Minimal residual disease in multiple myeloma: Benefits of flow cytometry

Over the last 20 years, the approaches to the treatment of multiple myeloma (MM) have changed considerably, which led to an increase in remission rate. Using new diagnostic methods has made it possible to assess the response to treatment more reliably and forecast disease recurrence: allele‐specific polymerase chain reaction, new‐generation sequencing and multicolor flow cytometry enable minimal residual disease (MRD) detection of with sensitivity of 10^?5 to 10^?6. MRD assessment with flow cytometry using is a rapidly developing area of research. The goal of multicenter groups that use flow cytometry as a tool to detect MRD in patients with MM is achieving standardization and increasing sensitivity and specificity of this method. This article provides data about the methods used for MRD monitoring and describes the advances in the field of flow cytometry.     

Computational flow cytometry provides accurate assessment of measurable residual disease in chronic lymphocytic leukaemia

Undetectable measurable residual disease (MRD) is associated with favourable clinical outcomes in chronic lymphocytic leukaemia (CLL). While assessment is commonly performed using multiparameter flow cytometry (MFC), this approach is associated with limitations including user bias and expertise that may not be widely available. Implementation of unsupervised clustering algorithms in the laboratory can address these limitations and have not been previously reported in a systematic quantitative manner. We developed a computational pipeline to assess CLL MRD using FlowSOM. In the training step, a self-organising map was generated with nodes representing the full breadth of normal immature and mature B cells along with disease immunophenotypes. This map was used to detect MRD in multiple validation cohorts containing a total of 456 samples. This included an evaluation of atypical CLL cases and samples collected from two different laboratories. Computational MRD showed high correlation with expert analysis (Pearson's r > 0.99 for typical CLL). Binary classification of typical CLL samples as either MRD positive or negative demonstrated high concordance (>98%). Interestingly, computational MRD detected disease in a small number of atypical CLL cases in which MRD was not detected by expert analysis. These results demonstrate the feasibility and value of automated MFC analysis in a diagnostic laboratory.     

Challenges and opportunities in the assessment of measurable residual disease in multiple myeloma

Treatment response assessment in multiple myeloma (MM) relies on the detection of paraprotein in serum and/or urine, bone marrow morphology and immunohistochemistry. With remarkable advances in therapy, particularly in the newly diagnosed setting, achievement of complete remission became frequent, creating the need to identify smaller amounts of residual disease and understand their prognostic and therapeutic implications. Measurable residual disease (MRD) can be assessed primarily by flow cytometry and next generation sequencing and state-of-the-art assays have sensitivity approaching 1 in 10⁶ cells. This review discusses the existing challenges in utilizing MRD to inform management of MM and highlights open research questions and opportunities as MRD is more routinely incorporated into clinical practice for patients with MM.     

Comparison of MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry analysis of peripheral blood and bone marrow-based flow cytometry for tracking measurable residual disease in patients with multiple myeloma

Matrix-assisted laser desorption ionisation time-of-flight mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOF MS) may soon replace routine electrophoretic methods for monitoring monoclonal proteins in patients with multiple myeloma. To further evaluate the clinical utility of this assay, we compared the performance of MALDI-TOF-MS head-to-head with an established bone marrow-based measurable residual disease assay by flow cytometry (Flow-BM-MRD), using Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center’s 10-color, single-tube method. Our results suggest that MALDI-TOF-MS adds value to bone marrow-based MRD testing and may be most useful for early detection of relapse in peripheral blood compared to current electrophoretic methods.     

