Cadaveric renal transplantation from a non-heart-beating pediatric donor into adult recipients

INTRODUCTION: The use of cadaveric pediatric kidneys has been suggested as a means to overcome organ shortage, but is debated because of technical complications and an increased incidence of functional allograft impairment. METHODS: We experienced 2 cases of cadaveric renal transplantation from a non-heart-beating pediatric donor. RESULTS: In our cases, transplanted kidneys achieved good graft function and proteinuria due to glomerulosclerosis was not recognized. CONCLUSION: Previous reports indicate that in transplantation from pediatric donors into adults recipients, glomerular sclerosis occurs as the reason for impairment of grafts. Further, cadaveric renal transplantation from a non-heart-beating donor has a warm ischemia time and an increased risk of hyperfiltrated injury and graft failure. If transplantation of pediatric kidneys into adults from a non-heart-beating donor is performed, BMI and BSA must be carefully considered in the selection of recipients in order to avoid imbalance between nephron supply and metabolic demands and to insure successful, healthy grafts.     

Results of transplantation of kidneys from related living donors

Between 1973 and 1981 23 transplantations of kidneys from living related donors have been performed in Frankfurt/Main. Donor complications were haematopneumothorax (1 case) and reversible urinary tract infections (3 cases). All donors were discharged after 8-12 days, all have until now (6 months to 8 years postoperatively) normal excretory renal function and normal arterial blood pressure. Patient-survival in the recipients is 5 years postoperatively 96% and graft-survival is 90%. Nine patients received HLA-identical kidneys, all have excellent to fair function of the grafts, 7 patients are off steroids. In 14 cases kidneys were transplanted, although donor and recipient shared only one haplotype. In these patients 5-year graft survival is 84%. Seven patients have normal graft function, whereas 6 patients have a reduced function or have rejected. One patient died. Results of kidney transplantation using living related donors are--even when donors with only one haplotype-identity are accepted--much better than those obtainable when using cadaveric donors. When renal transplantation is considered, patients should be informed about the favourable results attainable with kidneys from living related donors.     

The use of "marginal" donors for organ transplantation. The influence of donor age on outcome

The influence of donor age on outcome was studied in the recipients of 12,131 cadaveric renal allografts, 3026 heart allografts, and 2913 liver allografts with followup information in the UNOS data base for transplants performed between 10/1/87 and 12/31/89. For recipients of kidney transplants, donors of ages 6-15 had significantly better 1-year graft survival than donors of ages 56-65, but the difference was only 7.0%. Donors of age greater than 65 actually did better than donors ages 56-65, but donors less than or equal to 5 were less satisfactory. Kidneys from older donors survived as well as kidneys from younger donors in patients with repeat transplants, diabetes, black race, age over 45, O HLA or 5 and 6 HLA matches, delayed graft function, shared kidneys and PRA greater than 50. For kidney recipients, multifactorial analysis by Cox regression showed that donor age was less important than the use of ALG, donor race, diabetes or peak PRA in ages 16-45, delayed function, repeat transplant, and HLA match. Recipients of heart transplants from donors ages 45-55 had 1-year graft survival that was 8.4% less than recipients of hearts from donors age 16-45. However, 32.7% of heart patients died during the first 12 months after listing without benefit of a transplant. Liver transplant recipients of donor ages 16-45 had 10.8% better 1-year graft survival than recipients of donors greater than 45, but a greater percentage of older donors were transplanted to high risk and older recipients. Tragically, 24.3% of patients listed for liver transplantation died within 12 months without a transplant. This analysis shows that satisfactory graft survival can be achieved using older donors and that age in itself should not be a barrier to organ donation, providing that organ function is normal and that specific disease of the organ is absent.     

Fate of a renal tubulopapillary adenoma transmitted by an organ donor

Organ transplantation from cadaveric donors has a risk of cancer transmission. However, some reports indicate that kidneys bearing small carcinomas can be safely transplanted, as can other organs harvested from the same donor. We report herein the case of two allograft recipients (left kidney and heart with no evidence of tumor) who developed a renal carcinoma soon after transplantation. The initial tumor of the donor was a 17-mm tubulopapillary adenoma found on the right kidney, which was not transplanted. The left kidney recipient rejected all residual tumoral cells after graft removal and immunosuppression discontinuation. The heart recipient died 7 months after transplantation from metastasis of a renal carcinoma. This strongly suggests that circulating carcinoma cells were present at the time of organ retrieval and that they were not cleared by in situ perfusion. In contrast with the literature data, this report indicates that patients with small renal tubulopapillary tumors should not be considered for organ donation.     

