Radiation therapy alone or in combination with surgery in the treatment of carcinoma of the esophagus

The role of radiation in the treatment of squamous cell carcinoma of the esophagus was examined in a review of 74 patients treated with curative intent between 1974 and 1981. Aspects studied included the pattern of failure, the use of radiation as a surgical adjuvant, achievement of palliation, and the presence of technical or clinical factors predicting for a better outcome. The group was divided into 9 patients irradiated after esophageal resection, 14 patients irradiated before resection, and 51 patients treated with radiation and no resection. Median and 2-year survival rates among 51 patients treated by radiation without esophagectomy were 8.8 months and 11%, whereas they were 9.7 months and 0% in patients treated by radiation followed by resection, and 9.5 months and 28% in patients undergoing resection followed by radiation. Local failures were suffered in 28/51 patients treated without esophagectomy with rates of 2/4, 7/10, 7/15, and 5/10 after 50-55 Gy, 55-60 Gy, 60-65 Gy, and 65-69 Gy, respectively. Although prognosis for patients presenting with unresectable disease remains poor, a somewhat better outcome may be expected in patients treated with postoperative radiation after potentially unfavorable resections. Other predictors include sex and disease stage.     

Patterns of recurrence in adenocarcinoma of the rectum and rectosigmoid treated with surgery alone: Implications in treatment planning with adjuvant radiation therapy

This is an analysis of 140 patients with adenocarcinoma of the rectum and rectosigmoid treated with surgery alone at the University of Florida between May 1959 and April 1976. Patients in the study group had a complete resection, as determined by the surgeon and the pathologist, and no evidence of distant metastasis at the completion of the operation. There is a 5 year minimum follow-up. Local-regional recurrence rates were noted to vary with histologic grade, length of the lesion, and pathologic stage. Approximately 60 % of local-regional and distant recurrences were noted by 2 years after treatment, and 92–95 % were noted by 5 years. Evaluation of patient status at 5 years revealed that 0 % (Stage CIS), 0 % (A), 17 % (B11), 13 % (B2), 17 % (C1 ), and 28 % (C2) had developed local-regional recurrence without demonstrable distant metastasis. Complications and crude 5 year survival rates are presented and current treatment modifications discussed.     

Radiotherapy preceded by multidrug chemotherapy in carcinoma of the esophagus: a pilot study of the Radiation Therapy Oncology Group

This is a report on R.T.O.G. #77-07, a phase II pilot study aimed at determining the toxicity, primary tumor control, and survival achieved with a combination of triple-drug chemotherapy prior to radiotherapy in carcinoma of the esophagus. The drugs used were vincristine, bleomycin, and methotrexate. A total of 26 cases were registered, one of which died during chemotherapy; 11 had only one chemotherapy course, and 14 had two chemotherapy courses as planned. Drug toxicity could be evaluated in 23 patients: one died from liver damage secondary to chemotherapy effect (4%), two had nausea and vomiting (9%), one had weakness and skin rash (4%), and one had fever and vomiting (4%). There was no complete tumor response to chemotherapy in 22 evaluable cases; 12 of 22 (55%) showed some measurable tumor reduction. Radiation toxicity could be evaluated in 25 patients: 1 of 25 (4%) developed clinical pericarditis, and 2 of 25 (8%) developed severe esophagitis. A complete response to radiotherapy was observed in 15 of 25 (60%) patients; 7 of 25 (28%) showed a partial response; and 3 of 25 (12%) had no measurable tumor reduction. The median survival in 25 evaluable cases was 22 months. In 11 patients who received a single course of chemotherapy, the median survival was 19 months, while in 14 patients who received two courses of chemotherapy, the median survival was only 9 months. However, this difference is not statistically significant.     

Phase II trial of combination chemotherapy and irradiation in non-small-cell lung cancer, Radiation Therapy Oncology Group 88-04.

