Carotid stents: which is the best option?

Nowadays, carotid artery stenting (CAS) offers a potential alternative to carotid endarterectomy (CEA). CAS main advantages over CEA are the less invasive approach and the almost equal performance to CEA in terms of stroke prevention and complications. One of the most important factors which played significant role to CAS evolution is the progress in design of modern materials, especially stents. Today, several types of dedicated carotid stents have specific mechanical properties, which provide stents with individual characteristics making each of them suitable for specific carotid lesions and anatomies. The present review analyses the specific design and construction of modern stents, trying to point out their particular mechanical properties and characteristics. Additionally, it presents all available data published on comparison between different stent designs with the intention to identify which carotid stent is the best option for particular patient and lesion characteristics.     

Training of general surgical residents: what model is appropriate?

The training of general surgical residents has been a relatively stable process for the past several decades. However, a variety of forces have caused several recent changes in the education of general surgeons and more potentially radical alterations have been recommended by some surgical leaders. Much of the initiative for changing training is due to the inexorable forces of specialization and the increasingly vigorous competition for qualified trainees in various surgical disciplines. Decisions made within the next few years will likely decide the future of general surgery as a specialty.     

When is surgical treatment not appropriate for morphea?

Morphea is an inflammatory cutaneous disease that can be mistaken for a soft-tissue neoplasm. The authors report two cases of morphea that were resected surgically before the histological diagnosis of morphea was rendered. One of the patients had a recurrence of morphea around her large surgical scar. They present these cases to alert surgeons to the pitfall of inappropriate surgical treatment of an inflammatory condition.     

Reconstruction of proctocolectomy: which is the best surgical procedure?

Total proctocolectomy is commonly performed in patients with ulcerative colitis or familial adenomatosis coli. The standard surgical procedure for reconstruction is the ileal pouch anal anastomosis with rectal mucosal stripping (IPAA), which is radical treatment for the disease, or stapled ileal pouch anal anastomosis with preserved anal canal (stapled IPAA), which results in a lower incidence of soiling with a high possibility of one-stage surgery. Postoperative cancer surveillance colonoscopy is recommended in patients with stapled IPAA, and patients with IPAA have also at risk for cancer in the anastomotic site, although at very low incidence. Quality of life (QOL) studies (SF36, etc.) found good QOL after surgery in patients who underwent both procedures. Patients with permanent ileostomy for preoperative anal dysfunction also had good QOL. The surgical procedure for reconstruction should be determined based on surgical indications, preoperative anal function, and patient's request. For improved QOL in the future, pouch surgery should have a lower incidence of diverting ileostomy and result in fewer bowel movements and a lower incidence of soiling, with optimal management of pouchitis.     

Plastic bronchitis: is thoracic duct ligation a real surgical option?

Plastic bronchitis is an unusual clinical scenario of unknown cause and occurs in multiple clinical settings. The disease is characterized by the development of arborizing, thick, tenacious casts of the tracheobronchial tree that results in airway obstruction. Patients with congenital heart disease who have undergone a Fontan operation are at high risk for having this problem develop. Management of this distressing situation is difficult with only palliative options being available, such as repeated bronchoscopies, inhaled heparin, tissue plasminogen activator, inhaled bronchodilators, or azithromycin. The patients with Fontan circuits have a myriad of unique complications develop, such as atrial arrhythmias, recurrent pleural effusions, chylothoraces, protein-losing enteropathy, and plastic bronchitis. High intrathoracic lymphatic pressures with nondemonstrable lympho-bronchial fistulas were believed to be the cause for the development of these recurrent bronchial casts in plastic bronchitis. Faced with recurrent plastic bronchitis resistant to medical management in 2 Fontan patients with normal Fontan pressures on cardiac catheterization, we decided to explore a surgical solution by performing a thoracic duct ligation. This resulted in complete resolution of the formation of casts in both patients, who were discharged home and remain asymptomatic on continued follow-up. Thoracic duct ligation provides a surgical cure for plastic bronchitis by decreasing intrathoracic lymphatic pressure and flow.     

Necrotizing entercolitis and intestinal perforation in very low weight premature infants: which is the best surgical option?

