Biomechanical analysis of the cruciate four-strand flexor tendon repair

The purpose of this study was to develop and test in vitro a new flexor tendon suture technique that was simple and easy to perform, yet strong enough to withstand the projected forces of an in vivo active motion rehabilitation protocol. Forty human cadaveric flexor digitorum profundus tendons were divided and repaired using 1 of 4 suture techniques (the modified Kessler, the Strickland, the modified 4-strand Savage, and the Cruciate 4-strand repairs). Each repair was tested using a slow-test machine and displacement control at 2 mm/s. Force applied, the resultant gap, and ultimate tensile strength were recorded and statistical comparisons were performed using a two-tailed Student's t-test with level of significance set at p = .05. The Cruciate suture technique was demonstrated to be nearly twice as strong to 2-mm gap formation (44 N) compared with the Kessler, Strickland, and Savage repairs. Ultimate tensile strength was also significantly stronger for the Cruciate technique (56 N) than the Kessler, Strickland, or Savage repairs. The technique was significantly faster to perform than the Savage or Strickland repairs and was comparable in repair time to the 2-stranded Kessler repair. The design of the new suture technique allowed the tendon repair to be completed with the ease and speed of a 2-strand technique, but bestowed on the repair strength that exceeded current 4-strand techniques.     

A biomechanical comparison of multistrand flexor tendon repairs using an in situ testing model

An in situ testing model was used to evaluate the performance of zone II flexor tendon repairs and to compare the biomechanical properties of 4-strand repairs with 2- and 6-strand repairs. Fifty digits from human cadaveric hands were mounted in a custom apparatus for in situ tensile testing. Intratendinous metallic markers were placed so that gap formation could be determined by fluoroscopy during tensile testing. Three 4-strand repairs (the 4-strand Kessler, the cruciate, and a locked modification of the cruciate repair) were compared with the 2-strand Kessler and the 6-strand Savage repairs. Ultimate tensile strength, load at 2-, 3-, and 4-mm gap formation, and work of flexion were determined. Work of flexion, while increased for the multistrand repairs, did not show a statistically significant correlation with the number of strands crossing the repair site. The tensile strength of the 6-strand repair was significantly greater than each of the 2- or 4-strand repairs. The tensile strength of all 4-strand repairs was significantly greater than the 2-strand repair. The 6-strand repair and the 2 cruciate repairs demonstrated a statistically increased resistance to gap formation compared with the 2-strand Kessler repair, but notably there was no statistically significant difference in gap resistance between the 2and 4-strand Kessler repairs. This in situ tensiletesting protocol demonstrated that 4- and 6-strand repairs have adequate initial strength to withstand the projected forces of early active motion protocols. Three of the 4 multistrand repairs demonstrated improved gap resistance compared with the 2-strand repair. The presence of the second suture in the Kessler configuration significantly increases its strength but not its gap resistance.     

Biomechanic comparison of the Teno Fix tendon repair device with the cruciate and modified Kessler techniques

PURPOSE: To compare the mechanical behavior of a novel internal tendon repair device with commonly used 2-strand and 4-strand repair techniques for zone II flexor tendon lacerations. METHODS: Thirty cadaveric flexor digitorum profundus tendons were randomized to 1 of 3 core sutures: (1) cruciate locked 4-strand technique, (2) modified Kessler 2-strand core suture technique, or (3) Teno Fix multifilament wire tendon repair device. Each repair was tested in the load control setting on a Instron controller coupled to an MTS materials testing machine load frame by using an incremental cyclic linear loading protocol. A differential variable reluctance transducer was used to record displacement across the repair site. Cyclic force (n-cycles) to 1-mm gap and repair failure was recorded using serial digital photography. RESULTS: There was no significant difference in differential variable reluctance transducer displacement between the cruciate, modified Kessler, and Teno Fix repairs. The cruciate repair had greater resistance to visual 1-mm repair-site gap formation and repair-site failure when compared with the Kessler and Teno Fix repairs. No significant difference was found between the modified Kessler repair and the Teno Fix repair. In all specimens, the epitenon suture failed before the core suture. Repair failure occurred by suture rupture in the 7 cruciate specimens that failed, with evidence of gap formation before failure. Seven of 10 modified Kessler repairs failed by suture rupture. All of the Teno Fix repairs failed by pullout of the metal anchor. CONCLUSIONS: The Teno Fix repair system did not confer a mechanical advantage over the locked cruciate or modified Kessler suture techniques for zone II lacerations in cadaveric flexor tendons during cyclic loading in a linear testing model. This information may help to define safe boundaries for postoperative rehabilitation when using this internal tendon repair device.     

