Evaluation of banana leaf dressing for partial thickness burn wounds

An important factor in the healing of superficial and moderate partial thickness burn is early and effective coverage with a dressing that protects the wound from trauma and dessication and is non-adherent. In our country cost is also a very important factor. Disturbed by the pain and anxiety experienced by the patients during and after dressing changes, search for a new dressing material was begun for partial thickness burn wounds and the banana leaf dressing (BLD) was subsequently developed and optimised by June 1996. An open controlled study was carried out to compare banana leaf dressing and boiled potato peel bandage (BPPB), the dressing being used in our Burn Unit since 1994. Thirty patients all less than 40 years of age, with burn size less than 50% TBSA, involving comparable body areas with partial thickness burn, were included in the study. BLD along with a topical agent was applied over the right sided extremity while BPPB was applied with the same topical agent on the left sided extremity. Dressing was changed every day. The pain during dressing change, feeling of comfort and ease of handling dressing was assessed by awarding scores by the patients and care givers for each type of dressing. Analysis of the scores revealed that both BLD and BPPB caused easily tolerable, minimal pain during dressing change in majority of the patients. The days taken for epithelialisation, eschar formation and the need for skin grafting over deep partial thickness burns, did not reveal any significant difference between the areas treated by BLD and those by BPPB. So both the dressings were observed to have equal efficacy in protecting the wounds and aiding healing. Thus, the efficacy of BLD and BPPB was parallel in all respects. But BLD is 11 times cheaper than BPPB. Banana plants can be easily grown, the leaves are easily available throughout the year. The leaves of banana are large thus offering larger surface area and the surface is non-adherent, waxy and cool. The dressing can be prepared very easily with little training. It is also the cheapest dressing available today. We strongly recommend the use of banana leaf dressing for all partial thickness burn wounds in our environment.     

Conservative surgical debridement as a burn treatment: Supporting evidence from a porcine burn model

In thermal deep‐dermal burns, surgical debridement is normally used in conjunction with skin grafting or skin substitutes and debridement alone as a burn treatment is not usually practiced. The current study addresses whether or not debridement alone would enhance burn wound healing on small deep‐dermal‐partial thickness burns. This was a prospective and blinded experimental trial using a porcine deep‐dermal‐partial thickness burn model. Four burns, approximately 50 cm² in size, were created on each of eight pigs. Two burns from each pig were immediately surgically debrided and the other two were not debrided as the internal control. Hydrate gel together with paraffin gauze were used to cover the burns for four pigs and silver dressings for the other four. Clinical assessment of wound healing was conducted over a 6‐week period. Skin samples were collected at the end of the experiment and histopathological evaluation was performed. The results show thinner scar formation and lower scar height in the debrided compared with nondebrided wounds in the hydrate gel/paraffin gauze groups. There were no statistically significant differences in wound healing assessment between the debrided and nondebrided wounds dressed with silver dressings. This study provides supporting evidence that immediate debridement with an appropriate dressing and without skin grafting may promote wound healing, suggesting its potential benefit for clinical patients.     

An ultrathin poly(l‐lactic acid) nanosheet as a burn wound dressing for protection against bacterial infection

Burn wounds are highly susceptible to bacterial infection due to impairment of the skin's integrity. Therefore, prevention of bacterial colonization/infection in the wound is crucial for the management of burns, including partial‐thickness burn injuries. Although partial‐thickness burn injuries still retain the potential for reepithelialization, the complication of wound infection severely impairs the reepithelialization even in such superficial burn injuries. We recently developed a biocompatible nanosheet consisting of poly(l ‐lactic acid) (PLLA). The PLLA nanosheets have many useful and advantageous biological properties for their application as a wound dressing, such as sufficient flexibility, transparency, and adhesiveness. We herein investigated the suitability of the PLLA nanosheets as a wound dressing for partial‐thickness burn wounds in mice. The PLLA nanosheets tightly adhered to the wound without any adhesive agents. Although wound infection with Pseudomonas aeruginosa in the controls significantly impaired reepithelialization of burn wounds, dressing with the PLLA nanosheet markedly protected against bacterial wound infection, thereby improving wound healing in the mice receiving partial‐thickness burn injuries. The PLLA nanosheet also showed a potent barrier ability for protecting against bacterial penetration in vitro. The ultrathin PLLA nanosheet may be applied as a protective dressing to reduce environmental contamination of bacteria in a partial‐thickness burn wound.     

