Improving mass measurement of coronary artery calcification using threshold correction and thin collimation in multi-detector row computed tomography: in vitro experiment

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: This in vitro study was designed to improve the accuracy of coronary calcium mass measurement from computed tomography (CT) images by developing threshold-based calcium CT number correction and thin-slice spiral techniques. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A cardiac CT phantom containing simulated calcified cylinders of known calcium density was scanned with sequential 4 x 2.5-, spiral 16 x 1.5-, and spiral 16 x 0.75-mm collimation on 4- and 16-detector row CT scanners. The images obtained from the spiral scans were reconstructed in various slice widths. The calcified cylinders were imaged and their mean CT number and size were measured at thresholds ranging from 50 to 390 Hounsfield unit. The calcium mass measured was compared with the actual value to determine errors, and threshold-based correction factors were derived to minimize the errors. RESULTS: The minimum amount of measurable calcium in 1-mm cylinder was 0.3 mg at the 16 X 1.5-mm protocol and 0.2 mg at the 16 x 0.75-mm protocol. Compared with 2.5-mm sequential protocol, thin-slice spiral protocols yielded a higher radiation exposure and lower or similar image noise levels. The error in calcium mass after correction was significantly smaller than that in measured mass (P < .0001) and was consistent between the imaging protocols (P = .49). The accuracy of mass measurements was clearly improved by using thin-slice imaging protocols especially in 200-mg/cm3 calcium density (P < .0001). CONCLUSION: The accuracy of calcium mass CT measurement can be improved by threshold-based calcium CT number correction and thin collimation spiral techniques.     

Congenital anomalies of the coronary arteries: imaging with contrast-enhanced, multidetector computed tomography

The objective of this study is to evaluate multidetector CT (MDCT) in detecting and characterizing anomalous coronary arteries. Forty-four patients with anomalies of the coronaries were selected from a total of 1758 individuals examined with ECG-gated 4- and 16-row MDCT including thinMIP, MPR and VRT post-processing. Twenty-eight patients showed origin and course anomalies of the central coronary segments, and in this subgroup 13 were judged as malignant because of interarterial courses between the aortic root and the pulmonary trunk, either of the right coronary artery (n=11) or the left coronary artery (n=2). Twelve non-hemodynamic anomalies were found, affecting the coronary origins only (n=10) or the peripheral vessels courses (n=2). Four arteriovenous fistulas were present, all of them with complex arterial feeders. Regardless of vessel anatomy, coronary opacification was always possible by means of the systemic contrast agent, and the aberrant coronary arteries were visualized synoptically in direct relation to the great mediastinal vessels. In contrast to MDCT, selective cannulation and final diagnosis was possible in only 11 of the 20 catheter angiograms performed (accuracy of 55.0%). In conclusion, its non-invasiveness and precise visualization makes MDCT the standard of reference for evaluating anomalous coronary arteries.     

64-slice computed tomography assessment of coronary artery stents: a phantom study

Purpose: To compare the use of a new 64-slice computed tomography (CT) scanner with 16-slice CT in the visualization of coronary artery stent lumen.

Material and Methods: Eight different coronary artery stents, each with a diameter of 3 mm, were placed in a static chest phantom. The phantom was positioned in the CT gantry at an angle of 0° and 45° towards the z-axis and examined with both a 64-slice and a 16-slice CT scanner. Effective slice thickness was 0.6 mm with 64-slice CT and 1 mm with 16-slice CT. A reconstruction increment of 0.3 mm was applied in both scanners. Image quality was assessed visually using a 5-point grading scale. Stent diameters were measured and compared using paired Wilcoxon tests.

Results: Artificial lumen reduction was significantly less with 64-slice than with 16-slice CT. Average visible stent lumen was 53.4% using 64-slice CT and 47.5% with 16-slice MSCT. Most severe artifacts were seen in stents with radiopaque markers. Using 64-slice CT, image noise increased by approximately 30% due to thinner slice thickness.

Conclusion: Improved spatial resolution of 64-slice CT resulted in superior assessment of coronary artery stent lumen compared to 16-slice CT. However, a relevant part of the stent lumen is still not assessable with multi-slice CT.     

Multislice Spiral Computed Tomography of the Heart: Technique, Current Applications, and Perspective

Multislice spiral computed tomography (MSCT) is a rapidly evolving, noninvasive technique for cardiac imaging. Knowledge of the principle of electrocardiogram–gated MSCT and its limitations in clinical routine are needed to optimize image quality. Therefore, the basic technical principle including essentials of image postprocessing is described. Cardiac MSCT imaging was initially focused on coronary calcium scoring, MSCT coronary angiography, and analysis of left ventricular function. Recent studies also evaluated the ability of cardiac MSCT to visualize myocardial infarction and assess valvular morphology. In combination with experimental approaches toward the assessment of aortic valve function and myocardial viability, cardiac MSCT holds the potential for a comprehensive examination of the heart using one single examination technique.     

