Radiotherapy for medically inoperable non-small cell lung cancer at clinical stage I and II

We reviewed the records of 36 patients with medically inoperable stage I-II non-small cell lung carcinoma who were treated with radiotherapy. The median dose to the target was 60 Gy with conventional fractionation. Fifteen patients were treated without elective irradiation fields, while the remaining 21 were treated with extended fields including elective mediastinal regional lymph nodes. The overall survival rates at three and five years were 32.3% and 18.8%, the cause-specific survival rates were 40.9% and 27.3%, and the local control rates were 31.7% and 23.8%, respectively. In multivariate analysis the radiation dose had a marginally significant influence on the cause-specific survival, while tumor size had a significant influence on the local control rate. Only one patient had relapse in the regional mediastinal lymph nodes as the only site of metastasis. We conclude that the dose used in the present study is inadequate and recommend that further efforts be made to improve local control by dose escalation within a small target volume.     

Radiation therapy alone for medically inoperable patients with adenocarcinoma of the endometrium

Surgery with adjuvant radiation is the definitive method for treating patients with Stage I and II FIGO endometrial carcinoma. However, radiation therapy alone becomes the only curative alternative for patients who presented with severe, acute, and chronic medical illnesses which prevented surgical management. We report on 104 such patients treated at Centre Alexis Vautrin in Nancy (FRANCE) between 1975 and 1984. The minimum follow-up was 2 years, the maximum was 11 years. Fifty-two patients were treated by association of external irradiation (RT) and curietherapy (CUR), and 52 by curietherapy alone. The median age of the patients was 68.8 years with a minimum of 43 and maximum of 89 years old. Ninety-six patients (92.3%) were obese. Forty-nine (47.1%) were hypertensive. Forty-one (39.4%) had cardiovascular diseases, 25 (24%) had diabetes mellitus, and 13 (12.5%) had history of phlebitis. Seventy-nine patients (75.9%) were Stage I FIGO, 15 (14.4%) were Stage II, 4 patients (3.8%) were Stage III, and 6 patients (5.7%) were Stage IV. The 5- and 10-year overall absolute survival was 51.6% and 35.9% respectively. The 5- and 10-year determinate survival was 65.9% and 58.6% respectively. The 5- and 10-year absolute survival of patients treated by combination RT + CUR was 59.6 and 49.8% respectively. The 5- and 10-year survival of patients treated by CUR alone was 42.3% and 27% significantly worse (p = 0.025). The 5- and 10-year determinate survival for Stage Ia was 82.1%, 71.4% and for Stage Ib 64.6% and 64.6% respectively. The difference was not significant (p = 0.18). While the 5- and 10-year determinate survival for Stage II was 56.2% and 56.3%, significantly worse than Stage I patients (p = 0.043). Tumor differentiation (G) was found to be a significant prognostic factor in survival (p less than 0.05). Local failure was seen in 9 patients (8.6%) 5 in association with distant metastasis (DM). The 5- and 10-year actuarial local control were 87.6% and 85.1% respectively. Severe complications occurred in 18 patients (17.3%). Five of these patients are still alive with a mean follow-up of 8.8 years (minimum 6 years and maximum 11 years). The rate of complications had considerably diminished after 1980, as techniques improved and computerized dosimetry was used.     

Radiotherapy in treatment of carcinoma of the parotid gland, an approach for the medically or technically inoperable patient

Introduction: Initial surgical resection is considered the standard of care for patients diagnosed with tumours involving the salivary glands. We reviewed our institutional outcomes of patients treated with initial radiation therapy (RT) for diagnosed carcinoma of the parotid gland. Methods: This review examined seventeen patients that received RT as initial therapy for tumours involving the parotid gland. Fifteen patients had primary salivary gland cancer, and two patients had metastatic carcinoma to the parotid gland. Sixteen patients (94.1%) following surgical evaluation had operative risk of facial nerve impairment or sacrifice with initial surgery, four (23.5%) had clinical objective evidence of nerve involvement at evaluation, five (29.4%) were poor surgical candidates and three (17.6%) refused initial surgery. Primary tumour stages ranged T2-T4b, and disease stages ranged II-IVb. RT median dose was 70 Gy, and median follow-up was 12 months. Results: Eleven patients (64.7%) achieved a clinical complete response (CR) to therapy. Of these CR patients eight (72.7%) received definitive RT and three (27.3%) underwent surgery following RT. Two surgical patients avoided facial nerve impairment while one required nerve sacrifice. The other six patients (35.3%) achieved an unfavourable response to RT and had unresectable or metastatic disease at follow-up. No long-term complications were reported. Conclusion: Initial radiation therapy for tumours involving the parotid gland is effective to achieve clinical CR, eliminate surgical resection for many patients, and decrease risk of facial nerve impairment or sacrifice for those patients requiring surgery following RT.     

