Enquête nationale sur la pratique des « Revues de morbi-mortalité » en réanimation

Objective

A national survey was conducted by the “Collège français d’anesthésie et de réanimation (CFAR)” and the “Collège des bonnes pratiques en réanimation (CBPR)”, to analyze the implementation of morbidity and mortality conferences (MMCs) in French intensive care units (ICUs).

Study design

An electronic questionnaire was set up. We directed the survey at French ICUs physicians registered in the two Colleges directories, only one form was filled in by each participating unit.

Results

From December 2009 to February 2010, Among the 170 replies, 120 ICUs (71%) practiced MMC. No difference in the typology of the two groups was found. The median annual number of MMCs was 4 per year (1-15). The perimeter of the MMCs concerned only the ICU unit in 70 cases (58%), more than one ICU unit in the same department in 11 cases (9.8%), more than one department of ICU in 16 cases (13%) and other departments in 57 cases (48%). The events analyzed were: all deaths in 45 cases (37.5%), unexpected deaths in 50 cases (41.7%), severe adverse events in 67 cases (55.8%) and other events in 19 cases (15.8%). At least one adverse event defined by the two colleges in the process of “accreditation” was analyzed in 86 cases (72%). Participation of a physician of at least one other unit was reported in 56 cases (47%) and of medical students in 62 cases (52%). The low rate of participation of ICU nurses was reported in 62 cases (69.2%) and their absence in 35 cases (29%). MMCs consequences were drafting of new procedure in 99 cases (83%), changes in procedures in 75 cases (63%), conducting training programs in 60 cases (50%), organizational changes in 86 cases (72%), adverse event declaration in 21 cases (18%) and monitoring indicators in 40 cases (33%). Among units which did not practice MMCs, Identified obstacles were organizational causes in 25 cases (50%), inexperience in seven cases (14%), lack of methodology in 4 cases (8%), realization of other methods of formative assessment in 4 cases (8%) and physician's refusal in three cases (6%). The fear of medico-legal problem was never reported as a barrier to MMCs practice. Forty-five units (90%) projected to practice MMR.

Conclusion

This survey showed that the practice of MMR is common in French ICUs, allowing the identification of organizational problems, but also of training needs, joining one of the initial concerns that have led to their implementation. Expanding the participation to non-physician members of the units should be encouraged, without underestimating the difficulties particularly in the organizational domains that represent an obstacle to development of MMCs.     

Prélèvements sur « donneurs décédés après arrêt cardiaque » : l’expérience du Samu de la Seine-Saint-Denis

The use of non-heart-beating donors (NHBD) could help shorten the list of patients who are waiting for a kidney transplant. The aim of this study was to evaluate efficiency of prehospital management of non-heart-beating donors in Seine-Saint-Denis area. We performed a retrospective cohort study of non-heart-beating donor managed by prehospital medical team of Samu 93 from February 2007 to January 2008. There were 28 non-heart-beating donors included consecutively. Twenty-five NHBD (89%) were canuled by Gillot probe within 150 min from patient collapse. Fourteen NHBD were harvested and 17 kidneys were transplanted. Six-month survival rate for NHBD grafts was 94%. In the same time, eight brain dead donors were managed by Samu 93 and were harvested leading to transplant 16 kidneys. Finally, 50% of overall kidney transplant activity in Seine-Saint-Denis was provided by NHBD grafts.     

Crise d’hyperthermie maligne de l’anesthésie après cinq heures d’anesthésie avec le sévoflurane et plusieurs anesthésies antérieures avec halogénés

We report a case of per anaesthesia malignant hyperthermia (MH) arisen in a 16-year-old young man presenting antecedents of five anaesthesia with use of halogenated agents without complication and having started a typical crisis of MH after five hours of anaesthesia with sevoflurane and with recurrence of the crisis after 14 hours in ICU. The association in the same clinical case of these three peculiarities of the crisis of MH already described separately in the international literature allows us to insist on their importance, with the French-speaking anaesthesiologists community.     

Évaluation des régulateurs de débit passifs utilisés pour la perfusion intraveineuse

Objective

The aim of our study is to evaluate seven flow rate regulators (FRR) to assess the reliability of these devices compared to standard perfuser with roller clamp.

Study design

Each FRR was tested with 5% dextrose and 0.9% sodium chloride combined with three different theoretical flow rates (30, 80 and 250 ml/h). Accuracy was compared with the theoretical value. Repeatability of flow rate was assessed thanks to variance break-up.

Results

Each FFR exhibits at least one combination “flow rate–solution” significantly different of the theoretical flow rate. Exadrop^® was the least successful of the FFR according to the accuracy. This FFR had for each combination a flow rate different of the theoretical (mean error: −24.0 ml/h). Tutodrop^® was the most successful of the FFR according to the accuracy with five combinations comparable to the theoretical value (mean error: −1.2 ml/h). The standard perfuser with roller clamp, used without FRR, reported two combinations comparable to the theoretical value and showed lowest rates for repeatability.

Conclusion

Our study exhibits the poor performances of the FRR studied: according to expected flow regulation, the reported results demonstrate the lack of accuracy. Their only one value added compare to the roller clamp is to improve the repeatability of the flow rate.     