An evaluation of Aquaphor Gauze dressing in burned children

Aquaphor Gauze was evaluated as a dressing for skin graft donor sites, for partial thickness burn injuries and for split thickness skin grafts. Control dressings consisted of: fine mesh gauze for skin graft donor sites. silver sulphadiazine (Silvadene) on coarse mesh gauze for the partial thickness burns, and nitrofurazone cream (Furacin) on fine mesh gauze for the skin grafts. The Aquaphor Gauze was found to be inferior to the fine mesh gauze for donor site dressings. No statistically significant difference was identified between Aquaphor Gauze and controls for the treatment of partial thickness burns. As a dressing for skin grafts the Aquaphor Gauze was significantly superior to the control dressing as measured by graft take and reduced patient pain. We would recommend that Aquaphor Gauze be used as a dressing for skin grafts where the risk of infection is not excessive.     

异种(猪)脱细胞真皮基质一次性包扎治疗深Ⅱ度烧伤

目的探讨应用异种(猪)脱细胞真皮基质一次性包扎治疗深Ⅱ度烧伤创面的临床应用效果。方法1997年1月—2004年1月,应用异种(猪)脱细胞真皮基质一次包扎治疗50%~95%总体表面积(TBSA)、深Ⅱ度烧伤的患者67例[异种(猪)脱细胞真皮基质治疗组];同期保痂治疗的50%~95%TBSA、深Ⅱ度的患者10例(保痂治疗组),观察创面愈合时间和愈合质量及其并发症发生情况。治愈患者经过3个月~2年的随诊,观察瘢痕增生情况。结果异种(猪)脱细胞真皮基质治疗组深Ⅱ度创面中途基本不需换药,创面愈合时间缩短,平均(12.2±2.6)d,而保痂治疗组愈合时间为(27.4±3.5)d,差异具有统计学意义(P<0.05);同时,异种(猪)脱细胞真皮基质治疗组瘢痕增生情况较保痂治疗组明显减轻或者无瘢痕增生。结论一次性覆盖异种(猪)脱细胞真皮基质可有效地治疗深Ⅱ度烧伤创面,能加快创面愈合,减轻瘢痕增生,从而降低烧伤感染和炎症反应综合征的发生。     

A clinical comparison of pure knitted silk and a complex synthetic skin substitute for the treatment of partial thickness burns

Currently, many dressings are commercially available for the treatment of burn wounds. Some of these wound dressings remain on the wound, prevent painful dressing changes, and reduce tissue scarring. Nevertheless, still a wound dressing that is cost-effective, produces good wound healing properties, and has a high patient satisfaction is needed. Standard care of superficial burn wounds differs between burn centres. This study aimed to determine a dressing with easy appliance, accurate pain control, favourable outcome, and cost-effectiveness. Therefore, we compared the widely used but expensive Suprathel with the rather new but much cheaper Dressilk in the clinical setting. In a prospective clinical study, the healing of partial thickness burn wounds after simultaneous treatment with Suprathel and Dressilk was examined in 20 patients intra-individually. During wound healing, pain, infection, exudation, and bleeding were evaluated. A subjective scar evaluation was performed using the Patient and Observer Scar Scale. Both dressings were easy to apply, remained on the wound in place, and were gradually cut back as reepithelisation proceeded and showed similar times to wound closure. Dressing changes were not necessary, and neither infections nor bleeding was detected. Overall exudation and pain were highest in the beginning but declined during the wound-healing phase without significant differences. In the follow-up scar evaluation after 12 months, patients reported overall high satisfaction. Overall, the modern dressings Suprathel and Dressilk (solely made out of pure silk) led to safe wound healing without infection and rapidly reduced pain. There was no need for dressing changes, and they had similar clinical outcomes in scar evaluation. Therefore, both dressings seem to be ideal for the treatment of superficial burns. Because acquisition costs remain one of the main factors in the treatment of burns, Dressilk, which is ~20 times cheaper than Suprathel, remains a good option for the treatment of partial thickness burns.     

