Effect of screw length on bioabsorbable interference screw fixation in a tibial bone tunnel

Initial tibial fixation strength is the weak link after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with a quadrupled hamstring tendon graft fixed with bioabsorbable interference screws. The purpose of this study was to determine the biomechanical differences between 28-mm and tapered 35-mm interference screws for tibial fixation of a soft tissue graft in 16 young cadaveric tibias. Failure mode, displacement before failure, and ultimate failure load were tested with a testing machine aligned with the tibial tunnel to simulate a worst-case scenario. The mode of failure was graft slippage past the screw in all but one of the specimens. The mean maximum load at failure of the 28-mm screw was 594.9 +/- 141.0 N, with mean displacement at failure of 10.97 +/- 2.20 mm. The mean maximum load at failure of the 35-mm screw was 824.9 +/- 124.3 N, with a mean displacement to failure of 14.38 +/- 2.15 mm. The 38% difference in mean maximal load at failure was significant. Important variables in hamstring tendon graft fixation within a bone tunnel include bone mineral density, dilatation, gap size, screw placement, and screw width and length. Attention to these variables will help to provide secure graft fixation during biologic incorporation throughout the rehabilitation period.     

Multistranded hamstring tendon graft fixation with a central four-quadrant or a standard tibial interference screw for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

BACKGROUND: Tibial fixation of hamstring tendon grafts has been the weak link in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. HYPOTHESIS: Use of a central four-quadrant sleeve and screw provides superior fixation when compared with standard interference screw fixation. STUDY DESIGN: Controlled laboratory study. METHODS: In eight pairs of cadaveric knees each anterior cruciate ligament was reconstructed using either an interference screw or a central sleeve and screw on the tibial side. The specimens were then subjected to cyclic loading followed by a load-to-failure test. RESULTS: The load required to cause 1 and 2 mm of graft laxity, defined as the separation of the femur and the tibia at the points of graft fixation, was significantly greater with the sleeve and screw than with the interference screw (at 2 mm: sleeve and screw, 216.1 +/- 30.1 N; interference screw, 167.0 +/- 33.2 N). The force at initial slippage for each of the graft strands was significantly higher with use of the central sleeve and screw. CONCLUSIONS: The four-quadrant sleeve and screw device may provide greater surface area for healing of hamstring tendon grafts and allow equal tensioning of graft strands before fixation. These factors are associated with increased strength of fixation and reduced laxity of the graft after cyclic loading. Clinical Relevance: Use of the central four-quadrant sleeve and screw system offers increased strength of fixation in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with hamstring tendon graft.     

The influence of screw geometry on hamstring tendon interference fit fixation

We used a standardized model of calf tibial bone to investigate the influence of screw diameter and length on interference fit fixation of a three-stranded semitendinosus tendon graft for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Biodegradable poly-(L-lactide) interference screws with a diameter of 7, 8, and 9 mm and a length of 23 and 28 mm were used. We examined results in three groups of 10 specimens each: group 1, screw diameter equaled graft diameter and screw length was 23 mm; group 2, screw diameter equaled graft diameter plus 1 mm and screw length was 23 mm; group 3, screw diameter equaled graft diameter and screw length was 28 mm. The mean pull-out forces in groups 1, 2, and 3 were 367.2+/-78 N, 479.1+/-111.1 N, and 537.4+/-139.1 N, respectively. The force data from groups 2 and 3 were significantly higher than those from group 1. These results indicate that screw geometry has a significant influence on hamstring tendon interference fit fixation. Increasing screw length improves fixation strength more than oversizing the screw diameter. This is important, especially for increasing tibial fixation strength because the tibial graft fixation site has been considered to be the weak link of such a reconstruction.     

Femoral fixation of hamstring grafts in posterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: biomechanical evaluation of different fixation techniques: is there an acute angle effect?

