Effectiveness and safety profile of 40% trichloroacetic acid and cryotherapy for plantar warts

Plantar warts are one of the most common infectious skin disease caused by the human papillomavirus. In this study, cryotherapy with liquid nitrogen delivered by the physician, up to four treatments 2 weeks apart. Forty percent trichloroacetic acid (TCA) was applied to warts weekly up to four treatments. At the end of 4 weeks, the clinical improvement of the TCA group (n = 30) was six patients (20%) with no change, one patient (3.3%) with a mild response, 13 patients (43.3%) with a moderate response and 10 patients (33.3%) with a good response. In the cryotherapy group, clinical responses were 12 patients (40%) with no change, four patients (13.3%) with a mild response, 12 patients (40%) with a moderate response and two patients (6.7%) with a good response. There was a statistically significant difference in improvement between the two treatment groups (P = 0.027). According to our results, TCA 40% is more effective for clearance of plantar warts with significantly improved long‐term safety profile.     

Silver duct tape occlusion in treatment of plantar warts in adults: Is it effective?

Duct tape occlusive therapy may represent a convenient alternative to the standard wart therapies. The objective of the current study is to assess the therapeutic effect of duct tape occlusion in comparison to cryotherapy in treatment of plantar warts in adults, in a prospective comparative randomized non‐inferiority design. A total of 100 patients presenting with plantar warts were divided into two equal groups. First group was treated with silver duct tape occlusion for up to 8 weeks or disappearance of warts, whichever occurred first. Second group was treated with cryotherapy every 2 to 3 weeks for a maximum of four sessions or disappearance of warts. There was a statistically significant lower rate of complete resolution in duct tape than cryotherapy group (20% vs 58%, P = .0001, respectively). Degree of response to treatment in the duct tape and cryotherapy groups was not correlated to patients' age (P = .361 and .334, respectively) or disease duration (P = .266 and .285, respectively), while there was a statistically significant inverse relationship between the number (P = .0032 and .001, respectively) and diameter of warts (P = .013 and .003, respectively) and the degree of response in the two studied groups. Cryotherapy has higher efficacy than duct tape in the treatment of plantar warts in adults; however, duct tape may represent a practical and convenient alternative to cryotherapy in certain circumstances.     

An assessment of methods of treating viral warts by comparative treatment trials based on a standard design

A series of eleven comparative wart treatment trials undertaken between 1969 and 1975 and involving 1802 patients is described. A method of coding provided groups of patients matched for age, type, number and duration of warts, within which treatments could be randomized. The variation in response to treatment was shown to be influenced significantly by these factors and the level of cure to depend on the proportions of the various response groups within the population under consideration. These proportions were found to vary geographically and at different periods. In all the trials the results were assessed at 12 weeks. In the treatment of hand warts, the percentage cure of patients treated with liquid nitrogen fell significantly from 75 to 40% when the interval between freezings was increased from 3 to 4 weeks. The average number of freezings required for a cure was 3 I amongst all patients cured by 6 or less freezings at intervals of 2 or 3 weeks. In a two–centre trial there was no significant difference between the percentage cure of patients with hand warts treated with liquid nitrogen (69%) and of those applying a paint containing salicylic and lactic acids (SAL) (67%). Patients receiving both treatments concurrently did better (78%) but the difference was not found to be statistically significant. In the treatment of simple plantar warts the percentage cure for the SAL paint (84%) was found to compare favourably with that for a podophyllin treatment (81%). Only one of the patients cured by the paint in that trial was found to have had a recurrence after 6 months. The paint was found to be satisfactory for use under general practice conditions. Additions to the formula did not alter its effectiveness. In the treatment of mosaic plantar warts the overall percentage cure for the SAL paint in a series of comparative trials (1969–75) was 45%. In these trials it was compared directly with one or more other preparations. No differences were found between its efficacy and that of 10% buffered gluteraldehyde (47%), 40% benzalkonium chloride dibromide (Callusolve 40) (30%) and 5% 5-fluorouracil in dimethyl sulphoxide (53%). Only 25% of thirty-six patients treated with 5% idoxuridine in dimethyl sulphoxide were cured. Throughout the trials approximately 30% of patients with hand warts, 2o% of those with simple plantar warts and 50% of those with mosaic plantar warts were found to be resistant to treatment. The adoption of treatment with SAL paint for hand warts and simple plantar warts by the general practitioners in the Edinburgh area has proved satisfactory. Only resistant cases are now referred to hospital and these can be treated within a few weeks instead of 4-5 months as was the case in 1969.     

