Scaphoid nonunion: role of anterior interpositional bone grafts

Twenty-one cases of unstable fractures of the scaphoid were treated by open reduction, length restoration by interpositional anterior wedge grafting, and fixation with a Herbert screw to obtain union and restore carpal stability. There was primary union in 15 (71%) of 21 patients. Two failed cases were treated with a second anterior wedge graft and Herbert screw fixation; overall rate of union was 81%. Nonunions were related to improper screw placement, failure of compression at the nonunion, bone-graft resorption, or persistent avascular necrosis. In the united scaphoids, carpal instability was corrected, with improvement in the scapholunate angle (65 degrees to 54 degrees) and capitolunate angulations (35 degrees to 15 degrees). Scaphoid malalignment associated with nonunion was improved on biplanar tomographic measurement of the scaphoid angles.     

The clinical implications of scaphotrapezium-trapezoidal arthritis with associated carpal instability

PURPOSE: Common causes of dorsal intercalated segment instability (DISI) include scapholunate dissociations and scaphoid fracture nonunions. Although less common than these, scaphotrapezium-trapezoidal (STT) osteoarthritis (OA) may also be associated with the development of a DISI deformity. The clinical implications of this form of carpal instability in cases of STT arthritis are still unknown. To study the radiographic progression and incidence of this entity, we reviewed our patients and report on 24 wrists with DISI in the presence of STT arthritis. METHODS: A retrospective chart and radiographic review was performed on all patients seen between 1994 and 2004, with the diagnosis of STT arthritis to identify a subgroup of patients with DISI deformity on the presenting radiographs. Patients' clinical and surgical courses were noted. Postoperative radiographic changes were recorded, as were clinical outcomes. RESULTS: Sixteen patients with 24 wrists having STT arthritis and DISI deformity on presenting radiographs were identified. The median STT arthritis grade was 3.0 based on a modified Eaton and Glickel grading system. The median radiolunate angle was -21 degrees of dorsal tilt. All patients had normal scapholunate angles. Abnormal scaphoid extension was seen in 19 of 24 wrists as measured by the radioscaphoid angle. Concomitant carpometacarpal arthritis was seen in 67% (n = 16) of the wrists, and midcarpal arthritis was identified in 50% (n = 8) of patients. Fifteen wrists required surgery for the symptoms and were followed up for a mean of 29 months after surgery. In the surgical group the radiolunate angles increased by mean of 6 degrees after surgery. Four of the 15 wrists required revisional surgery for persistent pain. CONCLUSIONS: Patients with STT arthritis may present with carpal instability that is not related to radiographic scapholunate instability. This instability is characterized by a normal scapholunate angle with an extension stance of the scaphoid and lunate. Midcarpal arthritis may be present. Surgical intervention for patients with STT arthritis and DISI deformity may lead to radiographic progression of midcarpal instability.     

The role of carpal instability in scaphoid nonunion: casual or causal?

We studied twenty consecutive scaphoid nonunions in twenty patients between the ages of eighteen and thirty-eight years. There were nineteen males and one female. The mean age was 25.2 years. Factors evaluated were fracture displacement, delay in treatment, and carpal instability. Fracture displacement and carpal instability were documented in patients by abnormal x-rays showing fragment displacement, abnormal scapholunate and radiolunate angles, etc., or by fluoroscopically controlled arthrography. We concluded that intercarpal ligamentous instability is consistently present and, therefore, the critical factor in wrists with ununited scaphoid fractures. Thirteen patients have been treated surgically; ligamentous disruption was confirmed at surgical exploration. In twelve patients, treatment of the nonunion included intercarpal ligamentous reconstruction. A satisfactory outcome was achieved in all twelve of these patients. One patient's treatment did not include ligament reconstruction. Although the scaphoid fracture united after a Russe bone graft, he remains symptomatic with persistent intercarpal instability. The remaining seven patients are being evaluated or awaiting surgery. Since ligamentous injury is so common in nonunion, we believe it is causal and that surgical care of nonunion involves ligamentous repair or other stabilization procedure. Prevention of nonunion involves early attention to the therapy of carpal instability when associated with scaphoid fracture.     