Encouraging results of several clinical trials utilizing combination chemotherapy and irradiation in unresectable non-small-cell lung cancer have been reported. A recent report from a cooperative group study suggested that preirradiation vinblastine and cisplatin improved survival over irradiation alone. In an attempt to enhance the possible effectiveness of combination chemotherapy and irradiation, the Radiation Therapy Oncology Group embarked on a Phase II trial utilizing preirradiation vinblastine (5 mg/m2 weekly x 5) and cisplatin (100 mg/m2) on days 1 and 29 prior to irradiation and on days 50, 71, and 92 during irradiation. The irradiation began on day 50 and consisted of 6300 cGy in 7 weeks. Between May 20, 1988 and May 1, 1989, 30 patients were entered on study. Seventy-two percent of patients had Karnofsky status greater than 90, and 76% had weight loss less than 5%. Forty-eight percent of the patients were younger than 60 years of age. Forty-five percent of the patients had Stage IIIA disease. Eighty-three percent of the patients received at least four courses of vinblastine, and 59% received at least four courses of cisplatin. Seventy-eight percent of the patients received at least 95% of the prescribed irradiation. The major toxicity was hematologic, and there were two fatal complications in the study group. The preliminary survival figures are encouraging. This combination of chemotherapy and irradiation appears to be tolerable and may merit further investigation.     

Tolerance of pelvic normal tissues to hyperfractionated radiation therapy: results of Protocol 83-08 of the Radiation Therapy Oncology Group

A prospective, centrally randomized Phase I/II trial of hyperfractionation in definitive radiation therapy for locally advanced squamous and transitional cell carcinoma of the bladder was conducted by the Radiation Therapy Oncology Group (RTOG) from April 1983 through June 1986. Patients with T3-4 and T2 N+ (AJC) histologically-confirmed cancer of the bladder received twice daily radiation therapy with 1.2 Gy per fraction and a minimum of 4 hr between fractions. All patients received a whole pelvic total dose of 50.4 Gy: Total doses to reduced volumes were 60.0 Gy, 64.8 Gy, or 69.6 Gy. Of 54 patients entered, 50 were eligible. An unbalanced treatment assignment was used: Nine patients received 60.0 Gy, 15 patients received 64.8 Gy and 26 received 69.6 Gy. Performance status (Karnofsky) was 90-100 in 72% of patients and 92% had transitional carcinoma. Eighty percent of tumors were T3 or T4. Observation of at least 18 months was available for 26 patients. Grade 3 acute reactions (within 90 days) were reported in eight patients (one at 60.0 Gy, three at 64.8 Gy and four at 69.6 Gy). Five patients experienced a total of seven major late effects--four Grade 3 and three Grade 4. The cumulative probability of Grade 3 and 4 late complications of treatment for the 46 patients at risk for late complications was 5% +/- 3% at 6 months, 7% +/- 4% at 12 months, and 10% +/- 5% at 18 and 24 months. The cumulative probability of Grade 3 or 4 late complications for patients who received a total dose of 69.6 Gy was 5% +/- 4% at 6 and 12 months and 11% +/- 8% at 18 and 24 months. Only one patient who experienced major late effects was also reported to have major acute reactions. Comparisons of survival of patients treated in the current study with those who received 60 Gy in 30 fractions in 6 weeks in RTOG Protocol 71-04, did not suggest any deleterious effects from hyperfractionated radiation therapy to the pelvis. The normal pelvic tissues tolerated hyperfractionated radiation therapy sufficiently well to justify exploring it, alone and with brachytherapy, in other pelvic tumors.     

Isolated local-regional recurrence following mastectomy for adenocarcinoma of the breast treated with radiation therapy alone or combined with surgery and/or chemotherapy

The results of radiation therapy alone or combined with surgery and/or chemotherapy are reported for 47 patients who presented with local and/or regional recurrence without evidence of distant metastases following initial management of adenocarcinoma of the breast with radical or modified radical mastectomy (43) or simple mastectomy (4). Patients were treated between October 1964 and March 1983 at the University of Florida; all have a 2-year minimum follow-up and 42/47 (89%) have had follow-up for greater than or equal to 5 years. The overall actuarial local-regional control rates were 80% at 2 years, 68% at 5 years, and 61% at 10 years. The 5-year actuarial local-regional control rates by site and extent of disease were as follows: single chest wall nodule, 92%; multiple chest wall nodules, 49%; regional lymph nodes, 66%; and multiple sites, 64%. The 5- and 10-year actuarial determinate disease-free survival rates for all patients were 41 and 17%, respectively. The 5- and 10-year actuarial survival rates for all patients were 50 and 34%, respectively.     