Intralesional zinc sulfate 2% vs intralesional vitamin D in plantar warts: A clinicodermoscopic study

Verrucae are benign proliferations seen in skin due to infection with papillomaviruses. There are different treatment strategies for warts but all of these treatments are painful, time consuming, expensive, and recurrence is common. To evaluate and compare the efficacy of intralesional 2% zinc sulfate solution vs vitamin D3 in the treatment of plantar warts, as well as reporting the side effects. This three‐armed randomized clinical trial included 105 patients presented with plantar warts divided into three groups, 35 patients per group. The first group received intralesional 2% zinc sulfate, the second group received intralesional 2% vitamin D3, and the third group received normal saline. Four sessions were done, one every 2 weeks. At the end of the study, patients showing complete response were more in zinc group (71.4%), vitamin D3 group (62.9%) compared to saline group (40%). Most of the patients in zinc group showed severe pain during injection (48.6%), most of the patients in vitamin D3 group showed mild pain (80%), while most of the patients in saline group showed no pain (57.1%). Both intralesional 2% zinc sulfate and vitamin D3 are effective in treatment of plantar warts, with zinc sulfate being more effective.     

Cantharidin–podophylotoxin–salicylic acid versus cryotherapy in the treatment of plantar warts: a randomized prospective study

Background Plantar warts are refractory to any form of treatment. High cure rates have been reported with a topical proprietary formulation consisting of 1% cantharidin, 5% podophyllotoxin and 30% salicylic acid (CPS). However, no data exists comparing the efficacy of this formulation with another treatment. Cryotherapy is a method that is also widely used in the treatment of plantar warts. Likewise, there is no evidence that it is more effective than any topical treatment. Objective We aim to compare the efficacy of topical CPS and cryotherapy in the treatment of plantar warts. Methods Patients with plantar warts were consecutively treated with either cryotherapy or topical CPS. Both treatments were performed every 2 weeks for up to five sessions. In patients without complete clearance, the therapy was switched to the other treatment option. Results Twenty‐six patients with a total of 134 warts were included. Fourteen patients were completely cleared of their warts with topical CPS, whereas only in five of 12 patients (41.7%) warts were completely cleared with cryotherapy (P = 0.001). In seven patients without complete clearance, the therapy was switched to CPS. Four of these patients missed the follow‐up. While the two of the remaining three patients were cleared of their warts, one patient’s warts still failed to clear. Conclusion Topical CPS is more effective than cryotherapy in the treatment of plantar warts.     

Treatment of recalcitrant plantar warts with long-pulsed Nd:YAG laser versus cantharidin–podophylline resin–salicylic acid

Background: Treatment for recalcitrant plantar warts remains a continuing challenge as the options for treatment have differing levels of success. long-pulsed Nd:YAG laser is considered a good treatment modality in resistant plantar warts. On the other hand, high cure rates have been reported with a topical proprietary formulation consisting of 1% cantharidin, 5% podophyllotoxin, 30% salicylic acid. Aim: To compare the efficacy of 1% cantharidin, 20% podophylline resin and 30% salicylic acid (CPS) versus long-pulsed Nd:YAG laser in the treatment of recalcitrant plantar warts. Methods: This study included 30 patients with single or multiple recalcitrant plantar warts; patients were assigned to two groups: the first group included 15 patients with 71 recalcitrant plantar warts who were treated by long-pulsed Nd:YAG laser (group I) and the second group included 15 patients with 78 recalcitrant plantar warts who received CPS (group II). The diagnosis of plantar warts was made by clinical examination. Results: Fourteen patients (93%) were completely cleared of their warts with topical CPS, while 11 patients (73%) showed complete clearance with long-pulsed Nd:YAG laser with statistically significant difference between the two groups. Conclusion: Topical CPS is safe and efficacious and represents a promising therapeutic modality than long-pulsed Nd:YAG laser in the treatment of recalcitrant plantar warts.     

