Does neuroticism explain variations in care service use for mental health problems in the general population?

AbstractBackground Little is known about the role of personality characteristics in service utilisation for mental health problems. We investigate whether neuroticism: 1) predicts the use of primary and specialised care services for mental health problems, independently of whether a person has an emotional disorder; and 2) modifies any association between emotional disorder and service use.Methods Data were derived from the Netherlands Mental Health Survey and Incidence Study (NEMESIS) a prospective cohort study in the general population aged 18–64. Neuroticism was recorded at baseline, and emotional disorder and service use at 12-month follow-up, in a representative sample (N=7076), using the Composite International Diagnostic Interview.Results People with high neuroticism were more likely to receive care in the specialised mental health sector, and after entry to care they made more visits to the services, whether or not they had an emotional disorder. If they had an emotional disorder, their likelihood of receiving specialised mental health care showed an additional increase. Neuroticism also predicted the use of primary care for mental health problems, but greater numbers of visits were made only by clients with both high neuroticism and an emotional disorder.Conclusions It would be useful to incorporate personality characteristics into models to understand variations in service utilisation for mental health problems. The findings suggest that professionals would be wise to focus not just on their clients’ emotional problems and disorders, but also on strengthening their problem-solving abilities through approaches like cognitive behavioural therapy.     

The influence of state mental health perceptions and spending on an individual’s use of mental health services

Purpose

To explore the possible contextual effects of state-level mental health perceptions and public spending for mental health treatment on an individual’s use of mental health services, independent of the individual’s own perceptions.

Methods

Cross-sectional data from the 2007 Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System were used. A total of 216,514 participants from 35 states and the District of Columbia were included in the study. Logistic regression and multilevel modeling were used to estimate the effects of individual-level characteristics and three state-level factors—per capita spending on community mental health services, aggregated perceptions of the effectiveness of mental health treatment and the stigma of mental illness—on the individual’s current use of mental health services.

Results

Adjusting for the individual’s perceptions and characteristics, state-level perception of treatment effectiveness was positively associated with the use of mental health services [odds ratio (OR) for 5 % increase in the percentage perceiving effectiveness = 1.08; 95 % confidence interval (CI): 1.01, 1.16]. This association was strongest for individuals who experienced 1–4 days of mental distress in the past 30 days (OR = 1.17; 95 % CI 1.06, 1.29). State-level public spending on community mental health services was also positively associated with an individual’s use of mental health services (OR for a $40 increase in spending = 1.09; 95 % CI 1.01, 1.17); however, state-level perceptions of mental-illness stigma was not.

Conclusions

Our findings suggest there may be contextual effects of state-level perceptions of treatment effectiveness and state spending on community mental health services on the use of mental health services.     

Growing up in the shadow of Chornobyl: adolescents’ risk perceptions and mental health

Purpose  

Despite long-term research on risk perceptions of adults after ecological disasters, little is known about the legacy for the generation exposed to toxic elements as infants. This study examined Chornobyl-related risk perceptions and their relationship to mental health in adolescents raised in Kyiv in the aftermath of the accident.     

Correspondence of perceptions about centenarians’ mental health

Objectives: The goals of this study were to uncover the criteria by which centenarians, proxy/caregivers, and interviewers rated centenarians’ mental health. Often proxy and interviewer reports are obtained in studies of the oldest-old and become a primary source of information.

Methods: Data were from a population-based sample of mentally competent US centenarians in northern Georgia. The dependent variables were based on alternative reports for the centenarians’ mental or emotional health. Regression analysis was used to predict each source's rating of mental health separately with the same set of variables. These variables included information obtained from the centenarians and proxies about their distal experiences, demographics, and proximal resources including Mini-Mental Status Examination (MMSE), health, personality, socioeconomic resources, and coping behaviors.

Results: Examination of mean-level differences between sources revealed similarity across mental health ratings. For centenarians and proxies, perceived economic status was a very important predictor of mental health. For centenarians and interviewers, personality (neuroticism and extraversion) was an important common predictor. The interviewer and proxy mental health ratings were strongly associated with MMSE, but that was not the case for centenarians.

