Predictive Validity of a Computerized Emergency Triage Tool

Background Emergency department (ED) triage prioritizes patients on the basis of the urgency of need for care. eTRIAGE is a Web‐based triage decision support tool that is based on the Canadian Triage and Acuity Scale (CTAS), a five level triage system (CTAS 1 = resuscitation, CTAS 5 = nonurgent). Objectives To examine the validity of eTRIAGE on the basis of resource utilization and cost as measures of acuity. Methods Scores on the CTAS, specialist consultations, computed‐tomography use, ED length of stay, ED disposition, and estimated ED and hospital costs (if the patient was subsequently admitted to hospital) were collected for each patient over a six month period. These data were queried from a database that captures all regional ED visits. Correlations between CTAS score and each outcome were measured by using logistic regression models (categorical variables), univariate analysis of variance (continuous variables), and the Kruskal‐Wallis analysis of variance (costs). A multivariate regression model that used cost as the outcome was used to identify interaction between the variables presented. Results Over the six month study, 29,524 patients were triaged by using eTRIAGE. When compared with CTAS level 3, the odds ratios for consultation, CT scan, and admission were significantly higher in CTAS 1 and 2 and were significantly lower in CTAS 4 and 5 (p < 0.001). When compared with CTAS levels 2–5 combined, the odds ratio for death in CTAS 1 was 664.18 (p < 0.001). The length of stay also demonstrated significant correlation with CTAS score (p < 0.001). Costs to the ED and hospital also correlated significantly with increasing acuity (median costs for CTAS levels in Canadian dollars: CTAS 1 =$2,690, CTAS 2 =$433, CTAS 3 =$288, CTAS 4 =$164, CTAS 5 =$139, and p < 0.001). Significant interactions between the data collected were found in a multivariate regression model, although CTAS score remained highly associated with costs. Conclusions Acuity measured by eTRIAGE demonstrates excellent predictive validity for resource utilization and ED and hospital costs. Future research should focus on specific presenting complaints and targeted resources to more accurately assess eTRIAGE validity.     

Development of a Pediatric Mass Casualty Triage Algorithm Validation Tool

Background: Rapid, accurate evaluation and sorting of victims in a mass casualty incident (MCI) is crucial, as over-triage of victims may overwhelm a trauma system and under-triage may lead to an increase in morbidity and mortality. At this time, there is no validation tool specifically developed for the pediatric population to test an MCI algorithm's inherent capabilities to correctly triage children. Objective: To develop a set of criteria for outcomes and interventions to be used as a validation tool for testing an MCI algorithm's ability to correctly triage patients from a cohort of pediatric trauma patients. Methods: Expert opinion and literature review was used to formulate an initial Criteria Outcomes Tool (COT) that retrospectively categorizes pediatric (≤14 years of age) MCI victims based on resource utilization and clinical outcomes using the classic Red to Black MCI triage designations: Red - cardiopulmonary or mental status compromise needing intervention, Yellow - stable cardiopulmonary status but may require life or limb therapy, Green - minimally injured, and Black - deceased or likely to die given the circumstances. Using an anatomic approach, a list of criteria were defined and a modified-Delphi approach was used to create a summative COT that was reviewed by the American Academy of Pediatrics Disaster Preparedness Advisory Council. The resulting COT was independently applied to a weighted retrospective cohort of 25 pediatric victims from a single Level I trauma center by two reviewers to determine reproducibility. Results: We created a Criteria Outcomes Tool (COT) with 47 outcomes and interventions to validate an MCI algorithm's triage designation. When the COT was applied to a cohort of 25 weighted pediatric charts, we identified the following resource utilization and outcome based triage designations: six Red, six Yellow, six Green, and seven Black triage outcomes. The 100% agreement was obtained between the two reviewers in each of the four categories. Conclusions: We designed an outcomes and resource utilization tool, the COT, to evaluate the ability of an MCI algorithm to correctly triage pediatric patients. Our tool has good reproducibility on initial study.     

Effectiveness of nitrous oxide in a rural EMS system

Prehospital systems need a safe, effective analgesic agent for the treatment of patients suffering from pain. Recent studies have documented the efficacy of nitrous oxide in urban and rural settings. This study reviews the findings on 200 patients (157 trauma, 23 medical, 18 musculoskeletal problems) who received nitrous oxide during a 28-month period in a rural EMS system. Eighty-five percent of the patients reported pain relief. Only minor side effects were noted. Patient satisfaction was high, and there was no abuse noted among personnel.     