Multidrug chemotherapy (vincristine-bleomycin-methotrexate) followed by radiotherapy in inoperable carcinomas of the head and neck: a pilot study of the Radiation Therapy Oncology Group

This is a report on the Radiation Therapy Oncology Group (RTOG) Pilot Study 77-08, of a combination of chemotherapy with vincristine-bleomycin-methotrexate, followed by curative radiotherapy for inoperable carcinomas of the head and neck. The main objectives of the study were to determine toxicity, tumor control, and survival. Included were patients with untreated advances carcinomas, with no distant metastasis. Chemotherapy started with vincristine--1.5 mg/m2 (maximum of 2 mg) by I.V. injection, followed by bleomycin drip of 48 hours (15 units per day), and then methotrexate (200 mgs/m2 divided in equal doses 6 hours apart) with folinic acid rescue. Forty patients were registered for the study. Eleven of these received 1 course of the stated chemotherapy, and 28 were given 2 courses, with a 1-week rest period between them. Radical curative radiotherapy was usually started 2 weeks after chemotherapy. Salvage surgery was considered for persistent or recurrent tumor in the primary area, neck, or both. The level of toxicity that resulted from this combined therapy was considered acceptable. The percentage of complete response in the primary tumor was 6% with chemotherapy; 46% after irradiation; and 65% when surgery was added. The complete response (C.R.) in the primary tumor ranged from 54% for T-4 to 100% for T-2, 20% of T-3, and N with this therapeutic regime was--41% initially, 24% at one year, 19% at two years, and 16% at three years. The survival at one, two and three years after beginning radiotherapy was 54%, 30%, and 16%, respectively. This is considered a very satisfactory result for these very advances inoperable patients.     

Radiation Therapy Oncology Group Phase I-II study on fast neutron teletherapy for carcinoma of the bladder

From June 1977 through March 1981, the Radiation Therapy Oncology Group sponsored a Phase I-II study (RTOG 77-05) on the use of fast neutrons for treating carcinomas of the urinary bladder. Patients entered on the study had Stage B1 (grade III or IV histology) or Stage B2, C, or D1 (any grade histology) disease. Thirteen patients received preoperative mixed-beam (neutron/photon) irradiation to 50 photon Gy-equivalent, and in 12 of these a cystectomy was performed in 4 to 6 weeks. The incidence of pathologic downstaging to Po was 58% in the cystectomy specimens. The projected survival at 30 months is 32%. Twenty-six patients were treated definitively with mixed-beam irradiation consisting of 50 photon Gy-equivalent to the pelvis followed by a 20 photon Gy-equivalent boost to the bladder itself. Eighteen of 26 patients (69%) achieved tumor clearance at some time during their follow-up but 8/18 (44%) of these ultimately exhibited some component of local failure. The projected survival at 30 months for this group of patients is 34%. However, the subset of patients with Stage B or C disease had a projected survival at 30 months of 60%. Four patients received definitive neutron irradiation alone and 3/4 achieved tumor clearance at some time during their follow-up. Actuarial curves are presented for patient survival and duration of local control, and results are compared with comparably staged patients treated with megavoltage photon irradiation. Treatment-related morbidity is also discussed.     

Multidrug chemotherapy (vincristine-bleomycinmethotrexate) followed by radiotherapy in inoperable carcinomas of the head and nick: preliminary report of a pilot study of the Radiation Therapy Oncology Group

This is a preliminary report on the Radiation Therapy Oncology Group (RTOG) pilot study 77-08, of a combination of chemotherapy with vincristine-bleomycin-methotrexate, followed by radiotherapy, for inoperable carcinomas of the bead and neck. The main objectives of the study were to determine toxicity and tumor control. Patients who were included bad untreated carcinomas, with no distant metastases, and with adequate pulmonary, renal, and liver function. Forty patients were registered for the study. Chemotherapy started with vincristine—1.5 mgs/m² (maximum of 2 mgs) by I,V. injection, Wowed by bleomycin drip for 48 hours (15 units/day), and then methotrexate (200 mgs/m² divided in equal doses 6 hours apart) with folinic acid rescue. Eleven patients received one course of the stated chemotherapy; 28 were given two courses with one week rest period between them. Radical curative radiotherapy was started usually two weeks after chemotherapy. A surgical procedure was considered if the patient was found operable after receiving a dose of 5000 rad with continuous therapy or at 3000 rad with split-course therapy. The level of toxicity that resulted from this combined therapy was considered acceptable. The percentage of complete response of the primary tumor was 6% with chemotherapy; this increased to 46% after irradiation, and to 65% when surgery was added.     

