Between pregnancy biological variability of first trimester markers of Down syndrome and the implications for screening in subsequent pregnancies: an issue revisited

OBJECTIVES: To assess the level of correlation of first trimester biochemical and biophysical markers of Down syndrome between different pregnancies in the same individual. To assess the impact that between pregnancy biological variability has on the likelihood that women who are at increased risk in a first pregnancy being also at increased risk in a subsequent pregnancy. METHODS: During a three period women attending the OSCAR clinic at Harold Wood Hospital have had the opportunity to have first trimester screening for Down syndrome and other aneuploidies using the maternal serum biochemical markers free beta-human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) and pregnancy associated plasma protein-A (PAPP-A) in conjunction with fetal nuchal translucency (NT) thickness and maternal age. Of the 111,105 women undergoing such screening, the computer records were examined for women who had more than one pregnancy. The results from 1002 women with two normal singleton pregnancies were available for analysis. Marker correlations (as MoM) were established between the pregnancies and the proportion of women likely to be at increased risk in each pregnancy estimated, as was the likelihood of women being at increased risk in both pregnancies. RESULTS: For fetal NT there was no correlation between NT MoM in the first and second pregnancy (r = 0.0959, p > 0.10). For maternal serum free beta-hCG MoM a significant correlation was found (r = 0.3976, p < 0.001), as was also found for PAPP-A MoM (r = 0.4371, p < 0.001). CONCLUSION: The implication for such between pregnancy marker association is that women who have an increased risk of Down syndrome in one pregnancy are two or three times more likely to repeat this event in their next pregnancy. This information may be useful in counselling women when undergoing first trimester screening in a subsequent pregnancy.     

Gender impact on first trimester markers in Down syndrome screening

The influence of fetal gender on the level in the first trimester of the serological markers alpha-fetoprotein (AFP), pregnancy-associated plasma protein-A (PAPP-A) and free beta human chorionic gonadotropin (betahCG) and on nuchal translucency is described for 2637 singleton pregnancies with normal outcome. Mean log MoM values for pregnancies with female and male fetuses were calculated using regression of log marker values on gestational age expressed as crown rump length and on maternal weight. A pronounced gender impact was found for free betahCG, being 16% higher for female than for male fetuses.     

Effect of fetal gender on first trimester markers and on Down syndrome screening.

OBJECTIVES: The purpose of the present study was to evaluate whether a gender-related difference exists in first trimester markers used for Down syndrome screening, namely nuchal translucency (NT), maternal serum pregnancy-associated plasma protein-A (PAPP-A), and free beta-human chorionic gonadotrophin (beta-hCG), and whether this has an influence on screening performance. METHODS: A total of 1325 patients with a singleton pregnancy underwent combined first trimester screening at 10-13 weeks' gestation. Maternal serum PAPP-A and free beta-hCG were analyzed by fluoroimmunoassay, nuchal translucency (NT) was measured by transvaginal sonography. Only patients with normal outcomes and known fetal gender were included in the study. Data were categorized by gestational age and by fetal gender. RESULTS: There were no significant gender-related differences in NT and PAPP-A levels. However, free beta-hCG was significantly higher (p=0.00004) in the presence of a female fetus than in the presence of a male fetus. Women with female fetuses had a higher median calculated Down syndrome risk (1:5490) compared to those having males (1:6451). This difference was not, however, statistically significant. CONCLUSION: First trimester free beta-hCG is significantly higher in pregnancies with a female fetus.     

First trimester screening for Down syndrome in multiple pregnancy

The incidence of twins, triplets, and high-order multiples has increased substantially in the last two decades secondary to fertility treatments and to delayed childbearing. Prenatal diagnosis in these patients is challenging. Options for screening tests are limited. First trimester screening for Down syndrome in patients with multiples appears promising. This paper will review the advantages of first trimester screening in this high-risk patient population.     

Age-independent first trimester screening for Down syndrome: analysis of three modified software programs with 6,508 pregnancies

Background  

The conventional first trimester screening (FTS) method integrates maternal age into risk calculation. It was suggested that this concept increases the false-positive rate in older, and the false-negative rate in younger mothers.     

First trimester Down syndrome screening: public health implications

Down syndrome (DS) screening has been an integral part of routine prenatal screening for the last three decades. Recent efforts have been directed at developing additional non-invasive prenatal screening techniques that could not only improve sensitivity of prenatal screening, but also be employed in the first trimester to offer earlier diagnostic and interventional opportunities. Nuchal translucency has proven to be an effective and cost-effective screening test that, when combined with serum markers (hCG and pregnancy-associated plasma protein [PAPP-A]) in the first and/or second trimester, broadens the diagnostic possibilities and improves the diagnostic capabilities of current prenatal DS screening methods. Despite the potential benefits, significant operational issues regarding access to and availability of such testing may limit its widespread application and necessitates the maintenance of both non-sonographic and second trimester screening methods. The implementation of first trimester DS testing requires the development and maintenance of nationally standardized quality control systems to ensure the reliability of serum and ultrasound measurements and the accurate assessment of risk. Future efforts to improve prenatal screening should continue to emphasize the need for improved access to all aspects of prenatal care, stress the importance of provider education and the necessity for extensive patient counseling, and reinforce the role of patient education and choice.     

