Traumatic Shoulder Dislocation With Combined Bankart Lesion and Humeral Avulsion of the Glenohumeral Ligament in a Professional Basketball Player: Three-Year Follow-up of Surgical Stabilization

Traumatic anterior shoulder instability has been well documented to have associated lesions such as a Bankart tear, humeral avulsion of the glenohumeral ligament (HAGL), Hill-Sachs lesion, fracture, and nerve injury. To our knowledge, the combined Bankart and HAGL injury in a single acute anterior shoulder dislocation has not yet been reported. We describe a traumatic first-time anterior-inferior shoulder dislocation in a professional basketball player with a combined Bankart and HAGL lesion. The patient underwent arthroscopic Bankart repair followed by open repair of the HAGL lesion with an open capsular shift reconstruction. At 3 years' follow-up, the patient had returned to an elite level of play, with an excellent outcome.     

Humeral avulsion of glenohumeral ligaments as a cause of anterior shoulder instability

The avulsion of the glenohumeral ligament labral complex at the glenoid (Bankart lesion), as well as ligamentous laxity are well known causes of anterior shoulder instability. A lesser known entity, the humeral avulsion of glenohumeral ligaments (HAGL), was studied to determine its incidence and its role in anterior glenohumeral instability. Sixty-four shoulders with the diagnosis of anterior instability were prospectively evaluated by arthroscopy for intraarticular pathology, including Bankart, capsular laxity, and HAGL lesions. Six shoulders were found to have HAGL lesions (9.3%), 11 shoulders with generalized capsular laxity (17.2%), and 47 shoulders with Bankart lesions (73.5%). In patients with documented anterior instability without a demonstratable “primary” Bankart lesion, a HAGL lesion should be ruled out. This lesion is readily recognized arthroscopically, and an appropriate repair of this lesion can restore anterior stability to the patient. The pathological anatomy of the HAGL lesion and our treatment of this lesion is discussed.     

HAGL lesion occurring after successful arthroscopic Bankart repair

Recurrent traumatic anterior shoulder instability following surgical repair may be associated with implant failure and an array of capsulolabral pathology including separation of the labrum (Bankart lesion), humeral avulsion of the glenohumeral ligaments (HAGL lesion), and capsular rupture. We detail a previously unreported case of a HAGL lesion occurring in a shoulder with an intact arthrosopic Bankart repair following an additional traumatic event. Anatomic repair of this subsequent injury resulted in an excellent outcome. The patient returned to his high-demand ski racing activities without any shoulder limitation.Arthroscopy: The Journal of Arthroscopic and Related Surgery, Vol 17, No 2 (February), 2001: pp 206–208     

Anterior shoulder instability with humeral avulsion of the glenohumeral ligament lesion

Humeral avulsion of the glenohumeral ligament (HAGL) is a rare lesion. The purpose of this study was to analyze the clinical manifestations of HAGL lesions in patients who underwent operative treatment for anterior shoulder instability. Six patients with HAGL lesions were studied. Four patients had an HAGL lesion associated with a Bankart lesion, and two had an isolated HAGL lesion. The range of motion at final follow-up showed a loss of 1 degree in forward flexion and of 15 degrees in external rotation. During an operation to treat anterior shoulder instability, a thorough examination for not only Bankart lesions but also other associated lesions, including an HAGL lesion, should be considered to lower the risk of redislocation. In repairing an HAGL lesion, the surgeon should keep in mind the possibility of a postoperative loss of external rotation and follow an active rehabilitation protocol to obtain successful results.     

Anterior instability of the glenohumeral joint with humeral avulsion of the glenohumeral ligament. A review of 41 cases

We studied retrospectively a consecutive series of 547 shoulders in 529 patients undergoing operation for instability. In 41, the cause of instability was considered to be lateral avulsion of the capsule, including the inferior glenohumeral ligament, from the neck of the humerus, the HAGL lesion. In 35, the lesion was found at first exploration, whereas in six it was noted at revision of a previous failed procedure. In both groups, the patients were older on average than those with instability from other causes. Of the primary cases, in 33 (94.3%) the cause of the first dislocation was a violent injury; six (17.4%) had evidence of damage to the rotator cuff and/or the subscapularis. Only four (11.4%) had a Bankart lesion. In patients undergoing a primary operation in whom the cause of the first dislocation was a violent injury, who did not have a Bankart lesion and had no suggestion of multidirectional laxity, the incidence of HAGL was 39%.     

