Specificity of tyrosinase and HMB45 PCR in the detection of melanoma metastases in sentinel lymph node biopsies

AIMS: Sentinel lymph node biopsy is an increasingly established procedure in the primary staging of high-risk melanoma patients. However, the laboratory evaluation of sentinel lymph node biopsies is a matter of controversy. The aim of this study was to determine the specificity of polymerase chain reaction (PCR) techniques for the evaluation of lymph nodes with regard to melanoma metastases in comparison with histology and immunohistology. METHODS AND RESULTS: Sentinel lymph nodes (n = 41) from 29 melanoma patients and 29 lymph nodes from 27 patients without melanoma were analysed by histology (H&E) and immunohistology (Melan A, HMB45). cDNA of these lymph nodes was subjected to LightCycler PCR amplification using primers specific for tyrosinase and HMB45. Two melanoma sentinel lymph nodes contained naevus cells by histology and immunohistology and were therefore excluded from further evaluation. Eight (20.5%) of the remaining 39 melanoma sentinel lymph nodes were positive by histology and immunohistology and tyrosinase PCR, 15.4% (6/39) were positive only by tyrosinase PCR, 2.6% (1/39) were positive only by histology and immunohistology. HMB45 PCR revealed positive results in 7.7% (3/39) sentinel lymph nodes, which were also positive by tyrosinase PCR and histology and immunohistology. Of non-melanoma lymph nodes 13.8% (4/29) and 14.8% (4/27) of non-melanoma patients were positive by tyrosinase PCR but negative by histology and immunohistology and HMB45 PCR. Thus, tyrosinase PCR had a specificity of only 85.2%. CONCLUSIONS: The specificity of tyrosinase PCR and the sensitivity of HMB45 PCR are too low to recommend these PCR examinations for the guidance of therapy, in particular complete regional lymph node dissection.     

Can Melan-A replace S-100 and HMB-45 in the evaluation of sentinel lymph nodes from patients with malignant melanoma?

The sentinel lymph node (SLN) biopsy has become an increasingly important procedure used in the primary staging of malignant melanoma. However, micrometastases in a lymph node can be easily missed on routine H&E-stained sections. Therefore, S-100 and HMB-45 IHC stains are standardly performed on grossly negative SLNs for detection of metastatic melanoma. Each of these IHC markers, however, is not ideal. The authors investigated whether the newer IHC marker Melan-A would improve the detection of metastatic melanoma in SLN biopsies. Forty lymph nodes previously diagnosed with metastatic melanoma were retrospectively evaluated for S-100, HMB-45, and Melan-A expression. In addition, 42 SLN biopsies for metastatic melanoma detection were prospectively collected and evaluated for S-100, HMB-45, and Melan-A expression. All lymph nodes with metastatic melanoma from the retrospective study demonstrated S-100 reactivity. Five of the lymph nodes with metastatic melanoma from the retrospective study failed to express either HMB-45 or Melan-A, all of which displayed a desmoplastic morphology. One of the metastases positive for S-100 and HMB-45 failed to show reactivity with Melan-A (3%). The prospective study found 10 lymph nodes from 42 cases to be positive for metastatic melanoma, which were positive for S-100 (100%). Nine of the involved lymph nodes were positive for HMB-45(90%), and nine were positive for Melan-A (90%). Melan-A, although very specific, cannot replace the use of S-100 and HMB-45 for the detection of metastatic melanoma in SLNs. It can, however, substitute for HMB-45 with equally good results.     

