Relapse rates following cessation of chemotherapy during complete remission of acute lymphocytic leukemia

The therapeutic benefit of maintenance chemotherapy beyond three years for children with acute lymphocytic leukemia (ALL) in continuous complete remission was evaluated by the investigators of Childrens Cancer Study Group (CCSG). Two hundred and twenty leukemic children in first remission for three years or longer and who had received at least three years of continuous chemotherapy were eligible. One hundred and one patients were randomized to either continue chemotherapy for an additional three years or to discontinue therapy, and 119 patients nonrandomly continued or discontinued therapy. The patients had received a variety of chemotherapy regimens. The study period extended from April 1970 until December 1977, with a median follow-up time of 25 months. Relapses occurred in 15 randomized patients (15%). Randomized patients remaining on chemotherapy experienced a statistically significant lower relapse rate than patients randomized to discontinue therapy. Also among randomized patients, bone marrow relapse was signicantly more frequent in males than in females. Considering the total patient group, age and white blood count at diagnosis had no significance in predicting relapse. Of relapse events in males, 21% were isolated testicular relapses, identifying the testicle as a major risk site in males completing three years of continuous complete remission. This study demonstrates that continuing chemotherapy beyond three years results in a significant prolongation of remission in males, although the eventual survival outcome for later discontinuance of therapy will require longer follow-up.     

Acute myelogenous leukemia in children: a preliminary report of combination chemotherapy.

Twenty-four children (2 to 21 years) diagnosed as having AML from 1969 to 1972 were randomized to receive either a single combination (COMP or PRAVD) or sequential combination chemotherapy (alternating POMP and PRAVD). Seventeen achieved complete remission. Patients who received POMP alone had the longest median duration of remission (1,400 days) compared to PRAVD (395 days) or POMP-PRAVD (270 days); interpretation of this difference is uncertain, since the numbers in each group are small. Fifteen patients have relapsed, four initially with CNS involvement. Successful reinduction was achieved almost exclusively for patients who had initially received POMP. Survival after first relapse was short. Patients less than 16 years had a median survival of 632 days, compared to 285 days for patiens greater than 16 (p less than 0.05). The high initial induction rate in these patients is encouraging, but the duration remission is inferior to that seen in childhood ALL. Moreover, the slope of the relapse curve is continuous over a five-year period with no definite plateau where it might appear that patients are no longer at risk of relapse. Improved methods for the treatment of childhood ALL and adult AML suggest possible new approaches to AML in children, with prophylactic treatment of central nervous system, late intensification, and immunotherapy.     

A randomized study of intermittent chemotherapy with or without BCG inoculation in maintenance therapy of childhood ALL

One hundred ninety-six children with acute lymphocytic leukemia were entered into a randomized study of maintenance chemotherapy with either intermittent chemotherapy and immunotherapy with bacillus Calmette-Guerin (BCG) or only intermittent chemotherapy. On admission to the study, patients were stratified into three prognostic categories on the basis of clinical and laboratory features at presentation. Patients considered to have a favorable prognosis (PF) were induced with vincristine and prednisone; those with an unfavorable prognosis (PU) received combination chemotherapy consisting of either Ara-C, cyclophosphamide and asparaginase, or vincristine, prednisolone, and daunomycin followed by Ara-C and asparaginase; those with an average prognosis (PA) received vincristine and prednisolone followed by a single course of Ara-C and asparaginase. All patients received central nervous system prophylaxis with 2,400 rad cranial irradiation and four injections of intrathecal methotrexate. One hundred seventy-seven patients (90%) achieved complete remission, and 165 were randomized. Those randomized to Group A (83) received maintenance chemotherapy with six-week courses of 6-mercaptopurine, weekly oral methotrexate, and monthly vincristine. Each six-week course was followed by a two-week interval of no chemotherapy, and treatment was con tinued for 36 months. Patients randomized to Group B (82) received the same maintenance chemotherapy, but during the two-week interval without chemotherapy, they were given BCG inoculation. With a median follow-up of 110 weeks, no significant difference in duration of remission, survival, or CNS relapse was found between Groups A and B in the total patient population or within each prognostic category. In patients classified as PU, a significantly lower proportion (P < 0.02) remained in complete remission. Within this group, patients with a white cell count > 100 × 10⁹/L had a significantly shorter duration of remission (P < 0.05). Patients classified as PF showed a This research was done by the Australasian Cancer Society Childhood Leukemia Group.     