Efficacy and tolerability of a new topical nitric‐zinc preparation for “difficult‐to‐treat” warts

Treating plantar, periungual, and external genital warts can be challenging. A prospective study from four centers in Italy evaluated 37 immunocompetent patients with single or multiple warts and treated each lesion with a nitric‐zinc topical solution composed of organic and inorganic acids meant to devitalize tissue and destroy HPV DNA in infected keratinocytes. Thirty of the 37 patients had external genital warts, two had plantar warts, two had palm and finger warts, and three had subungual warts for a total of 55 lesions treated. Nitric‐zinc aqueous solution was applied over each wart utilizing a 30 µL capillary tube until a whitening response was observed. Additional applications as needed were accomplished at 2‐week intervals until the wart was gone. In those with hand, plantar, and subungual warts, there was a 100% clearance after two to three sessions. Three with external genital warts had only a partial response and one no benefit after four applications. Thus, this approach was effective in external genital and other “difficult‐to‐treat” warts in 90% of patients after one to four applications. It also was easy to use with no adverse events noted.     

平阳霉素局部注射治疗多发性跖疣45例临床观察

目的评价平阳霉素局部注射治疗多发性跖疣的临床疗效。方法将入选的120例多发性跖疣患者随机分为A组（45例）、B组（35例）和C组（40例）。A组予平阳霉素注射治疗,B组予超脉冲CO2激光治疗,C组予液氮冷冻治疗,均为每4周1次,共治疗1-2次。结果治疗8周后,A组有效率为93.33%,B组为74.29%,C组为70.00%,A组显著优于B组和C组,差异均有统计学意义（P均〈0.05）。结论平阳霉素局部注射治疗多发性跖疣的疗效好,不良反应小,而且复发率低。     

The successful treatment of flat warts with auricular acupuncture

Background Flat warts are a common presenting complaint in adolescents and adults and may be a cosmetic problem as well. Patients suffering from flat warts are often unsatisfied with conventional medical care because of adverse effects such as intolerable pain, hyperpigmentation, hypopigmentation, or occasionally allergic contact dermatitis. To offset the possibilities of hyperpigmentation, hypopigmentation, and scar formation, the method of auricular acupuncture was used. Methods Single‐blind method adopted, 60 subjects with flat warts were all outpatients and randomly allocated to a treatment group or a control group, with 30 patients in each group. Thirty subjects in the treatment group were treated with weekly auricular acupuncture for 10 weeks while the other subjects in the control group were treated with 0.1% of tretinoin ointment topically for 10 weeks. Results Sixteen subjects in the treatment group (53.33%) recovered fully from flat warts without recurrence during the ensuing six months’ follow‐up after 10 weeks’ surgery compared with only one subject in the control group (3.33%). The therapeutic effect of the treatment group was statistically better than that of the control group by Mann–Whitney U‐test with SPSS software (P < 0.01). During the treatment period and the ensuing six months’ follow‐up, no adverse effects were observed by the investigators or reported by patients. Conclusions Our findings suggest that auricular acupuncture may be a viable alternative for the treatment of flat warts. Larger randomized studies are needed to fully evaluate auricular acupuncture against more conventional treatments, and these are planned.     

