CT肺动脉成像诊断肺栓塞的一致性研究

目的评价CT肺动脉成像（CTPA）诊断肺栓塞（PE）时,不同经验的读片者间和同一读片者内的一致性。方法 55例临床可疑PE患者行CTPA检查,6位不同经验的放射科医生独立地分析CTPA图像来评价读片者间的一致性。3位放射科医生3个月后第二次分析CTPA图像来评价读片者内的一致性。PE的表现分为阳性、阴性和难以确定。读片者一致性用百分比及Kappa系数表示。结果 6位读片者判定29～31例（平均29.2例）患者CTPA为PE阳性,1～5例（平均3.0例）患者CTPA为难以确定。6位读片者在48例（87.3%）患者CTPA的诊断上取得一致意见,5位读片者在4例患者（7.3%）的诊断上取得一致意见,4位读片者在2例患者（3.6%）的诊断上取得一致意见,3位读片者在1例患者（1.8%）的诊断上取得一致意见。在诊断PE上,如果以每例患者为观察单位,读片者间的一致性＂非常好＂（Kappa值为0.91）。以每个肺动脉为观察单位,读片者间的一致性＂好＂（85%,Kappa值为0.74）;以肺叶动脉为观察单位,读片者间的一致性＂好＂（89%,Kappa值为0.78）;以肺段动脉为观察单位,读片者间的一致性＂中等＂（75%,Kappa值为0.59）。如果以每例患者为观察单位,同一读片者内的平均一致性＂非常好＂（96%,Kappa值为0.93）。结论在CTPA上诊断PE时,经验不同的读片者间和同一读片者内的一致性均较好。     

Prospective comparison of helical CT with angiography in pulmonary embolism: global and selective vascular territory analysis. Interobserver agreement

The objective of this prospective study was to evaluate the sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive values, and interobserver agreement in the diagnosis of pulmonary embolism with helical CT, compared with pulmonary angiography, for both global results and for selective vascular territories. Helical CT and pulmonary angiography were performed on 66 consecutive patients with clinical suspicion of pulmonary embolism. The exams were blindly interpreted by a vascular radiologist and by two independent thoracic radiologists. Results were analyzed for the final diagnosis as well as separately for 20 different arterial territories in each patient. Pulmonary angiography revealed embolism in 25 patients (38%); 48% were main, 28% lobar, 16% segmental, and 8% subsegmental. The sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values of helical CT for observer 1 were, respectively, 91, 81.5, 75, and 94%; in 7.5% of the patients the exam was considered indeterminate. For observer 2 the values were, respectively, 88, 86, 81.5, and 91%; in 9% of the patients the exam was considered indeterminate. Main arteries were considered as non-valuable in 0–0.8%, the lobar in 1.5%, the segmental in 7.5–8.5%, and the subsegmental in 55–60%. Interobserver agreement for the final diagnosis was 80% (kappa 0.65). For each vascular territory, this was 98% (kappa 0.91) for main arteries, 92% (kappa 0.78) for lobar arteries, 79% (kappa 0.56) for segmental arteries, and 59% (kappa 0.21) for subsegmental arteries. Helical CT is a reliable method for pulmonary embolism diagnosis, with good interobserver agreement for main, lobar, and segmental territories. Worse results are found for subsegmental arteries, with high incidence of non-valuable branches and poor interobserver agreement. Electronic Publication     

多层螺旋CT肺血管造影对肺栓塞解剖分布及形态的评价

目的 评价肺栓塞（PE）在多层螺旋CT肺血管造影（CTPA）上的解剖位置分布及形态特点. 资料与方法 75例PE患者作CTPA,由两名有经验的放射科医师阅片,根据血栓在最大肺血管分支内的位置分为5型：肺动脉干型、左或右肺动脉型、肺叶动脉型、肺段动脉型和肺亚段动脉型;同时观察血栓在血管内的形态. 结果 75例PE中,肺动脉干型6例（8%）,左或右肺动脉型12例（16%）,肺叶动脉型28例（37.3%）,肺段动脉型19例（25.3%）和肺亚段动脉型10例（13.3%）.PE形态为：中央型51例（68%）,附壁型7例（9.3%）,闭塞型17例（22.7%）. 结论 CTPA可准确、清晰地显示PE的解剖位置分布及形态,能提高小PE的检出率,为临床治疗方案的选择提供依据.     

