Cell type-specific methylation profiles occurring disproportionately in CpG-less regions that delineate developmental similarity

Our previous studies using restriction landmark genomic scanning (RLGS) defined tissue- or cell-specific DNA methylation profiles. It remains to be determined whether the DNA sequence compositions in the genomic contexts of the NotI loci tested by RLGS influence their tendency to change with differentiation. We carried out 3834 methylation measurements consisting of 213 NotI loci in the mouse genome in 18 different tissues and cell types, using quantitative real-time PCR based on a Virtual image rlgs database. Loci were categorized as CpG islands or other, and as unique or repetitive sequences, each category being associated with a variety of methylation categories. Strikingly, the tissue-dependently and differentially methylated regions (T-DMRs) were disproportionately distributed in the non-CpG island loci. These loci were located not only in 5'-upstream regions of genes but also in intronic and non-genic regions. Hierarchical clustering of the methylation profiles could be used to define developmental similarity and cellular phenotypes. The results show that distinctive tissue- and cell type-specific methylation profiles by RLGS occur mostly at NotI sites located at non-CpG island sequences, which delineate developmental similarity of different cell types. The finding indicates the power of NotI methylation profiles in evaluating the relatedness of different cell types.     

Epigenetic marks by DNA methylation specific to stem,germ and somatic cells in mice

BACKGROUND: DNA methylation is involved in many gene functions such as gene-silencing, X-inactivation, imprinting and stability of the gene. We recently found that some CpG islands had a tissue-dependent and differentially methylated region (T-DMR) in normal tissues, raising the possibility that there may be more CpG islands capable of differential methylation. RESULTS: We investigated the genome-wide DNA methylation pattern of CpG islands by restriction landmark genomic scanning (RLGS) in mouse stem cells (ES, EG and trophoblast stem) before and after differentiation, and sperm as well as somatic tissues. A total of 247 spots out of 1500 (16%) showed differences in the appearance of their RLGS profiles, indicating that CpG islands having T-DMR were numerous and widespread. The methylation pattern was specific, and varied in a precise manner according to cell lineage, tissue type and during cell differentiation. CONCLUSIONS: Genomic loci with altered methylation status seem to be more common than has hitherto been realized. The formation of DNA methylation patterns at CpG islands is one of the epigenetic events which underlies the production of various cell types in the body. These findings should have implications for the use of embryonic stem cells and cells derived from them therapeutically, and also for the cloning of animals by the transfer of somatic cell nuclei.     

A new class of tissue-specifically methylated regions involving entire CpG islands in the mouse

CpG islands, which have higher GC content and CpG frequencies compared to the genome as a whole, are generally believed to be unmethylated in tissues except at promoters of genes undergoing X chromosome inactivation or genomic imprinting. Recent studies, however, have shown that CpG islands at promoters of a number of genes contain tissue-dependent, differentially methylated regions (T-DMRs). In general, the tissue-specific methylation is restricted to a part of the promoter CpG island, with hypomethylation of the remaining sequence. In the current study, using comparison between Restriction Landmark Genomic Scanning (RLGS) and in silico RLGS, we identified ten sperm-specific unmethylated NotI sites, T-DMRs located in CpG islands that were hypomethylated in sperm but near-completely methylated in the kidney and brain. Unusually, these T-DMRs involve the whole CpG island at each of these loci. We characterized one of these genes, adenine nucleotide translocator 4 (Ant4), which is expressed in germ cells. Using a promoter assay, we demonstrated that expression of Ant4 gene is controlled by DNA methylation at the CpG island sequences within the promoter region. Ant4 and other sperm-specific hypomethylated loci represent a new class of CpG islands that become completely methylated in different cell lineages. T-DMRs at CpG islands are functionally important gene regulatory elements that may now be categorized into two classes: T-DMRs involving a subregion of the CpG island and those that occupy the whole CpG island.     

