Comparison of collared and collarless femoral components in primary uncemented total hip arthroplasty

Two hundred three consecutive primary uncemented total hip arthroplasties were prospectively randomized using collared and collarless versions of an identical titanium stem. Identical 28-mm titanium heads were implanted in all cases. One hundred three collared hips were compared with 100 collarless hips. Follow-up periods avereraged 45.7 months in both groups. Intraoperative, early, and late complications were similar. Hip scores, including thigh pain, at final follow-up visit were also similar. No significant differences were noted in acetabular or femoral radiolucencies, subsidence, osteolysis, or proximal femoral remodeling. At 5 years, more collarless stems revealed pedestal formation (57.1% vs 33.9%). The presence of a collar had no effect on the adequacy of fixation, proximal femoral osteopenia, or clinical scores at 5 years.     

Does a collar improve the immediate stability of uncemented femoral hip stems in total hip arthroplasty? A bilateral comparative cadaver study

The aim of this study was to compare the immediate stability of collared vs collarless uncemented femoral stems in total hip arthroplasty. A bilateral comparative study of 20 cadavers (40 hips: 20 collarless, 20 collared) was performed. Forces in the vertical and horizontal planes required to initiate subsidence of femoral stem and subsequent femoral fracture were measured. In vertical plane, subsidence began at an average force of 3129 ± 494 N for collarless stems and 6283 ± 3584 N for collared stems (P = .02). Fracture occurred at a significantly higher force for collared stems (P = <.001). In horizontal plane, subsidence began at an average force of 540 ± 170 N for collarless stems and 678 ± 206 N for collared stems (P = .01). Fracture occurred at a significantly higher force for collared stems (P = .005). Collared uncemented stems have significantly greater immediate stability than collarless. They are able to withstand greater vertical and horizontal forces before the initiation of subsidence and subsequent fracture.     

Mid-term results of Exeter vs Endurance cemented stems

The mid-term results are reported of 2 uniquely different cemented stems implanted and followed prospectively by a single surgeon. The highly polished, collarless, tapered Exeter stem and the Endurance stem, a collared, roughened, satin finished stem, were inserted through a lateral approach using third-generation cement techniques. A total of 118 hips with the Exeter stem with an average follow-up of 7.25 years and 34 hips with the Endurance stem with an average follow-up of 4.57 years are included in the study. The Exeter patients had no revisions for aseptic loosening (0%) of the femoral stem. In contrast, the Endurance patients had 5 revisions and 2 impending revisions for aseptic loosening (20.5%) of the femoral stem with an average time to failure of 3.72 years. The excellent mid-term results of the Exeter stem support its ongoing use. By contrast, because of the poor early results of this modern cemented Endurance stem design, it is no longer used at our institution.     

Collar versus collarless cemented HD-II femoral prostheses

A randomized prospective study was done in 1982 to evaluate the effect of a collar on the cemented femoral component. During a 2-year period, 84 patients were enrolled to receive a collared (44 hips) or a collarless (40 hips) HD-II femoral component at the time of their primary total hip arthroplasty. Three patients were lost to followup, two patients were excluded because of randomization errors, six patients had good clinical results but refused followup, and 30 patients had died. The 43 surviving patients (collar 24, collarless 19) had radiographic and clinical followups at an average of 9.6 years (range, 61-143 months). Harris hip scores were similar, with an average of 89 in the collared group and 78 in the collarless group. There were no differences in the incidence or magnitude of pain between the patients receiving a collared or collarless femoral component. The Kaplan-Meier survivorship analysis predicted an overall survival rate free of revision of 86% at 10 years. There were no statistically significant differences in survival rates between the two groups.     

Cemented collarless (exeter-CPT) versus cementless collarless (PCA) femoral components: A 2- to 14-year follow-up evaluation

The purpose of this study was to compare the intermediate results of total hip arthroplasty with a cemented, collarless, femoral prosthesis design (Exeter, Howmedica, Middlesex, UK and CPT, Zimmer, Warsaw, IN) with those of a cementless, collarless, porous-coated femoral component (PCA, Howmedica). A total of 151 hips in 128 patients were reviewed. In the cemented group, 85 Exeter-CPT prostheses were used in 71 patients with an average follow-up period of 6.5 years. In the uncemented group, 66 PCA prostheses were placed in 57 patients with an average follow-up period of 7 years. Harrington hip scores improved from 50.1 to 80.7 for the PGA group and from 49.5 to 87.3 for the Exeter-CPT group. The patient satisfaction rates were 89 and 96%, respectively. Sixty-eight patients with Exeter or CPT prostheses had excellent function and no significant thigh pain after 2 years. One Exeter stem was revised 10 years after the primary surgery because of localized osteolysis due to cement defect. Two Exeter sockets were revised because of aseptic loosening. In the PCA group, the incidence of thigh pain that persisted beyond 2 years was 39.4%, and there were high incidences of distal cortical hypertrophy (66.6%) and bead loosening (45.5%). Sixteen hips were revised for aseptic stem loosening, uncontrollable thight pain, or stem fracture (1 hip), and seven were revised because of migration and aseptic loosening of the socket. The cementless ingrowth stems failed earlier (around 5 years), whereas the cemented stems continued to perform well past 14 years. In this study, the cemented, collarless, collarless, porous-coated anatomic design at an average follow-up period of 7 years (range, 2–14 years).     