High-dose methotrexate improves clinical outcome in children with acute lymphoblastic leukemia: St. Jude Total Therapy Study X

High-dose methotrexate (HDMTX, 1,000 mg/m2) and cranial irradiation/sequential chemotherapy (RTSC) were compared for ability to extend complete remission durations in children with acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL). Three hundred thirty patients were enrolled in the study, according to our criteria for standard-risk ALL: a leukocyte count less than 100 X 10(9)/L, no mediastinal mass, no leukemic involvement of the central nervous system (CNS), and blast cells lacking sheep erythrocyte receptors and surface immunoglobulin. Prednisone-vincristine-asparaginase induced complete remissions in 95% of the patients, who were then randomized to receive either HDMTX (n = 154) or RTSC (n = 155). HDMTX was administered with intrathecal MTX for the first 3 weeks following remission induction, and then every 6 weeks with daily mercaptopurine (MP) and weekly oral MTX for a total of 18 months. The RTSC regimen consisted of 1,800 cGy cranial irradiation and intrathecal MTX for 3 weeks, followed by MP/MTX, cyclophosphamide/doxorubicin, and teniposide/cytarabine administered sequentially over 18 months. The final 12 months of treatment for both groups was MP and oral MTX; all patients received intrathecal MTX every 12 weeks. With a median follow-up of 5 years, complete remission durations have been significantly longer among children treated with HDMTX, compared with RTSC (P = .049) or historical institutional control regimens (P = .002). Approximately 67% of the patients receiving HDMTX and 56% of those receiving RTSC are expected to be in continuous complete remission at 4 years. Overall, isolated CNS relapse rates were similar (P = .17) in the two treatment groups, although by newer risk criteria cranial irradiation could be expected to provide better protection in patients with an unfavorable prognosis. These findings indicate that addition of intermittent HDMTX infusions to conventional chemotherapy is an effective method for extending complete remissions in children with ALL.     

Marrow transplant experience in children with acute lymphoblastic leukemia: an analysis of factors associated with survival, relapse, and graft-versus-host disease

One hundred fourteen children with acute lymphoblastic leukemia were treated with allogeneic marrow transplantation from HLA-identical siblings after conditioning with cyclophosphamide and total body irradiation. Methotrexate was given posttransplantation for prophylaxis of graft-versus-host disease. The minimum follow-up after transplantation was 2 years. Sixteen of 51 patients transplanted in marrow remission survive from 2.1 to 8.9 years (median 2.7), 13 in continuous remission, one in remission following testicular relapse, and two after marrow relapse. Sixty-three were transplanted in relapse and eight survived 3-10 years (median 5.7), five in continuous remission, and three in remission following testicular relapse. In a multivariate analysis, factors significantly related to increased survival were marrow remission at transplant (p less than 0.007) and chronic graft-versus-host disease (p less than 0.005). Factors associated with increased relapse were marrow relapse at transplant (p less than 0.002) and absence of significant graft-versus-host disease (p less than 0.004). The development of acute graft-versus-host disease was associated with high marrow cell doses (p less than 0.04). These data suggest that some children with acute lymphoblastic leukemia and a poor prognosis with conventional chemotherapy may be cured with marrow transplantation.     