The HAGL lesion: An arthroscopic technique for repair of humeral avulsion of the glenohumeral ligaments

Glenoid avulsion of the capsulolabral complex and associated capsular laxity are well-described results of traumatic anterior dislocation. A less common consequence of traumatic anterior instability is the humeral avulsion of the glenohumeral ligaments (HAGL) lesion. An understanding of the arthroscopic pathoanatomy of the HAGL lesion will assist the surgeon in recognizing this uncommon entity. We describe a suture anchor technique for arthroscopic repair of HAGL lesions that anatomically reapproximates the torn edge of the glenohumeral ligament complex to its humeral head insertion. The technique is technically straightforward and does not require special equipment beyond that typical for arthroscopic labral repairs.     

Primärstabilität des Kapsel-Labrum-Komplexes nach Rekonstruktion mit Mitek-Bioknotless-Fadenankern am humanen Schulterkadavermodell

Background

This study examines the postoperative stability of the Mitek Bioknotless anchor system with biomechanical draw-out pulling in human cadaver shoulders.

Method

With simulation of anterior shoulder dislocation a test group (n=10, Ø 45 years) was tested against a native group (n=8, Ø 47 years). All shoulders were dissected up to the passive stabilizers. In the test group an artificial Bankart lesion was created and repaired with three Mitek Bioknotless anchors. The humeri of both groups were fixed in 60° glenohumeral abduction and 90° external rotation and then dislocated in a ventral direction. For evaluation purposes the ultimate draw-out strength, mode of failure, translation of humeral head, capsular slope, and bone density in the test group were measured.

Results

In the test group the ultimate strength was a median of 937 N (min. 554 N, max. 1,294 N) with 28 bony anchor dislocations, 1 suture rupture, and 1 capsular rupture, and in the native group with 6 Bankart and 2 HAGL lesions it was 1,214 N (708 N, 1,471 N). The bone density showed a positive correlation to the draw-out strength regarding cortical density and total density.

Conclusion

Regarding the high draw-out strength the Mitek Bioknotless anchor system provides enough stability for early functional treatment.     

Arthroscopic treatment of instability attributable to capsular injury or laxity

Among the many causes of shoulder instability are traumatic capsular injury associated with the Bankart lesion and capsular laxity as seen in multidirectional instability. Previously, open surgical procedures were the most commonly accepted surgical treatment of these disorders. However, because of the foresight of surgeons such as Richard Caspari, arthroscopy rapidly is becoming the surgical treatment of choice. Current studies have shown a 97% satisfactory outcome of arthroscopic Bankart repair. Similarly, the arthroscopic treatment of multidirectional instability has produced a 93% satisfactory outcome. These results parallel the gold standard open surgical techniques of the past and subsequently have led to a change in the treatment of shoulder instability.     

Kinematics of the glenohumeral joint with bankart lesion and repair

A Bankart repair is performed to reduce abnormal translations of the humeral head on the glenoid due to a Bankart lesion, a separation of the capsulolabral complex from the glenoid rim. However, this is often accompanied by a loss of rotational range of motion that may lead to decreased function and osteoarthritis. This loss of rotation, coupled to the goal of reducing humeral translations, may be a result of the amount of imbrication of the capsule during repair. To determine the effects of capsular imbrication, we investigated how two Bankart repairs (2.5 and 5.0 mm of capsular imbrication) and a Bankart lesion altered the translations and rotations of the human glenohumeral joint in vitro. Coupled moments were applied to the unconstrained humerus in abduction-adduction, in flexion-extension, and to simulate the cocked phase of throwing. Motion was measured with an electromagnetic system. There were no differences in the kinematics betweenthe intact specimens and those with a Bankart lesion or between normal specimens and the first (2.5 mm) Bankart repair. The first repair significantly reduced external rotation for the cocked phase of throwing compared with the Bankart lesion: from 46.8 ± 23.6° to 32.4 ± 14.2° (±SD). The second (5.0 mm) Bankart repair produced significantly different posterior translation (-4.7 ± 3.9 mm) of the humeral head relative to the glenoid compared with normal (5.1 ± 4.7 mm anterior) and the first repair (6.1 ± 8.3 mm anterior), as the humerus moved from full flexion to full extension. Differences were also found for all rotations in the cocked phase of throwing. For the second repair, the humerus extended 24.3° and externally rotated 18.6° less than normal and was abducted 15.4° more. These results indicate that both Bankart repairs do little to affect humeral translations with unconstrained moment loading but that rotations are affected during the cocked phase of throwing, with significant losses of external and extension rotations.     