Reliability and validity of carpal alignment measurements in evaluating deformities of scaphoid fractures

Purpose

Several radiographic carpal alignment indices are used to evaluate the deformities of scaphoid fractures. The purpose of this study was to determine the reliabilities and validities of radiographic carpal alignment indices commonly used to evaluate deformities of scaphoid fractures.

Methods

Thirty-six patients with a scaphoid fracture were evaluated. Five carpal alignment indices were assessed on lateral plain radiographs, namely, scapholunate angle, radioscaphoid angle, radiolunate angle, radiocapitate angle, and capitolunate angle. Three examiners measured these radiographic indices at two sessions, and intraobserver and interobserver reliabilities were determined and expressed as intraclass correlation coefficients. Discriminant validities of radiographic carpal alignment indicies between injured and uninjured wrists were evaluated. For convergent validity testing, the correlation between the radiographic carpal alignment indices and intrascaphoid angles (ISAs) or height-to-length (HL) ratios on CT longitudinal scans was assessed. Further, carpal alignment indices after surgical reconstruction were compared to the Mayo wrist score.

Results

Scapholunate and radiolunate angles had the highest reliabilities, and radiocapitate angle had the lowest. Radiolunate angle had the highest discriminant validity followed by scapholunate, and capitolunate angles. In convergent validity testing, scapholunate angles and radiolunate angles correlated with ISA angles, and radiolunate and capitolunate angles correlated with HL ratios. Only the radiolunate angles correlated with the Mayo wrist scores.

Conclusions

Among radiographic carpal alignment measures, radiolunate angle is the most reliable and valid carpal alignment index for evaluating deformities of scaphoid fractures. Scapholunate and capitolunate angles could be used as an alternative, but have less validity.     

Development of degenerative changes in the wrist with pseudarthrosis of the scaphoid bone

In patients with symptomatic scaphoid nonunion there was an increased evidence of progessive osteoarthrosis expressed as instability of the wrist; it is defined as a scapholunate angle more than 70 degrees or a radiolunate angle of more than 10 degrees. We tried to determine the factors of risk and prognostic indicators of degenerative arthritis. In this study 40 patients with painfull nonunion of the scaphoid were analysed. Duration of nonunion was not in correlation with development of osteoarthritic changes (p=0,644; p>0,05). Progessive degenerative changes correlated well with radiolunate angle (p=0,398; p<0,05), kapitolunate angle (p=0,381; p<0,05) and carpal index (p=0,392; p<0,05). The average values of intercarpal angles increased with progression of osteoarthritic changes. There was a statistically strong corelation between location of fracture in proximal third and presence of degenerative changes (p=0,341; p<0,01). Intesity of arthritic changes showed no statistically significant correlation regarding untreated fractures (p=0,665; p>0,05). We recommend that a scaphoid nonunion associated with carpal instability should be operated before degenerative changes develop.     

Carpal alignment after different surgical approaches to the scaphoid: a comparative study

Thirty-seven patients with inlay bone grafting for scaphoid nonunion were evaluated before and after operation for wrist function and carpal alignment. There were 26 in whom a palmar approach had been used. The remaining 11 had been treated with a dorsal approach. The two procedures showed a similar union rate (around 80%). The palmar approach, however, caused a significant increase in the scapholunate angle (p less than 0.001) and in the lunocapitate angle (p less than 0.05) and consequently augmented carpal collapse. The dorsal approach did not affect carpal alignment. The surgical division of the palmar radiocarpal ligaments, which is necessary when using a palmar approach, may be responsible for these findings. Accordingly, a dorsal approach should be preferable to a palmar approach when a graft is used for treatment of a scaphoid nonunion.     

