Applicator reconstruction in MRI 3D image-based dose planning of brachytherapy for cervical cancer

Background and purpose

To elaborate a method for applicator reconstruction for MRI-based brachytherapy for cervical cancer.

Materials and methods

Custom-made plastic catheters with a copper sulphate solution were made for insertion in the source channels of MR-CT compatible applicators: plastic and titanium tandem ring applicators, and titanium needles. The applicators were CT and MR scanned in a phantom for accurate 3D assessment of applicator visibility and geometry. A reconstruction method was developed and evaluated in 19 patient MR examinations with ring applicator (plastic: 14, titanium: 5). MR applicator reconstruction uncertainties related to inter-observer variation were evaluated.

Results

The catheters were visible in the plastic applicator on T1-weighted images in phantom and in 14/14 clinical applications. On T2-weighted images, the catheters appeared weaker but still visible in phantom and in 13/14 MR clinical applications. In the titanium applicator, the catheters could not be separated from the artifacts from the applicator itself. However, these artifacts could be used to localize both titanium ring applicator (5/5 clinical applications) and needles (6/6 clinical applications). Standard deviations of inter-observer differences were below 2 mm in all directions.

Conclusion

3D applicator reconstruction based on MR imaging could be performed for plastic and titanium applicators. Plastic applicators proved well to be suited for MRI-based reconstruction. For improved practicability of titanium applicator reconstruction, development of MR applicator markers is essential. Reconstruction of titanium applicator and needles at 1.5 T MR requires geometric evaluations in phantoms before using the applicator in patients.     

Applicator reconstruction and applicator shifts in 3D MR-based PDR brachytherapy of cervical cancer

Purpose

To evaluate the methods of applicator reconstruction in 3D MR-based planning for brachytherapy of cervical cancer, and to investigate applicator shifts and changes in DVH parameters during PDR treatment.

Methods

For each application MR scans with applicator in situ were made: three T2-weighted (4.5 mm slices) Turbo Spin Echo (TSE) scans and a balanced Steady State Free Precession scan (1.5 mm). Three observers tested two applicator reconstruction methods: (A) directly on the bSSFP scan and (B) on a resampled combination of the three T2-weighted scans. For 10 patients MR imaging was repeated on the second day of each PDR fraction to determine applicator shifts and changes in DVH parameters.

Results

For both applicator reconstruction methods the interobserver variation for the DVH parameters was comparable (average <1.5% in dose). Differences between the two methods were larger (up to 6.4% for target) and were related to position differences during MR scanning.The average applicator shift relative to the pelvic structures was 5-6 mm into the ventral direction and 3-4 mm cranially. For a single PDR fraction, the average D90 (HR-CTV) on ‘day 2’ was 0.2 (SD 2.0) Gy lower than that for day 1. The average increase in D_2cc (bladder) was 1.0 (SD 3.0) Gy_αβ3 for a single PDR fraction. If the effect of both fractions was combined, for 1 patient a total decrease of D90 of 7 Gy_αβ10 was found, whereas for another patient the total increase in bladder dose was 12 Gy_αβ3.

Conclusions

Applicator reconstruction on MR data is feasible. In the overall accuracy during PDR brachytherapy the reconstruction uncertainty is of minor importance. Applicator and/or organ movement during the course of the PDR fraction produce larger uncertainties.     

Exclusive MRI-based tandem and colpostats reconstruction in gynaecological brachytherapy treatment planning

Purpose

According to the GYN GEC-ESTRO Recommendations, MRI is needed with the modality of T2 weighted. CT-MR compatible tandem plus colpostats (T/C) (Nucletron) is widely used in cervical brachytherapy. The major challenge of MRI is the lack of dummy catheters. Therefore, an additional imaging modality is usually required. One disadvantage of sliced-based reconstruction is that resolution in longitudinal directions can be affected by the slice thickness. The aim of this study is to present a modified T/C applicator in which the catheter visibility is significantly improved.