Effectiveness of a Glasgow Coma Scale instructional video for EMS providers

INTRODUCTION: The Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) is the standard measure used to quantify the level of consciousness of patients who have sustained head injuries. Rapid and accurate GCS scoring is essential. OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the effectiveness of a GCS teaching video shown to prehospital emergency medical services (EMS) providers. METHODS: Participants and setting--United States, Mid-Atlantic region EMS providers. Intervention--Each participant scored all of the three components of the GCS for each of four scenarios provided before and after viewing a video-tape recording containing four scenarios. Design--Before-and-after single (Phase I) and parallel Cohort (Phase II). Analysis--Proportions of correct scores were compared using chi-square, and relative risk was calculated to measure the strength of the association. RESULTS: 75 participants were included in Phase I. In Phase II, 46 participants participated in a parallel cohort design: 20 used GCS reference cards and 26 did not use the cards. Before observing the instructional video, only 14.7% score all of the scenarios correctly, where as after viewing the video, 64.0% scored the scenarios results were observed after viewing the video for those who used the GCS cards (p = 0.001; RR = 2.0; 95% CI = 1.29 to 3.10) than for those not using the cards (p < 0.0001; RR = 10.0; 95% CI = 2.60 to 38.50). CONCLUSIONS: Post-video viewing scores were better than those observed before the video presentation. Ongoing evaluations include analysis of long-term skill retention and scoring accuracy in the clinical environment.     

Medical Oversight,Educational Core Content,and Proposed Scopes of Practice of Wilderness EMS Providers: A Joint Project Developed by Wilderness EMS Educators,Medical Directors,and Regulators Using a Delphi Approach

Introduction: A disparity exists between the skills needed to manage patients in wilderness EMS environments and the scopes of practice that are traditionally approved by state EMS regulators. In response, the National Association of EMS Physicians Wilderness EMS Committee led a project to define the educational core content supporting scopes of practice of wilderness EMS providers and the conditions when wilderness EMS providers should be required to have medical oversight. Methods: Using a Delphi process, a group of experts in wilderness EMS, representing educators, medical directors, and regulators, developed model educational core content. This core content is a foundation for wilderness EMS provider scopes of practice and builds on both the National EMS Education Standards and the National EMS Scope of Practice Model. These experts also identified the conditions when oversight is needed for wilderness EMS providers. Results: By consensus, this group of experts identified the educational core content for four unique levels of wilderness EMS providers: Wilderness Emergency Medical Responder (WEMR), Wilderness Emergency Medical Technician (WEMT), Wilderness Advanced Emergency Medical Technician (WAEMT), and Wilderness Paramedic (WParamedic). These levels include specialized skills and techniques pertinent to the operational environment. The skills and techniques increase in complexity with more advanced certification levels, and address the unique circumstances of providing care to patients in the wilderness environment. Furthermore, this group identified that providers having a defined duty to act should be functioning with medical oversight. Conclusion: This group of experts defined the educational core content supporting the specific scopes of practice that each certification level of wilderness EMS provider should have when providing patient care in the wilderness setting. Wilderness EMS providers are, indeed, providing health care and should thus function within defined scopes of practice and with physician medical director oversight.     

Safety of a Novel Obstructive Sleep Apnea Triage Tool for Postoperative Orthopedic Surgery Patients

PurposeThe purpose of this quality improvement project is to provide a tool for effective and safe triage of postoperative patients in the postanesthesia care unit with known or suspected obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) at an academic orthopedic hospital in New York City.DesignThe structure of this project was observational after implementation of a novel OSA triage tool.MethodsResults were reported from a single center experience in a hospital where there was no existing standard assessment tool consistently used to triage patients with either known or suspected OSA in the postoperative period. Adult patients who underwent orthopedic surgery between October 2018 and February 2020 and who had a known or suspected history of OSA were included. After admission to the postanesthesia care unit (PACU) and upon meeting their modified Aldrete criteria or after 2 hours had elapsed, the PACU primary provider used the OSA triage tool to assess whether the patient had a high or low risk of respiratory deterioration after discharge from the PACU related to OSA. Patients without high-risk criteria were discharged from the PACU to a medical/surgical unit. For patients with high-risk criteria, the PACU provider requested critical care consultation to determine each patient's appropriate hospital disposition upon PACU discharge.FindingsOver the course of the study period, 216 patients were evaluated using the OSA triage tool: 53.2% of the cohort was male, median BMI was 36.3 kg/m², and 80.1% had a prior diagnosis of obstructive sleep apnea. Patients underwent a variety of orthopedic surgeries with 23.6% having undergone hip surgery, 51.4% knee surgery, 13.4% spine surgery, 9.7% shoulder surgery, and 1.9% foot or ankle surgery. Notably, with the use of this tool, only 12.5% of patients met criteria for critical care consult and 91.7% were admitted to the floor from the PACU. Rapid response for respiratory complications were not observed in any of the patients. There were only three patients who required critical care evaluation after PACU discharge. An anonymous survey completed by PACU nurse practitioners and anesthesiologists revealed a 96.8% self-reported satisfaction with OSA triage tool.ConclusionWe demonstrated that use of a OSA triage tool in the single-center orthopedic PACU at NYULH is potentially a safe and effective method of triaging patients with known or suspected OSA to acute care beds versus higher levels of care.     

Effectiveness of a 6-week online course in the Canadian Triage and Acuity Scale for emergency nurses.