Pulmonary embolism: optimization of small pulmonary artery visualization at multi-detector row CT

PURPOSE: To compare the frequency of well-visualized pulmonary arteries according to anatomic level by using different collimation with single- and multi-detector row computed tomography (CT) in patients suspected of having acute pulmonary embolism. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Sixty patients were examined with one of three techniques (20 patients each). Group 1 was examined with single-detector row CT with 3-mm collimation and 1.3-1.6 pitch; groups 2 and 3, with multi-detector row CT with 2.5- and 1.25-mm collimation, respectively. Three thoracic radiologists independently reviewed examination findings to determine if each main, lobar, segmental, and subsegmental artery was well visualized for presence of pulmonary embolism. chi2 tests were performed. For well-visualized vessels, the presence and/or absence of pulmonary embolism was recorded and kappa statistic was determined. RESULTS: Reader 1 scored 95% (114 of 120), 96% (115 of 120), and 99% (119 of 120) of lobar arteries (P >.05); 76% (304 of 400), 86% (346 of 400), and 91% (363 of 400) of segmental arteries (P <.001); and 37% (300 of 800), 56% (448 of 800), and 76% (608 of 800) of subsegmental arteries as well visualized (P <.001) using techniques 1, 2, and 3, respectively. Reader 2 scored 97% (116 of 120), 95% (114 of 120), and 99% (119 of 120) of lobar arteries (P >.05); 77% (308 of 400), 87% (349 of 400), and 93% (371 of 400) of segmental arteries (P <.001); and 39% (310 of 800), 53% (422 of 800), and 78% (621 of 800) of subsegmental arteries (P <.001) as well visualized using techniques 1, 2, and 3, respectively. Reader 3 scored 86% (103 of 120), 82% (98 of 120), and 91% (109 of 120) of lobar arteries (P >.05); 63% (252 of 400), 70% (280 of 400), and 85% (339 of 400) of segmental arteries (P <.001); and 39% (310 of 800), 56% (451 of 800), and 71% (572 of 800) of subsegmental arteries (P <.001) as well visualized using techniques 1, 2, and 3, respectively. Sixteen patients had pulmonary embolism. Interobserver agreement for detection of pulmonary embolism was significantly better for segmental and subsegmental arteries for all readers with technique 3 (segmental, kappa = 0.79-0.80; subsegmental, kappa = 0.71-0.76) than that with technique 1 (segmental, kappa = 0.47-0.75; subsegmental, kappa = 0.28-0.54). CONCLUSION: Multi-detector row CT at 1.25-mm collimation significantly improves visualization of segmental and subsegmental arteries and interobserver agreement in detection of pulmonary embolism.     

Suspected acute pulmonary embolism: evaluation with multi-detector row CT versus digital subtraction pulmonary arteriography

PURPOSE: To determine diagnostic accuracy of four-channel multi-detector row computed tomography (CT) in emergency room and inpatient populations suspected of having acute pulmonary embolism (PE) who prospectively underwent both CT and pulmonary arteriography (PA). MATERIALS AND METHODS: Patients referred for PA to assess suspected PE were eligible. Institutional review board approval and written informed consent were obtained. All patients underwent CT and PA within a 48-hour period. For CT, 4 x 2.5-mm collimation was used. Three readers independently evaluated each study for PE presence. PE status, vessel level, and lobar location were determined by means of majority rule, and interobserver agreement (kappa) was calculated for PE status, as assessed with each modality. Sensitivity and specificity of CT were calculated by using PA as the reference standard. Two radiologists later reviewed false-positive CT studies. RESULTS: The study group comprised 93 patients (median age, 56 years; range, 19-88 years). Sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy of CT were 100%, 89%, and 91%, respectively. kappa values were 0.71 and 0.83 for CT and PA, respectively, and were not significantly different between modalities. At PA, 18 patients (19%) had PE at 50 vessel levels (five main and/or interlobar, 24 segmental, and 21 subsegmental), 17 (94%) of which had PE at multiple sites. At CT, 26 patients (28%) had PE at 71 vessel levels (24 main and/or interlobar, 33 segmental, and 14 subsegmental). Twenty patients (77%) had PE at multiple sites. Review of eight false-positive CT studies showed an appearance highly suggestive of acute PE in three patients, chronic PE in one, and no PE in three; one study was inconclusive. CT better demonstrated large-level vessel involvement (P < .01), while PA better demonstrated small-level vessel involvement (P < .01). CONCLUSION: Multi-detector row CT has an accuracy of 91% in the depiction of suspected acute PE when conventional PA is used as the reference standard.     

