A call for clinically driven experimental design in assessing neuroprotection in experimental Parkinsonism

Parkinson's disease is a progressive neurodegenerative disorder. At present, only symptomatic treatments are of proven efficacy, whereas strategies that slow or stop the neurodegenerative process are currently not available. The selection of interesting drug candidates or surgical strategies should be based on the soundest clinically driven preclinical validation. My goal here is not to discuss the relative merits of the available models, but to simply raise the issue of the experimental design that has led to the demonstration of efficacy of given compounds in these models. As some compounds previously shown to be active in classic experimental designs fail when tested in clinically relevant experimental designs, I emphasize the need for progressive screening methods and for the use of different animal species before entering into the clinic.     

Nicotine neuroprotection against nigrostriatal damage: importance of the animal model

Parkinson's disease is a neurodegenerative movement disorder that is characterized by a loss of nigrostriatal dopamine-containing neurons. Unexpectedly, there is a reduced incidence of Parkinson's disease in tobacco users. This finding is important because the identification of the component(s) responsible for this effect could lead to therapeutic strategies to slow down or halt the progression of Parkinson's disease. Results from cell culture models consistently show that nicotine protects against neurotoxicity. However, data from animal models of nigrostriatal damage are conflicting, thus raising questions about a neuroprotective role of nicotine. Accumulating evidence indicates that discrepancies are observed primarily in mouse models of the disease. By contrast, reproducible protection occurs in rat models and in a nonhuman primate parkinsonian model that closely resembles the human disease. These findings highlight the need to use the appropriate animal model and treatment conditions when testing putative neuroprotective agents.     

Criteria for an animal model of alcoholism

A correspondence between the various components of human alcoholism and their animal analogue has not yet been achieved; in some part, this failure resides with experimental attempts which obtain which obtain only surface equivalencies and which lack an underlying motivational structure. Seven criteria for an animal model are proposed including the oral ingestion of alcohol without food deprivation, substantial ingestion of alcohol with competing fluids available, drinking directed to the intoxicating effect of alcohol, the performance of work to obtain alcohol, the maintenance of intoxication over a long period and, finally, the production of physical dependence and, on withdrawal, the abstinence syndrome.     

Trazodone-digoxin interaction in an animal model

Serum digoxin concentrations have been reported to increase in two patients taking daily doses of trazodone. However, in a canine model, no elevation in serum digoxin concentration was found with combined trazodone-digoxin administration. The authors suggest that serum digoxin concentrations should be monitored in patients receiving trazodone and digoxin concomitantly.     

Nicotine in an animal model of attention

Studies in smokers have suggested that at least part of the improved psychomotor performance produced by nicotine is the result of an effect on attention. Many animal experiments have assessed the effects of nicotine and its antagonists on diverse types of learning and memory but relatively few have looked at it in tasks designed to assess attention. In a five-choice serial reaction time task (5-CSRTT), rats with restricted access to food were presented with an array of five holes; illumination of a randomly selected hole signalled that a nose-poke into it would be reinforced by food presentation. Initially, signal length and the inter-trial interval (ITI) were varied and the procedure was demonstrated to satisfy some criteria for a vigilance task. The effects of nicotine on deficits in performance induced by varying signal length and ITI were assessed. Under appropriate conditions, small doses of nicotine increased the percentage of correct responses (accuracy), decreased omission errors and reaction time, and increased anticipatory responses. Subsequently, the effects of varying the ITI were examined more extensively in a slightly modified task. Here, nicotine produced small but robust, highly significant dose-related increases in accuracy, as well as decreases in omission errors and reaction times. Nicotine also increased accuracy when light stimuli were presented in an unpredictable manner. The nicotine antagonist mecamylamine produced a modest deficit in reaction time only. It is concluded that appropriate doses of nicotine can produce robust improvements in performance of normal rats in an attentional task. The effect cannot be attributed easily to changes in sensory or motor capability, learning or memory and may provide the measures needed to investigate the neuropharmacological and neuroanatomical bases of the elusive attentional effect of nicotine.     