Influence of core suture purchase length on strength of four-strand tendon repairs

PURPOSE: Recently the length of core suture purchase has been identified as a variable affecting the strength of tendon repairs. The influence of the length of the core suture purchase on the strength of multistrand locking and grasping suture repairs, however, has not been studied extensively in transversely lacerated tendons. We assessed the effects of the length of the core suture purchase on the strength of three 4-strand grasping or locking repair techniques. METHODS: Seventy-four fresh adult pig flexor tendons were cut transversely and repaired with 1 of 3 methods: double-modified Kessler, locking cruciate, and modified Savage. Each method was assessed using 2 different lengths of core suture purchase (1.0 and 0.4 cm). The tendons were subjected to a linear noncyclic load-to-failure test in a tensile testing machine. We recorded the forces required for gap formation, ultimate strength, stiffness of the tendon, and the mode of repair failure. RESULTS: The resistance to gap formation, the ultimate strength of all 3 repairs, and the stiffness of the tendons with the double-modified Kessler and modified Savage repairs decreased significantly as the length of core sutures decreased from 1.0 to 0.4 cm. Locking and grasping repairs had a similar decrease in strength when the purchase was decreased from 1.0 to 0.4 cm. All tendons with modified Savage repairs with 1.0-cm purchase failed by suture breakage and tendons with 0.4-cm purchase failed predominantly by pullout. CONCLUSIONS: The length of core suture purchase significantly affects the strength of these 4-strand tendon repairs. The forces required for gap formation and the ultimate failure of repairs with 0.4-cm purchase were 20% to 45% lower than those of the repairs with 1.0-cm purchase. Locking repairs did not show a greater capacity to offset the decrease in strength than grasping repairs when the length of core suture purchase was decreased from 1.0 to 0.4 cm. Our study indicates that the length of suture purchase directly influences the strength of both locking and grasping core tendon repair methods.     

Effects of direction of tendon lacerations on strength of tendon repairs

PURPOSE: We compared the tensile strength of different repair configurations on tendons with oblique and transverse lacerations. METHOD: Seventy-two fresh pig flexor tendons were divided randomly and repaired using the modified Kessler, the cruciate, or the 4-strand Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH) repair methods. The tendons were lacerated either transversely or obliquely. They were repaired with conventional and oblique suture repairs. The 2-mm gap formation force and ultimate strength were determined as biomechanical performance for each repair. RESULTS: The gap formation and ultimate strength of the tendons vary with orientations of tendon lacerations and suture methods. In the tendons repaired with the modified Kessler or the cruciate methods, the 2-mm gap formation and ultimate strength of obliquely cut tendons were significantly lower than those of transversely cut tendons. The obliquely placed modified Kessler or cruciate sutures significantly improved the repair strength in the tendons with an oblique laceration. In the tendons repaired with the MGH method, no statistical differences were found in the repair strength of obliquely and transversely lacerated tendons. CONCLUSIONS: The direction of tendon lacerations affects strength of certain repair configurations. The nonlocking modified Kessler or the cruciate tendon repairs are weakened considerably when the tendon laceration is oblique but their mechanical performance is strengthened by re-orienting the repair strands to lie parallel to the laceration. The cross-locked configuration of the MGH repair is not affected by the obliquity of the tendon laceration.     