Evaluation of pediatric cadaver kidneys transplanted into adult recipients receiving cyclosporine

The major problem in clinical transplantation is the imbalance between the need for cadaveric organs and the available numbers of donors. If pediatric kidneys were transplanted into adult recipients when no pediatric recipient was available, the potential number of renal donors would be increased by 15 to 20%. Some centers are reluctant to use pediatric kidneys for adult recipients because of recent reports indicating poorer patient and allograft survival, increased delayed graft function, increased post-transplant hypertension and increased technical complication. (There also has been concern that the nephrotoxic effect of cyclosporine A would retard the organ growth that is necessary to provide normal renal function in adults.) A retrospective analysis was performed on 18 adult recipients who received kidneys from cadaver donors 14 months to 12 years old (group 1). These patients were compared to 106 adult recipients who received kidneys from donors greater than 12 years old (group 2). Actuarial patient survival at 1 year was 85% for group 1 and 95.8% for group 2 (p equals 0.13), while 1-year actuarial allograft survival was 83.1% for group 1 and 81.1% for group 2 (p equals 0.87). There was no significant difference between groups 1 and 2 in the frequency of delayed graft function, serum creatinine at 1, 3 and 6 months after transplantation, incidence of post-transplant hypertension or frequency of surgical complications. It is of interest that the pediatric kidneys had significant growth during the initial post-transplant month. Sonographic examination at postoperative days 1 and 30 demonstrated a mean increase in size from 80.7 to 143.5 cm. (p less than 0.001). In this series pediatric kidneys were safe and effective donor organs in adult recipients, and increased the available number of organs by 15%.     

Non-heart-beating kidney transplantation: 6-year outcomes

Non-heart-beating donor kidneys (NHBD) are being used to increase the donor pool due to the scarcity of cadaveric heart beating donors (HBD). We evaluated the long-term outcomes of renal transplantation using NHBD kidneys, comparing the first 100 NHBD kidneys transplanted at our facility to the next consecutive cadaveric HBD kidneys for graft survival, recipient survival, and quality of graft function. Recipient survival (P = .22) and graft survival (P = .19) at 6 years did not differ between recipients of NHBD (83%, 80%) and HBD (89%, 87%) kidneys. Quality of graft function using the mean glomular filtration rates were significantly lower in the NHBD group up to 3 months following discharge (41 +/- 2 vs 47 +/- 2, P = .007) but were then comparable up to 6 years following transplantation (43 +/- 5 vs 46 +/- 4, P = .55).     

Renal transplantation in polycystic kidney disease.

Thirty-one renal transplantations were performed in 25 patients with end-stage polycystic disease of the kidneys. Of the 14 recipients transplanted with both polycystic kidneys in situ and followed for at least 6 months, 10 had a previous history of urinary tract infection. Four of these 14 recipients had relapsing urinary tract infection after transplantation, the other 10 have been at risk on immunosuppressive therapy for a total of 152 months and have had no trouble that could be attributed to the presence of the polycystic kidneys. Despite the potentiality of polycystic kidneys to be a source of post-transplant infection when left in situ, a good outcome of renal transplatation could be achieved without preparative bilateral nephrectomy. The one-year patient and graft survivals are comparable to those obtained in our total transplantation series and renal transplantation is considered to be an acceptable therapy in polycystic disease.     