Evaluation of minimal residual disease in multiple myeloma patients by fluorescent-polymerase chain reaction: the prognostic impact of achieving molecular response

This study aimed to standardize a simple molecular method for evaluating the response to treatment in multiple myeloma (MM) patients after high dose chemotherapy. Fifty three patients enrolled in the GEM2000 protocol were studied for minimal residual disease (MRD) using both fluorescent-polymerase chain reaction (F-PCR) and flow cytometry. Most patients had achieved complete remission or very good response after autologous stem cell transplantation. The molecular analysis of immunoglobulin gene rearrangements at diagnosis and during the follow-up was carried out by F-PCR according to the Biomed-2 protocols. F-PCR could be used in 91% of the patients and the results were similar to flow cytometry. F-PCR was able to identify a group of patients with a better prognosis [progression-free survival (PFS) 67·86% in patients with negative F-PCR vs. 28%; P  = 0·001], even amongst patients who achieved a complete response with negative immunofixation (PFS 75% vs. 25%; P  = 0·002). Multivariate analysis identified the F-PCR result as the only variable to show a prognostic value when PFS was analysed. F-PCR of DHJ and light chain rearrangements of immunoglobulin genes is a feasible method for evaluating MRD in MM patients after intensive therapy. Achieving molecular response by F-PCR shows prognostic value.     

Aggressive and extramedullary plasma cell myeloma evade bone marrow flow cytometric minimal residual disease detection

The role of the fibrinolytic system in the development of venous thrombosis (VT) is unclear. We studied the risk of first and recurrent VT associated with reduced fibrinolysis, as measured by clot lysis time (CLT). We also studied the relationship between CLT and thrombin generation to determine if any relationship between CLT and VT was affected by thrombin generation. Analyses were performed in the Thrombophilia Hypercoagulability Environmental risk for Venous Thromboembolism Study, a two‐centre population‐based case‐control study, including 579 patients and 338 controls, with patients followed from the event to determine incidence of recurrent VT. Hypofibrinolysis was associated with a 1·8‐fold increased risk of a first VT [95% confidence interval (CI) 1·2–2·7]. Adjustment for sex, age, study location and Endogenous Thrombin Potential (ETP) did not change the result. The risk of VT was 2·9‐fold increased when the 90th percentiles of prolonged CLT and high ETP were combined, with the highest risk for unprovoked first events (Odds Ratio = 4·2, 95% CI 1·3–13·5). In the follow‐up study the Hazard Ratio for a recurrent VT associated with hypofibrinolysis was 1·5 (95% CI 0·9–2·6). A weak dose response effect was observed in relation to prolongation of CLT and recurrent VT. Although hypofibrinolysis constitutes a risk factor for a first VT, an association with recurrence is, at best, weak.     

Flow cytometric myeloma measurable residual disease testing in the era of targeted therapies

Therapies in myeloma are rapidly advancing with a host of new targeted therapies coming to market. While these drugs offer significant survival benefits and better side-effect profiles compared with conventional chemotherapeutics, they raise significant difficulties in monitoring post-therapy disease status by flow cytometry due to assay interference and/or selection of phenotypically different sub-clones. The principal culprit, anti-CD38 monoclonal antibodies, limits the ability to detect plasma cells based on classical CD38/CD45 gating. Other markers, such as CD138, are known to be suboptimal by flow cytometry. Various techniques have been proposed to overcome this problem. The most promising of these techniques has been the marker VS38c, a monoclonal antibody targeting an endoplasmic reticulum protein which has shown high sensitivity for plasma cells. Alternative techniques for gating plasma cells, while variably effective in the near term are already the subject of several targeted therapies rendering their usefulness limited in the longer term. Likewise, future targets of these therapies may render present aberrancy markers ineffective in MRD testing. These therapies pose challenges that must be overcome with new markers and novel panels in order for flow cytometric MRD testing to remain relevant.     

High-sensitive immunophenotyping and DNA ploidy studies for the investigation of minimal residual disease in multiple myeloma.