The impact of induction anthracycline on long-term failure-free survival in childhood acute lymphoblastic leukemia

Early intensive therapy might be critical in improving failure-free survival for children with acute lymphoblastic leukemia. Between 1973 and 1977, 107 children received vincristine and prednisone (VP) induction and 30 received the same two agents plus an anthracycline (VPA). Ninety-nine of the VP-treated group and all 30 of the VPA-treated patients achieved complete remission. At a median observation time of 10 years, 59 of 137 children remain in continuous complete remission. Failure-free survival was 37% for the VP group and 63% for the VPA group (p = 0.02). Failure-free survival for boys who received VP was 28%, compared with 68% for boys who received VPA (p = 0.007). All 11 extramedullary relapses and all seven relapses occurring beyond 3.8 years from diagnosis (three testicular and four bone marrow) were observed among the VP group. We conclude that use of an anthracycline during remission induction therapy influenced failure-free survival and that early results of successful antileukemic therapy in children must be confirmed by follow-up progress reports.     

Long-term survival in childhood acute leukemia: "late" relapses.

The "late" relapse patterns of childhood acute leukemia were studied in 83 children in their first continuous complete remission for more than three years prior to randomization for stopping therapy (40 patients) or continuing therapy (43 patients) for a total of six years. Twenty of 83 (22.9%) have relapsed: Ten in the bone marrow, one in the central nervous system, and nine in the testes. The testes relapse rate of 41.1% (7/17) in males discontinuing therapy at three years was much higher than that of 8.7% (2/23) in males continuing therapy. This difference is significant at P = 0.01 (Wilcoxon test).     

Long-term survival in childhood acute leukemia: “Late” relapses

The “late” relapse patterns of childhood acute leukemia were studied in 83 children in their first continuous complete remission for more than three years prior to randomization for stopping therapy (40 patients) or continuing therapy (43 patients) for a total of six years. Twenty of 83 (22.9%) have relapsed: Ten in the bone marrow, one in the central nervous system, and nine in the testes. The testes relapse rate of 41.1% (7/17) in males discontinuing therapy at three years was much higher than that of 8.7% (2/23) in males continuing therapy. This difference is significant at P = 0.01 (Wilcoxon test).     

The significance of an M2 bone marrow at cessation of chemotherapy in childhood acute lymphoblastic leukemia

The decision to cease chemotherapy in childhood acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) is taken when clinical examination and investigations at the end of the predetermined treatment period show no evidence of residual disease. Since 1972, 11 children treated at this institution have not fulfilled the criteria for cessation of therapy in that they all had elevated blast counts in their bone marrows at "off-treatment" studies (i.e., an M2 marrow, defined as 5-25% blasts). Initially, the significance of this finding was not appreciated and the first child in this series received a further 2 years of chemotherapy. Subsequently the relevance of such an M2 marrow to remission status was questioned and the next 10 patients were simply observed and their bone marrows were reexamined after an interval of 4-12 weeks. Nine of these 11 remain in continuous complete remission with a follow-up of 5-15 years from diagnosis. It is postulated that this finding represents an immunologic rebound phenomenon and is not related to potential for later relapse.     

Immunocompetence and prognosis in children with acute lymphoblastic leukemia: combination of two different maintenance therapies.

Intensive chemotherapy in patients with leukemia produced immunosuppression. The level of immunocompetence correlates with prognosis. The immunological function of 29 children with acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) in complete remission and on 2 different maintenance therapies was evaluated and compared with 16 normal children (Group A). Sixteen children (Group B) with ALL received 6 mercaptopurine (6MP) daily and methotrexate (MTX) twice a week, and 13 children (Group C) received 6MP and MTX weekly for maintenance. There was depression of both cellular immunity, measured by the number of T cells and skin tests, and humoral immunity, measured by number of B cells, primary antibody production to typhoid vaccine, and levels of immunoglobulins. However, continuous maintenance therapy (Group B) produced significantly more severe immunosuppression of cellular immunity than the intermittent therapy (Group C). Humoral immunity was equally depressed in both groups of leukemia patients, but was less altered than cellular immunity. Concomitantly, patients with intermittent maintenance chemotherapy had less hematologic depression, fewer episodes of infection, and fewer died in complete remission. Patients of both groups with higher levels of immunocompetence had better prognosis with longer duration of complete remission than patients with severe immunosuppression. Out of 6 patients with "favorable immunocompetence" only 1 relapsed at 7 months and the other 5 remain in complete remission from 8 to 31 months. Among 23 leukemic patients with "unfavorable immunocompetence," 15 relapsed and 8 remain in complete remission from 9 to 26 months.     