BACKGROUND: The literature provides little biomechanical data about femoral fixation of hamstring grafts in posterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. HYPOTHESIS: A hybrid fixation technique with use of an undersized screw has sufficient strength to provide secure fixation of posterior cruciate ligament grafts. Additional aperture fixation with a biodegradable interference screw can prevent graft damage that might be caused by an acute angle on the edge of the femoral tunnel. STUDY DESIGN: Controlled laboratory study. METHODS: In part 1, extracortical fixation of posterior cruciate ligament reconstructions with quadrupled porcine flexor digitorum grafts to simulate human hamstring grafts was compared with hybrid fixation methods using 6-, 7-, and 8-mm screws. Groups were tested in cycling loading with the load applied in line with the bone tunnel. In part 2, extracortical fixation was compared with hybrid fixation using a 1-mm undersized screw anterior and posterior to the graft. Structural properties and graft abrasion were evaluated after cyclic loading with the load applied at 90 degrees to the tunnel. In each group, 8 porcine knees were tested. RESULTS: In part 1, stiffness, maximum load, and yield load were significantly higher for hybrid fixation than for extracortical fixation. Hybrid fixation with an 8-mm screw resulted in higher yield load than with a 7-mm screw. In part 2, graft laceration was more pronounced in specimens with extracortical fixation than with hybrid fixation. Posterior screw placement was superior to the anterior position. CONCLUSION: For all parameters, hybrid fixation with an interference screw provided superior structural results. No relevant disadvantages of undersized screws could be found. Graft damage due to abrasion at the edge of the femoral bone tunnel was reduced by use of an interference screw. The posterior screw placement seems favorable. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Hybrid fixation of hamstring grafts in posterior cruciate ligament reconstruction is superior to extracortical fixation alone with no relevant disadvantages of undersized screws. The results raise the suspicion of an acute angle effect of the femoral bone tunnel.     

Interactive effects of tunnel dilation on the mechanical properties of hamstring grafts fixed in the tibia with interference screws

The effect of dilation of the tibial tunnel on the strength of hamstring graft fixation using interference screws was evaluated. In all, 28 RCI screws were tested in male human tibia-hamstring constructs with tibial tunnels reamed or dilated to the respective size of the graft diameter. Dilation of the tibial tunnel failed to significantly enhance hamstring fixation. Grafts secured in dilated tunnels displayed an 11% greater resistance to the initiation of graft slippage (174+/-112 N) compared to their undilated controls (156+/-77 N, P=0.63). Dilation of the tibial tunnel increased the failure load by an average of 4%, independent of screw diameter (dilated specimens: 360+/-120 N, controls: 345+/-88 N, P=0.74). Biomechanical research on the effect of tibial tunnel dilation in hamstring fixation has not provided satisfactory evidence as to the benefits of this additional surgical step during anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction.     

Biomechanical properties of patellar and hamstring graft tibial fixation techniques in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: experimental study with roentgen stereometric analysis

BACKGROUND: Reliable fixation of the soft hamstring grafts in ACL reconstruction has been reported as problematic. HYPOTHESIS: The biomechanical properties of patellar tendon (PT) grafts fixed with biodegradable screws (PTBS) are superior compared to quadrupled hamstring grafts fixed with BioScrew (HBS) or Suture-Disc fixation (HSD). STUDY DESIGN: Controlled laboratory study with roentgen stereometric analysis (RSA). METHODS: Ten porcine specimens were prepared for each group. In the PT group, the bone plugs were fixed with a 7 x 25 mm BioScrew. In the hamstring group, four-stranded tendon grafts were anchored within a tibial tunnel of 8 mm diameter either with a 7 x 25 mm BioScrew or eight polyester sutures knotted over a Suture-Disc. The grafts were loaded stepwise, and micromotion of the graft inside the tibial tunnel was measured with RSA. RESULTS: Hamstring grafts failed at lower loads (HBS: 536 N, HSD 445 N) than the PTBS grafts (658 N). Stiffness in the PTBS group was much greater compared to the hamstring groups (3500 N/mm versus HBS = 517 N/mm and HSD = 111 N/mm). Irreversible graft motion after graft loading with 200 N was measured at 0.03 mm (PTBS), 0.38mm (HBS), and 1.85mm (HSD). Elasticity for the HSD fixation was measured at 0.67 mm at 100 N and 1.32 mm at 200 N load. CONCLUSION: Hamstring graft fixation with BioScrew and Suture-Disc displayed less stiffness and early graft motion compared to PTBS fixation. Screw fixation of tendon grafts is superior to Suture-Disc fixation with linkage material since it offers greater stiffness and less graft motion inside the tibial tunnel. Clinical Relevance: Our results revealed graft motion for hamstring fixation with screw or linkage material at loads that occur during rehabilitation. This, in turn, may lead to graft laxity.     