Necrotizing enterocolitis (NEC) and isolated intestinal perforation (IP) are common diseases in very low birth weight infants (VLBW) and require surgery in 20-40% of cases. We have performed a retrospective review of VLBW infants with NEC or IP who underwent a surgical procedure between 2000 and 2010, either initial laparotomy (group 1), peritoneal drain placement and subsequent laparotomy (group 2) or peritoneal drainage (group 3). Of 487 VLBW infants admitted to our hospital in the last ten years, 80 patients had NEC or IP, out of these, 31% (n=25) were treated surgically. The study population consisted of 14 girls and 11 boys with a mean gestational age of 26+3 weeks and mean birth weight of 801.4 g (range 460 to 1490 g). Pneumoperitoneum was seen in 48% of cases (n=12). Twelve patients underwent initial laparotomy, 10 patients were treated with peritoneal drainage and subsequent laparotomy and in 3 patients a peritoneal drainage was placed. Mean time between drainage and laparotomy was 69.6 hours. Sixty-eight percent of patients had NEC and thirty-two percent were IP. Survival rate was higher in the group who underwent initial laparotomy (p = 0.001) with an overall mortality of 32% (8 deaths). Optimal surgical procedure must be decided upon clinical condition of individual patients. We consider that initial laparotomy should be the treatment option in VLBW infants with intestinal perforation due to NEC or IP.     

Adrenocortical carcinoma: which surgical approach?

Introduction  

There are no randomised studies comparing open and laparoscopic approaches foradrenalectomy in patients with adrenal cortical carcinoma.     

Rectal prolapse. Abdominal or perineal approach? Current situation

Rectal prolapse is a major challenge for the surgeon who has to resolve the anatomical problem and the functional disturbances in the same procedure. Abdominal procedures are the most appropriate in young patients, and the most common technique is rectopexia with or without resection. The use of mesh or sutures provides the same results and the choice depends on the surgeon's preference. Laparoscopic surgery has been demonstrated to have similar efficacy to conventional surgery and may become the option of the future. The perineal approach is the best option in elderly patients and in those with associated morbidity; the Delorme technique is simple to carry out, but rectosigmoidectomy provides better results.     

Colorectal cancer in the elderly: which surgical approach?

Single-operator case studies of 135 patients undergoing surgery for colon rectal carcinoma (CRC) between June 2004 and April 2008 in our Institute. Patients were divided into two groups (A: < 70 years old, n = 44, - = 27 U = 17, B: ≥ 70 years old, n = 91, - = 49 U = 42) and were compared clinical, pathological and surgical data. In particular, were analyzed age range and average age, ASA score, post-operative complications (major and minor), mortality at 30 days. Surgical procedure with radical intent (R0) was achieved in 41 (93%) and 76 (83%) patients respectively in group A and B; Given the more than double the number in group B than in group A is easy to imagine that for equal numbers in both groups might have observed an almost equal R0 resections in both groups; Despite the uneven number of groups A and B, it was noted that age is not a factor in determining the surgical therapeutic strategy in the CRC, as well as the clinical conditions of patients.     

E‐learning vs lecture: which is the best approach to surgical teaching?

Aim Most medical teaching is still delivered by traditional face‐to‐face interaction. E‐learning has the potential benefit of instilling deeper learning of topics by virtue of repeated and convenient access to content presented in a range of media. We aimed to evaluate objectively the benefit of educating medical students on a common surgical topic (haemorrhoids), through a website and podcast package vs a traditional lecture. Method Baseline knowledge was established by a questionnaire given to two different groups of third‐year medical students starting their first clinical attachment. Group A (n = 73) was given a lecture and group B (n = 75) was asked to use a website containing text and pictures augmented by a podcast. Students were reassessed using the same preintervention questionnaire, and satisfaction was acquired from details given in a feedback form. Results There was no difference in knowledge between the two groups at baseline. Both groups demonstrated significant gains in knowledge after intervention (P < 0.0001). Group B (Web/podcast) showed a significantly greater increase in knowledge (P < 0.05) than group A (lecture). Preintervention subjective assessment of knowledge rated by the students showed no difference between the groups. Both groups of students were equally satisfied with the educational method. Conclusion E‐learning supplemented with a podcast results in greater knowledge acquisition when compared with a traditional lecture, without a loss of satisfaction with teaching. Using augmented Web‐based educational tools reduces demands on teaching time with no decrease in quality for selected parts of the curriculum.     

Ross operation for bicuspid aortic valve disease in adults: is it a valid surgical option?

