Management of thoracic outlet syndrome

The experience with transaxillary first-rib resection and scalenotomy reported herein shows these to be safe and effective treatments for patients with thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS). The former operation usually offers the best possibility for complete resection of the first rib and all anomalous congenital bands, and is curative in most cases, regardless of the mechanism of the compression. Scalenotomy, or Powers' operation, is also helpful, in particular for cases of TOS with a vertebral arterial insufficiency. Accurate diagnosis of TOS and selection for surgery after a detailed history and proper physical examination will result in gratifying relief of symptoms in almost all patients with TOS.     

Management of thoracic outlet syndrome

Summary The experience with transaxillary first-rib resection and scalenotomy reported herein shows these to be safe and effective treatments for patients with thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS). The former operation usually offers the best possibility for complete resection of the first rib and all anomalous congenital bands, and is curative in most cases, regardless of the mechanism of the compression. Scalenotomy, or Powers' operation, is also helpful, in particular for cases of TOS with a vertebral arterial insufficiency. Accurate diagnosis of TOS and selection for surgery after a detailed history and proper physical examination will result in gratifying relief of symptoms in almost all patients with TOS.     

Management of vascular complications in thoracic outlet syndrome

Arterial complications of thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS) were surgically treated in 11 patients (12 limbs) and venous complications in five (6 limbs). Arteriography showed total occlusion or significant stenosis of the subclavian artery in eight patients (bilateral in 1), with complicating peripheral thrombosis in three. Two patients had unilateral subclavian artery aneurysm: One was the patient with bilateral subclavian occlusion, and the other also had brachial artery embolism. Yet another patient had brachial thrombosis. Treatment included reconstructive surgery (3 limbs), thoracic sympathectomy (3) or decompression alone (6). Of the five patients with venous TOS complications, four were found at phlebography to have subclavian thrombosis and one had significant bilateral subclavian obstruction. Treatment was transaxillary first-rib resection (4 cases) or division of soft-tissue bands and hypertrophied anterior scalene muscle (1 case). After follow-up averaging 9 years, eight of the nine survivors in the arterial group were working and seven were asymptomatic. All five in the venous group were working and only two had slight, strain-related symptoms. Impaired arterial flow in TOS can usually be managed with decompression, but direct surgery (bypass or thrombectomy) or thoracic sympathectomy is required in cases with severe ischemia with proximal occlusion and after resection of a subclavian aneurysm or in cases with unilateral Raynaud's phenomenon or thrombosis of small arteries. For venous symptoms decompression alone suffices.     

Recurrent thoracic outlet syndrome

Recurrent symptoms develop in 15% to 20% of patients undergoing either first rib resection or scalenectomy for thoracic outlet syndrome. Over the past 22 years 134 operations for recurrence were performed in 97 patients. Four operations were used: transaxillary first rib resection (26); supraclavicular first rib resection with neurolysis (15); scalenectomy with neurolysis (58); and brachial plexus neurolysis (35). Complications included temporary plexus injury (0.7%), temporary phrenic palsy (3.7%), and permanent phrenic palsy (1.4%). The combined primary success rate of all four operations for recurrence was 84% in the first 3 months. This fell to 59% at 1 to 2 years; 50% at 3 to 5 years; and 41% at 10 to 15 years. No significant difference was found in results between the four operations used for recurrence. When recurrence was caused by trauma the results of reoperations were better than when recurrence was spontaneous. The primary success rates of three initial operations for thoracic outlet syndrome were compared to their secondary success rates (improved after reoperation). By use of life-table methods, reoperation improved the 5- to 10-year success rate of transaxillary first rib resection from 69% to 86% and for scalenectomy from 69% to 84%. Reoperation is successful in most cases of recurrent thoracic outlet syndrome and better when recurrence is the result of a neck injury.     

