Advantages of patellar resurfacing in total knee arthroplasty

Complications of patellar resurfacing in total knee arthroplasty have rekindled the interest of many surgeons in patellar retention. In a prospective study 20 randomly selected patients of 40 underwent patellar resurfacing in combination with their total knee arthroplasty. The other 20 patients were left with an unresurfaced patella. Within 24 months of follow-up, the advantages of patellar resurfacing could be seen according to the Knee Society Score. Especially in advanced osteoarthritis of the knee joint, the patients achieved better scores in climbing stairs and in function. The superior functional results are arguments for patellar resurfacing, at least in knees with advanced osteoarthritis.     

Technique for patellar resurfacing in total knee arthroplasty

The proper size of the patellar component for a total knee arthroplasty can be determined with the use of a caliper. The thickness of the patella is measured prior to removing the articular surface and again after the trial component has been inserted into the patella. The measurements should be approximately the same in thickness. It is important to select the proper patellar component to avoid loss of flexion of the knee, a very prominent patella, and postoperative subluxation of the patella.     

The role of patellar resurfacing in total knee arthroplasty

The ideal treatment of the patella in primary total knee arthroplasty (TKA) for osteoarthritis (OA) remains unclear. Although data exist in the literature to support either resurfacing or not resurfacing the patella, evidence continues to emerge that unresurfaced patellas deteriorate with time. Recent prospective, randomized studies also favor patellar resurfacing over retaining the native patella, reporting reoperation rates to convert unresurfaced to resurfaced patellas exceeding those for complications after patellar resurfacing. In addition, the incidence of residual patellofemoral pain after secondary resurfacing is substantially higher than when patellofemoral resurfacing is done primarily. Patient selection criteria are critical in the decision-making process. Patellofemoral complications, the greatest argument against resurfacing, have been diminished with improved surgical techniques and implant design.     

The need for patellar resurfacing in total knee arthroplasty: a literature review

The controversy over whether or not to routinely resurface the patella during a total knee arthroplasty has persisted despite three decades of successful joint replacement procedures. Advocates for routine patellar resurfacing admit the occasional need for secondary patellar resurfacing and declare increased incidence of anterior knee pain in patients with non‐resurfaced patellae as a cause for worry. Surgeons that leave the patella unresurfaced cite avoidance of complications that include patellar fracture, avascular necrosis, patellar tendon injury and instability. This review discusses the available literature on patellar resurfacing through an evidence‐based analysis of randomized and pseudo‐randomized controlled trials and published meta‐analyses to date. The published literature seems to favour resurfacing the patellar routinely. Selective patellar resurfacing would be the ideal solution if sound pre‐operative criteria could be established. So far, a method for accurately predicting which patients can avoid patellar resurfacing has not been found. Future research looking at patellar resurfacing should concentrate on developing criteria for selecting those patients that would benefit from patellar resurfacing and those that would do as well without resurfacing, and thus, limiting potential surgical complications.     

Evidence in orthopaedics: patellar resurfacing in total knee arthroplasty

Abstract Four good quality randomized clinical trials comparing patellar resurfacing versus noresurfacing in knee arthroplasty are analyzed. The outcomes evaluated were anterior knee pain, scores on the Knee Societys rating system and reoperation.No relevant differences were found in knee scores, but anterior knee pain was less frequent in patients with patellar resurfacing. Few patients had severe anterior knee pain. Still, patients with anterior knee pain were less satisfied with the clinical result. Studies with longer follow-up showed that anterior knee pain increased with time in both groups. A clinically relevant increase in reoperation rate in the nonresurfaced group could not be excluded with the numbers available.Anterior knee pain seems to be influenced by the decision of resurfacing the patella during knee arthoplasty. Although it is not associated with important changes in knee scores, patients perceive it as a cause of insatisfaction. Influence of patellar resurfacing on implant supervivence is not clear.     