Biomechanical properties of quadruple tendon and patellar tendon femoral fixation techniques

Two femoral fixation techniques for quadruple hamstring tendon grafts were compared under cyclic loading with the patellar tendon: the rectangular inserted pin (TransFix) and biodegradable interference screw fixation of the quadruple tendon and titanium interference screw fixation of the middle third of the patellar tendon. Porcine specimens were mounted onto a tension load machine, and the tendon-fixation-femur-complex was tested for stiffness, displacement during 800 cycles of loading between 50 and 250 N and ultimate tension load. TransFix fixation showed the greatest stiffness at 183.6 N/mm ( P<0.05). The least displacement under cyclic loading was observed for the titanium interference screw followed by the TransFix and biodegradable interference screw ( P<0.01). The ultimate tension load was greatest for the TransFix fixation at 1303+/-282 N, followed by patellar tendon fixation with 763+/-103 N and the biodegradable interference screw fixation with 480+/-133 N ( P<0.001). To reduce initial elongation of the graft and displacement at the fixation site, preconditioning of both the tendon and tendon-fixation complex is especially important when using quadruple tendons. TransFix fixation provides better stability and greater stiffness and pull-out strength than the other techniques. This finding is of clinical relevance to surgeons of the anterior cruciate ligament.     

Compaction drilling does not increase the initial fixation strength of the hamstring tendon graft in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in a cadaver model

BACKGROUND: Compaction of the bone tunnel walls has been proposed to increase the fixation strength of soft tissue grafts fixed with an interference screw in anterior cruciate ligament reconstructions. HYPOTHESIS: Compaction drilling does not increase the initial fixation strength of the hamstring tendon graft in comparison with conventional extraction drilling. STUDY DESIGN: Randomized experimental study. METHODS: Initial fixation strength of quadrupled hamstring tendon grafts fixed with bioabsorbable interference screws was assessed in 22 pairs of human cadaveric tibiae. Bone tunnels were drilled with either a compaction drill or a conventional extraction drill. Specimens underwent a cyclic-loading test and the surviving specimens were then loaded to failure in a single-cycle load-to-failure test. Trabecular bone mineral density at the site corresponding to the actual site of the tibial bone tunnel was determined by using peripheral quantitative computed tomography. RESULTS: During the cyclic-loading test, no significant stiffness or displacement differences were observed between the two drilling techniques. Three specimens failed in the compaction-drilling group, whereas there were no failures in the extraction-drilling group. In the subsequent single-cycle load-to-failure test, no significant differences between the two drilling techniques were found with regard to displacement at yield load, stiffness, or mode of failure. There was no significant difference in trabecular bone mineral density between the two groups. CONCLUSIONS: Compaction drilling does not increase the initial fixation strength of the hamstring tendon graft compared with conventional extraction drilling.     

Interference screws should be shorter than the hamstring tendon graft in the bone tunnel for best fixation

Purpose

Interference screw fixation of hamstring tendon grafts in bone has to overcome the challenges that tendons have a slippery surface and viscoelastically adapt under pressure. As the typical failure mode of the graft is to slip past the interference screw, it was hypothesized that the position and configuration of the graft end may be of influence on the fixation strength.