Radiation therapy alone in the treatment of carcinoma of uterine cervix. I. Analysis of tumor recurrence

This is a retrospective analysis with emphasis on the patterns of failure in 849 patients with histologically proven invasive carcinoma of the uterine cervix treated with irradiation alone. In 281 patients with Stage IB tumors, the total incidence of pelvic failure was 6.4% (two without and 16 combined with distant metastasis). In 88 patients with Stage IIA, 12.5% failed in the pelvis (one without and ten combined with distant metastasis). The total pelvic failure rate in Stage IIB was 17.4% (22 without and 22 combined with distant metastasis). In 212 patients with Stage III, the overall pelvic failure rate was 35.8% (31 without and 45 combined with distant metastasis). Approximately 25% of the pelvic recurrences were central (cervix or vagina) and 75% parametrial. The overall incidence of distant metastasis was 13.5% for Stage IB, 27.3% for Stage IIA, 23.8% for Stage IIB, and 39.6% in Stage III. Higher doses of irradiation delivered to the medial and lateral parametrium with external beam irradiation and intracavitary insertions were correlated with a lower incidence of parametrial failures in all stages, except IB. In Stage IIA, medial parametrial doses below 9000 rad resulted in 10/78 = 12.8% pelvic failures, in contrast to one recurrence in 10 patients treated with doses over 9000 rad. In Stage IIB, doses below 9000 rad yielded a pelvic recurrence rate of 36/203 (17.7%) compared to 5/49 (10.2%) with higher doses. In Stage III there were 66/167 (39.5%) recurrences with doses below 9000 rad and 10/44 (22.7%) with larger doses. Statistically significant differences were observed among the Stage IIB (P = 0.02) and III patients (P = 0.005) respectively. The lateral parametrial dose also showed some correlation with tumor control, although the differences were not statistically significant. The survival in patients with Stage IIB and III was 10% higher in the patients treated with higher parametrial doses. However, the differences are not statistically significant. These results strongly suggest that higher doses of irradiation must be delivered to patients with Stage IIB and III, but improvement in tumor control must be weighed against an increasing number of complications. Factors other than the total doses of irradiation, such as the characteristics of the tumor and the quality of the intracavitary insertion influence the therapeutic results in irradiation of carcinoma of the uterine cervix. Other therapeutic approaches must be designed to improve the effect of irradiation in the tumor without further injury to the normal tissues. Hypoxic cell sensitizers, hyperthermia and high LET particles are under investigation.     

Concomitant cisplatin chemotherapy and radiotherapy in advanced mucosal squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck. Long-term results of the Radiation Therapy Oncology Group study 81-17

One hundred twenty-four eligible patients with advanced mucosal squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck were entered into a pilot study of concomitant cisplatin (100 mg/m2 given every 3 weeks for three doses) and standard irradiation. The initial complete response (CR) was 71% with an additional two cases salvaged by surgery for an overall 73% CR. When no keratin was identified in the histologic specimen (41 patients) the CR was 90%. The nasopharynx showed the best CR (89%) among the sites. At 4 years after treatment, the estimated locoregional tumor control rate was 43% and the survival, 34%. When no keratin was present in the specimen, the estimated locoregional control of tumor was superior (56% versus 38% with keratin identified, P = 0.02) and the estimated survival was also superior (48% versus 26%, P = 0.008). Acute treatment-related toxicities included one death due to renal damage and two patients with life-threatening renal damage. The delivery of radiotherapy was not altered. Late toxicity included necrosis -3%, fibrosis -4%, and one fistula. The results of this study justify a randomized trial for the comparison of this combination of cisplatin and radiotherapy versus radiotherapy alone in advanced mucosal carcinomas of the head and neck.     