Intraindividual comparison of gadolinium- and iodine-enhanced 64-slice multidetector CT pulmonary angiography for the detection of pulmonary embolism in a porcine model

This study is an evaluation of the diagnostic accuracy of gadolinium-enhanced computed tomography pulmonary angiography (CTPA) for the detection of pulmonary embolism (PE) in comparison with iodine-enhanced CTPA. PE was induced in five anesthetized pigs by administration of blood clots through an 11-F catheter inside the jugular vein. Animals underwent CTPA in breathhold with i.v. bolus injection of 50 ml gadopentetate dimeglumine (0.4 mmol/kg, 4 ml/s). Subsequently, CTPA was performed using the same imaging parameters but under administration of 70 ml nonionic iodinated contrast material (400 mg/ml, 4 ml/s). All images were reconstructed with 1 mm slice thickness. A consensus readout of the iodium-enhanced CTPAs by both radiologists served as reference standard. Gadolinium-enhanced CTPAs were evaluated independently by two experienced radiologists, and differences in detection rate between both contrast agents were assessed on a per embolus basis using the Wilcoxon signed-rank test. Interobserver agreement was determined by calculation of қ values. PE was diagnosed independently by both readers in all five pigs by the use of gadolinium-enhanced CTPA. Out of 60 pulmonary emboli detected in the iodine-enhanced scans, 47 (78.3%; reader 1) and 44 (62.8%; reader 2) emboli were detected by the use of gadolinium. All 13 (100%) emboli in lobar arteries (by both readers) and 26 (reader 1) and 25 (reader 2) out of 27 emboli (96.3% and 92.6%) in segmental arteries were detected by the use of the gadolinium-enhanced CTPA. In subsegmental arteries, only 8 (40%; reader 1) and 6 (30%; reader 2) out of 20 emboli were detected by the gadolinium-enhanced CTPA. By comparing both scans on a per vessel basis (Wilcoxon test), Gd-enhanced CTPA was significantly inferior in emboli detection on subsegmental level (P < 0.0001). The interobserver agreement was excellent on lobar and segmental level (қ = 1.0 and 0.93, respectively), whereas readers only reached moderate agreement for PE evaluation on subsegmental level (қ = 0.56). Compared to conventional CTPA with iodinated contrast media, gadolinium-based contrast agents achieve an equivalent diagnostic accuracy in detection of PE down to segmental level. Gadolinium-enhanced CTPA may be considered as an alternative for the diagnostic workup of acute pulmonary embolism in patients with contraindications to iodinated contrast agents.     

CT肺动脉成像诊断肺栓塞的读片者一致性研究

目的:评价CT肺动脉成像(CTPA)诊断肺栓塞(PE)时,不同经验的读片者间和同一读片者内的一致性.方法:55例临床可疑PE患者,作了CTPA检查,6位不同经验的放射科医生独立地分析CTPA图像来评价读片者间的一致性.3位放射科医生3个月后第二次分析CTPA图像来评价读片者内的一致性.PE的表现分为阳性、阴性和难以确定.读片者一致性用百分比及Kappa系数表示.结果:6位读片者判定29～31例(平均29.2例)患者CTPA为PE阳性,1～5例(平均3.0例)患者CTPA为难以确定.6位读片者在48例(87.3%)患者CTPA的诊断上取得一致意见,5位读片者在4例患者(7.3%)的诊断上取得一致意见,4位读片者在2例患者(3.6%)的诊断上取得一致意见,3位读片者在1例患者(1.8%)的诊断上取得一致意见.在诊断PE上,如果以每例患者为观察单位,读片者间的一致性"非常好"(Kappa值为0.91).以每个肺动脉为观察单位,读片者间的一致性"好"(85%,Kappa值为0.74);以肺叶动脉为观察单位,读片者间的一致性"好"(89%,Kappa值为0.78);以肺段动脉为观察单位,读片者间的一致性"中等"(75%,Kappa值为0.59).如果以每例患者为观察单位,同一读片者内的平均一致性"非常好"(96%,Kappa值为0.93).结论:在CTPA上诊断PE时,经验不同的读片者间和同一读片者内的一致性均较好.     

