Gender differences of cognitive function in migraine patients: evidence from event-related potentials using the oddball paradigm

Background

Migraine shows gender-specific incidence and has a higher prevalence in females. Gender plays an important role in the prevalence of migraine, but few studies have investigated the effect of gender on the cognitive functions of migraine patients. This study investigated gender differences in the cognitive function of migraine patients without aura.

Methods

We recruited 29 migraine patients (15 females; mean age 25.4 y) during the interictal period and 28 healthy age-matched participants (14 females; mean age 24.8 y). We used an auditory oddball paradigm to analyze target processing using event-related potentials.

Results

We investigated the N2 and P3 components. The P3 amplitude was decreased in patients compared with the control, and this reduction was not modulated by gender. These results of the P3 provided a new evidence for the dysfunction of cognitive function in migraine patients. The N2 amplitude was larger for male than female migraine patients, and this gender effect was not found in the control group.

Conclusions

These results of the P3 provided a new evidence for the dysfunction of cognitive function in migraine patients. And those of N2 may explain that male patients have the super-sensitivity of cerebral function relevant to the early target-selection and response preparation. Our findings emphasize the importance of considering gender when researching the cognitive function of migraine patients.     

Cognitive processing in headache associated with sexual activity

Cognitive processing in headache associated with sexual Cognitive processing as measured by event-related potentials (ERP) in patients suffering from the explosive subtype of headache associated with sexual activity (HSA type 2) was investigated. Visual ERP were measured in 24 patients with HSA type 2 outside the headache period. The differences of the first and the second part of measurement were evaluated separately to determine the amount of cognitive habituation. Twenty-four sex- and age-matched healthy subjects and 24 patients with migraine without aura served as controls. A missing increase of P3 latency during the second part of the measurement was found in 79% of patients with HSA type 2 and in 75% with migraine, but only in 17% of the healthy controls (P < 0.001). The P3 amplitude was increased during the second part in 71% of patients with HSA type 2 and in 79% with migraine, but only in 33% of the healthy controls (P = 0.02). Mean P3 latency was decreased and mean P3 amplitude was increased during the second part of the measurement in HSA type 2 and in migraine but not in the healthy control group. Patients with HSA type 2 have a loss of cognitive habituation as measured by ERP. This specific information processing is very similar to that in migraine observed in previous studies.     

Trigeminal evoked potentials in cluster headache

We sought out alterations of early trigeminal evoked potenials (TEPs) in patients suffering from episodic cluster headache, in order to evaluate a possible direct involvement of the trigeminal nerve. The study was carried out at the Centre for Pain Relief, National Institute for Cancer Research, Genoa in collaboration with the Interuniversity Centre for Pain Neurophysiology, unit of the University of Genoa. We studied 32 patients suffering from episodic cluster headache. TEPs were recorded from the scalp, after stimulation of the infraorbital nerve on both sides. The recordings were performed during the patients' bouts, but outside attacks in 24 cases. In 8 patients the recordings were performed during attacks. All 8 patients tested during an attack showed a delayed or absent W2 and W3 of the TEP, while only 3 of the 24 patients tested outside the attack had delayed W2 and W3. The alterations detected point towards a temporary impairment of conduction along the nerve fibres, approximately at the gasserian ganglion. Such a situation is consistent with a moderate compression by a swollen internal carotid artery or cavernous sinus upon the ganglion, during the attack. Received: 27 January 2000 / Accepted in revised form: 28 February 2000     

Orbital phlebography in patients with cluster headache

Thirteen patients with cluster headache in an active stage were investigated with orbital phlebography. About 60% of the patients showed pathologic changes on the phlebograms, such as changes in the appearance of the superior ophthalmic vein. Five patients had pathologic changes on both sides and three patients on one side only. All patients with unilateral pathologic findings on orbital phlebography had the attacks on the same side. The phlebographic findings in these patients with cluster headache were very similar to those of patients with the Tolosa-Hunt syndrome. There is also some similarity in the symptoms in the two disorders. It has previously been suggested that the Tolosa-Hunt syndrome is caused by venous vasculitis, and the present findings to some extent support the idea that cluster headache may have the same etiology.     