Differential targets of CpG island hypermethylation in primary and metastatic head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC)

Head and neck squamous cell carcinomas (HNSCC) often metastasise to the cervical lymph nodes. It is known for HNSCC as well as other cancers that progression from normal tissue to primary tumour and finally to metastatic tumour is characterised by an accumulation of genetic mutations. DNA methylation, an epigenetic modification, can result in loss of gene function in cancer, similar to genetic mutations such as deletions and point mutations. We have investigated the DNA methylation phenotypes of both primary HNSCC and metastatic tumours from 13 patients using restriction landmark genomic scanning (RLGS). With this technique, we were able to assess the methylation status of an average of nearly 1300 CpG islands for each tumour. We observed that the number of CpG islands hypermethylated in metastatic tumours is significantly greater than what is found in the primary tumours overall, but not in every patient. Interestingly, the data also clearly show that many loci methylated in a patient's primary tumour are no longer methylated in the metastatic tumour of the same patient. Thus, even though metastatic HNSCC methylate a greater proportion of CpG islands than do the primary tumours, they do so at different subsets of loci. These data show an unanticipated variability in the methylation state of loci in primary and metastatic HNSCCs within the same patient. We discuss two possible explanations for how different epigenetic events might arise between the primary tumour and the metastatic tumour of a person.     

Combined restriction landmark genomic scanning and virtual genome scans identify a novel human homeobox gene, ALX3, that is hypermethylated in neuroblastoma.

Restriction landmark genome scanning (RLGS) allows comparative analysis of several thousand DNA fragments in the genome and provides a means to identify CpG islands that are altered in tumor cells as a result of amplification, deletion, or methylation changes. We have developed a novel informatics tool, designated virtual genome scan (VGS), that makes it possible to predict automatically the sequence of fragments in RLGS patterns by matching to the human genome sequence. A combination of RLGS and VGS was utilized to identify changes of chromosome 1-derived fragments in neuroblastoma. A NotI-EcoRV fragment was found to be absent frequently in neuroblastoma cell line RLGS patterns. Sequence prediction by VGS as well as cloning of the fragment showed that it contained a CpG island that is part of the human orthologue of the hamster homeobox gene Alx3. Expression analysis in a panel of human and mouse tissues showed predominant expression of ALX3 in brain tissue. Methylation-sensitive sequence analysis of the promoter region in neuroblastoma cell lines indicated that methylation of specific sequences correlated with repression of the ALX3 gene. Expression was re-induced after treatment with the methylation inhibitor 5-aza-2'-deoxycytidine. Promoter methylation analysis of ALX3 in primary neuroblastoma tumors, using methylation-sensitive polymerase chain reaction, found preferential ALX3 methylation in advanced-stage tumors. The VGS approach we have implemented in combination with RLGS is useful for the identification of genomic CpG island-related methylation changes or deletions in cancer.     

Preference of DNA methyltransferases for CpG islands in mouse embryonic stem cells

Many CpG islands have tissue-dependent and differentially methylated regions (T-DMRs) in normal cells and tissues. To elucidate how DNA methyltransferases (Dnmts) participate in methylation of the genomic components, we investigated the genome-wide DNA methylation pattern of the T-DMRs with Dnmt1-, Dnmt3a-, and/or Dnmt3b-deficient ES cells by restriction landmark genomic scanning (RLGS). Approximately 1300 spots were detected in wild-type ES cells. In Dnmt1(-/-) ES cells, additional 236 spots emerged, indicating that the corresponding loci are methylated by Dnmt1 in wild-type ES cells. Intriguingly, in Dnmt3a(-/-)Dnmt3b(-/-) ES cells, the same 236 spots also emerged, and no additional spots appeared differentially. Therefore, Dnmt1 and Dnmt3a/3b share targets in CpG islands. Cloning and virtual image RLGS revealed that 81% of the RLGS spots were associated with genes, and 62% of the loci were in CpG islands. By contrast to the previous reports that demethylation at repeated sequences was severe in Dnmt1(-/-) cells compared with Dnmt3a(-/-)Dnmt3b(-/-) cells, a complete loss of methylation was observed at RLGS loci in Dnmt3a(-/-)Dnmt3b(-/-) cells, whereas methylation levels only decreased to 16% to 48% in the Dnmt1(-/-) cells. We concluded that there are CpG islands with T-DMR as targets shared by Dnmt1 and Dnmt3a/3b and that each Dnmt has target preferences depending on the genomic components.     