Second trimester prenatal screening for Down syndrome: the associations between the levels of serum markers in successive pregnancies

OBJECTIVE: To investigate the association of Down syndrome screening results in successive pregnancies, and assess the impacts of including previous screening results in the current risk estimation on screening performance. METHODS: The study was based on 56,951 women who had triple marker screening in two or more singleton pregnancies in the Ontario Maternal Serum Screening (MSS) program between October 1993 and September 2000. The problem of recurrent false positive results was examined by comparing screening results from different pregnancies in the same individuals. Between-pregnancy associations in the levels of serum markers were estimated using correlation analysis. A published method was used to adjust current risk estimation for previous screening results. The effect of this adjustment was assessed by comparing screening performances prior and subsequent to the adjustment. RESULTS: The observed false positive rate (FPR) in subsequent pregnancies was 2.5 times higher than that expected (26.4% vs 10.7%) among women who screened positive in one previous pregnancy, and 3.9 times higher (47.4% vs 12.1%) among women who screened positive in two previous pregnancies. Adjusting for a previous screening result will significantly reduce the recurrent FPR without compromising detection. CONCLUSION: Risk estimation for Down syndrome may be adjusted using the screening result from a previous pregnancy.     

The first trimester 'combined test' for the detection of Down syndrome pregnancies in 4939 unselected pregnancies

The high detection rate (DR) for Down syndrome (DS) pregnancies which can be achieved by measuring fetal nuchal translucency (NT) early in pregnancy can be improved by combining it with placental hormones [pregnancy-associated plasma protein A (PAPP-A) and free beta-human chorionic gonadotrophin (fbeta-hCG)] and maternal age ('combined test'). In this study we wanted to assess the DR using the 'combined test' in an unselected population of self-referred pregnant women at a false-positive rate (FPR) of about 5%. NT, PAPP-A, fbeta-hCG and maternal age were measured in all women with singleton pregnancies who booked for delivery in our hospital from 1 December 1997 to 31 April 2000 and who were between 10 and 13 completed weeks of gestation [crown-rump length (CRL) 35-70 mm]. The specific DS risk was calculated using the computer program Alpha Version 5aa (Logical Medical Systems, London, UK). A total of 4939 women were tested. Out of 14 DS pregnancies that occurred during this period of time, 12 were detected with the test. A total of 246 women had a false-positive test result in a non-DS pregnancy (FPR 5.0%). This makes the 'combined test' by far the best test for the detection of DS pregnancies in a low-risk population. The constant increase in maternal age at the time of delivery can also lead to an improved DR if a simple age-dependant protocol for DS detection is used, but only at the price of a much higher number of amniocenteses and subsequent abortions. The DR for DS can be increased much more markedly using the 'combined test' with a FPR that still remains at the level as it was in the early 1970s.     

SP1 in pregnancies with Down syndrome in the first trimester of pregnancy. International Prenatal Screening Research Group.

We conducted a study to determine the value of serum pregnancy-specific beta-1-glycoprotein (Schwangerschafts protein 1, SP1) as an antenatal screening test for Down syndrome in the first trimester. Serum samples collected from women at 8 to 14 weeks of pregnancy, immediately prior to having a chorionic villus sampling procedure on account of advanced maternal age, were retrieved from 96 women with Down syndrome pregnancies (cases) and from 480 women with unaffected pregnancies (controls). Cases and controls were ascertained at 21 obstetric centres in nine countries. Each case was matched with five controls for maternal age (same five-year age groups), duration of storage of the serum sample (same calendar year) and gestational age (usually the same week of pregnancy). The levels of SP1 were lower in pregnancies associated with Down syndrome: the median level was 0.86 multiples of the median level in the controls (95 per cent confidence interval 0.76 to 0.97). This difference, though statistically significant, was not large enough for SP1 to be a useful marker in screening, at least from 10 weeks onwards where most of our data lie.     

Maternal serum screening for Down syndrome in the first trimester: experience from Belarus.