Patellar clunk syndrome in total knee arthroplasty without patellar resurfacing

In a series of 647 total knee arthroplasties, the patella was not resurfaced if bony geometry of the patella was good enough to maintain good congruency of the patella undersurface to the femoral component and the patella was tracking normally at the femoral component groove at the time of surgery. Three hundred seventy-two total knee arthroplasties were done with a femoral component that had the same geometry as the original total condylar prosthesis. None of these knees resulted in patellar catching, whether the patella was resurfaced or not. Two hundred seventy-five total knee arthroplasties were done with a more contemporary femoral component with wider intercondylar space and shorter posterior extension of the intercondylar notch. Eleven of these 275 knees demonstrated catching of the patella at 60° to 90° of flexion when the knee was tested from flexion to extension during the surgery. All of these 11 knees did not have patellar resurfacing during surgery at first. Of these 11 knees with patellar catching noted during surgery, at first, patellar catching was eliminated with patellar resurfacing in 4 and by shaving of the superior pole of the patella in 7. None of the knees with the patella resurfacing in this series showed patellar catching.     

Comparison of patellar resurfacing versus nonresurfacing in bilateral total knee arthroplasty

Twenty-five patients who received bilateral total knee prostheses were studied to evaluate the advantages and disadvantages of patellar resurfacing. Only patients with advanced patellofemoral disease were included in the study. In all patients, patellar resurfacing had been done in the right knee but not in the left knee. The DePuy porous-coated implant was used in all cases. Subjective criteria were compared with objective criteria, which included range of motion, knee flexion and extension, and roentgenographic evaluation. The findings in this study suggest that patellar resurfacing can offer the patient a superior knee with regard to pain relief and strength.     

Comparison of patellar resurfacing versus nonresurfacing in total knee arthroplasty.

OBJECTIVES: To determine whether resurfacing the patellar component during total knee replacement (TKR) influences the clinical outcome. DESIGN: A retrospective study of data gathered prospectively during the recovery course of patients who underwent TKR with or without patellar resurfacing. SETTING: Victoria General Hospital, Halifax, NS. PATIENTS: One hundred and eighty-five patients operated on between 1992 and 1995. The inclusion criteria were (a) osteoarthritis, (b) replacement carried out by 2 independent surgeons, (c) no comorbid illness such as rheumatoid arthritis, cancer or infection, (d) pre- and postoperative attendance at the assessment clinics. INTERVENTION: TKR with (45) or without (140) patellar replacement. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Range of motion (ROM), pain assessment, Hospital Severity Score (HSS) and complications. RESULTS: There was no statistical difference between the 2 groups with respect to ROM, pain, HSS and complications postoperatively. CONCLUSIONS: Resurfacing the patella during TKR does not seem to influence the clinical outcome with respect to ROM, pain and overall complications. The decision should be based on individual criteria, depending on the preoperative and intraoperative findings. Randomized clinical trials assessing ROM, pain, complications and cost-effectiveness with long-term follow-up are necessary to further investigate this controversial issue.     

The patellofemoral joint after total knee arthroplasty without patellar resurfacing

One hundred total knee replacements with a total condylar prosthesis and without patellar resurfacing were followed for a minimum of two years. Eighty-four per cent of the knees were affected by osteoarthrosis. Graded according to the knee-rating system of the Hospital for Special Surgery, there were eighteen excellent, fifty-three good, eighteen fair, and eleven poor results. At the most recent follow-up, twenty-nine knees (29 per cent), nine of which were affected by rheumatoid arthritis, were still painful in the patellofemoral area. The height and weight of the patient definitely influenced the amount of patellofemoral pain postoperatively. Small patients who had osteoarthrosis were exceptionally free of pain, regardless of sex, age, or level of activity. It seems that the best approach to patellofemoral replacement includes resurfacing of the patella in all patients who have rheumatoid arthritis and in patients who have osteoarthrosis if they have preoperative patellofemoral pain, are more than 160 centimeters tall, weigh more than sixty kilograms, and have advanced changes in the patella at the time of the operation.     

