Pediatric Transplant Rating Instrument – A scale for the pretransplant psychiatric evaluation of pediatric organ transplant recipients

Abstract:  Although the majority of pediatric solid organ transplant centers in the United States employ psychosocial criteria to assess the suitability of potential transplant candidates, there are no standardized pretransplant psychosocial assessment measures. Assessment scales that have been developed were designed for adult transplant recipients and are not suitable for use in the pediatric population. The P-TRI was developed to address this gap in the pediatric pretransplant psychosocial evaluation. It is intended to identify areas of psychosocial vulnerability that may be associated with poor treatment adherence and to facilitate the development of informed and focused psychosocial interventions for pediatric patients before and after transplant surgery. Items on the rating instrument were generated based on a review of the major correlates of treatment adherence in the pediatric population. Data are currently being collected for further reliability and validity analyses.     

Pretransplant six‐minute walk test predicts peri‐ and post‐operative outcomes after pediatric lung transplantation

The purpose of the pretransplant assessment in lung transplantation is to determine a patient's need for transplant as well as their potential survival post‐procedure. In 2005, the UNOS introduced the LAS, a calculation based on multiple physiologic measures to determine need and likelihood for survival. Measures include NYHA class and the 6‐MWT. Some adult studies indicate a positive correlation with 6‐MWT and waiting list survival. In pediatric/adolescent patients, there are minimal data regarding the predictive value of physiologic markers in either wait list survival or post‐transplant outcome. A retrospective cohort study of 60 consecutive lung transplantations from 1990 to 2008 was performed at a pediatric tertiary care facility. Functional pretransplant assessments were abstracted from the medical record and compared with outcomes after transplantation. Results: a 6‐MWT of >1000 ft (305 m) prior to transplantation correlated with a shorter ICU stay (7 vs. 11 days, p = 0.046) and fewer days of mechanical ventilation (2 vs. 4, p = 0.04). A pretransplant 6‐MWT greater than 750 ft (229 m) correlated with shorter overall hospitalization (37 vs. 20 days, p = 0.03). Measuring pretransplant 6‐MWT tests for pediatric patients is valuable in predicting peri‐operative outcomes after lung transplantation.     

Generalized and specific anxiety in adolescents following heart transplant

Mental health concerns are associated with worse outcomes after adult heart transplant. Illness‐specific anxiety is associated with worsened psychological well‐being after other solid organ transplants but has never been characterized after pediatric heart transplant. This single‐center cross‐sectional study aimed to evaluate illness‐specific and generalized anxiety after heart transplantation in adolescents. A novel 12‐item PHTF, GAD‐7, and the PedsQL were administered. Univariate associations of demographics, clinical features, and medication adherence as measured by immunosuppression standard deviation with the PHTF and GAD‐7 scores were evaluated. Internal consistency and validity of the PHTF were examined. In total, 30 patients participated. The most common illness‐specific fears were retransplantation, rejection, and more generally post‐transplant complications. The PHTF had good internal consistency (Cronbach α = .88). Construct validity was demonstrated between PHTF and GAD‐7 (r = .62) and PedsQL (r = ?.54 to ?.62). 23% endorsed moderate to severe generalized anxiety symptoms. More severe symptoms were associated with older age at survey (P = .03), older age at listing (P = .01) and having post‐transplant complications (P = .004). Patients with moderate or severe symptoms were more likely to report late immunosuppression doses (P = .004). Illness‐specific and generalized anxiety may be prevalent after pediatric heart transplant. Screening for anxiety in adolescents post‐transplant may identify those at risk for adverse outcomes including non‐adherence. The PHTF is a brief, valid, and reliable instrument identifying illness‐specific anxiety in this population.     

