Radiolunate arthrodesis in the rheumatoid wrist: a retrospective clinical and radiological longterm follow-up

A retrospective study was performed to investigate the clinical and radiological results of radiolunate arthrodesis in the rheumatoid wrist. Ninety-one wrists in 78 patients were assessed at a mean follow-up of 60 months. Most patients were pain-free and content with the overall result. In 68 wrists the carpus had been repositioned or maintained in neutral or slightly ulnar alignment and no further translation occurred. Midcarpal dislocation occured in ten and midcarpal rotation in 13 wrists. The midcarpal joint underwent further arthritic destruction in 34 wrists and secondary arthrosis in 32 wrists. In 25 wrists the midcarpal joint space remained unchanged. Radiolunate arthrodesis can successfully be performed in wrists even with advanced destruction. In cases with fixed carpal collapse, anatomical repositioning of the lunate and restoration of carpal height should not be attempted as this causes midcarpal dislocation or rotation or precipitates secondary arthrosis.     

Treatment of radiocarpal degenerative osteoarthritis by radioscapholunate arthrodesis and distal scaphoidectomy

PURPOSE: The purpose of this study was to assess wrist pain, range of motion, and the presence of radiographic midcarpal degenerative joint disease (DJD) in patients who had a distal scaphoidectomy in association to a radioscapholunate (RSL) arthrodesis and to compare these findings with prior studies of patients with only an RSL fusion. METHODS: Sixteen patients with radiocarpal DJD treated by RSL arthrodesis and distal scaphoidectomy were evaluated retrospectively for pain relief and range of motion at an average follow-up period of 37 months (range, 12-84 mo). Radiographs were assessed for the presence of secondary radiographic midcarpal DJD. RESULTS: Complete pain relief was obtained in 10 patients, 3 patients complained of slight pain during strenuous loading, and 3 patients had occasional pain with regular activities. The average postoperative ranges of motion were 32 degrees of flexion, 35 degrees of extension, 14 degrees of radial deviation, and 19 degrees of ulnar deviation. Two patients exhibited secondary midcarpal DJD. These results are significantly better compared with those previously published about RSL arthrodesis alone in terms of residual pain and decrease of wrist radial deviation and flexion. CONCLUSIONS: Patients who require an RSL arthrodesis for the treatment of severe localized radiocarpal DJD appear to have less pain and to retain more flexion and radial deviation if the distal scaphoid is excised concomitantly. This associated procedure also may help prevent secondary midcarpal DJD.     

Radiocarpal arthrodesis in the treatment of the rheumatoid wrist. A prospective midterm follow-up

This prospective study was performed to evaluate the clinical and radiological results of radiocarpal joint arthrodesis in the treatment of unstable Simmen group III and Larsen grade II or III rheumatoid wrists. Radiolunate arthrodesis was performed in 16 wrists and radioscapholunate arthrodesis in 7 wrists in 20 patients. When they were evaluated at a mean of 5.8 (range 3.5-9.8) years later, flexion was 29 degrees and extension 34 degrees , representing 67% and 92% of the preoperative values, respectively. Patient satisfaction was excellent, or good, for 20 wrists and satisfactory for 1 wrist. In two patients with poor satisfaction, arthritis progressed to the midcarpal joint and necessitated total arthrodesis of the wrist. Radiolunate joint arthrodesis, with inclusion of the scaphoid in the fusion if necessary, is a useful operation in the treatment of this degree of wrist disease as it produces a functional and pain-free wrist at the same time as preserving much of the mobility and bone stock.     

Radioscapholunate arthrodesis

Although RSL fusion is a viable option for isolated radiocarpal arthritis, the enthusiasm for this procedure should be tempered with the reality that kinematics of the wrist is not entirely suited for independent midcarpal flexion and extension [10]. Limited wrist flexion and extension is expected following a successful RSL arthrodesis. The effects of imposed abnormal kinematics are further shown by the high incidence of RSL nonunions, occurrence of scaphoid fractures, and postoperative deterioration of the midcarpal joint [15,22]. In a young patient with posttraumatic arthritis or rheumatoid arthritis limited to the radiocarpal joint, however, RSL arthrodesis remains a viable alternative to complete wrist arthrodesis if the midcarpal joint is normal. Internal fixation with plates and screws and distal scaphoid excision are technical alternatives to consider when an RSL arthrodesis is performed.     