Treatment of scaphoid nonunion by radical curettage, trapezoidal iliac crest bone graft, and internal fixation with a Herbert screw

Ten adult male patients with scaphoid nonunions were treated by radical curettage, trapezoidal iliac crest bone grafting, and internal fixation with a Herbert screw. The mean patient age was 24.7 years, and the mean duration of the nonunion before surgery was 37.3 months. Mean follow-up time was 30.4 months. Nine of the ten nonunions healed, although one patient required a second bone-grafting procedure. The mean postoperative grip strength was 45.0 kg, and the mean postoperative pinch strength was 11.5 kg. The mean postoperative range of motion was volar flexion, 76.1 degrees; dorsiflexion, 74.2 degrees; radial deviation, 22.1 degrees; and ulnar deviation, 40.1 degrees. The scapholunate angle decreased from a mean of 72.8 degrees preoperatively to 60.6 degrees postoperatively (p less than 0.025). The mean carpal index was 0.57 postoperatively. Mean scaphoid length increased postoperatively and was within 0.2 mm of the opposite (normal) scaphoid in every patient except the single patient with a persistent nonunion (p less than 0.025). All patients returned to work (eight as laborers), and nine of ten wrists were subjectively rated as good or excellent. The results of the series suggests that treatment of displaced scaphoid nonunion by radical curettage, trapezoidal iliac crest bone grafting, and internal fixation with a Herbert screw is an effective method of treatment that reconstitutes scaphoid anatomy and promotes excellent wrist function.     

Bone malalignment in acute injuries of the wrist.

The purpose of this study was to analyze radiographic signs of carpal bone instability in patients with an acutely injured wrist. There were 80 patients (52 women and 28 men) with a fall on the outstretched hand. Fifty patients had a fracture of the distal radius, and eight had a scaphoid fracture. The patients with a bone fracture showed a larger scapholunate angle than those without a fracture (P less than 0.001, t-test). However, only four of them showed true carpal bone instability: two patients with a scaphoid fracture and one with a radius fracture had dorsiflexion instability of the wrist and one patient with a radius fracture had dorsal subluxation of the wrist. In addition, one patient without any bone fracture had scapholunate dissociation, one form of carpal bone instability. Although carpal bone instability is not frequent in an acutely injured wrist, its signs should be remembered in the radiographic analysis of the traumatic wrist to prevent subsequent articular disorders.     

Radiocarpal articular contact characteristics with scaphoid instability

The relative importance of the three major periscaphoid ligament complexes in maintaining the normal radiocarpal articulation was assessed. Pressure-sensitive film recorded the changes in radioscaphoid and radiolunate articular contact that occurred with sequential ligament sectioning in 12 cadaver wrists. Alterations in the radiocarpal articular contact as a result of ligament disruption are evident in the absence of the recognizable static x-ray changes of carpal instability. The scapholunate interosseous ligament is essential in preventing scapholunate diastasis and dorsoradial subluxation of the proximal scaphoid. Rotatory subluxation of the scaphoid occurs when disruption of the scapholunate interosseous ligament is coupled with disruption of either the palmar intracapsular radiocarpal ligaments or the scaphotrapezial ligament complex. These data help explain the development of degenerative arthritis caused by carpal ligamentous instability.     

Open reduction and internal fixation of acute displaced scaphoid waist fractures

Fourteen consecutive patients with acute displaced scaphoid waist fractures were treated with open reduction and internal fixation. The operative technique consisted of anatomic reduction of the displaced scaphoid waist fracture, correction of carpal instability, radial bone grafting for comminution, and internal fixation with K-wires or Herbert screw. The patients were evaluated an average of 26 months (range, 4-48 months) after surgery. Thirteen of the 14 (93%) fractures united. The average time to union was 11.5 weeks (range, 8-20 weeks). Fracture union was confirmed with trispiral tomography. Final radiographic assessment consistently revealed a healed scaphoid fracture, restored intrascaphoid alignment, and no evidence of carpal instability. All patients regained functional wrist range of motion (wrist extension, 57 degrees; wrist flexion, 52 degrees ) and grip strength. Open reduction and internal fixation of acute displaced scaphoid waist fractures restores scaphoid alignment and leads to predictable union. Early operative intervention avoids malunion and carpal instability that often occurs with closed management of these complex fractures.     