Core suture purchase affects strength of tendon repairs

PURPOSE: It generally is considered that a certain distance should be maintained between the site of the tendon-suture junction and the laceration level of the tendon. In this study we assessed how the length of core suture purchase may affect the repair strength of transversely cut tendons using a 2-strand modified Kessler method and a 4-strand circle-locking method. METHODS: Seventy-four fresh pig flexor tendons were transected. Fifty-eight tendons were divided into 4 groups and repaired with a 2-strand grasping repair technique with the core suture purchase in the tendon stump ranging from 0.4 to 1.2 cm. Sixteen tendons were repaired with a 4-strand circle-locking tendon-suture repair technique. The core suture purchase of these tendons was 0.4 and 1.0 cm, respectively. The tendons were subjected to a linear, noncyclic, load-to-failure test in a tensile testing machine. The forces measured for initial gap formation, 2-mm gap formation, and ultimate strength were recorded for each repair. RESULTS: The resistance to gap formation and ultimate strength of 2-strand grasping technique repairs increased significantly as the suture purchase increased from 0.4 to 0.7, 1.0, and 1.2 cm although strength remained constant from 0.7 to 1.2 cm. The strength of 4-strand circle-locking repairs with a suture purchase of 1.0 cm was statistically greater than that of the repairs with a suture purchase of 0.4 cm. CONCLUSIONS: For both the 2-strand grasping and 4-strand circle-locking repair methods, the length of core suture purchase significantly influences the resistance to 2-mm gap formation and the ultimate strength of repairs in transversely lacerated flexor tendons. We determined that the optimal length of purchase is between 0.7 and 1.0 cm and that increased length of purchase from 0.7 to 1.2 cm does not increase the strength of the repair. Core suture purchase length of 0.4 cm or less results in significantly weaker repairs.     

指屈肌腱双环加强缝合法及其生物力学研究

目的：介绍作者设计的指屈肌腱双环加强缝合法。方法：用３６条人体指屈肌腱标本，行双环加强缝合法、改良Ｋｅｓｓｌｅｒ法、Ｌｅｅ法、Ｂｅｃｋｅｒ法和Ｓａｖａｇｅ法缝合肌腱，并进行生物力学测定比较。结果：５种缝合方法的平均抗拉强度分别为６７．５Ｎ、３５．８Ｎ、３６．７Ｎ、７４．７Ｎ、９６．８Ｎ。结论：双环加强缝合法操作简单，抗拉强度足够临床需要，术后可早期进行主动屈指活动，具有较大的安全系数     

A comparative analysis of the six-strand double-loop flexor tendon repair and three other techniques: a human cadaveric study

The ideal zone II flexor tendon repair would be easy to perform, cause minimal scarring, and be strong enough to allow early active motion. A 6-strand loop suture technique devised by the senior author (T.M.T.) was studied in vitro. Forty flexor tendons were harvested from fresh-frozen human hands and divided into 4 groups of 10 tendons each. Each group of tendons was repaired with a specific technique: group 1, the modified Kirchmayr (modified Kessler) technique; group 2, the single-loop 2-strand technique described by Tsuge; group 3, Tsai's double-loop 4-strand modification of Tsuge's technique; and group 4, Tsai's double-loop 6-strand modification of Tsuge's technique. Gap resistance of each repair technique was recorded on a computer using a Differential Variable Reluctance Transducer (MicroStrain, Burlington, VT) and on videotape to record first gap formation, 1-mm and 2-mm gap formation, and maximum load. Statistically significant differences between groups were as follows: at first gap formation between the 2-strand and 6-strand loop suture techniques, and at maximum load between the modified Kessler and 4-strand, modified Kessler and 6-strand, 2-strand and 4-strand, and 2-strand and 6-strand loop suture techniques. The 6-strand double-loop suture technique had a higher tensile strength than the other techniques, as measured in this model at each stage in our experiment. The 6-strand double-loop suture technique simplifies flexor tendon repair. It improves the repair's strength and its resistance to gapping without increasing tendon handling or bulk. This increased repair strength allows us to pursue a more aggressive rehabilitation program.     

Repair of flexor digitorum profundus tendon avulsions from bone: an ex vivo biomechanical analysis

Avulsions or distal transections of the flexor digitorum profundus tendon are typically repaired by direct suture of the tendon stump to the distal phalanx. The optimal repair technique to withstand in vivo rehabilitation forces is unknown. Our objective was to determine the time-zero tensile mechanical properties of 4-strand tendon-bone repair site constructs performed with 3-0 and 4-0 sutures and with modified Kessler and modified Becker grasping techniques. We hypothesized that the 3-0 modified Becker grasping suture technique not described previously for the reattachment of tendon to bone would show improved biomechanical properties compared with the 4-0 or modified Kessler techniques. All modified Kessler repairs failed by suture pullout from the tendon, whereas all modified Becker repairs failed by rupture of the suture at the tendon-bone junction. Although the 3-0 modified Becker repair group showed greater ultimate force then the other groups (p <.01), tendon-bone gap observed did not differ markedly between Becker or Kessler groups. Neither suture caliber nor repair technique had a notable effect on strain at 20-N force, suggesting that early gap formation at the tendon-bone repair site may occur regardless of technique.     

