Update on eustachian tube dysfunction and the patulous eustachian tube

PURPOSE OF REVIEW: The purpose of this review is to summarize the recent knowledge on eustachian tube dysfunction and the patulous eustachian tube. RECENT FINDINGS: A clinically useful test for eustachian tube function is still lacking. Narrowing of the isthmus alone was demonstrated to be an insufficient cause of otitis media. Inflammatory mediators identified within the eustachian tube and middle ear cells were causally linked with otitis media with effusion. Increasing evidence was found that allergic disease and reflux may be two of the most important contributors of tubal inflammation causing otitis media with effusion. The adenoid size and proximity to the torus tubaris may also be important in considering which patients with persistent otitis media with effusion may benefit from adenoidectomy. Computed tomography scan has documented loss of soft tissue within the cartilaginous eustachian tube in patients with patulous eustachian tubes. An endoscopic approach to seal the tubal lumen has been found to be effective in relieving patulous symptoms. SUMMARY: These studies suggest that allergic rhinitis and gastroesophageal reflux should be investigated in patients with eustachian tube dysfunction. Adenoidectomy should also be considered in patients who have adenoids that obstruct the torus tubaris. Patients with a patulous eustachian tube may benefit from an endoscopic closure. Further research is needed to identify a clinically useful test for eustachian tube dysfunction.     

Eustachian tube function in patients with eosinophilic otitis media associated with bronchial asthma evaluated by sonotubometry

OBJECTIVE: To determine eustachian tube function in patients with asthma and with or without eosinophilic otitis media (EOM), a new middle ear disease entity with a highly viscous middle ear effusion containing many eosinophils and usually associated with bronchial asthma. One of the most important causes of otitis media (OM) is eustachian tube dysfunction. DESIGN: Retrospective case review. SETTING: A referral center. PATIENTS: Twenty patients with EOM and patients with asthma but without OM. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: We studied eustachian tube function using sonotubometry and a questionnaire. Sonotubometry was also performed on 13 control patients with chronic otitis media (COM) and 7 normal controls. RESULTS: The tubal opening duration was significantly longer in patients with EOM than in patients with asthma but without OM, controls with COM, and normal controls, indicating the presence of patulous eustachian tubes in patients with EOM. Responses to the questionnaire also supported the presence of patulous eustachian tubes in the patients with EOM. CONCLUSIONS: The presence of a patulous eustachian tube may be a major cause of EOM in patients with bronchial asthma. In patients with asthma who have a helper T-cell 2-dominant predisposition, a patulous eustachian tube easily allows the entry of antigenic materials into the middle ear, causing eosinophil-dominant inflammation.     

Clinical characteristics of so called eosinophilic otitis media.

OBJECTIVE: Although "eosinophilic otitis media" is not as uncommon a condition as was previously believed, its cause and pathogenesis are not yet fully understood. The purpose of this study was to describe the clinical characteristics in patients with "eosinophilic otitis media" to clarify its pathogenesis. METHODS: Seven adult patients with persistent and intractable otitis media with viscous middle ear effusion containing many eosinophils, who were also under treatment for bronchial asthma, were studied. The following examinations were conducted: nasopharyngeal endoscopy, pure-tone audiometry, eustachian tube function test, temporal bone CT scan, blood analysis, bacterial and fungal culture of middle ear effusion, histological study of the middle ear and nasal specimens, and measurement of eosinophilic cationic protein (ECP) in middle ear effusion. RESULTS: Some patients had persistent perforation with papillomatous granulation tissue arising from the mesotympanic mucosa, and all the patients had nasal polyposis. The pure-tone audiometry showed the mixed-type of hearing loss in all the patients, and the hearing level deteriorated progressively during the course in some patients. The eustachian tube function was not always poor but was patulous in some cases. The most severely diseased areas were in the eustachian tube and mesotympanum by temporal bone CT images. All the seven patients had the high levels of total serum IgE, but the RAST scores were negative in three patients and low grade in three patients. The accumulation of eosinophils was observed in middle ear effusion, middle ear mucosa and nasal polyps, and the eosinophils were highly activated with degranulation. High level of ECP was also recovered from middle ear effusion. CONCLUSIONS: Active eosinophilic inflammation occurs in the entire respiratory tract, including the middle ear in these patients. From our present investigation, we propose the criteria and clinical characteristics of "eosinophilic otitis media".     

