Cancer research 2001: drug resistance, new targets and drug combinations.

The development of new anticancer drugs and the identification of novel targets represent major focus areas for pharmaceutical and biotech companies, universities and research institutes worldwide. The 92nd Annual Meeting of the American Association for Cancer Research (AACR) provided a glimpse of the latest developments in the cancer field. We highlight here presentations on resistance mechanisms (efflux, target modulation), new targets and drugs in development (topoisomerase, angiogenesis, cell cycle inhibitors) and new molecular technologies. The emergence of technologies for concurrently screening for expression of thousands of genes, has provided a new approach for the identification of molecular targets and mechanisms of both action and resistance of new compounds. The importance of inhibiting multiple targets simultaneously was brought up in several presentations.     

The apicoplast as an antimalarial drug target.

Resistance to commonly used malaria drugs is spreading and new drugs are required urgently. The recent identification of a relict chloroplast (apicoplast) in malaria and related parasites offers numerous new targets for drug therapy using well-characterized compounds. The apicoplast contains a range of metabolic pathways and housekeeping processes that differ radically to those of the host thereby presenting ideal strategies for drug therapy. Indeed, many compounds targeting these plastid pathways are antimalarial and have favourable profiles based on extensive knowledge from their use as antibacterials.     

The impact of antimalarial drug resistance mutations on parasite fitness, and its implications for the evolution of resistance.

It is widely assumed in genetics that most mutations disrupt metabolism to some extent, and are consequently likely to be disadvantageous for the organisms that inherit them. This may apply to mutations encoding drug resistance in malaria, where the mutation may be disadvantageous in the absence of the drug, imposing a genetic 'cost' of resistance. We review several lines of evidence suggesting that such costs do occur, that they may be relatively large, and review their likely impact on the evolution of drug resistance in the malaria parasite Plasmodium falciparum.     

The danger of fixed drug combinations.

After the second world war a number of pharmaceutical firms which were not able to create new therapeutic substances by their own research, put a great number of fixed drug combinations on the market. Their number quickly increased, as the efficiency of these compounds required no legal proof and as, with appropriate propaganda, large profits could be earned. The number of firms doing this sort of production also increased, and in West Germany, for instance, more than 3/4 of all drugs on the official list are now fixed combinations. Our task is, therefore, to ask for regulations which limit fixed combinations to such preparation the efficiency of which has been shown and whose advantages more than outweigh their disadvantages. The advantages of these preparations are convenience to the patient, avoidance of potential mistakes made possible by too many drugs given on the same day and, perhaps, lower prices. The disadvantages are: 1. The individual optimum dose for a patient cannot be achieved, because in case of a change of dosis all components are changed. 2. Different components may have different duration of action. 3. Different components may have a different bioavailability. 4. Different components may interact. 5. Some components may create tolerance, others not. In many cases fixed combinations have been used to make drugs with poor efficiency financially viable by combining them with very efficient drugs. The existence of thousands of fixed combinations makes the drug market indiscernible and useless. They obscure the relatively few essential drugs and make it difficult for the doctor to find his way amongst the mass of offered medicaments. Few fixed combinations are justifiable. These are well known and they should be permitted as before. All others should be banned until it has been shown that their advantages are greater than their disadvantages.     

Novel antimalarial drug targets: hope for new antimalarial drugs

Malaria is a major global threat, that results in more than 2 million deaths each year. The treatment of malaria is becoming extremely difficult due to the emergence of drug-resistant parasites, the absence of an effective vaccine, and the spread of insecticide-resistant vectors. Thus, malarial therapy needs new chemotherapeutic approaches leading to the search for new drug targets. Here, we discuss different approaches to identifying novel antimalarial drug targets. We have also given due attention to the existing validated targets with a view to develop novel, rationally designed lead molecules. Some of the important parasite proteins are claimed to be the targets; however, further in vitro or in vivo structure–function studies of such proteins are crucial to validate these proteins as suitable targets. The interactome analysis among apicoplast, mitochondrion and genomic DNA will also be useful in identifying vital pathways or proteins regulating critical pathways for parasite growth and survival, and could be attractive targets. Molecules responsible for parasite invasion to host erythrocytes and ion channels of infected erythrocytes, essential for intra-erythrocyte survival and stage progression of parasites are also becoming attractive targets. This review will discuss and highlight the current understanding regarding the potential antimalarial drug targets, which could be utilized to develop novel antimalarials.     