Single coronary artery with spasm

A single coronary artery is a rare and potentially serious anomaly. We present the case of a 54-year-old woman with chest pain predominantly at rest. A single coronary artery was demonstrated by 64-row multidetector computed tomography (CT) imaging, which is useful for the diagnosis and classification of coronary anomaly. In our case, no coronary artery stenosis was demonstrated on CT angiographic images, and totally occlusive coronary spasm was confirmed by intracoronary infusion of acetylcholine.     

Detection,visualization and evaluation of anomalous coronary anatomy on 16-slice multidetector-row CT

Early identification and evaluation of relatively frequent anomalous coronary anatomy is quite relevant because of the occurrence of sudden cardiac death or related symptoms of myocardial ischemia. Selective coronary angiography (CAG) is invasive, expensive and cannot always provide the required information adequately. Recently, non-invasive imaging techniques such as magnetic resonance imaging and multidetector-row computed tomography (MDCT) have been shown to provide a good anatomical view of the coronary artery tree. This study aims to demonstrate the value of 16-MDCT for evaluation of anomalous coronary anatomy. In 13 patients scanned using 16-MDCT, six different coronary anomalies were diagnosed [two absent left main, one single vessel left coronary artery (LCA), three LCA originating from the right (two with interarterial course), six right coronary artery originating from the left, one double left anterior descending (LAD)]. Mean diagnostic quality, recorded by two observers using a 5-point scale (1= non-diagnostic to 5= excellent diagnostic quality), resulted in a mean score of 3.73 (SD 1.19) without any non-diagnostic result. MDCT offers an accurate diagnostic modality to visualize the origin and course of anomalous coronary arteries by a three-dimensional display of anatomy. Shortcomings in CAG can be overcome by the use of contrast-enhanced MDCT.     

Value of conventional chest radiography for the detection of coronary calcifications: comparison with MSCT

Purpose

To evaluate if computed tomography (CT) coronary calcium scoring is needed after detection of coronary calcifications on conventional chest radiographs.

Materials and methods

One hundred and five patients (67 men; 57.2 ± 12.8 years) with suspected coronary artery disease underwent conventional chest radiography and non-enhanced, retrospectively ECG-gated multislice spiral CT (MSCT) of the heart (4 mm × 2.5 mm, 120 kV, 133 mAs_eff.). Chest radiographs were assessed independently by two radiologists. Detection of coronary calcifications was compared between both methods. Sensitivity, specificity, negative and positive predictive values, median, 25% and 75% percentiles for the detection of coronary calcifications were calculated. Receiver operating characteristics (ROC) analyses were computed.

Results

In 90 patients, MSCT revealed coronary calcifications. The mean coronary calcium score was 526.2 (0–4784.5). On chest radiographs, coronary calcifications were correctly detected in 46 (61) patients by observer 1 (observer 2). The corresponding sensitivity was 51.1% in observer 1 and 67.8% in observer 2. Median of detected coronary calcifications was 361.9 (426.4) for observer 1 (observer 2). Corresponding 25% und 75% percentiles were 109.6 (109.6) and 798.5 (898.5). The area under the ROC curve was 0.636 for observer 1 and 0.715 for observer 2. There was no correlation between image quality and the detection of coronary calcifications on plain film radiographs.

Conclusion

As coronary calcifications of various extents are inconsistently detected on plain chest radiographs, CT calcium scoring may not be omitted even if coronary artery calcifications were detected on conventional chest radiographs.     

Calcium score of small coronary calcifications on multidetector computed tomography: Results from a static phantom study

Introduction

Multi detector computed tomography (MDCT) underestimates the coronary calcium score as compared to electron beam tomography (EBT). Therefore clinical risk stratification based on MDCT calcium scoring may be inaccurate. The aim of this study was to assess the feasibility of a new phantom which enables establishment of a calcium scoring protocol for MDCT that yields a calcium score comparable to the EBT values and to the physical mass.

Materials and methods

A phantom containing 100 small calcifications ranging from 0.5 to 2.0 mm was scanned on EBT using a standard coronary calcium protocol. In addition, the phantom was scanned on a 320-row MDCT scanner using different scanning, reconstruction and scoring parameters (tube voltage 80–135 kV, slice thickness 0.5–3.0 mm, reconstruction kernel FC11–FC15 and threshold 110–150 HU). The Agatston and mass score of both modalities was compared and the influence of the parameters was assessed.