Association between lunate morphology and carpal collapse patterns in scaphoid nonunions

PURPOSE: Type I lunates have a single distal facet for articulation with the capitate; type II lunates have an additional (medial) hamate facet on the distal articular surface. We retrospectively reviewed a series of patients with scaphoid nonunions to determine if there was an association between lunate morphology and the degree of carpal instability observed. Association between lunate morphology and the location of the scaphoid fracture (proximal or waist) was also investigated. METHODS: Radiographs were evaluated for 45 patients with established scaphoid nonunions. Lunate morphology, scaphoid fracture location, and radiolunate angle were determined. RESULTS: Type I lunates were present in 21 patients. Of these, 15 were found to have a dorsal intercalated segment instability pattern (radiolunate angle greater than 15 degrees ). By contrast, only 4 of the patients with type II lunates exhibited this pattern of instability. No significant association was found between lunate morphology and the scaphoid fracture location. CONCLUSIONS: Type II lunate morphology is associated with significantly decreased incidence of dorsal intercalated segment instability (DISI) deformity in cases of established scaphoid nonunion (p = .0002). Lunate morphology, however, was not significantly associated with the location of the scaphoid fracture in these cases (p = .19).     

Resection of the scaphoid distal pole for symptomatic scaphoid nonunion after failed previous surgical treatment

PURPOSE: To evaluate the results of resection of the scaphoid distal pole for symptomatic scaphoid nonunion after failed prior surgical treatment. METHODS: Thirteen patients who were treated with resection of the scaphoid distal pole for persistent nonunion after previous surgical treatment were included in this study. The mean follow-up period was 5 years. Evaluation included measurement of wrist range of motion, assessment of pain, and evaluation of radiographic parameters. The Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand score was used to determine the functional outcome after the excision. RESULTS: Before surgery all but 1 patient reported pain. After surgery 2 patients presented with mild pain during strenuous activity. Mean wrist flexion and extension increased significantly, by 23 degrees and 29 degrees, respectively. The postoperative Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand score was 25 +/- 19 points. There was a significant increase in the radiolunate angle, indicating dorsal intercalated segment instability deformity in 6 patients. CONCLUSIONS: Scaphoid distal pole excision remains a valuable treatment option for patients for whom multiple attempts at union have failed previously and who have no associated complete scapholunate ligament tears. TYPE OF STUDY/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic, Level IV.     

Treatment of scaphoid non-unions of the proximal third with conventional bone grafting and mini-Herbert screws: an analysis of clinical and radiological results

This study assessed the clinical and radiological outcomes after treatment of scaphoid non-union of the proximal third by non-vascularised bone grafts and stabilisation by Mini-Herbert Screws from a dorsal approach. Thirty-one patients, one woman and 30 men, were reviewed retrospectively at a mean of 42 (12-77) months. All patients received pre- and postoperative CT scans to assess bone union. In addition to demographic data, the range of motion, grip strength, DASH score, Krimmer score, Mayo wrist score and radiological parameters (carpal height, scapholunate and radiolunate angles) were recorded. Bone union was achieved in 21 patients. The average DASH score in patients with bone union was 12 and that in patients with persistent non-union it was 30. No progression into carpal collapse or increase of scapholunate angles was detected. Our study demonstrates that acceptable union rates can be achieved with non-vascularised bone grafts, and this technique compares favourably with other reports in the literature.     

Distal scaphoid resection arthroplasty for the treatment of degenerative arthritis secondary to scaphoid nonunion

Nineteen patients with chronic scaphoid nonunion and associated degenerative arthritis between the distal fragment and the radial styloid were treated by resection of the distal fragment. All patients had a dorsal intercalated segment instability wrist collapse pattern with an average radiolunate angle of -32 degrees and a 10% reduction in the carpal height, both of which changed minimally during the follow-up period. The duration of the nonunion averaged 12 years and the follow-up period averaged 49 months. Range of motion improved 85% and grip improved 134%. Thirteen of the patients experienced complete pain relief. One patient required additional surgery and elected wrist arthrodesis. Resection of the distal fragment is not recommended for patients with capitolunate arthritis. Two of the 4 patients with capitolunate arthritis had persistent symptoms; 3 had progressive degenerative changes.     

