Nontraumatic coma. Glasgow coma score and coma etiology as predictors of 2-week outcome

In 1987 and 1988, we carried out a prospective study of patients older than 10 years with nontraumatic coma in the intensive care units of Columbia-Presbyterian Medical Center, New York, NY. Of 188 patients with Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) determinations within 72 hours, 61% were dead or in persistent coma by 2 weeks from onset. Age, sex, and ethnicity did not influence outcome. The 2-week outcome for patients with initial GCS of 3 to 5 was 14.8% awake; 85.2% were dead or in persistent coma. For the GCS 6 to 8 group, 53.1% were awake and 46.9% were dead or in persistent coma. Hypoxic or ischemic coma had the worst 2-week outcome (79% dead or comatose); coma caused by metabolic disease or sepsis (68%), focal cerebral lesions (66%), and general cerebral diseases (55%) were intermediate, while drug-induced coma had a favorable outcome (27% dead or comatose). The independent predictors of 2-week outcome were the first GCS and drug-induced coma. The predicted probability of waking at 2 weeks was eight times better for drug-induced coma than other causes when GCS was held constant. Patients with an initial GCS score of 6 to 8 were seven times more likely to waken than those with a score of 3 to 5. The motor subscore alone was a significant independent predictor of 2-week outcome. Modification of coma score to include etiology may give more accurate predictions of 2-week outcome after nontraumatic coma.     

Predicting outcome in hypoxic-ischemic coma. A prospective clinical and electrophysiologic study.

A prospective analysis of 40 patients with hypoxic-ischemic coma lasting at least 6 h following sudden cardiac arrest was undertaken. The patients, all of whom had preserved brain-stem function, were studied electrophysiologically with electroencephalography (EEG), and median nerve somatosensory evoked potentials (SEPs) within 48 h to establish prognostic indices. Our results indicate that preserved brain-stem function does not necessarily predict favorable outcome following cardiac arrest as 26 of 40 (65%) patients died without awakening. The bilateral absence of cortical evoked potentials predicted death without awakening in 19 of 26 patients (73%) while malignant EEG change was similarly predictive in 11 patients (42%). Bilateral absence of cortical evoked potentials and/or malignant EEG change reliably predicted unfavorable outcome in 21/26 patients (81%). Patients with normal or delayed central conduction time (CCT) as well as 'benign' or 'uncertain' EEG findings had an uncertain prognosis as some entered a persistent vegetative state (PVS) or died without awakening. Fourteen patients (35%) awakened of whom 5 (13%) recovered completely while another 9 (23%) had varying degrees of motor or cognitive impairment. SEP and EEG findings did not distinguish between these outcomes.     

Predicting coma and other low responsive patients outcome using event-related brain potentials: a meta-analysis.

OBJECTIVE: A meta-analysis was performed to estimate the predictive power (odd ratio, OR) for awakening of auditory event-related potential (ERP) components in low responsive patients with stroke or hemorrhage, trauma, anoxic, post-operative, and metabolic encephalopathy etiologies. METHODS: We reviewed MEDLINE and analyzed citations for retrieved articles. Logistic regressions were applied on patient samples (Glasgow Coma Scale <12) across and for separate etiologies. RESULTS: For stroke and hemorrhage the ORs with 95% confidence intervals were: 2.05 [1.12-3.75] (N100), 4.47 [1.92-10.44] (MMN), 10.29 [2.00-52.79] (P300), for trauma: 1.63 [0.70-3.80] (N100), 4.72 [1.35-16.44] (MMN), 12.89 [4.82-34.43] (P300), anoxic: 8.03 [2.83-22.75] (N100), 15.50 [4.27-56.26] (MMN), 5.93 [2.38-14.77] (P300), post-operative: 10.66 [1.98-57.50] (N100), metabolic encephalopathy: 2.12 [0.34-13.13] (N100), 3.60 [0.28-46.36] (MMN), 7.71 [0.75-79.77] (P300), and all etiologies: 2.85 [1.91-4.27] (N100), 6.53 [3.55-12.01] (MMN), and 8.79 [4.88-15.83] (P300). Based on six N100 studies (N=548 patients), five MMN studies (N=470), and six P300 studies (N=313), the N100, MMN, or P300, when present, significantly predicted awakening, P300 and MMN being significantly better predictors than N100. CONCLUSIONS: The MMN and P300 appear to be reliable predictors of awakening. SIGNIFICANCE: The prognostic assessment of low responsive patients with auditory ERP should take into account both MMN and P300.     

Can somatosensory evoked potentials predict outcome from coma?

Long-term somatosensory evoked potential (SEP) recordings for a period of 2 1/2 years are reported for a patient rendered comatose from hypoxic encephalopathy. Findings are compared with previously published reports on poor outcome associated with bilaterally absent cortical responses. In the present case, the patient was admitted with poor neurological status but has preserved cortical responses bilaterally throughout his course until his final recovery and return to previous employment. Somatosensory cortical responses when bilaterally absent are universally associated with poor outcome; however, when persistently present they can indicate hope of recovery despite poor clinical status on admission.     