Arsenic-induced bladder cancer in an animal model

Dimethylarsinic acid (DMA(V)) is carcinogenic to the rat urinary bladder, but not in mice. The carcinogenic mode of action involves cytotoxicity followed by regenerative cell proliferation. Dietary DMA(V) does not produce urinary solids or significant alterations in urinary composition. The cytotoxicity is due to formation of a reactive metabolite, likely dimethylarsinous acid (DMA(III)), concentrated and excreted in the urine. Urinary concentrations of DMA(III) are dose-dependent, and the urinary concentrations are at cytotoxic levels based on in vitro studies. The no observed effect level (NOEL) in these rat dietary studies for detectable levels of DMA(III), cytotoxicity, and proliferation is 2 ppm, with marginal changes at 10 ppm. The tumorigenic dose is 100 ppm. Recent investigations have demonstrated that arsenicals administered to the rat result in binding to a specific cysteine in the hemoglobin alpha chain as DMA(III), regardless of the arsenical being administered. Monomethylarsonic acid (MMA(V)) is not carcinogenic in rats or mice. In short term experiments (< or =10 weeks), sodium arsenate in the drinking water induces significant cytotoxicity and regenerative proliferation. There is little evidence that the cytotoxicity produced following administration of arsenicals is caused by oxidative damage, as antioxidants show little inhibitory activity of the cytotoxicity of the various arsenicals either in vitro or in vivo. In summary, the mode of action for DMA(V)-induced bladder carcinogenesis in the rat involves generation of a reactive metabolite (DMA(III)) leading to cytotoxicity and regenerative proliferation, is a non-linear process, and likely involves a threshold. Extrapolation to human risk needs to take this into account along with the significant differences in toxicokinetics and toxicodynamics that occur between different species.     

Effects of diethylcholine in two animal models of Parkinsonism tremors.

(2-Hydroxyethyl) methyldiethylammonium iodide (diethylcholine; DEC) was tested against trihexyphenidyl for its ability to block tremors in two animal models of Parkinsonism tremors. Both DEC (75 mg/kg) and trihexyphenidyl (10 mg/kg) antagonized physostigmine tremors in mice. Both drugs also blocked tremors in rats which received intracaudate injections of carbachol. DEC was more efficacious than trihexyphenidyl in the rat model. No dose-related inhibition of tremors was seen for trihexyphenidyl (5--20 mg/kg) but inhibition by DEC was dose-related (25--50 mg/kg). The ED50 for tremor inhibition in the rat model by DEC was 33 mg/kg. DEC was also shown to cross the blood-brain barrier in mice. The probable mechanism of action of DEC is discussed.     

Development and applications of an animal model for human tumor xenografts

Wistar rats treated with cyclophosphamide (4x 10 mg/kg), total lymphoid irradiation (9.0 Gy; dose rate 0.60 Gy/min) and cyclosporin A (15 mg/kg, daily, orally) developed a state of immune suppression permitting the growth of human tumor xenografts. Immunosuppression was monitored by lymphocyte counts, serum IgG determination. PHA and Con A lymphocyte-responses, proportion of B cells and histopathological studies of the lymphoid organs. The lymphocyte counts, IgG levels, PHA and Con A stimulation values remained severely depressed, during the period of cyclosporin A administration. Repopulation of the paracortical areas of the lymph nodes and the peri-arteriolar sheaths of the spleen did not occur, neither the reconstruction of the germinal centers in these organs. The thymus underwent severe atrophy. Seven of eight different types of human tumors were successfully xenografted in the immunomodified rat. The xenografted tumors maintained their original morphologic features and the mitotic rate did not change during subsequent transplantations.     

Antitumor activity of trovafloxacin in an animal model

Quinolone antibiotics come close to being ideal chemotherapeutic agents in that they are administered orally, are concentrated in cells and tissue, are readily available, relatively safe and exhibit increased activity against both bacteria and tumor cells both in vitro and in vivo. Our objective was to evaluate the in vivo activity of trovafloxacin and ciprofloxacin against murine leukemic cells in neutropenic mice with lung infection due to Klebsiella pneumoniae. The results showed that both trovafloxacin and ciprofloxacin were effective in clearing lung infection. However, trovafloxacin, but not ciprofloxacin, was effective in preventing metastasis of leukemia cells to the lungs and other tissue and in prolonging the survival of mice.     