Vascular thoracic outlet syndrome

Abstract The surgical treatment of 30 cases of vascular thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS) in 25 patients is presented. Patients included 17 women and 8 men with average age of 26.1 years. The causes of compression were cervical rib (n = 16), soft tissue anomalies (n = 12), and scar tissue after clavicle fracture (n = 2). Ten subclavian artery aneurysms containing intraluminal thrombus as well as one subclavian artery occlusion were found. All such cases had multiple distal arterial embolization. Presenting features of cases with arterial TOS included: hand ischemia (n = 11), transient ischemic attack (TIA) (n = 1), and claudication or vasomotor phenomena during the arm hyperabduction (n = 11). Two patients with venous TOS developed hand edema during arm hyperabduction, and five other patients had axillary-subclavian venous thrombosis. In all cases decompressive procedures using a combined supraclavicular and infraclavicular approach were performed. Decompression was achieved by cervical rib excision (n = 12), combined cervical and first rib excision (n = 4), and first rib excision (n = 14). In all cases division of all soft tissue elements was also accomplished. Associated vascular procedures included resection and replacement of 10 subclavian artery aneurysms, one subclavian-axillary and one axillary-brachial bypass, as well as nine brachial embolectomies. All five cases with axillary-subclavian vein thrombosis before decompression were treated with anticoagulant therapy. The mean follow-up period was 3 years and 2 months (range 1 to 6 years). Two pleural entry injuries and two transient brachial plexus injuries were noted. All reconstructed arteries were patent during the follow-up period. Complete resolution of symptoms with a return to full activity was noticed in all cases with arterial TOS and in two cases with venous TOS without axillary-subclavian vein thrombosis. In cases with axillary-subclavian vein thrombosis relief of symptoms was mild, and there were limitations on daily activity. Vascular TOS is seen less frequently than the neurogenic form; however, in most cases it requires surgical treatment. We prefer a combined supraclavicular and infraclavicular approach because it offers complete exposure of the subclavian artery, cervical and first ribs, and all soft tissue anomalies. Electronic Publication     

Venous thoracic outlet syndrome

Venous thoracic outlet syndrome is caused by subclavian vein obstruction with or without thrombosis. The primary symptom is arm swelling, frequently accompanied by cyanosis, pain, and occasionally paresthesias. Venography is the only reliable diagnostic tool. Therapy has three goals: (1) remove the thrombus (in thrombotic cases), (2) remove the extrinsic compression, and in a minority of cases, (3) remove the intrinsic stenosis.     

Neurogenic thoracic outlet syndrome

Current concepts for the diagnosis of neurogenic thoracic outlet syndrome are presented together with the surgical experience and results in series of 51 patients caused by a cervical rib. Surgical treatment is recommended in patients with persistent and disabling symptoms not responding to conservative therapy. In carefully selected patients good to excellent results can be achieved.     

Arterial thoracic outlet syndrome

Arterial vascular complications resulting from thoracic outlet compression, although rare, can be substantial and potentially limb threatening. Bony abnormalities such as cervical ribs can lead to chronic trauma to the subclavian artery. Early on, the clinical symptoms can be subtle and confusing, causing potential delay in diagnosis.     

Recurrent thoracic outlet syndrome

In the author's experience, the rate of recurrence is lower (5%-10%) when a combined procedure (transaxillary first rib resection followed by immediate transcervical anterior and middle scalenectomy) is performed as the primary operation. The author strongly believes this combined procedure accomplishes an excellent decompression of the thoracic outlet area and decreases the rate of recurrence and reoperation. In addition, spontaneous recurrence most likely is caused when scar tissue gradually builds up in the surgical area. For this reason, as mentioned previously, the author instructs and encourages patients to start postoperative exercises the day after surgery and to continue these exercises for at least 6 months and preferably 1 year to improve brachial plexus and subclavian vessel gliding and to minimize the harmful effects of scar tissue.     

Diagnosing thoracic outlet syndrome

Diagnosing and treating thoracic outlet syndrome can be challenging and frustrating. It must be emphasized that the diagnosis of TOS is a clinical one based on a detailed history and physical examination. This takes time and effort and is often confounded by the patient's research on the internet and emotional problems usually resulting from the symptoms and lack of appropriate treatment. Years of inappropriate diagnosis and ineffective therapy take a heavy toll on these patients. Some have psychologic problems to the point that no treatment, no matter how well indicated, will make them well. Some have had symptoms so long that there is permanent neurologic damage. Each patient presents his or her own diagnostic challenge. Solving the problem and providing effective therapy can be rewarding for doctor and patient.     