Methods

Different configurations of the graft ending and its effect to primary fixation with interference screws after viscoelastic adaptation were tested in six groups: I: graft and the screw inserted at the same depth, II/III: the graft overlaps the tip of the screw (interference screw of 28 and 19 mm in length, respectively), IV: strengthening of the graft ending with additional suture knots, V: Endopearl, respectively, and VI: effect of partial retraction of the screw after excessive insertion. In vitro tests were performed with fresh calf tendon grafts and interference screws in bone tunnels (fresh porcine distal femur) all of 8 mm in diameter.

Results

The relative position of the graft ending to the tip of the interference screw thereby was recognized as a significant factor on pullout forces. Further strengthening at the graft endings with additional suture knots or an Endopearl device could improve primary hold as well.

Conclusions

Better fixation strength is achieved if the tip of interference screw does not extend past the end of a tendon graft. Enforcement of the tendon end with sutures or an implant can further improve fixation.     

Initial fixation strength of two bioabsorbable pins for the fixation of hamstring grafts compared to interference screw fixation: single cycle and cyclic loading

BACKGROUND: During the early postoperative period, the fixation of a hamstring graft to the bone tunnel is the primary factor in limiting rehabilitation. HYPOTHESIS: The initial fixation strength of a double cross pin fixation technique is comparable with the biodegradable interference screw fixation technique. STUDY DESIGN: Experimental laboratory study. METHODS: The authors examined the initial fixation strength of two 3.3-mm bioabsorbable pins compared to interference screws for hamstring grafts in bovine knees. RESULTS: Analysis of yield load, maximum load, and stiffness in the single-cycle loading test showed no statistically significant differences for cross pin and interference fixation (P <.05). For cross pins and interference screws, the mean displacement under 1000 cycles to 250 N was 5.07 ( +/- 1.9) mm and 4.81 ( +/- 2.5) mm, stiffness 252 ( +/- 78) N/mm and 289 ( +/- 148) N/mm. Only grafts fixed with cross pins survived 1000 cycles to 450 N. CONCLUSION: The initial fixation strength of the double cross pin technique is comparable to that of interference screw fixation with a stiffness comparable to that of the native ACL. Clinical Relevance: Hamstring graft fixation using two cross pins provides an alternative to bioabsorbable interference screw fixation.     

The influence of supplementary tibial fixation on laxity measurements after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with hamstring tendons in female patients

BACKGROUND: Female patients undergoing arthroscopic anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with a hamstring tendon graft developed increased postoperative laxity compared to male and female patients who had reconstruction using a patellar tendon graft. This difference may be due to graft slippage in less dense female tibial bone. HYPOTHESIS: Reinforcement of tibial fixation of the hamstring tendon graft in women by supplementary methods may reduce laxity. STUDY DESIGN: Randomized controlled clinical trial; Level of evidence, 2. METHODS: Fifty-six female patients divided into 2 groups (standard tibial fixation with 7 x 25-mm metal interference screw versus metal interference screw with supplementary staple fixation) were followed for 2 years. RESULTS: After 2 years, the mean side-to-side difference using KT-1000 arthrometer manual maximum measurements was 1.8 mm (standard group) and 1.1 mm (staple group) (P=.05). The percentage of patients with a side-to-side difference of <3 mm did not differ significantly between the 2 groups (P=.66): 88.8% of the standard group versus 90.5% of the staple group. A grade 0 Lachman test result was present in 63% of the standard group and 86% of the staple group (P=.04). Kneeling pain was experienced by 7% of the standard group and 29% of the staple group (P=.05). CONCLUSIONS: Supplementary tibial fixation in female patients undergoing anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with hamstring tendon graft in addition to a single-size screw significantly improves laxity measurements and clinical stability assessment 2 years after surgery. However, this improvement is at the cost of increased kneeling pain.     