Multidetector row CT pulmonary angiography and indirect venography for the diagnosis of venous thromboembolic disease in intensive care unit patients

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: To determine the diagnostic quality, performance characteristics and interreader reliability of computed tomography pulmonary angiography (CTPA) and venography (CTV) in intensive care unit (ICU) patients with suspected venous thromboembolism (VTE). MATERIALS AND METHODS: A total of 100 consecutive ICU patient CT examinations performed for clinically suspected VTE on a four-row CT scanner were reviewed. Three readers rated the diagnostic quality of each CTPA and CTV examination as excellent, acceptable, or nondiagnostic. Readers scored the overall determination for pulmonary embolism (PE) and deep venous thrombosis (DVT) using a 5-point scale, and scored the determination for PE by anatomic level. Receiver operator characteristic (ROC) analysis was performed for each reader and the original clinical report, using consensus interpretation as the reference standard. Interobserver variability for PE and DVT was determined using kappa analysis, and was stratified by examination quality. RESULTS: A total of 25% of CTPA examinations were nondiagnostic, most commonly because of motion artifact and poor contrast opacification. A total of 24% of CTV examinations were nondiagnostic, most commonly because of poor contrast opacification and metallic hardware. Using receiver operating characteristic analysis, the areas under the curve (Az) for PE diagnosis were 0.875, 0.923, 0.888, and 0.674 for the three readers and clinical reading, respectively, and for DVT diagnosis were 0.842, 0.859, 0.952 and 0.669. Interobserver agreement for detection of PE was moderate at the supralobar level (kappa = 0.55), very good at the lobar level (kappa = 0.69), and moderate for segmental (kappa = 0.54) and subsegmental arteries (kappa = 0.44). Overall reader agreement was good for excellent/good quality CTPA examinations (kappa = 0.52-0.56), and poor when examination quality was poor (kappa = 0.06). CONCLUSIONS: CTPA and CTV are sufficiently accurate and reliable techniques for evaluating VTE in ICU patients, particularly in light of patient complexity.     

Pulmonary perfusion in acute pulmonary embolism: agreement of MRI and SPECT for lobar, segmental and subsegmental perfusion defects

Purpose: To assess prospectively the agreement of magnetic resonance (MR) pulmonary perfusion with single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) perfusion for perfusion defects down to the subsegmental level in patients with suspected pulmonary embolism (PE).

Material and Methods: In 41 patients with suspected PE, contrast-enhanced MR pulmonary perfusion (3D-FLASH, TR/TE 1.6/0.6 ms) was compared to SPECT perfusion on a per-examination basis as well as at the lobar, segmental, and subsegmental level.

Results: The MRI protocol was completed in all patients, and mean examination time was 3 min 56 s. MR perfusion showed a very high agreement with SPECT (kappa value per examination 0.98, and 0.98, 0.83, and 0.69 for lobar, segmental, and subsegmental perfusion defects, respectively). Of 15 patients with PE, MR perfusion detected 14 cases.

Conclusion: The very high agreement of MR perfusion with SPECT perfusion enables the detection of subtle findings in suspected PE.     

