Causes of variation in BCG vaccine efficacy: Examining evidence from the BCG REVAC cluster randomized trial to explore the masking and the blocking hypotheses

BCG protection varies and in some places (nearest the equator) is low or absent. Understanding this variation can inform the efforts to develop new vaccines against tuberculosis. Two main hypotheses are used to explain this variation: under masking, new vaccines are unlikely to increase protection; under blocking new vaccines have a greater potential to be effective when BCG is not. We conducted a cluster randomized trial to explored the masking and blocking hypotheses by studying BCG vaccine efficacy of neonatal vaccination and when administered for the first or a second (revaccination) time at school age in two sites (Manaus close and Salvador further south from the equator). Seven hundred and sixty three state schools were matched on socio economic characteristics of the neighborhood and 239,934 children were randomized to vaccine (BCG vaccination at school age) or control group. Protection by first BCG vaccination at school age was high in Salvador (34%, 95% CI 7–53%, p = 0.017) but low in Manaus (8%, 95% CI t₀ 39–40%, p = 0.686). For revaccination at school age, protection was modest in Salvador (19%, 95% CI 3–33%, p = 0.022) and absent in Manaus (1%, 95% CI to 27–23%, p = 0.932). Vaccine efficacy for neonatal vaccination was similar in Salvador (40%, 95% CI 22–54%, p < 0.001) and Manaus (36%, 95% CI 11–53%, p = 0.008). Variation in BCG efficacy was marked when vaccine was given at school age but absent at birth, which points towards blocking as the dominant mechanism. New tuberculosis vaccines that overcome or by pass this blocking effect could confer protection in situations where BCG is not protective.     

Sensitivity and specificity of the BCG scar reading

OBJECTIVE: To validate the BCG scar as a marker of BCG vaccination status. METHODS: A cross-sectional survey was carried out among 53,348 schoolchildren aged 6-14 years who underwent BCG scar examination as part of a large BCG vaccine trial taking place in the city of Manaus, Brazil. Results of BCG scar reading were compared with information on vaccine status of their vaccination cards or provided by parents or guardians. Double-reading was performed in a sub-sample. Data analysis was conducted using Stata 7 and Kappa coefficient. RESULTS: Of 52,348 schoolchildren studied, vaccine status information from parents/guardian letters was available for 29,254 and from vaccination cards for 4,947. There was found a high agreement between the double-readings of the scars (Kappa=0.81). When the agreement between letter and card information was the gold standard, the sensitivity of BCG scar readings was 96.6% (95%CI 96.0-97.1) and the specificity was 71.1% (95%CI 55.7-83.7). The sensitivity was 96.1%, 97.3% and 95.3% for children vaccinated up to one month of age, four months and one year, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Sensitivity and specificity did not show an association with the child's age at the scar reading. BCG scar was a good marker of BCG vaccination status regardless of age - from the first years of life up to 14 years old.     

Effect of simultaneous BCG and smallpox vaccination in schoolchildren. Report of a WHO-sponsored preliminary study

The effect of simultaneous BCG and smallpox vaccination and the possible interaction of primary BCG vaccination and smallpox revaccination were studied in 1099 Burmese children arbitrarily allocated to four groups. All were tuberculin-tested and all had received primary smallpox vaccination but had not been vaccinated with BCG. In the first group, no vaccination was performed; in the second, negative reactors received BCG vaccine; the third received smallpox vaccine; and the fourth also received smallpox vaccine, negative reactors also receiving BCG vaccine.     

The immunological effect of revaccination with Bacille Calmette-Guérin vaccine at 19 months of age

Background

Bacille Calmette-Guérin (BCG) vaccination has important non-specific immune effects. In a randomized trial in Guinea-Bissau, BCG revaccination was associated with significantly increased survival in children who received diphtheria-tetanus-pertussis (DTP)-booster vaccine before enrolment and in children who did not receive micronutrient supplementation (MN). Within the trial we assessed the immunological effects of BCG revaccination.