The impact of recipient BKV shedding before transplant on BKV viruria,DNAemia, and nephropathy post‐transplant: A prospective study

We previously demonstrated that detectable BKV replication in donor urine pretransplant was significantly associated with post‐transplant recipient BKV viremia. In this 4‐year prospective study, we assessed whether recipient BKV replication pretransplant was associated with post‐transplant viremia/BKV nephropathy. We studied 220 primary adult and pediatric organ transplant recipients for 490 person‐years and 2100 clinical visits. BKV viruria was detectable in 28 (16%), 26 adults and two children; and viremia in none pretransplant. Post‐transplant viruria occurred in all recipients with pretransplant BKV viruria, significantly more than in recipients without pretransplant viruria on univariate (P<.005) and multivariate analysis including type of organ transplanted and immunosuppression type (P .008). Time to post‐transplant viruria was significantly shorter in recipients with pretransplant viruria (P .01). By univariate and multivariate analysis, BKV viruria in recipients pretransplant did not impact post‐transplant BKV viremia (P=.97 and .97, respectively) even when stratified by type of organ transplant (kidney P=.6; liver P=.5). The peak serum and urine BKV PCR post‐transplant were not significantly different in patients with pretransplant BKV viruria and no one developed BK nephropathy. In conclusion, recipient BKV viruria prior to transplant predicts post‐transplant viruria but not viremia or BKV nephropathy.     

Liver abnormalities and post‐transplant survival in pediatric Fontan patients

The impact of liver parenchymal abnormalities on survival post‐heart transplant remains unknown in pediatric Fontan patients. We assessed pediatric Fontan patients who underwent heart transplant and had documented pretransplant hepatic ultrasound (U/S) studies. Liver U/S findings were classified as normal (Group 1), mildly abnormal (Group 2, hepatomegaly/vascular congestion), or severely abnormal (Group 3, heterogeneous echotexture/nodularity). Among 30 study patients, 8 were classified as Group 1, 14 as Group 2, while 8 met Group 3 criteria. Pretransplant liver biochemistry and synthetic function were similar in all groups. Six Group 3 patients underwent liver biopsy; 4 demonstrated perisinusoidal or centrilobular fibrosis, and 2 had cirrhosis. Overall mortality was 30% (n = 9). Median follow‐up was 5 years (range, 0.25‐13 years). One‐year survival was similar among all 3 groups (P = .37), with a trend toward higher cumulative 5‐year survival in Group 1 (100%). The majority of pediatric Fontan patients who underwent heart transplant demonstrated abnormal preoperative liver ultrasound findings. Heterogeneous echotexture or nodularity detected on U/S frequently indicates underlying liver parenchymal abnormalities. The presence of severe liver abnormalities was not associated with higher early mortality post‐heart transplant in pediatric Fontan patients; however, late outcomes must be further elucidated.     

Is there an optimal organ acceptance rate for pediatric heart transplantation: “A sweet spot”?

Despite a limited supply of donors, potential donor hearts are often declined for subjective concerns regarding organ quality. This analysis will investigate the relationship between donor heart AR and patient outcome at pediatric transplant centers. The UNOS database was used to identify all match runs for pediatric candidates (age < 18 years) from 2008 through March 2015 in which a heart offer was ultimately placed. Centers which received ≥10 offers/y were included (10 634 offers, 38 centers). Transplant centers were stratified based on their AR: low (<20%, n = 13), medium (20%‐40%, n = 16), or high (>40%, n = 9). Low AR centers experienced worse negative WL outcome compared with medium (P = .022) and high (P = .004) AR centers. Low AR centers had similar post‐transplant graft survival to medium (P = .311) or high (P = .393) AR centers; however, medium AR centers had better post‐transplant graft survival than high AR centers (P = .037). E‐F survival from listing regardless of transplant was worse for low AR centers compared with medium (P < .001) or high (P = .001) AR centers. Low AR centers experience worse WL outcomes without improvement in post‐transplant outcomes. High AR centers experience higher post‐transplant graft failure than medium AR centers. AR of 20%‐40% appears to have optimal WL and post‐transplant outcomes.     

Physical activity and its correlates in a pediatric solid‐organ transplant population

PA has been shown to have benefits in SOT patients. Studies assessing physical activity levels and its correlates in a pediatric solid‐organ transplant population are limited. The aim of this study was to assess PA levels and identify baseline and contemporaneous factors that contribute to PA in a pediatric SOT population. A retrospective cross‐sectional review was performed on 58 pediatric transplant patients (16 heart, 29 kidney, and 13 liver transplant). PA was measured by PAQ‐C or PAQ‐A. Demographics, baseline, and contemporaneous factors were collected. There were no significant differences in baseline and contemporaneous characteristics between heart, kidney, and liver transplant recipients. SOT recipients were 15.2 [12.3‐17.3] years old at time of completing the PAQ. Median PAQ score was 2.2 [1.7‐2.9]. There were no significant differences in PAQ scores between organ transplant type or between genders. Lower PAQ score was associated with sensory disability (9 vs 49 without disability; P = <.01) and age at time of completing the PAQ (r = ?.50, P = <.01). These results suggest that older age at time of completing the PAQ and presence of sensory disability may influence PA levels in the pediatric SOT population.     

