but it has many disadvantages, such as oncogenic effects and immunogenicity. However, cationic polymers, like chitosan, have potential for DNA complexation and may be useful as non-viral vectors for gene therapy applications. Chitosan is a natural non-toxic polysaccharide, it is biodegradable and biocompatible, and protects DNA against DNase degradation and leads to its condensation. The objective of this paper was to summarize the state of the art in gene therapy and particularly the use of chitosan to improve the transfection efficiency in vivo and in vitro.     

Folate-linked lipid-based nanoparticle for targeted gene delivery

Cancer gene therapy has been intensively developed using non-viral vectors, among which cationic liposomes and nanoparticles are the most thoroughly investigated. For targeted delivery to tumors, vitamin folic acid has been utilized for folate receptor (FR)-mediated drug delivery, since FR is frequently overexpressed on many types of human tumors. Liposomes conjugated to folate ligand have been used as carriers of chemotherapeutic agents and DNA to receptor-bearing tumor cells in vitro. As an alternative treatment for prostate cancer, suicide gene therapy by local injection using an adenoviral vector has been reported, but not that using non-viral vectors. The folate-linked, lipid-based nanoparticles which we developed could deliver genes extensively to FR-negative LNCaP and PC-3 cells, as well as FR-positive KB and Hela cells. In this review, we outline folate-linked liposomes and nanoparticles, and show the effectiveness of folate-linked, lipid-based nanoparticles as a vector for DNA transfection and for suicide gene therapy, to treat human nasopharyngeal and prostate tumors.     

Polyethylenimine-based non-viral gene delivery systems.

Gene therapy has become a promising strategy for the treatment of many inheritable or acquired diseases that are currently considered incurable. Non-viral vectors have attracted great interest, as they are simple to prepare, rather stable, easy to modify and relatively safe, compared to viral vectors. Unfortunately, they also suffer from a lower transfection efficiency, requiring additional effort for their optimization. The cationic polymer polyethylenimine (PEI) has been widely used for non-viral transfection in vitro and in vivo and has an advantage over other polycations in that it combines strong DNA compaction capacity with an intrinsic endosomolytic activity. Here, we give some insight into strategies developed for PEI-based non-viral vectors to overcome intracellular obstacles, including the improvement of methods for polyplex preparation and the incorporation of endosomolytic agents or nuclear localization signals. In recent years, PEI-based non-viral vectors have been locally or systemically delivered, mostly to target gene delivery to tumor tissue, the lung or liver. This requires strategies to efficiently shield transfection polyplexes against non-specific interaction with blood components, extracellular matrix and untargeted cells and the attachment of targeting moieties, which allow for the directed gene delivery to the desired cell or tissue. In this context, materials, facilitating the design of novel PEI-based non-viral vectors are described.     

Evaluation of Multicomponent Non-viral Vectors for Liver Directed Gene Delivery

Multicomponent, non-viral gene delivery vehicles are designed to have as a minimum, a DNA binding component, and a cell recognition component for specific delivery to target cells. The DNA binding component cannot only bind, but also protect DNA from serum degradation, and tends to condense DNA to sizes that can be taken up by receptor-mediated processes of target cells. Generally, cationic peptides, single chained, e.g. poly- l -lysine or branched polymers or synthetic peptides with DNA binding properties are used for DNA binding components. Ligands for binding to receptors on cell surfaces can be covalently linked to the DNA binding component. Multicomponent, non-viral vectors have been successfully used to deliver genes into cells in vitro and in vivo. Improvements have been made to the non-viral carriers resulting in increased solubility of DNA/carrier complexes and longer survival in serum. Improvements have also been made by incorporating fusogenic/lysosomolytic components that enable DNA/carrier complexes to escape intracellular degradation and enhance the levels and duration of expression of genes in vitro and in vivo.     

Toxicogenomics of cationic lipid-based vectors for gene therapy: impact of microarray technology

Implementation of the high-throughput microarray gene expression profiling technology towards "toxicogenomics" has advanced identification process for safer drugs in the century of 'omics' technology. Applying such technology, in fact, to identify mechanisms for cellular toxicity can provide a means to clarify safety liabilities early in the drug discovery and developments process. The underlying principle in gene therapy is primarily targeting a specific gene (e.g., for silencing). Hence, massive efforts have been devoted to validate the gene-based therapeutics, regardless of toxicogenomics potential of delivery systems. Of the gene delivery systems, viral and non-viral vectors, as two main paradigms, have so far been widely used for delivering of the genome-based therapeutics such as oligonucleotide, small interfering RNA and DNA. However, the use of viral vectors was narrowed due to the safety concerns. Non-viral vectors were utilized as safer alternatives for gene delivery in vitro and ex-vivo; though their success for in vivo gene therapy has been limited due to low efficiency and safety issues. Fundamental principle for gene therapy is to deliver gene-based therapeutics into target cells for specific gene targeting ideally with minimal cellular toxicity. Until now, few works have been conducted about geno-compatibility of delivery systems itself, including cationic lipid-based nanosystems. Inadvertent toxicogenomic impact of gene delivery systems (e.g., cationic lipids) may intrinsically affect the outcome of gene therapy, where often only a single desired genetic change is sought. Further, there exists a possibility that gene changes induced by the lipid delivery system itself could exacerbate, attenuate or even mask the desired effects of the gene-based therapeutics. This review will focus on toxicogenomics impact of the cationic lipid-based formulations for gene therapy.     