Histo-morphological changes of eustachian tube of guinea pigs with effusion after being treated by pulmonary surfactant]

OBJECTIVE: To study the effect of pulmonary surfactant on otitis media with effusion in guinea pigs to find a new way to manage otitis media with effusion. METHODS: Nonviable heat-killed pneumococci (HKP) solution was inoculated into the middle ear cavity in guinea pigs via a transeardrum approach to set up a model of otitis media with effusion in guinea pigs. Seven days after being injected with pulmonary surfactant (PS) by transeardrum approach, ABR threshold and histomorphological changes of eustachian tube mucosa of guinea pigs were examined by light microscopy and scanning microscopy. RESULTS: Five days following inoculation of HKB serous effusion were present in the middle ear cavity of guinea pigs, but disappearance of light cone. Response (mean +/- s) threshold raised from (14.0 +/- 3.1) dB to (45.0 +/- 5.7) dB. The eustachian tube mucosa was thickened and lined eosin-stained structureless matter over mucosa, while cilia of eustachian tube mucosa irregularly arranged. Seven days after being treated by PS, serous effusion of tympanum was reduced or disappeared, and response threshold decreased from (45.0 +/- 5.7) dB to (23.5 +/- 6.3) dB. There was significantly difference between them (P < 0.001). Eustachian tube mucosa was thinned, Cilia of eustachian tube mucosa regularly arranged to the nasopharynx. CONCLUSION: Pulmonary surfactant plays a important role in otitis media with effusion of guinea pigs.     

Ligation of eustachian tube for intractable patulous eustachian tube: a preliminary report

Pharyngeal orifice of the eustachian tube was ligated on ten patients, 15 ears with intractable patulous eustachian tube. While the eustachian tube orifice was observed by an endoscope inserted through the contralateral nostril, the orifice was ligated transnasally and/or transorally using instruments usually used in the endoscopic nasal surgery. Now 13–27 months after the surgery, the outcome was excellent (both symptoms and sonotubometry were normalized) in two ears, good (either symptoms or sonotubometry was improved) in seven ears, and unchanged in the remaining six ears. In one of the ears with an outcome of unchanged, the ligation was found to be spontaneously released soon after surgery, but the symptom was improved after the second operation 2.5 months after the first operation. Temporary otitis media with effusion was seen in one ear, mild inflammation around the ligated site also in one ear, but no other serious complication has been observed. Although further improvement in the surgical procedure and further discussion about its long-term outcome should be required, this procedure appeared to be one of the therapeutic options for intractable patulous eustachian tube.     

Tubal compliance--changes with age and in tubal malfunction

OBJECTIVE: It is known that eustachian tubal compliance has influence on the tubal function. We applied the direct measurement method to ascertain whether or not aging and tubal diseases are related to the compliance of the cartilaginous part of the eustachian tube. METHODS: We developed a method for directly measuring tubal compliance by inserting a balloon catheter, which is inflated with water, into the eustachian tube and comparing the change in balloon pressure with the balloon volume. This method is advantageous in that one can directly measure tubal compliance in the cartilaginous part of the eustachian tube. Using this method we examined tubal compliance in 16 normal young volunteer ears, 21 normal elderly volunteer ears, 11 elderly ears with patulous tube and 12 elderly ears with stenotic tube including otitis media with effusion. RESULTS: In adults the tubal compliance increases in value with age. Tubal compliance of the elderly patulous tube was significantly higher than that of the normal elderly one, on the other hand the compliance of the elderly stenotic tube was significantly lower than that of the normal one. CONCLUSION: Tubal compliance was considered to be changed with aging and influence of the patulous and stenotic tubes.     

分泌性中耳炎咽鼓管及鼓室黏膜的光镜及电镜观察

目的：探讨分泌性中耳炎的发病原因，为临床治疗提供理论依据。方法：通过微波烧灼双侧咽鼓管口，建立分泌性中耳炎动物模型。光镜观察比较咽鼓管管腔及黏一软骨膜和鼓室黏膜变化。电镜观察咽鼓管鼓室段暗颗粒分泌细胞及其表面活性物质样板层体的变化。结果：各组咽鼓管管腔通畅，咽鼓管黏一软骨膜不易受炎症浸润及负压影响。鼓室黏膜水肿、增生、炎性细胞浸润明显，暗颗粒细胞分泌功能受损，表面活性物质板层体结构明显减少或消失。结论：咽鼓管黏一软骨膜在分泌性中耳炎发病过程中起重要作用。表面活性物质减少与分泌性中耳炎的发生密切相关。     