马蹄铁肾移植的外科策略探讨(附二例报告)

目的 为避免供肾浪费，探讨马蹄铁肾移植的可行性和安全性。方法 对尸体马蹄铁肾采取原位灌注、整块切取法获取供肾。将马蹄铁肾离断峡部后，分成2个供肾，分别植入2例受者。结果 肾移植术中开放血管后，移植肾血供正常。1例随访至今(12个月)，肾功能正常，未发现与马蹄铁肾有关的并发症；另1例在移植后1．5个月死于感染。结论 在一定的外科策略指导下，马蹄铁肾移植是可行和安全的。     

Renal transplantation in high risk patients older than sixty years

Nine patients between the ages of sixty and seventy-one years, with end-stage renal failure, received kidney grafts during a five year period. Five received related donor kidneys and four received cadaver donor kidneys. Six of these patients are still alive—four of the five (80 per cent) with related kidneys and two of the four (50 per cent) with cadaver kidneys. All six patients have normal kidney function an average of twenty-seven months after transplantation.We believe the elderly uremic patient should not be categorically excluded as kidney graft recipients on the basis of age alone. The prognosis of these patients treated by transplantation far exceeds that for uremic patients of the same age who are restricted to hemodialysis therapy.     

Extended criteria for organ acceptance. Strategies for achieving organ safety and for increasing organ pool

The terms extended donor or expanded donor mean changes in donor acceptability criteria. In almost all cases, the negative connotations of these terms cannot be justified. Factors considered to affect donor or organ acceptability have changed with time, after showing that they did not negatively affect graft or patient survival per se or when the adequate measures had been adopted. There is no age limit to be an organ donor. Kidney and liver transplantation from donors older than 65 years can have excellent graft and patient actuarial survival and graft function. Using these donors can be from an epidemiological point of view the most important factor to esablish the final number of cadaveric liver and kidney transplantations. Organs with broad structural parenchyma lesion with preserved functional reserve and organs with reversible functional impairment can be safely transplanted. Bacterial and fungal donor infection with the adequate antibiotic treatment of donor and/or recipient prevents infection in the latter. The organs, including the liver, from donors with infection by the hepatitis B and C viruses can be safely transplanted to recipients with infection by the same viruses, respectively. Poisoned donors and non-heart-beating donors, grafts from transplant recipients, reuse of grafts, domino transplant and splitting of one liver for two recipients can be an important and safe source of organs for transplantation.     

Inferior Early Posttransplant Outcomes for Recipients of Right Versus Left Deceased Donor Kidneys: An ANZDATA Registry Analysis

Anatomical differences between right and left kidneys could influence transplant outcome. We compared graft function and survival for left and right kidney recipients transplanted from the same deceased organ donor. Adult recipients of 4900 single kidneys procured from 2450 heart beating deceased donors in Australia and New Zealand from 1995 to 2009 were included in a paired analysis. Right kidneys were associated with more delayed graft function (DGF) (25 vs. 21% for left kidneys, p < 0.001) and, if not affected by DGF, a slower fall in serum creatinine. One‐year graft survival was lower for right kidneys (89.1 vs. 91.1% for left kidneys, p = 0.001), primarily attributed to surgical complications (66 versus 35 failures for left kidneys). Beyond the first posttransplant year, kidney side was not associated with eGFR, graft or patient survival. Receipt of a right kidney is a risk factor for inferior outcomes in the first year after transplantation. A higher incidence of surgical complications suggests the shorter right renal vein may be contributory. The higher susceptibility of right kidneys to injury should be considered in organ allocation.     

Successful transplantation of organs retrieved from a donor with enterococcal endocarditis

We report on a patient with an extensive cerebral infarction secondary to enterococcal endocarditis that, in spite of adequate antibiotic treatment, evolved to brain death. The patient was evaluated as a potential organ donor; renal and liver function were normal and both liver and kidneys appeared normal on ultrasonographic examination. When negativity of serial blood and urine cultures was ascertained, liver and kidneys were retrieved for transplantation. The organs were transplanted into three recipients with good results after 14 months of follow-up. All of the recipients received antibiotic prophylaxis against Enterococcus faecalis. None of them has presented infectious complications to date. This case emphasizes that patients with enterococcal endocarditis may be potential organ donors provided both donor and recipients are adequately treated. This is especially important when organs are urgently needed. Received: 3 February 1998 Received after revision: 24 March 1998 Accepted: 15 April 1998     

Spousal renal donor transplantation in Chinese subjects: a 10 year experience from a single centre.