Conclusion: Mean-level findings and the comparative regression results provide corroborating evidence that centenarians’ self-reports of mental health are similar based on average ratings and presence of common associations with other raters (i.e., perceived economic status and personality). Implications of differences across rater pairs are discussed as guidance about the comparative value of substitution of proxies as informants for addressing specific influences on mental health.     

Does educational background explain inequalities in care service use for mental health problems in the Dutch general population?

OBJECTIVE: To investigate whether (1) education predicts the use of care services for mental health problems, independently of mental disorder and functional impairment and (2) education modifies the association between mental disorder and service use. METHOD: Predictors of service use were recorded at baseline, and service use itself at 12-month follow-up, in a representative sample (N=7076) of the Dutch population, using the Composite International Diagnostic Interview. RESULTS: People with more education were less likely to use primary care but more likely to use mental health care. The effects on both types of care remained significant after adjustment for mental disorder and functional impairment. Lower education tended to strengthen the association between mood or anxiety disorder and primary care use. CONCLUSION: Further research on inequalities in service use will benefit from additional explanatory analyses and from the inclusion of sociopsychological variables, like cost-benefit considerations in decisions to use services.     

Did we learn something positive out of the COVID-19 pandemic? Post-traumatic growth and mental health in the general population

BackgroundWhen facing a traumatic event, some people may experience positive changes, defined as posttraumatic growth (PTG).MethodsUnderstanding the possible positive consequences of the pandemic on the individual level is crucial for the development of supportive psychosocial interventions. The present paper aims to: 1) evaluate the levels of PTG in the general population; 2) to identify predictors of each dimension of post-traumatic growth.ResultsThe majority of the sample (67%, N = 13,889) did not report any significant improvement in any domain of PTG. Participants reported the highest levels of growth in the dimension of “appreciation of life” (2.3 ± 1.4), while the lowest level was found in the “spiritual change” (1.2 ± 1.2). Female participants reported a slightly higher level of PTG in areas of personal strength (p < .002) and appreciation for life (p < .007) compared to male participants, while no significant association was found with age. At the multivariate regression models, weighted for the propensity score, only the initial week of lockdown (between 9-15 April) had a negative impact on the dimension of “relating to others” (B = −.107, 95% CI = −.181 to −.032, p < .005), while over time no other effects were found. The duration of exposure to lockdown measures did not influence the other dimensions of PTG.ConclusionsThe assessment of the levels of PTG is of great importance for the development of ad hoc supportive psychosocial interventions. From a public health perspective, the identification of protective factors is crucial for developing ad-hoc tailored interventions and for preventing the development of full-blown mental disorders in large scale.     

What are the ethics of care in mental health disorders?

Psychiatry is undergoing a major crisis, on both an institutional as well as a clinical level. Numerous players involved in psychiatry feel in difficulty and are increasingly raising questions as to what direction and meaning to give to their practice. It is in such a context that ethics can help us to progress, reflect and build the future together. It is high time to create the specific basis of ethics in psychiatry.     

Religious advisors’ role in mental health care in the European Study of the Epidemiology of Mental Disorders survey

Objective

To study the role of religious advisors in mental health problems in six European countries and to compare it to data from the USA.

Methods

Data were derived from the European Study of the Epidemiology of Mental Disorders (ESEMeD) study, a cross-sectional study, conducted in Belgium, France, Germany, Italy, the Netherlands and Spain. 21,425 individuals, 18 and older, were interviewed with the Composite International Diagnostic Interview 3.0. Findings were compared to the National Comorbidity Survey (NCS) and replication of the NCS (NCS-R) in the US.

Results

In ESEMeD, 0.6% of individuals (0.3% exclusively) sought help from religious advisors concerning mental health problems during the previous year, compared to 2.6% in NCS and 3.4% (for human services) in NCS-R in the US. Among those using any form of service, 6.9% consulted religious advisors (12.2% in Germany to 2.1% in Spain) compared to 18.8% in the US. Being younger (less than 25 years old), being older (more than 64) and religiosity are associated with the use of religious advisors, whereas being a student is associated with a lower probability.