Radio-scapho-lunate arthrodesis with distal scaphoid excision

Painful dysfunction of the radio-scapho-lunate joint may occur secondary to a number of post-traumatic, inflammatory and non-inflammatory conditions. When symptomatic, this problem may necessitate fusing the radio-scapho-lunate joint. The goal of this study is to describe precisely the technical steps of radio-scapho-lunate fusion with distal scaphoidectomy and to present the results in a clinical series. Sixteen patients presented with degeneration of the radio-scapho-lunate joint combined with a normal midcarpal joint. Radio-scapho-lunate fusion with distal scaphoidectomy was performed in all patients. At an average follow-up of 37 months, complete relief of pain was obtained in 10 patients, three had slight pain with strenuous loading, and three had occasional pain with regular activities. The average range of passive motion at follow-up was 32 degrees of flexion and 35 degrees of extension. The average postoperative grip strength was 76%. In all cases a solid fusion was obtained. In two patients who had originally suffered a perilunate dislocation, midcarpal degenerative arthritis was noted. We suggest that in cases of radio-scapho-lunate osteoarthritis without degenerative change in the midcarpal joint, radio-scapho-lunate fusion is a possible solution. However, it is necessary to perform distal scaphoidectomy in order to avoid scapho-trapezo-trapezoid impingement. Provided all the technical principles are respected, complications such as ulnocarpal impingement or nonunion, are rare.     

The role of midcarpal arthroscopy in the diagnosis of disorders of the wrist.

The findings of midcarpal versus radiocarpal arthroscopic examinations were compared in the diagnosis of a variety of wrist pathology in 89 patients. During 15 months 89 midcarpal arthroscopic examinations were performed in conjunction with radiocarpal arthroscopic examinations. Eighty-one wrists underwent arthroscopy for acute or chronic intracarpal instability. Eight wrists underwent arthroscopy for arthroscopy-assisted intra-articular distal radius fracture reduction. In the acute wrist instability group midcarpal arthroscopy added to the radiocarpal diagnosis in 21 of 26 (82%) of the wrists. In the chronic wrist instability group midcarpal arthroscopy added to the radiocarpal diagnosis in 46 of 55 (84%) of the wrists. In the distal radius group 5 of 8 wrists had additional pathology on the midcarpal arthroscopy examination, leading to additional surgical intervention. These results demonstrate that midcarpal arthroscopy added statistically significant information to the radiocarpal examination compared with wrist arthroscopy performed without a midcarpal examination.     

Chondrocalcinosis of the wrist

Calcium Pyrophosphate Dihydrate Deposition (CPDD) disease has characteristic radiographic features including soft tissue calcification, joint space narrowing, bone sclerosis, subchondral cyst formation without osteophyte formation, and large intraosseous geodes. Triangular fibrocartilage calcification is frequently found and isolated scapho-trapezio-trapezoid (STT) arthritis is specific for CPDD. Distal radio-ulnar (DRUJ), isolated midcarpal joint and piso-triquetral joint involvement also occur. 127 patients were reviewed. Seventy-eight had symptomatic STT joint arthritis, for which 36 underwent surgery. Twenty-two patients had a SLAC wrist deformity for which ten underwent surgery. Eight patients had isolated midcarpal arthritis for which three midcarpal arthrodeses, two four-bone arthrodeses and two carpal tunnel releases were performed. Nineteen patients had a generalized arthritis and seven of the patients underwent surgery: four-corner arthrodesis+scaphoidectomy (one case), carpal tunnel release (two cases) extensor synovectomy (two cases) and trigger finger release (two cases).     

Radiolunate arthrodesis: A procedure for stabilising and preserving mobility in the arthritic wrist

We carried out arthrodesis of the radiolunate joint in 46 wrists (38 patients) for pain and ulnar translation of the carpus because of rheumatoid (42) or psoriatic arthritis (4). At follow-up, three patients had died and in three (1 bilateral) an additional midcarpal arthrodesis had been undertaken. The remaining 32 patients (39 wrists) were evaluated after a mean of five years. The clinical results were good with a mean visual analogue score of 8.3 for pain, 7.2 for hand function and 9 for overall satisfaction. Except for palmar flexion, mobility was equal to or better than before operation. Radiologically, there was deterioration of the midcarpal joint with an increase in the Larsen score from 1.8 to 2.7 (p < 0.001), some decrease in carpal height and recurrence of carpal translation. Radiolunate arthrodesis gives good clinical results at five years although there is some deterioration radiologically.     

