Antigen-specific and nonspecific deletion of immature cortical thymocytes caused by antigen injection

Analysis of antigen-induced negative selection of thymocytes in T cell receptor (TCR)-transgenic mice is complicated by the presence of an antigen-responsive peripheral T cell compartment. Our experiments address the question of whether and how peripheral T cell activation can affect immature thymocytes. Following three daily injections of peptide antigen into mice expressing a peptide-specific transgenic TCR and deficient for TAP1, we and others have found profound deletion of the CD4⁺CD8⁺ (DP) thymocyte subset. However, our work shows that even though mature CD8⁺ T cells are inefficiently selected in TAP1-deficient mice, there was a striking degree of peripheral expansion and activation of CD8⁺ peripheral T cells. Furthermore, when cells from TCR-transgenic mice were adoptively transferred, we found that deletion of non-transgenic DP thymocytes occurred in Thy-1-congenic and even more efficiently in TAP1-deficient recipients after repeated peptide injection resulting in peripheral T cell activation. In the adoptive transfer experiments the degree of deletion of immature bystander thymocytes was decreased upon blocking of TNF. These data show that deletion of DP thymocytes can result from excessive peripheral T cell activation and identify TNF as an important effector molecule for this process. When steps are taken to avoid peripheral T cell activation, peptide antigen can induce TCR-mediated thymocyte deletion, presumably in the thymus cortex, since injection of TAP1-deficient TCR-transgenic mice resulted in deletion of immature DP thymocytes prior to detectable peripheral T cell expansion and activation. This effect was not blocked by inhibiting tumor necrosis factor activity. In addition, DP depletion was seen in the absence of peripheral T cell activation when antibody-mediated depletion of CD8⁺ T cells was performed. Our work clearly shows that two mechanisms for deletion of DP thymocytes exist: deletion induced by antigen presentation in the thymus and deletion as a consequence of repeated stimulation of mature peripheral T cells.     

Double-positive thymocytes resistant to antigen-MHC-induced negative selection lack active caspase

Thymocytes bearing autoreactive TCR are eliminated from the organism by a process termed negative selection. The molecular basis of this deletion has been recently shown to be a consequence of TCR-triggered activation of a caspase by certain peptide-MHC ligands in the immature CD4+CD8+ double-positive (DP) thymocyte subpopulation. Of note, the numerically minor TCRhigh DP thymocyte subpopulation, unlike the major TCRlow DP subset, is resistant to negative selection. Despite exposure to cognate peptide, TCRhigh DP thymocytes mature into single-positive thymocytes and are exported into the periphery. Here we investigated the mechanism by which these thymocytes escape negative selection. Using a cytochemical assay in conjunction with a caspase-specific affinity ligand, we demonstrate that the resistance of the TCRhigh DP thymocytes to negative selection correlates with the disappearance of TCR-triggered caspase activity in these cells. Thus thymocytes which have presumably begun the positive selection process inactivate the thymic caspase pathway and are no longer susceptible to negative selection.      

Deficient activation and resistance to activation-induced apoptosis of CD8+ T cells is associated with defective peripheral tolerance in nonobese diabetic mice

Activation-induced cell death (AICD) is a mechanism of homeostasis that limits the clonal expansion of autoreactive T cells and regulates central and peripheral tolerance. In nonobese diabetic (NOD) mice, defects in central and peripheral tolerance are associated with a proliferative hyporesponsiveness of thymocytes and peripheral T cells elicited upon TCR activation. We investigated whether these defects in tolerance induction and hyporesponsiveness of NOD T cells manifest in an altered susceptibility to TCR-induced AICD. TCR-activated NOD splenic CD4+ and CD8+ T cells are more resistant to AICD than control strain C57BL/6, BALB/c, and NOR T cells. NOR CD4+ but not CD8+ T cells are resistant to TCR-induced AICD. Whereas c-FLIP expression is reduced in activated T cells from control strains, it persists in activated NOD CD8+ T cells and is accompanied by diminished activity of caspase-3 and -8. IL-4 reduces this c-FLIP expression and increases caspase-3 and -8 activity in activated NOD CD8+ T cells. Moreover, IL-4 and CD28 costimulation restores the susceptibility of NOD CD8+ T cells to AICD, and this is associated with increased expression of CD25, CD95, CD95L, and TNFR2. Thus, deficient activation of CD8+ T cells and their greater resistance to TCR-induced AICD may mediate defective peripheral tolerance and the development of T1D in NOD mice.     