Sensitive techniques for monitoring minimal residual disease (MRD) in multiple myeloma (MM) are needed to evaluate the effectiveness of new intensive treatment strategies. The aim of the present study was to explore the applicability and sensitivity of flow cytometry immunophenotyping and DNA ploidy studies for the investigation of residual myelomatous plasma cells (PC) in MM patients. Bone marrow (BM) samples from 61 untreated MM patients were immunophenotypically analysed with a panel of 21 monoclonal antibodies, using a high-sensitive method based on a two-step acquisition procedure through a SSC/CD38 -CD138+ 'live-gate'. Overall, in 87% of MM cases, PC displayed an aberrant phenotype at diagnosis. The most important aberrant criteria were: antigen over-expression of CD56 (62%), CD28 (16%) and CD33 (6%) and asynchronous expression of CD117 (28%), sIg (21%) and CD20 (10%). DNA aneuploidy was found in 62% of cases. The simultaneous use of these two techniques allowed the detection of aberrant/aneuploid PC in 95% of the cases. Based on dilutional experiments, the detection limit of both techniques ranged from 10(-4) to 10(-5). In 29 stem cells harvests and 19 BM samples obtained 3 months after autologous transplantation, we have investigated the presence of residual myelomatous PC; they were detected in 44% of the stem cell collections and in 61% of the BM samples obtained after transplant. The percentage of pathological PC did not significantly change during the days of harvest. In summary, the present study shows that the combined use of immunophenotyping and DNA ploidy studies is a suitable approach for MRD investigation in MM patients based on their applicability (95% of cases) and sensitivity (up to 10(-5)).     

The immunophenotypic stability of plasma cell myeloma by flow cytometry

Introduction: Flow cytometry (FC) has become increasingly utilized in the diagnosis and monitoring of plasma cell myeloma (PCM), though few studies have evaluated the longitudinal stability of antigen expression. Methods: We studied 45 PCM patients by four‐color FC for shifts in CD19, CD20, CD38, CD45, CD56, and cytoplasmic light chain expression, between diagnostic/first encounter and positive follow‐up analyses. An immunophenotypic (IP) change was defined as gain, loss, or ½ log shift of antigen expression. Results: An IP change was observed in 14/45 (31%) patients, with single IP changes in 9/14, two changes in 2/14, and three changes in 3/14. 3/14 reverted from an aberrant to a normal plasma cell IP, while remaining light chain‐restricted. Changes in expression of CD45 occurred in 9/45 (20%), CD19 in 5/45 (11.1%), CD20 in 2/45 (4.4%), and CD56 in 5/45 (11.1%). Conclusion: Approximately 1/3 of PCM cases show IP changes over time, with CD45 the least stable antigen. Recognition of this relative instability is important to avoid narrow targeting of follow‐up FC analyses, especially for minimal residual disease monitoring.     

Prognostic impact of minimal residual disease analysis by flow cytometry in patients with acute myeloid leukemia before and after allogeneic hemopoietic stem cell transplantation

Allogeneic stem cell transplantation (allo‐SCT) has become the treatment of choice in patients with intermediate‐risk and high‐risk acute myeloid leukemia (AML). The quality of response to treatment, assessed in terms of detection of minimal residual disease (MRD), has been consistently associated with prognosis and clinical outcome in patients with AML. The aim of the present study was to evaluate the prognostic impact of analyzing MRD in bone marrow using 4‐color multiparametric flow cytometry (MFC) in 29 patients with AML before and after allo‐SCT. Eighteen patients who were shown to be MRD‐negative [≤0.1% leukemia‐associated immunophenotypes (LAIPs)] by MFC at transplantation and underwent allo‐SCT had lower rates of relapse (15% vs. 66%, P = 0.045), better overall 1‐yr survival (83% vs. 52%, P = 0.021) and a lower cumulative incidence of relapse (P = 0.032) than patients who were MRD‐positive (>0.1%). All post‐transplant MRD‐positive patients underwent a therapeutic intervention after transplant (tapering of immunosuppression, donor lymphocyte infusion, or re‐transplant) with the intention of preventing relapse. Disease was controlled and MRD disappeared in five of these patients. Disease recurred in the other seven patients. We can conclude that follow‐up with MFC for the detection of MRD in AML before and after SCT is useful for predicting relapse. In the post‐transplant setting, monitoring of MRD by MFC could be a key preemptive intervention.     