The guinea pig as an animal model for asthma

Experimental guinea pig asthma is a reliable and clinically relevant facsimile of human disease. The guinea pig is the preferred choice for use as a model of allergic bronchial asthma in the evaluation of anti-asthmatic drugs, since the airway anatomy and the response to inflammatory mediators is similar to humans. Further, the great strength of this model is the direct anaphylactic bronchoconstriction upon antigen challenge. Under certain conditions a late asthmatic response can be measured and airway hyperresponsiveness is observed in vitro and in vivo. Moreover, the inflammatory response is comparable with the human situation. More recent studies describe a chronic model for asthma in which airway remodeling is induced as can be observed in the asthmatic patients. The focus here is to demonstrate that guinea pig asthma models are useful for testing novel therapeutics.     

Age differences in an animal model of obsessive-compulsive disorder: participation of dopamine: dopamine in an animal model of OCD

The putative age difference in the effect of chronically administered quinpirole (0.125 and 0.5 mg/kg, 11 injections) on alternation in a T maze was studied. Male juvenile (43 days old) and adult (around 90 days old) rats exhibited similar control values of alternation. In adults, quinpirole (0.5 mg/kg) produced a drastic perseveration after 10 and 11 injections (mean number of repetitive choices of 3.4 and 3.1, respectively); conversely, in juvenile, such treatment produced a less marked perseveration (mean number of repetitive choices of 1.7 and 2.1, for the 10th and 11th injection, respectively). We also studied the age difference in the protective actions of clomipramine subchronically administered (15 mg/kg, three times) on the quinpirole-induced perseveration. Clearly, as previously demonstrated, in adult animals, this tricyclic antidepressant completely prevented the drug-induced perseveration (mean number of repetitive choices of 1.7); while in juvenile, animals only produced a weak action (mean number of repetitive choices of 1.8). Data agreed with basic research showing a hyposensitivity of juvenile animals to dopaminergic agonists and with clinical findings suggesting a weaker effect of clomipramine treatment in youth. These results reinforce perseveration in a T maze as a useful animal model for studying age differences in obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD).     

Comments on an animal model of depression

Depression is a multifactorial illness and genetic factors play a role in its etiology. The understanding of its pathophysiology relies on the availability of experimental models potentially mimicking the disease. Here is presented a model built up by selective breeding of mice with strikingly different responses in the tail suspension test, a stress paradigm aimed at screening potential antidepressants. Indeed, "helpless" mice are essentially immobile in the tail suspension test, as well as the Porsolt forced-swim test, and they show reduced consumption of a palatable 2% sucrose solution. In addition, helpless mice exhibit sleep-wakefulness alterations resembling those classically observed in depressed patients, notably a lighter and more fragmented sleep, with an increase pressure of rapid eye movement sleep. Compared with "nonhelpless" mice, they display higher basal serum corticosterone levels and lower serotonin metabolism index in the hippocampus. Remarkably, serotonin1A autoreceptor stimulation induced greatest hypothermia and inhibition of serotoninergic neuronal firing in the nucleus raphe dorsalis in helpless than in nonhelpless mice. Thus, helpless mice exhibit a decrease in serotoninergic tone, which evokes that associated with endogenous depression in humans. Finally, both the behavioral impairments and the serotoninergic dysfunction can be improved by chronic treatment with the antidepressant fluoxetine. The helpless line of mice may provide an opportunity to approach genes influencing susceptibility to depression and to investigate neurophysiological and neurochemical substrates underlying antidepressant effects.     

Pralidoxime in carbaryl poisoning: an animal model

INTRODUCTION: Poisoning from organophosphates and carbamates is a significant cause of morbidity and mortality worldwide. Concerns have been expressed over the safety and efficacy of the use of oximes such as pralidoxime (2-PAM) in patients with carbamate poisoning in general, and more so with carbaryl poisoning specifically. The goal of the present study was to evaluate the role of 2-PAM in a mouse model of lethal carbaryl poisoning. METHODS: Female ICR Swiss Albino mice weighing 25-30 g were acclimated to the laboratory and housed in standard conditions. One hundred and ten mice received an LD50 dose of carbaryl subcutaneously. Ten minutes later, they were randomized by block randomization to one of eight treatment groups: normal saline control, atropine alone, 100 mg/kg 2-PAM with and without atropine, 50 mg/kg 2-PAM with and without atropine, and 25 mg/kg 2-PAM with and without atropine. All medications were given intraperitoneally and the atropine dose was constant at 4 mg/kg. The single objective endpoint was defined as survival to 24 hours. Fatalities were compared using a Chi squared or Fisher's exact test. RESULTS: Following an LD50 of carbaryl, 60% of the animals died. Atropine alone statistically improved survival (15% lethality). High dose 2-PAM with and without atropine was numerically worse, but not statistically different from control. While the middle dose of 2-PAM was no different than control, the addition of atropine improved survival (10% fatality). Low-dose 2-PAM statistically improved survival (25% lethality). Atropine further reduced lethality to 10%. CONCLUSION: When appropriately dosed, 2-PAM alone protects against carbaryl poisoning in mice. Failure to demonstrate this benefit in other models may be the result of oxime overdose.     