Novel antimalarial drug targets: hope for new antimalarial drugs

Malaria is a major global threat, that results in more than 2 million deaths each year. The treatment of malaria is becoming extremely difficult due to the emergence of drug-resistant parasites, the absence of an effective vaccine, and the spread of insecticide-resistant vectors. Thus, malarial therapy needs new chemotherapeutic approaches leading to the search for new drug targets. Here, we discuss different approaches to identifying novel antimalarial drug targets. We have also given due attention to the existing validated targets with a view to develop novel, rationally designed lead molecules. Some of the important parasite proteins are claimed to be the targets; however, further in vitro or in vivo structure-function studies of such proteins are crucial to validate these proteins as suitable targets. The interactome analysis among apicoplast, mitochondrion and genomic DNA will also be useful in identifying vital pathways or proteins regulating critical pathways for parasite growth and survival, and could be attractive targets. Molecules responsible for parasite invasion to host erythrocytes and ion channels of infected erythrocytes, essential for intra-erythrocyte survival and stage progression of parasites are also becoming attractive targets. This review will discuss and highlight the current understanding regarding the potential antimalarial drug targets, which could be utilized to develop novel antimalarials.     

Arteether, a new antimalarial drug: synthesis and antimalarial properties

Arteether (6) has been prepared from dihydroquinghaosu (3) by etherification with ethanol in the presence of Lewis acid and separated from its chromatographically slower moving alpha-dihydroqinghaosu ethyl ether (7). The absolute stereochemistry at C-12 has been determined by 1H NMR data (J11,12, NOESY). Ethyl ethers 6 and 7 showed potent in vitro inhibition of Plasmodium falciparum, and both compounds were highly potent antimalarials in mice infected with a drug-sensitive strain of Plasmodium berghei. Crystalline arteether (6) and its oily epimer 7 were 2-3 times more potent schizontocides than quinghaosu (1), but deoxy compounds 8, 9, and 11 were 100-300 times less potent in vitro than their corresponding peroxy precursors. Pharmacological studies have shown arteether(6) to have antimalarial activity in animals comparable to artesunate (2) and artemether (4), both of which are fast-acting blood schizontocides in humans. Arteether (6) has now been chosen for a clinical evaluation in high-risk malaria patients.     

Novel approaches in antimalarial drug discovery

Introduction: The development of new antimalarial drugs remains of the utmost importance, since Plasmodium falciparum has developed resistance against nearly all chemotherapeutics in clinical use. In an effort to contain the resistance of P. falciparum against artemisinins and to further eradication efforts, studies are ongoing to identify novel and more efficacious approaches to develop antimalarials.

Areas covered: The authors review the classical and new approaches to antimalarial drug discovery, with a special emphasis on the various stages of the parasite's life cycle and the different Plasmodium species. The authors discuss the methodologies and strategies for early efficacy testing that aim to narrow down the portfolio of promising compounds.

Expert opinion: The increased efforts in the discovery and development of new antimalarial compounds have led to the recognition of new promising hits. However, there is still major roadblock of selecting the most promising compounds and then further testing them in early clinical trials, especially in the current restricted economy. Controlled human malaria infection has much potential for speeding-up the early development process of many drug candidates including those which target the pre-erythrocytic stages.     

Novel approaches to antimalarial drug discovery

Major advances in our understanding of malaria parasite biology have been made. Coupled with the completion of the malaria genome, this has presented exciting opportunities for target-based antimalarial drug discovery. However, the unraveling of more validated biological targets will not necessarily translate into the identification of new chemical entities that are effective against drug resistant parasites in the long term. As history has already shown, development of antiplasmodial agents aimed at a single parasite target or specialized process has failed to stem the tide of drug resistance. This review highlights recent starting points and/or approaches to antimalarial drug discovery with particular emphasis on innovative efforts, which are not necessarily based on the identification of new drug targets and attendant inhibitor design. Approaches covered include utilization of validated chemical scaffolds, bioprecursor and carrier prodrugs, double drug development and/or multi-therapeutic strategies, use of metallocenic scaffolds, the medicinal chemistry of antimalarial natural products and in silico drug design.     