Immunocompetence and prognosis in children with acute lymphoblastic leukemia: Combination of two different maintenance therapies

Intensive chemotherapy in patients with leukemia produces immunosuppression. The level of immunocompetence correlates with prognosis. The immunological function of 29 children with acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) in complete remission and on 2 different maintenance therapies was evaluated and compared with 16 normal children (Group A). Sixteen children (Group B) with ALL received 6 mercaptopurine (6MP) daily and methotrexate (MTX) twice a week, and 13 children (Group C) received 6MP and MTX weekly for maintenance. There was depression of both cellular immunity, measured by the number of T cells and skin tests, and humoral immunity, measured by number of B cells, primary antibody production to typhoid vaccine, and levels of immunoglobulins. However, continuous maintenance therapy (Group B) produced significantly more severe immunosuppression of cellular immunity than the intermittent therapy (Group C). Humoral immunity was equally depressed in both groups of leukemia patients, but was less altered than cellular immunity. Concomitantly, patients with intermittent maintenance chemotherapy had less hematologic depression, fewer episodes of infection, and fewer died in complete remission. Patients of both groups with higher levels of immunocompetence had better prognosis with longer duration of complete remission than patients with severe immunosuppression. Out of 6 patients with “favorable immunocompetence” only 1 relapsed at 7 months and the other 5 remain in complete remission from 8 to 31 months. Among 23 leukemic patients with “unfavorable immunocompetence,” 15 relapsed and 8 remain in complete remission from 9 to 26 months.     

A study of intermittent alternating drug program reinduction therapy on the frequency and duration of response in adult acute leukemia

Of 41 adults with a diagnosis of acute leukemia that were randomized for induction therapy in combination with methotrexate, 6-MP, vincristine and prednisone (POMP) versus a combination of cytosine arabinoside, cytoxan, vincristine and prednisone (COAP), 23 (56%) patients achieved a complete remission. During remission, patients received consolidation therapy with the three courses of remission induction regimen that they had not received initially. They then received daunomycin (three courses) and L-asparaginase and were then maintained for two years with their induction therapy. The median duration of survival for all patients was 40 weeks; the median duration of survival of those patients that responded to chemotherapy was 80 weeks. There was no significant difference between the two induction regimens with regard to complete remission more than four and one half years from diagnosis and two and one half years from discontinuation of all therapy.     

Initial experiences in the treatment of children with metastatic and recurrent neuroblastoma using meta-iodobenzylguanidine

At four involved hospitals 16 children were treated with Metaiodobenzylguanidine (131J-MIBG). These children had a relapse of neuroblastoma stage III or IV or did not respond sufficiently to chemotherapy. In 10 children extreme bone pain disappeared and they became free of fever during the MIBG-treatment. 10 children responded to the therapy demonstrated either by decrease of the solid tumor part or by decrease of catecholamines in urine or plasma or by decrease of bone-marrow involvement. One patient reached a complete remission continuing up to present time (longer than 180 days). 9 patients died meanwhile of tumor progression. 131J-MIBG is an effective instrument, to get a decrease of the tumor up to a complete remission in extensively pretreated patients with tumor relapse, which are refractory to chemotherapy.     