A biomechanical comparison of initial soft tissue tibial fixation devices: the Intrafix versus a tapered 35-mm bioabsorbable interference screw

BACKGROUND: Biomechanical testing of the Intrafix device has not been performed using human tibiae. HYPOTHESIS: The Intrafix device would provide comparable or superior tibial fixation of a quadrupled hamstring tendon graft to a 35-mm-long bioabsorbable interference screw. STUDY DESIGN: In vitro, biomechanical study. METHODS: Eight paired human tibiae and 16 quadrupled hamstring tendon grafts were divided into 2 groups. Each quadrupled hamstring tendon graft was fixed in a tunnel sized to 0.5 mm graft diameter with either an Intrafix device or a screw. RESULTS: Displacement at failure was greater in the Intrafix group (17.3 +/- 4.6 mm versus 10.9 +/- 4.4 mm, P =.002). Load at failure (796 +/- 193 N versus 647 +/- 269 N), stiffness (49.2 +/- 21.9 N/mm versus 64.5 +/- 22 N/mm), and bone mineral density (0.74 +/- 0.15 gm/cm(3) versus 0.74 +/- 0.14 gm/cm(3)) did not display significant differences for the Intrafix device and the screw, respectively (P >.05). CONCLUSIONS: Displacement at failure was greater for the Intrafix device. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Increased displacement at failure for the Intrafix group suggests slippage from sheath channel deployment. Concentric fixation may not occur when less than optimal tibial bone mineral density increases the difficulty of attaining precise sheath deployment and quadrupled hamstring tendon graft strand alignment.     

A biomechanical comparison of different surgical techniques of graft fixation in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

Different surgical methods of graft fixation in ACL reconstruction were examined to determine the effects on mechanical properties of the reconstructed ACL. Ten human cadavers were used in this study. Six different types of grafts were studied. The tendon grafts were removed from each cadaver and fixed to femurs and tibias as ACL substitutes with different surgical fixation methods, leaving femur-reconstructed graft-tibia preparations. The surgical techniques used were staple fixation, tying sutures over buttons, and screw fixation. In the latter, the screws were introduced through femoral and tibial drill holes from the outside in order to achieve interference fit as described by Lambert. Tensile testing demonstrated that the original ACL is significantly stronger than the graft used for reconstruction in linear load, stiffness, and maximum tensile strength. All of the failures of the reconstructed ACL grafts occurred at the fixation site, indicating that the mechanically weak link of the reconstructed graft is located at the fixation site. Among the different methods of fixation, one-third of the patellar tendon secured with a cancellous screw, especially with a custom designed large diameter screw, showed significantly higher values. Although many other factors affect the success of ACL reconstruction, our study indicates that the method of surgical fixation is the major factor influencing the graft's mechanical properties in the immediate postoperative period.     

Arthroscopic anterior cruciate ligament double-bundle reconstruction using hamstring tendon grafts-fixation with two interference screws: technical note

In this article, an original double-bundle anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction technique is described. The procedure is developed using hamstring tendon grafts while maintaining tibial osseous insertion. Two tibial tunnels are drilled and a simplified and precise outside-in double tunnel femoral drilling technique is utilized. The graft fixation is made using only two interference screws.     

Effects of interference fit screw length on tibial tunnel fixation for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

Graft-tunnel mismatch during arthroscopically assisted anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using the central-third patellar tendon results in less than 20 mm of bone plug remaining in the tibial tunnel. We decided to evaluate the strength of bone plug fixation using interference fit screws that were less than 20 mm in length. Biomechanical testing was performed on 48 porcine hindquarters using 9-mm diameter interference fit screws that measured 12.5, 15, and 20 mm in length. No significant difference was noted between the different-length screws for insertion torque, divergence, stiffness, displacement, or load to failure. We believe, therefore, that comparable graft fixation can be achieved in the tibial tunnel using 9-mm diameter interference fit screws that are less than 20 mm long, and that these shorter screws may be useful in cases of graft-tunnel mismatch.     