Laser eustachian tuboplasty: a preliminary report

OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS: Surgical correction of eustachian tube dysfunction remains an elusive challenge. Repeat ventilation tube placement is often inadequate to prevent tympanic membrane and middle ear complications. Endoscopic analyses of eustachian tube dynamics have localized the site of primary pathophysiology to within the cartilaginous tube. The study investigated the feasibility, safety, and efficacy of a new endoluminal eustachian tube operation for the treatment of eustachian tube dysfunction. STUDY DESIGN: Prospective, institutional review board-approved surgical trial in a tertiary-care medical center. METHODS: Ten patients with more than 5 consecutive years of intractable otitis media with effusion recurring after two or more tympanostomy tube placements were treated with unilateral laser eustachian tuboplasty. Surgery was performed on an outpatient basis with the use of general anesthesia and combined both transnasal and transoral approaches. A 980-nm diode or argon laser was used to vaporize an appropriate amount of mucosa and cartilage on the posterior wall of the tubal lumen. Preoperative and postoperative dynamic video eustachian tube function analyses were compared. Outcome measures were presence or absence of middle ear effusion and impedance tympanograms. RESULTS: Five patients had at least 12 months of follow-up, and three of them had absence of any effusion (60%). Two patients had recurrence of their otitis media with effusion and required tympanostomy tubes again. Five patients had at least 6 months of follow-up, and four of them had absence of any effusion. The remaining patient had recurrence of otitis media with effusion and received a tympanostomy tube again. Overall results for all 10 patients after 6 months were 7 free of effusion (70%). There were no intraoperative complications. Postoperative complications were limited to minimal peritubal adhesions and one intranasal synechia. CONCLUSIONS: Preliminary results suggest that laser eustachian tuboplasty is safe and efficacious in the treatment of intractable eustachian tube dysfunction. Further study will be necessary to determine whether laser eustachian tuboplasty is a suitable alternative to repeated tympanostomy tube placement in selected patients.     

Pharyngeal ciliary activity in guinea pigs with otitis media

Summary The function of cilia present in the tubotympanum plays an important role in the pathogenesis and chronicity of otitis media with effusion (OME). We used a photoelectric method to examine the ciliary activity in the eustachian tube, in the central pharynx, as well as the nasal cavity of normal animals and animals with otitis media. In normal animals, the ciliary activity in the nasal cavity was not different from that in the eustachian tube. In some animals with otitis media, however, there was a significant difference between the ciliary activity in the nasal cavity and that in the eustachian tube. On the other hand, no significant differences were recognized in any given group of animals examined between the level of the ciliary activity in the central pharynx and that in the eustachian tube. Our findings show that the function of the cilia present in the pharynx is a valid index of that in the eustachian tube. Our study further indicates that it may be possible to clinically assess the ciliary activity in the pharyngeal mucosa biopsied from patients with OME to determine objectively the effects of medical treatments of the disease.     

Pharyngeal ciliary activity in guinea pigs with otitis media

The function of cilia present in the tubotympanum plays an important role in the pathogenesis and chronicity of otitis media with effusion (OME). We used a photoelectric method to examine the ciliary activity in the eustachian tube, in the central pharynx, as well as the nasal cavity of normal animals and animals with otitis media. In normal animals, the ciliary activity in the nasal cavity was not different from that in the eustachian tube. In some animals with otitis media, however, there was a significant difference between the ciliary activity in the nasal cavity and that in the eustachian tube. On the other hand, no significant differences were recognized in any given group of animals examined between the level of the ciliary activity in the central pharynx and that in the eustachian tube. Our findings show that the function of the cilia present in the pharynx is a valid index of that in the eustachian tube. Our study further indicates that it may be possible to clinically assess the ciliary activity in the pharyngeal mucosa biopsied from patients with OME to determine objectively the effects of medical treatments of the disease.     

First forty-eight hours of developing otitis media: an experimental study

The early inflammatory changes in the tympanic membrane were explored in 2 rat models. Acute otitis media was induced by instillation of Streptococcus pneumoniae type 3 into the middle ear cavity, and otitis media with effusion was induced by blockage of the eustachian tube. Otomicroscopic examination was performed before the rats were painlessly sacrificed at 3, 6, 9, 12, 18, 24, or 48 hours after initiation of the otitis media conditions. The tympanic membrane was studied by light and electron microscopy. Both acute otitis media and otitis media with effusion caused early inflammatory changes of the tympanic membrane, and the pars flaccida was the portion that reacted first. The inflammatory alterations were most pronounced in the acute otitis media model. The course of inflammation showed a bimodal pattern with an early deposition of a filamentous material with a band pattern, typical of fibrin. Despite a fluid-filled middle ear cavity, the inflammatory changes in the otitis media with effusion model were moderate, as was consistent with the clinical appearance of the tympanic membrane.     