Radiotherapy in inoperable stage I lung cancer

In 38 cases of Stage I lung cancer, for which surgery was not indicated because of poor cardiopulmonary function or other reason, radical irradiation yielded excellent results. The five year survival rate was 42.1%, the 10-year survival rate 28.4% and the 15-year survival rate 17.1%. Postradiation complications which can be life-threatening, were acceptably low in incidence, and there was no radiation-related death. The results support the concept of radical irradiation being acceptable as a treatment modality for Stage I lung cancer if the patients concerned cannot have surgery because of poor cardiopulmonary function or some other reason.     

Radiotherapy alone in technically operable,medically inoperable,early-stage (I/II) non-small-cell lung cancer

PURPOSE: To investigate the effectiveness of high-dose, curative radiotherapy (RT) given alone in technically operable, but medically inoperable, patients with early-stage (I-II) non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC). METHODS AND MATERIALS: Computerized and manual searches were done to identify published reports dealing with curative RT for NSCLC. Relevant studies were identified and the information provided therein was extracted regarding patient and treatment characteristics, treatment outcome, and various pretreatment and treatment-related factors influencing outcome, as well as toxicity and quality-of-life issues. RESULTS: Although a large variation of pretreatment and treatment characteristics was noted in the available studies, a median survival time of >30 months and a 5-year survival rate of up to 30% had been achieved. Accumulated experience seems to suggest that doses of at least 65 Gy with standard fractionation, or its equivalent when altered fractionation is used, are necessary for control of NSCLC. Smaller tumors seem to have a favorable prognosis, and the issue of elective nodal RT continues to be controversial. Analyses of patterns of failure have clearly identified local failure as the predominant pattern. Although a number of potential pretreatment patient- and tumor-related prognostic factors have been examined, none has been shown to clearly influence survival. Toxicity was usually low, but very high doses (e.g., 80 Gy) given with a conventional approach may carry a risk of an excessive rate of side effects. CONCLUSION: High-dose, curative RT is an effective treatment modality in technically operable, but medically inoperable, patients with early-stage NSCLC.     

External cobalt 60 irradiation alone for stage IIB carcinoma of the uterine cervix

From 1964 to 1980, 97 patients with Stage IIb carcinoma of cervix uteri were treated by external 60Co irradiation alone. Of these 97 patients, 94 (96.9%) had squamous cell carcinoma. The parametrial extension of the lesion almost reached the pelvic wall in 73.2% and vaginal extension reached to the upper half of vaginal in 24.7% of the patients. A tumor dose of 60 Gy was given to the whole pelvis by a four field technic (opposing parallel AP and lateral portals) in 6-8 weeks. A booster dose of 10 Gy was delivered to the cervix by a pair of reduced opposing parallel AP portals or a perineal portal in a week. The doses delivered were equivalent to the Time-Dose-Fractionation (TDF) value of 110-130 at the center of pelvis and 90-110 in the whole pelvis. The 5-year survival rate for all 97 patients was 56.7%. It was 59.8% when those who died of other diseases were excluded. The prognosis of patients without residual tumor on the cervix and/or vagina was better than that with residual tumor (p less than 0.01). Thirty-seven patients died of cancer (23 died of recurrence, 8 of distant metastases, 2 of both, and 4 were lost before the fifth year). Of these 37 patients, 97.3% died within 3 years after initial treatment. During the radiation treatment, reactions were moderate. Late complications included 19 (19.6%) with mild cystitis and 16 (16.5%) with mild proctitis, 2 (2.7%) developed recto-vaginal fistula. These results were slightly poorer than those using intracavitary and external irradiation or the combination of preoperative irradiation plus surgery. Yet, for patients with extensions nearing the pelvic wall or with contra-indications to surgery or intracavitary radiotherapy, external irradiation alone is still of value.     