Description de la prévention et estimation de la fréquence des erreurs de programmation de vitesse d’administration en continu des médicaments en réanimation par une application informatique

Objectives

To assess the usefulness and the feasibility to use a software supervising continuous infusion rates of drugs administered with pumps in ICU.

Study design

Follow-up of practices and inquiry in three intensive care units.

Material

Guardrails software^TM of reassurance of the regulations of the rates of pumps (AsenaGH^TM, Alaris).

Methods

First, evaluation and quantification of the number of infusion-rates adjustments reaching the maximal superior limit (considered as infusion-rate-errors stopped by the software). Secondly, appreciate the acceptance by staffs to such a system by a blinded questionnaire and a quantification of the number of dataset pumps programs performed with the software.

Results

The number of administrations started with the pumps of the study in the three services (11 beds) during the period of study was 63,069 and 42,694 of them (67.7 %) used the software. The number of potential errors of continuous infusion rates was 11, corresponding to a rate of infusion-rate errors of 26/100,000. KCl and insulin were concerned in two and five cases, respectively. Eighty percent of the nurses estimated that infusion-rate-errors were rare or exceptional but potentially harmful. Indeed, they considered that software supervising the continuous infusion rates of pumps could improve safety.

Conclusion

The risk of infusion-rate-errors of drugs administered continuously with pump in ICU is rare but potentially harmful. A software that controlled the continuous infusion rates could be useful.     

Amélioration de la perfusion des organes vitaux par la valve d’impédance inspiratoire et le concept de pompe respiratoire : rationnel physiologique et application clinique

Objective

In this article, we review the effects of the respiratory pump to improve vital organ perfusion by the use of an inspiratory threshold device.

Data sources

Medline and MeSH database.

Study selection

All papers with a level of proof of I to III have been used.

Data extraction

The analysis of the papers has focused on the physiological modifications induced by intrathoracic pressure regulation.

Data synthesis

Primary function of breathing is to provide gas exchange. Studies of the mechanisms involved in animals and humans provide the physiological underpinnings for “the other side of breathing”: to increase circulation to the heart and brain. We describe studies that focus on the fundamental relationship between the generation of negative intrathoracic pressure during inspiration through a low-level of resistance created by an impedance threshold device and the physiologic effects of a respiratory pump. A decrease in intrathoracic pressure during inspiration through a fixed resistance resulting in an intrathoracic pressure of −7 cmH₂O has multiple physiological benefits including: enhanced venous return, cardiac stroke volume and aortic blood pressure; lower intracranial pressure; resetting of the cardiac baroreflex; elevated cerebral blood flow oscillations and increased tissue blood flow/pressure gradient.

Conclusion

The clinical and animal studies support the use of the intrathoracic pump to treat different clinical conditions: hemorrhagic shock, orthostatic hypotension, septic shock, and cardiac arrest.     

Complications neurologiques de l’anesthésie locorégionale : analyse des expertises et conclusions des CRCI

All the files of complications of regional anaesthesias requiring an expertise for a Regional Commission for Conciliation and Compensation for medical accidents (CRCI) between 2003 and 2008 were analyzed. The objective was to estimate the homogeneity of the appointed experts, their opinions and the opinions of the CRCI. Querying the database, shared by the National Office for Compensation for Medical Accidents (ONIAM) and the CRCI, and identified 40 files corresponding to the selection criteria. The expertise carried out involved an anaesthetist in 27 cases, always registered, either on the national list of the experts in medical accidents, or on one list of court-appointed experts. Conversely, in 13 cases, no specialist performing himself the technique in question was involved in the expertise, and sometimes the expert was registered on any list. Mostly, the non-specialists do not conclude to medical malpractice. This was not the case in a single file, where the anaesthetist sought and obtained the addition of an anaesthetist in a new expertise, which concluded differently. Damages assessed were highly variable, but the given evidence provided to understand why. The CRCI have generally followed the opinions of the experts, except in a few cases where the evidence allowed a different opinion without requiring a new expertise. In conclusion, the abnormalities in the appointment of experts do not seem to have had consequences in terms of damage assessment, but may alter the balance between causes faulty and not faulty, in favour of the latter.     

Rupture traumatique trachéobronchique : gestion des voies aériennes

We report the case of a 25-year-old man who suffered a severe trauma with a complete rupture and separation of the right main bronchus. The patient presented on the scene with respiratory distress and severe hypoxemia. At the admission in the trauma resuscitation unit, the CT scan and fiberoptic examination confirmed the diagnosis of right main bronchus rupture. Selective fiberoptic intubation of the left main bronchus was done and the patient was sent to the operating theater for urgent thoracotomy. During thoracotomy, profound arterial oxygen desaturation requested the right main bronchus being intubated by the surgeon under the control of view and separate lung ventilation, until the end of the bronchus suture. Surgery allowed the patient to survive. He was then discharged alive from the hospital at day 36. Severe tracheobronchial rupture may be rapidly associated with major respiratory distress and severe hypoxemia that necessitate specialised care in referring centre. Initial orientation of these patients appears to be as important that airway and hypoxemia management.