Use of NiTi shape memory alloys in the eustachian tube to prevent and treat adhesive middle ear]

OBJECTIVE: To explore and assess the use of NiTi shape memory alloys in the eustachian tube to prevent and treat adhesive middle ear. METHODS: All preliminary study cases were divided into three groups (A: 56 cases of adhesive otitis media, B: 27 cases of otitis media with effusion, C: 52 cases without ear disease as control). The eustachian orifice in all cases was observed by endoscopy. Autopsy of Eustachian tube was done in two specimens. The NiTi shape memory alloys were then installed into the Eustachian tube to prevent and treat adhesive middle ear in 4 cases. The installer of NiTi shape memory alloys was designed by ourselves. RESULTS: The Eustachian orifice can be classified into three types: wide, narrow and fissured. They comprised of 20, 31 and 5 cases in group A, 9, 13 and 5 cases in group B and 45, 7 and 0 cases in group C, respectively. The differences among three groups were statistically significant (A, B vs C, chi 2 = 29.66, 25.44 respectively, P < 0.001), but the difference between A and B was not statistically significant (chi 2 = 1.59, P > 0.05). Two cases with adhesive otitis media gained good ventilation with Valsalva method and the audiometric improvement of 15-30 dB after the NiTi shape memory alloys installation. One of the two cases with otitis media with effusion gained A-B gap closure over 8 months, and the other still improved with ventilative tube removed. In all 4 cases, there was no any side-effect or signs of patulous Eustachian tube. CONCLUSION: Adhesive otitis media can be prevented and treated by using NiTi shape memory alloys without any side-effect, but more study is necessary.     

Transtympanic endoscopic findings in patients with otitis media with effusion

Using a fine, rigid endoscope (Olympus, SES-1711K), we examined the middle ear, including the tympanic orifice of the eustachian tube, of children with otitis media with effusion (OME) in its active stage (26 ears), in the convalescent stage (13 ears), and during treatment with ventilation tubes for 10 days to 6 months (five ears) through myringotomy with the patients under general anesthesia. Several color photographs of representative ears are shown. In the active stage of OME, edema (73.1%) and hyperemia (23.1%) were characteristic features of the middle ear mucosa, and normal mucosa was seen in only one ear (3.1%). The tympanic orifice of the eustachian tube, which could be examined in 12 ears, were stenosed with edema in four ears (33.3%) or plugged with effusion in three ears (25.0%) in this group. In the convalescent stage of OME, dilated vessels were most often seen (69.2%), but the rest of the patients had normal mucosa (30.8%) in the middle ear, and none of them had edema nor hyperemia. The tympanic orifice of the eustachian tube, which could be examined in five ears, was clearly patent in all the patients in this group. One ear that was treated with a ventilation tube for 1 month showed dilated vessels and less severe inflammation than did ears that were in the active stage of OME, and three ears that were treated for more than 3 months showed almost normal middle ear mucosa.     

Update on functional anatomy and pathology of human eustachian tube related to otitis media with effusion

New anatomic and histopathologic information regarding the eustachian tube and its surrounding structure as well as possible mechanisms of opening and closing function and dysfunction are discussed in this article. In the past two decades, much light has been shed on the relationship between anomalies of the eustachian tube and the pathogenesis of otitis media with effusion. Now that a technique for obtaining specimens for any histopathologic study that includes the temporal bone as well as the eustachian tube is available, it is hoped that, by harvesting and examining a large number of such specimens, more information will be gained about the relation between eustachian tube pathology and eustachian tube dysfunction, particularly as it relates to otitis media effusion. Only in this way can the clinical management of otitis media be improved.     