A minimal level of MHC class II expression is sufficient to abrogate autoreactivity.

The establishment of CD4(+) T cell tolerance requires that self-reactive thymocytes are negatively selected during thymic development. A threshold of antigen concentration appears to exist for both MHC class I- and class II-mediated negative selection, below which clonal deletion of a self-reactive transgenic TCR does not occur. Similarly, both the specificity and thymic concentration of MHC molecules affect the efficiency with which autoreactive thymocytes are deleted. However, this threshold for MHC class II concentration has not been well established. Here, we show that this threshold must be extraordinarily low. We have used the human lysozyme promoter to re-express an A(beta)(b) cDNA on macrophages and other phagocytic myelomonocytic cells of class II-deficient A(beta)(b) -/- mice. Surface expression of I-A(b) could be detected on mature peritoneal macrophages and, minimally, on thymic dendritic cells; however, this level of expression was not sufficient for antigen-specific T cell activation. Nevertheless, when backcrossed onto an autoreactive K14 background, this minimal level of class II was sufficient to induce negative selection of a polyclonal self-reactive population. We conclude that provision of extremely low levels of class II to thymic dendritic cells confers on them the ability to mediate clonal deletion of autoreactive T cells.     

Clonal deletion of major histocompatibility complex class I-restricted CD4+CD8+ thymocytes in vitro is independent of the CD95 (APO-1/Fas) ligand

The CD95 (APO-1/Fas) ligand (CD95L) mediates apoptosis in sensitive target cells, Ca²⁺-independent cytotoxicity of cells from perforin knock-out mice, and peripheral deletion of activated T cells through engagement of its cognate receptor CD95. Double-positive thymocytes show a high constitutive expression of CD95. Therefore, we used a model system and investigated whether negative selection through apoptosis might involve CD95/CD95L. We analyzed whether CD95L may induce antigen-specific deletion of double-positive thymocytes from mice transgenic for a lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV)/H2^b-specific T cell receptor (TCR). These cells are deleted in vitro upon addition of the LCMV-peptide 33–41 in a major histocompatibility complex-class I-restricted fashion. Deletion was not blocked by soluble mouse and human CD95-Fc receptor decoys. CD95-Fc receptor decoys, however, were effective in blocking apoptosis induced by mouse CD95L-transfected L929 cells in sensitive CD95⁺ target cells and in thymocytes. These results suggest that TCR-induced deletion of immature thymocytes in vitro is independent of CD95L. Thus, our data argue against a role of CD95L in negative selection of MHC-class I-restricted autoreactive thymocytes.     

Immunotargeting of insulin reactive CD8 T cells to prevent Diabetes

Insulin is one of the earliest targeted autoantigens in the immune destruction of insulin-producing beta cells by autoreactive CD4 and CD8 T cells in type 1 diabetes. In this study, we used Non-obese diabetic (NOD) transgenic T cells engineered to express MHC class I-insulin peptide complexes linked to a T cell activation component (InsCD3-ζ), to target insulin-reactive CD8 T cells. We showed that activated, but not naïve, InsCD3-ζ CD8 T cells killed diabetogenic insulin-reactive CD8 target cells in vitro, inducing antigen-specific cell death mediated via both the release of perforin and the Fas–Fas ligand pathway. In vivo, InsCD3-ζ CD8 T cells migrated to the pancreatic lymph nodes of NOD mice after adoptive transfer. Concomitant with this, infiltration of CD8 T cells was also reduced in the pancreatic islets. Finally, in vivo, we showed that diabetes induced by adoptive transfer of insulin-reactive T cells was reduced following injection of activated InsCD3-ζ CD8 T cells. Furthermore, young NOD mice injected with InsCD3-ζ CD8 T cells developed a lower incidence and delayed onset of diabetes. Thus, using this novel system we have demonstrated that InsCD3-ζ CD8 T cells can directly kill insulin-reactive CD8 T cells in vitro and by targeting insulin-specific CD8 T cells early in the course of disease alter the progression of spontaneous diabetes in vivo in NOD mice.     