Regional variation in the use of 1A status exceptions for pediatric heart transplant candidates: is this equitable?

The use of status exceptions (SE) was recently publicized as a strategy to reduce waitlist times for children awaiting heart transplant (HTx). The aim of this study was to assess SE use across UNOS regions and compare survival in patients listed using a SE to those listed by standard criteria. The OPTN database was queried for all pediatric patients listed for HTx (2000–2014). SE use was compared across UNOS regions. Survival curves were generated and compared using the log‐rank test. 1A SE use is uncommon, being utilized in 108 of 4587 pediatric 1A listings (2.4%). There is significant variability in SE use across UNOS regions (0.7%–16.4% of 1A listings, P < .001). Waitlist survival is significantly higher in candidates listed using a 1A SE compared to those listed by standard criteria (P = .001) and is similar to 1B listings. Regional variation in 1A SE use has the potential to introduce bias into a system designed to be equitable. Waitlist survival in patients listed using a SE is similar to those listed status 1B, suggesting these patients may not require 1A status. Careful review of pediatric heart allocation policies is needed to optimize patient outcomes and ensure a fair and unbiased allocation system.     

Psychosocial predictors of medication non‐adherence in pediatric organ transplantation: A systematic review

Adherence to immunosuppressant medication is critical to health and quality‐of‐life outcomes for children who have received a solid organ transplant. Research on the psychological and social predictors of medication adherence is essential to the advancement of pretransplant assessments and transplant psychosocial services. Despite the importance of identifying risk factors, the literature remains limited regarding psychosocial predictors of non‐adherence. A systematic search was conducted to identify studies of the psychosocial predictors of post‐transplant medication non‐adherence in pediatric solid organ transplantation. From 1363 studies identified in searches of empirical literature, a final sample consisted of 54 publications representing 49 unique studies. Findings regarding psychosocial predictors were inconsistent with non‐adherence associated largely with adolescence, racial/ethnic minority status, and presence of mental health issues. Familial predictors of non‐adherence problems included single‐parent households, lower socioeconomic status, lower family cohesion, presence of family conflict, and poor family communication. Several studies reported an association between non‐adherence and social pressures (eg, peer social interaction, wanting to feel normal) among adolescent transplant recipients. While significant methodological and substantive gaps remain in this body of knowledge, this review synthesizes current evidence for assessment for transplant clinicians and researchers.     

Impact of center volume and the adoption of laparoscopic donor nephrectomy on outcomes in pediatric kidney transplantation

Reports for pediatric kidney transplant recipients suggested better outcomes for ODN compared to LDN. Contemporary outcomes stratified by donor type and center volume have not been evaluated in a national dataset. UNOS data (2000‐2014) were analyzed for pediatric living donor kidney transplant recipients. The primary outcome was GF; secondary outcomes were DGF, rejection, and patient survival. Live donor nephrectomies for pediatric recipients decreased 30% and transitioned from ODN to LDN. GF rates did not differ for ODN vs LDN (P = .24). GF was lowest at high volume centers (P < .01). Donor operative approach did not contribute to GF. LDN was associated with less rejection than ODN (OR 0.66, CI 0.5‐0.87, P < .01). Analysis of the 0‐ to 5‐yr recipient group showed no effect of ODN vs LDN on GF or rejection. For the contemporary era, there was no association between DGF and LDN in the 0‐ to 5‐yr group (OR 1.12, CI 0.67‐1.89, P = .67). Outcomes of kidney transplants in pediatric recipients following LDN have improved since its introduction and LDN should be the approach for live donor nephrectomy regardless of recipient age. The association between case volume and improved outcomes highlights future challenges in organ transplantation.     