Silver sulphadiazine and the healing of partial thickness burns: a prospective clinical trial

A clinical trial was devised to determine whether the healing of partial thickness burns was retarded by the use of silver sulphadiazine cream (SSD) compared with simple, non-bacteriocidal dressings. Biopsy-confirmed partial thickness burns of at least 2% confluent area were dressed according to a strict protocol to compare the rate of epithelialisation of the control dressing, tulle gras, with that obtained with the use of silver sulphadiazine. The same comparative dressing regimen was carried out on a series of split thickness graft donor sites. Twenty such donor sites and fifteen burn areas were admitted to the trial. The mean time to healing of SSD-treated burn areas was longer than that for tulle gras; the difference when analysed by paired t-test was statistically significant (p less than 0.05). There was very little difference in the compared healing rates of the donor sites, which implies that SSD does not retard epithelialisation of dermal depth injuries but rather that the delayed healing is a unique response of the partial thickness burn wound to the presence of SSD. A review of the relevant literature is included in the discussion.     

Clinical experience with biobrane® biosynthetic dressing in the treatment of partial thickness burns

Biobrane®, a synthetic, bicomposite wound dressing, has been used to treat 17 patients with partial thickness burn wounds covering 0·5–12·5 per cent of the total body surface area (mean 4·4 per cent). In 16 patients we found complete healing of the wound after removal of the dressing, 6–15 days after the injury. In one patient, the wounds were determined on the third day post-injury to be deeper than initially suspected, and she was taken to the operating room for surgical debridement and grafting. Biobrane is an effective wound covering for clean, superficial partial thickness burns of limited extent; the simultaneous use of topical antimicrobial agents for such wounds is not necessary.     

Influence of a temporary synthetic skin substitute on capillary stasis in burns

The prognosis of deep partial thickness burns depends on several factors e.g. infection, wound dehydration, mechanical trauma etc. As shown by Zawacki years ago, the prognosis can be influenced by immediate post-burn application of various dressings. Appropriate dressings can cause early reversal of the capillary “stasis zone”, improving the prognosis. In his study, Zawacki showed that he could achieve the best results by using porcine skin grafts. In our study, we repeated Zawacki’s experimental model, replacing porcine skin graft with a temporary synthetic skin substitute, Omiderm^?. Deep partial thickness burns were inflicted on guinea pigs, who were then divided into three groups and treated as follows: removal of burn blister, burn blister left intact and removal of burn blister which was then replaced by Omiderm. At various times the animals were sacrificed and perfusion with India ink was performed in order to evaluate capillary stasis and its reversal. Upon statistical analysis of results we found that by using Omiderm we achieved early reversal of the stasis zone, as compared to the other groups. It seems to us that appropriate early treatment of deep partial thickness burns can make a significant difference to the prognosis of the burn wound.     

A novel human ex-vivo burn model and the local cooling effect of a bacterial nanocellulose-based wound dressing

BackgroundBurn wound progression is a significant problem as burns initially thought to be superficial can actually become full thickness over time. Cooling is an efficient method to reduce burn wound conversion. However, if the cooling agent is below room temperature, depending on the wound size the patient is at risk of hypothermia. Additionally, tissue perfusion is reduced leading to an aggravation of burn wound progression. We investigated if wound dressings based on non-pre-cooled bacterial nanocellulose (BNC) with a high water content cool a burn just by evaporation and reduce the intradermal damages in the skin.Material and methodsIn a human ex-vivo model, skin explants underwent contact burns using a 100 °C hot steel block. The burned areas were divided into two groups of which one was cooled with a BNC-based wound dressing. Intradermal temperature probes measured temperature in cooled and uncooled burn sites over 24 h. For histological assessments of the burned areas biopsies were taken at different time points. High mobility group box-1 (HMBG1) staining served as marker for cell vitality and necrosis in the different skin layers.ResultsIntradermal temperature measurement showed that application of the BNC-based wound dressing reduced temperature significantly in burned skin. This cooling effect resulted in a maximum temperature difference of 6.4 ± 1.9 °C and a significant mean reduction of the area under the curve in the first hour after burn of 62% (p < 0.0001). The histological results showed less necrosis and less dermal-epidermal separation in the cooled areas. The HMGB1 staining revealed more vital cells in the cooled group than in the uncooled group.ConclusionBased on our results, BNC-based wound dressings cool a burn. Intradermal temperature as well as thermal damage of the tissue was reduced. The tested BNC-based wound dressing can be used without pre-cooling to cool a burn as well as to reduce the burn BNC-based wound progression through its evaporation cooling effect.     