Methods and materials

A modification to the existing T/C applicator has been made available, increasing the catheter entrance diameter. It allows a greater dummy catheter diameter, and consequently it can be filled with more material per unit length. Visibility was studied with different materials.

Results

The catheter filled with saline water plus iodine compound was clearly seen in both axial and longitudinal acquisitions. To avoid uncertainties introduced by the slice thickness, a simple procedure is presented using longitudinal acquisitions.

Conclusions

The modified applicator plus catheter allows a powerful signal in T2 weighted MRI, using a very simple and accessible material. Also, a method is proposed to solve the problem of the uncertainty derived from slice thickness using few longitudinal acquisitions.     

Unintended exposure in radiotherapy: Identification of prominent causes

Background and purpose

Unintended exposures in radiotherapy are likely to occur when certain conditions that favour such exposures exist. Based on the frequency of occurrence of various causes of 100 events of unintended exposures in radiotherapy as derived from the analysis of published reports, a checklist for assessing the vulnerability of radiotherapy facilities for potential accidents has been prepared. The list presents items to be considered for safety critical assessments of a radiotherapy department for the improvement of patient safety and the entire radiotherapy processes.

Materials and methods

The resources used for this paper consist of 100 unintended radiotherapy exposures and were derived from existing published reports. The analysis was performed by forming two templates: one consisting of 10 initiating events and another of 35 contributing factors.

Results

Four most prominent initiating events were identified and together accounted for about 70% of all the unintended exposure events. Ten most prominent contributing factors were also identified and together accounted for about 70% of all the radiotherapy unintended exposure events covered under this study.

Conclusion

With this knowledge of high frequency of occurrences, the identified four prominent initiating events and the 10 most prominent contributing factors must be checked and dealt with as a matter of priority when assessing the safety of a radiotherapy facility. A simple checklist for checking the quality assurance programmes of a radiotherapy department for every aspect of the design and delivery of radiation have been provided.     

Determining DVH parameters for combined external beam and brachytherapy treatment: 3D biological dose adding for patients with cervical cancer

Purpose

To compare two methods of DVH parameter determination for combined external beam and brachytherapy treatment of cervical cancer.

Materials and methods

Clinical treatment plans from five patients were used in this study. We simulated two applications given with PDR (32 × 60 cGy per application, given hourly) or HDR (4 × 7 Gy in two applications; each application of two fractions of 7 Gy, given within 17 h) standard and optimised treatment plans, all combined with IMRT (25 × 1.8 Gy). Additionally, we simulated an external beam (EBRT) boost to pathological lymph nodes or the parametrium (7 × 2 Gy).We determined D90 of the high-risk CTV (HR-CTV) and D_2cc of bladder and rectum in EQD2 in two ways. (1) ‘Parameter adding’: assuming a uniform contribution of the EBRT dose distribution and adding the values of DVH parameters for the two brachytherapy insertions, and (2) ‘distributions adding’: summing 3D biological dose distributions of IMRT and brachytherapy plans and subsequently determining the values of the DVH parameters. We took α/β = 10 Gy for HR-CTV, α/β = 3 Gy otherwise and half-time of repair 1.5 h.

Results

Without EBRT boost, ‘parameter adding’ yielded a good approximation. With an EBRT boost to lymph nodes, the total D90 HR-CTV was underestimated by 2.6 (SD 1.3)% for PDR and 2.8 (SD 1.4)% for HDR. This was even worse with a parametrium boost: 9.1 (SD 6.2)% for PDR and 9.9 (SD 6.2)% for HDR.

Conclusion

Without an EBRT boost ‘parameter adding’, as proposed by the GEC-ESTRO, yielded accurate results for the values for DVH parameters. If an EBRT boost is given ‘distributions adding’ should be considered.     