Evaluation of multicomponent non-viral vectors for liver directed gene delivery

Multicomponent, non-viral gene delivery vehicles are designed to have as a minimum, a DNA binding component, and a cell recognition component for specific delivery to target cells. The DNA binding component cannot only bind, but also protect DNA from serum degradation, and tends to condense DNA to sizes that can be taken up by receptor-mediated processes of target cells. Generally, cationic peptides, single chained, e.g. poly-L-lysine or branched polymers or synthetic peptides with DNA binding properties are used for DNA binding components. Ligands for binding to receptors on cell surfaces can be covalently linked to the DNA binding component. Multicomponent, non-viral vectors have been successfully used to deliver genes into cells in vitro and in vivo. Improvements have been made to the non-viral carriers resulting in increased solubility of DNA/carrier complexes and longer survival in serum. Improvements have also been made by incorporating fusogenic/lysosomolytic components that enable DNA/carrier complexes to escape intracellular degradation and enhance the levels and duration of expression of genes in vitro and in vivo.     

Non-viral ocular gene therapy: potential ocular therapeutic avenues

Non-viral vectors for potential gene replacement and therapy have been developed in order to overcome the drawbacks of viral vectors. The diversity of non-viral vectors allows for a wide range of various products, flexibility of application, ease of use, low-cost of production and enhanced "genomic" safety. Using non-viral strategies, oligonucleotides (ODNs) can be delivered naked (less efficient) or entrapped in cationic lipids, polymers or peptides forming slow release delivery systems, which can be adapted according to the organ targeted and the therapy purposes. Tissue and cell internalization can be further enhanced by changing by physical or chemical means. Moreover, a specific vector can be selected according to disease course and intensity of manifestations fulfilling specific requirements such as the duration of drug release and its level along with cells and tissues specific targeting. From accumulating knowledge and experience, it appears that combination of several non-viral techniques may increase the efficacy and ensure the safety of these evolving and interesting gene therapy strategies.     

The design of cationic lipids for gene delivery

Synthetic gene delivery vectors are gaining increasing importance in gene therapy as an alternative to recombinant viruses. Among the various types of non-viral vectors, cationic lipids are especially attractive as they can be prepared with relative ease and extensively characterised. Further, each of their constituent parts can be modified, thereby facilitating the elucidation of structure-activity relationships. In this forward-looking review, cationic lipid-mediated gene delivery will mainly be discussed in terms of the structure of the three basic constituent parts of any cationic lipid: the polar headgroup, hydrophobic moiety and linker. Particular emphasis will be placed on recent advances in the field as well as on our own original contributions. In addition to reviewing critical physicochemical features (such as headgroup hydration) of monovalent lipids, the use of headgroups with known nucleic-acid binding modes, such as linear and branched polyamines, aminoglycosides and guanidinium functions, will be comprehensively assessed. A particularly exciting innovation in linker design is the incorporation of environment-sensitive groups, the intracellular hydrolysis of which may lead to more controlled DNA delivery. Examples of pH-, redox- and enzyme-sensitive functional groups integrated into the linker are highlighted and the benefits of such degradable vectors can be evaluated in terms of transfection efficiency and cationic lipid-associated cytotoxicity. Finally, possible correlations between the length and type of hydrophobic moiety and transfection efficiency will be discussed. In conclusion it may be foreseen that in order to be successful, the future of cationic lipid-based gene delivery will probably require the development of sophisticated virus-like systems, which can be viewed as "programmed supramolecular systems" incorporating the various functions required to perform in a chronological order the different steps involved in gene transfection.     

Reducing the immunostimulatory activity of CpG-containing plasmid DNA vectors for non-viral gene therapy

The mammalian innate immune system has the ability to recognise and direct a response against incoming foreign DNA. The primary signal that triggers this response is unmethylated CpG motifs present in the DNA sequence of various disease-causing pathogens. These motifs are rare in vertebrate DNA, but abundant in bacterial and some viral DNAs. Because gene therapy generally involves the delivery of DNA from either plasmids of bacterial origin or recombinant viruses, an acute inflammatory response of variable severity inevitably results. The response is most serious for non-viral gene delivery vectors composed of cationic lipid-DNA complexes, producing adverse effects at lower doses and lethality at higher doses of complex. This review examines the role of immunostimulatory CpG motifs in the acute inflammatory response to non-viral gene therapy vectors. Strategies to neutralise or eliminate CpG motifs within plasmid DNA vectors, and the existing limitations of CpG reduction on improving the safety profile of non-viral vectors, will be discussed.     

Reducing the immunostimulatory activity of CpG-containing plasmid DNA vectors for non-viral gene therapy

The mammalian innate immune system has the ability to recognise and direct a response against incoming foreign DNA. The primary signal that triggers this response is unmethylated CpG motifs present in the DNA sequence of various disease-causing pathogens. These motifs are rare in vertebrate DNA, but abundant in bacterial and some viral DNAs. Because gene therapy generally involves the delivery of DNA from either plasmids of bacterial origin or recombinant viruses, an acute inflammatory response of variable severity inevitably results. The response is most serious for non-viral gene delivery vectors composed of cationic lipid–DNA complexes, producing adverse effects at lower doses and lethality at higher doses of complex. This review examines the role of immunostimulatory CpG motifs in the acute inflammatory response to non-viral gene therapy vectors. Strategies to neutralise or eliminate CpG motifs within plasmid DNA vectors, and the existing limitations of CpG reduction on improving the safety profile of non-viral vectors, will be discussed.