Conclusions

Seeking help from religious advisors for mental health problems varies dramatically among ESEMeD countries. Except for Germany, organised religion in the ESEMeD countries could not be considered as an alternative.     

Genetic risk of Parkinson’s disease in the general population

IntroductionWe investigated whether a risk score based on genetic risk variants for Parkinson’s disease (PD) is associated with the risk and improves prediction of incident PD, and whether the risk score is associated with basic activities of daily living (BADL) in healthy individuals.MethodsWithin the population-based Rotterdam Study, we genotyped 26 independent risk variants for PD and constructed a genetic risk score in 7167 participants who were free of parkinsonism and dementia at baseline (1990 or 2000). Participants were followed for a maximum of twenty years for the onset of parkinsonism, dementia or death until January 1, 2011 (median follow-up 12.1 years). We studied the relationship between the genetic risk score and incident PD with adjustment for age, sex, smoking and parental history. In an independent sample of 2997 persons free of parkinsonism and dementia, we studied whether the PD risk score was associated with impaired BADL.ResultsDuring follow-up (median 12.1 years), 99 persons were diagnosed with incident PD. The genetic risk score was associated with incident PD (hazard ratio per standard deviation risk 1.25 [95% confidence interval = 1.02; 1.55]), but did not substantially improve prediction (change in C-statistic 0.687 [0.628; 0.745] to 0.698 [0.635; 0.760], ΔC = 0.011 [−0.011; 0.033]). The genetic risk score was associated with a higher probability of any impairment in BADL (odds ratio = 1.11 [1.00; 1.23]).ConclusionGenetic variants for PD are associated with the risk of incident PD in the general population and with impairment in daily functioning in individuals without clinical parkinsonism, but do not improve the clinical prediction of PD. However, we were probably underpowered to detect a small improvement in PD prediction.     

Intervention to promote physical health in staff within mental health facilities and the impact on patients’ physical health

Background: Patients with severe mental illnesses have an increased physical morbidity and premature mortality on account of somatic diseases. Patients with mental illness are nursed and cared for by the staff, who may acts as role models for the patients. Aims: The study tested the efficacy of an intervention programme for improving physical health in staff working in long-term psychiatric treatment facilities. Furthermore, the paper measured the association between staff's changes in physical health and the patients’ changes in physical health. Methods: The study was a cluster randomized controlled 12-month intervention study, and the intervention was active awareness on physical health. Results: In the intervention group the staff reduced their waist circumference by 2.3 cm (95% CI: 0.3–4.4) when controlling for gender, age and cigarette consumption. In the control group, the staff changed their waist circumference by ? 2.1 cm (95% CI: ? 5.6–1.5). The staff in the intervention group experienced a significant reduction in diastolic blood pressure of ? 5.9 mmHg (95% CI: ? 9.5 to ? 2.3, p = 0.009). The study indicated an association between the staff average change in each facility and the individual patient's changes in health parameters (body mass index, total body fat and quality of life). Conclusion: The staff in the intervention group showed a significant reduction of waist circumference, while staff in the control group showed a non-significant increase. Furthermore, a significant reduction in the diastolic blood pressure was seen. Indications that staff acted as positive role models for the patients’ physical health were seen.     

The surgeon general’s national action agenda on children’s mental health

The Surgeon General’s National Action Agenda highlighted key issues that challenge the public health system in appropriately meeting the mental health needs of children and their families. Among these issues included the need for screening and early identification, improving access to appropriate mental health care, strengthening the infrastructure, and expanding training for providers. Two key gate-keeping systems identified as critical in this reform of mental health care for children and their families are education and primary care. This paper focuses on these two systems to illustrate problems related to these issues. Central to the Surgeon General’s call for reform is also the pressing public health responsibility to improve and use the science base by strengthening the connection between what we know from the scientific evidence base and what we do in practice. The implications of this reform for specialty mental health are discussed.