MRI-guided treatment-planning optimisation in intracavitary or combined intracavitary/interstitial PDR brachytherapy using tandem ovoid applicators in locally advanced cervical cancer

Purpose

To study the impact of MRI-guided treatment planning on dose/volume parameters in pulsed dose rate (PDR) brachytherapy (BT) for cervical cancer. Additionally, we investigated the potential benefit of an intracavitary/interstitial (IC/IS) modification of the classical tandem ovoid applicator.

Material and methods

For 24 patients we compared Standard PDR BT plans, Scaled Standard plans and MRI-guided Optimised plans. The total EBRT/BT prescribed dose to Manchester point A or to 90% of the HR-CTV (D90 HR-CTV) [1] expressed in EQD₂ was 80 Gy_αβ10 in 17 patients (Period I) and 84 Gy_αβ10 in 7 patients (Period II). The constraints to 2 cm³ of the OAR were 90 Gy_αβ3 for bladder and 75 Gy_αβ3 for rectum, sigmoid and bowel. Most cases were treated with a traditional intracavitary tandem ovoid applicator. In 6 patients we used a newly designed combined IC/IS modification for the second PDR fraction and investigated the benefit of the interstitial part.

Results

The average gain of MRI-guided optimisation expressed in D90 HR-CTV was 4 ± 9 Gy_αβ10 (p < 0.001) and 10 ± 7 Gy_αβ10 (p = 0.003) in the two periods. The dose to 2 cm³ of the OAR met the constraints. In the group that was treated with the combined IC/IS approach, we could increase the D90 HR-CTV for the second PDR fraction with 5.4 ± 4.2 Gy_αβ10 (p = 0.005) and the D100 with 4.8 ± 3.1 Gy_αβ10 (p = 0.07).

Conclusions

Three-dimensional MRI-guided treatment planning and optimisation improves the DVH parameters compared to conventional planning strategies. Additional improvement can be achieved by using a combined IC/IS approach.     

Localization of the surgical bed using supine magnetic resonance and computed tomography scan fusion for planification of breast interstitial brachytherapy

Purpose

To evaluate the feasibility of supine breast magnetic resonance imaging (MR) for definition and localization of the surgical bed (SB) after breast conservative surgery. To assess the inter-observer variability of surgical bed delineation on computed tomography (CT) and supine MR.

Materials and methods

Patients candidate for breast brachytherapy and no contra-indications for MR were eligible for this study. Patients were placed in supine position, with the ipsilateral arm above the head in an immobilization device. All patients underwent CT and MR in the same implant/treatment position. Four points were predefined for CT-MRI image fusion. The surgical cavity was drawn on CT then MRI, by three independent observers. Fusion and analysis of CT and MR images were performed using the ECLIPSE treatment planning software.

Results

From September 2005 to November 2008, 70 patients were included in this prospective study. For each patient, we were able to acquire axial T1 and T2 images of good quality. Using the predefined fusion points, the median error following the fusion was 2.7 mm. For each observer, volumes obtained on MR were, respectively, 30%, 38% and 40% smaller than those derived from CT images. A highly significant inter-observer variability in the delineation of the SB on CT was demonstrated (p < 0.0001). On the contrary, all three observers agreed on the volume of the SB drawn on MR.

Conclusion

Supine breast MRI yields a more precise definition of the SB with a smaller inter-observer variability than CT and may obviate the need for surgical clips. The volume of the SB is smaller with MRI. In our opinion, CT-MRI fusion should be used for SB delineation, in view of partial breast irradiation.     

High-dose preoperative chemoradiotherapy in esophageal cancer patients does not increase postoperative pulmonary complications: Correlation with dose-volume histogram parameters

Purpose

To investigate the association of high-dose preoperative chemoradiotherapy (CRT) and dose-volume histogram (DVH) parameters of lungs with incidence of postoperative pulmonary complications and to identify predictive clinical factors of pulmonary complications.