Increased diabetes development and decreased function of CD4+CD25+ Treg in the absence of a functional DAP12 adaptor protein

Prior to the development of type 1 diabetes, T cells are primed in the pancreatic lymph nodes (PLN) where they interact with APC displaying beta cell-derived peptides. The details concerning the regulation of autoreactive T cell responses in the PLN are unclear. BDC2.5/B6g7 TCR transgenic mice represent a simplified model of type 1 diabetes, in which beta cell-specific CD4+ T cells expressing a diabetogenic transgenic TCR are first activated in the PLN and subsequently home to the pancreas where they mediate killing of beta cells. DNAX-activating protein of 12 kDa (DAP12) is an adaptor molecule carrying an ITAM motif. It associates with receptors on lymphoid and myeloid cells, including APC. We here show that introduction of a DAP12 null mutation in BDC2.5/B6g7 mice accelerated diabetes development and promoted an augmented activation state of PLN T cells expressing the transgenic TCR. Transferred BDC2.5 T cells proliferated more efficiently in the PLN of DAP12-deficient B6g7 recipients, which correlated with a decreased impact of co-transferred BDC2.5+CD4+CD25+ T cells. We propose that signaling through a DAP12-associated receptor on APC facilitates activation of Treg in the PLN and by this contributes to the maintenance of peripheral tolerance to beta cell-derived antigens.     

Both central and peripheral tolerance mechanisms play roles in diabetes prevention in NOD-E transgenic mice

The non-obese diabetic (NOD) mouse spontaneously develops diabetes and is a widely used model of Type 1 Diabetes in humans. The major histocompatibility complex class II plays an important role in governing disease susceptibility in NOD mice. NOD mice express a rare I-A allele, I-A(g7), and do not express I-E molecules. Interestingly, transgenic NOD mice which express I-E (NOD-E) fail to develop diabetes although, the protective mechanism(s) are incompletely understood. Initially, we explored whether diabetes prevention was due to deletion of autoreactive T cells. Through adoptive transfer with depletion of CD25+ T cells, we demonstrated that autoreactive T cells were present in the periphery of NOD-E mice. Although, BDC2.5NOD T cells proliferated less in the pancreatic lymph nodes of NOD-E mice, we found that they transferred disease with a similar kinetic in NOD.scid and NOD-E.scid recipients suggesting that there was little difference in peripheral antigen presentation in NOD-E mice. We also found that there were no proportional or functional differences between NOD and NOD-E T regs. Our studies indicate that autoreactive T cells are present within the periphery of NOD-E mice but that these cells are present in low numbers suggesting that peripheral tolerogenic mechanisms are able to prevent them from inducing diabetes.     

The stage of negative selection in tolerance induction in neonatal mice

In flow microfluorometry analysis of thymus and lymph node cells of C57BL/6(I-E-,Mlsb) mice rendered neonatally tolerant to (C57BL/6 x AKR/J)F1 (I-E+,Mlsb/a) lymphoid cells, both CD4+ and CD8+ cells showed a striking reduction in the number of V beta 6+ cells capable of recognizing Mlsa in the context of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecules, indicating that clonal deletion of V beta 6+ cells by Mlsa antigen occurs just at a stage of immature V beta 6lowCD4+CD8+ thymocytes. On the other hand, the number of V beta 11+ cells capable of recognizing I-E was markedly reduced in CD4+ cells, but CD8+ cells showed only partial (20%) reduction of such a population. The clonal deletion of V beta 11+ cells by I-E may begin at the transitional stage from V beta 11lowCD4+CD8+ to V beta 11highCD4+CD8- single-position cells, and V beta 11lowCD4+CD8+ cells differentiating to V beta 11highCD4-CD8+ cells seem to be resistant to clonal deletion. V beta 11+ T cells are also stimulated by staphylococcal enterotoxin A (SEA) irrespective of expression of CD4 or CD8. Nearly all of both V beta 11+CD4+ and V beta 11+CD8+ lymph node T cells were deleted by the injection of SEA every other day from birth. In their thymi, both V beta 11+CD4+CD8- and V beta 11+CD4-CD8+ single-positive thymocytes were deleted, and the proportion of V beta 11low thymocytes was lower than that of normal mice. The clonal deletion of V beta 11+ T cells by SEA injection occurs at a stage of immature V beta 11lowCD4+CD8+ double-positive thymocytes, resulting in deletion of both V beta 11+CD4+ and V beta 11+CD8+ T cells.     