The effect of chronic timolol in an animal model for myocardial infarction

The effect of no drug or timolol (5 mg/kg, PO, for 1, 2, or 8 weeks on postganglionic cardiac sympathetic neural discharge, blood pressure, heart rate and beta-receptor density after acute coronary occlusion of the left anterior descending artery was compared. Beta-receptor density, determined by binding of 3H-dihydroalprenolol, was examined in the myocardium (LA = left atrium, RA = right atrium, LV1 = proximal and LV2 = distal left anterior descending artery distribution, LV3 = posterior left ventricle, S = septum, and RV = right ventricle). In control cats (no coronary occlusion or timolol) beta-receptor density of LV2 and LV3 was greater (P less than .05) than LA, RA, LV1, and RV. LV3 was greater (P less than .05) than S and RA, and LA was less than S. Longer treatment with timolol increased beta-receptor density. When compared with no timolol, beta-receptor density was greater in RA after 8 weeks and in LV1 after 2 weeks and not different in LV2 and S. Beta-receptor density and LV3 and RV were greater after 8 weeks than after 1 week or no timolol. Spearman rank correlation coefficients between dose and beta-receptor density revealed an increase (P less than .05) for all heart areas. Heart rate did not vary before timolol and was decreased after all doses of timolol. Timolol increased the mean times to coronary occlusion-induced death although the increase was not statistically significant. Timolol did not prevent postganglionic cardiac sympathetic neural discharge associated with arrhythmia. Timolol may increase beta-receptor density and decrease synaptic norepinephrine, causing a decreased release per cardiac sympathetic nerve impulse. Alternatively, molecules of timolol may accumulate in nerve endings and be released in greater concentrations at the receptors. This could explain the protection against coronary occlusion-induced arrhythmia and death.     

Effects of S9977 and dihydroergotamine in an animal experimental model for migraine.

The present study concerns the effects of S9977, a trimethylxanthine derivative with potential antimigraine characteristics, on the distribution of carotid blood flow in the anaesthetized pig. Furthermore, the effects of dihydroergotamine have been analysed for comparison. Dihydroergotamine (3, 10, 30 and 100 micrograms/kg, i.v.) elicited dose-dependent pressor and bradycardic responses which were probably mediated by its partial agonist action on alpha-adrenoceptors and dopamine2 receptors. In contrast, S9977 (0.3, 1, 3 and 10 mg/kg, i.v.) caused a moderate hypotension and bradycardia. The carotid haemodynamic effects of dihydroergotamine (3, 10, 30 and 100 micrograms/kg, i.v.) consisted of a dose-dependent reduction of arteriovenous anastomotic blood flow and conductance and an increase in nutrient (tissue) blood flow and conductance. As a consequence, jugular venous PO2 decreased. These findings, demonstrating an active constriction of arteriovenous anastomoses, are in agreement with earlier findings in cats. Though S9977 (0.3, 1, 3 and 10 mg/kg, i.v.) decreased carotid (two highest doses) and arteriovenous anastomotic (highest dose) blood flow, there was no concomitant decrease in the vascular conductances. Therefore, the effects of S9977 seem to be related to a decrease in arterial blood pressure and not to an active vasoconstriction of arteriovenous anastomoses. These results are discussed in terms of the potential therapeutical usefulness of S9977 in the treatment of migraine.     

Pre- and postsynaptic serotonergic manipulations in an animal model of depression

Rats working on a food-reinforced operant schedule and exhibiting behavioral depression following administration of D,L-5-hydroxytryptophan (5-HTP) were pretreated with one of three drugs: methysergide, fluoxetine, or amitriptyline. The former two drugs were used to establish a basis for distinguishing between pre- and postsynaptic events. We found that methysergide, a known postsynaptic blocker of serotonin, almost completely abolished the depressive effect of 5-HTP, whereas fluoxetine, a known specific uptake blocker of serotonin, potentiated the depressive effect of the 5-hydroxytryptamine (5-HT) precursor. Amitriptyline, one of the commonly prescribed antidepressive drugs, reduced the behavioral depression following 5-HTP by approximately 50%. These data indicate that amitriptyline can act as an antagonist of 5-HT at the postsynaptic receptor. The results of this study, as well as those recently reported from CNS membrane binding studies, suggest that the therapeutic effects of some antidepressive drugs may be explained by their postsynaptic rather than presynaptic properties at central serotonergic receptors. Thus, these studies support the hypothesis that some types of human depression may be primarily due to an excess of free 5-HT acting at postsynaptic receptors.     