Virtual genome scan: a tool for restriction landmark-based scanning of the human genome

There is substantial interest in implementing technologies that allow comparisons of whole genomes of individuals and of tissues and cell populations. Restriction landmark genome scanning (RLGS) is a highly resolving gel-based technique in which several thousand fragments in genomic digests are visualized simultaneously and quantitatively analyzed. The widespread use of RLGS has been hampered by difficulty in deriving sequence information for displayed fragments and a lack of whole-genome sequence-based framework for interpreting RLGS patterns. We have developed informatics tools for comparisons of sample derived RLGS patterns with patterns predicted from the human genome sequence and displayed as Virtual Genome Scans (VGS). The tools developed allow sequence prediction of fragments in RLGS patterns obtained with different restriction enzyme combinations. The utility of VGS is demonstrated by the identification of restriction fragment length polymorphisms, and of amplifications, deletions, and methylation changes in tumor-derived CpG islands and the characterization of an amplified region in a breast tumor that spanned <230 kb on 17q23.     

Aberrant hypermethylation of the major breakpoint cluster region in 17p11.2 in medulloblastomas but not supratentorial PNETs

Deletions of 17p have been consistently reported in up to 50% of medulloblastomas (MBs), and the major breakpoint interval has been localized to chromosome segment 17p11.2. Based on several reports linking aberrant DNA methylation and chromosomal disruption, we examined the methylation pattern in this region by employing restriction landmark genomic scanning (RLGS). Several CpG islands located in the major breakpoint cluster region were identified using a bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC) contig of the breakpoint region. A long-range methylation map was established for 20 MBs and 5 supratentorial primitive neuroectodermal tumors (stPNETs). Selected CpG islands were examined using Southern and bisulfite sequencing analysis. Aberrantly hypermethylated CpG islands in 17p11. 2 were found in 33% of MBs. Interestingly, one CpG island was methylated in MBs, but not in any of the examined stPNETs. A BAC clone covering three of the methylated CpG islands was partially sequenced in the search for a potential tumor suppressor gene. None of the expressed sequence tag sequences and full-length mouse/human cDNAs that were associated with aberrant methylation showed a change in expression levels due to methylation. The potential link between chromosomal instability in 17p11.2 and hypermethylation in this region is discussed.     

Infrequent occurrence of age-dependent changes in CpG island methylation as detected by restriction landmark genome scanning

Hypermethylation of CpG islands, resulting in the inactivation of tumor suppressor genes, is an early event in the development of some malignancies. Recent studies suggest that this abnormal methylation may be a function of aging. The number of CpG islands that methylate with age is unknown. We used restriction landmark genome scanning (RLGS) to approximate the extent to which CpG islands change methylation status during aging. Comparison of more than 2000 loci in T lymphocytes isolated from newborn, middle age, and elderly people revealed that 29 loci ( approximately 1%) changed methylation status during aging, with 23 increasing methylation, and six decreasing. The same subset also changed methylation status with age in the esophagus, lung, and pancreas, but in variable directions. Virtual genome scanning identified one of these loci as a member of the forkhead family, recently implicated in aging, and another as an EST fragment. The methylation status of both correlated with level of expression. Confirming studies in multiple tissues from normal and DNMT1(+/-) mice demonstrated only one age dependent change in the methylation of more than 2000 loci, occurring in liver and kidney. These results indicate that the methylation status of the majority of CpG islands in both mice and humans is tightly controlled during aging, and that changes are infrequent and in humans confined to a specific subset of genes.     