Superior thoracic outlet syndrome

The authors discuss Superior Thoracic Outlet Syndrome (STOS), which is characterized by aspecific symptomatology. However, some tests may be used to reveal the specificity of the disease. In the past, treatment was often followed by recurrence of the disease. In the last ten years, the Roos operation has been used with a high success rate.     

Post-traumatic thoracic outlet syndrome

Background  

To evaluate the clinical presentation, diagnostic and therapeutic management and outcome of 27 cases of post-traumatic thoracic outlet syndrome (PT TOS).     

Reoperation for recurrent thoracic outlet syndrome.

Recurrent thoracic outlet syndrome that requires reoperation accounts for 1% of first rib resections. Symptoms in a series of 30 patients were mainly neurological and consisted of pain and paresthesia involving the neck, shoulder, arm, and hand and were severe and unrelenting. Recurrence of symptoms ensued from one month to seven years following initial rib resection, with the majority appearing within the first three months. Nerve conduction velocities were diminished to an average of 51 m per second, well below the normal of 72 m per second. Reoperation was required after a period of extensive physiotherapy and muscle relaxants. The high posterior thoracoplasty approach is recommended for all reoperations, as it gives better exposure to achieve safe neurolysis of the plexus and complete excision of the regenerated periosteum and posterior rib remnant, which were present in almost all patients. Results of reoperation were gratifying, and postoperative nerve conduction velocities were improved to an everage of 66 m per second.     

Epidemiology of thoracic outlet syndrome

Thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS) describes a complex disease process with three anatomic variations each with their own individual characteristics. Understanding the prevalence, diagnosis, and treatment of TOS is challenging for many providers. For this reason, the establishment of comprehensive care models and expert leadership by dedicated vascular surgeons with TOS experience has been invaluable.     

History of thoracic outlet syndrome

Thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS), a condition in which neurovascular structures in the thoracic outlet region are compressed, can be caused by anatomical abnormalities or acquired changes in the soft tissues and bony structures in the region. The brachial plexus is the most frequently affected structure. TOS is one of the most difficult neurovascular compressions in the upper extremity to manage because of the variability of complaints and the high risk associated with surgical treatment.     

Diagnosis of thoracic outlet syndrome

Thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS) is a nonspecific label. When employing it, one should define the type of TOS as arterial TOS, venous TOS, or neurogenic TOS. Each type has different symptoms and physical findings by which the three types can easily be identified. Neurogenic TOS (NTOS) is by far the most common, comprising well over 90% of all TOS patients. Arterial TOS is the least common accounting for no more than 1%. Many patients are erroneously diagnosed as "vascular" TOS, a nonspecific misnomer, whereas they really have NTOS. The Adson Test of noting a radial pulse deficit in provocative positions has been shown to be of no clinical value and should not be relied upon to make the diagnosis of any of the three types. The test is normal in most patients with NTOS and at the same time can be positive in many control volunteers. Arterial TOS is caused by emboli arising from subclavian artery stenosis or aneurysms. Symptoms are those of arterial ischemia and x-rays almost always disclose a cervical rib or anomalous first rib. Venous TOS presents with arm swelling, cyanosis, and pain due to subclavian vein obstruction, with or without thrombosis. Neurogenic TOS is due to brachial plexus compression usually from scarred scalene muscles secondary to neck trauma, whiplash injuries being the most common. Symptoms include extremity paresthesia, pain, and weakness as well as neck pain and occipital headache. Physical exam is most important and includes several provocative maneuvers including neck rotation and head tilting, which elicit symptoms in the contralateral extremity; the upper limb tension test, which is comparable to straight leg raising; and abducting the arms to 90 degrees in external rotation, which usually brings on symptoms within 60 seconds.