Alterations in femoral strain,micromotion, cortical geometry,cortical porosity,and bony ingrowth in uncemented collared and collarless prostheses in the dog

The effects of a collared femoral endoprosthesis in uncemented total hip arthroplasty were evaluated in 12 dogs. This experimental study compared the biomechanic and histologic responses between collared and collarless femoral prostheses 4 months after implantation. Implant stability (micromotion) and cortical surface strain were evaluated immediately and 4 months after implantation in a simulated postoperative condition, whereas bone ingrowth, cortical porosity, and cortical remodeling were assessed after 4 months only. There were no significant differences in implant stability or cortical surface strains when the collared and collarless groups were compared acutely or after 4 months (P > .05). There were also no significant differences in percent fill, bony ingrowth, or cortical geometry after 4 months (P > .05). There was a significant increase in cortical porosity measured from the proximal femur after 4 months for both the collared (P = .0002) and collarless groups (P = .009) and when both groups were compared (collarless, 8.2% and collared, 5.8%; P = .03). The results suggest that a collar may be beneficial in decreasing the cortical remodeling that occurs in the proximal femoral cortex after implantation of an uncemented total hip arthroplasty.     

Mid-term results and migration behaviour of a ti-alloy cemented stem

Between 1991 and 1994, 147 patients (154 hips) underwent a primary cemented total hip replacement using the Ultima ti-alloy, collarless, double-tapered stem and a UHMWPE cup. The average age at operation was 66.4 years. Ninety-one patients (97 hips) were available for review with an average follow-up of 76 months. The Harris hip score had improved from pre-operative average of 43.1 (12.5-65.0) to the latest score of 88.9 (67.5-100). There were 11 revisions in total, eight of which were for aseptic stem loosening. The results of Kaplan-Meier survival analysis, based on stem revision for aseptic loosening as an end-point, was 92% at 8 years. Early stem migration analysis at 2 years was possible in 114 cases using digitised radiographs analysed by the EBRA method. Sixty-three stems had not migrated and 35 migrated less than 2 mm with only one of these ending in failure. Sixteen stems showed early migration of more than 2 mm and five of these failed. Early stem migration is predictive of stem failure. Osteolytic lesions occurred in 12 femurs and four of these stems failed.     

Collarless polished tapered stem: clinical and radiological results at a minimum of ten years' follow-up

We retrospectively reviewed 175 patients (191 hips) who had undergone primary cemented total hip replacement between November 1992 and November 1995 using a collarless polished double-tapered femoral component after a minimum of ten years (mean 11.08; 10 to 12.8). All stems were implanted using contemporary cementing techniques with a distal cement restrictor, pressurised lavage, retrograde cementing with a gun and proximal pressurisation. Clinical outcome was assessed using the Harris Hip score. Radiological analysis was performed on calibrated plain radiographs taken in two planes. Complete radiological data on 110 patients (120 hips) and clinical follow-up on all the surviving 111 patients (122 hips) was available. The fate of all the hips was known. At final follow-up, the mean Harris Hip score was 86 (47 to 100), and 87 of 116 patients (75%) had good or excellent scores. Survival with revision of the stem for aseptic loosening as the endpoint was 100%; and survival with revision of the stem for any reason was 95.9% (95% confidence interval 87.8 to 96.8) at ten years. All the stems subsided vertically at the stem-cement interface in a predictable pattern, at an overall mean rate of 0.18 mm per year (0.02 to 2.16), but with a mean rate of 0.80 mm (0.02 to 2.5) during the first year. The mean total subsidence was 1.95 mm (0.21 to 24). Only three stems loosened at the cement-bone interface. There was excellent preservation of proximal femoral bone stock. There was a high incidence of Brooker III and IV heterotopic ossification affecting 25 patients (22%). The collarless polished tapered stem has an excellent clinical and radiological outcome at a minimum of ten years' follow-up. The pattern and magnitude of subsidence of the stem within the cement mantle occurred in a predictable pattern, consistent with the design philosophy.     