Diagnosis of pulmonary embolism: comparison of CT angiography and MR angiography in canines

PURPOSE: To compare the sensitivity and specificity of helical computed tomographic angiography (CTA), CTA with multiplanar reconstructions (MPR)/three-dimensional-shaded surface display (3D-SSD), and gadolinium-enhanced magnetic resonance angiography (MRA) for pulmonary embolism (PE) detection. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Gelatin sponge emboli were introduced into the femoral veins of seven dogs and conventional digital subtraction angiography (CA), CTA, and MRA performed. Images from CTA, CTA with MPR/3D-SSD, and MRA were reviewed for the presence of PE in lobar and segmental arteries, and subsegmental zones. Postmortem angiography and CA were the gold standard. RESULTS: There were 50 emboli in the 294 vessels/zones analyzed. The sensitivity of CTA for the two readers was 76% (95% confidence interval [CI]; 64%-88%) and 64% (95% CI; 50%-78%), and for the two MRA readers was 52% (95% CI; 38%-66%) and 48% (95% CI; 34%-62%). CTA was more sensitive than MRA when PE were subdivided by vessel caliber. Specificity was high for CTA and MRA among all readers (98.8%-99.6%). MPR/3D-SSD did not improve results of axial CT. MRA perfusion defects were 46% and 47% sensitive and 100% specific. Interobserver agreement was high for CTA and MRA (kappa 0.92 and 0.93, respectively). The average diameter of vessels with emboli was 3.7 mm +/- 1.06. CONCLUSION: Helical CTA is more sensitive than three-dimensional gadolinium-enhanced MRA for the detection of PE. Both CTA and MRA are highly specific for PE detection and demonstrate high interobserver agreement. MPR/3D-SSD did not increase CTA performance over axial images alone.     

Ventilation-perfusion lung scintigraphy as a guide for pulmonary angiography in the localization of pulmonary emboli.

PURPOSE: To assess the appropriateness of ventilation-perfusion (V-P) scintigraphic abnormalities as a guide to pulmonary angiography for the diagnosis of pulmonary embolism (PE). MATERIALS AND METHODS: V-P scintigrams and pulmonary angiograms of 104 patients with angiographically proved PE were reviewed by two nuclear medicine physicians and two interventional radiologists. For V-P scintigrams, the lung with the larger amount of perfusion abnormality was determined followed by identification of specific lobes. Pulmonary angiograms were similarly evaluated for lateralization and lobar distribution of PE. Conclusions were initially reached independently and subsequently by consensus. RESULTS: Interobserver agreement for lateralization was 88% (kappa = 0.75) for V-P scintigraphy and 98% (kappa = 0.96) for pulmonary angiography. In 72 patients, V-P scintigrams predicted unilateral embolus; 64 patients underwent pulmonary angiography of the suspected side. Eight patients underwent contralateral angiography only. Of the 64 patients, 61 (95%) had PE on the predicted side at angiography. V-P scintigrams predicted lobar distribution in 55 patients. Of these, PE was found in the predicted lobe in 42 (76%). CONCLUSION: Localization of perfusion abnormalities at V-P scintigraphy provides useful information for the interventional radiologist and serves as an accurate guide for determining the initial approach for pulmonary angiography.     

螺旋CT肺动脉造影对肺栓塞的诊断

目的：评价螺旋CT及其肺动脉造影诊断肺动脉栓塞（PE）的价值。方法：回顾性分析12例PE患,均行螺旋CT容积扫描,并在工作站进行图像后处理,获得肺动脉多平面重建图像及三维立体图像。结果：对12例196支肺动脉分支进行分析,受累率为46.4%;栓子发生在主肺动脉、左右肺动脉干及叶段肺动脉。多平面重建图像上表现为充盈对比剂血管内有充盈缺损区,或其远侧方无对比剂充填区。肺动脉成像示,主干血管内可见充盈缺损影,或呈截断状影;叶栓塞或段栓塞亦呈突然“截断状”,其远侧方肺动脉分支不显影或呈纤维状。结论：螺旋CT肺动脉造影不仅可以获得轴位图像,而且可以获得立体图像,可多轴向旋转观察PE部位,是诊断叶或段以上PE可靠而直观的检查方法。     

Pulmonary nodule detection with low-dose CT of the lung: agreement among radiologists