Methods

Data of 65 patients were collected retrospectively. Thirty-five patients underwent transthoracic esophagectomy (TTE) alone and 30 received cisplatin and 5-fluorouracil, concomitant with radiotherapy, median dose 66 Gy, and followed by TTE. From the DVH for each lung alone and for both lungs together as one organ we generated total lung volume, mean radiotherapy dose, relative and absolute volumes receiving more than a threshold dose, and relative and absolute volumes receiving less than a threshold dose. Postoperative pulmonary complications were defined as pneumonia or respiratory failure.

Results

Sixty percent of the patients in the TTE alone group had postoperative pulmonary complications versus 63% in the CRT + TTE group. Postoperative mortality was 8.6% and 16.7% in the respective patient groups (p = NS). None of the DVH parameters was associated with postoperative pulmonary complications. Squamous cell carcinoma was an adverse factor related to increased postoperative pulmonary complications.

Conclusion

High-dose preoperative CRT was not associated with increased postoperative pulmonary complications in this cohort of esophageal cancer patients.     

The effect of alternative biological modelling parameters (α/β and half time of repair T1/2) on reported EQD2 values in the treatment of advanced cervical cancer

Purpose

To evaluate the effect of different α/β and half-time of repair T_½ on the assessment of clinical treatment plans for patients with cervical cancer.

Materials and methods

We used EBRT and BT treatment plans of five patients, planned with MRI guided BT. We computed 3D EQD2 dose distributions of combined EBRT and BT treatments and calculated D90 of high-risk clinical target volume (HR-CTV) and D_2cc for bladder and rectum, and the ratio D_2cc(bladder)/D90(HR-CTV). BT was modelled as PDR (two applications of 32 × 60 cGy) and HDR (two applications of 2 × 7 Gy). We assumed a low, standard and high value for the biological parameters: HR-CTV α/β = 5/10/15 Gy and T_½ = 0.5/1.5/2.5 h; OAR α/β = 2/3/4 Gy; T_½ = 0.5/1.5/4.5 h.

Results

The chosen variation in modelling parameters had a much larger effect on PDR treatments than on HDR treatments, especially for OAR, thus creating larger uncertainties. The relative mean range of the ratio D_2cc(bladder)/D90(HR-CTV) is 72% for PDR and 25% for HDR. Out of the 125 modelled combinations 48 PDR plans and 23 HDR plans comply with clinical objectives.

Conclusion

For HDR brachytherapy, only α/β has a significant impact on reported EQD2 values, whereas for PDR both α/β and T_1/2 are important.Generally, the ratio D_2cc(bladder)/D90(HR-CTV) is more favourable for PDR, even considering the larger uncertainties in EQD2.     

Analysis of dose-volume histogram parameters for radiation pneumonitis after definitive concurrent chemoradiotherapy for esophageal cancer

Purpose

To evaluate dose-volume histogram (DVH) parameters as predictors of radiation pneumonitis (RP) in esophageal cancer patients treated with definitive concurrent chemoradiotherapy.

Patients and methods

Thirty-seven esophageal cancer patients treated with radiotherapy with concomitant chemotherapy consisting of 5-fluorouracil and cisplatin were reviewed. Radiotherapy was delivered at 2 Gy per fraction to a total of 60 Gy. For most of the patients, two weeks of interruption was scheduled after 30 Gy. The percentage of lung volume receiving more than 5-50 Gy in increments of 5 Gy (V5-V50, respectively), and the mean lung dose (MLD) were analyzed.

Results

Ten (27%) patients developed RP of grade 2; 2 (5%), grade 3; 0 (0%), grade 4; and 1 (3%), grade 5. By univariate analysis, all DVH parameters (i.e., V5-V50 and MLD) were significantly associated with grade ?2 RP (p < 0.01). The incidences of grade ?2 RP were 13%, 33%, and 78% in patients with V20s of ?24%, 25-36%, and ?37%, respectively. The optimal V20 threshold to predict symptomatic RP was 30.5% according to the receiver operating characteristics curve analysis.

Conclusion

DVH parameters were predictors of symptomatic RP and should be considered in the evaluation of treatment planning for esophageal cancer.     