Combined radiocarpal arthrodesis and midcarpal (lunocapitate) arthroplasty for treatment of rheumatoid arthritis of the wrist

Arthroplasties for the wrist with rheumatoid arthritis are usually revised for the articulation between radius and carpus. The midcarpal joint is disregarded although it remains structurally better preserved and is therefore better suited for the preservation of stable motion. When the midcarpal surfaces are satisfactory, a radio-scapho-lunate fusion, accompanied by a midcarpal synovectomy, is an excellent procedure. When the midcarpal surfaces, particularly the head of the capitate, are also destroyed, the tendency has been to either perform a pan-arthrodesis, or to insert a wrist endo-prosthesis. For these severely unstable and destroyed wrists, a stabilization of the radiocarpal joint by arthrodesis, combined with preservation of motion at the midcarpal level by resection of the damaged head of the capitate and its replacement with a small implant has been done. This procedure has allowed all patients to retain a functional range of motion and to experience satisfactory relief of pain.     

Midcarpal arthrodesis with complete scaphoid excision and interposition bone graft in the treatment of advanced carpal collapse (SNAC/SLAC wrist): operative technique and outcome assessment

Thirty-six patients with stage II or III SNAC and SLAC wrists were treated by midcarpal arthrodesis and complete scaphoid excision. When assessed at a mean follow-up of 25 months, pain was significantly reduced both under resting and stress conditions. The active range of motion was 54% of the contralateral wrist and grip strength was 65% of the non-operated hand. The mean DASH score was 28 points, the Mayo wrist score was 63 points, and the Krimmer wrist score was 68. Correlation of the wrist scores with the DASH values demonstrated a significant correlation. Our data demonstrate that midcarpal fusion with complete excision of the scaphoid is a reliable procedure for treating advanced carpal collapse.     

Salvage procedures for degenerative osteoarthritis of the wrist due to advanced carpal collapse

Arthrodesis of the wrist has been considered as the gold standard for osteoarthritis of the wrist. In 1984 Watson and Ballet identified a specific pattern of carpal collapse (scapholunate advanced collapse = SLAC) with progressive osteoarthritis. In order to preserve some motion, other alternative procedures have been proposed: proximal row carpectomy (PRC) and scaphoidectomy combined with a four-corner arthrodesis (4CA). In this cohort of 63 patients, three types of surgical treatment were performed (arthrodesis in 19, PRC in 26 and scaphoidectomy with 4CA in 18). The DASH questionnaire was used to evaluate the residual disability. PRC had a significantly better outcome (DASH=16), while there were no significant differences between full arthrodesis (DASH=45) and four corner arthrodesis (DASH=39). In PRC and in four corner arthrodesis a functional range of motion could be preserved (resepectively 44 degrees and 52 degrees flexion/extension arc). Gripping force remained inferior to the non operated side. There was a significant increase in gripping force in the PRC group, but not in the others. The final gripping force was not significantly different in the three treatment regimes.     

Kienbock's disease: diagnosis and treatment

Kienbock's disease, or osteonecrosis of the lunate, can lead to chronic, debilitating wrist pain. Etiologic factors include vascular and skeletal variations combined with trauma or repetitive loading. In stage I Kienbock's disease, plain radiographs appear normal, and bone scintigraphy or magnetic resonance imaging is required for diagnosis. Initial treatment is nonoperative. In stage II, sclerosis of the lunate, compression fracture, and/or early collapse of the radial border of the lunate may appear. In stage IIIA, there is more severe lunate collapse. Because the remainder of the carpus is still uninvolved, treatment in stages II and IIIA involves attempts at revascularization of the lunate-either directly (with vascularized bone grafting) or indirectly (by unloading the lunate). Radial shortening in wrists with negative ulnar variance and capitate shortening or radial-wedge osteotomy in wrists with neutral or positive ulnar variance can be performed alone or with vascularized bone grafting. In stage IIIB, palmar rotation of the scaphoid and proximal migration of the capitate occur, and treatment addresses the carpal collapse. Surgical options include scaphotrapeziotrapezoid or scaphocapitate arthrodesis to correct scaphoid hyperflexion. In stage IV, degenerative changes are present at the midcarpal joint, the radiocarpal joint, or both. Treatment options include proximal-row carpectomy and wrist arthrodesis.     