Flexor tendon suture methods: a quantitative analysis of suture material within the repair site

This study compared the cross-sectional area and volume occupied by suture material at the repair site in three common methods of flexor tendon repair. A total of 51 human cadaveric tendons were studied. Zone II flexor digitorum profundus tendon lacerations were created and then repaired using the techniques described by Kessler, Tajima, and Savage. Quantitative cross-sectional area and volumetric measurements of suture material within each repair site were determined using a digital image analysis system. The Tajima repair occupied 27% of the tendon area at the repair site, while the Savage and Kessler repairs occupied 18% and 2%, respectively.     

A biomechanical study of Tang's multiple locking techniques for flexor tendon repair

This study was designed to biomechanically compare Tang's multiple looped locking techniques with various suture techniques for flexor tendon repair in the hand. Fifty flexor digitorum profondus tendons taken from pig toes were used as models; The tendons were transected in the middle part of zone 2 defined as the area beneath bifurcation of the flexor digitorum superficialis tendons, and were repaired by five different suture methods: (1) modified Kessler, (2) Tsuge's suture, (3) double Kessler, (4) modified Kessler plus Tsuge, and (5) Tang's suture. The repaired tendons were placed in an Instron tensile testing machine to determine the tensile properties of the repair. 2 mm gap formation force and ultimate tensile strength were measured during the test. Maximal work to failure were calculated according to area under the load-displacement curve of the test. 2 mm gap formation force was 21.5 N for the Kessler, 20.6 N for the Tsuge, 31.6 N for double Kessler, 30.9 N for the Kessler plus Tsuge and 41.4 N for the Tang. Ultimate tensile strength was 23.5 N for the Kessler, 22.9 N for the Tsuge, 34.5 N for the Kessler plus Tsuge and 45.6 N for the Tang. Statistically, Tang's suture had the greatest gap formation force, ultimate strength and energy for failure among the five techniques (p < 0.01 or p < 0.001). Gap formation force, ultimate strength and energy to failure for double Kessler or the Kessler plus Tsuge were significantly greater than those for the Kessler or the Tsuge (p < 0.05 or < 0.01). The tendons repaired by Tang's method tolerated a significantly higher tensile load (133 to 198% of the other techniques) than the other methods. Among the methods tested, Tang's multiple looped locking suture provides sufficient gap resistance and tensile strength that may be able to withstand early active mobilization after primary flexor tendon repair.     

Flexor tendon repair using a stainless steel external splint. Biomechanical study on human cadaver flexor tendons

A stainless steel external tendon splint was used in repair of cadaver tendons and compared with standard tendon repairs with suture. The splint was combined with a Kessler repair and tested against the Kessler, Becker, and Savage repairs in fresh human cadaver flexor digitorum profundus tendons. Biomechanical testing was done on a tensile testing machine, and load-displacement curves were generated. The repairs using the external tendon splint demonstrated a range of improvement of 32 to 146% in mean maximal tensile strength and a 20 to 185% improvement of mean ultimate tensile strength compared with all other repairs. The external tendon splint is relatively easy to apply to a tendon. The repair is strengthened and becomes capable of withstanding early active range of motion exercises. In vivo testing will be needed to assess the potential clinical usefulness of such a device.     

The effect of flexor tendon repair bulk on tendon gliding during simulated active motion: an in vitro comparison of two-strand and six-strand techniques

The gliding function of 2-strand (Tajima) and 6-strand (Savage) techniques of flexor tendon repair were compared in an in vitro biomechanical model. Stainless steel beads were inserted directly into the metacarpals, phalanges, and flexor digitorum profundus tendons of 22 human cadaver specimens. The FDP tendons were loaded from 5 to 25 N using a pneumatic actuator. The angular rotation and tendon excursion of the cadaver specimens were measured radiographically. The gliding function of the repairs was compared with core suture only, core suture plus epitenon repair, and sheath repair. There was no significant difference in angular rotation or linear excursion between the 2-strand and 6-strand techniques of flexor tendon repair. The addition of the epitendinous suture to the core suture improved the angular rotation and linear excursion for the 2-strand technique. Although the 6-strand repair tended to increase the repair site bulk more than the conventional 2-strand technique, the gliding function of the repair techniques was equivalent.     