BACKGROUND: The shortage of cadaveric kidneys for renal transplantation is a particularly problematic situation in the locality of Hong Kong. Kidneys from spousal donors are therefore increasingly being used for transplantation. This study was undertaken to evaluate the outcome of spousal donor transplant recipients in comparison with that of genetically related living donor (LRD) allograft recipients. METHODS: From 1988, we have transplanted 22 spousal kidney recipients (group 1). All donors must demonstrate a genuine spousal relationship. Their outcome was compared with that of 24 LRD allograft recipients (group 2) transplanted in the same period with similar demographics, pre-transplant dialysis duration, immunosuppressive protocol and length of post-transplant follow-up. RESULTS: The mean (+/-SD) age was 36.5 +/- 8 and 32.5 +/- 6 years for groups 1 and 2, who were followed for 56.6 +/- 35 and 59.1 +/- 38 months, respectively. There was no difference in the incidence of delayed graft function, acute rejection and serum creatinine level at 5 years. Graft survival rates were 86.4 and 79.2% (P = 0.56), while patient survival rates were 100 and 91.7% (P = 0.171) at 5 years for groups 1 and 2, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Spousal kidney transplantation shares comparable results with LRD transplantation and should be encouraged in places where cadaveric organs remain scarce. Stringent measures must be implemented to prevent the possible emergence of kidney bartering and to protect the interests of living donors. The ethical and social issues regarding the spousal donor in Hong Kong and other countries are discussed.     

Assessment of Kidneys Procured From Expanded Criteria Donors Before Transplantation

Background

Using expanded criteria donor (ECD) organs is 1 strategy to make more organs available for transplant. To reduce the number of posttransplant complications and failures, there is a need to create a comprehensive system of evaluation before transplantation, especially for kidneys harvested from ECD. The aim of this study was to assess the results of kidneys procured from ECD seeking to discover the most useful factors for kidney evaluation before transplantation.

Patients and Methods

One hundred seventy-two patients received cadaveric renal transplants between January 1, 2006, and August 31, 2008. We collected data on donors, recipients, and perfusion parameters. We analyzed patient and graft survivals, as well as immediate, delayed, and slow graft function. Kidney recipient function was assessed by serum creatinine concentrations and by creatinine clearance calculated according to the Cockroft-Gault formula. Renal biopsy specimens were obtained in the perioperative periods 147 cases.

Results

The overall 1-year graft survival was 86.9%. More than 25% of transplanted kidneys were harvested from ECD. There were no significant differences in patient survival between recipients of standard criteria donor kidneys (RSCDK) versus of expanded criteria donor kidneys (RECDK). One-year graft survival was higher among the RSCDK group than the RECDK group, namely, 94.4% versus 62.5%, (P = .004). There were no differences in the incidence of primary nonfunction or in delayed graft function between the groups. RECDK were more likely to show slow graft function (69.2% vs 37.8%; P = .033). A lower graft survival at 6 months after transplantation was observed among organs harvested from ECD compared with standard criteria donor (SCD) kidneys who showed histologic lesions or a flow at the fourth hour of machine perfusion below 0.4 mL/g. Using a logistic regression model, chronic histologic changes were shown to influence kidney survival at 6 months after transplantation.

Conclusion

There was no significant difference in patient survival between recipients of kidneys harvested from expanded versus standard criteria donors. ECD kidneys displayed lower graft survival rates. There was no significant difference in the incidence of delayed graft function between recipients of kidneys harvested from expanded versus standard criteria donors. Pretransplant evaluation of ECD kidneys should include 3 variables: donor parameters, histologic findings, and machine perfusion parameters.     

低龄心脏停跳供者单个肾脏成人移植11例

目的 总结符合脑死亡诊断标准的低龄患儿心脏停跳后供肾应用于成人移植的处理经验.方法 心跳停止后单个供肾患儿6例,月龄49～106(75.35±22.8)个月,体质量16.6～37.8(23.9±8.4)kg.受者11例,平均年龄(28.2±7.9)岁,体质量(46.9±4.2)kg.单个供肾植入受者右侧髂窝.手术方法同成人尸肾移植.术中开始单/多克隆抗体加甲泼尼龙诱导治疗,术后常规环孢素或他克莫司、霉酚酸酯、泼尼松三联免疫抑制剂治疗.结果 受者肾功能均恢复正常,其中出现移植肾功能延迟恢复3例.术后移植肾增大明显,灌注后和移植后1周移植肾长径分别为(70.6±5.5)和(86.1±6.9)mm(P＜0.001),之后移植肾持续缓慢增大,至术后12个月移植肾长径为(104.5±8.8)mm.平均随访时间(21.8±9.5)个月,1年人/肾存活率均为100%.结论 低龄心跳停止供者单个供肾植入低体重的成人受者,可以成功维持受者正常肾功能,1年人/肾存活率与成人尸肾移植无显著差异.     