Long-term results of high-dose-rate brachytherapy in the primary treatment of medically inoperable stage I-II endometrial carcinoma

PURPOSE: Total-abdominal hysterectomy and bilateral salpingo-oophorectomy (TAHBSO) is the gold-standard therapy for patients with endometrial carcinoma. However, patients with high operative risks are usually treated with radiation therapy (RT) alone. The goal of this study was to update our experience of high-dose-rate brachytherapy (HDRB), with or without external-beam irradiation (EBRT), for such patients. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Between 1984 and 2003, 38 patients with Stage I and Stage II adenocarcinoma of the endometrium considered high operative risk received RT as the primary treatment. The median age was 74.1 years. Before 1996, the local extent of the disease was assessed by an examination under anesthesia (EUA) and by EUA and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) thereafter. Eight patients (21%) were treated with combined HDRB and EBRT, and 30 patients (79%) were treated with with HDRB alone. The median HDRB dose was 23.9 Gy, typically delivered in 3 fractions in a weekly schedule. The median EBRT dose was 42 Gy. RESULTS: At a median follow-up of 57.5 months for patients at risk, 11 patients (29%) have failed: 6 patients (16%) locally, 4 patients (10.5%) distantly, and 1 patient (3%) locally and distantly. Local failure was established by biopsy, and 4 patients were salvaged by TAHBSO. Higher stage and higher grade were both associated with increased failure rate. The 15-year disease-specific survival (DSS) was 78% for all stages, 90% for Stage I, and 42% for Stage II (p < 0.0001). The 15-year DSS was 91% for Grade I and 67% for Grade II and III combined (p = 0.0254). Patients with Stage I disease established by MRI (11 patients) and who received a total HDRB dose of 30 Gy had a DSS rate of 100% at 10 years. Four patients experienced late toxicities: 1 Grade II and 3 Grade III or IV. CONCLUSION: Medically inoperable Stage I endometrial carcinoma may be safely and effectively treated with HDRB as the primary therapy. In selected Stage I patients, our results are equivalent to that of surgery. We believe that the alternative option of HDRB as the primary therapy for selected Stage I endometrial carcinoma, even in patients with low operative risks, needs further evaluation.     

59例子宫内膜癌单纯放射治疗

目的 评价子宫内膜癌单纯放射治疗的效果,分析影响治疗效果的因素。方法 对５９例子宫内膜癌病例病进行回顾性分析,其中Ｉ期１７例,Ⅱ期２６例,Ⅲ期１４例,Ⅳ期２例。休外照射应用６或８ＭＶＸ射线直线加速器,后装治疗应用ＷＤ－ＨＤＲ１８及（或）Ｂｕｃｈｌｅｒ）后装治疗机。结果 该组患者５年生存率为５年生存率为６４．３％,其中Ｉ期为７９．２％,Ⅱ期为７５．３％,Ⅲ期为３１．４％,Ⅳ期为０．０％。期别、病理组     

Radiotherapy for ductal carcinoma in situ

AimsThe introduction of breast screening mammography has led to an increase in the diagnosis of ductal carcinoma in situ (DCIS). Mastectomy gives high rates of local control. However, most cases are suitable for local excision. The aim of this article is to review the role of radiotherapy in the treatment of DCIS after breast conserving surgery.Material and methodsA review of the literature relating to radiotherapy and DCISResultsThe published trials show that adjuvant radiotherapy after breast conserving surgery halves the ipsilateral recurrence rates of DCIS and invasive cancer. No subgroups have been reliably identified that do not benefit from adjuvant radiotherapy. Risk factors for recurrence are discussed.DiscussionAll patients with DCIS have potential benefit to gain from adjuvant radiotherapy. However, radiotherapy also has adverse effects and represents over-treatment from many women. Support should be given to current trials which are assessing endocrine treatment of DCIS, and whether radiotherapy can reasonably be omitted in lower risk disease.     