Evaluation of hyperspectral imaging as a modern aid in clinical assessment of burn wounds of the upper extremity

The most common burn wound assessment continues to be the clinical inspection and the tactile examination, which are subjective and remain challenging even for experienced burn surgeons. Recently, hyperspectral imaging camera systems have been increasingly used to support the evaluation of burn wounds. The aim of our study was to determine if hyperspectral imaging analysis differentiates and objectifies the assessment of burn wounds in burns of the upper extremities.We included 97 superficial partial, deep partial dermal burns, and full thickness burns. Hyperspectral imaging analysis was performed for all burns using proprietary software. The software recorded parameters for tissue oxygenation (StO2), tissue hemoglobin index, and near-infrared perfusion. These values were compared with the recordings for healthy, non-burned skin.We found that hyperspectral imaging analysis effectively differentiates burn wounds and shows the ability to distinguish even superficial partial burns from deep partial burns in the near-infrared perfusion analysis feature. Although, it was not possible to differentiate burn wounds in all features.Currently, it is important to optimize the respective reference values of the individual burn degrees for an objectified assessment.     

The use of lyophilised skin as an initial dressing in partial thickness burns

Summary Sixty patients with partial thickness burns have been treated using freeze dried cadaver allograft. It has proved a convenient biological dressing and has useful properties of pain relief, reduction in fluid loss and post burn skin hypertrophy and irritation; there is reduction in healing time compared with exposed areas. The limitation in its use lies in the availability of cadaver skin.In our opinion the presence of lyophilised allograft ensures that optimum conditions for healing prevail through mechanical protection of the burn wound. On the whole, infection is reduced by sealing the wound and prevention of evaporative loss greatly reduces the amount of resuscitative fluid required in the post burn period. The early mobility found by using lyophilised allograft on hand skin covering joint sites is largely due to relief of pain and reduction in bulky dressings. At the same time early dispersal of oedema occurs.We would like to thank the Consultants at Queen Victoria Hospital under whose care these patients came, and the Department of Medical Photography for their co-operation in this trial.     

Influence of a temporary synthetic skin substitute on capillary stasis in burns

Summary The prognosis of deep partial thickness burns depends on several factors e.g. infection, wound dehydration, mechanical trauma etc. As shown by Zawacki years ago, the prognosis can be influenced by immediate post-burn application of various dressings. Appropriate dressings can cause early reversal of the capillary stasis zone, improving the prognosis. In his study, Zawacki showed that he could achieve the best results by using porcine skin grafts. In our study, we repeated Zawacki's experimental model, replacing porcine skin graft with a temporary synthetic skin substitute, Omiderm®. Deep partial thickness burns were inflicted on guinea pigs, who were then divided into three groups and treated as follows: removal of burn blister, burn blister left intact and removal of burn blister which was then replaced by Omiderm. At various times the animals were sacrificed and perfusion with India ink was performed in order to evaluate capillary stasis and its reversal. Upon statistical analysis of results we found that by using Omiderm we achieved early reversal of the stasis zone, as compared to the other groups. It seems to us that appropriate early treatment of deep partial thickness burns can make a significant difference to the prognosis of the burn wound.     