Use of somatosensory evoked responses in the prediction of outcome from coma

Present data on 60 comatose patients with head trauma, hypoxia and cerebrovascular disease suggested that SER may yield quantitative, useful information concerning the functional state of the cerebral cortex. To assess the prognosis of individual patients we propose to classify patients from various etiologies of coma into the following categories: I. If there is bilateral absence of cortical responses, irrespective of the etiology of coma, none of these patients recover. II. If the initial cortical responses in the first 24 hours are normal, then it is imperative that these should be repeated in the first week before any definitive prognosis can be given, (since as in one case, we noted on the fifth day there was distortion of amplitude of his response and eventually the cortical responses were unobtainable, therefore indicating a poor prognosis). III. Patients who have normal responses throughout the acute course of illness carry an excellent prognosis from coma of all etiologies, except with ischemic etiology. The prognosis remains favorable for recovery from coma, but these patients may remain with significant neurological deficits. IV. When there is a 75% drop in the amplitude of the responses, it indicates a poor prognosis for ultimate neurological recovery, and the majority of these patients will remain in a persistent vegetative state. V. In patients with intermediate reduction in amplitude, 25-50% carried a moderate prognosis, and the majority of these cases in our series were able to perform activities of daily living.     

Auditory evoked potentials in coma after closed head injury: a clinical-neurophysiologic coma scale for predicting outcome

We studied auditory evoked potentials in 45 head-injured patients. All but three were comatose or stuporous at the time of study. Preservation of brainstem auditory or long-latency auditory evoked potentials predicted good outcome. The Glasgow coma scale (GCS), the clinical subtotal of the neurophysiologic coma scale (NPCS), and the NPCS had predictive accuracies of 71%, 82%, and 82%. Although there were 22 falsely pessimistic predictions with the GCS and 9% with the clinical subtotal of the NPCS, there were no falsely pessimistic predictions with the NPCS.     

Predicting outcome of schizophrenia: significance of symptom profiles and outcome dimensions

To clarify the antecedents of poor long-term outcome in schizophrenia, 58 DSM-III diagnosed schizophrenic inpatients, mostly chronic, were prospectively assessed on psychiatric symptoms and background variables. The 46 patients (79.3%) who could be relocated after 1 to 4 years (mean, 2.7 years) were evaluated on a multidimensional outcome scale and days of subsequent hospitalization. We found, contrary to prevailing belief, that a baseline positive, not negative, syndrome predicted poor outcome. Thought disturbance portended the worst prognosis and depressive syndrome the best. Multiple regression analysis showed (a) reliable prediction for 9 of 10 outcome measures (r values from .49 to .61); (b) separate contributions by clinical, genealogical, and historical predictors; and (c) different sets of variables that predicted social v occupational adjustment. The results have implications for prognosis, rehabilitation planning, and understanding of the obstacles to successful transition to community living.     

Recurrent coma and Lesch-Nyhan syndrome.

A patient with Lesch-Nyhan syndrome has had 3 recurrent episodes of coma, each associated with an acute illness. Extensive investigation for known causes of coma has failed to yield a diagnosis. Although coma is not generally recognized as a feature of Lesch-Nyhan syndrome, similar patients have been reported previously. This and other episodic phenomena observed in Lesch-Nyhan syndrome may be explained by the disruption of cellular energy metabolism due to purine depletion, consequent to lack of the purine salvage pathway normally provided by the hypoxanthine-guanine-phosphoribosyl-transferase enzyme.     

Predicting outcome of status epilepticus

BackgroundStatus epilepticus (SE) is a frequent neurological emergency complicated by high mortality and often poor functional outcome in survivors. The aim of this study was to review available clinical scores to predict outcome.MethodsLiterature review. PubMed Search terms were “score”, “outcome”, and “status epilepticus” (April 9th 2015). Publications with abstracts available in English, no other language restrictions, or any restrictions concerning investigated patients were included.ResultsTwo scores were identified: “Status Epilepticus Severity Score — STESS” and “Epidemiology based Mortality score in SE — EMSE”. A comprehensive comparison of test parameters concerning performance, options, and limitations was performed. Epidemiology based Mortality score in SE allows detailed individualization of risk factors and is significantly superior to STESS in a retrospective explorative study. In particular, EMSE is very good at detection of good and bad outcome, whereas STESS detecting bad outcome is limited by a ceiling effect and uncertainty of correct cutoff value. Epidemiology based Mortality score in SE can be adapted to different regions in the world and to advances in medicine, as new data emerge. In addition, we designed a reporting standard for status epilepticus to enhance acquisition and communication of outcome relevant data. A data acquisition sheet used from patient admission in emergency room, from the EEG lab to intensive care unit, is provided for optimized data collection.ConclusionStatus Epilepticus Severity Score is easy to perform and predicts bad outcome, but has a low predictive value for good outcomes. Epidemiology based Mortality score in SE is superior to STESS in predicting good or bad outcome but needs marginally more time to perform. Epidemiology based Mortality score in SE may prove very useful for risk stratification in interventional studies and is recommended for individual outcome prediction. Prospective validation in different cohorts is needed for EMSE, whereas STESS needs further validation in cohorts with a wider range of etiologies.This article is part of a Special Issue entitled “Status Epilepticus”.     