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of our study was to assess relative intra- and interobserver agreement in detecting pulmonary nodules when interpreting low-dose chest CT screening examinations. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Two hundred ninety-three selected low-dose CT examinations of the lung were independently interpreted by three radiologists to detect and classify pulmonary nodules. The data set selected was enriched with examinations depicting pulmonary nodules. A subset of 30 examinations was interpreted twice. All pulmonary nodules greater than 1.0 mm were marked. All nodules greater than 3.0 mm were marked, measured, and scored as to their probability of being benign or malignant. Nodule-based and examination-based relative reviewer agreements were evaluated using percentage of agreement and kappa statistics. Similar assessments were performed on the subset of examinations interpreted twice. RESULTS: The three radiologists identified a total of 470, 729, and 876 pulmonary nodules of which 395, 641, and 778 were rated as noncalcified with some level of suspicion for being malignant. Nodule-based interobserver agreement among the radiologists was poor (highest kappa value in a paired comparison, 0.120). Examination-based agreement was higher (highest kappa value in a paired comparison, 0.458). Intraobserver agreement was higher than interobserver agreement for examination-based agreement (highest kappa = 0.889) but lower for nodule-based agreement (highest kappa = -0.035). Agreement improved as the suspicion of malignancy increased. CONCLUSION: Unaided intra- and interobserver agreement in detecting pulmonary nodules in low-dose CT of the lung is relatively low. Computer-assisted detection may provide the consistency that is needed for this purpose.     

Prospective comparison of helical CT and MR imaging in clinically suspected acute pulmonary embolism

The purpose of this study is to compare sensitivity and specificity of helical CT and MR imaging for detecting acute pulmonary embolism (PE). Patients who were suspected clinically of having PE were randomly assigned to undergo either helical contrast-enhanced CT or gradient-echo MR (if one modality was contraindicated, the patient was assigned to the other). Patients were considered to have PE if they had: (1) high-probability V-Q scan and high clinical probability of PE; or (2) pulmonary angiogram positive for PE. Patients were considered not to have PE if they had either: (1) normal V-Q scan; (2) low probability V-Q scan and low clinical probability of PE; or (3) pulmonary angiogram negative for PE. The CT and MR images were read randomly and independently by five radiologists with varying levels of CT and MR experience. Twenty eight patients underwent CT and 25 MR. A total of 21 patients underwent pulmonary angiography (6 had PE, 15 did not have PE). Of the other 32 patients, 15 had high probability scan/high clinical probability and 17 had low probability scan/low clinical probability. For the five observers, the average sensitivity of CT was 75% and of MR 46%; the average specificity of CT was 89% and of MR 90%. Experience with vascular MR and enhanced CT influenced diagnostic accuracy. For the two vascular MR experts, average sensitivity and specificity of MR were 71% and 97%, and of CT 73% and 97%. In this pilot study, when CT and MR were interpreted with comparable expertise, they had similar accuracy for detecting pulmonary embolism.     

ECG-gated multislice spiral CT for diagnosis of acute pulmonary embolism

AIM: The purpose of this study was to determine the feasibility of echocardiogram (ECG)-gated multi-slice CT angiography (MCTA) in patients with clinical suspicion of acute venous thromboembolism (VTE), to investigate the effect of ECG-gating on cardiac motion artefacts, and to determine the diagnostic reader agreement of ECG-gated MCTA in comparison with conventional MCTA. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Forty-eight consecutive patients were prospectively enrolled and randomly underwent ECG-gated (n=25, group 1) or non-ECG-gated (n=23, group 2) eight-slice pulmonary MCTA. Image data were evaluated by three independent chest radiologists with respect to the presence or absence of emboli at different arterial levels (main, lobar, segmental, and subsegmental arteries), and with regard to cardiac motion artefacts. Statistical tests used to calculate inter-observer agreement were weighted kappa statistics, extended kappa statistics and confidence indices indicating three-reader agreement accuracy. RESULTS: Twenty-seven patients (56.3%) were diagnosed to have pulmonary embolism (13 from group 1, 14 from group 2). Cardiac motion artefacts were significantly more frequent in group 2 (70% in group 2 versus 13% in group 1, p=0.0001). The overall diagnostic agreement was excellent with both MCTA techniques (three-reader confidence index for all vascular territories: 0.76 and 0.84 for groups 1 and 2, respectively (extended kappa=0.69 and 0.78, respectively); three-reader confidence index for diagnosis of VTE: 0.94 and 0.85 for groups 1 and 2, respectively (extended kappa=0.91 and 0.73, respectively), weighted kappa=0.81-0.83 and 0.92-0.95 for groups 1 and 2, respectively, and did not differ significantly between the two groups. In addition there was no significant difference of inter-observer agreement in either group at any assessed pulmonary arterial level. CONCLUSION: ECG-gated pulmonary MCTA is feasible in patients with clinical suspicion of VTE. However, ECG-gated image acquisition did not influence the diagnostic reader agreement accuracy and inter-observer agreement of MCTA. Hence, it does not appear to be advantageous for the MCTA diagnosis of pulmonary embolism.     