基因组差异甲基化片段筛选技术

分离和鉴定细胞之间的差异甲基化片段,不仅有助于了解基因的功能、分离疾病相关基因,而且可以发现与细胞分化或病变相关的甲基化标记。目前筛选差异甲基化DNA片段的方法主要有:甲基化敏感的限制性界标基因组扫描、甲基化敏感的代表性差异分析、甲基化敏感的限制性指纹技术、甲基化CpG岛扩增-代表性差异分析、微阵列技术等。其中微阵列法又先后建立有CpG岛微阵列、寡核苷酸微阵列和表达CpG岛序列标签微阵列。这些方法各有特点和适用范围,应根据具体研究目的和工作条件进行恰当的选择。     

Hypermethylation of CpG islands is more prevalent than hypomethylation across the entire genome in breast carcinogenesis

This study aimed to establish a high-throughput, genome-wide and non-gene-specific approach to assess the methylation status of multiple CpG islands in parallel and employ it to detect the CpG island methylation profiling alterations in breast carcinogenesis. We used methylation-sensitive restriction fingerprint (MSRF) to screen the permutations of primers that could detect varied and specific methylation profiling in genomic DNA isolated from four different cell lines. Five permutations of nine arbitrary primers were determined for the following experiments based on the above test. We then examined the methylation profiling alterations of CpG islands in 31 breast cancer tissue samples relative to their adjacent non-neoplastic tissues with modified MSRF that replaced silver staining with denatured high-performance liquid chromatography for size fraction. We found that two pairs of primers could reveal specific alterations of CpG methylation in the examined tissues, and 83.9% (26/31) of breast cancer tissues exhibited specific CpG island methylation profiling relative to their adjacent non-neoplastic tissues. Size fraction analysis revealed that hypermethylation of CpG islands was responsible for the aberrant methylation profiling in breast cancer tissues. Our work not only established a relative high-throughput, genome-wide and economic method to detect methylation alterations of CpG island profiling, but also revealed that hypermethylation of CpG islands was more prevalent than hypomethylation across the entire genome in our examined cancer tissues. The methylation profiling alterations revealed by two primer pairs used in the present study might be a novel marker for breast cancer.     

Genetic changes in prostate cancer

Recent advances in molecular biology have allowed us to understand that it is the accumulation of genetic alterations which leads to each step of tumor genesis. What the specific alterations may be, however, often varies with each neoplasm. Prostate cancer is somewhat unique in its presentation to the pathologist of a bewildering array of histologies difficult to assign to diagnostic categories and contributing to misinterpretations of underlying molecular events. As with any malignancy, It is of utmost importance to thoroughly analyze and record the genetic aberrations found in prostate cancer with the objective of correlation to the pathology and natural history of the disease. Multiple ontogeny and tumor suppressor genes have been investigated in both clinical and latent cancers using conventional mutational analyses. To probe deeper Into these genes and to uncover novel molecular events, genomic tumor DNA were examined using restriction landmark genomic scanning (RLGS), a method which allows the Identification and comparison of specific genetic alterations within large segments and multiple samples of DNA at a time. This article reviews what has been identified based on numerous molecular studies, focusing on the genetic alterations peculiar to human prostate cancer.     

DNA methylation patterns in hereditary human cancers mimic sporadic tumorigenesis.

Cancer cells have aberrant patterns of DNA methylation including hypermethylation of gene promoter CpG islands and global demethylation of the genome. Genes that cause familial cancer, as well as other genes, can be silenced by promoter hypermethylation in sporadic tumors, but the methylation of these genes in tumors from kindreds with inherited cancer syndromes has not been well characterized. Here, we examine CpG island methylation of 10 genes (hMLH1, BRCA1, APC, LKB1, CDH1, p16(INK4a), p14(ARF), MGMT, GSTP1 and RARbeta2) and 5-methylcytosine DNA content, in inherited (n = 342) and non-inherited (n = 215) breast and colorectal cancers. Our results show that singly retained alleles of germline mutated genes are never hypermethylated in inherited tumors. However, this epigenetic change is a frequent second "hit", associated with the wild-type copy of these genes in inherited tumors where both alleles are retained. Global hypomethylation was similar between sporadic and hereditary cases, but distinct differences existed in patterns of methylation at non-familial genes. This study demonstrates that hereditary cancers "mimic" the DNA methylation patterns present in the sporadic tumors.     