Negative pressure dressing assisted healing in pediatric burn patients

Background/Purpose

Pediatric burn patients traditionally require multiple dressing changes and significant amounts of narcotics. Negative pressure dressings (NPDs) have emerged as an effective wound therapy that may represent an alternative primary dressing for these patients.

Methods

This is a single institution, retrospective study of pediatric burn patients treated with NPDs over a defined 2 year period. Twenty-two patients were identified and their charts reviewed for age, sex, mode of injury, location of injury, degree of burn, length of stay, length of dressing required, number of dressing changes, and narcotic use between dressing changes.

Results

The average patient was 3.5 years old (range of 8 months to 10 years old) with partial thickness burns involving 8.5% (range 3–18%) body surface area. The average treatment regimen was 3.5 dressing changes more than 6.6 days, with a mean hospital stay of 9.6 days. The average child received 9.4 total doses of delivered narcotics during their inpatient care.

Discussion

The use of NPD in pediatric burn patients does require sedation and narcotics which limits its usefulness in the general pediatric burn population. Yet, they adhere well and stay in place even on active children, they capture and quantify fluid losses, they only require changes every 2–4 days and promote the adherence of split thickness skin grafts making them useful in various clinical situations.

Conclusions

NPDs are a viable option for both partial and full thickness burns in pediatric patients that do not require transfer to a burn unit. NPDs may be advantageous in highly active children, those with extensive fluid losses, those that require sedation for dressing changes and those that will require grafting.     

A prospective,randomized trial of silver containing hydrofiber dressing versus 1% silver sulfadiazine for the treatment of partial thickness burns

Silver sulfadiazine has been used as a topical burn wound treatment for many years. Pain associated with dressing changes is a common problem in burn wounds. Aquacel Ag, a hydrofiber dressing coated with ionic silver has been reported to reduce burn wound infection and promote antimicrobial activity. The purpose of this study was to show the benefits of Aquacel Ag for the treatment of partial thickness burns. This prospective randomized study was conducted in 70 patients who had partial thickness burns less than 15% of total body surface area and were treated at Siriraj outpatient burn clinic during December 2006–February 2008. Patients were divided into two groups: Aquacel Ag‐treated group with dressing changes every 3 days (35 patients) and 1% silver sulfadiazine‐treated group, with daily dressing changes (35 patients). There was no difference in demographic data including age, gender, burn percentage between groups. Time‐to‐wound healing pain score during dressing change and cost of treatment were compared between both groups. Time‐to‐wound closure was significantly shorter in the Aquacel Ag‐treated group (10 ± 3 versus 13.7 ± 4 days, P < 0·02) as well as pain scores at days 1, 3 and 7 (4·1 ± 2·1, 2·1 ± 1·8, 0·9 ± 1·4 versus 6·1 ± 2·3, 5·2 ± 2·1, 3·3 ± 1·9, respectively, P < 0·02). Total cost of treatment was 52 ± 29 US dollars for the Aquacel Ag‐treated group versus 93 ± 36 US dollars for the silver sulfadiazine‐treated group. This study showed that Aquacel Ag increased time to healing, decreased pain symptoms and increased patient convenience because of limiting the frequency of replacement of the dressing at lower total cost. This study confirms the efficacy of Aquacel Ag for the treatment of partial thickness burns at an outpatient clinic.     

Porcine dermal collagen as a wound dressing for skin donor sites and deep partial skin thickness burns

Collagen was extracted by pepsin digestion from porcine skin, and collagen membrane was prepared by salt precipitation. The porcine collagen membrane was evaluated as a burn wound dressing in deep partial skin thickness burn wounds in rats. Burn wounds, 4 × 4 cm, were inflicted by exposure of skin to 75°C for 15 s followed by de-epithelialization. Wound healing was assessed by planimetry of epithelialization on day 10 after injury. Open wounds exhibited 24 per cent of wound area re-epithelialized. Collagen membrane dressing significantly improved the healing to 69 per cent of wound area (P < 0.0001). In a completely separate experiment, the porcine collagen membrane was applied as a wound dressing to the donor sites of burn patients, and its effect on wound healing was compared with that of a petroleum jelly gauze dressing. The donor sites covered with petroleum jelly gauze had re-epithelialized by an average of 14.5 days (ranging from 13 to 16 days) after wounding. The wounds dressed with collagen membrane demonstrated a significant increase in the healing rate. Complete re-epithelialization was observed by 10.3 days (ranging from 10 to 12 days) after wounding (P < 0.0001).     