Multiparameter flow cytometry quantification of bone marrow plasma cells at diagnosis provides more prognostic information than morphological assessment in myeloma patients

Quantification of bone marrow plasma cells in multiple myeloma patients using conventional morphology is of limited prognostic value, while the merit of multiparameter flow cytometry immunophenotyping is still considered unproven. Here we compare the bone marrow plasma cell counts obtained by morphology and multiparameter flow cytometry and explore the potential prognostic impact of both techniques in 765 newly diagnosed, uniformly treated multiple myeloma patients. Although multiparameter flow cytometry generally yields lower plasma cell counts (median percentage of 11% vs. 40%, respectively; p<0.001), there is a significant positive correlation between the two techniques (R =0.46, p<0.001). Regarding prognosis, multivariate analysis selected the bone marrow plasma cell counts obtained by multiparameter flow cytometry as an independent prognostic factor for overall survival (p=0.007), supporting the incorporation of multiparameter flow cytometry immunophenotyping into the routine diagnostic evaluation of multiple myeloma patients and validating the clinical utility of bone marrow plasma cell counting by multiparameter flow cytometry approaches. (clinicaltrials.gov identifier: NCT00560053).     

A CD138‐independent strategy to detect minimal residual disease and circulating tumour cells in multiple myeloma

CD138 (also termed SDC1) has been the gold‐standard surface marker to detect multiple myeloma (MM) cells for decades; however, drug‐resistant residual and circulating MM cells were shown to have lower expression of this marker. In this study, we have shown that residual MM cells following bortezomib treatment are hypoxic. This combination of drug exposure and hypoxia down‐regulates their CD138 expression, thereby making this marker unsuitable for detecting residual or other hypoxic MM cells, such as circulating tumour cells, in MM. Hence, we developed an alternative biomarker set which detects myeloma cells independent of their hypoxic and CD138 expression status in vitro, in vivo and in primary MM patients. The new markers were able to identify a clonal CD138‐negative population as minimal residual disease in the bone marrow and peripheral blood of MM patients. Further investigation to characterize the role of this population as a prognostic marker in MM is warranted.     

United we stand,divided we fall. Multicentre standardization of measurable residual disease assessment in acute leukaemia is the way forward

Assessment of measurable residual disease (MRD) using multiparameter flow cytometry in precursor B-cell acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL) is routine. However, studies on the harmonization of laboratory techniques as well as on the interpretation of results are limited. Here, Ikoma-Colturato and colleagues from Brazil demonstrate multicentric standardization of B-ALL MRD using EuroFlow protocols. Commentary on: Ikoma-Colturato et al., Multicentric standardization of minimal/measurable residual disease in B-cell precursor acute lymphoblastic leukaemia using next-generation flow cytometry in a low/middle-level income country. Br J Haematol 2023;200:381-384.     

Detection of minimal residual disease in B-lineage acute lymphoblastic leukaemia by quantitative flow cytometry

The clinical significance of detecting minimal residual disease (MRD) in B-lineage acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL) was evaluated by quantitative flow cytometry using a combination of TdT with CD10 and CD19. 53 patients with B-cell precursor ALL were followed during and after completion of treatment (median follow-up 23 months). Nine patients relapsed and MRD had been detected in six of them, 5–15 weeks before relapse despite morphological complete remission. 43 patients remain in clinical remission and in none of these was MRD detected. Disease-free survival based on the detection of MRD by flow cytometry showed a statistically significant difference between both groups ( P  < 0.0001). The absence of MRD correlates with a low relapse rate, whereas the presence of MRD predicted early relapse. This study has shown that flow cytometry can improve the morphologic assessment of bone marrow (BM) remission status in B-lineage ALL. The finding of < 5% blasts in BM aspirates did not correlate with 'true' remission in a proportion of cases as residual leukaemic blasts were detected by flow cytometry in nine samples from six patients. On the other hand, the presence of > 5% blasts assessed by morphology was not necessarily a feature of relapse in five patients as these cells were shown to have a phenotype identical to normal TdT-negative B-cell precursors. Quantitative flow cytometry was more informative than conventional morphology to assess remission status and showed a strong correlation with clinical outcome. This methodology is useful to define MRD in the majority of patients with B-lineage ALL and should be tested in prospective clinical trials.