KBA.62: a useful marker for primary and metastatic melanomas

We previously described a novel antimelanoma antibody, designated KBA.62. However, review of the literature showed that only a few studies have reported on this antibody. We report our experience in the diagnosis of melanoma using KBA.62 and its value in both primary and metastatic conditions. In addition to conventional melanomas, we included desmoplastic and spindle cell melanomas, whose diagnosis can be challenging. We also focus on identification of malignant cells in sentinel lymph node biopsies using KBA.62, by comparison with anti-S-100 protein and HMB-45 antibodies, because discrepancies in sensitivity and specificity of melanoma markers have given rise to numerous studies aiming to determine the best panel for the evaluation of sentinel lymph node from patients with melanoma. Overall, KBA.62 was positive in 93% of primary and metastatic melanomas. Interestingly, the 12 cases of desmoplastic and spindle cell melanomas had strongly positive results. In addition, the results of our study performed on a series of 215 sentinel lymph nodes showed that the sensitivity of anti-S-100 protein and KBA.62 antibodies in detecting occult metastasis was similar. Moreover, KBA.62 identified 6 patients (3%) who had confirmed sentinel lymph node metastasis but were negative for HMB-45. The resolution was higher with KBA.62 than that observed with anti-S-100 protein antibody, as the nonmelanocytic positive cells for KBA.62 in lymph nodes were only represented by endothelial cells, which therefore constituted an intrinsic positive control. We conclude that KBA.62 antibody is a useful additional marker for melanoma, specifically in desmoplastic/spindle cell cases and in the context of micrometastasis in sentinel lymph node.     

Malignant melanoma: A search for occult lymph node metastases

Lymph nodes regarded as “negative” following routine pathologic examination were reexamined in seven patients with malignant melanoma who later developed systemic metastases. A total of 185 lymph nodes were serially sectioned; five to seven levels of each lymph node were examined for the presence of occult metastases. In this manner previously undetected tumor was found within a solitary lymph node of one patient. It is concluded that attempts to detect occult melanoma metastases by routine serial sectioning of lymph nodes is not of practical applicability.     

The development of optimal pathological assessment of sentinel lymph nodes for melanoma

1158 sentinel lymph nodes (SLNs), excised from patients with primary cutaneous melanoma, were assessed pathologically using histology with immunohistochemistry (IHC) on all nodes, and RT-PCR for Mart-1 and tyrosinase on 55 nodes. RT-PCR was compared with the histology and IHC assessed on the same nodes. The evaluation of progressively more detailed protocols for histology and IHC modulated by the RT-PCR results led to a procedure that consistently detects metastases in 34% of patients submitted to SLN biopsy for cutaneous melanomas with a vertical growth phase and a mean thickness of 2.02 mm (range 0.25, with regression, to 19 mm). As this technique is virtually free of false positives and produces only a marginally lower detection rate than RT-PCR, which was subject to false positives of 7% in our study, it is suggested that this extended protocol should be the basis on which further evaluation of the place of RT-PCR in SLN assessment takes place. The evolved protocol described here has been adopted by the EORTC as the standard procedure for pathological handling of sentinel lymph nodes for melanoma when SLN status is a criterion in their clinical trials or studies.     

Histopathological patterns of melanoma metastases in sentinel lymph nodes

AIMS: Sentinel lymph node biopsy (SLNB) is an important component in the staging and treatment of cutaneous melanoma (CM). The medical literature provides only limited information regarding melanoma sentinel lymph node (SLN) histology. This report details the specific histological patterns of melanoma metastases in sentinel lymph nodes (SLNs) and highlights some key factors in evaluating SLNs for melanoma. METHODS: From 281 SLNB cases between June 1998 and May 2002, 79 consecutive cases of SLN biopsies positive for metastases from CM were retrospectively reviewed. The important characteristics of the SLNs and the metastatic foci are described. RESULTS: The median size of positive SLNs was 17 mm (range, 5-38). SLNs had a median of two metastatic foci (range, 1-11), with the largest foci being a median of 1.1 mm in size (range, 0.05-24). S-100 and HMB-45 staining was positive in 100% and 92% of the detected metastatic foci, respectively. The metastatic melanoma cells were epithelioid, spindled, and mixed in 86%, 5%, and 9% of cases. Metastatic foci were most often (86%) found in the subcapsular region of the SLN. Benign naevic cells were found coexisting in 14% of positive SLNs. CONCLUSIONS: Staining for S100 is more sensitive than HMB-45 (100% v 92%), but HMB-45 staining helped to distinguish benign naevic cells from melanoma. The subcapsular region was crucial in SLN evaluation, because it contained the metastases in 86% of cases. Evaluation of the subcapsular space should not be compromised by cautery artefacts or incomplete excision of the SLN.     