Definitive irradiation and chemotherapy for radiosensitization in management of anal carcinoma: interim report on Radiation Therapy Oncology Group study no. 8314

Following documented evidence of the synergism of 5-fluorouracil (5-FU) and radiation therapy and an additive effect with mitomycin and irradiation, pilot studies have demonstrated the potential for definitive radiation therapy in the management of squamous cell and basaloid carcinomas of the anal canal, allowing sphincter preservation. Our study explored the long-term effectiveness of combined therapy at this disease site and examined the feasibility of a Radiation Therapy Oncology Group study involving concomitant radiation therapy and chemotherapy. Between 1983 and 1987, 79 assessable patients with any primary tumor stage of anal canal carcinoma were treated by external-beam irradiation combined with mitomycin given by bolus iv injection and 5-FU given by continuous infusion. Radiation was delivered to the perineum and pelvis to a total dose of 4,080 cGy in 4.5-5 weeks. The inguinal nodal areas received 4,080 cGy, calculated at a 3-cm depth in the center of the nodal area. A 96-hour infusion of 5-FU was started on days 2 and 28 of the irradiation at a dose of 1,000 mg/m2 over 24 hours, and a bolus injection of mitomycin was administered on day 2 at a dose of 10 mg/m2. The overall survival rates are 97% at 1 year and 73% at 3 years. Patients with lesions less than 3 cm in diameter and those treated strictly according to the protocol did significantly better than those with larger lesions and those whose treatment did not comply with the protocol. The interim outcome of the study demonstrates that this combined therapy is effective for patients with anal cancer and allows preservation of the sphincter and of sexual function.     

Superiority of adriamycin-containing combination chemotherapy in the treatment of diffuse lymphoma: a Southwest Oncology Group study.

As a part of an ongoing prospective controlled trial, the Southwest Oncology Group compared the results of treatment of advanced non-Hodgkin's lymphoma with two CHOP regimens (cyclophosphamide, adriamycin, vincristine and prednisone with either low-dose bleomycin or BCG by scarification) to a COP regimen (cyclophosphamide, vincristine and prednisone) with low-dose bleomycin (COP-Bleo). The study design emphasized histopathology review and systematic restaging to define complete remission (CR). Confirmed rates of CR for 443 evaluable patients were 59% for 286 patients receiving the CHOP regimens and 59% for 157 patients receiving COP-Bleo. Rates of CR were higher for patients with nodular lymphoma (69%) compared to those with diffuse lymphoma (54%) (p = 0.005). For patients with nodular lymphoma there was no difference in CR rates according to treatment. For patients with diffuse lymphomas the CR rate was higher with the CHOP programs (58%) than with COP-Bleo (44%) (p = 0.10). Overall duration of CR and survival was significantly longer for patients with nodular lymphoma compared to diffuse lymphoma (p less than 0.01). At this time, remission duration and survival were similar regardless of induction regimen used in patients with nodular lymphoma. However, in patients with diffuse lymphoma, the duration of CR and overall survival were improved by treatment with the CHOP regimens compared to COP-Bleo (p = 0.02). Thus, in this controlled study we have demonstrated that initial combination chemotherapy employing the CHOP regimen was a superior remission induction therapy for patients with diffuse lymphoma.     

T1-2 anal carcinoma requires elective inguinal radiation treatment - The results of Trans Tasman Radiation Oncology Group study TROG 99.02

Background and purpose

Elective inguinal irradiation increases morbidity. We describe outcomes of moderate intensity chemoradiation treating anal canal and adjacent pelvic nodes only.

Material and methods

Forty patients with T1-2, N0 anal carcinoma were enrolled between March 1999 and March 2003. Inguinal nodes were NOT electively irradiated. The anal canal and regional pelvic nodes received 36 Gy/20# over 4 weeks, and 2 weeks later the anal canal was boosted with 14.4 Gy/8#. Chemotherapy was 5 fluorouracil 800 mg/m²/day on days 1-4 and 36-39, and Mitomycin C 10 mg/m² on day 1.

Results

Median follow-up was 44 months. Complete response was 95%. Four year results were; overall survival 71%, local control 82%, and colostomy-free survival (including salvage) 85%. Inguinal failure occurred in 22.5% but was isolated in only 12.5%. Treatment was well tolerated acutely with no toxic deaths. Severe late toxicity occurred in 7.5%.