Pediatric marginal donor hearts: Trends in US national use, 2005‐2014

Pediatric patients awaiting heart transplant face high mortality rates due to donor organ shortages, including non‐use of marginal donor hearts. We examined national trends in pediatric marginal donor heart use over time. UNOS data were queried for heart donors <18 years from 2005 to 2014. The proportion of donor hearts considered marginal was determined using previously cited marginal characteristics: left ventricular ejection fraction (LVEF) <50%, use of ≥2 inotropes, cerebrovascular death, CDC high‐risk status, and eGFR < 30 mL/min/1.73 m². Disposition of donor hearts was determined and stratified by marginal donor status. Of 6778 pediatric hearts offered from 2005 to 2014, 2373 (35.0%) were considered marginal. Non‐use of marginal donor hearts was significantly higher than that of donor hearts without any marginal characteristics (59.5% vs 20.3%, P < .001). In particular, LVEF < 50% and donor inotropes were associated with high rates of organ non‐use among pediatric donors. Yet, non‐use of marginal donor organs decreased from 67% to 48% from 2005 to 2014 (P < .001). Although the proportion of pediatric donor hearts used for pediatric patients has increased, more than half of donor hearts are declined for use in pediatric recipients due, in part, to perceived marginal status.     

Diffuse myocardial fibrosis among healthy pediatric heart transplant recipients: Correlation of histology,cardiovascular magnetic resonance,and clinical phenotype

Fibrosis is commonly described in heart allografts lost late after transplantation. CMR‐derived ECV is a validated measure of DMF in native adult hearts that may predict heart failure and mortality. We explored associations of ECV with histologic myocardial fibrosis and clinical features after pediatric heart transplantation. Twenty‐five recipients (7.0±6.3 years at transplant and 10.7±6.5 years post‐transplant) were prospectively recruited for CMR and BNP measurement at the time of surveillance biopsy. All had normal ejection fractions and lacked heart failure symptoms. Fibrosis was quantified on biopsy after picrosirius red staining as CVF. ECV was quantified using contemporaneous hematocrit on basal and mid‐short‐axis slices. ECV was moderately correlated with CVF (r=.47; P=.019). We found no associations of ECV with hemodynamics, ischemic time, time since transplantation, or number of prior biopsies or acute rejections. Compared to healthy non‐transplant controls, there was no significant difference in ECV (25.1±3.0 vs 23.7±2.0%, P=.09). Log‐transformed BNP was correlated with ECV (recipients: r=.46, P=.02; recipients and controls: r=.45, P=.006). These findings suggest ECV quantifies DMF and relates to biological indicators of cardiac function after pediatric heart transplantation.     

Outcome of heart transplantation in pediatric cancer survivors

The aim of this study is to evaluate the outcome of heart transplantation in children surviving malignancies. Pediatric heart transplant recipients were identified using the UNOS database. Follow‐up data including survival and rate of malignancy were analyzed. A total of 7169 children received heart transplants between 1987 and 2011. Of these, 107 (1.5%) survived previous malignancy treatment (group I) and 7062 (98.5%) did not have prior malignancy (group II). Survival after transplant was 92.5%, 90.6%, 80.3%, and 65% at three months, one, five, and 10 yr in group I, similar to the rate in group II (90.1%, 84.4%, 73.8%, and 57.7%). Survival after transplantation was similar between group I and children who underwent OHT secondary to cardiomyopathy in group II. The rate of post‐OHT malignancy in group I was higher than that in group II (14/107(13%) vs. 386/7062 (5.4%), p = 0.001). Children who developed malignancy in group I had similar survival as children who developed malignancy in group II. Post‐transplant survival is similar in children with and without pretransplant malignancy in spite of higher rate of malignancy in children with pretransplant malignancy. OHT appears to be a reasonable treatment option in children who develop end‐stage heart disease after malignancy treatment.     

Pediatric Transplant Rating Instrument - a scale for the pretransplant psychiatric evaluation of pediatric organ transplant recipients.