Multidetector computed tomography (MDCT) in the diagnosis of pulmonary embolism: interobserver agreement among radiologists with varied levels of experience

Purpose: To assess the interobserver variability of radiologists with varied levels of experience in the interpretation of multidetector computed tomography (MDCT) pulmonary angiographies.

Material and Methods: Review of CT pulmonary angiographies performed on patients included in a diagnostic study evaluating a decision-based algorithm for diagnosing pulmonary embolism (PE). Five radiologists, three board-certified general radiologists and two radiology trainees with 2 years' experience, participated in the study.

Results: According to the consensus reading, PE was present in 91 (31%) and absent in 194 (67%) patients, while in five patients (1.7%) the interpretations were regarded as equivocal. The per-patient agreement on the diagnosis of PE achieved by each of the four readers compared to the consensus reading was very good (κ range 0.85-0.92), but peripheral emboli were missed in four to six patients by three of four observers. The agreement on the most proximal level of PE (per-proximal level) assessed by mean κ value was 0.83 (κ range 0.68-0.91) for the detection of proximal emboli, 0.61 for segmental emboli (κ range 0.40-0.80), and 0.38 for emboli in the subsegmental vessels (κ range 0.0-0.89).

Conclusion: The overall agreement on the diagnosis of PE by MDCT for general radiologists and radiology trainees is very good, and we therefore believe that the initial management of patients with suspected PE could be based on the preliminary assessment performed by on-call radiologists with 2 years of experience.     

Evaluation of pulmonary embolisms using coronal reformations on 64-row multidetector-row computed tomography: Comparison with axial images

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate coronal reformations of the chest on 64-row multidetector-row computed tomography (MDCT) for detection of pulmonary embolisms compared with axial images. METHODS: Thirty-eight consecutive patients who underwent pulmonary computed tomography angiography (CTA) on 64-row MDCT for a suspected pulmonary embolism were retrospectively studied. Contiguous 2-mm axial and coronal images were reviewed independently. A pulmonary embolism was assessed in the main, lobar, or segmental pulmonary arteries and was scored using a 5-point scale. RESULTS: A pulmonary embolism was demonstrated in 10% (4 of 38) of axial images and 16% (6 of 38) of coronal images. Interpretation was concordant in 95% to 100% of cases for a main or lobar pulmonary embolism and in 80% to 82% of cases for a segmental pulmonary embolism. Agreement of scores was almost perfect for a a main or lobar pulmonary embolism (mean weighted kappa value = 0.969) and moderate to good for a segmental pulmonary embolism (mean weighted kappa value = 0.560). CONCLUSION: Coronal reformations of the chest on 64-row MDCT were as informative as axial images for the detection of main, lobar, and segmental pulmonary embolisms.     

Comparison of radiologist and CAD performance in the detection of CT-confirmed subtle pulmonary nodules on digital chest radiographs

OBJECTIVES: Detection of subtle pulmonary nodules on digital radiography is a challenging task for radiologists. The aim of this study was to evaluate the performance of a newly approved computer aided detection (CAD) system. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The sensitivity of 3 radiologists and of a CAD system for the detection of pulmonary nodules from 5 to 15 mm in size on digital chest radiography of 117 patients was compared. The reference standard was established by consensus reading of computed tomography scans by 2 experienced radiologists. Computed tomography scans and chest radiographs were performed within 4 weeks. Sixty-six pulmonary nodules from 42 patients, with a mean nodule diameter of 7.5 mm (standard deviation: 2.2 mm), were included in the statistical analysis. Seventy-five of the 117 patients did not have nodules from 5 to 15 mm of size. RESULTS: Two hundred and eighty-eight false-positive detections of the CAD system were found with an average of 2.5 false-positives per image. Sensitivity of the CAD system was 39.4% (95% confidence interval: 11.8%), when compared with 18.2% to 30.3% (95% confidence interval 9.3% to 11.1%) of the 3 radiologists. Substantial agreement for nodule detection ([kappa]N: 0.64-0.73) was found among the 3 radiologists, whereas only moderate agreement was found between the radiologists and the CAD performance ([kappa]N: 0.45-0.52). CONCLUSIONS: The CAD system's diagnostic sensitivity in detecting pulmonary nodules of 5 to 15 mm of size was superior to the 1 of radiologists. The CAD system may be used for assisting the radiologist in the detection of lung nodules on digital chest radiographs.     