Conclusions

This moderate dose ‘non inguinal’ chemoradiation regimen resulted in modest acute toxicity, minimal long term morbidity and local control in line with other series. However staging failed to identify 12.5% of patients whose isolated inguinal failure might have been prevented by elective irradiation. Without more effective staging, all patients should receive elective inguinal irradiation.     

Comparison of postoperative radiotherapy and combined postoperative radiotherapy and chemotherapy in the multidisciplinary management of malignant gliomas. A joint Radiation Therapy Oncology Group and Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group study

Recently, the RTOG and ECOG concluded a joint randomized study on malignant gliomas that was in progress for the past five years. A total of 626 patients entered this protocol. Sixty-seven percent of the 535 evaluable patients have died and thus this represents a preliminary report of a major joint clinical trial. The objective of this study was to evaluate the efficacy after neurosurgery of three new treatment options as compared with control treatment of radiotherapy alone. The four options were: (1) control radiation; 6000 rad/6-7 weeks to whole brain; (2) a higher radiation dose; Control dose plus a booster dose of 1000 rad/1-2 weeks to the tumor; (3) control radiation dose plus BCNU (80 mg/m2/day IV X 3 and repeat BCNU every 8 weeks); (4) Control radiation dose plus combination methyl-CCNU (125 mg/m2/day orally X 1 and repeat methyl-CCNU every 8 weeks), and DTIC (150 mg/m2/day IV X 5 and repeat DTIC every 4 weeks). All pertinent patient characteristics were studied and several important prognostic factors have been identified. Notably, age, histologic type (Astrocytoma with anaplastic foci, versus glioblastoma multiforme), initial performance status, time since first symptoms and presence or absence of seizure. At this time, it appeared that there was no treatment option which was significantly better than the control. The study identified that age was the most important prognostic factor. Patients who were younger than age 40 years had an 18-month survival of 64%, patients who were age 40-60 years had an 18-month survival of 20%, and patients who were older than age 60 had an 18-month survival of 8%. The study also demonstrated that a modified histologic classification of anaplastic astrocytoma versus glioblastoma provided better prognostic information than the astrocytoma grading system of Kernohan. Patients with anaplastic astrocytoma had a median survival of 27 months as compared to 8 months for patients with glioblastoma. In further evaluation of any beneficial effect of chemotherapy, it was identified that only among the 40-60-year-old groups, BCNU treated patients appeared to have significantly increased survival than patients in the control groups (P = 0.01, one-sided). Similarly, methyl-CCNU + DTIC was suggestively better than the control (P = 0.08, one-sided). The higher radiation dose, 7000 rad/8-9 weeks appeared to give no significantly better survival over the control dose option. Both BCNU and methyl-CCNU + DTIC produced some toxicity. The combination of methyl-CCNU + DTIC was more toxic than BCNU, producing severe or worse thrombocytopenia in 23% of the patients as compared to 6% on BCNU.     

Randomized phase III study comparing irradiation and hyperthermia with irradiation alone in superficial measurable tumors. Final report by the Radiation Therapy Oncology Group

A total of 307 patients with superficial measurable tumors were registered on a Radiation Therapy Oncology Group (RTOG) protocol involving fractionated radiation therapy, either alone or followed immediately by hyperthermia (42.5 degrees C, 45-60 min). Overall complete response (CR) was observed in 30% of the lesions treated with radiotherapy (RT) and 32% of those receiving RT and heat. Response was found to be significantly related to both maximum tumor diameter (less than 3 or greater than or equal to 3 cm) and site/histology (breast/adenocarcinoma, head and neck/squamous, or other site/histologies). In tumors less than 3 cm in diameter in the breast, trunk, and extremities, a better CR rate was noted with irradiation and heat (62 and 67%) than with irradiation alone (40 and 0%). However, in the head and neck there was only minimal difference in CR with irradiation alone or combined with hyperthermia (50 vs 38%). In lesions less than 3 cm treated with irradiation and heat, there was improved local control. In lesions greater than 3 cm, there was no difference in local control between the two treatment arms. The higher response rate in patients with smaller lesions (less than 3 cm) may be explained by the fact that these tumors are easier to heat. Problems in correlating tumor response with quality of heating include less than optimal heating in larger lesions and the limited ability of current thermometry to map the temperature distribution in a tumor. Acute and late toxicities in both treatment arms were comparable, except for an overall 30% incidence of thermal blisters in the heated tumors.