Special aspects of wrist arthritis management for SLAC and SNAC wrists using midcarpal arthrodesis: results of bilateral operations and conversion to total arthrodesis

Although midcarpal wrist arthrodesis is recognized as a standard procedure to treat scapholuate advanced collapse (SLAC) and scaphoid nonunion advanced collapse (SNAC) of the wrist, little has been reported about patients with bilateral involvement and the number, cause, and results of failed cases requiring conversion to total wrist arthrodesis. This study investigated the results of 20 patients with bilateral procedures and of 22 patients who underwent total wrist fusion after failed midcarpal arthrodesis out of an overall group of 907 patients treated by this method during a 12-year period. Of these, 16 bilateral and 20 converted cases were reexamined after an average of 48 months and 42 months, respectively. Patients after bilateral midcarpal arthrodesis experienced a pain reduction by an average of 54% of the preoperative pain values at rest and by 56% at stress on the visual analog scale (scale range: 0 to 100) and from intolerable (3.7) to pain only during stress (1.9) on the verbal scale (scale range: I to 4). A mean arc of wrist extension and flexion of 53 degrees on the right and 49 of the left wrist was preserved. The mean DASH score was 45 points and 70% of the patients felt impaired only during certain activities. Total arthrodesis reduced pain in 18 of 20 reexamined wrists by 67% of the previous values after the failed partial arthrodesis at rest and by 46% at stress on the visual analog scale andfrom intolerable pain (3.7) to pain only during stress (2.1) on the verbal scale. Seven of the 20 reexamined patients noted complete pain relief at rest and two also under stress conditions. The DASH score averaged 39 points. A mean Krimmer score of 46 points and a mean Buck-Gramcko and Lohman evaluation of 6 points represented a satisfactory result. Grip strength of the operated hand averaged 53% of the opposite side. Subjectively, 30% felt impaired only during certain activities, 55%felt considerably and 15% strongly limited in daily life. However, all but two patients were satisfied with the secondary total wrist fusion as pain was considerably reduced. Midcarpal arthrodesis reliably reduced pain and preserved valuable wrist mobility thus improving daily activity and quality of life also in bilateral carpal collapse. In the rare cases when midcarpal arthrodesis failed, total wrist arthrodesis markedly improved the complaints in most patients, but in contrast to other studies complete pain was seldom.     

A comparison of plate and pin fixation for arthrodesis of the rheumatoid wrist

This retrospective study compared plate fixation versus pin fixation in 57 patients with rheumatoid arthritis who underwent wrist arthrodesis. Fixation was achieved by using plates in 32 patients and longitudinal pins in 25 patients. Clinical follow-up averaged 29 months (range: 12-57 months) and radiographic follow-up averaged 16 months (range 12-39 months). Union occurred in 97% of the wrists fixed with plates and in 96% of the wrists fixed with pins. There were 6 (19%) complications in the plate group and 7 (28%) complications in the pin group. Three (12%) wrists fixed with pins moved from the immediate postoperative position to a position of relative volar flexion, while radiographs showed no changes in wrist position in the plate group. With both methods, successful arthrodesis stabilized the wrist in a high percentage of patients. Plate fixation offers an excellent alternative method for arthrodesis of the rheumatoid wrist.     

Reliability of the 8?Week Time Point for Single Assessment of Midcarpal Fusion by CT Scan

High rates of nonunion have recently been reported for midcarpal fusions. Due to curvature and overlap of carpal interfaces, two dimensional films are not reliable in determining union of a midcarpal fusion. Computed tomography is the most reliable radiographic method of evaluating osseous union. Initiating motion as soon as fusion has occurred is a priority with the goal of maximizing final range. Cost control in healthcare makes obtaining serial scans unreasonable. The single optimal time point for a computed tomography scan to determine union of a midcarpal fusion remains to be determined. A prospective protocol selected 8 weeks post operative as the point in time to obtain the single determining scan. Forty-six consecutive midcarpal fusions with scaphoidectomy were retrospectively analyzed for the reliability of this time point. All fusions had achieved union by 8 weeks and only this one scan was clinically necessary to advance the patients on to full range of motion without a splint at that time.     