Impaction bone grafting for total hip revision

We used impaction bone grafting for total hip revision on 26 hips in 25 patients. Average patient age was 68 (34-89) years, and average duration from last surgery was 9 years. In all cases morselized allograft bone was used for the graft, and the femoral component was a collarless, polished, tapered stem. Average duration of surgery was 2.4 h, intraoperative blood loss 600 cc, blood replacement 2.4 units, and acute-care hospital stay 5 days. Complications were varus placement of the stem in two patients and postoperative development of varus in one, one intraoperative and three postoperative femoral fractures, and one postoperative dislocation. Average subsidence was 0.6 cm. We believe that most, if not all, of these complications could have been prevented.     

Total hip arthroplasty with a collarless, tapered, fiber metal proximally coated femoral stem: minimum 5-year follow-up

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the midterm results, osteointegration potential, and implant-related complications of a cementless, collarless, proximally coated, distally tapered femoral hip prosthesis. The clinical and radiographic results for 129 hips in 116 patients after total hip arthroplasty with a Fiber Metal Taper (Zimmer, Inc ,Warsaw, Ind) femoral stem are reported. One hundred twenty-two (95%) hips were available for the minimum of 5 years clinical and radiographic follow-up. The mean duration of follow-up was 81 months (range, 60-104 months). The mean Harris hip score improved from 44 to 92 at the most recent follow-up. All femoral components were clinically stable with radiographic evidence of bone ingrowth. There has been no evidence of subsidence greater than 2 mm, no significant thigh pain, and no femoral revisions for any reason. Total hip arthroplasty with the Fiber Metal Taper stem demonstrates good clinical and radiographic results at midterm follow-up.     

Clinical outcome and quantitative evaluation of periprosthetic bone-remodeling of an uncemented femoral component with taper design. A prospective study

The rationale of uncemented taper stems is based on fixation in the proximal portion of the femoral diaphysis, a self-locking principle, and a low modulus of elasticity. The aim of this study was to evaluate a collarless femoral component designed to be a three-dimensional taper for press-fit insertion with regard to clinical outcome, efficacy of fixation, incidence of osteolysis, and periprosthetic bone-remodeling. The first 48 consecutive patients (50 hips) with osteoarthritis who had had primary total hip arthroplasty using the Cerafit Multicone stem and the Cerafit Triradius-M press-fit cup with alumina-alumina pairing (Ceraver Osteal, Paris, France) were followed-up for a mean of 2.3 years (2 to 2.5 years). The mean age of patients at index operations was 52.5 years. Current criteria were used for clinical and radiological assessment. Quantitative evaluation of periprosthetic bone-remodeling was prospectively assessed using computed tomography. Clinical and radiological follow-up was obtained in all hips. Forty-nine hips (98%) were clinically rated good or excellent, one hip (2%) was rated fair, owing to a persisting limp. The mean preoperative Harris Hip Score was rated 62, and it has improved to 93.5 at the time of follow-up. One hip (2%) had marked postoperative thigh pain. This pain had disappeared at 3-month follow-up. All stems showed radiological signs of stable fixation by bone ingrowth. No stem required revision. Thirty-four hips (68%) had either no change in femoral bone density or only patchy loss of bone density isolated to Gruen zones 1 and 7. Sixteen hips (32%) had some reduction of bone density isolated to zone 1. Radiolucencies without progression were found in zones 1 and 7 in 3 hips (6%), and in zone 1 alone in 3 other hips (6%). A slight cortical hypertrophy was seen in 3 hips (6%). Twenty-three hips (46%) developed radiographic appearance of bone apposition at the stem tip as partial pedestal (19 hips) and as complete pedestal (4 hips). No signs of cup loosening were detected at follow-up. Twenty-four patients (25 hips) were eligible for computed tomography. The mean decrease of the overall bone mineral density in the metaphyseal portion of the femur one year after insertion of the stem was rated 15.4%, and the mean decrease of the cortical bone mineral density was rated 17.2%. On the other hand, a mean decrease of the cortical bone mineral density of less than 5% was observed in the diaphyseal portion of the femur around the implant. The clinical and radiological results of the Cerafit Multicone stem at a mean follow-up of 2.3 years are very promising and do not contrast with those achieved using other uncemented stems with tapered design. Furthermore, results of quantitative evaluation of periprosthetic bone-remodeling were considered satisfactory favourably with others reported in the literature using stems inserted without cemented.     