Genetic and immunological basis of autoimmune diabetes in the NOD mouse

The non-obese diabetic (NOD) mouse is an animal model of human insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM). Most NOD mice show insulitis at several weeks of age, and 60-90% of the female mice develop overt diabetes after 20-30 weeks of age. NOD mice share many features of human IDDM. As in human IDDM, the disease development in NOD mice is controlled by a number of disease susceptibility or resistant genes (Idds), including the major histocompatibility complex locus. Cumulative evidence suggests that Thl CD4+ T cells play a critical role in the autoimmune process leading to beta cell destruction. In addition to CD4+ T cells, CD8+ cells and B cells also participate in the pathogenesis. There are several candidate antigens recognized by autoreactive T cells such as glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD), insulin and heat shock protein (HSP) 60. Treatment by these antigens suppresses IDDM development in NOD mice, suggesting that they may initiate the autoimmune process of NOD mice.     

CD154-dependent priming of diabetogenic CD4(+) T cells dissociated from activation of antigen-presenting cells

We followed the fate of K(d)- or I-A(g7)-restricted beta cell-autoreactive T cells in monoclonal TCR-transgenic NOD mice expressing or lacking CD154. 8.3-NOD.RAG-2(-/-)/CD154(-/-) mice, which bear autoreactive CD8(+) T cells, developed diabetes with the same incidence and tempo as 8.3-NOD.RAG-2(-/-)/CD154(+) mice. Recruitment of CD154(-/-) 8.3-CD8(+) CTL was accelerated by CD154(+)CD4(+) T cells, by expression of a B7.1 transgene in beta cells or by treatment of the mice with CpG-DNA or an agonistic anti-CD40 antibody. In contrast, the autoreactive CD4(+) T cells maturing in 4.1-NOD.RAG-2(-/-) mice lost their diabetogenic potential if they lacked CD154, even in the presence of CD154(+)CD4(+) T cells, B7.1 molecules on beta cells, CpG-DNA treatment, or systemic CD40 ligation. These results demonstrate the existence of a novel, CD154-dependent pathway of CD4(+) T cell activation that is independent of CD40-mediated activation of APCs.     

Origin and selection of peripheral CD4-CD8- T cells bearing alpha/beta T cell antigen receptors in autoimmune gld mice

We have analyzed the origin and development of unusual CD4-CD8- alpha/beta T cell receptor-positive peripheral T cells produced in large numbers by mice homozygous for the gld mutation (C3H-gld/gld). These mice may be an important model for investigating processes controlling T cell development. Bone marrow transfers demonstrated that the gld defect was intrinsic to bone marrow-derived cells. Clonal deletion of potentially autoreactive cells was observed in peripheral gld CD4-CD8-, CD4+CD8-, and CD4-CD8+ T cells, as well as mature thymocytes. This suggests that gld CD4-CD8- T cells have passed through the thymus in ontogeny and that gld autoimmunity does not result from a general defect in elimination of self-reactive thymocytes. These observations, combined with demethylation of the CD8 gene in the CD4-CD8- population, support prior expression of CD4 and/or CD8 in gld CD4-CD8- T cell ontogeny, perhaps at a CD4+CD8+ stage. Steroid sensitivity of gld thymocytes and CD4-CD8- T cells was normal. Therefore, we found no gross abnormalities in two major mechanisms of inducible cell death in the gld thymus, the clonal deletion process associated with tolerance and the steroid-inducible endogenous endonuclease thought to be involved in apoptosis of unselected thymocytes. The data suggest that if gld CD4-CD8- T cells arise via escape from normal elimination in the thymus, they must do so by a novel defect in thymic selection (perhaps related to aberrant positive signals) and/or are expanded by an extrathymic process which allows clonal deletion to occur.     