OBJECTIVE: The validity of the Ross operation as freestanding root replacement in adult patients with bicuspid aortic valve disease has lately been questioned. We have analyzed retrospectively our results in 23 adult patients (19 males) operated for bicuspid aortic valve disease ad modum "Ross" employing a freestanding root replacement technique. DESIGN: In 9 patients the dominant aortic valve lesion was stenotic (aortic stenosis group) and in the remaining 14 patients it was aortic insufficiency (aortic insufficiency group). The fate of the pulmonary autograft in the two groups was studied. The intraoperatively measured aortic and pulmonary annuli diameters from the two groups were compared with those from a population of normal looking aortic and pulmonary valves matched for body surface area. RESULTS: The aortic insufficiency group needed significant reduction of the aortic annulus diameter to conform to the size of the pulmonary autograft. The pulmonary autograft annuli in this group were significantly larger in diameter than the ones in the aortic stenosis group. The mean pulmonary annulus diameter in the aortic stenosis group was, on the other hand, significantly smaller when compared with that in the normal matched population. After a mean follow-up period of about 19 months, the aortic insufficiency group showed significant dilatation of the neo-aortic sinuses. Between the two groups, the remaining echocardiographic variables remained either stable or improved at follow-up. CONCLUSION: Pre-existing larger diameters of the aortic and pulmonary annuli in the aortic insufficiency group combined with the significantly increased left ventricular end-diastolic diameters, may predispose these patients to significant dilatation of the unsupported aortic sinuses after a Ross operation. This dilatation does not, however, lead to increase in the autograft valve insufficiency at short-term follow-up if the aortic annulus and the distal ascending aorta are tailored to the size of the pulmonary autograft. Ross operation, employing freestanding aortic root replacement technique, may therefore be recommended in adult patients with bicuspid aortic valve disease with excellent short-term results.     

Non-absorbable prosthetic meshes: which is the best option in the repair of abdominal wall defects?

The mechanical properties and macroscopic behaviour of non-absorbable materials have been widely studied. Nevertheless, biological tissue response to contact with these prostheses is not well-known. Our purpose was to compare the microscopic behaviour of two non-absorbable materials. Polypropylene and mersilene meshes were implanted on 36 female Wistar rats each (PPL and ME groups) . Six animals per group were sequentially sacrificed at 1, 2, 3, 5, 10 and 15 weeks. Global cell density and number of polymorphonuclear leukocytes, giant cells, fibroblasts and histiocytes were compared for every studied phase. The polypropylene group showed higher cell density and polymorphonuclear response in the initial phases, while scores for giant cells were higher in the mersilene group. Fibrohistiocytic reaction was increased in the polypropylene group. Polypropylene tends to provoke higher acute inflammatory reaction and connective tissue formation than mersilene. The latter induces higher foreign body reaction.     

Ottawa versus Bernese: which is better?

Purpose

Trauma of the foot and ankle is commonly seen in the emergency service. For most patients, fractures cannot be ruled out without radiography. The aim of this study is to consider these injured patients in the light of the Ottawa ankle rules and the Bernese ankle rules.

Methods

Our study is a randomized, prospective clinical study. This study was performed during a 24-month period in the Süleyman Demirel University Emergency Medicine Service. A total of 962 adult patients with foot and ankle pain or tenderness following trauma incurring within the previous 10 days were included in the study. Patients were examined only by physicians who had been trained in the correct application of the Ottawa ankle rules and the Bernese ankle rules. All patients were X-rayed with standardized anterior-posterior and lateral radiographs of the ankle and foot, regardless of whether the Ottawa ankle rules and the Bernese ankle rules were positive or negative. The sensitivity and specificity of the Ottawa and Bernese ankle rules according to the study results regarding the correlation between physical examination and radiography were calculated.

Results

For the Ottawa ankle rules, the sensitivity was 74.8 %, specificity was 68.6 %, false-negative ratio was 15.1 %, and the false-positive ratio was 46.3 %. For the Bernese ankle rules, the sensitivity was 55.7 %, specificity was 79 %, false-negative was ratio 21.4 %, and the false-positive ratio was 43.7 %.

Conclusion

These data suggest that the Ottawa ankle rules are more sensitive than the Bernese ankle rules to accurately identify the fracture, but they are still not 100 % reliable.     

Lobular neoplasia: is surgical excision warranted?

The treatment of breast cancer associated with lobular neoplasia detected on core needle biopsy (CNB) remains controversial. The purpose of this study was to review the prevalence of lobular neoplasia in CNB specimens and to correlate CNB pathology to final surgical pathology. Patients with lobular neoplasia were included for analysis in this retrospective review. Patients with concomitant malignant or atypical lesions were excluded. Method of initial diagnosis, clinical history, pathology results, and follow-up data were then analyzed. From January 1994 to December 2005, 5257 CNBs were performed at our tertiary level medical facility. Of patients with lobular neoplasia, 42 of 50 (84%) patients had atypical lobular hyperplasia, whereas 8 (16%) patients were diagnosed with lobular carcinoma in situ on CNB specimens. There were no associated malignancies in 21 patients who underwent immediate surgical excision. Of those patients who were serially followed, four developed malignancies at an average of 73 months after the sentinel diagnosis. Three of the four (75%) malignancies occurred in the ipsilateral breast. Patients with a diagnosis of lobular neoplasia by CNB should not routinely undergo an open surgical biopsy. Lobular neoplasia should only be considered a risk marker for future invasive breast cancer.