Piperaquine: a resurgent antimalarial drug

Piperaquine is a bisquinoline antimalarial drug that was first synthesised in the 1960s, and used extensively in China and Indochina as prophylaxis and treatment during the next 20 years. A number of Chinese research groups documented that it was at least as effective as, and better tolerated than, chloroquine against falciparum and vivax malaria, but no pharmacokinetic characterisation was undertaken. With the development of piperaquine-resistant strains of Plasmodium falciparum and the emergence of the artemisinin derivatives, its use declined during the 1980s. However, during the next decade, piperaquine was rediscovered by Chinese scientists as one of a number of compounds suitable for combination with an artemisinin derivative. The rationale for such artemisinin combination therapies (ACTs) was to provide an inexpensive, short-course treatment regimen with a high cure rate and good tolerability that would reduce transmission and protect against the development of parasite resistance. This approach has now been endorsed by the WHO. Piperaquine-based ACT began as China-Vietnam 4 (CV4): dihydroartemisinin [DHA], trimethoprim, piperaquine phosphate and primaquine phosphate), which was followed by CV8 (the same components as CV4 but in increased quantities), Artecom (in which primaquine was omitted) and Artekin or Duo-Cotecxin (DHA and piperaquine phosphate only). Recent Indochinese studies have confirmed the excellent clinical efficacy of piperaquine-DHA combinations (28-day cure rates >95%), and have demonstrated that currently recommended regimens are not associated with significant cardiotoxicity or other adverse effects. The pharmacokinetic properties of piperaquine have also been characterised recently, revealing that it is a highly lipid-soluble drug with a large volume of distribution at steady state/bioavailability, long elimination half-life and a clearance that is markedly higher in children than in adults. The tolerability, efficacy, pharmacokinetic profile and low cost of piperaquine make it a promising partner drug for use as part of an ACT.     

The role of asymptomatic P. falciparum parasitaemia in the evolution of antimalarial drug resistance in areas of seasonal transmission

In areas with seasonal transmission, proper management of acute malaria cases that arise in the transmission season can markedly reduce the disease burden. However, asymptomatic carriage of Plasmodium falciparum sustains a long-lasting reservoir in the transmission-free dry season that seeds cyclical malaria outbreaks. Clinical trials targeting asymptomatic parasitaemia in the dry season failed to interrupt the malaria epidemics that follow annual rains. These asymptomatic infections tend to carry multiple-clones, capable of producing gametocytes and infecting Anopheles mosquitoes. Different clones within an infection fluctuate consistently, indicative of interaction between clones during the long course of asymptomatic carriage. However, the therapy-free environment that prevails in the dry season dis-advantages the drug resistant lineages and favors the wild-type parasites. This review highlights some biological and epidemiological characteristics of asymptomatic parasitaemia and calls for consideration of polices to diminish parasite exposure to drugs “therapy-free” and allow natural selection to curb drug resistance in the above setting.     

Structure-release relationship of physical polymer/drug combinations. 2. Diffusion of 3-methylpyrazole through a synthetic polymer matrix

The diffusion of 3-methylpyrazole through a synthetic polymer matrix and the effect of the solubility of the bioactive agent in polymers on the release behaviour of polymer combinations were studied. With increasing hydrophilicity of the polymer both the diffusion and the diffusion coefficient of 3-methylpyrazole increased and the solubility of the agent in the polymer decreased. The hydrophilicity of various polymers is discussed on the basis of a parameter determined by turbidimetric titrations.     

Ecotoxicological evaluation of the antimalarial drug chloroquine

There is limited information available about the potential environmental effects of chloroquine (CQ), a widely used antimalarial agent and a promising inexpensive drug in the management of HIV disease. The acute effects of CQ were studied using four ecotoxicological model systems. The most sensitive bioindicator was the immobilization of the cladoceran Daphnia magna, with an EC50 of 12 microM CQ at 72 h and a non-observed adverse effect level of 2.5 microM CQ, followed very closely by the decrease of the uptake of neutral red and the reduction of the lysosomal function in the fish cell line PLHC-1 derived from the top minnow Poeciliopsis lucida, probably due to the selective accumulation of the drug into the lysosomes. There was significant cellular stress as indicated by the increases on metallothionein and glucose-6P dehydrogenase levels after 24 h of exposure and succinate dehydrogenase activity mainly after 48 h. No changes were observed for ethoxyresorufin-O-deethylase (EROD) activity. The least sensitive model was the inhibition of bioluminescence in the bacterium Vibrio fischeri. An increase of more than five-fold in the toxicity from 24 to 72 h of exposure was observed for the inhibition of the growth in the alga Chlorella vulgaris and the content of total protein and MTS tetrazolium salt metabolization in PLHC-1 cells. At the morphological level, the most evident alterations in PLHC-1 cultures were hydropic degeneration from 25 microM CQ after 24h of exposure and the presence of many cells with pyknotic nuclei, condensed cytoplasm and apoptosis with concentrations higher than 50 microM CQ after 48 h of exposure. In conclusion, CQ should be classified as harmful to aquatic organisms.     