水杨酸粉封包联合CO2激光治疗跖疣疗效评价

目的：评价自制水杨酸粉封包联合CO2激光治疗跖疣的临床疗效。方法：将152例跖疣患者（总疣体个数819个）给予水杨酸粉封包后刮除联合CO2激光治疗,观察创面愈合情况及原位复发情况。结果：水杨酸粉封包联合CO2激光治疗后创面愈合时间缩短,随访12周,85％跖疣疣体完全消除。结论：自制水杨酸粉封包联合CO2激光治疗跖疣安全有效。     

Verrucae Treated by Levamisole

To assess the role of levamisole in treatment of different types of warts, a double-blind study was conducted on 40 patients with different types of warts. Patients were divided into two equal groups, A and B. Group A received levamisole 5 mg/kg body weight on 3 consecutive days every 2 weeks for a period up to 5 months, while patients of group B received placebo for the same period. In group A, 12 patients showed complete cure (60%), two showed partial cure (10%), and the remaining six patients showed no response (30%). In group B, complete cure was achieved only in one case. The higher cure rate was observed in plane and common warts, while plantar warts showed no improvement with levamisole treatment.     

Local hyperthermia cleared multifarious viral warts in a patient with Cushing's syndrome

A female Cushing's syndrome patient had been suffering from extensive viral warts for months. She was diagnosed with flat warts, common warts and plantar warts. The plantar warts on her right foot were initially treated using local hyperthermia at 44°C for 30 min according to a defined protocol, followed by treatment targeting a common wart on her left thumb. In response to hyperthermia, the flat warts on her eyelid dissipated within 12 weeks, and when combined with a 1 week administration of imiquimod, the common warts and plantar warts completely disappeared within 8 weeks. There were no signs of recurrence and during this treatment her Cushing's syndrome was alleviated. This pioneer trial suggests that local hyperthermia may serve as an effective mean for treating multiple cutaneous warts under the conditions of a systemic immuno‐compromised disease.     

Comparative Evaluation of Topical 10% Potassium Hydroxide and 30% Trichloroacetic Acid in the Treatment of Plane Warts

Background:Warts are benign proliferations of skin and mucosa caused by the human papillomavirus (HPV). Plane warts are caused by HPV types 3, 10, 28, and 41, occurring mostly in children and young adults. Among the treatment modalities, topical application of trichloroacetic acid (TCA) is age old. Potassium hydroxide (KOH) has a keratolytic effect on virus-infected cells. It is less irritating, less painful, less scar forming, and can be safely used in children too. Hence, it could be a better topical agent in the treatment of plane warts.Results:Statistically no significant difference (P = 0.07) was found between the objective therapeutic response to 10% KOH and 30% TCA at the end of study (12 weeks). However, subjective response to 10% KOH was better and statistically significant (P = 0.03). There was no recurrence of warts seen on follow-up for 3 months of complete responders in both the arms.Conclusion:10% KOH is found to be equally effective in the treatment of plane warts compared to 30% TCA with the advantage of faster onset of action and tendency of completely clearing warts with fewer side effects.     

Pulsed dye laser treatment for viral warts: a study of 120 patients

A prospective, non-blinded, non-randomized study on 120 wart patients treated with pulsed dye laser was performed to evaluate the efficacy and safety of pulsed dye laser treatment for viral warts and to demonstrate the proper application and effective technique of this method. The overall clearance rate was 49.5%. The clearance rates of flat warts, periungual warts, plantar warts and common warts were 67.6%, 51.1%, 47.6% and 44.3%, respectively. Overall, the response rates of pediatric warts, recalcitrant warts and old warts were superior to those of adult warts, simple warts and non-old warts, respectively; however, those trends were not statistically significant. We concluded that pulsed dye laser treatment is a safe, tolerable and relatively effective treatment method for viral warts. Pulsed dye laser treatment may be a more efficacious method for flat warts and recalcitrant periungual warts, and it can be an effective modality for newly-developed warts. The highest clearance rate was noted at a fluence of 9.5 J/cm2 (P < or = 0.05) and it is recommended that practitioners perform pulsed dye laser treatments for viral warts at the fluences of 9.0-9.5 J/cm2. A replacement of pulsed dye laser treatment should be considered unless prominent improvement is observed after three treatment sessions.     