A phase II trial of accelerated hypofractionated three-dimensional conformal radiation therapy in locally advanced non-small cell lung cancer

Purpose

The aim of this study is to evaluate the safety and efficacy of accelerated hypofractionated radiotherapy (HypoRT) combined with sequential chemotherapy in locally advanced non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC).

Materials and methods

A total of 34 patients with stage III NSCLC were enrolled. All patients received accelerated HypoRT (initially 50 Gy/20 fractions, then a fraction dose of 3 Gy) using three-dimensional conformal radiation therapy (3D-CRT), omitting elective nodal irradiation (ENI), to a total dose of 65-68 Gy. All patients received two cycles of induction chemotherapy; 1-2 cycles of consolidation chemotherapy were given to 31 patients. The primary outcome measure was a profile of radiation toxicity. The secondary endpoints included overall survival (OS), progression-free survival (PFS), locoregional PFS (LR-PFS) and the pattern of initial failure.

Results

Radiation toxicity was minimal. The median and 3-year OS, PFS were 19.0 months, 32.1%; 10.0 months, 29.8%, respectively. The 1-, 2-, and 3-year LR-PFS were 69.6%, 60.9% and 60.9%, respectively. No patient experienced isolated elective nodal failure as the first site of failure.

Conclusion

This study suggests that accelerated HypoRT using 3D-CRT omitting ENI can be used in combination with sequential chemotherapy in locally advanced NSCLC.     

The effect of delineation method and observer variability on bladder dose-volume histograms for prostate intensity modulated radiotherapy

Purpose

To quantify the effect of delineation method on bladder DVH, observer variability (OV) and contouring time for prostate IMRT plans.

Materials and methods

Planning CT scans and IMRT plans of 30 prostate cancer patients were anonymized. For 20 patients, 1 observer delineated the bladder using 9 methods. The effect of delineation method on the DVH curve, discrete dose levels and delineation time was quantified. For the 10 remaining CTs, 6 observers delineated bladder wall using 4 methods. Observer-based volume variation and intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) were used to describe the dosimetric effects of OV.

Results

Manual delineation of the bladder wall (BW_m) was significantly slower than any other method (mean: 20 min vs. ?13 min) and the dosimetric effect of OV was significantly larger (V70 Gy ICC: 0.78 vs. 0.98). Only volumes created using a 2.5 mm contraction from the outer surface, and a method providing a consistent wall volume, showed no notable dosimetric differences from BW_m in both absolute and relative volume.

Conclusions

Automatic contractions from the outer surface provide quicker, more reproducible and reasonably accurate substitutes for BW_m. The widespread use of automatic contractions to create a bladder wall volume would assist in the consistent application of IMRT dose constraints and the interpretation of reported dose.     

Does the planning dose-volume histogram represent treatment doses in image-guided prostate radiation therapy? Assessment with cone-beam computerised tomography scans

Purpose

To assess the accuracy of the initial CT plan dose-volume histograms (DVH’s) for prostate, rectum and bladder by comparison to delivered doses determined from cone beam CT (CBCT) scans acquired during image-guided treatment.

Materials and methods

Twelve prostate patients were treated using daily implanted fiducial guidance and following local protocol for bladder and rectal preparation. CBCT scans were acquired twice weekly and contoured for prostate, rectum and bladder. The planned beams were applied to all CBCT scans to determine the delivered doses. Prostate dose coverage was assessed by the proportion of the CTV fully encompassed by the 95% and 98% isodose lines. Rectal and bladder volumes receiving 40 Gy, 60 Gy and 70 Gy at treatment were compared to the initial plan, with significance determined using the one-sample t-test.

Results

Four patients showed marginally compromised CTV coverage by the 95% isodose at all CBCT plans. For nine patients the initial plan rectal DVH was significantly outside the range of the treatment DVH’s.

Conclusions

Dose coverage of the prostate was not achieved for all patients. Observed rectal and bladder doses were higher than predicted. The initial treatment plan cannot be assumed to represent accurate normal tissue doses.     