Although the majority of pediatric solid organ transplant centers in the United States employ psychosocial criteria to assess the suitability of potential transplant candidates, there are no standardized pretransplant psychosocial assessment measures. Assessment scales that have been developed were designed for adult transplant recipients and are not suitable for use in the pediatric population. The P-TRI was developed to address this gap in the pediatric pretransplant psychosocial evaluation. It is intended to identify areas of psychosocial vulnerability that may be associated with poor treatment adherence and to facilitate the development of informed and focused psychosocial interventions for pediatric patients before and after transplant surgery. Items on the rating instrument were generated based on a review of the major correlates of treatment adherence in the pediatric population. Data are currently being collected for further reliability and validity analyses.     

Perioperative renal failure in pediatric heart transplant recipients: outcome and risk factors

PRF is encountered in 10-13% of adult heart transplants. Only one study of a single center's experience with PRF has been reported in pediatric patients. This study examines the effect of PRF on pediatric heart transplant outcome using the UNOS database. A total of 3598 patients met inclusion criteria, of whom 254 (7%) had PRF. The PRF group comprised 31 recipients requiring PRE and 223 recipients requiring POST. Compared with No-PRF patients, PRE patients had similar survival rate and POST patients had decreased survival rate at 30 days, one, five, and 10-yr post-transplant (p < 0.001). PRF patients also had significantly lower graft survival at one, five, and 10 yr (p < 0.001). Risk factors for developing PRF included ECMO, ventilator, and inotropic support at listing and CHD as the listing diagnosis. PRF increased the duration of hospital stay and the incidence of chronic severe renal dysfunction. PRF that requires POST (whether or not it began pretransplant) has a significant negative impact on pediatric heart transplant outcome. Specific characteristics identify patients at particular high risk of developing PRF.     

Educational and learning morbidity in pediatric heart transplant recipients: A pediatric heart transplant society study

Educational development is an important component of quality of life for children with heart transplant. Aims include determining prevalence of and risk factors for modified education placement in a large representative sample of pediatric heart transplant recipients. Participants included 1495 patients (age 6‐18 years) from the PHTS database. Data on education placement and clinical predictors were collected at listing and at 1 and 3 years post‐transplant. At listing, 88% of patients were in typical education placement, while 12% were in modified education. Males (P = .02), those with CHD (P < .0001), those with non‐private insurance (P < .0001), and those with longer hospital stay (P = .001) were more likely to be in a modified education placement at time of listing. Age, race, listing status, mechanical support, and waitlist time were not significantly associated with placement. The prevalence of typical education placement was similar (87% at 1‐year and 86% at 3‐year) post‐transplant. Predictors of modified education placement at 3‐year follow‐up included placement at listing (OR = 12.9 [95% CI 7.6‐21.9], P < .0001), non‐private insurance (OR = 2.0 [95% CI 1.3‐3.2], P = .001), CHD (OR = 1.8 [95% CI 1.1‐2.7, P = .01), history of post‐transplant infection (OR = 1.9 [95% CI 1.2‐2.9, P = .007), and number of post‐transplant infections (OR = 1.3 [95% CI 1.1‐1.5, P = .002). Among pediatric heart transplant recipients, males, those with non‐private insurance, those with CHD, and those who experience post‐transplant infections are at greatest risk for modified academic placement, which persists for several years post‐transplant and deserves targeted intervention.     

Lung transplant waitlist mortality: Height as a predictor of poor outcomes

The LAS was designed to minimize pretransplant mortality while maximizing post‐transplant outcome. Recipients <12 are not allocated lungs based on LAS. Waitlist mortality has decreased for those >12, but not <12, suggesting this population may be disadvantaged. To identify predictors of waitlist mortality, a retrospective analysis of the UNOS database was performed since implementation of the LAS. There were 16 973 patients listed for lung transplant in the United States; 12 070 (71.1%) were transplanted, and 2498 (14.7%) patients died or were removed from the wait list. Significantly more pediatric patients died or were removed compared with adults (22.0% vs. 14.4%, p < 0.01). In multivariate analysis, in addition to higher LAS at time of listing (adj. HR1.058, 1.055–1.060), shorter height (1.008, 1.006–1.010), male gender (1.210, 1.110–1.319), and requiring ECMO (1.613, 1.202–2.163) were associated with pretransplant mortality. Post‐transplant survival was not affected by height. The current age cutoff may impose limitations within the current lung allocation system in the United States. Height is an independent predictor of waitlist mortality and may be a valuable factor for the development of a comprehensive lung allocation system.     