Novel customized template designing for patellar resurfacing in total knee arthroplasty

Due to the irregular shape of patella and difficulty in identifying its bony landmarks, it can be a challenge for surgeons to accurately and symmetrically perform patellar resurfacing. Three‐dimensional (3D) models of 20 patellae were generated from computed tomographic images. Using a computer‐assisted preoperative planning technique, customized template designs were developed to guide patellar resurfacing. The patellar models and corresponding templates were produced through rapid prototyping. The accuracy of this technique was assessed after applying the templates on patellar models and cadaver specimens, respectively. Using preoperative planning and predesigned templates, a significant improvement in symmetric patellar resurfacing, with a mean angle of 1.21° mediolateral (ML) obliquity and 1.95° superoinferior (SI) obliquity, was observed compared with the conventional sawguide technique (mean angle of ML and SI was 4.13°, 4.95°, respectively). Additionally, the use of customized templates reproduced the desired preplanned patellar resection. Preoperative planning with 3D imaging and customized templates improved the accuracy of patellar resurfacing in terms of the obliquity and thickness. Clinical Relevance: A novel customized template designed for patellar resectioning will benefit surgeons in performing patellar resurfacing. This technique will provide accurate patellar resurfacing in clinical practice. © 2016 Orthopaedic Research Society. Published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Orthop Res 34:1798–1803, 2016.     

Total knee arthroplasty without patellar resurfacing

One hundred and eleven total knee replacements without patellar resurfacing were followed-up for a minimum of 48.8 months (range 48.8-108.2 months; average 78.2 months). Evaluation was performed using the Knee Society Clinical Rating System (KS-CRS). Preoperatively, the mean knee score was 34.3 points and the mean function score was 42.2 points. Postoperatively, this knee score improved to a mean of 91.1 points and the function score improved to mean of 89.6 points at the most recent follow-up. There were no significant differences among the knees with mild, moderate, or severe degenerative change to the patella with regard to the preoperative (p=0.83) and postoperative (p=0.39) knee pain score. It seems likely that the postoperative knee pain is not related to the severity of degenerative change to the patella in total knee arthroplasties performed without patellar resurfacing, and none of those patients required patellar resurfacing to achieve knee pain relief.     

Total knee arthroplasty without patellar resurfacing

Twenty-seven knees treated between 1974 and 1980 had a total condylar type knee arthroplasty without patellar resurfacing; the average follow-up period was 5.2 years. Compared with a previously reported group of 100 consecutive total condylar arthroplasties, the overall results in this series were very similar. However, there was a significant difference in stair-climbing ability, and one-third of the patients could not use the operated knee for this activity. In most knees the patella could be resurfaced. A working hypothesis assumes that the patellar button can be omitted in patients with relatively normal patellar cartilage, or relatively young, active, or obese patients who are considered a high risk for patellar bone fractures.     

The outcome of three methods of patellar resurfacing in total knee arthroplasty

Summary Two hundred and three patients with 219 Miller Galante type I knee arthroplasties have been reviewed in a multicentre study at an average of 3.5 years after operation. Three groups are compared: 83 patients were treated with a full polyethylene patellar component; 68 with a metal backed component, and 68 with patellar debridement without resurfacing. We found no differences between the 3 groups in relation to pain, range of movement, stability, flexion or extension deficit, extension lag, alignment, walking distance, ability to climb stairs or the use of walking aids. There was also no difference in the incidence of patellofemoral complications. The number of revision operations was the same in patellar-resurfaced and non-resurfaced knees. Lateral release was accompanied by more complications in every subgroup.

---

Résumé Dans un travail multicentrique nous avons étudié 219 arthroplasties de Miller Galante type 1 chez 203 patients avec un suivi postopératoire de 3.5 ans en moyenne (de 2 à 6). On a comparé trois modes de traitement: 83 fois un implant rotulien en polyéthylène, 68 fois une plaque métallique postérieure, les 68 autres malades furent traités par débridement simple sans revêtement artificiel de la surface articulaire. On n'a trouvé aucune différence entre les trois groupes quant à la douleur, la mobilité, la stabilité, le déficit de flexion ou d'extension, l'impossibilité d'extension active, l'alignement, la distance de marche, la montée des escaliers ou la nécessité d'utiliser des cannes. En outre le taux de complications patello-fémorales était le même pour les trois groupes. Le nombre de réinterventions ne différait pas selon que les malades avaient bénéficié ou non d'un recouvrement de la face postérieure de la rotule. C'est la section de l'aileron externe de la rotule qui a entraîné le plus de complications dans les trois groupes.