Prognosis improvements in children with acute myelocytic leucemia after more intensive induction therapy (author's transl)]

Between October 1974 and October 1978 23 children with acute myelocytic leucemia (AML) received intensive therapy in the Univ.-Kinderklinik Münster: 4 children were treated according to the ALGB-protocol consisting of 5-7 day courses of ARA-C-infusion and 3 DNR-injections. 19 patients received the West-Berlin-protocol: The first 7 the original ALL protocol, 11 the modified form of AML, which will be presented here as AML-therapy-study BFM 78. 4 of the 23 patients died with early acute cerebral bleeding. 2 patients were nonresponders. 17 children went into remission. One girl died in remission of septicemic aspergillosis. 4 children had a relapse. In November 1978 there were still 12 patients in continuous complete remission, 3 of them already without therapy. 13 of the 19 patients, who were treated with the West-Berlin-protocol went into remission. 1 had a relapse. At present there are 11 patients in continuous complete remission. The above results and those found in the literature could signify that the long term prognosis of children with AML will be improved. To coordinate efforts toward this goal a cooperative AML-therapy-study in the "Deutsche Arbeitsgemeinschaft für Leuk?mieforschung" (BFM-group) using the here presented therapy protocol was formed in November 1978.     

Inevitable and avoidable deaths in childhood ALL

The causes of 37 deaths among 100 Finnish children with ALL were analyzed after a median follow-up of 5 years. Five children died during primary induction, 9 in complete remission, and 23 in hematological relapse. Infections were responsible for 17 deaths, and four deaths were due to toxicity of chemotherapy. In 16 cases ALL relapse was the major cause of death. Ten of the deaths were defined as "avoidable" because they occurred in potentially curable children, i.e., during induction or primary remission. Critical analysis revealed that 5 out of the 10 "avoidable" deaths might indeed have been prevented by appropriate diagnosis and therapy. We want to emphasize the need for continuous education of all pediatricians involved in the care of ALL patients, as well as the importance of best available clinical expertise and centralization of medical therapy in the efforts to diminish the mortality in childhood ALL.     

Outcome after relapse in an unselected cohort of children and adolescents with Ewing sarcoma

BACKGROUND: Survival after relapse in patients with Ewing sarcoma is very poor and this retrospective study attempts to identify of prognostic factors predicting survival after relapse. PROCEDURE: A total of 191 patients with localised Ewing sarcoma were registered in the ET-2 trial of the United Kingdom Children's Cancer Study Group (UKCCSG). All patients received standardised primary treatment with chemotherapy and surgery and or radiotherapy as local modality treatment. Sixty-four patients who relapsed are included in this report. Treatment at relapse was variable and included chemotherapy, surgery, radiotherapy and high dose therapy (HDT) or megatherapy with peripheral stem cell transplantation (PBSCT) or autologous bone marrow transplantation (ABMT) in various combinations. A subgroup of patients had only non-specific symptomatic treatment at relapse. Both univariate and multivariate methods were used to investigate variables affecting survival after relapse. RESULTS: The overall actuarial median survival from relapse for all patients was 14 months (95% CI 11-16 months). Univariate analysis showed that males had a longer survival (median, 16 months vs. 11 months); patients who relapsed while on treatment did worse (median, 3 months vs. 16 months) and patients who had a longer disease-free interval (DFI) prior to relapse had a better outcome (DFI <1 year, median survival = 3 months; DFI 1-2 years, survival = 8 months; DFI > 2 years, median survival = 24 months, P < 0.001). Multivariate analysis confirmed that duration of first remission was the only factor associated with longer survival after relapse. CONCLUSIONS: These data suggest that although aggressive therapy may delay disease progression after relapse for some children, the course of the disease after relapse is usually fatal. International co-operative studies are needed to evaluate new strategies.     

Treatment of recurrence of acute myeloid leukemia in childhood. A retrospective analysis of recurrence in the AML-BFM-83 study]