HMB-45, S-100, NK1/C3, and MART-1 in metastatic melanoma

The diagnosis of melanoma metastatic to lymph node remains a difficult problem given its histological diversity. We examined the staining patterns of S-100, NK1/C3, HMB-45, and MART-1 (DC10) in melanoma metastases to lymph nodes. Immunohistochemical stains were performed on tissue sections of 126 formalin-fixed lymph nodes from 126 patients with an established diagnosis of metastatic melanoma. A total of 98% of cases (123 of 126) stained positive for S-100, 93% (117 of 125) stained positive for NK1/C3, 82% (103 of 126) stained positive for MART-1, and 76% (95 of 125) stained positive for HMB-45. The distribution and intensity of staining varied among these markers. A diffuse staining pattern, defined as >50% of tumor cells stained, was observed in 83% of MART-1-positive cases but in only 56% of S-100-positive cases, 48% of NK1/C3-positive cases, and 34% of HMB-45-positive cases. A maximally intense signal was almost always observed for MART-1 (83% of positive cases) but was rarely observed for NK1/C3 (20%). S-100 and HMB-45 showed maximally intense staining in 50% and 54% of cases, respectively. S-100 and NK1/C3 stained both histiocytes and melanocytes, whereas MART-1 and HMB-45 stained only melanocytes. Seventy-eight cases (63%) stained positive for all 4 markers, 17 cases (14%) stained for all markers except HMB-45, 13 cases (10%) stained for all markers except MART-1, 6 cases (5%) stained only with S-100 and NK1/C3, 4 cases (3%) stained only with S-100 and HMB-45, and 2 cases stained for all markers except S-100. One case each stained for the following: only S-100, only S-100 and HMB-45, and all markers except NK1/C3. One case exhibited absence of staining for any of these markers. We demonstrate that lymph node metastases of melanoma are heterogeneous with regard to tumor marker expression. S-100 and NK1/C3 were the most sensitive stains for detecting metastatic melanoma; however, they both also stain other nontumor cells in lymph nodes. MART-1 did not stain histiocytes and exhibited a more frequently intense and diffuse staining pattern than NK1/C3. HMB-45 was less sensitive and demonstrated less diffuse staining than MART-1.     

Sentinel lymph nodes in cutaneous melanoma: the experience in the Florence area

In the period 1997-2001, 466 sentinel lymph nodes from 342 lymphatic basins in 322 melanoma patients were examined at the Health Unit of Florence. The lymphatic mapping was performed through pre-operative lymphoscintigraphy using technetium-labelled nano-colloid, intradermal injections of vital blue dye and intra-operative gamma-probe. The examined patients were 182 females and 140 males. Sentinel lymph node was one in 65.2% of cases; two sentinel lymph nodes were detected in 27% of cases and more than 2 sentinel nodes were detected in 7.8% of cases. Melanoma metastases in one or more sentinel lymph nodes were found in 61/322 patients (18.9%). Lymphatic basins resulted to be involved by melanoma metastases were 64/342 (18.7%); sentinel lymph nodes containing metastatic melanoma deposits were 73/466 (15.6%). No metastasis was found in patients with melanoma thickness < or = 1 mm. One or more positive sentinel lymph nodes were found in 7.5% of patients with melanoma thickness > 1.00 and < or = 1.50 mm, in 27.7% of patients with melanoma > 1.50 and < or = 3.00 mm, in 38.2% of patients with melanoma > 3.00 and < or = 4.00, and in 60.7% of patients with melanoma > 4.00 mm. Frozen section analysis of sentinel lymph nodes, performed in 59/61 patients with nodal metastases, detected nodal involvement in 21 patients (35.6%). Metastases were identified by routine hematoxylin-eosin staining in 57/64 positive lymphatic basins; in 7 cases (11%) metastases were detected by immunohistochemical stainings (S100 and HMB-45). A nodal nevus was found in 3/466 sentinel lymph nodes (0.6%). Our data are analyzed and compared to previously data of the literature. The value of frozen section analysis and the major problems in the diagnosis of melanoma micrometastases in sentinel lymph nodes are discussed. The importance of the sentinel node biopsy for the detection of occult metastases and for the correct staging of melanoma patients are stressed, according to the new TNM melanoma classification.     