Mechanical evaluation of a soft tissue interference screw in free tendon anterior cruciate ligament graft fixation

In this study of bioabsorbable screw fixation of free tendon grafts used in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction, we performed load-to-failure and cyclic loading of tendon fixation in porcine bone. Bone density measurements from dual photon absorptometry scans were obtained to correlate bone density with fixation failure. The average density of porcine bone (1.42 g/cm2) was similar to that of young human bone (1.30 g/cm2) and significantly higher than that of elderly human cadaveric bone specimens (0.30 g/cm2). Cyclic loading was performed on free tendon grafts fixed with a bioabsorbable screw alone and on grafts fixed with a bioabsorbable screw and an anchor (polylactic acid ball or cortical bone disk). Stiffness of fixation increased substantially with the addition of a cortical bone disk anchor or polylactic acid ball compared with the interference screw alone. Tensile fixation strength of central quadriceps free tendon and hamstring tendon grafts were significantly superior in porcine bone of density similar to young human bone than in elderly human cadaveric bone. The bioabsorbable interference screw yielded loads at failure comparable with traditional bone-tendon-bone and hamstring tendon fixation when controlled for bone density. The addition of a cortical bone disk anchor provided the most optimal fixation of free tendon with the bioabsorbable screw and reduced slippage with cyclic loading to a very low level.     

Pullout strength of tibial graft fixation in anterior cruciate ligament replacement with a patellar tendon graft: interference screw versus staple fixation in human knees

The endoscopic single incision technique for anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction with a femoral half-tunnel may lead to a graft/tunnel mismatch and subsequent protrusion of the block from the tibial tunnel. The typical tibial fixation with an interference screw is not possible in these cases. Fixation with staples in a bony groove inferior to the tunnel outlet can be used as an alternative technique. Current literature does not provide biomechanical data of either fixation technique in a human model. This study was performed to evaluate the primary biomechanical parameters of this technique compared with a standard interference screw fixation of the block. Fifty-five fresh-frozen relatively young (mean age 44 years) human cadaver knee joints were used. Grafts were harvested from the patellar tendon midportion with bone blocks of 25 mm length and 9 mm width. A 10-mm tibial tunnel was drilled from the anteromedial cortex to the center of the tibial insertion of the ACL. Three different sizes of interference screws (7 × 30, 9 × 20, 9 × 30 mm) were chosen as a standard control procedure (n = 40). For tibial bone-block fixation the graft was placed through the tunnel, and the screw was then inserted on the cancellous or the cortical surface, respectively. Fifteen knees were treated by staple fixation. A groove was created inferior to the tunnel outlet with a chisel. The bone block was fixed in this groove with two barbed stainless steel staples. Tensile testing in both groups was carried out under an axial load parallel to the tibial tunnel in a Zwick testing machine with a velocity of 1 mm/s. Dislocation of the graft and stiffness were calculated at 175 N load. Maximum load to failure using interference screws varied between 506 and 758 N. Load to failure using staples was 588 N. Dislocation of the graft ranged between 3.8 and 4.7 mm for interference screw fixation and was 4.7 mm for staples. Stiffness calculated at 175 N load was significantly higher in staple fixation. With either fixation technique, the recorded failure loads were sufficient to withstand the graft loads which are to be expected during the rehabilitation period. Staple fixation of the bone block outside of the tunnel resulted in a fixation strength comparable to interference screw fixation. Received: 2 September 1996 Accepted: 30 January 1997     

Biomechanical comparison of posterior cruciate ligament reconstruction techniques using cyclic loading tests