Transplantation of pediatric cadaveric kidneys into adult or pediatric recipients

In Japan, nationwide cadaveric organ sharing for kidney transplantation by the Japan Organ Transplant Network (JOTN) has operated since April 1995. This study retrospectively analyzed the long-term results of single pediatric donor kidneys transplanted into adult or pediatric recipients at a single center. From March 1983 to December 2002, 281 cadaveric renal allografts were transplanted at our center, including, 17 recipients of cadaveric kidneys from donors aged less than 16 years. We divided these 17 recipients into two groups: 10 adult recipients (group 1; G1) and seven pediatric recipients (group 2; G2). HLA-AB, -DR mismatches were 1.3 +/- 1.3, 0.7 +/- 0.5 in G1 and 2.6 +/- 1.3, 1.4 +/- 0.8 in G2, respectively (P < .05 for both). The end of the observation of this study was March 2003. Among G1, two recipients died with functioning grafts and one died after graft loss. Among G2, no recipients died. Patient survival rates at 1 and 5 years were 90% and 80% in G1 and 100% and 100% in G2, respectively. At the end of the observation in this study, five recipients among G1 and six recipients among G2 had functioning grafts. Graft survival rates at 1 and 5 years were 90% and 80% in G1 and 85.7% and 85.7% in G2, respectively. Our results demonstrate that transplantation of pediatric cadaveric kidneys into pediatric recipients was excellent compared to adult recipients in terms of survival. Priority to pediatric patients should be given especially in cases of pediatric donors.     

Donor characteristics associated with reduced graft survival: an approach to expanding the pool of kidney donors

BACKGROUND: Availability of cadaveric kidneys for transplantation is far below the growing need, leading to longer waiting time and more deaths while waiting. METHODS: Using national data from 1995 to 2000, we evaluated graft survival by donor characteristics and the rate of discard of retrieved organs, with the goal of increasing use of kidneys that are associated with increased risk of graft failure, that is, expanded donor kidneys. RESULTS: Cox models identified four donor factors that independently predicted significantly higher relative risk of graft loss compared with a low-risk group. These factors included donor age, cerebrovascular accident as the cause of death, renal insufficiency (serum creatinine >1.5 mg/dL), and history of hypertension. Expanded donor kidneys were defined as those with relative risk of graft loss greater than 1.70 and included all donors aged 60 years and older and those aged 50 to 59 years with at least two of the other three conditions (cerebrovascular cause of death, renal insufficiency, hypertension). The expanded donor group accounted for 14.8% of transplanted kidneys. Among organs procured from expanded donors, 38% were discarded versus 9% for all other kidneys. The risk of graft loss of expanded donor kidneys was increased in both older and younger recipients but to a greater extent in those recipients older than 50 years. CONCLUSION: By identifying donor factors associated with graft failure, these analyses may help to expand the number of transplanted kidneys by increasing the utilization of retrieved cadaveric kidneys.     

Factors contributing to long graft survival in non-heart-beating cadaveric renal transplantation in Japan: a single-center study at Kitasato University