Low donor‐to‐recipient weight ratio does not negatively impact survival of pediatric heart transplant patients

Tang L, Du W, Delius RE, L’Ecuyer TJ, Zilberman MV. Low donor‐to‐recipient weight ratio does not negatively impact survival of pediatric heart transplant patients.
Pediatr Transplantation 2010: 14:741–745. © 2010 John Wiley & Sons A/S. Abstract: A major limitation to success in pediatric heart transplantation is donor organ shortage. While the use of allografts from donors larger than the recipient is accepted, the use of undersized donor grafts is generally discouraged. Using the UNOS database, we wanted to evaluate whether using smaller donor hearts affects the short‐ and long‐term survival of pediatric heart transplant patients. A retrospective analysis of data entered into the UNOS database from April 1994 to May 2008 was performed. Pediatric heart transplant recipients (ages 0–18 yr) with DRWR <2.0 were identified and divided into two groups: Low‐DRWR (<0.8) and Ideal‐DRWR (0.8–2.0). Patients’ demographics, pretransplant diagnoses, age at transplantation, severity of pretransplant condition, and rate of complications prior to hospital discharge after transplantation were noted. Fisher’s exact, chi‐square, and Wilcoxon rank sum tests were used to compare patients’ baseline characteristics. Kaplan–Meier curves and Cox proportional hazard regression were used to compare patients’ survival and to identify independent risk factors for outcomes. There were 3048 patients (204 with Low‐ and 2844 with Ideal‐DRWR). The Low‐ratio group patients were older (8.3 vs. 6.9 yr; p = 0.001), there was a slight male predominance in the Low‐DRWR group (p = 0.055). The Low‐DRWR group had longer transplant wait time than the Ideal‐DRWR group (97 vs. 85 days; p = 0.04). The groups did not differ in race, primary diagnoses, severity of pretransplant condition (medical urgency status, need for ventilation, inotropic support, ECMO, nitric oxide, or dialysis, the PVR for those with bi‐ventricular anatomy), or post‐transplant complications (length of stay, need for inotropic support, dialysis, and rate of infections). The Low‐DRWR patients had less episodes of acute rejection during the first‐post‐transplant month. Infants with DRWR 0.5–0.59 had lower 30‐day survival rate (p = 0.045). There was no difference in short‐ and long‐term survival between the patients with DRWR 0.6–0.79 and DRWR 0.8–2.0. Use of smaller allografts (DRWR 0.6–0.8) has no negative impact on the short‐ and long‐term survival of pediatric heart transplant patients.     

Assessing associations between medication adherence and potentially modifiable psychosocial variables in pediatric kidney transplant recipients and their families

Post-transplant immunosuppressant (IS) medication adherence is essential for long-term graft survival and relatively little is known about psychosocial barriers that interfere with optimum medication adherence in pediatric kidney transplant patients. The objective of this prospective observational cohort study was to assess the impact of modifiable psychosocial variables on medication adherence. Our hypothesis was that parental stress, dysfunctional parent-child interactions and child behavior problems would be associated with poorer medication adherence. Thirteen pediatric kidney transplant patients and their caregivers were enrolled. Transplant recipients who were able to read and caregivers of all the transplant recipients completed behavioral and attitudinal surveys. A subgroup of seven families dispensed their primary IS medication from an electronic monitoring vial (MEMS Smart Cap). For these patients, medication adherence was calculated by computing a ratio of the medication taken divided by the prescribed dose. In addition, for the entire group, serial IS levels were reviewed by two board certified pediatric nephrologists who categorized all 13 transplant recipient families as either 'probably adherent (PA)' or 'possibly non-adherent (PNA)'. Pearson correlation coefficients and independent samples Student t-tests were used to assess the association between medication adherence and psychosocial variables measured by standardized questionnaires. In this study, elevated parental stress, dysfunctional parent-child interactions, and child behavior problems were associated with poorer medication adherence. In addition, we found evidence to support the relationship between subjective dissatisfaction with appearance and poorer medication adherence. These findings suggest that pre-transplant recipient evaluations of risk factors for poor adherence are warranted.