Pseudo-subarachnoid hemorrhage: A potential imaging pitfall associated with spontaneous intracranial hypotension

Objective

(1) To determine the frequency of CT mimics of subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH) in a large cohort of subjects with spontaneous intracranial hypotension (SIH). (2) To emphasize the distinctive radiologic features of SIH.

Patients and methods

CT scans of 95 subjects with SIH were retrieved and reviewed to search for findings of pseudo-SAH (CT mimics of SAH in the absence of blood).

Results

Pseudo-SAH radiologic findings (increased attenuation in the basilar cisterns, sylvian fissures, or along the tentorium) were detected on CT scans of 10 of the 95 SIH subjects. However, on MRI scans, these subjects exhibited the typical SIH abnormalities (diffuse pachymeningeal enhancement and brain sagging with obliteration of basilar cisterns).

Conclusions

In the emergency room, SIH should be considered in the differential diagnosis between SAH and pseudo-SAH. Although SIH and SAH can share some radiologic features, SIH has distinctive MRI and CT findings. Their recognition should obviate the need for more invasive procedures (e.g., cerebral angiography) to definitely rule out SAH and an aneurismal source of bleeding.     

Performance measures in Friedreich ataxia: potential utility as clinical outcome tools.

Although several neuroprotective agents have been proposed as potential therapies in Friedreich ataxia (FA), clinical trials of their efficacy are limited by a lack of sensitive outcome measures. We assessed whether performance measures (nine-hole peg test, the timed 25-foot walk, and low-contrast letter acuity) provide valid measures of disease status in FA. Scores for each measure correlated significantly with neurologic disability and disease duration. Rank correlations between scores for performance measures were moderate in magnitude, suggesting that the each test captures separate yet related dimensions of neurological function in FA. Linear regression models demonstrated that scores from the nine-hole peg test and the timed 25-foot walk (after reciprocal transformation) were predicted by age and triplet repeat length in patients with FA. In addition, comparison of the temporal courses of change for each performance measure demonstrated that scores from the timed 25-foot walk change early in the course of FA, nine-hole peg test scores change slowly over the full course of the disorder, and low-contrast letter acuity scores change in the later stages of the disease. Thus, a composite scale derived from these performance measures may provide the best overall measure for assessing disease progression throughout the illness.     

Predicting neurological outcome following cardiac arrest

Because a large number of patients will suffer cardiac arrest each year, physicians must place attention on improving care for patients in the post-resuscitative setting. Part of this effort requires setting realistic goals based on patients' potential for recovery. Recovery from cardiac arrest often depends on the extent of anoxic brain injury, and for this reason primary teams consult neurologists to offer insight into potential for awakening from post-arrest coma. In doing so, neurologists inform a decision with legal, social and ethical implications. Though inapplicable without preparation at the time of cardiac arrest, the four principles of medical ethics have a direct impact on decision making during the post-resuscitative period. A review of the literature reveals that physical examination, electrophysiology, radiology, and biochemical markers can prove useful in estimating a patient's chances for neurological recovery from cardiac arrest. These factors most reliably predict poor outcome, but do so with high specificity. However, the role of the neurology consultant must change to include guidance on strategies of neuroprotection. Aggressive efforts directed towards neuroprotection may change predictions for outcomes after cardiac arrest in the future.     

Predicting outcome for borderline personality disorder

The purpose of this study is to identify variables predictive of the psychosocial outcomes of borderline patients 2 years following an acute psychiatric hospitalization. Of the initial 88 inpatients scoring positive for the Diagnostic Interview for Borderlines (DIB), 65 (73.8%) were reinterviewed, 14 (15.9%) refused, five (5.7%) were unable to be located, and four (4.6%) suicided. The dropouts (n = 19) were significantly more likely to be single, separated, or divorced, to be male, and to be diagnosed as having co-existing antisocial personality disorder than the followed-up probands (n = 69). In terms of global functioning, over the 2-year follow-up period, 61 (87.7%) of the 69 probands were judged to be functioning normally less than 50% of the follow-up interval. Using logistic regression, two variables, initial impulse action scores and poor premorbid functioning, predicted poor versus good outcome. This study supports the literature, which indicates that the early course of borderline personality disorder (BPD) is stormy. Impulsivity and poor premorbid functioning may be predictive of poor short-term outcome in borderline patients.