A comparative analysis of the biomechanical behaviour of five flexor tendon core sutures

Five core suture techniques were compared by static tensile testing in vitro. Fifty porcine tendons were used. The core sutures were performed with 3-0 or 4-0 braided polyester suture (Ticron) and the over-and-over running peripheral sutures with 6-0 monofilament polypropylene (Prolene). The core sutures were: (1) Pennington modified Kessler (3-0), (2) Double Pennington modified Kessler (3-0), (3) 4-strand Savage (3-0), (4) 4-strand Savage (4-0), and (5) 6-strand Savage (4-0). Repairs were compared as paired in regard to one variable: the number of core suture strands, the suture calibre, or the suture configuration. Biomechanical differences between the repair groups started during the linear region, with the yield force and stiffness increasing along with the number of core suture strands. All three variables influenced the strain at the yield point. Thus, the strength of the intact repair can be improved by modifying the core suture. In all repairs gap formation started near the yield point after failure of the peripheral suture. The yield force represents the strength of the intact repair composite and should be considered the strength of the tendon repair.     

Tensile properties of suture methods for repair of partially lacerated human flexor tendon in vitro

The decision to treat zone II partially lacerated flexor tendons is challenging, because there can be justification for either repair or no repair, depending on the surgeon's assessment of the strength of the residual intact portion of the tendon. In this study tensile properties of various repair techniques were compared. Cadaveric human flexor tendons (n = 118) were lacerated to 75% of their cross-section and repaired with either a core suture method (Kessler, modified Kessler, Savage, Lee, augmented Becker, or Tsuge all finished with a circumferential running suture), an epitendinous suture alone (circumferential or partial), or the tendons were left unrepaired. Among the core suture methods there was no significant difference (p >.05) in maximum failure force (overall mean, 211.2 N; SD, 53.2) or force to produce a 1.5-mm gap (74.1 N; SD, 49.7). Likewise there was no significant difference (p >.05) in tendon stiffness (41.0 N/mm; SD, 14.0) or resistance to gap formation (52.3 N/mm; SD, 23.1). In comparison, repairs without the core suture, including unrepaired tendons, were significantly weaker (144.7 N, p <.001) and had a marginally lower stiffness (p =.04) but had a similar resistance to gap formation (43.5 N/mm).     

Tendon repair using flexor tendon splints: An experimental study

Mechanical strength of tendon repair using Dacron tendon splints across the laceration site were evaluated in human cadaver profundus tendons; the splints were placed both on the dorsal surface and internally within the tendon substance. Comparison was made to modified Kessler, Becker, and Savage repair techniques. Ultimate tensile strength was 2.55 kgf for the Kessler, 3.00 kgf for the Becker, 8.29 kgf for the Savage, 8.46 kgf for the internal tendon splint, and 8.10 kgf for the dorsal tendon splint; the Savage and both Tendon Splints techniques had significant higher tensile strength than the Kessler and Becker. Gap strength was 1.44 kgf for the Kessler, 2.22 kgf for the Becker, 2.45 kgf for the Savage, 2.05 kgf for internal tendon splint, and 3.15 kgf for the dorsal tendon splint. The dorsal tendon splint technique showed significant greater gap strength than the other four techniques. There was no significant difference in the magnitude of the gap during cyclic testing of these techniques; however, three of seven Kessler repairs failed and one of six Becker repairs failed. The results of these cadaver studies suggest that both tendon splint repair techniques are comparable to the Savage and may have sufficient strength to allow postoperative active motion against minimal resistance. Further in vivo testing is in order.     