Migraine in patients with cluster headache

One hundred and twenty seven patients with cluster headache have been compared with 122 patients with migraine. Twenty of the patients with cluster headache have had migraine attacks but only 2 still have migraine attacks after the onset of cluster headache. No migraine patients had cluster headache. Among the 127 patients with cluster headache, one of the parents suffered from cluster headache in 4.7% of the cases. Among the 122 patients with migraine, 0.8% had a parent with cluster headache. Among the 122 patients with migraine 54.9% had parents with migraine, and in the cluster headache group 23.6% of the patients had one parent with migraine. The coexistence of migraine and cluster headache is rare. The two types of headache, as far as the heredity pattern is concerned, are independent entities.     

Burden of cluster headache

The aim was to analyse the socioeconomic burden of cluster headache in patients from a tertiary headache centre. One hundred consecutive patients from the Danish Headache Centre were invited to an interview about the socioeconomic impact of cluster headache. Work absence and use of medical services were compared with a Danish population-based survey. Eighty-five patients participated; 78% reported restrictions in daily living and 13% also outside of cluster periods; 25% reported a major decrease in their ability to participate in social activities, family life and housework. The disease caused lifestyle changes for 96%, most frequently in sleeping habits and avoidance of alcohol. The absence rate among patients was 30%, which was significantly higher than 12% among the general population (P < 0.001). Use of health services due to headache was also higher among the patients (P < 0.001). Cluster headache, although periodic in most cases, has considerable impact on social functions, quality of life and use of healthcare.     

Episodic cluster headache and narcolepsy: a case report

A patient who first presented with episodic cluster headache later developed narcolepsy. In spite of REM sleep alterations associated with narcolepsy, the frequency and distribution of pain attacks did not change when narcolepsy occurred and were similar to those seen in cases of episodic cluster without narcolepsy. The lack of influence of narcolepsy on the pattern of cluster pains questions the role of REM sleep states in triggering pain in episodic cluster.     

A case of parasellar meningioma mimicking cluster headache

A medical history of a 46-year-old male is reported. At 23 years of age, he started having diffuse pain in the left side of his head for up to 30 min once or twice a month. At 28, the pain changed into left-sided cluster headache-like attacks with 2-3 h duration and with ipsilateral conjunctival injection, lacrimation, and rhinnorhea, but with short-lasting free intervals of about two to three weeks. At 36, the pattern of the attacks corresponded to chronic migrainous neuralgia. At 40, the symptoms changed to painful ophthalmoplegia-picture. A left-sided parasellar meningioma was then diagnosed. Removal of the tumor caused complete amelioration. The case history is suggested to support the hypothesis that the cavernous sinus region is involved in cluster headache.     

The blink reflex in chronic cluster headache: a comparison with migraine patients suffering from unilateral pain

Objective. To evaluate the blink reflex (BR) in chronic cluster headache (CH) patients. Design. The elecrophysiological data were collected in during the headache-free phase. Setting. Headache patients were recruited from outpatients seen for the first time at the First Neurologic Clinic of Bari University. Patients and participants. Ten CH patients, 19 migraine without aura patients with strictly unilateral headache (MwoA) and 18 normal controls were selected. Measurements and results. The BR procedure was applied. In CH, a significant R2 duration increase was found on the symptomatic side in comparison with MwoA and controls. In both patient groups an early appearance of the R3 component was bilaterally clear. Conclusions. The BR findings confirm the central genesis of CH. The R3 abnormalities suggest a basic dysfunction of the Central control on the trigeminal nociceptive circuits. The R2 involvement on the symptomatic side indicates a unilateral facilitation of the trigeminal-facial connections persisting after the CH bout. Received: 3 January 2000, Accepted in revised form: 2 November 2000     

Effects of increasing the intracranial blood volume in cluster headache patients and controls

Eleven patients with episodic cluster headache in period, five patients out of period and six controls were studied concerning the effects of an increase of the intracranial blood volume by tilting. Common carotid artery (CCA) blood flow was similar in all three groups at baseline and during tilting. CCA diameters were similar at baseline and increased during tilting in all three groups, indicating that tilting caused an increase in the extra- and intracranial blood volume. Unilateral pain or sympathetic dysfunction did not appear during tilting in the patients out of period or in the controls. In four of eight studied patients with cluster headache in period, unilateral miosis and ptosis appeared during tilting. Two of these four patients developed intense unilateral pain, while the other two did not report any pain. Four other patients developed slight unilateral pain but no sympathetic dysfunction during tilting.     