Effects of human middle ear effusions on the mucociliary system of the tubotympanum in the guinea pig

Effusion fluid resulting from otitis media contains a variety of inflammatory substances. This middle ear effusion (MEE) may be itself affect the mucosa of the tubotympanum and contribute to chronicity of the condition. The present study was designed to elucidate in vitro and in vivo effects of MEEs on the mucosa of the guinea pig tubotympanum. The results obtained demonstrated that the ciliary activity of the eustachian tube was reduced in the presence of human MEEs. This activity decreased to approximately 80% in the presence of serous MEE at 48 h and was 60% after exposure to mucoid MEE. Intratympanic inoculation of human MEEs resulted in accumulation of a serous effusion in the tympanic cavity. Histologic study of the tubotympanum in inoculated animals demonstrated mucociliary dysfunction as well as a general inflammatory process and increased vascular permeability. This damage was more prominent following inoculation with the mucoid MEEs. The ciliary depression and inflammation found in the tubotympanum suggest that the pathologic nature of MEEs may be, at least partially, responsible for the chronicity of otitis media.     

No effect of a nasal decongestant on eustachian tube function in children with ventilation tubes

OBJECTIVE: The aim of the study was to assess the effect of a topical decongestant on eustachian tube function in children with ventilation tubes because of persistent otitis media with effusion. STUDY DESIGN: A randomized, double-blinded, placebo-controlled study. METHODS: At the outpatient departments of a secondary referral hospital and a tertiary referral hospital, eustachian tube function was measured before and after intranasal administration of five drops of 0.05% xylometazoline hydrochloride or placebo in 80 randomly selected children with ventilation tubes because of otitis media with effusion. RESULTS: Xylometazoline nose drops had no effect on the ventilatory or the protective function of the eustachian tube. CONCLUSIONS: Topical decongestants do not have a positive effect on eustachian tube function in children. Therefore, the use of topical decongestants to prevent or treat otitis media with effusion in children is not justified and should be discouraged.     

Otitis Media Following Tympanostomy Tube Placement in Children With IgG2 Deficiency

Children with IgG₂ deficiency commonly develop recurrent acute otitis media. It is believed that these infections are secondary to impaired antibody response rather than eustachian tube dysfunction and are therefore less responsive to treatment with tympanostomy tubes. The authors compared the incidence of acute otitis media in IgG₂-deficient patients following tympanostomy tube placement with controls in a retrospective cohort study. The charts of 20 patients (10 with IgG₂ deficiency and 10 controls) were reviewed. Episodes of otitis media were recorded for 12 months. IgG₂-deficient patients experienced three times as many occurrences of otitis media as did controls. This suggests that otitis media is much more common in these patients following tympanostomy tube placement. We believe that an immunodeficiency workup should be considered in patients with multiple episodes of otitis media following placement of tympanostomy tubes.     

Implications of laser assisted tympanostomy in adults.

OBJECTIVES: To assess outcome in adult individuals undergoing laser-assisted tympanostomy without ventilation tube placement. STUDY DESIGN: Case series with 2-month follow-up. SETTING: Faculty practice, research protocol, tertiary care academic medical center. PATIENTS AND METHOD: Laser-assisted tympanostomy was performed on a total of 142 ears (108 individuals). Indications included serous otitis media with effusion (66 ears/47 patients), functional eustachian tube dysfunction (48 ears/36 patients), acute otitis media (19 ears/16 patients), and endoscopic visualization of the middle ear (9 ears/9 patients). INTERVENTION: The laser-assisted tympanostomy procedure is performed with a CO2 laser under local anesthesia on an outpatient basis. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Patency time of the tympanostomy, presence of fluid after the closure of the tympanostomy, tympanometry and tone audiometry findings, relief of symptoms. RESULTS: Middle ear disease was resolved after the closure of tympanostomy in 47.9% of patients with serous otitis media with effusion. In 79.1% of patients with functional eustachian tube dysfunction, symptoms were diminished. All patients with acute otitis media had a satisfactory outcome. Laser-assisted tympanostomy was found to be quite helpful in patients undergoing middle ear endoscopy. CONCLUSIONS: Laser-assisted tympanostomy without ventilation tubes provides a safe alternative surgical option in adult patients in certain cases. The selection criteria for this procedure are addressed in detail.     

Patulous eustachian tube in long-term survivors of nasopharyngeal carcinoma

This article reports on 21 long-term (10 years) survivors of nasopharyngeal carcinoma, divided into 2 groups: those subjected to an inflation-deflation test and a clearance function test in a longitudinal study, and those receiving sonotubometry in a cross-sectional study. On the inflation-deflation test, 12 (55%) out of 22 ears had a patulous eustachian tube, and on sonotubometry, 10 (50%) out of 20 ears also revealed a patulous eustachian tube. Except for 4 ears with chronic otitis media, the ears had resolved to a normal eardrum appearance at 10 years postirradiation. The phenomenon might be attributed to both restoration of the impaired tubal function and the development of a patulous tube.