Modern concepts in arthroscopic Bankart repair

The purpose of this report is to review recent advances in Bankart repair that allow it to be performed arthroscopically. Metallic implants in the form of staples, screws, or rivets were used initially, but problems with loosening of implants has prompted development of alternative devices and techniques. A modified form of the transglenoid suturing technique used in open Bankart repair has been used successfully but is associated with an increased risk of soft tissue complications. The use of absorbable tacks avoids some of the complications associated with this approach, but the ability to advance the capsule to reduce the volume is limited. Recently, the use of suture anchors has been described for arthroscopic Bankart lesion repair. However, the ability of these anchoring systems to advance and reduce the capsular volume is limited, and the arthroscopic techniques are technically demanding. One particularly innovative suture anchor system uses a bioabsorbable suture anchor with an integrated suture passing system. This self-contained implant allows multiple passes with suture through the capsule, followed by attachment to the glenoid with the bioabsorbable anchor. This procedure allows the capsule to be advanced by passing suture through before it is anchored to the glenoid, thereby reducing capsular volume to help restore shoulder stability.     

New secure suture relay technique for arthroscopic Bankart repair without making an additional working portal

Bankart repair is more frequently performed arthroscopically these days. To do this, an additional working portal is usually necessary, especially for repair of the badly damaged labrum or capsular ligaments using various types of relay techniques. We have devised a suture relay technique to perform arthroscopic Bankart repair using suture anchors without making any additional working portal. This is advantageous not only cosmetically, but also in terms of cost because only a simple device is required. This technique can be applied to almost any type of Bankart lesion repair as well as the plication of the capsule or SLAP lesion repair.     

Die arthroskopische Bankart-Operation mit Hilfe von resorbierbaren Nahtankern

OBJECTIVE: Arthroscopic refixation of the labrum-ligament complex at the glenoid. INDICATIONS: Posttraumatic anterior or anterior-inferior shoulder instability with Bankart or ALPSA lesion (anterior labral periosteal sleeve avulsion). CONTRAINDICATIONS: Atraumatic shoulder instability. Instabilities due to blunted or frayed degeneration of the labrum-ligament complex. HAGL lesion (humeral avulsion of the glenohumeral ligaments) with humeral detachment of the glenohumeral ligaments. Larger bony glenoid defects. SURGICAL TECHNIQUE: Mobilization of the labrum-ligament complex from the neck of the glenoid, superior tightening and refixation at the glenoid rim with the aid of absorbable suture anchors. POSTOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT: Immobilization of the affected arm for 4 weeks in an immobilization bandage with abduction pillows. Daily pendulum exercises. Active flexion up to 70 degrees and abduction up to 40 degrees, all in neutral or internal rotation. Avoidance of external rotation for a total of 6 weeks. RESULTS: From January 1999 to December 2001, 58 patients with a Bankart or ALPSA lesion were treated with arthroscopic shoulder stabilization using absorbable suture anchors and slowly absorbable braided sutures. 56 patients underwent a follow-up clinical examination after, on average, 31 months (24-48 months). None of these patients had suffered more than five shoulder dislocations before the operation (average 2.8). Of the intraoperative lesions, a plain Bankart lesion was present in twelve patients (21.4%), 44 patients had an ALPSA lesion (78.6%), of which one in two were combined with an SLAP 2 or SLAP 3 lesion (superior labrum from anterior to posterior). In the evaluation using the Rowe Score, there was an excellent result for 40 patients (71.4%), and a good result for twelve (21.4%). Four patients suffered a repeat dislocation and were therefore classified as poor results (7.2%).     