Sex steroids and cluster headache: hypotheses

The pathophysiological significance of the changes in gonadal function observed in cluster headache is far from clear. Some features of the disease, such as the sex predominance, the lateralization of symptoms and the character of pain itself may be connected to some biological effects of gonadal steroids.     

Treatment of cluster headache with topiramate: effects and side-effects in five patients

We report on clinical experience with topiramate in the prophylactic treatment of three patients with chronic and two patients with episodic, otherwise therapy-resistant, cluster headache. Patients were treated with daily doses of 75-200 mg topiramate. Topiramate was effective in three patients but proved ineffective and also caused intolerable side-effects in two patients. Topiramate may have prophylactic properties for treating cluster headache at lower doses than needed in epilepsy therapy, but its clinical value is limited due to central nervous system side-effects.     

Substance P mechanism in cluster headache: Evaluation in plasma and cerebrospinal fluid

Substance P (SP), present in sensory afferent neurons, seems to process nociceptive information in the trigeminal system. SP, released from peripheral trigeminal endings, causes typical cluster headache (CH) signs, e.g. vasodilatation, conjunctival and nasal edema and miosis. Opiates and somatostatin (SRIF), both active in relieving CH attack, inhibit SP release from the central and peripheral trigeminal system. In the present study, plasma and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF), SP-like immunoreactivity (SPLI) and enkephalinase activity (EKA), and plasma SRIF-like immunoreactivity (SRIFLI) have been evaluated during spontaneous and histamine induced attacks in the cluster phase. During the histamine provoked attacks, CSF SPLI and plasma SRIFLI and EKA were unchanged, while plasma SPLI decreased significantly. During spontaneously occurring attacks, plasma SRIFLI was found to be unmodified and a significant lowering of SPLI was detected when compared with controls. Moreover, both during and between attacks in the cluster phase, plasma EKA was increased in comparison with the values in controls. It remains to be seen whether variations of plasma SPLI and EKA levels play a role in the CH mechanism.     

Reduced habituation of trigeminal reflexes in patients with episodic cluster headache during cluster period

A growing body of evidence supports the pivotal role of the hypothalamus in the pathophysiology of cluster headache (CH). On the basis of animal studies, it has been suggested that a hypothalamic dysfunction can lead to a habituation deficit of brainstem reflex responses, as result of a stress-like condition. Taking into account these findings, we tested the hypothesis that habituation of brainstem reflexes may be impaired in CH patients. The habituation phenomenon of the late components (R2 and R3) of the blink reflex was studied in 27 CH patients during the cluster period, in 22 migraine patients interictally and in 20 control subjects. A significant habituation deficit in the R2 and R3 components was found in CH compared with both controls and migraineurs. The lack of habituation in CH, more pronounced than in migraine, points to abnormal processing of sensory stimuli at the trigeminal level that could be driven by hypothalamic dysfunction during the cluster period.     

Acute pharmacotherapy of migraine,tension-type headache,and cluster headache

Abstract In most migraine patients acute therapy is needed. Migraine can be treated either with specific drugs, the triptans and ergot alkaloids, or with NSAIDs. Triptans are a major step foreward in migraine therapy. The therapeutic gain for headache relief is 50% for subcutaneous sumatriptan whereas it is 30-40% for most oral triptans. After oral triptans sustained pain free is only 30%. There is thus still ample room for improvement of acute therapy in migraine. For tension-type headache there is no specific therapy and it is treated with NSAIDs. Only 17-32% become pain free after these drugs. For attacks of cluster headache oxygen and subcutaneous sumatriptan can be used. Intranasal triptans can be an alternative.     

Lithium carbonate in cluster headache: assessment of its short- and long-term therapeutic efficacy

The short- and long-term effects of administration of lithium carbonate in cluster headache (CH) have been investigated. Of the 90 patients treated (78 males and 12 females), 68 had episodic CH and 22 had the chronic form of the disease. The doses used were almost always 900 mg/day. Eleven of the 22 patients with chronic CH showed a definite, constant improvement both short and long term. In 7 of the 22 patients, lithium treatment provided excellent results initially but was later followed by some transient worsening; in the remaining 4 only partial benefits were observed initially and treatment proved still less effective after a few months. The effects of cessation of lithium administration after at least five months of continuous treatment were studied in 9 cases. In 6 of them the attacks re-appeared immediately, whereas in 3 the attacks occurred again only after free intervals of four to six months. Of the 68 patients with episodic CH, 26 proved highly responsive to treatment, 26 only partially responsive, and 16 refractory. In 3 cases, after one to three years of continuous treatment, euthyroid goitre developed, which disappeared after the drug was discontinued.     