A total of 107 cadaveric kidneys from non-heart-beating donors (NHBDs) have been transplanted between 1974 and 2000 at Kitasato University Hospital, Sagamihara, Japan. The patient survival of the 107 recipients of cadaveric renal transplants at 1, 5 and 10 yr was 0.857, 0.770 and 0.746, respectively. The 50% graft survival was 3.8 yr. The 5 and 10-yr graft survival was 0.457 and 0.337, respectively. Twenty of the 107 recipients of non-heart-beating cadaveric renal transplantation had graft survival longer than 10 yr. Of these 20 patients, 14 survivors still maintain functioning renal grafts and two died with functioning graft, although the remaining four reverted to dialysis because of chronic rejection and nephropathy. The average graft survival of these 20 patients at the time of study was 13.3 yr and the longest was 21.4 yr. The average serum creatinine level at 10 yr after transplantation was 1.63 mg/dL, almost identical to that at 5 yr post-transplant. The donors aged on average 40.2 yr; 13 were male and seven were female. The youngest donor was 9-yr-old and the oldest was 66. The graft survival was significantly better in the group with donor age younger than 55 yr (Log-rank: p=0.007). The average weight of the renal graft was not different between the long and shorter graft survival groups. The average warm ischemic time and total ischemic time were 9.7 and 539.7 min, respectively. The duration of post-transplant acute tubular necrosis averaged 9.2 days. These parameters tended to be shorter than those in recipients with graft survival >10 yr, but with no statistical significance. The mean numbers of acute rejection (AR) episode within 3 months after transplantation were 0.25 +/- 0.66 and 0.92 +/- 0.90 (p=0.020) in long survival and shorter survival groups, respectively. Long survivors had a significantly lower incidence of AR. Two of 20 cases received conventional immunosuppression with prednisolone, azathioprine and mizoribin, and 18 had prednisolone and calcineurin inhibitor (CNI). Kaplan-Meier analysis showed a significant contribution of CNI to graft survival (p=0.036). However, the graft survival reduction rate after 1 yr post-transplant did not differ between conventional and CNI immunosuppression. These data suggest that renal grafts retrieved with proper organ procurement procedures from NHBDs may survive long-term and help to overcome donor shortage.     

Superior long-term graft function and better growth of grafts in children receiving kidneys from paediatric compared with adult donors.

BACKGROUND: Organs from paediatric donors are often not accepted for paediatric recipients because previous reports suggested inferior graft function for small kidneys transplanted in children. On the other hand, studies have shown that kidneys of adult donors transplanted into children down-regulate filtration after transplantation and may not increase their function to the need of the growing child. METHODS: We assessed 64 male and 35 female (total n = 99) white children aged <10 years (male: mean 5.1 years, SD 2.8; female: mean 5.8 years, SD 3.4) who had received cadaveric kidney transplants at our centre between 1990 and 2005. Mean observation time was 5.9 years, SD 4.0. The children were divided into two groups depending on the kidney donor age: 63 children (mean age 5.0 years, SD 2.9) received an organ of an adult, and 39 (mean age 6.4 years, SD 3.4) of a paediatric donor. Immunosuppression was performed with prednisolone, cyclosporin A microemulsion+/-mycophenolate mofetil. RESULTS: Three to five years after transplantation the calculated glomerular filtration rate corrected to body surface was significantly higher in recipients of paediatric organs. The size of paediatric grafts doubled in the first years after transplantation while adult grafts had a stable size. Graft survival was comparable in both groups during observation time. CONCLUSIONS: We conclude that paediatric donor kidneys should be given preferentially to paediatric recipients due to better long-term function.     

Cadaveric renal transplantation: our experience at the Institute of Kidney Diseases & Research Centre, Institute of Transplantation Sciences, Ahmedabad

In a developing country such as India, cadaveric renal transplantation accounts for only less than 1% of total renal transplantations. The reasons for such a low rate of cadaveric transplantation are many, ranging from lack of awareness to socioeconomic reasons. Our institute conducted a statewide public awareness program and initiated an intercity organ harvesting program. This doubled the cadaveric renal transplantations in the last 2 years. We performed 38 cadaveric transplantations among 190 renal transplantations in the last year (August 2005 to July 2006). We retrieved kidneys from 21 donors, of whom 9 were outside our city. From 21 donors we transplanted 38 recipients; out of whom 3 received dual kidneys and one kidney was discarded. The Mean age of the donors was 41.4 +/- 18.2 years with a mean cold ischemia time of 6.9 +/- 3.8 hours. Sixty-eight percent had delayed graft function. At the last follow-up, which was 190 +/- 98 days, patient survival rate was 90%: 4 patients died, including 2 due to bacterial sepsis and 2 due to cytomegalovirus (CMV) disease. The Graft survival rate was 85%, and the death-censored graft survival rate was 90%. Mean serum creatinine value at the last follow-up was 1.2 +/- 0.3 mg%. There were 5 episodes of acute rejection in 31 patients during first 3 months (16% acute rejection rate). The increase in cadaveric transplantations was associated with satisfactory patient and graft survival despite the high incidence of delayed graft function.