The epigenetics of (hereditary) colorectal cancer

In the last decade, it has become apparent that not only DNA sequence variations but also epigenetic modifications may contribute to disease, including cancer. These epigenetic modifications involve histone modification including acetylation and methylation, DNA methylation, and chromatin remodeling. One of the best-characterized epigenetic changes is aberrant methylation of cytosines that occur in so-called CpG islands. DNA hypomethylation, prevalent as a genome-wide event, usually occurs in more advanced stages of tumor development. In contrast, DNA hypermethylation is often observed as a discrete, targeted event within tumor cells, resulting in specific loss of gene expression. Interestingly, it was found that sporadic and inherited cancers may exhibit similar DNA methylation patterns, and many genes that are mutated in familial cancers have also been found to be hypermethylated, mutated, or deleted in sporadic cancers. In this review, we will focus on DNA methylation events as heritable epimutations predisposing to colorectal cancer development.     

Genome-wide and locus-specific DNA hypomethylation in G9a deficient mouse embryonic stem cells

In the mammalian genome, numerous CpG-rich loci define tissue-dependent and differentially methylated regions (T-DMRs). Euchromatin from different cell types differs in terms of its tissue-specific DNA methylation profile as defined by these T-DMRs. G9a is a euchromatin-localized histone methyltransferase (HMT) and catalyzes methylation of histone H3 at lysines 9 and 27 (H3-K9 and -K27). To test whether HMT activity influences euchromatic cytosine methylation, we analyzed the DNA methylation status of approximately 2000 CpG-rich loci, which are predicted in silico, in G9a(-/-) embryonic stem cells by restriction landmark genomic scanning (RLGS). While the RLGS profile of wild-type cells contained about 1300 spots, 32 new spots indicating DNA demethylation were seen in the profile of G9a(-/-) cells. Virtual-image RLGS (Vi-RLGS) allowed us to identify the genomic source of ten of these spots. These were confirmed to be cytosine demethylated, not just at the Not I site detected by the RLGS but extending over several kilobase pairs in cis. Chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP) confirmed these loci to be targets of G9a, with decreased H3-K9 and/or -K27 dimethylation in the G9a(-/-) cells. These data indicate that G9a site-selectively contributes to DNA methylation.     

Epigenetic markers and response to chemotherapy in cancer

The last ten years has seen an explosion in interest in epigenetic mechanisms of control of gene expression. This is particularly true in the field of cancer research where epigenetic alterations are now regarded as equally important as genetic alterations in the development and progression of cancer. Of particular interest is altered DNA methylation, which is a key feature of essentially all tumour types. Aberrant methylation of CpG islands represents an ideal candidate for both diagnostic and prognostic markers in cancer. It is highly prevalent, very largely tumour specific and potentially far more readily detectible than most genetic alterations. This review will discuss the genes already identified as potential epigenetic markers of drug response, as well as the rapidly improving technology for detection of methylation which has greatly expanded the potential sources of tumour specific DNA that can be used for epigenetic marker analysis.     

基因组CpG岛甲基化检测技术研究进展

启动子CpG岛甲基化所致的抑癌基因失活和肿瘤发生密切相关，因而了解抑癌基因CpG岛甲基化情况具有重要意义。目前CpG岛甲基化的检测方法众多，其原理分别基于甲基化敏感的限制性内切酶切割和亚硫酸氢钠修饰，用于全基因组大量CpG岛甲基化检测和基因特异性CpG岛的一个或多个CpG位点甲基化检测。     

The epigenome of testicular germ cell tumors

Gene expression is tightly regulated in normal cells, and epigenetic changes disturbing this regulation are a common mechanism in the development of cancer. Testicular germ cell tumor (TGCT) is the most common malignancy among young males and can be classified into two main histological subgroups: seminomas, which are basically devoid of DNA methylation, and nonseminomas, which in general have methylation levels comparable with other tumor tissues, as shown by restriction landmark genome scanning (RLGS). In general, DNA methylation seems to increase with differentiation, and among the nonseminomas, the pluripotent and undifferentiated embryonal carcinomas harbor the lowest levels of DNA promoter hypermethylation, whereas the well-differentiated teratomas display the highest. In this regard, TGCTs resemble the early embryogenesis. So far, only a limited number of tumor suppressor genes have been shown to be inactivated by DNA promoter hypermethylation in more than a minor percentage of TGCTs, including MGMT, SCGB3A1, RASSF1A, HIC1, and PRSS21. In addition, imprinting defects, DNA hypomethylation of testis/cancer associated genes, and the presence of unmethylated XIST are frequent in TGCTs. Aberrant DNA methylation has the potential to improve current diagnostics by noninvasive testing and might also serve as a prognostic marker for treatment response.     