Comparison of E-Z Derm and Jelonet dressings for partial skin thickness burns

A prospective, randomized trial of 32 patients with partial skin thickness burns is reported comparing E-Z Derm with Jelonet as a burn dressing. The bacterial colonization rate, need for surgical treatment, time for spontaneous healing, analgesic requirements and frequency of dressing changes were assessed in each group. No statistically significant differences were found between the two groups, for any of these factors.     

Treatment of second degree facial burns with allografts--preliminary results

Facial burns are very common and have significant clinical impact. However, the treatment regimen for superficial to deep facial burns is not well defined. The purpose of this study was to investigate the effects of cadaver skin grafting in deep partial thickness facial burns in comparison to standard care. In a prospective open study design severely injured patients with superficial and deep partial thickness burns were randomized into the group receiving open treatment with silversulfadiazine (standard n=5) or into the group receiving early superficial debridement followed by coverage with glycerolized cadaver skin (n=5). The outcome measures were time and quality of wound healing, and incidence of hypertrophic scarring at 3 and 6 months post burn. There were no significant differences in demographics between groups. In the group treated with the allogenic material time to reepithelialization was 10.5 days, while it was 12.4 days in the silversulfadiazine group (p<0.05). Scar quality was found to be significantly improved in the allogenic treatment group. Three and 6 months postburn there were no patients with significant hypertrophic scarring in the allogenic group while there were two patients who developed hypertrophic scars in the silversulfadiazine group (p<0.05). In this study, we demonstrated that glyzerolized cadaver allograft skin represents a superior biological dressing for shallow and deep partial thickness facial burns. This is in concordance with other reports on scalds. It would be worthwhile to perform more clinical studies with a larger number of patients to further evaluate the effect and function of allogenic skin for facial burns.     

HydroColloid dressing (Duoderm) for the treatment of superficial and deep partial thickness burns

HydroColloid Dressing (Duoderm, HCD) is a new kind of dressing, based on the fact that occlusion can provide an optimum wound environment for quick re-epithelialization. Seventy patients with superficial and deep partial thickness burns of up to 7% TBSA were treated with HCD. In 16 patients a second burned area, similar in size and depth of the burn treated with HCD, was treated with human allografts or silversulfadiazine (SSD). Five patients with very small full thickness burns were also treated with HCD. In three patients (4.5%) the treatment with HCD had to be discontinued before total re-epithelialization had occurred, for various reasons. Statistically, HCD provided faster re-epithelialization than allografts or SSD. The cosmetic and functional results were excellent. After six months only one patient was found to have a small area of hypertrophy. In this study HCD was found to be a very good dressing for the treatment of smaller partial thickness burns.     

Management of partial thickness facial burns (comparison of topical antibiotics and bio-engineered skin substitutes).

This study compared the effect of standard topical antibiotic management versus a biological skin substitute wound closure for mid-partial thickness burns of the face. Adult patients with mid-dermal facial burns produced by flash flames or flame exposure were studied using a randomized prospective study design. Total daily burn care time, pain (0-10 scale) and healing time were monitored. Immediately after partial thickness debridement, the entire face burn, including ears, was closed with a bioengineered skin substitute coated with fibronectin (TransCyte) or treated by the open technique using bacitracin ointment applied 2-3 times daily. 21 patients were studied, with 10 patients in the skin substitute group. We found a significant decrease in wound care time 0.35 +/- 0.1 versus 1.9 +/- 0.5 h, decrease in pain of 2 +/- 1 versus 4 +/- 2 and re-epithelialization time 7 +/- 2 versus 13 +/- 4 days in the skin substitute group compared to topical antibiotics. We can conclude that a bioengineered skin substitute significantly improves the management and healing rate of partial thickness facial burns, compared to the standard open topical ointment technique.