Dopamine antagonism inhibits anorectic behavior in an animal model for anorexia nervosa

Excessive physical activity is commonly described as symptom of Anorexia Nervosa (AN). Activity-based anorexia (ABA) is considered an animal model for AN. The ABA model mimics severe body weight loss and increased physical activity. Suppression of hyperactivity by olanzapine in anorectic patients as well as in ABA rats suggested a role of dopamine and/or serotonin in this trait. Here, we investigated the effect of a non-selective dopamine antagonist in the ABA model. A dose–response curve of chronic treatment with the non-selective dopaminergic antagonist cis-flupenthixol was determined in the ABA model. Treatment reduced activity levels in both ad libitum fed and food-restricted rats. Treated ABA rats reduced body weight loss and increased food intake. These data support a role for dopamine in anorexia associated hyperactivity. Interestingly, in contrast to leptin treatment, food-anticipatory activity still persists in treated ABA rats.     

Attenuated stress responsiveness in an animal model for neurodevelopmental psychopathological disorders.

Day 7 amygdala-lesioned (D7 AMX) rats have been proposed as a model for neurodevelopmental psychopathological disorders such as schizophrenia. Patients with schizophrenia are sensitive to stress and show an impaired hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal response to certain stressful stimuli. Therefore, we investigated neuroendocrine and behavioral stress responses in the D7 AMX lesion model. Plasma concentrations of ACTH, corticosterone, and catecholamines were measured in response to foot shock and novelty in D7 and D21 lesioned (AMX) and non-lesioned (SHAM) animals. Behavior was recorded and analyzed afterwards. D7 AMX rats, unlike other rats, had a reduced ACTH response to foot shock and showed less active behavior in response to novelty. Neurodevelopmental dysfunction of target structures of the amygdala is associated with disturbed endocrine and behavioral responses to stress. These data accord with the notion that the D7 amygdala-lesioned rat can function as a neurodevelopmental model with relevance to schizophrenia.     

Neuropathy in experimental diabetes: an animal model.

A morphometric study of the common peroneal nerve in early experimental diabetes in rats showed that fibre size was diminished. The reduction in the size of the axon was twice that of the myelin sheath. This may contribute to the understanding of the impaired motor conduction velocity found in diabetics shortly after the onset of their disease.     

Evaluation of reward processes in an animal model of depression

Rationale Anhedonia is a core symptom of major depression. Deficits in reward function, which underlie anhedonia, can be readily assessed in animals. Therefore, anhedonia may serve as an endophenotype for understanding the neural circuitry and molecular pathways underlying depression. Objective Surprisingly, there is scant knowledge regarding alterations in brain reward function after olfactory bulbectomy (OB), an animal model which results in a behavioural syndrome responsive to chronic antidepressant treatment. Therefore, the present studies aimed to assess reward function after bulbectomy. Materials and methods The present study utilized sucrose preference, cocaine-induced hyperlocomotion and intra-cranial self-stimulation (ICSS) responding to examine reward processes in the OB model. Results Bulbectomized animals showed a marked preference (>90%) for 0.8% sucrose solution compared with water; similar to the preference exhibited by sham controls. Importantly, there were pronounced deficits in brain reward function, as assessed using ICSS, which lasted 8 days before returning to baseline levels. Furthermore, bulbectomized animals were hyper-responsive to the locomotor stimulating properties of an acute and a repeated cocaine regimen. However, no difference in ICSS facilitation was observed in response to an acute cocaine injection. Conclusions Taken together, these results suggest that bulbectomized rats display alterations in brain reward function, but these changes are not long-lasting and thus, not amenable to investigating the effects of pharmacological interventions. However, given that OB animals are hypersensitive to drugs of abuse, bulbectomy may be an appropriate inducing factor for the development of animal models of co-morbid depression and drug dependence.