Radiation therapy for medically inoperable stage I and II non-small cell lung cancer

The published results of primary radiation therapy for early stage NSCLC, indicate that it is a reasonable alternative in patients with medical contraindications or who refuse surgery, resulting in acceptable morbidity, local control, and survival rates. There is no conclusive evidence that EMI is of benefit. Consequently treatment with involved field alone, may be considered when there is no evidence of hilar involvement, or when it is necessary to limit the volume of lung tissue irradiated. Although the data are not conclusive, there is evidence to suggest that the total dose of radiation delivered to the primary should be sufficient to eradicate gross disease (60 Gy or higher). Such does result in high response rates particularly for T1 tumors. There is also an indication that complete responders have better survival than other patients, suggesting that radiotherapeutic strategies to enhance tumor eradication may improve survival.     

Radiotherapy of uterine cervix carcinoma

Seventy-eight patients with uterine cervix cancer were treated radically with standardized radiation therapy at Teikyo University Hospital in Tokyo from January 1979 to December 1985. The age of these patients ranged from 32 to 88 years old (average age 66.0). The pathology and the stage of them were 71 cases of squamous cell carcinoma (1 in stage I, 11 in stage II, 58 in stage III and 1 in stage IV) and 7 cases of adenocarcinoma (6 in stage III and 1 in stage IV). The cumulative survival rates for 5 years by Kaplan-Meier method were 71.5% for squamous cell carcinoma stage II, 47.4% for squamous cell carcinoma stage III and 0% for adenocarcinoma stage III. Radiation injury was studied by the grading system of Kottmeier-NIRS in Japan. The incidence of the injuries for grade 2 and 3 was 12.8% (10/78), and the items of those were rectal injury 5.1% (4/78) and sigmoidal colonic injury 7.7% (6/78). The results of survival rate were fair for the squamous cell carcinoma compared with the other reports but poor for adenocarcinoma stage III. Concerning the therapy for advanced adenocarcinoma of the uterine cervix, special consideration should be given for irradiation doses or infusion chemotherapy.     

Intensity-modulated stereotactic radiotherapy for the treatment of medically inoperable patients with NSCLC stage I

The standard treatment for stage I non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) is lobectomy. However, a considerable number of patients are not eligible for standard lung surgery due to poor pulmonary function or comorbidities. We evaluated the efficacy and tolerability of intensity-modulated stereotactic radiotherapy (IMSRT) with moderate hypofractionation for these patients. Twelve patients were selected for IMSRT. 4D-CT planning was performed by gating CT-scanning positioning. The applied doses ranged between 10x4.5?Gy (80% ID) (N=1), 12x4.5?Gy (95% ID) (N=1) and 10x5.5?Gy (95% ID) (N=10). Long-term follow-up was performed including spirometry and CT for evaluation of local, locoregional and distant control. Even in patients with poor pulmonary function IMRST was safe and well tolerated. No severe acute adverse effects were observed. Estimated local control at 2?years was 90%. Moreover, IMSRT does not induce a significant deterioration of pulmonary function. IMRST is safe and feasible even for patients with very poor pulmonary function. The applied dose provides a high local control rate, although the biological equivalent dose (BED) is lower compared to the average of other SRT regimens. Therefore, IMRST may be an efficient alternative for all NSCLC stage I patients with contraindications to standard lobectomy especially in patients with small tumors in high-risk localisations.     

Stereotactic hypofractionated radiotherapy for stage I non-small cell lung cancer--mature results for medically inoperable patients