Management of Female Genital Warts with an Analog of Imiquimod 2% in Cream: A Randomized,Double-Blind,Placebo-Controlled Study

The purpose of this randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study was to determine the clinical efficacy and tolerability of an analog of imiquimod (2%) in cream to cure genital warts in women. Sixty preselected women, ranging between 18 and 45 years of age (mean 24.3) and having 411 lesions (mean 6.8) with clinical, histopathological and polymerase chain reaction (PCR) confirmed diagnosis of human papilloma virus (HPV) infection were randomized to two parallel groups. Each patient received a precoded 40-g tube and instructions on how to apply the trial medication to their lesions at home two times daily for five consecutive days per week. The active treatment period was six weeks. Patients were evaluated on a weekly basis. A clinically and PCR established total clearance of target warts was recorded as a cure. By the end of the treatment, 43.3% of patients and 42.8% of warts were cured. Code disclosure revealed that imiquimod cream had cured 83.3% of the treated patients and 84.3% of the treated warts, while the placebo healed one subject and four warts (p<0.0001). Eight patients (13.3%) in the imiquimod group experienced mild to moderate, non-objective, drug-induced symptoms with no dropouts. Among the 26 cured patients, five had a relapse after 11 months. In conclusion, the data presented demonstrate that 2% imiquimod in cream with mild to moderate subjective side effects is significantly more effective than placebo in eliminating genital warts in women.     

Plantar warts treated with an immune response modifier: a report of two cases

Summary Viral warts are the most common disease of the skin and are caused by human papillomavirus (HPV). Plantar warts, a manifestation of infection by HPV-1, -2 and -4, tend to be smoother and flatter than common warts and can also be painful when pressure is applied. A variety of local treatments, including topical salicyclic acid, cryotherapy, topical 5-fluorouracil, intralesional interferons and photodynamic therapy, are available to treat plantar warts. Here we report two cases of plantar warts, which had been previously treated without success. Total clearance of the warts was observed in both cases after treatment with imiquimod 5% cream over a period of 12 weeks. No evidence of local skin reactions was observed in either case during the treatment period. Recurrent lesions were not evident in the follow-up period for each patient.     

The prevalence of common skin conditions in Australian school students: 3. Acne vulgaris

Although viral warts are common, their exact frequency in the community is often underestimated and not well recorded. A random sample of 2491 students from schools throughout the State of Victoria, Australia were examined by dermatologists and dermatology registrars to record the prevalence of common, plantar and plane warts. The overall prevalence of warts adjusted for the age and sex of Victorian school children was 22% (95% confidence interval (CI) 20.1–20.7) varying from 12% (95% CI 9.4–15.7) in 4–6 year olds to 24% (95% CI 18.3–30.4) in 16–18 year olds. Common warts were the most frequent (16%) compared with plantar warts (6%) and plane warts (2%). There was no difference in the overall frequency of warts between males and females and there was no difference in frequency between those who had eczema and those who did not. Almost 40% of those found to have warts on examination had indicated on the survey questionnaire that they did not have any of these lesions. Of those who knew that they had warts, only 38% had used any treatment for them. These data, the first community-based prevalence data on warts ever published from Australia, confirm that warts are indeed common. They suggest the need for education programmes in schools on the nature of these lesions and the treatment available.     

Treatment efficacy of 0.9% saline and mepivacaine infiltration with Dermojet® in eliminating plantar warts

Background

Plantar warts are benign, epidermal neoformations, viral, and easily transmitted. Although 30% of these warts disappear spontaneously, the American Association of Dermatology recommends treatment if they cause pain or bleeding.

Objectives

The aim of this study was to determine the efficacy of Dermojet® infiltration using a solution composed of equal parts of 0.9% saline and 2% mepivacaine in the treatment of plantar warts, and to identify the type of necrosis achieved at 7–10 days after the infiltration (M1 sample) and at 15–17 days (M2 sample).