Results

On EBT the Agatston and mass scores were between 0 and 20, and 0 and 3 mg, respectively. On MDCT the Agatston and mass scores were between 0 and 20, and 0 and 4 mg, respectively. All parameters showed an influence on the calcium score. The Agatston score on MDCT differed 52% between the 80 and 135 kV, 65% between 0.5 and 3.0 mm and 48% between FC11 and FC15. More calcifications were detected with a lower tube voltage, a smaller slice thickness, a sharper kernel and a lower threshold. Based on these observations an acquisition protocol with a tube voltage of 100 kV and two reconstructions protocols were defined with a FC12 reconstruction kernel; one with a slice thickness of 3.0 mm and a one with a slice thickness of 0.5 mm. This protocol yielded an Agatston score as close to the EBT as possible, but also a mass score as close to the physical phantom value as possible, respectively.

Conclusion

With the new phantom one acquisition protocol and two reconstruction protocols can be defined which produces Agatston scores comparable to EBT values and to the physical mass.     

Effects of scanning and reconstruction parameters on image quality in electron-beam CT angiography: coronary artery phantom study

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: This study compared the image quality obtained with different scanning and reconstruction parameters for electron-beam computed tomographic (CT) angiography and sought optimal methods for visualizing the coronary artery lumen. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Electron-beam CT angiography with contrast material enhancement was used to image 35 branches of fresh postmortem swine coronary arteries. Different collimation widths, fields of view (FOVs), reconstruction kernels, and algorithms were employed to reconstruct the acquired raw data into CT angiographic images. Image quality was compared and analyzed. RESULTS: The contrast-to-noise ratios (C/Ns) for 1.5-, 2-, and 3-mm section thickness were 28.4 +/- 15.2, 31.9 +/- 9.3, and 33.8 +/- 14.5, respectively (P < .05). The lengths of visualized coronary artery lumina were significantly longer for 1.5-mm scanning (71.6 mm +/- 4.3) than for 2-mm (58.3 mm +/- 5.5) and 3-mm scanning (59.0 mm +/- 8.0) (P < .01). The C/Ns for 12.7-, 18.0-, and 26.0-cm FOV reconstruction were 32.8 +/- 9.9, 28.9 +/- 8.2, and 27.1 +/- 8.2, respectively (not significant), and the visualized luminal lengths were 76.1 mm +/- 12.5, 71.7 mm +/- 14.6, and 65.4 mm +/- 13.1, respectively (not significant). The highest C/N (48.2 +/- 13.3) was achieved with smooth kernels and a cone-beam algorithm, and the lowest (14.7 +/- 3.4) with very sharp kernels and a normal algorithm. Cone-beam algorithm images had significantly higher C/Ns than did normal algorithm images (P < .001), and they demonstrated longer coronary artery lumina (P < .01). CONCLUSION: Collimation width, FOV, reconstruction kernels, and algorithms are important in the processing of high-quality electron-beam coronary angiograms. A 1.5-mm collimation width, 12.7-cm FOV, cone-beam reconstruction algorithm, and very sharp kernels should help in obtaining the best image quality and depicting the longest segments of coronary artery lumen.     

Causes of interscan variability of coronary artery calcium measurements at electron-beam CT

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: The authors performed this study to investigate the causes of interscan variability of coronary artery calcium measurements at electron-beam computed tomography (CT). MATERIALS AND METHODS: Two sets of electron-beam CT scans were obtained in 298 consecutive patients who underwent electron-beam CT to screen for coronary artery calcium. Interscan variations of coronary artery calcium characteristics and the effects of heart rate, electrocardiographic (ECG) triggering method, image noise, and coronary motion on interscan variability were analyzed. RESULTS: The interscan mean variabilities were 21.6% (median, 11.7%) and 17.8% (median, 10.8%) with the Agatston and volumetric score, respectively (P < .01). Variability decreased with increasing calcification score (34.6% for a score of 11-50 and 9.4% for a score of 400-1,000, P < .0001). The absolute difference in Agatston score between scans was 44.1 +/- 95.6. The correlation coefficient between the first and second sets of scans was 0.99 (P < .0001). Lower interscan variability was found in younger patients (<60 years), patients with stable heart rates (heart rate changing less than 10 beats per minute during scanning), patients with no visible coronary motion, and those with an optimal ECG triggering method (P < .05 for all). Results of multivariate logistic analysis showed that changes in calcium volume, mean attenuation, and peak attenuation were significant predictors of interscan variability and caused the interscan variations of the coronary artery calcium measurements (r2 = 0.83, P < .0001). CONCLUSION: Coronary calcification at electron-beam CT varies from scan to scan. Volumetric scoring and optimal ECG triggering should be used to reduce interscan variability. Baseline calcium score and interscan variability must be considered in the evaluation of calcium progression.     