We have carried out a large retrospective study of alpha-fetoprotein (AFP), free-beta human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) and pregnancy-associated plasma protein (PAPP-A) in the first trimester of pregnancy. Unlike other studies all women had routine ultrasound dating, carried out during a nuchal translucency measurement project. A total of 13,477 serum samples were tested for AFP and 11,659 for free beta-hCG. A subset of 1564 samples from unaffected pregnancies were also tested for PAPP-A on a case-control basis. All three markers were also determined in 31 samples from pregnancies with Down syndrome. Equations were derived to express results in multiples of the median using both gestational age and crown rump length and to adjust for maternal weight. Statistical modelling with Gaussian distribution parameters obtained in the study were used to predict the detection rate for a 5 per cent false-positive rate. The predicted rates were: 73.7 per cent for all three markers; 69.1 per cent for PAPP-A and free beta-hCG; 47.4 per cent for PAPP-A and AFP; 57.6 per cent for free beta-hCG and AFP. As these rates are similar to those in the second trimester, health planners may now want to consider a change in policy from second-trimester to first-trimester screening with biochemical markers.     

Down syndrome screening in multiple pregnancies

First or second trimester screening in twin pregnancies is feasible and still efficacious by using either a combination of ultrasound and maternal serum biochemistry in the first trimester or maternal serum biochemistry in the second trimester. Special care, however, should be emphasized in what concerns biochemical screening, since it is much less sensitive in multiples. These "pseudo-risks" have been challenged for their scientific and clinical validity, however. Until more data are available from larger studies on the distribution of markers in concordant or discordant twins, nuchal translucency estimated for each fetus should be the predominant factor by which women who present with increased risk should be counseled regarding invasive testing. In dizygotic pregnancies, pregnancy-specific risk should be calculated by summing the individual risk estimates for each fetus. In monozygotic twins, the risk should be calculated based on the geometric mean of both nuchal translucency measurements, not forgetting that the false-positive rate of nuchal translucency screening is expectantly higher than in singletons.     

Diagnosis of fetal acrania during the first trimester nuchal translucency screening for Down syndrome.

OBJECTIVES: Prenatal screening during the first-trimester using fetal nuchal translucency (NT) measurement and maternal serum levels of free beta-human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) and pregnancy-associated plasma protein-A (PAPP-A) has become an established method for the detection of fetal Down syndrome. Increasing evidence has shown that some of the fetal structural abnormalities could be identified during NT scanning. Second trimester maternal serum alpha-fetoprotein (MSAFP) measurements and ultrasound scans have been widely used in clinical practice to identify fetal neural tube defects (NTDs). In this study, we evaluated the effectiveness of early diagnosis of fetal acrania during NT scanning. METHODS: We reviewed the medical records of 5890 pregnancies that were delivered in our hospital between January 1, 1999 and January 31, 2001. Among them, 3600 pregnant women received NT-based Down syndrome screening at 10-13 weeks' gestation. Pregnancies with fetal NTDs were evaluated and their maternal serum levels of free beta-hCG and PAPP-A were compared with those of the normal control pregnancies. RESULTS: Seven of the 3600 pregnancies were identified with fetal acrania and all of them were detected during first-trimester NT scanning. Among the seven cases, five had measurements of maternal serum concentration free beta-hCG and PAPP-A concentration, yet there were not significant difference between the pregnancies with fetal acrania and those of the control pregnancies (PAPP-A, 1.13 vs. 0.96; free beta-hCG, 1.10 vs. 1.06; P>0.05). Two of the seven affected patients did not have maternal serum biochemical measurements due to the immediate termination of pregnancies. CONCLUSIONS: We demonstrated that pregnancies with fetal acrania could be easily identified at the time of NT scanning. Careful ultrasound inspection of fetal structure during NT measurements at 10-13 weeks of gestation provides an encouraging advantage for early diagnosis of fetal acrania.     

Fetal facial sonographic markers for second trimester Down syndrome screening in a Thai population

Objective

To assess the efficacy of using facial sonographic markers for screening fetuses in the second trimester for Down syndrome (DS) in a high-risk Thai population.

Method

Frontomaxillary facial angle (FMF) and nasal bone length (NBL) were measured prospectively in pregnant women at high-risk for DS who were undergoing genetic amniocentesis from November 2008 to October 2009. The receiver operator characteristic (ROC) curves were constructed to assess the screening efficacy of FMF angle and NBL.

Result

A total of 460 pregnant women were recruited, and a mid-sagittal facial profile was obtained for 403 fetuses. There were 386 fetuses with normal chromosomes, 10 fetuses with DS, 1 fetus with trisomy 13, and 1 fetus with trisomy 18. The remaining 5 fetuses had balanced translocation (n = 2), deletion (n = 1), and mosaic Turner (n = 2). Two different combinations of FMF angle and biparietal diameter to nasal bone length (BPD:NBL) ratio for DS screening in the second trimester achieved 50% and 90% detection rates and 4.4% and 14.0% false positive rates, respectively.

Conclusion

The combination of FMF angle and BPD:NBL ratio has a high sensitivity and specificity for screening for DS in the second trimester in a high-risk Thai population.