     

Retropatellar contact characteristics in total knee arthroplasty with and without patellar resurfacing

Total knee replacement with and without patellar resurfacing was performed in 6 cadaver specimens. The contact pressure and contact area between femur and patella was measured at 60° of flexion. In comparison to specimens without resurfacing the specimens with small size resurfacing showed a significant decrease in contact area, whereas average and maximum pressure were unchanged. In specimens with medium size resurfacing, contact area and average pressure increased slightly, whereas maximum pressure increased significantly. Patellar resurfacing did not change the retropatellar pressure, but was associated with reduced contact area.

---

Résumé  6 cadavres ont été examinés après implantation d’une prothèse totale du genou avec et sans implants de restructuration de la surface rotulienne. Les mesures de la pression et de la surface de contact ont été réalisées avec une flexion du genou à un angle de 60°. En comparant les résultats de genoux sans implants et genoux avec implants de la rotule de taille ”petite”, on remarque que ces derniers ont causé une diminution significative de la surface de contact rétro-rotulienne. Les pressions moyenne et maximum n’ont pas changé de manière déterminante. Les implants de taille ”moyenne” ont conduit à une augmentation considérable de la pression maximum et à une diminution significative de la force alors que la surface de contact et la pression moyenne ont elles, légèrement augmenté. Après la pose des deux types d’implants de la rotule on a constatée une réduction significative de la surface de contact, mais ne pas de la pression rétro-rotulienne.

---

---

Accepted: 24 January 2000     

The efficacy of patellar decompression for improving anterior knee pain following total knee arthroplasty without patellar resurfacing

Background

Anterior knee pain remains common following total knee arthroplasty (TKA). In this study, we evaluated the efficacy of patellar decompression via drilling for the treatment of anterior knee pain following TKA without patellar resurfacing.

Methods

A prospective cohort study was performed in 271 consecutive patients who underwent primary total knee replacement with patellar decompression (study group, n = 131) or without decompression (control group, n = 140). The patients were assessed according to the Knee Society rating, clinical anterior knee pain score, and British Orthopaedic Association patient-satisfaction score in each group. Each assessment was performed without the examiner knowing whether the patella had been decompressed. Radiographic evaluations were also performed according to the Knee Society scoring system for functional activity and our own severity grade system for patellofemoral articular change.

Results

There were no adverse events following patellar decompression. The overall prevalence of anterior knee pain was not significantly different between groups (p = 0.71). However, patients presenting pain over grade II after the operation in the study group were statistically low (p = 0.01). The overall postoperative knee scores were higher in the study group, but there were no significant differences between groups (p = 0.0731). Analyses of the radiographs revealed similar postoperative outcomes in both groups of knees.

Conclusions

As we observed significantly lower rates of anterior knee pain and no patellar complications following patellar decompression via drilling in TKA without patellar resurfacing, we recommend performing patellar decompression in cases of total knee replacement without patellar resurfacing.     

Radiolucent zone of the patella following total knee arthroplasty without patellar resurfacing

Background

The radiolucent zones in the patella are sometimes observed in patients who have undergone total knee arthroplasty (TKA) without patellar resurfacing. On the basis of radiological findings from our clinical experience, we hypothesize that the pathogenesis of this lesion may be similar to that of the lesions of spontaneous osteonecrosis, and this lesion may be due to both osteoporosis and stress concentration. The present study aimed to determine the incidence of the radiolucent zone after TKA without patellar resurfacing. Moreover, the roles of osteoporosis and patellar morphology, which are related to the stress distribution in the patella, were also investigated.

Methods

We studied 48 knees of 38 patients who underwent primary TKA using the Genesis II prosthesis. Axial radiographs taken 1 year postoperatively were used to assess the incidence of the radiolucent zone. The World Health Organization fracture risk assessment tool (FRAX) score and the preoperative patellar facet angle were compared between patients with and without the radiolucent zones.