The Long-Term Results of Total Hip Arthroplasty With a Cemented β-Titanium Stem

BackgroundWe report on the outcomes of a double-tapered cemented stem made of β-titanium alloys (Ti-15Mo-5Zr-3Al) at least 10 years after total hip arthroplasty.MethodsWe retrospectively analyzed 148 consecutive, primary total hip arthroplasties using this stem performed in 130 patients between January 2004 and August 2008. The patients’ mean age was 59.6 years (range, 24-79). Implant survival was evaluated using Kaplan-Meier curves with the primary end point being stem revision for any reason and the secondary end point being stem revision for aseptic stem loosening. We also clinically and radiologically followed 140 hips (in 123 patients) for an average of 12.2 years (range, 10-15).ResultsThe only revisions were for 2 stems with deep infection. Ten-year survival was 99.3% (95% confidence interval, 95.4%-99.9%) and 100% for the primary and secondary end point, respectively. The mean Japanese Orthopaedic Association hip score improved from 51.4 preoperatively to 88.7 at the last follow-up. Radiolucent lines at the stem-cement interface were seen in 14 hips (10.0%). None of the hips met the criteria of radiological stem loosening. Nineteen stems (13.6%) subsided by around 1 mm between 2 and 8 years after surgery. Distal femoral cortical hypertrophy occurred in 24 hips (17.0%), mostly with valgus alignment.ConclusionThe clinical outcomes of the femoral stems were excellent with survival at 10 years. Stem subsidence and distal femoral cortical hypertrophy did not affect the results. Long-term use of β-titanium alloy stems is safe and effective.     

Total hip arthroplasty with a cemented, polished, collared femoral stem and a cementless acetabular component. A follow-up study at a minimum of ten years

BACKGROUND: Recent studies have suggested that cemented femoral components with a polished surface may provide superior long-term fixation when compared with femoral components with a roughened surface. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the results of total hip arthroplasty with a cemented femoral component with a polished surface finish and compare them with the results of total hip arthroplasty performed with a similar design of cemented femoral component with a rougher surface finish. METHODS: We retrospectively reviewed a consecutive group of 132 patients (149 hips) in whom primary total hip arthroplasty had been performed by one surgeon using a cemented collared femoral component with a polished (0.1-microm Ra) surface finish and a cementless acetabular component. Ninety-eight patients (115 hips) were followed for a minimum of ten years. We compared the survivorship of this prosthesis with that of a femoral component of similar design but with rougher surfaces (matte or grit-blasted). RESULTS: No polished stems were revised because of aseptic loosening or demonstrated radiographic evidence of loosening; however, eight hips (5.4%) with a polished stem demonstrated osteolysis distal to the greater or lesser tro-chanter. In contrast, six stems (2.0%) with a matte surface finish of 0.8-microm Ra were revised because of aseptic loosening, and an additional five stems were seen to be loose radiographically. Eleven stems (9.2%) with a grit-blasted surface finish of 2.1-microm Ra were revised because of aseptic loosening, and an additional four stems were seen to be loose radiographically. The difference in the prevalence of revision due to aseptic loosening between the group with the 0.1-microm Ra surface and the group with the 2.1-microm Ra surface was significant (p = 0.001), as was the difference between the prevalence of revision due to aseptic loosening between the group with the 0.8-microm Ra surface and the group with the 2.1-microm Ra surface (p = 0.001). No cups were revised because of aseptic loosening, and one hip had radiographic signs of acetabular loosening. CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrated excellent durability of a prosthesis consisting of a cemented, collared, polished femoral component and a cementless acetabular component. While no hips were revised because of aseptic loosening, distal femoral osteolysis was observed in eight hips (5.4%), a higher prevalence than has been reported by others after similar durations of follow-up of tapered, collarless, polished femoral components.     

Femoral revision with a fluted, tapered, modular stem seventy patients followed for a mean of 3.9 years

Fluted tapered revision femoral stems have been used successfully in Europe. Modularity makes these implants more versatile, but outcomes of modular designs have not been reported. We report a retrospective review of 70 such stems with a mean follow-up of 47 months. Combined metaphyseal/diaphyseal bone loss was present preoperatively in 36 (51%) of 70 hips. Three hips (4.3%) were re-revised or in need of re-revision, and worst-case survival was 87%. The mean postoperative patient-assessed Oxford Hip Score was 21.1. Restoration of proximal bone was noted in 56%. Complications included mean subsidence of 9.9 mm, dislocation in 7 (10%) of 70 hips, and fracture or cortical perforation in 17 (24.2%) of 70. These results are equivalent to, or better than, reported results of other types of cementless revision femoral stems.     