Triple angiokinase inhibition, tumour hypoxia and radiation response of FaDu human squamous cell carcinomas

Background and purpose

To test the effect of BIBF 1120, a novel small molecule inhibitor of multiple angiogenic receptor tyrosine kinases, on the hypoxia and radiation response of tumours.

Materials and methods

Poorly differentiated human squamous cell carcinoma FaDu growing in nude mice was treated with BIBF 1120 and investigated by functional histology. To test the effect of BIBF 1120 on the radiobiological hypoxic fraction (rHF), the number and intrinsic radiation sensitivity of tumour stem cells and the outcome after fractionated irradiation, a series of local tumour control assays were performed.

Results

BIBF 1120 significantly reduced the vessel area, vessel area with a perfusion signal and tumour growth rate but did not affect tumour hypoxia or the number and intrinsic radiation sensitivity of tumour stem cells. Concurrent BIBF 1120 had no effect on local tumour control after fractionated irradiation.

Conclusion

Triple angiokinase inhibition resulted in a clear-cut decrease of angiogenesis, vessel area with a perfusion signal and tumour growth but did not change tumour hypoxia or radiation response of tumour stem cells. Further experiments into mechanisms of interaction between anti-angiogenic strategies and irradiation appear to be necessary to better define and exploit the potential of this strategy to improve local tumour control after fractionated radiotherapy.     

Improving target delineation on 4-dimensional CT scans in stage I NSCLC using a deformable registration tool

Introduction

Correct target definition is crucial in stereotactic radiotherapy for lung tumors. We evaluated use of deformable registration (DR) for target contouring on 4-dimensional (4D) CT scans.

Materials and methods

Three clinicians contoured gross tumor volume (GTV) in an end-inspiration phase of 4DCT of 6 patients on two occasions. Two clinicians contoured GTVs in all phases of 4DCT and on maximum intensity projections (MIP). The initial GTV was auto-propagated to 9 other phases using a B-spline algorithm (VelocityAI). Internal target volumes (ITVs) generated were (i) ITV_10manual encompassing all physician-contoured GTVs, (ii) ITV-MIP_optimized from MIP after review of individual 4DCT phases, (iii) ITV_10deformed encompassing auto-propagated GTVs using DR, and (iv) ITV_{10deformed-optimized}, from an ITV_10deformed target that was modified to form a ‘clinically optimal’ ITV. Volume-overlaps were scored using Dice’s Similarity Coefficients (DSCs).

Results

Intra-clinician GTV reproducibility was greater than inter-clinician reproducibility (mean DSC 0.93 vs. 0.88, p < 0.0004). In five of 6 patients, ITV-MIP_optimized differed from the ITV_{10deformed-optimized}. In all patients, the DSC between ITV_{10deformed-optimized} and ITV_10deformed was higher than that between ITV_{10deformed-optimized} and ITV-MIP_optimized (p < 0.02 T-test).

Conclusion

ITVs created in stage I tumors using DR were closer to ‘clinically optimal’ ITVs than was the case with a MIP-modified approach.     

Intrafraction motion in patients with cervical cancer: The benefit of soft tissue registration using MRI

Background and purpose

During radiation delivery, target volumes change their position and shape due to intrafraction motion. The extent of these changes and the capability to correct for them will contribute to the benefit of an MRI-accelerator in terms of PTV margin reduction. Therefore, we investigated the primary CTV motion within a typical IMRT delivery time for cervical cancer patients for various correction techniques: no registration, rigid bony anatomy registration, and rigid soft tissue registration.

Materials and methods

Twenty-two patients underwent 2-3 offline MRI exams before and during their radiation treatment. Each MRI exam included four sagittal and four axial MRI scans alternately within 16 min. We addressed the CTV motion by comparing subsequent midsagittal CTV delineations and investigated the correlation with intrafraction bladder filling.