Medically inoperable patients with stage I NSCLC are mainly offered conventionally fractionated radiotherapy with a limited chance of local control and some toxicity. A technique for stereotactic precision therapy for extracranial tumors using a linear accelerator and a body frame for patient immobilization was applied in an attempt to improve the local control and decrease toxicity for consecutive patients with inoperable stage I NSCLC at Sahlgrenska University hospital since 1998. A hypofractionated schedule with three fractions of 15Gy to a total of 45 Gy during 1 week was used which represents a biological equivalent dose (BED) of 112.5 Gy. Planning target volume (PTV) was a 5mm margin around the tumor in the transversal plane and 10mm in the cranial-caudal direction and the dose was prescribed in the periphery of the PTV. Forty-five patients were treated between September 98 and March 03, 25 men and 20 women, median age 74 years (58-84) and median Karnofsky 80 (100-60). TNM: 18 T1N0, 27 T2N0. Histology: 18 squamous cell carcinoma, 15 adenocarcinoma, 3 NSCLC and histology was missing in nine patients. The majority, 51%, did not experience any toxicity at all, four had esophagitis grade I, nine had skin reactions, four had transient chest pain and four had infections. Late toxicity was two rib fractures and three patients with atelectasias. After a median follow-up of 43 months had nine patients developed local recurrence or never achieved local control, two had regional recurrence and nine distant metastases. The 1-, 2-, 3- and 5-year overall survival was 80, 71, 55 and 30%, respectively, with a median survival of 39 months. No prognostic factor for survival could be identified among histology, tumor stage and size, gender and age. We think this hypofractionated stereotactic radiotherapy shows encouraging survival and a relatively low toxicity in this elderly population with substantial comorbidity. A multicenter randomized trial comparing this treatment with conventional fractionated radiotherapy is under way.     

High-dose fractionated radiotherapy to 80 Gy for stage I-II medically inoperable non-small-cell lung cancer

Introduction: Management of medically inoperable non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC) has been historically challenging, with poor rates of local control and disease-specific survival. Nearly all published series of standard fractionation radiotherapy have utilised doses <70 Gy. The present investigation describes disease control and survival outcomes for a large series of patients prescribed high-dose radiotherapy for early-stage NSCLC. Methods: Retrospective analysis of disease control and survival outcomes for stages I–II NSCLC patients prescribed ≥70 Gy at 1.8–2.5 Gy per fraction. Results: Between May 1997 and August 2008, 100 primary lung tumours in 98 patients (two metachronous) were eligible for analysis. The median age was 71 years (range 49–93), and 92 patients were considered medically inoperable. Nearly all cases were clinical stage cT1N0 (51 patients) or cT2N0 (35). The median radiotherapy dose prescribed was 80.5 Gy (range 70–90). At a median follow-up of 18 months, 72 patients died (44 of/with disease) and 50 experienced recurrence. The estimated 3-year in-field control, progression-free survival, disease-specific, and overall survival rates were 50, 29, 30 and 24%, respectively. Univariate analyses demonstrated an inverse association between local control and tumour size. Medical inoperability was associated with decreased disease-specific and overall survivals. Patient age and biologically equivalent dose were also associated with overall survival. Conclusions: Disease control and survival of fractionated radiotherapy for early-stage NSCLC remain suboptimal. Medical inoperability is associated with worse overall survival; however, local control remains a predominant pattern of failure despite 80 Gy in standard fractionation, particularly in patients with larger tumour size.     

Radiotherapy alone in the curative treatment of rectal carcinoma

Surgery is the standard treatment for rectal adenocarcinoma. The tumour is resistant to radiation; doses above 80 Gy are necessary and have to be delivered by endocavitary irradiation. Contact radiotherapy is a basic method of delivering a high dose in a small volume. Brachytherapy can be used to deliver a boost of radiation into a residual lesion. External-beam radiotherapy can be used to supplement the dose to the deep part of the primary tumour and to the perirectal lymph nodes. T1N0 tumours have been treated by contact radiotherapy, and local control was achieved in 85-90% of patients with no severe toxic effects. Combined endocavitary irradiation and external-beam irradiation can achieve local control in 80% of patients with T2 tumours and 60% of patients with T3 tumours with only moderate toxic effects and a 60% 5-year overall survival. Radiotherapy alone is suitable for patients with T1N0 lesions (contact radiotherapy) or patients with T2-3 (combined endocavitary and external-beam radiotherapy) who cannot undergo surgery. For T2 or early T3 tumours of the lower rectum requiring surgery and a permanent colostomy, combined irradiation can be used as a first-line treatment in an attempt to avoid abdominoperineal amputation.