Results

Five patellae (10.4 %) showed the radiolucent zones postoperatively (the radiolucent group), whereas no such lesions were found in the remaining 43 patellae (the normal group). The major osteoporotic fracture risk of the radiolucent group calculated using the FRAX was 24.8 % and significantly higher than that in the normal group (14.7 %; p = 0.01). The average patellar facet angle in the radiolucent group was 123.6°, which was significantly smaller than that in the normal group (133.6°; p = 0.003).

Discussion and conclusions

The results of the present study suggest that both underlying osteoporosis and a steep patellar facet angle may play an important role in the pathogenesis of the radiolucent zones in patellae after TKA without patellar resurfacing. Patellar resurfacing may be considered, particularly in osteoporotic patients who have a steep patellar facet angle, to avoid the appearance of the postoperative radiolucent zone in the patella.     

全膝关节置换术中髌骨置换与否对早期疗效及膝前痛的影响

 目的 探讨全膝关节置换术中髌骨置换与否对早期疗效及膝前痛发生率的影响。方法 2010年6月至2011年6月拟行全膝关节置换术患者100例,随机分为两组：髌骨置换组43例50膝,髌骨未置换组57例66膝。比较术后6个月、12个月两组患者的西安大略和麦克马斯特大学(West Ontario and McMaster Universities,WOMAC)骨关节炎指数、美国膝关节外科协会(Knee Surgery Society,KSS)膝评分和功能评分、膝前痛视觉模拟评分(visual analogue scale,VAS)。结果 髌骨置换组与髌骨未置换组患者术后膝前痛VAS评分均较术前明显降低,两组间VAS评分及膝前痛发生率的差异无统计学意义。WOMAC骨关节炎指数6个月分别为28.8±11.2和18.6±7.2、术后12个月分别为20.7±6.2和16.0±5.5,KSS膝评分6个月分别为(87.0±8.3)分和(90.9±7.2)分、术后12个月分别为(84.2±10.6)分和(88.8±9.2)分,KSS功能评分术后6个月分别为(86.6±21.6)分和(84.9±16.5)分、术后12个月分别为(85.2±16.4)分和(91.0±10.0)分,组间差异均无统计学意义。髌骨轴位X线片示髌骨与股骨假体滑车吻合度良好,无不稳及脱位表现。术后1年内无翻修、髌骨表面再置换病例。结论 全膝关节置换术对改善因骨关节炎或类风湿关节炎导致的膝关节疼痛、功能受限有效;髌骨置换与否对术后短期疗效及膝前痛发生率没有影响。     

Patellar resurfacing in total knee arthroplasty

Routine patella resurfacing in total knee arthroplasty has been debated for decades. The early total knee designs and surgical techniques lead to a high complication rate following patellar resurfacing. This lead to many surgeons abandoning this practice and either leaving the patella unresurfaced routinely or selectively resurfacing. Modern day randomized control trials and meta-analyses of these trials reveal a higher incidience of anterior knee pain and a resultant higher reoperation rate in nonresurfaced patellae. We argue that with modern day designs and surgical techniques, there is a low complication rate to resurfacing and little downside to resurfacing.     

Patellar resurfacing in total knee arthroplasty

Whether or not to resurface the patella when performing a primary total knee arthroplasty remains an open question. A number of recent studies have added new information relevant to this controversy. Anatomic studies show that there is normally substantial variability in the anatomy of the trochlear groove. Implanting a femoral component therefore results in a change in the surface topography of the knee in a high percentage of cases. Even though a number of intraoperative techniques have been described in an attempt to accurately reproduce femoral and tibial component rotation, studies of the application of these techniques reveal that component malpositioning or malrotation of a measurable degree occurs in 10% to 30% of cases, depending on the surgical technique and landmarks used. There has been substantial change in the design of both femoral and patellar components in recent years. Even with current designs, biomechanical studies indicate that some degree of change in kinematics and contact stresses occurs following total knee arthroplasty. However, the results of clinical studies have been extremely variable, with most showing either no difference or very little difference between resurfaced and nonresurfaced patellae in osteoarthritic knees. The decision to resurface the patella or not must be individualized on the basis of the surgeon's training and experience and an intraoperative assessment of the patellofemoral articulation.