Suture techniques with high breaking strength and low gliding resistance: Experiments in the dog flexor digitorum profundus tendon

We studied the breaking strength and gliding resistance between the pulley and flexor tendon for various suture techniques. Canine flexor digitorum profundus tendons were transected and sutured using one of eight repair techniques: modified Kessler (MK); Tsuge (Tsuge); two variations of a double modified Kessler (DK1, DK2); combined modified Kessler-modified Tsuge (MKT); augmented Becker (Becker); Cruciate (Cruciate); and modified double Tsuge (DT). The force to produce a 1.5 mm gap, ultimate failure load, resistance to gap formation, and gliding resistance were measured. The force to produce a 1.5 mm gap and the ultimate breaking force were higher with the DK1, DK2, MKT, Becker, Cruciate, and DT repairs than they were with the MK and Tsuge repair, while the gliding resistance of the Becker was higher than that of the MK, DK1, DK2, MKT, Cruciate, and DT repairs. In addition to confirming that repair strength increases as the number of strands crossing the repair increases, we also found that these stronger repairs need not produce higher gliding resistance than less robust repairs.     

Comparison of modified Kessler tendon suture at different levels in the human flexor digitorum profundus tendon and porcine flexors and porcine extensors: an experimental biomechanical study

This study compared the biomechanical behaviour of repairs in the human flexor digitorum profundus tendon in zones I, II and III with repairs of different segments of the porcine flexor tendon of the second digit and the extensor digiti quarti proprius tendon, in order to assess the validity of porcine tendons as models for human flexor tendon repairs. These porcine tendons were selected after comparing their size with the human flexor digitorum profundus tendon. The tendon repairs were done in three segments of each porcine tendon and repairs in the human tendons were done in zones I,II and III. Ten tendons in each group yielded a total of 90 specimens. A modified Kessler repair was done with 3-0 coated braided polyester suture and subjected to uniaxial tensile testing. In human flexor tendons, the ultimate force was higher in zones I and II than in zone III. The porcine flexor digitorum profundus tendon from the second digit and the proximal segment of the extensor digiti quarti proprius tendon behaved similarly to the human flexor tendon in zone III and can be considered as surrogates for the human flexor tendon.     

Suture techniques with high breaking strength and low gliding resistance: experiments in the dog flexor digitorum profundus tendon

We studied the breaking strength and gliding resistance between the pulley and flexor tendon for various suture techniques. Canine flexor digitorum profundus tendons were transected and sutured using one of eight repair techniques: modified Kessler (MK); Tsuge (Tsuge); two variations of a double modified Kessler (DK1, DK2); combined modified Kessler-modified Tsuge (MKT); augmented Becker (Becker); Cruciate (Cruciate); and modified double Tsuge (DT). The force to produce a 1.5 mm gap, ultimate failure load, resistance to gap formation, and gliding resistance were measured. The force to produce a 1.5 mm gap and the ultimate breaking force were higher with the DK1, DK2, MKT, Becker, Cruciate, and DT repairs than they were with the MK and Tsuge repair, while the gliding resistance of the Becker was higher than that of the MK, DK1, DK2, MKT. Cruciate, and UT repairs. In addition to confirming that repair strength increases as the number of strands crossing the repair increases, we also found that these stronger repairs need not produce higher gliding resistance than less robust repairs.     

Suture techniques with high breaking strength and low gliding resistance: Experiments in the dog flexor digitorum profundus tendon

We studied the breaking strength and gliding resistance between the pulley and flexor tendon for various suture techniques. Canine flexor digitorum profundus tendons were transected and sutured using one of eight repair techniques: modified Kessler (MK); Tsuge (Tsuge); two variations of a double modified Kessler (DK1, DK2); combined modified Kessler-modified Tsuge (MKT); augmented Becker (Becker); Cruciate (Cruciate); and modified double Tsuge (DT). The force to produce a 1.5 mm gap, ultimate failure load, resistance to gap formation, and gliding resistance were measured. The force to produce a 1.5 mm gap and the ultimate breaking force were higher with the DK1, DK2, MKT, Becker, Cruciate, and DT repairs than they were with the MK and Tsuge repair, while the gliding resistance of the Becker was higher than that of the MK, DK1, DK2, MKT, Cruciate, and DT repairs. In addition to confirming that repair strength increases as the number of strands crossing the repair increases, we also found that these stronger repairs need not produce higher gliding resistance than less robust repairs.