Total volar extrusion of the lunate and scaphoid proximal pole with concurrent scapholunate dissociation

This article describes a case of a 24-year-old man with a total volar extrusion of the lunate and scaphoid proximal pole with concurrent scapholunate dissociation. The viability of the lunate and the proximal pole of the scaphoid are at high risk in this type of injury. Scaphoid nonunion, avascular necrosis of the lunate and proximal pole of the scaphoid, and carpal instability are inevitable unless the blood supply is restored. Thus, proximal row carpectomy at injury may be an acceptable option to avoid these complications and late sequelae, including chronic wrist pain and dysfunction. However, the authors attempted accurate reduction of the extruded bones and internal fixation.Final radiographs and magnetic resonance imaging 12 years postoperatively showed healing without avascular necrosis. Carpal indices involving the scapholunate angle, radiolunate angle, and carpal height ratio were similar in both wrists without evidence of carpal instability or collapse. Range of motion and grip power were 75% and 76%, respectively, compared with those of the uninjured wrist. Clinical scores showed good results, and the patient reported no pain during activities of daily living and was satisfied with his surgical results. Open reduction and internal fixation can be a viable option in this rare pattern of injury.     

Radiolunate arthrodesis in rheumatoid wrist--the modified Chamay technique with broadening of indications

AIM: Radiolunate arthrodesis (RLA) has become an established surgical technique for stabilising wrists destroyed by RA. Our modified surgical technique with special osteosynthesis material has enabled the spectrum of indications to be expanded to include stage IV a--sagittal instability. METHOD: 44 radiolunate arthrodeses were carried out from 10.96 to 6.98. 19 (43.2%) satisfied the criteria for correction RLA with correction of sagittal instability. All (100%) of the 19 radiolunate arthrodeses were included in a follow-up examination, and all were examined clinically and radiologically at specified intervals. The mean follow-up is 22.8 months. RESULTS: Correction of the lunate drift in the sagittal plane was successful. The radiolunate angle was reduced from a mean 23.7 degrees before surgery to 9.3 degrees afterwards. The lunate drift in the frontal plane, which is shown by the ulnar translation index (UTI) was corrected from an average of 0.35 before surgery to 0.30 afterwards. Restoration of the carpal height by bone grafting from a mean preoperative CHI of 0.47 to 0.50 after surgery was achieved. We discovered one failure, thus the consolidation rate dropped to 94.7%. CONCLUSION: Since the capitate is the centre of rotation and movement at the wrist, a stable central pivot is essential, and correction of sagittal instability is particularly important. This demand can also be met by our modified radiolunate arthrodesis.     

Der posttraumatische karpale Kollaps Verlauf und Therapiekonzept

Significant progress has been made in the understanding of carpal kinematics and posttraumatic disorders of the wrist. The importance of stabilization of the scaphoid is well known. More and more ligament injuries of the proximal carpal row have been diagnosed in cases of severe arthrotic changes. Long-standing scaphoid nounion or scapholunate ligament injuries can lead to progressive carpal collapse due to a break of the continuity of the proximal carpal row. SLAC-wrist (scapholunate advanced collapse) and SNAC-wrist (scaphoid nonunion advanced collapse) after missed fusion of scaphoid fractures should be differentiated. Severity of degenerative changes is classified into three stages. Salvage procedures preserving wrist mobility, like midcarpal fusion, are preferable to total wrist fusion because of the functional benefit. With complete excision of the scaphoid and fusion of the midcarpal joint, all arthritic joint surfaces are eliminated and motion is preserved in the radiolunate joint which is usually spared of degenerative changes.     