Alterations of DNA methylation and clinicopathological diversity of human cancers

Alterations of DNA methylation can account for the histological heterogeneity, reflected in the stepwise progression and complex biological characteristics of human cancers, that genetic alterations alone cannot explain. Analysis of DNA methylation status in tissue samples can be an aid to understanding the molecular mechanisms of multistage carcinogenesis. Human cancer cells show a drastic change in DNA methylation status, that is, overall DNA hypomethylation and regional DNA hypermethylation, which results in chromosomal instability and silencing of tumor-suppressor genes. Overexpression of DNA methyltransferase (DNMT) 1 is not a secondary result of increased cell proliferative activity but may underline the CpG island methylator phenotype of cancers. Splicing alteration of DNMT3B may result in chromosomal instability through DNA hypomethylation of pericentromeric satellite regions. Alterations of DNA methylation are observed even in the precancerous stage frequently associated with chronic inflammation and/or persistent viral infection or with cigarette smoking. Precancerous conditions showing alterations of DNA methylation may generate more malignant cancers. Aberrant DNA methylation is significantly associated with aggressiveness of cancers and poorer outcome of cancer patients. Genome-wide analysis of DNA methylation status based on array-based technology may identify DNA methylation profiles that can be used as appropriate indicators for carcinogenetic risk estimation and prognostication.     

Increased DNA methyltransferase 1 (DNMT1) protein expression correlates significantly with poorer tumor differentiation and frequent DNA hypermethylation of multiple CpG islands in gastric cancers

We evaluated the significance of aberrant DNA methyltransferase 1 (DNMT1) protein expression during gastric carcinogenesis. The protein expression of DNMT1, Muc2, human gastric mucin, E-cadherin, and proliferating cell nuclear antigen was examined immunohistochemically in gastric cancers and corresponding noncancerous mucosae from 134 patients. The DNA methylation status of the CpG islands of the p16, human MutL homologue 1 (hMLH1), E-cadherin, and thrombospondin-1 (THBS-1) genes and the methylated in tumor (MINT)-1, -2, -12, and -31 clones was examined by methylation-specific polymerase chain reaction and combined bisulfite restriction enzyme analysis. Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) infection was detected by in situ hybridization. Nuclear immunoreactivity for DNMT1 was not detected in any of the noncancerous epithelia, except in proliferative zones (positive internal control), but was found in 97 (72%) of the gastric cancers. DNMT1 overexpression correlated significantly with poorer tumor differentiation (P < 0.001), but not with the phenotype (gastric type versus intestinal type) of the cancer cells. It also correlated significantly with DNA hypermethylation of the CpG islands of the hMLH1 (P = 0.024) and THBS-1 genes (P = 0.043), and with the CpG island methylator phenotype in the gastric cancers (P = 0.007). Reduced E-cadherin expression correlated significantly with poorer tumor differentiation (P = 0.002), DNA hypermethylation of the E-cadherin gene (P < 0.001) and DNMT1 overexpression (P = 0.014). DNMT1 overexpression was also associated with EBV infection (a potential etiological factor in gastric carcinogenesis) but not with the proliferative activity of the cancer cells as indicated by the proliferating cell nuclear antigen-labeling index. These results suggest that DNMT1 overexpression may not be just a secondary effect of increased cancer cell proliferative activity, but may be associated with EBV infection and other etiological factors during gastric carcinogenesis. Furthermore, DNMT1 may play a significant role in the development of poorly differentiated gastric cancers by inducing frequent DNA hypermethylation of multiple CpG islands.