Complete remission (CR) rates of 80% are achieved with the AML-BFM protocols but one third of patients relapse within the first three years. There are few reports of treatment of relapsed childhood AML, and these deal with the evaluation of new drugs for frontline therapy. We performed a retrospective analysis to investigate how patients previously treated with the AML-BFM-83 protocol were treated after relapse and how many long term remissions were achieved. 48 of 139 patients relapsed after having achieved complete remission with the AML-BFM-83 protocol which consists of continous infusion of ARA-C 100 mg/m2 day 1-2, ARA-C 200 mg/m2 day 3-8, Daunorubicin 60 mg/m2 day 3, 4, and 5, and VP-16 150 mg/m2 day 6, 7, and 8, and an 8 week consolidation therapy consisting of Prednisolone, Thioguanine, Vincristine, ADR, ARA-C, Cyclophosphamide, intrathecal ARA-C and cranial irradiation followed by maintenance therapy. Duration of first remission ranged from 1.5 months to 66.3 months. Excluding 5 children with either isolated or combined extramedullary relapses and another 4 patients for missing data, 39 children were evaluable. 20 children received no therapy or palliative therapy while 16 patients received chemotherapy and another 3 children were transplanted in relapse. Although 9 different intensive chemotherapy regimens were used for reinduction, a high number (12 of 16 = 75%) of second complete remissions was achieved. Several therapeutic options were used to maintain a second remission: regular maintenance therapy (7 patients), allogeneous bone marrow transplantation (BMT) (2 patients), autologous BMT (3 patients).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Localized bone marrow relapse in acute lymphoblastic leukemia

Localized bone marrow relapse is rare in acute lymphoblastic leukemia. Discordant bone marrow specimens were found in an 11-year-old asymptomatic girl who had been in remission for six years and off chemotherapy for 2 1/2 years. One bone marrow sample showed marked leukemic infiltration, whereas marrow from another site was normal. Three months later, with normal peripheral blood counts, she developed severe back pain and x-ray evidence of vertebral collapse and periosteal changes in the public bone. At that time three of the four areas of bone marrow sampled showed leukemic involvement. Reinduction therapy was begun, and she is now in remission on maintenance chemotherapy. At this time, it is unclear whether routine performance of marrow aspirations and biopsies from multiple sites, in periodic follow-up examinations of patients with acute leukemia would allow earlier detection of relapse frequently enough to justify the procedure. The issue of localized bone marrow involvement, if more common than previously reported, should be addressed at the time a decision is being made to discontinue therapy.     

Localized bone marrow relapse in acute lymphoblastic leukemia.

Localized bone marrow relapse is rare in acute lymphoblastic leukemia. Discordant bone marrow specimens were found in an 11-year-old asymptomatic girl who had been in remission for six years and off chemotherapy for 2 1/2 years. One bone marrow sample showed marked leukemic infiltration, whereas marrow from another site was normal. Three months later, with normal peripheral blood counts, she developed severe back pain and x-ray evidence of vertebral collapse and periosteal changes in the pubic bone. At that time three of the four areas of bone marrow sampled showed leukemic involvement. Reinduction therapy was begun, and she is now in remission on maintenance chemotherapy. At this time, it is unclear whether routine performance of marrow aspirations and biopsies from multiple sites, in periodic follow-up examinations of patients with acute leukemia would allow earlier detection of relapse frequently enough to justify the procedure. The issue of localized bone marrow involvement, if more common than previously reported, should be addressed at the time a decision is being made to discontinue therapy.     

Leukemic ophthalmopathy: A report of 21 pediatric cases

A multicentric retrospective study on leukemic ophthalmopathy (LO) is reported. It includes 21 patients, 16 males and 5 females, with acute leukemia (AL) observed in 10 SIOP centers. LO developed in three patients at the time of diagnosis of AL; five patients were in first complete remission (three off therapy); four patients were in second or third remission; and nine were in combined relapse. Most frequent symptoms were blurred vision, photophobia, and ocular pain. Two patients with acute nonlymphoblastic leukemia died before treatment; another underwent bone marrow transplantation; one patient with B-cell acute lymphoblastic leukemia (B-ALL) treated with chemotherapy and radiotherapy died 4 months after LO; the remaining 17 children were treated according to different schedules with (10) or without (7) radiotherapy on the affected eye. Twelve patients achieved ocular remission and four of these had a second ocular relapse. Complete remission after LO treatment lasting for more than 3, 7, 24, 29 months was observed in four patients. The authors conclude that cure is possible in patients who had LO in first complete remission treated with chemotherapy and radiotherapy at high dose on the affected eye. © 1994 Wiley-Liss, Inc.