Comparison between arthroscopy and arthrotomy in the treatment of shoulder instability

Anterior post-traumatic shoulder instability represents a common finding in orthopaedic surgery. The surgical treatment of this lesion is often indispensable for the normal social life of the patient and for the sports activity of the young. The Bankart procedure with capsular retensioning by arthrotomic access has for years been the gold standard. In the last 10 years arthroscopic accesses have gained more and more consent for the surgical treatment of such lesions, with results that have considerably improved in time. It is the purpose of this study to compare the results obtained in patients affected with anterior-inferior post-traumatic shoulder instability treated by Bankart surgery, arthrotomic and arthroscopic, with a minimum follow-up of 4 years.     

Biomechanical Comparison of the Latarjet Procedure with and without Capsular Repair

Background

The purpose of this study was to determine if capsular repair used in conjunction with the Latarjet procedure results in significant alterations in glenohumeral rotational range of motion and translation.

Methods

Glenohumeral rotational range of motion and translation were measured in eight cadaveric shoulders in 90° of abduction in both the scapular and coronal planes under the following four conditions: intact glenoid, 20% bony Bankart lesion, modified Latarjet without capsular repair, and modified Latarjet with capsular repair.

Results

Creation of a 20% bony Bankart lesion led to significant increases in anterior and inferior glenohumeral translation and rotational range of motion (p < 0.005). The Latarjet procedure restored anterior and inferior stability compared to the bony Bankart condition. It also led to significant increases in glenohumeral internal and external rotational range of motion relative to both the intact and bony Bankart conditions (p < 0.05). The capsular repair from the coracoacromial ligament stump to the native capsule did not significantly affect translations relative to the Latarjet condition; however it did cause a significant decrease in external rotation in both the scapular and coronal planes (p < 0.005).

Conclusions

The Latarjet procedure is effective in restoring anteroinferior glenohumeral stability. The addition of a capsular repair does not result in significant added stability; however, it does appear to have the effect of restricting glenohumeral external rotational range of motion relative to the Latarjet procedure performed without capsular repair.     

Pathomorphologie der Schulterinstabilität

In cases of a traumatic anterior first-time dislocation of the shoulder, pathomorphological changes may initially occur at three different sites: at the capsule itself, at its origin or at its insertion. The typical injury is an avulsion of the labrum and the capsule from the glenoid and is called a Bankart lesion. There is a tendency to underestimate the amount of plastic deformation of the capsule and alternative injuries, such as avulsion of the capsule from the humeral head (HAGL lesion). Bony deformities at the humeral head or at the glenoid are of utmost importance for the prognosis of shoulder instability. In the dislocated position the anterior glenoid rim may notch the posterior surface of the humeral head (Hill-Sachs lesion). Bony defects of the glenoid may be caused by a fracture or due to chronic wear (fracture or erosion type). If bony defects exceed a certain size, isolated reconstruction of soft tissues does not guarantee stability of the shoulder.     

Combined Posterior Bankart Lesion and Posterior Humeral Avulsion of the Glenohumeral Ligaments Associated With Recurrent Posterior Shoulder Instability

Recurrent posterior glenohumeral instability is uncommon and is often misdiagnosed. Damage to the posterior capsule, posteroinferior glenohumeral ligament, and posterior labrum have all been implicated as sources of traumatic posterior instability. We describe a case of traumatic recurrent posterior instability resulting from a posterior Bankart lesion accompanied by posterior humeral avulsion of the glenohumeral ligaments. The Bankart lesion was repaired using a single arthroscopic suture anchor at the glenoid articular margin. The posterior humeral avulsion of the glenohumeral ligaments was addressed with 3 suture anchors placed at the capsular origin at the posterior humeral head. Using these anchors, the posterior capsule was advanced laterally and superiorly for a secure repair. Arthroscopic anatomic reconstruction of both lesions resulted in an excellent clinical outcome.     

Modification of Bankart reconstruction with lateral capsulotomy and selective anatomic repair using suture anchors

Twenty consecutive patients (17 male, 3 female) with a diagnosis of traumatic recurrent anterior instability of the shoulder were treated by a modified Bankart procedure using suture anchors. The technique consists of vertical incision of the capsule, just medial to the lateral insertion on the humerus and anatomic repair of the Bankart lesion. Humeral-based capsular shifting was performed in patients with anterior-inferior instability. The average age was 24 years (range: 14 to 39 years), and average follow-up period 68 months (range: 2 to 8 years). The average Bankart rating score was 92.5 (range: 70 to 100); with 16 (80%) excellent (score 90 to 100), 2 (10%) good (score 75 to 89), and 2 (10%) fair results. Failure in terms of recurrent dislocation was not reported. Eleven patients (55%) had a loss of 5 degrees to 10 degrees of external rotation either with the extremity at the side or at 90 degrees of abduction. Nine (45%) patients had external rotation equal to the contralateral side. We believe selective anatomic Bankart reconstruction by lateral capsulotomy and humeral-based capsular shifting in cases with marked inferior laxity is a more anatomic and physiologic technique.     