Pre-attack and pre-episode symptoms in cluster headache: a multicenter cross-sectional study of 327 Chinese patients

BackgroundThere have been a few studies regarding the pre-attack symptoms (PAS) and pre-episode symptoms (PES) of cluster headache (CH), but none have been conducted in the Chinese population. The purpose of this study was to identify the prevalence and features of PAS and PES in Chinese patients, as well as to investigate their relationships with pertinent factors.MethodsThe study included patients who visited a tertiary headache center and nine other headache clinics between January 2019 and September 2021. A questionnaire was used to collect general data and information about PAS and PES.ResultsAmong the 327 patients who met the CH criteria (International Classification of Headache Disorders, 3rd edition), 269 (82.3%) patients experienced at least one PAS. The most common PAS were head and facial discomfort (74.4%). Multivariable logistic regression analysis depicted that the number of triggers (OR = 1.798, p = 0.001), and smoking history (OR = 2.067, p = 0.026) were correlated with increased odds of PAS. In total, 68 (20.8%) patients had PES. The most common symptoms were head and facial discomfort (23, 33.8%). Multivariable logistic regression analysis showed that the number of triggers were associated with increased odds of PES (OR = 1.372, p = 0.005).ConclusionsPAS are quite common in CH patients, demonstrating that CH attacks are not comprised of a pain phase alone; investigations of PAS and PES could help researchers better understand the pathophysiology of CH.     

Symptoms and diseases and smoking habits in female episodic cluster headache and migraine patients

Twenty-seven episodic female cluster headache patients were compared to 27 age-matched female migraine patients with regard to occurrence of symptoms and diseases other than headache, and also with regard to tobacco consumption. Some symptoms and diseases were found to occur significantly or almost significantly more often in the cluster headache patients than in the migraine patients: Chronic fatigue ( p <0.01), vertigo ( p <0.05), arthralgia ( p <0.05), back pain ( p =0.05), spontaneous ecchymoses ( p =0.05) and constipation andor periodic diarrhea ( p =0.09). There were significantly fewer persons who had never smoked in the cluster headache group than in the migraine group ( p <0.01). The extent of smoking was significantly greater in the cluster headache group than in the migraine group, both as to the number of cigarettes smoked per day ( p <0.001) and as to smoking years ( p <0.001).     

Concentration and uptake of 5-hydroxytryptamine in platelets from cluster headache and migraine patients

Concentrations of 5-hydroxytryptamine (5-HT) in platelets were determined in 33 cluster headache patients (17 males) and in 34 migraine patients (16 males) outside attacks. The 5-HT uptake into platelets was measured and the kinetic constants V_max and K_m determined in 26 cluster patients (14 males) and in 30 migraine patients (13 males). Significantly lower 5-HT concentrations in whole blood were found in cluster headache and migraine patients than in 50 healthy controls (19 males). The V_max and K_m values of the 5-HT uptake were significantly lower in cluster headache and migraine patients compared with 22 healthy controls (9 males). The 5-HT concentrations and the kinetics of the 5-HT uptake did not differ between cluster headache and migraine. In healthy controls a significant positive correlation was found between the 5-HT uptake rate at 0.25 μM and K_m but not in cluster headache and migraine patients. The 5-HT concentrations in whole blood correlated positively with V_max and K_m, respectively, in cluster headache and with K_m in healthy controls but not with V_max nor with K_m in migraine. There was no obvious relation between the kinetics of platelet monoamine oxidase (MAO) and the 5-HT uptake except for an increased incidence of low V_max of MAO and low K_m of the 5-HT uptake in cluster headache. The kinetics of the 5-HT uptake was apparently not related to the state of migraine. The results indicate a possible constitutional trait in cluster headache and migraine expressed as low 5-HT concentrations in whole blood and low V_max and K_m of the 5-HT uptake into platelets.