Pulmonary embolism detection: prospective evaluation of dual-section helical CT versus selective pulmonary arteriography in 157 patients

PURPOSE: To evaluate the accuracy of dual-section helical computed tomography (CT) in acute pulmonary embolism (PE) diagnosis. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Of 204 consecutive patients with clinically suspected acute PE (mean age, 58 years +/- 14 [SD]), 158 were enrolled. All patients underwent dual-section helical CT (2.7-mm effective section thickness) and selective pulmonary arteriography within 12 hours of each other. Each image was analyzed independently by two observers, who determined image quality and presence of PE among arterial segments, including at the subsegmental level. The final diagnosis was made with consensus. RESULTS: Selective pulmonary arteriography was considered optimal in 147 (93%), suboptimal in 10 (6%), and inconclusive in one (0.6%) of 158 patients. Dual-section helical CT findings were considered technically optimal in 140 (89%), suboptimal in 11 (7%), and inconclusive in six (4%). Selective pulmonary arteriography demonstrated PE in 62 patients. Four (6%) of 62 patients had isolated subsegmental PE. The sensitivity of dual-section helical CT was 90%, and the specificity was 94%. The positive and negative predictive values were 90% and 94%, respectively. CONCLUSION: Dual-section helical CT is an improvement in helical CT that offers a high sensitivity and specificity for the depiction of PE, including at the subsegmental level. Dual-section helical CT can replace pulmonary arteriography for the direct demonstration of PE in a majority of patients.     

Detection of pulmonary embolism using 16-slice multidetector-row computed tomography: evaluation of different image reconstruction parameters

OBJECTIVE: To compare different image reconstruction parameters for detecting emboli of the pulmonary arteries according to anatomic levels using 16-slice multidetector-row computed tomography in patients suspected of having an acute pulmonary embolism (PE). METHODS: Sixty-two patients (33 male and 29 female) with a clinically suspected acute PE were included in the present study. Multidetector-row computed tomography scans were performed using 16-mmx0.75-mm collimation. Based on the computed tomography data set, different image reconstruction parameters were used for each patient: axial slice thicknesses (STs) of 0.75, 2, 4, and 6 mm; axial maximum intensity projection (MIP) STs of 4 mm; and coronal STs of 2 and 4 mm. In joint reading fashion, 2 experienced radiologists reviewed examination findings regarding the presence and/or absence of a PE. The reference standard for visualization and detection of PEs was defined using the axial images with a 0.75-mm ST. RESULTS: In 23 of 62 patients, a PE was diagnosed. For main and lobar pulmonary arteries, the sensitivities and specificities were as follows: axial 2-mm images, 1.0/1.0; axial 4-mm images, 1.0/1.0; axial 6-mm images, 0.97/0.99; MIP 4-mm images, 0.95/0.99; coronal 2-mm images, 1.0/1.0; and coronal 4-mm images, 1.0/1.0. Regarding segmental and subsegmental pulmonary arteries, sensitivity and specificity varied: axial 2-mm images, 0.97/1.0; axial 4-mm images, 0.81/0.99; axial 6-mm images, 0.65/0.99; axial MIP 4-mm images, 0.63/0.99; coronal 2-mm images, 0.91/0.99; and coronal 4-mm images, 0.74/0.99. CONCLUSIONS: In detecting segmental and subsegmental PEs, only the axial images with an ST of 2 mm proved to have results comparable with the axial 0.75-mm images. Therefore, thin-slice collimation and ST are mandatory for visualization of segmental and subsegmental PEs in patients suspected of having an acute PE.