Capsular Tear in Line With the Inferior Glenohumeral Ligament: A Cause of Anterior Glenohumeral Instability in 2 Patients

Anterior glenohumeral instability typically involves lesions associated with the inferior glenohumeral ligament complex. Multiple lesions have been described in this setting, including Bankart, humeral avulsion of the inferior glenohumeral ligament complex, and mid-substance capsular tears. These lesions are indicative of the high-force traumatic nature of anterior shoulder dislocation. Two cases of recurrent anterior shoulder instability are presented with a capsular tear perpendicular to the usual orientation and not consistent to the amount of force involved in a dislocation. Arthroscopy revealed a capsular defect from the glenoid to the humeral head in the anterior inferior glenohumeral ligamentous complex in both. This lesion is an unusual circumstance, providing another pathology to include in the differential diagnosis of anterior glenohumeral instability.     

Which labral lesion can be best reduced with external rotation of the shoulder after a first-time traumatic anterior shoulder dislocation?

Introduction  Immobilization in external rotation after a first-time traumatic anterior shoulder dislocation has been shown to improve the position of the labroligamentous lesion relative to the glenoid rim. The purpose of the present study was to evaluate the effect of the external rotation position of the shoulder on different types of labroligamentous lesions in patients with first-time traumatic anterior shoulder dislocation by using MRI. Patients and methods  We performed a standardized MRI in internal and external rotation of the shoulder after initial reduction in 34 patients with a first-time traumatic anterior shoulder dislocation. Labroligamentous lesions were classified as Bankart, Perthes, or nonclassifiable. Four distinct grades were used to classify the amount of plastic deformation of the anterior labroligamentous structures. The position of the labrum was defined relative to the tip of the glenoid rim by measuring the dislocation and separation. Results  In all patients, dislocation and separation of the labrum relative to the rim of the glenoid were significantly improved in shoulders in the external rotation position compared to those in the internal rotation position. We observed 15 Bankart, 15 Perthes, and 4 non-classifiable lesions. No HAGL or GLAD lesions were found. Fourteen patients showed a plastic deformation grade I, 16 showed grade II, 3 showed grade III, and 1 showed grade IV. In regression analysis, the odds ratio was 1.100 for the type of lesion and 1.660 for the grade of plastic deformation. Perthes lesions (with an intact anterior scapular periosteum) and grade I plastic deformations showed the best labral reduction on the external rotation MRI. Conclusion  Placing the shoulder in external rotation after a first-time traumatic shoulder dislocation, significantly improves the position of the labroligamentous lesion on the glenoid rim. Perthes lesions that showed a low grade of plastic deformation displayed better reduction in external rotation and then compared to Bankart or other lesions that showed a high grade of plastic deformation. In conclusion, immobilization of the shoulder after a first-time traumatic shoulder dislocation is most effective in patients with Perthes lesions that show low grade plastic deformation.     

Humeral avulsion of glenohumeral ligaments

Humeral avulsion of glenohumeral ligaments (HAGL) is an increasingly recognized cause of recurrent shoulder instability. HAGL lesions are the result of acute traumatic glenohumeral subluxation or dislocation. Anterior avulsion of the inferior glenohumeral ligament from the humeral neck is the more common lesion; however, posterior lesions are seen as well. Careful history and physical examination are critical in the diagnosis of HAGL lesions. MRI is the best imaging study for diagnosing these lesions. Injection of intra-articular contrast dye aids in visualization. Most HAGL lesions cause recurrent instability and require surgical repair. Arthroscopic repair with the use of accessory portals has yielded promising results. Excellent results have been achieved with open surgical management using a subscapularis incision. Mini-open techniques involve limited incision in the lower one half of the subscapularis.