Cement-within-cement stem exchange using the collarless polished double-taper stem

The clinical and radiographic outcomes of the cement-within-cement femoral stem exchange technique at revision hip arthroplasty were determined. Twenty-three revisions with a collarless polished double-taper stem design were prospectively monitored at up to 12 years. The most common indications for revision were recurrent dislocation and acetabular revision. Radiographic stem subsidence was measured by the Ein Bild Röentgen Analyse method. There was no stem re-revision and no radiographic loosening. Stem within cement subsidence, an intentional design feature of this stem, averaged 0.8 mm (range, 0-2 mm). The average subsidence was similar to that in primary hip arthroplasty. The excellent long-term results of cemented collarless polished taper stems for primary and revision hip arthroplasty can be extended even further by cement-within-cement exchange, which preserves the femur.     

Ten-year survival of the MS-30 matt-surfaced cemented stem

The Morscher-Spotorno (MS-30) femoral stem is a stainless-steel, straight, three-dimensionally tapered, collarless implant for cemented fixation in total hip replacement.We report the results at ten years of a consecutive series of 124 total hip replacements in 121 patients with the matt-surfaced MS-30 stem and an alumina ceramic head of 28-mm diameter. All the stems were fixed with Palacos bone cement with gentamicin using a modern cementing technique. They were combined with an uncemented, press-fit cup. The mean period of observation was 10.2 years (8.3 to 12.1) and no patient was lost to follow-up. Twenty-seven patients (22%) died with the implant in situ. Nine could only be interviewed by telephone. We included 85 patients with 88 hips in the clinical and radiological follow-up examinations.None of the stems or cups had been revised. The Harris hip score was excellent or good in 97% (85 hips) and moderate in 3% (three hips). Radiologically, six hips (6.8%) had osteolysis adjacent to the stem, mostly in Gruen zone 7. Twenty (22.7%) showed one or more radiolucent lines. Twenty-two stems (25%) had subsided by 2 mm to 5 mm. In these cases two showed osteolysis (9.1%) with subsidence and four without (6.1%). Radiolucent lines were seen in seven with migration (31.8%) and in 13 without (19.7%). No infections and no acetabular osteolysis were observed.The clinical results were excellent with survivorship after ten years of 100% and only a slightly statistically non-significant higher rate of osteolysis and radiolucency in cases of subsidence.     

Catastrophic failure of cementless total hip arthroplasty using a femoral component without surface coating

Consecutive series of 90 hips that had had a primary cementless arthroplasty with use of straight collarless stems between January 1988 and September 1992 were reviewed. Twenty-eight hips with Omnifit Normalized Stems (Fit-N) and 45 hips with Omniflex Normalized Stems (Flex-N) without porous coatings were compared clinically and radiographically with 17 hips with Omnifit Microstructured Stems (Fit-M) with porous coating. The average follow-up periods for the 3 stems were 97 months, 73 months, and 93 months. Revision was performed or awaited in 9 cases (32.1%) in the Fit-N group, 18 cases (40.0%) in the Flex-N group, and 1 case (5.8%) in the Fit-M group. The average annual subsidence was 0.62 mm/y, 0.73 mm/y, and 0.17 mm/y. Osteolysis of more than 3 mm occurred in 28.6%, 37.8%, and 23.5%. Fit-N stems and Flex-N stems without porous coatings are not appropriate for cementless total hip arthroplasty.     

Impact of Femoral Stem Design on Failure After Anterior Approach Total Hip Arthroplasty

Background

An increased rate of complications related to femoral component failure has been described with less invasive total hip arthroplasty (THA). This study evaluated the incidence of femoral complications associated with the direct anterior approach for THA.

Impaction allograft with cement for the revision of the femoral component. A minimum 39-month follow-up study with the use of the Exeter stem in Asian hips

We report the results of impaction bone grafting of the femoral side in revision total hip arthroplasty in Asian hips (South Korean patients) in which the surgery was performed with the use of the Exeter stem. The minimum follow-up was 39 months (mean, 48.4; range, 39-66). There was subsidence of the cement-graft interface (<1 mm) in three hips (5%), of the stem-cement interface (<1 mm) in 12 hips (21%) and of the stem-cement interface (1-2 mm) in 14 hips (25%). Five hips (9%) developed intraoperative femoral fracture and two hips (4%) femoral perforation in revision. The complications of femoral fracture and subsidence did not have an adverse effect on the final clinical outcomes. The impaction of fresh-frozen allograft and use of a cemented, polished, tapered stem (Exeter stem) were also successful with good clinical and radiographic outcomes in our study of Asian hips (South Korean patients). However, we used smaller stems than the usual ones used for Western patients because of the smaller femur sizes.