Multidetector CT (64 Slices) of the liver: examination techniques

Sixty-four-row MDCT, although developed primarily for cardiac imaging, has the potential to have a great impact on liver imaging as well. Liver-imaging protocols with sub-millimeter collimation improve longitudinal spatial resolution, making the acquired dataset a real isotropic volume perfectly designed for optimal three-dimensional rendering and accurate organ and lesion volumetry. The 64-row detector array offers a wide volumetric coverage (up to 40 mm), suitable not only for shortening scanning time and improving spatial resolution, but also for including a large volume per single rotation, particularly useful for accurate CT perfusion studies. In order to take full benefit from the enormous performance offered by new 64-row MDCT scanners, imaging protocols need to be redesigned. Due to the extremely short scanning window, contrast agent injection should be performed at high flow rate and followed by saline bolus chaser; the use of highly concentrated contrast media might be useful. Timing should be accurately calculated either by a test bolus or, better, by using an automatic bolus-detection technique. Radiation exposure is kept under control, using automatic device-modulating dose delivery according to the patient’s anatomy. Finally, the evaluation of acquired volumetric datasets needs the extensive use of a dedicated workstation, with software with sophisticated rendering capabilities.     

Aortic atherosclerosis detected with electron-beam CT as a predictor of obstructive coronary artery disease

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: Several studies have demonstrated an association between coronary and aortic atherosclerosis. Aortic atherosclerosis is easily quantified by means of electron-beam computed tomography (CT). The aim of this study was to evaluate the usefulness of measurement of aortic atherosclerosis with electron-beam CT as an independent predictor of obstructive coronary artery disease (CAD). MATERIALS AND METHODS: Ninety-seven patients (67 men, 30 women; mean age, 61 years +/- 12) were enrolled and underwent electron-beam CT with and without contrast material. Coronary artery calcification was quantified with nonenhanced electron-beam CT by means of Agatston score. CAD was defined as luminal narrowing of the coronary artery by at least 70%, as measured with electron-beam angiography. Aortic atherosclerosis was quantified by measuring raised lesions of the aortic wall (plaque) and wall thickening (volume and thickness) in the midportion of the descending thoracic aorta (10 contiguous sections), as depicted at contrast material-enhanced CT angiography. RESULTS: Aortic plaque and calcification were detected only in patients who were at least 58 years old. The presence of aortic plaque was predictive of obstructive CAD, independent of coronary artery calcification. The sensitivity of aortic plaque (raised lesions) for obstructive CAD was 89% in patients at least 58 years old, and the specificity was 63%. Aortic calcification had a sensitivity of 56% and a specificity of 72% for diagnosis of obstructive CAD. CONCLUSION: This study demonstrated that aortic plaque detected with contrast-enhanced electron-beam CT was a more consistent predictor of obstructive CAD than other independent aortic variables. Aortic calcification depicted on nonenhanced CT images was highly specific for obstructive CAD.     

Effects of window and threshold levels on the accuracy of three-dimensional rendering techniques in coronary artery electron-beam CT angiography

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: The authors performed this study to evaluate the effect of window level and gray-scale threshold on the demonstration of coronary artery lumina at three-dimensional electron-beam computed tomographic (CT) angiography. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Forty-four coronary artery branches in postmortem pigs were evaluated with electron-beam CT angiography, and the findings were compared with those from conventional angiography. Images from electron-beam CT angiography were reconstructed with maximal intensity projection (MIP), multiplanar reformation (MPR), and shaded-surface display (SSD). Four categories of window level and gray-scale threshold were evaluated. RESULTS: Three-dimensional electron-beam CT angiography accurately depicted the luminal diameters of the coronary arteries compared with conventional angiography (r = 0.83-0.90, P < .0001). The length of lumina visualized at electron-beam CT angiography was significantly shorter than that visualized with conventional angiography (P < .001). The use of MPR enabled visualization of longer segments of coronary arteries than did the use of MIP or SSD (P < .05). The higher the window level and gray-scale threshold used, the smaller the coronary luminal diameters measured (P < .05). The most accurate window level and gray-scale threshold (82.6 HU +/- 29.8 and 89.5 HU +/- 29.7, respectively) were found to correspond to the attenuation of the lumina (275.8 HU +/- 58.8). Results of simple linear regression showed a strong correlation between luminal attenuation and window level (r = 0.89, P < .0001) or gray-scale threshold (r = 0.95, P < .0001). CONCLUSION: Electron-beam CT angiography shows promise in the visualization of coronary artery lumina. For accurate display of lumina, a proper window level and gray-scale threshold for three-dimensional rendering techniques should be determined and used on the basis of the attenuation of the target vessel.     