Method

In this analytical prospective observational study, 102 histories were reviewed by the same researcher. The patients were treated with this technique at four private podiatry clinics.

Results

A total of 61.8% of the patients were male. The patients' mean age was 26.6 ± 14.10 years. A total percentage of 78.4% of the patients achieved complete elimination of the lesion by the second evaluation and after a single infiltration. Bivariate analysis revealed a significant inverse relationship between treatment efficacy and a history of previous disease (p < 0.001) and the period of evolution of the lesion (p < 0.001; 95% CI [0.78–7.91]). Multivariate linear regression analysis revealed an association with the number of evaluation sessions (p < 0.001) and with previous illnesses (p = 0.014). A total percentage of 82.35% presented partial necrosis in the M1 sample and 76.92% had complete necrosis in the M2 sample.

Conclusions

In 78.4% of the patients considered, the plantar warts treated disappeared after a single infiltration. The variables associated with treatment efficacy were the number of follow-up visits and the existence of associated diseases.     

Intralesional injection of measles,mumps, and rubella vaccine versus cryotherapy in treatment of warts: A randomized controlled trial

Cutaneous warts are benign hyperkeratotic papillomas resulting from infection by human papillomavirus (HPV). Cryotherapy is a known method for warts treatment. Immunotherapy stimulates HPV recognition by the immune system; this helps resolution of warts. To determine the efficacy of intralesional immunotherapy with measles, mumps, and rubella (MMR) vaccine versus cryotherapy in the treatment of patients with multiple common and plantar warts. Forty‐eight patients with multiple common and plantar warts were divided into two groups: to undergo either intralesional injection of MMR vaccine (Group A), or cryotherapy (Group B). Forty patients completed the study. In the MMR group, 70% of the patients showed complete response, 5% partial response, and 25% showed no response to treatment. In the CRYO group, 45% of the patients showed complete response, 35% partial response, and 20% showed no response to treatment. The complete response was higher in the MMR group (70%) as compared to the CRYO group (45%), but the difference between the two groups was not statistically significant. Meanwhile, the partial response was significantly higher in the CRYO group. Intralesional MMR injection was a safe and effective treatment for multiple common and plantar warts as compared to cryotherapy.     

Oral zinc sulphate in the treatment of recalcitrant viral warts: randomized placebo-controlled clinical trial

BACKGROUND: Viral warts are common dermatological diseases; although the rate of spontaneous recovery is high, it usually takes a long time, and some patients might not show this spontaneous healing. Zinc has an important effect on the immune system and it has been used as an immunomodulator to treat a variety of skin disorders. OBJECTIVE: To assess whether oral zinc was effective in treating viral warts of patients evaluated between May 1999 and April 2000. PATIENTS AND METHODS: This was a placebo-controlled clinical trial. Eighty patients with viral warts (common, plantar and plane) were all resistant to all forms of treatment. Each patient had > 15 warts. Forty patients were treated by oral zinc sulphate at a dose of 10 mg kg(-1) daily up to 600 mg day(-1) and followed-up for resolution of their warts and for any evidence of recurrence for 2-6 months. Another 40 patients were given a placebo oral treatment in the form of glucose, and followed-up for the same period. RESULTS: Only 23 patients of the first group (zinc treated) and 20 patients of the second group (placebo treated) completed the study. In all patients the serum level of zinc was low. In the zinc-treated group, the overall response was complete clearance of warts observed in 20 patients (86.9%) after 2 months of treatment. Fourteen patients (60.9%) showed complete disappearance of their warts after 1 month. Three patients (13.3%) failed to respond to the treatment after 2 months of therapy. The response to treatment was directly related to the increment in serum zinc level. No patient of the placebo-treated group showed any response. CONCLUSIONS: We conclude that zinc sulphate at a dose of 10 mg kg(-1) daily seems to be a highly efficacious therapeutic option for recalcitrant viral warts and proved to be safe with few adverse effects.