Posterior tibial translation (PTT) of the posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) reconstructed-knee under cyclic loading of 1,000 cycles with a 100-N load was compared between four different procedures, including two reconstructions with patellar tendon graft (transtunnel and inlay techniques) and two reconstructions with hamstring tendon graft (Endobutton and EndoPearl techniques) in twelve fresh-frozen human knees. The EndoPearl technique is a direct tendon fixation using biodegradable interference screws and an anchoring device, while the Endobutton technique is an indirect tendon fixation using a titanium button and surgical tape. The change of PTT after cyclic loading in the Endobutton technique was significantly greater than in the other reconstruction technique. No graft rupture at the killer turn or complete pullout from the bone tunnel was found. The advantage of the inlay technique compared to the transtunnel technique with respect to the posterior stability could not be shown in the current study. Posterior laxity of PCL reconstructed-knees with hamstring tendon graft using the Endobutton technique increased more easily than that with patellar tendon graft. For PCL reconstruction using the hamstring tendon graft, anatomical fixation may be preferable to prevent excessive posterior laxity in the early phase of the rehabilitation protocol.     

Close-looped graft suturing improves mechanical properties of interference screw fixation in ACL reconstruction

Purpose

In anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with looped soft-tissue grafts, an interference screw is frequently used for tibial fixation. This study compared three alternatives thought to improve the initial mechanical properties of direct bioabsorbable interference screw fixation: suturing the graft to close the loop, adding a supplementary staple, or increasing the oversize of the screw diameter relative to the bone tunnel from 1 to 2 mm.

Methods

Twenty-eight porcine tibiae and porcine flexor digitorum profundus tendons were randomized into four testing groups: a base fixation using 10-mm-diameter screw with open-looped graft, base fixation supplemented by an extracortical staple, base fixation but closing the looped graft by suturing its ends, and base fixation but using an 11-mm screw. Graft and bone tunnel diameters were 9 mm in all specimens. Constructs were subjected to cyclic tensile load and finally pulled to failure to determine their structural properties.

Results

The main mode of failure in all groups was pull-out of tendon strands after slippage past the screw. The sutured graft group displayed significantly lower residual displacement (mean value reduction: 47–67 %) and higher yield load (mean value increase: 38–54 %) than any alternative tested. No other statistical differences were found.

Conclusions

Suturing a soft-tissue graft to form a closed loop enhanced the initial mechanical properties of tibial fixation with a bioabsorbable interference screw in anterior cruciate ligament reconstructions using a porcine model, and thus, this may be an efficient means to help in reducing post-operative laxity and early clinical failure. No mechanical improvement was observed for an open-looped tendon graft by adding an extracortical staple to supplement the screw fixation or by increasing the oversize of the screw to tunnel diameter from 1 to 2 mm.     

Comparative pull-out and cyclic-loading strength tests of anchorage of hamstring tendon grafts in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction.

This study examined four devices for anchorage of hamstring tendons used as anterior cruciate ligament grafts: a stirrup, a clawed washer and screw, and "soft" and round-headed interference screws. Ultimate strength tests were performed using bovine tendons and bones. The stirrup was significantly stronger than the other anchorage devices, failing at 898 N. The clawed washer failed at 502 N, the soft screw at 691 N, and the round-headed screw at 445 N. Cyclic loading to 150 N (to simulate walking) caused elongation of 2.1 mm with the stirrup by 1100 cycles, and 6.7 mm with the clawed washer by 300 cycles. Different hole and soft screw diameters and placements (inside-out versus outside-in) allowed 1-to 3-mm slippage (no significant differences) by 1100 cycles. The round-headed screw allowed 6.8-mm slippage by 1100 cycles, and a sharp edge below the screw head caused tendon damage. Cyclic loads to 450 N (to simulate jogging) were then imposed until failure, and all specimens failed rapidly; only stirrup fixation kept all specimens intact after 300 load cycles. We concluded that anterior cruciate ligament reconstructions using hamstring tendons will slacken if rehabilitation is too aggressive, so forces on the reconstructed ligament should be minimized until tendon-to-bone healing occurs.