INTRODUCTION: There is increasing interest in 5-level triage systems in emergency departments; however, the adoption of a new system places heavy training demands on ED department nurses and physicians. One emerging training option is online learning. The purpose of this study was to explore the effectiveness of an online course in the 5-level Canadian Triage and Acuity Scale (CTAS) on the clinical practice of the triage nurse. METHODS: Interviews were held with 23 emergency nurses from across Canada. A chart audit of triage codes from 367 charts from 6 hospitals was conducted. RESULTS: The most consistent finding was that the majority of RN staff enjoyed the online course and believed it had improved their triage practice. Nurses believed that their patient assessments were more thorough, accurate, and consistent throughout the department. Improved communication between staff and with patients and families was identified. Nurses reported using what they learned to improve triage assessment. Triage accuracy was high; the overall agreement between CTAS graduates and the chart auditor/expert within one CTAS level was 99.7%. Nurses also identified a number of organizational barriers to CTAS implementation after the course. DISCUSSION: The online format appears to be an effective, efficient, and convenient way to educate large numbers of ED staff in CTAS. Further research is needed regarding the use of multimedia and computer online chat options to further enhance the online learning experience for nurses.     

Evaluation of the Educational Effectiveness of a Virtual Reality Intravenous Insertion Simulator

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate construct and content validity as well as learners' perceptions of CathSim, a virtual reality intravenous (IV) insertion simulator. METHODS: A prospective cohort study design was employed to determine construct validity, and a participant survey was used to ascertain content validity as well as user perceptions of CathSim. Forty-one attendings, residents, and medical students in emergency medicine and anesthesia attempted five simulated IV insertions on CathSim. Subject performances were scored by the computer, and subject perceptions of the simulator were measured using a Likert scale questionnaire (1 = worst rating; 5 = best rating). The subjects were divided into three groups (novices, intermediates, and experts) based on previous IV experience. To determine construct validity, performances of the three groups were compared using one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA). To determine content validity, the experts' perceptions of the simulator's realism and usefulness were assessed. Study subjects' perceptions of the simulator's ease of use and overall appeal were analyzed. RESULTS: The experts scored better than the others in five of nine scoring parameters (p < 0.05). The experts rated the realism of CathSim's four major simulation components at 3.85, 3.46, 3.69, and 3.46; the overall realism of CathSim at 2.93; and its utility for medical student training at 4.57. The simulator's ease of use was rated at 2.34 by all subjects. Novices reported a score of 4.59 regarding their likelihood to use the simulator. CONCLUSIONS: CathSim demonstrated construct validity in five of nine internal scoring parameters and was judged to be adequately realistic and highly useful for medical student training. Despite being difficult to learn to use, it remained appealing to the users, especially the novices.     

The Effectiveness of a Standardized Educational Program for Children Using Patient-Controlled Analgesia

purpose . To examine the effectiveness of two types of preoperative education (routine education and a standardized educational program) for children undergoing spinal fusion.

design.

design. Two group, phase-lag design.

setting.

setting. Tertiary pediatric hospital.

participants.

participants. Children ages 8-18 years (N = 93)

main outcome measures.

main outcome measures. Adolescent Pediatric Pain Tool, Child Pain Scale, Post-PCA Satisfaction Interview, and PCA infusion pump data.

results.

results. No statistically significant differences between the groups on any of the main outcome variables. Children and parents reported, however, that the SEP provided them with invaluable information regarding the use of PCA and alleviated their concerns about getting "hooked on drugs," overdosing, side effects, and being able to get pain relief when needed.

conclusion.

conclusion. Children having spine fusion surgery experienced severe postoperative pain that was not ameliorated by optimizing use of PCA through standardized education. Further testing of the SEP with other populations is needed in order to more fully realize its potential for influencing pain outcomes.     

Effectiveness of Implementing Emergency Severity Index Triage System in a Selected Primary Health Care Center in Oman: A Quasi-Experimental Study

BackgroundBecause most primary health care centers in Oman do not use a formal triage system, there are no available data on the effectiveness of implementing this system.PurposeTo assess the effectiveness of implementing an Emergency Severity Index triage system in primary health care centers in Oman.MethodsA pretest/posttest quasi-experimental design was used. The sample comprised 187 patients before Emergency Severity Index implementation and 102 patients after implementation. Waiting time, length of stay, patient satisfaction, and accuracy of classification were compared across the 2 groups.ResultsThe mean time (hour:minute) from registration to triage was reduced in the post-Emergency Severity Index group (mean = 0:18, SD = 0:14) compared with the pre-Emergency Severity Index group (mean = 0:23, SD = 0:19) (t = 2.59, P = 0.01). Furthermore, the mean length of stay was reduced in the post-Emergency Severity Index group (mean = 1:09, SD = 0:37) compared with that of the preimplementation group (mean = 1:24, SD = 0:41) (t = 3.10, P = 0.002). Patient satisfaction in the postimplementation group was improved (mean = 66.95, SD = 8.33) compared with that of the Emergency Severity Index group (mean = 65.01, SD = 8.73), but it did not reach statistical significance (t = −1.83, P = 0.07). The inter-rater agreement of triage level in post-Emergency Severity Index implementation markedly improved in the postimplementation group (Cohen’s kappa = 0.910, P < 0.001) compared with that of the preimplementation group (Cohen’s kappa = 0.082, P = 0.005).ConclusionsAlthough this is a single-setting study, the results have shown that the Emergency Severity Index system can contribute to a decrease in the negative crowding outcomes in primary health care centers in Oman.