Specific IgE to cross-reactive carbohydrate determinants strongly affect the in vitro diagnosis of allergic diseases

BACKGROUND: Cross-reacting carbohydrate determinants (CCDs) are antigenic structures shared by allergenic components from taxonomically distant sources. The case history of a patient with a great discrepancy between skin test and specific IgE results led us to investigate the role of these determinants in his specific case and in an allergic population. OBJECTIVE: We sought to determine the role of CCDs in causing false-positive and clinically irrelevant results in in vitro tests. METHODS: The involvement of CCDs was studied by specific IgE inhibition by using glycoproteins with a known carbohydrate structure. Direct and inhibition assays were performed by commercially available systems, in-house ELISA, and the immunoblotting technique. The binding to the periodate-oxidated carbohydrate structure of glycoproteins and allergenic extracts was also evaluated. A comparative study between skin test and specific IgE responses to the antigens studied was carried out in 428 consecutive allergic subjects. RESULTS: All the tests performed suggested that cross-reacting carbohydrate epitopes were the cause of false-positive specific IgE results in one of the commercial systems and the high reactivity in all the solid-phase in vitro tests. None of the cross-reacting carbohydrate allergens yielded a positive skin test response. Periodate treatment caused variable degrees of reduction of IgE binding to the different antigens studied, indicating that CCDs played a different role in each of them. About 41% of patients allergic to pollen had specific IgE for a glycoprotein, without a positive skin test response to the same molecule. CONCLUSIONS: CCDs must be taken into account when evaluating the clinical relevance of positive results in in vitro specific IgE assays, at least in the diagnosis of patients with pollen allergy. Commercial systems should be carefully assessed for the ability to detect specific IgE for carbohydrate determinants to avoid false-positive or clinically irrelevant results.     

Biological activity of IgE specific for cross-reactive carbohydrate determinants

BACKGROUND: The clinical relevance of IgE specific for cross-reactive carbohydrate determinants (CCDs) has been a matter of controversy. Until now, no convincing experiments have been performed to test the biologic significance of individual multivalent allergens that carry multiple carbohydrate epitopes. OBJECTIVE: We sought to contribute to the understanding of the role of CCD-specific IgE antibodies and to study whether CCD-specific IgE antibodies are able to activate basophils using different multivalent glycoproteins as antigens. METHODS: Purified natural tomato beta-fructofuranosidase (nLyc e 2) and rLyc e 2.02 expressed in Escherichia coli were compared by means of histamine release tests. In addition, native and deglycosylated horseradish peroxidase and a neoglycoprotein consisting of a defined glycopeptide (Manalpha1-6[Xylbeta1-2]Manbeta1-4GlcNAcbeta1-4[Fucalpha1-3]GlcNAc) coupled to BSA were used in histamine release assays using stripped basophils from normal donors resensitized with IgE from CCD-reactive patients with food allergy to tomato. RESULTS: Ten CCD-positive and 2 CCD-negative sera from patients with tomato allergy underwent histamine release testing by using the glycoproteins and nonglycosylated controls as antigens, respectively. All sera induced histamine release with tomato extract (up to 100%), confirming the allergic status of the donors. Four of the CCD-positive sera induced releases ranging from 12% to 82% with all of the glycoproteins but not with the nonglycosylated or monovalent controls. All other sera showed no response or only very weak response to the glycoproteins. CONCLUSION: Approximately one third of the CCD-positive sera from patients with tomato allergy have biologically relevant CCD-specific IgE antibodies. Therefore the general claim that CCD-specific IgE is clinically irrelevant has to be reconsidered critically. Hence IgE specific for CCDs should be taken into consideration in the diagnosis and therapy of certain allergies. In the subgroup of patients sensitized to CCDs, the use of natural allergens should be preferred over the use of recombinant allergens expressed in prokaryotic organisms.     

Sensitization to cross-reactive carbohydrate determinants in relation to alcohol consumption