Tyrosinase expression in malignant melanoma,desmoplastic melanoma,and peripheral nerve tumors

CONTEXT: Pathologists may encounter problems in the differential diagnosis of malignant melanoma, spindle and epithelioid neoplasms of peripheral nerves, and fibrohistiocytic tumors. Tyrosinase has been demonstrated to be a sensitive marker for melanoma. OBJECTIVE: To determine the specificity of tyrosinase expression in the differential diagnosis of melanoma, desmoplastic melanoma, and peripheral nerve sheath tumors. DESIGN: Immunoreactivity for tyrosinase, HMB-45 (anti-gp100 protein), S100 protein, CD34, and vimentin was studied in 70 tumors, including 15 melanomas (5 desmoplastic, 4 amelanotic, 6 melanotic), 13 malignant peripheral nerve sheath tumors; 10 schwannomas (1 pigmented), 12 neurofibromas (4 pigmented), and 20 fibrohistiocytic tumors (10 dermatofibrosarcoma protuberans and 10 dermatofibromas). Microwave-based antigen retrieval was performed in 10mM citrate buffer, pH 6.0, for 20 minutes at 121 degrees C. RESULTS: All melanomas demonstrated positive immunostaining for tyrosinase, HMB-45, and S100 protein. Immunoreactivity for HMB-45 was generally stronger than that for tyrosinase in amelanotic lesions and significantly stronger in 1 of the desmoplastic lesions. The 4 pigmented neurofibromas were focally positive for tyrosinase, but did not stain for HMB-45. The pigmented schwannoma was focally positive for both tyrosinase and HMB-45. The malignant peripheral nerve sheath tumors, dermatofibrosarcoma protuberans, and dermatofibromas were nonreactive for tyrosinase and HMB-45. CONCLUSIONS: Our results support the sensitivity of tyrosinase expression and demonstrate the relative specificity of tyrosinase as a marker for melanocytic lesions, including desmoplastic melanoma, although pigmented peripheral nerve tumors may demonstrate focal positive staining. Immunoreactivity for tyrosinase and HMB-45 may have been enhanced by the microwave-based antigen-retrieval technique used in this study.     

Rapid immunohistochemistry of sentinel lymph nodes for metastatic melanoma

Sentinel lymph node (SLN) biopsy is performed on patients with malignant melanoma (MM) to assess the need for selective complete lymphadenectomy. Melanoma metastasis to regional lymph nodes is an important prognostic indicator in patients with MM. This study assesses the sensitivity and specificity of rapid immunohistochemistry (RIHC) in intraoperative delineation of melanoma metastasis to SLN. RIHC for S-100 protein, HMB45, and a melanoma marker cocktail (melan A, HMB45, and tyrosinase) was performed on 71 SLNs obtained from 28 patients with MM. Frozen sections (6 micro thick) on plus slides were fixed for 2 to 3 minutes in cold acetone and then stored at -70 degrees C. The EnVision kit (Dako, Carpinteria, CA) for rapid immunohistochemistry (RIHC) on frozen tissue sections was used, and the staining technique took 19 minutes. Together with preparation of the frozen sections and fixation in acetone, immunostained slides were available in approximately 25 minutes. Of the 71 SNLs examined, 7 showed melanoma metastasis in permanent sections. RIHC of frozen sections detected metastatic melanoma in 6 SLNs, with a sensitivity of 86% for HMB45 and 71% for S-100 protein and the melanoma cocktail and a specificity of 97% for HMB45 and 100% for S-100 and the melanoma cocktail. We conclude that RIHC for HMB45, S-100 protein, and the melanoma cocktail may help detect melanoma metastasis in SLN intraoperatively, leading to total lymph node dissection and obviating the need for 2 surgical procedures. Section folds and background stain can make interpretation difficult. Intraoperative time constraints require a more rapid technique. A recent consensus group has discouraged frozen-section examination of SLN.