桡骨远端骨折对腕关节稳定性的影响

目的研究各型桡骨远端骨折导致的腕关节不稳手术与非手术治疗的临床疗效及对腕关节稳定性的影响。方法1999年1月至2006年9月桡骨远端骨折患者200例,采用AO分型,标准腕关节正侧位片测量桡月角、舟月角、桡骨远端长度、关节面落差、舟月近远侧间距。手法复位石膏外固定患者和桡骨远端切开复位内固定治疗患者进行比较,采用改良Gartland和Werley评分标准评定腕关节功能恢复情况,并进行统计学分析。结果临床平均随访时间5年2个月,结果发现舟月分离、背屈不稳、掌屈不稳、背侧偏移和掌侧偏移5种腕关节不稳;优良率为78％。桡骨远端长度缩短≥2．5mm与〈2．5mm的桡骨远端骨折患者腕关节不稳发生率比较,Fisher确切概率P〈0．01;桡骨远端关节面的落差≥2mm与〈2mm的桡骨远端骨折患者腕关节不稳发生率比较,Fisher确切概率P〈0．01。结论桡骨远端骨折对桡腕关节面、桡骨远端长度、掌倾角的恢复与患者的疗效密切相关,腕关节的稳定性依赖于骨性结构和周围韧带的完整性,腕关节不稳将严重影响腕关节功能。对于严重关节内的骨折应手术治疗解剖复位。     

Does three-dimensional computer simulation improve results of scaphoid nonunion surgery?

The purpose of this study was to clarify the effectiveness of the three-dimensional computer simulations in scaphoid nonunion surgery. Seven consecutive clinical patients with scaphoid nonunion at the middle third comprised the study group. Surface models of the scaphoid were constructed on the computer using computed tomography data of the bilateral wrists in neutral position. The distal and proximal fragments of the nonunion model were matched to the mirror image of the contralateral scaphoid model. The rotation of the distal fragment relative to the proximal fragment was calculated, and reduction of the displaced fragment of the scaphoid nonunion was simulated. Similarly, the estimated bone defect and the appropriate site and direction of the screw insertion were simulated. Full-sized hard models of the bone, including a model with simulated reduction and screw insertion, then were made using stereolithography based on the computer data. In the actual surgery, reduction, bone grafting, and screw insertion were achieved using the hard models as guides. All the patients obtained solid bone fusion and substantial clinical improvement with normalized scapholunate and radiolunate angles after surgery. Three-dimensional computer simulations were found as useful for accurate correction of scaphoid nonunions and proper screw placement, which consequently leads to good clinical results.     

Acutrak无头加压空心螺钉治疗舟骨骨折不愈合

目的：探讨Acutrak无头加压空心螺钉治疗舟骨骨折不愈合的早期疗效。方法：自2008年1月至2011年7月共收治21例舟骨骨折不愈合患者,男18例,女3例,平均年龄（23.6±4.6）岁。右侧12例,左侧9例。根据Herbert-Fisher分型：D1型10例,D2型7例,D3型3例,D4型1例。受伤至手术时间（12.4±2.7）个月。所有患者采用Acutrak无头加压空心螺钉固定,其中6例行2枚螺钉固定,15例行1枚螺钉固定;7例固定同时行Matti-Russe植骨。测量手术前后腕骨高度、舟骨指数及舟月角变化。记录腕关节活动范围及握力,并采用PRWE评分评定手术效果。结果：21例平均随访（21.3±3.6）个月。骨折均影像学愈合,平均愈合时间（13.3±2.4）周。无明显围手术期并发症发生。术后舟骨指数及舟月角分别为0.69±0.10和（44.3±8.2）°,较术前的0.61±0.13和（59.4±6.8）°明显改善（P<0.05）.握力显着提高,疼痛明显缓解。术后PRWE评分高于术前（76.1±5.2 vs 45.2±4.7,P<0.05）.21例术后均返回原工作岗位,平均时间（6.0±1.1）个月。结论：对于舟骨骨折不愈合,Acutrak无头加压空心螺钉固定能达到舟骨解剖复位,术后愈合率高,腕关节功能恢复较好,早期疗效满意。