Background Alcohol consumption is associated with increased serum IgE of unknown specificity. Objective To investigate the prevalence of specific IgE to cross‐reactive carbohydrate determinants (CCDs) in adults, and its relation to alcohol consumption. Methods Population‐based survey of 457 adults (218 abstainers, 195 light‐to‐moderate drinkers, 44 heavy drinkers). Specific IgE determinations included a CCD (MUXF³, the N‐glycan of bromelain), pollens (Lolium perenne and Olea europaea), Hymenoptera venoms (Apis mellifera and Vespula spp.), and a mite (Dermatophagoides pteronyssinus). We replicated these studies in an additional sample of alcoholics (n=138). Inhibition assays were performed in selected cases. Results In the general population, 5.6% of individuals (95% confidence interval 3.5–7.6%) showed positive (0.35 kU/L) CCD‐specific IgE. The levels of CCD‐specific IgE were particularly high in heavy drinkers, who also showed a high prevalence of positive IgE to pollens and Hymenoptera venoms, doubling (at least) the prevalence found in alcohol abstainers and light‐to‐moderate drinkers. The presence of IgE to pollens and Hymenoptera venoms was closely correlated with the presence of CCD‐specific IgE. These features were confirmed in the additional sample of alcoholics. Inhibition studies indicated a role of CCD interference in IgE positivity to pollen and Hymenoptera allergens in alcoholics. Conclusions CCD‐specific IgE is prevalent in heavy drinkers, and is associated with positive IgE to pollens and Hymenoptera venoms. Specific IgE results should be interpreted with caution in heavy drinkers.     

Sensitization to cross-reactive carbohydrate determinants and the ubiquitous protein profilin: mimickers of allergy

BACKGROUND: During the last decade, evidence has been provided for profilins and cross-reactive carbohydrate determinants (CCDs) to be capable of inducing cross-reactive IgE antibodies with little clinical relevance. OBJECTIVE: To investigate the prevalence of sensitization to CCD and profilin in isolated allergies (birch, timothy grass, house dust mite, pets (cat and/or dog), natural rubber latex (NRL) and hymenoptera venom). To study the contribution of anti-CCD and anti-profilin IgE antibodies as a cause of clinically irrelevant IgE for NRL and apple. METHODS: For the first part of the study, 100 patients with inhalant allergy, 17 patients with NRL allergy and 40 patients with venom anaphylaxis were enrolled. Diagnosis was based on a questionnaire and a positive IgE determination and skin test for relevant allergen. Patients were identified as sensitized to CCD if they had a negative prick test and positive IgE for the glycoprotein bromelain. Sensitization to profilin was assessed by IgE for rBet v 2 (recombinant birch profilin). For the second part of the study, sera containing IgE against apple (n=82) or NRL (n=38) were classified as true-negative or false-positive according to the presence or absence of an oral allergy syndrome (OAS) or NRL-induced anaphylaxis. In these patients, sensitization to CCD and profilin was evaluated as described above. RESULTS: No sensitization to bromelain-type CCD and profilin was found in isolated birch pollen or NRL allergy. In contrast, sensitization to bromelain-type CCD was found in 4/17 patients with isolated grass pollinosis, 5/24 patients with combined pollinosis (birch, timothy, mugwort) and 7/33 patients with venom anaphylaxis. Sensitization to profilin was almost restricted to patients with combined pollen allergy (5/24). In pollen-allergic individuals with a false-positive IgE against NRL the prevalence of sensitization to bromelain-type CCD and profilin IgE was higher than in NRL-allergic patients (P<0.00001 and P=0.0006, respectively). In pollen-allergic individuals with a false-positive IgE to apple, the frequency of sensitization to bromelain-type CCD was higher than in OAS patients (P=0.004). Clinically irrelevant NRL and apple were also found in four and five out of the seven patients sensitized to venom CCD, respectively. In pollinosis, clinically irrelevant NRL and apple IgE antibodies were inhibited by bromelain and recombinant birch profilin, whereas in isolated venom anaphylaxis these antibodies were inhibited by bromelain. CONCLUSIONS: Patients monoallergic to NRL or birch pollen showed no sensitization to bromelain-type CCD or profilin. Sensitization to profilin and/or bromelain-type CCD, caused by pollen (timothy grass, mugwort) or hymenoptera venom allergens, can elicit false-positive IgE antibodies against NRL and apple.     

Characterization of peptidic and carbohydrate cross-reactive determinants in pollen polysensitization

Background Cross‐reactivity may be due to protein sequence or domain homologies and/or the existence of cross‐reactive carbohydrate determinants (CCDs). The clinical relevance of peptidic cross‐reactivities is well known, whereas that of CCDs is still a question of debate. The aim of this study is to characterize the IgE specificity of various patients suffering from pollen polysensitization to identify both peptidic and carbohydrate cross‐reactive determinants. Material and methods Rapeseed, grass and Arabidopsis proteins were separated by isoelectric focusing, followed by SDS‐PAGE, and transferred to a nitrocellulose sheet. The sheets were incubated either with an individual serum from a birch+grass‐sensitive patient, followed by anti‐human IgE, or with labelled Concanavalin A (ConA). Binding inhibition was tested by incubation of the sera with a mixture of sugar residues. Results The results showed two different patterns of cross‐reacting sera: a pattern that implies few proteins, not always glycosylated and known as allergens, and a pattern that implies numerous proteins with molecular masses over 30 kDa. This second pattern was very close to the ConA ‐binding pattern. The IgE binding was abolished by pre‐incubation with sugar residues only in the case of the second pattern. Discussion This study shows that multiple pollen sensitizations could result from multiple sensitizations to specific proteins or from a cross‐sensitization to a wide range of glycoproteins. Two‐D blots allow to characterize a cross‐sensitization due to carbohydrate determinants, and thus to improve the diagnosis of allergy and its medical treatment.     