Thymic selection of CD4+CD25+ regulatory T cells induced by an agonist self-peptide

Despite accumulating evidence that regulatory T cells play a crucial role in preventing autoimmunity, the processes underlying their generation during immune repertoire formation are unknown. We show here that interactions with a single self-peptide can induce thymocytes that bear an autoreactive T cell receptor (TCR) to undergo selection to become CD4+CD25+ regulatory T cells. Selection of CD4+CD25+ thymocytes appears to require a TCR with high affinity for a self peptide because thymocytes that bear TCRs with low affinity do not undergo selection into this pathway. Our findings indicate that specificity for self-peptides directs the selection of CD4+CD25+ regulatory thymocytes by a process that is distinct from positive selection and deletion.     

Central tolerance spares the private high‐avidity CD4+ T‐cell repertoire specific for an islet antigen in NOD mice

Although central tolerance induces the deletion of most autoreactive T cells, some autoreactive T cells escape thymic censorship. Whether potentially harmful autoreactive T cells present distinct TCRαβ features remains unclear. Here, we analyzed the TCRαβ repertoire of CD4⁺ T cells specific for the S100β protein, an islet antigen associated with type 1 diabetes. We found that diabetes‐resistant NOD mice deficient for thymus specific serine protease (TSSP), a protease that impairs class II antigen presentation by thymic stromal cells, were hyporesponsive to the immunodominant S100β_1‐15 epitope, as compared to wild‐type NOD mice, due to intrathymic negative selection. In both TSSP‐deficient and wild‐type NOD mice, the TCRαβ repertoire of S100β‐specific CD4⁺ T cells though diverse showed a specific bias for dominant TCRα rearrangements with limited CDR3α diversity. These dominant TCRα chains were public since they were found in all mice. They were of intermediate‐ to low‐avidity. In contrast, high‐avidity T cells expressed unique TCRs specific to each individual (private TCRs) and were only found in wild‐type NOD mice. Hence, in NOD mice, the autoreactive CD4⁺ T‐cell compartment has two major components, a dominant and public low‐avidity TCRα repertoire and a private high‐avidity CD4⁺ T‐cell repertoire; the latter is deleted by re‐enforced negative selection.     

NOD小鼠胸腺细胞TCR介导的信号通路缺陷

目的 进一步研究NOD小鼠T细胞应答改变机理。方法 用抗TCR抗体、ConA激活NOD小鼠胸腺细胞，分析TCR介导的信号通路的水平。结果 与Balb／c小鼠胸腺细胞相比，抗TCR抗体诱导的增殖应答较弱，与年龄及NOD胸腺CD4^ CD8^-和CD4^-CD8^ SP细胞有关；rIL-2能部分恢复对TCR抗体应答的缺乏。NOD小鼠对PMA IONO和PMA anti—TCR-mAb应答正常，但对anti-TCRmAb IONO应答缺乏。结论 与年龄有关的NOD小鼠胸腺细胞对TCR抗体应答的缺乏与T细胞激活时上游PKC信号通路的缺乏有关。     

A T-cell functional phenotype common among autoimmune-prone rodent strains

The genetic basis and familial clustering of autoimmunity suggest that common phenotypic traits predispose individuals to disease. We found a hyporesponsive T-cell phenotype that was shared by all autoimmune-prone mouse and rat strains tested, including MRL, nonobese diabetic (NOD), NZB, NZW, NZB/W F1, SJL and SWR mice, as well as DA and BB rats, but was not evident in nonautoimmune-prone rodents. This T-cell intrinsic, age-independent hyporesponsiveness is measured as an increased activation threshold for upregulation of activation markers upon T-cell receptor (TCR) cross-linking both in vitro and in vivo. Inefficient deletion of CD4 and CD8 single-positive, heat stable antigen (HSA)hi medullary thymocytes was also observed in hyporesponsive donors. We interpret these data to suggest that increased TCR-mediated signalling thresholds in autoimmune-prone individuals may contribute to the escape of autoreactive thymocytes from negative selection.     

Thymocytes can tolerize thymocytes by clonal deletion in vitro.