Results

The maximum (residual) motions within 16 min for all points on the CTV contour for 90% of the MRI exams without registration, with rigid bony anatomy registration, and with rigid soft tissue registration were 10.6, 9.9, and 4.0 mm. A significant but weak correlation was found between intrafraction bladder filling and CTV motion.

Conclusions

Considerable intrafraction CTV motion is observed in cervical cancer patients. Intrafraction MRI-guided soft tissue registration using an MRI-accelerator will correct for this motion.     

MRI-guided prostate radiation therapy planning: Investigation of dosimetric accuracy of MRI-based dose planning

Background and purpose

Dose planning requires a CT scan which provides the electron density distribution for dose calculation. MR provides superior soft tissue contrast compared to CT and the use of MR-alone for prostate planning would provide further benefits such as lower cost to the patient. This study compares the accuracy of MR-alone based dose calculations with bulk electron density assignment to CT-based dose calculations for prostate radiotherapy.

Materials and methods

CT and whole pelvis MR images were contoured for 39 prostate patients. Plans with uniform density and plans with bulk density values assigned to bone and tissue were compared to the patient’s gold standard full density CT plan. The optimal bulk density for bone was calculated using effective depth measurements. The plans were evaluated using ICRU point doses, dose volume histograms, and Chi comparisons. Differences in spatial uniformity were investigated for the CT and MR scans.

Results

The calculated dose for CT bulk bone and tissue density plans was 0.1 ± 0.6% (mean ± 1 SD) higher than the corresponding full density CT plan. MR bulk bone and tissue density plans were 1.3 ± 0.8% lower than the full density CT plan. CT uniform density plans and MR uniform density plans were 1.4 ± 0.9% and 2.6 ± 0.9% lower, respectively. Paired t-tests performed on specific points on the DVH graphs showed that points on DVHs for all bulk electron density plans were equivalent with two exceptions. There was no significant difference between doses calculated on Pinnacle and Eclipse. The dose distributions of six patients produced Chi values outside the acceptable range of values when MR-based plans were compared to the full density plan.

Conclusions

MR-alone bulk density planning is feasible provided bone is assigned a density, however, manual segmentation of bone on MR images will have to be replaced with automatic methods. The major dose differences for MR bulk density plans are due to differences in patient external contours introduced by the MR couch-top and pelvic coil.     

Identifying afterloading PDR and HDR brachytherapy errors using real-time fiber-coupled Al2O3:C dosimetry and a novel statistical error decision criterion

Background and purpose

The feasibility of a real-time in vivo dosimeter to detect errors has previously been demonstrated. The purpose of this study was to: (1) quantify the sensitivity of the dosimeter to detect imposed treatment errors under well controlled and clinically relevant experimental conditions, and (2) test a new statistical error decision concept based on full uncertainty analysis.

Materials and methods

Phantom studies of two gynecological cancer PDR and one prostate cancer HDR patient treatment plans were performed using tandem ring applicators or interstitial needles. Imposed treatment errors, including interchanged pairs of afterloader guide tubes and 2-20 mm source displacements, were monitored using a real-time fiber-coupled carbon doped aluminum oxide (Al₂O₃:C) crystal dosimeter that was positioned in the reconstructed tumor region. The error detection capacity was evaluated at three dose levels: dwell position, source channel, and fraction. The error criterion incorporated the correlated source position uncertainties and other sources of uncertainty, and it was applied both for the specific phantom patient plans and for a general case (source-detector distance 5-90 mm and position uncertainty 1-4 mm).

Results

Out of 20 interchanged guide tube errors, time-resolved analysis identified 17 while fraction level analysis identified two. Channel and fraction level comparisons could leave 10 mm dosimeter displacement errors unidentified. Dwell position dose rate comparisons correctly identified displacements ?5 mm.

Conclusion

This phantom study demonstrates that Al₂O₃:C real-time dosimetry can identify applicator displacements ?5 mm and interchanged guide tube errors during PDR and HDR brachytherapy. The study demonstrates the shortcoming of a constant error criterion and the advantage of a statistical error criterion.