In vitro hymenoptera venom allergy diagnosis: improved by screening for cross-reactive carbohydrate determinants and reciprocal inhibition

BACKGROUND: Immunoglobulin (Ig) E-double positivity for honeybee (HB) and yellow jacket (YJ) venom causes diagnostic difficulties concerning therapeutical strategies. The aim of this study was to clarify the cause and relation of the cross-reactivity in patients with insect venom allergy. METHODS: For this purpose, 147 patients with suspected stinging insect allergy and CAP-FEIA-double positivity were investigated for specific sIgE to additional cross-reactive carbohydrate determinant (CCD)-containing allergens: timothy grass pollen, rape pollen, natural rubber latex (NRL), bromelain, and horseradish peroxidase (HRP). Sera with sIgE to NRL were further investigated with the commercially available recombinant latex allergens. Reciprocal inhibition assays with both venoms and HRP were performed. RESULTS: About 36 of 147 (24.5%) patients had sIgE to both venoms only. However, 111 of 147 (75.5%) additionally reacted to CCD-carrying allergens. 89 of 111 CCD-reactive sera had NRL-sIgE. In cases where inhibition experiments were performed, the NRL-sIgE binding was completely abolished in the presence of HRP. Only nine of 61 sera were positive for at least one recombinant latex allergen; all of them were negative in history and NRL-skin prick test. In 43 sera containing sIgE to CCD, HRP inhibition revealed unequivocal results: In 28 of 43 (65%) an HRP-inhibition >70% of sIgE to one venom occurred, pointing out the relevant venom. In three of 43 sIgE proved to be entirely CCD-specific. CONCLUSIONS: Our data indicate that in cases of IgE positivity to both insect venoms supplementary screening tests with at least one CCD-containing allergen should be performed; HRP being a suitable tool for this test. In addition, subsequent reciprocal inhibition is an essential diagnostic method to specify cross-reacting sIgE results.     

Natural rubber latex and hymenoptera venoms share ImmunoglobinE-epitopes accounting for cross-reactive carbohydrate determinants

BACKGROUND: Epidemiological data on the prevalence and risk factors of latex sensitization have suggested a significant association between latex sensitization and the presence of one or more positive skin prick test responses to aeroallergens, food allergens and to one or more insect venoms. Xylose and core 3-fucose are typical complex glycans in plants and are foreign to mammals. Plant N-glycans and insect N-glycans may cross-react in humans. OBJECTIVE: The aim of our study was to investigate whether there are cross-reactive IgE-binding structures in natural rubber latex (NRL) and hymenoptera venoms and to examine their nature. METHODS: Hundred and twenty-five consecutive patients with insect venom allergy were screened for coincidental latex-specific IgE. IgE-binding components in the venoms from Apis mellifera and/or vespula species and in NRL extracts were characterized by IgE-immunoblotting to the natural allergen sources and determination of specific IgE to recombinant allergens. Cross-reactive components were investigated by inhibition experiments. The involvement of carbohydrates in the constitution of cross-reactive IgE-epitopes was further examined by specific IgE-binding to cross-reactive carbohydrate determinants (CCD) in bromelain and horseradish peroxidase as well as by periodate treatment. RESULTS: NRL glove extracts inhibited patients' serum IgE-binding to venom allergens. Vice versa, the IgE-binding to latex glove extracts could be inhibited by pre-incubation with the insect venoms. Specific IgE-binding to recombinant latex allergens was absent, whereas the cross-reactive IgE-epitopes were sensitive to periodate treatment and specific IgE to CCD (MMXF and MUXF type) could be detected. CONCLUSION: Insect venoms and NRL share IgE-binding CCD that may be responsible for positive serological test results to NRL in patients with insect venom allergy. This copositivity occurs frequently (13.6%) among venom-allergic individuals and did not elicit clinical symptoms upon contact to latex in the patients examined. In contrast, true cosensitization to insect venoms and NRL allergens can occur and may not be missed.     