Clonal deletion of thymocytes bearing TCR for self antigens is one major mechanism of T cell tolerance induction. Peptide antigen-induced deletion of thymocytes from alpha beta TCR transgenic mice has been studied using single cell suspension cultures. The results show that antigen-presenting immature CD4+CD8+ thymocytes can tolerize antigen-reactive immature thymocytes in vitro by programmed cell death (apoptosis) 6-8 h after antigen exposure. Antigen-induced apoptosis of immature thymocytes was inhibited by antibodies specific for the alpha beta TCR, CD3, CD8, and LFA-1 molecules. This implies that clonal elimination of self-reactive CD4+CD8+ thymocytes does not depend on specialized deleting cell types in the thymus and occurs whenever the TCR of immature thymocytes bind antigen fragments presented by MHC molecules.     

1Alpha,25-dihydroxyvitamin D3 restores thymocyte apoptosis sensitivity in non-obese diabetic (NOD) mice through dendritic cells

AIMS/HYPOTHESIS: Resistance of NOD thymocytes to apoptosis-inducing signals is restored by 1alpha,25-dihydroxyvitamin D3 (1alpha,25OH2D3), a therapy preventing diabetes in NOD mice. We studied whether modulation of thymocyte apoptosis is due to direct effects on thymic T lymphocytes or indirect effects via thymic dendritic cells, since both cell types constitute known targets for 1alpha,25OH2D3. METHODS AND RESULTS: Female NOD mice were treated with 1alpha,25OH2D3 (5microg/kg/2d) from 21 to 70 days. Vehicle-treated NOD and NOR mice served as controls. Analysis of thymic T lymphocytes from 1alpha,25OH2D3)-treated mice revealed a decrease in number of apoptosis-resistant CD4+CD8+ and CD4+CD8-HSA(high) T lymphocyte subsets, higher pro-apoptotic IL-2 and FasL, and lower anti-apoptotic Bclx-L mRNA expression levels. Thymic dendritic cells from 1alpha,25OH2D3-treated NOD mice had increased CD8alpha+FasL+ and CD80+/86+ expression compared to control NOD mice. In a syngeneic co-culture system of thymocytes and thymic dendritic cells, apoptosis levels were 20% higher only in co-cultures where both T cell- and dendritic cell-compartments originated from 1alpha,25OH2D3-treated mice. Activation-induced cell death-sensitivity in peripheral T lymphocytes was comparable to levels present in NOR mice, confirming better thymic selection in 1alpha,25OH2D3-treated mice. CONCLUSION/INTERPRETATION: We conclude that 1alpha,25OH2D3 needs both thymic T cell- and dendritic cell-compartments to exert its apoptosis-restorative effects in NOD thymocytes.     

Selection of phenotypically distinct NK1.1+ T cells upon antigen expression in the thymus or in the liver.

Unlike the main TCR alphabeta T cell lineage in which deletion occurs at the CD4+ CD8+ double-positive (DP) stage upon TCR engagement by antigen in the thymus, some T cells appear to require such engagement for their selection, either in the thymus or extrathymically. We used a transgenic TCR (tgTCR) model which, as we previously showed, led to selection upon expression of the corresponding antigen H-2Kb (Kb) in the thymus, of tgTCR/CD3(lo) CD4- CD8- double-negative (DN) thymocytes that expressed the NK1.1 marker (NK T cells) (Curnow, S. J., et al., Immunity 1995. 3: 427). We now report that antigen expression on medullary epithelial cells of the thymus failed to select the NK T cells, whereas its expression on thymocytes did, although tgTCR DP thymocyte development was affected under both conditions. Antigen expression on hepatocytes (Alb-Kb mice) did not perturb tgTCR DP thymocyte development. No enrichment in tgTCR NK T cells was detected in the periphery, except for the liver of the Alb-Kb/tgTCR mice. When reconstitution of thymectomized and irradiated H-2k hosts expressing or not Kb was performed with bone marrow from tgTCR H-2k mice, an enrichment in tgTCR+ NK T cells was found in the liver, but not in the spleen, of the hosts which expressed Kb, either selectively on hepatocytes or ubiquitously. Surprisingly, the majority of the hepatic tgTCR+ NK T cells also expressed the CD8 alpha/beta heterodimer. These results indicate that thymus-independent NK T cells with unique phenotypic characteristics can be selected upon antigen encounter in the liver.