AQ-13 - an investigational antimalarial drug

Introduction: AQ-13 is a drug candidate in development for the treatment of Plasmodium falciparum infections. The chemical structure is similar to chloroquine, a 4-aminoquinoline, with a shorter diaminoalkane side chain. Chloroquine has been the standard of care for P.falciparum malaria for more than 40 years, but the spread of resistant parasites in all malaria endemic regions has led to abandonment of the drug. The outstanding attribute of AQ-13 is its retrieval of activity against chloroquine-resistant P.falciparum.

Areas covered: We review preclinical and clinical studies on AQ-13 and summarize findings on pharmacokinetic, safety, potency and efficacy.

Expert opinion: Based on its properties invivo, the most likely future indication of AQ-13 could be case management of uncomplicated falciparum malaria – as a partner drug in a combination therapy. Several 4-aminoquinolines combined with a partner drug are on the market and in development. The outstanding properties of AQ-13 should be identified to direct further clinical development.     

Current drug development portfolio for antimalarial therapies

In response to the emergence of parasite drug resistance to currently deployed antimalarials, the scientific community, in partnership with the pharmaceutical industry and public organizations, has fashioned an antimalarial drug development portfolio for the sustained development and registration of safe, effective and cheap antimalarial medicines. The management of this portfolio is being driven by MMV (Medicines for Malaria Venture), with a number of projects recently reaching the clinical end of this drug development pipeline.     

Novel molecular targets for antimalarial drug development

Malaria with one million deaths and about 500 million new cases reported annually is a challenge to drug therapy and discovery. As current antimalarial therapeutics become increasingly ineffective because of parasitic resistance, there exists an urgent need to develop and pursue new therapeutic strategies. Antimalarial drug development can follow several strategies, ranging from minor modifications of existing agents to the design of novel agents that act against new targets. Recent advances in our knowledge of parasite biology as well as the availability of the genome sequence provide a wide range of novel targets for drug design. Several promising targets for drug intervention have been revealed in recent years. This review discusses novel molecular targets of the malaria parasite available to the drug discovery scientist.     

Use of drug combinations in treatment of opioid withdrawal.

During the last 10 years new approaches for rapid opioid detoxification have included drug combinations such as clonidine and naltrexone to speed and ease the transition from opioid agonist to antagonist maintenance. Other drug combinations include naloxone with midazolam or methohexitone for inpatients, but rapid outpatient methods are more desirable. Clonidine combined with naltrexone enables abrupt opioid withdrawal in 3-5 days in an outpatient/day setting. This approach can be further improved by transition to the partial agonist buprenorphine from either heroin or methadone followed by a 1 day detoxification using naltrexone precipitated withdrawal, ameliorated by clonidine.     

Economic implications of resistance to antimalarial drugs

The widespread evolution of drug resistance in malarial parasites has seriously hampered efforts to control this debilitating disease. Chloroquine, the mainstay of malaria treatment for many decades, is now proving largely ineffective in many parts of the world, particularly against the most severe form of malaria--falciparum. Alternative drugs have been developed, but they are frequently less safe and are all between 50 and 700% more expensive than chloroquine. Choice of drug clearly has important budgetary implications and national malaria control programmes need to weigh up the costs and benefits in deciding whether to change to more effective but more expensive drugs. The growth in drug resistance also has implications for the choice of diagnostic tool. Clinical diagnosis of malaria is relatively cheap, but less specific than some technological approaches. As more expensive drugs are employed, the cost of wasted treatment on suspected cases who do not in fact have malaria rises and the more worthwhile it becomes to invest in more specific diagnostic techniques. This paper presents an economic framework for analysing the various malaria drug and diagnostic tool options available. It discusses the nature of the key factors that need to be considered when making choices of malaria treatment (including treatment costs, drug resistance, the costs of treatment failure and compliance) and diagnosis (including diagnosis cost and accuracy, and the often overlooked costs associated with delayed treatment), and uses some simple equations to illustrate the impact of these on the relative cost effectiveness of the alternatives being considered. On the basis of some simplifying assumptions and illustrative calculations, it appears that in many countries more effective drugs and more specific and rapid diagnostic approaches will be worth adopting even although they imply additional expense.