Basophil sensitivity and reactivity to monoclonal anti-human IgE afterin vitro sensitization with human myeloma IgE

Leucocytes from human peripheral blood were acid eluted and sensitizedin vitro with increasing concentrations of radiolabelled myeloma IgE. This sensitization step was performed with or without 30% IgE depleted serum. After the IgE binding, cells were washed and submitted to a challenge with monoclonal anti-IgE for the determination of the cellular sensitivity and reactivity in a histamine release assay. A sample of each of the sensitized cells was analyzed for its radioactivity and the number of basophils quantified, thus allowing the determination of the mean number of IgE molecules per basophil. Raising the IgE concentrations in the sensitization procedure led to an increase of the IgE on the basophil membrane, and to a concommitant elevation of the cell sensitivity. The presence of serum during the binding of IgE onto the cells lowers slightly the binding of IgE to the basophils but decreases strongly the cellular reactivity.     

Factors influencing human IgE synthesis in vitro and in vivo

Several pitfalls may affect studies on human IgE synthesis in vitro. In this paper, the requirement for stringent specificity of the anti-IgE antibodies used and for assessment not only of IgE detectable in culture supernatants but also as cell-associated IgE is emphasized. The use of cycloheximide-treated cultures as controls also leaves wishes open. Activated, human T cells and T cell hybridomas produce IgE-binding factors, which may be detected by a sensitive in vitro test and which may apparently also become the endeavour of synthesis by molecular biological techniques. Although the evidence available in rodents for the role of IgE-binding factors in modulating IgE synthesis has not yet been fully reproduced by us in man, the fact that classical IgE-enhancing procedures in rodents (e.g. radiotherapy, T cell suppression) also affect IgE production in man leads to believe that similar immunoregulation mechanisms apply to various mammalian species studied so far.     

Topological distribution of virus-specific and cross-reactive antigenic determinants on the gB glycoprotein of the herpes simplex viruses

The antigenic properties and relations between the herpes simplex virus type 1 and 2 (HSV1, HSV2) gB glycoproteins were investigated. Using several assay systems to analyze the virus-specific reactivity of polyclonal monospecific rabbit anti-gB sera, it was demonstrated that most of the antigenic determinants of the gB glycoproteins exposed at the surface of both virions and infected cells are virus-specific rather than cross-reactive. Comparative examination of the reactivity of human immune sera with HSV1 and HSV2 antigens by immunoblotting also revealed differences in the ability of HSV1 and HSV2 immune sera to recognize homologous vs. heterologous gB antigens. These results indicate that despite the high degree of amino acid sequence homology which exists between the HSV1 and HSV2 gB glycoproteins many of the immunologically relevant antigenic determinants of the gB glycoproteins probably reside in regions of the molecule which are not so highly conserved between the two HSV serotypes.     

Effects of retinoids on in vitro and in vivo IgE production

BACKGROUND: Retinoids modulate the growth and number of different cell types, including B cells. We could previously show that retinoic acid (RA) strongly inhibits CD40 + IL-4-mediated IgE production in vitro. The aim of the present study was to extend these findings regarding the potential use of retinoids for the treatment of allergic diseases. METHODS: In vitro IgE production was studied in anti-CD40 + IL-4-stimulated peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) from allergic donors in the presence of 10(-15)-10(-5) M all-trans and 13-cis RA and in ovalbumin (OVA)-sensitized BALB/c mice treated with RA (20 mg/kg) before and during sensitization. IgE and IgG1 levels were determined in the sera of the mice at day 21 after 2 injections (days 1 and 8) of aluminum hydroxide-absorbed OVA. RESULTS: All-trans and 13-cis RA inhibited in vitro IgE production from PBMC in a dose-dependent manner, but were more efficient in atopic dermatitis patients with low total serum IgE levels (< 400 kU/ml), maximal inhibition for all-trans RA at 10(-7) M (87%) and for 13-cis RA at 10(-5) M (96%) compared to patients with high serum IgE levels (>2,000 kU/ml), maximal inhibition for both all-trans and 13-cis RA at 10(-5) M (53 and 39%, respectively). In contrast, the in vivo data from OVA-sensitized mice revealed comparable total IgE and IgG1 levels in control versus all-trans RA or CD336-treated groups, specific IgE was even higher in the CD336-treated group (n = 10, 2,814 ng/ml), and was comparable in mice treated with OVA alone or with additional all-trans RA (n = 10, 1,447 and 1,354 ng/ml, respectively). CONCLUSIONS: These results indicate that the efficacy of retinoids to inhibit IgE production in vitro depends on the frequency of switched cells in the peripheral blood and that in an in vivo model using OVA-sensitized mice, retinoids fail to inhibit IgE production.