Optimal electrocardiographically triggered phase for reducing motion artifact at electron-beam CT in the coronary artery

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: The authors performed this study to (a) investigate coronary movement with electron-beam computed tomography (CT) and (b) find the optimal electrocardiographic (ECG) triggering phase for eliminating motion artifact. MATERIALS AND METHODS: One hundred fifty-one patients without arrhythmia were examined with electron-beam CT. First, movie scans were obtained to create displacement and velocity graphs of coronary artery movement. Then, a volume scan with an exposure time of 100 msec was obtained with various ECG trigger settings. RESULTS: Movement patterns of coronary arteries varied with heart rate. Optimal triggering phase was before atrial systole (near 71% of the R-R interval) when heart rate was slower than 68 beats per minute and at ventricular end systole when heart rate was fast. Rate of severe motion artifacts decreased from 43% to 0% when triggering was altered from 80% of the R-R interval to the individual optimal value. Experimental values of the optimal phase at different heart rates were derived, and severe motion artifact was only 3.0% with these values. CONCLUSION: ECG triggering set according to the heart rate enables a great reduction in motion artifacts at electron-beam CT with a 100-msec exposure time. The results may have implications for magnetic resonance imaging of the coronary artery.     

Measurement of the RT interval on ECG records during electron-beam CT

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: The R wave of the electrocardiogram is used widely as a trigger for cardiac imaging. This study was designed to determine the optimal interval between the R wave and end systole for triggering of electron-beam computed tomography (CT) in a group of patients with various heart rates who are undergoing assessment for coronary artery calcification. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A total of 862 consecutive asymptomatic patients referred for screening with electron-beam CT for coronary artery calcification were enrolled in the study. Patients' R-R, RT, and PR intervals were measured by using the software of the CT console computer. Correlation coefficients were computed and linear regression analyses were performed for all intervals measured. Results were analyzed according to patient age (three subgroups), sex (two subgroups), and heart rate (nine subgroups). Separate formulas for calculating the length of RT intervals in men and in women were developed. RESULTS: After correction for heart rate, a significant difference was found in mean RT and PR intervals between women and men, with the mean intervals in women being longer (P < .001). No significant difference was found in these intervals within the three age-defined subgroups (< or = 40, 41-60, and >60 years; P > .05). However, significant negative correlations were found between heart rates and the lengths of all measured intervals. The results of statistical analysis indicate that most of the variation in the R-R interval with different heart rates occurred in diastole and that the duration of systole was relatively constant. CONCLUSION: For optimal cardiac imaging, triggering should take place in late systole, avoiding the RT interval variability that occurs in diastole.     

Detection of coronary artery calcifications predicting coronary heart disease: comparison of fluoroscopy and spiral CT

The aim of this study was to evaluate the clinical relevance of coronary artery calcifications detected by spiral CT, congruence with fluoroscopy (FS) and coronary angiography, and comparison with studies reporting on application of double-helical CT and ultrafast CT. Forty patients underwent spiral CT (2-mm slice thickness, table feed 3 mm/s), coronary angiography, and FS (performed in the usual manner). Stenosis and calcifications were evaluated semiquantitatively. Nineteen patients suffering from a stenosis ≥ 75 % were verified at coronary angiography. All had coronary artery calcification on spiral CT. Fluoroscopy did not detect 8 of 19 patients with a stenosis ≥ 75 % (1 vessel: n = 1; 2 vessels: n = 3; 3 vessels: n = 4). In spiral CT sensitivity was 100 % and specificity was 33 % (FS: 58 and 48 %). Positive predictive value was 83 % for spiral CT (FS: 50 %), and negative predictive value was 100 % (FS: 56 %). A significant linear increase in the calcification score was found for increasing maximal stenosis (p < 0.005). Spiral CT is more sensitive than FS in the recognition of hemodynamic relevant stenoses using the detection of coronary artery calcifications. Statistical parameters are comparable to ultrafast-CT. Spiral CT is a suitable non-invasive diagnostic technique in coronary heart disease. Coronary calcifications found incidentally in symptomatic patients at chest CT should be reported to the referring physician for further cardiological workup. Received 14 July 1997; Revision received 29 December 1997; Accepted 5 January 1998