Atraumatic palmar midcarpal dislocation in a skeletally immature adolescent with hemiatrophy

We report a late presentation of a palmar midcarpal dislocation in an adolescent female with open growth plates who had no history of antecedent wrist injury. Midcarpal arthrodesis improved function and eliminated progressive pain.     

Capitolunate arthrodesis with compression screws

Scapholunate dissociation or scaphoid pseudarthrosis may lead to wrist osteoarthritis. When osteoarthritis concerns the midcarpal joint, proximal row carpectomy is not possible. Only 4-corner or capitolunate arthrodesis may be indicated. In this procedure, pseudarthrosis was frequently described in literature. However, in these series, fixation was performed with pins or staples. Type and position of the device are important to obtain carpal bones fusion. The efficiency of compression screws has been validated in scaphoid fracture or pseudarthrosis. Moreover, the axial position of the screws, parallel to the physiological wrist loads, may participate to improve bone fusion. Therefore, we present our technique of capitolunate arthrodesis with compression screws fixation through a dorsal approach.     

Internal headless compression screw method for 4-corner fusion

Midcarpal fusion and scaphoidectomy, also referred to as 4 corner fusion, is a common treatment for post-traumatic wrist arthritis, either scapholunate advanced collapse or scaphoid nonunion advanced collapse. Historically fixation for the fusion mass was performed with Kirschner wires. Bone graft was sometimes taken from the discarded scaphoid. More recently, articles have focused on the method of fixation and its potential role in causing high nonunion rates or specific complications. This article offers readers a reliable technique for midcarpal fusion designed to minimize both nonunion and hardware related complications.     

Stabile mediokarpale Teilarthrodese bei fortgeschrittenem karpalen Kollaps (SNAC-Wrist und SLAC-Wrist)

In a retrospective study, the indications and results after miniplate and spider plate osteosynthesis for stable midcarpal arthrodesis of the wrist after ?scaphoid nonunion advanced collapse“ (SNAC) wrist and ?scapho-lunate advanced collapse“ (SLAC) wrist were evaluated. The diagnosis was confirmed by conventional X-rays as well as magnetic resonance imaging/computed tomography and/or arthroscopy of the wrist. The principle of a stable midcarpal arthrodesis lies in the reduction of pain in the wrist by elimination of the arthrosis in the damaged joint, stabilization of the carpus, and sustainment and improvement of the movement of the wrist. From 1998 until 2007, 83 patients were stably treated with spider plates or other plates, and autogenous spongiosa graft. In 76 cases, a clinical and radiological follow-up examination was performed on average 48 months after operation. Within 6–8 weeks, the fusion was completed without external fixation. Three weeks after operation, physiotherapy was started. In the follow-up examination, the average range of motion from extension to flexion was 75°; the average grip strength about 85% compared with the other hand. Pain was reduced to 28 points on the visual analogue scale (VAS 1–100). The mean DASH score postoperatively was 22.1 points. Only two patients received a full arthrodesis two years after the first operation. All the other patients showed clinically good or excellent results, arthodesis was radiographically stable, and function was clinically convincing. In only one case was an arthrosis of the radiolunate joint with a slight ulnar translocation found in the X-ray. However, this X-ray pathology had no influence on the movement or pain of the wrist. Stable arthodesis guarantees early functional movement without pain in case of correct diagnosis and exact implementation of the steps of this challenging operation.     

Arthroscopic thermal capsulorrhaphy for palmar midcarpal instability

Midcarpal instability is an uncommon problem in which deficient static and dynamic wrist stabilisers cause sudden, uncontrolled movement of the proximal carpal row. We studied 15 wrists prospectively in 13 patients who underwent arthroscopic thermal capsulorrhaphy for palmar midcarpal instability. Capsulorrhaphy was performed using standard wrist arthroscopic techniques and a small diameter monopolar radiofrequency probe. One hundred percent follow-up was achieved at a mean of 42 (range 14 - 67) months. With regards to instability, all wrists showed improvement or resolution of instability. Functional improvement was confirmed by an improvement in the mean DASH score from 38 pre-operatively to 17 at final follow-up. Our early results show that thermal capsulorrhaphy is effective in reducing the instability symptoms of palmar midcarpal instability.