Methods

Children were randomized to BCG or nothing. Blood was sampled 6–11 weeks after randomization (early sample group) or 5–9 months later (late sample group). In vitro cytokine responses (interferon (IFN)-γ, interleukin (IL)-13, tumor-necrosis-factor (TNF)-α, and IL-10) were assessed in whole blood cultures stimulated with lipopolysaccharide (LPS), purified protein derivative (PPD) or phytohaemagglutinin (PHA). Effect-modification by sex, DTP-booster vaccination and MN was studied.

Results

Cytokines were measured in 345 infants. BCG was associated with significantly increased IFN-γ (geometric mean ratio (GMR) = 4.54 (95% confidence interval: 3.13–6.58)) and IL-13 (GMR = 1.43 (1.00–2.05)) PPD responses, the effect being strongest in the early sample group. Across all three conditions BCG tended to increase IL-10 (LPS, PHA, PPD: GMR = 1.20, 1.12, 1.20), most pronounced in the late sample group. BCG reduced the TNF-α/IL-10 ratio in boys with DTP-booster at bleeding and increased it in those without (interaction test: p = 0.03). In children without MN, BCG was associated with reduced TNF-α response in the early sample group (p = 0.006), and increased IL-10 in the late sample group (p = 0.03).

Conclusion

BCG revaccination resulted in a strong IFN-γ response to PPD, which waned slightly over time. BCG also affected the pro-/anti-inflammatory balance, with reduced TNF-α and increased IL-10 responses to LPS, PHA and PPD. This effect depended on sex, DTP-booster vaccination and micronutrient supplementation, being most pronounced in children who had received DTP-booster before enrolment and children who had not received MN, i.e. the group of children which also had lower mortality after BCG revaccination.     

The safety of BCG revaccination: A systematic review

IntroductionRevaccination with Bacillus Calmette-Guérin (BCG) vaccine is not generally recommended due to a lack of proven efficacy of repeat doses for protection against tuberculosis. However, there is a growing interest in the use of BCG vaccine for its ‘off-target’ effects which might involve revaccination. We did a systematic review of the safety of BCG revaccination.MethodsMEDLINE (1946 to March 2020) and the BCG World Atlas (updated 2017) were searched, limiting to studies of BCG administration by the intradermal or percutaneous route. Adverse events as well as patient and vaccine characteristics were reviewed.ResultsThe search identified 388 articles, of which 24 met the inclusion criteria. These reported 22 studies comprising eight randomised trials, four case-control studies, four observational studies and six case series or reports. Overall, there was evidence for a small increase in the rate of mild local and systemic reactions. No serious adverse events were reported in immunocompetent individuals.ConclusionsEvidence to date suggests that revaccination with BCG vaccine carries minimal risk. Future studies of BCG vaccine for novel applications should report adverse event data stratified by prior BCG vaccination status.     

Economic evaluation of universal BCG vaccination of Japanese infants

BACKGROUND: The international controversy surrounding the use and effectiveness of the Bacillus Calmette-Guérin (BCG) vaccine and the low incidence of tuberculosis (TB) among Japanese children prompted this study. METHODS: We compared 'universal BCG vaccination' with 'no vaccination at all' using a cost-effectiveness analysis. The study population was a hypothetical cohort comprising a total of 1.2 million infants born in 1996 at locations all over Japan. A model was developed to calculate the number of TB cases prevented by the vaccination programme. Assuming 40-80% overall vaccine efficacy (64-86% for TB-meningitis) and 10 years of protection, we calculated the cost and number of immunizations required to prevent one child from developing TB, the total number of TB cases averted by vaccination and total costs required for the programme. RESULTS: Based on an assumption of flexible vaccine efficacy (40-80%), we estimated that 111-542 TB cases including 10-27 of TB-meningitis would be prevented during the 10 years after BCG vaccination among the cohort of infants born in 1996. About US$35 950-175 862 or 2125-10 399 immunizations would be required to prevent one child from developing TB. Sensitivity analyses covering a wide duration of protection, incidence of TB, vaccine coverage and discount rate, revealed that other than vaccine efficacy, the cost of preventing a single case of TB is highly sensitive to the duration of BCG protection and TB incidence. CONCLUSION: The cost per case of TB prevented is heavily dependent on vaccine efficacy and the duration of protection, and is high compared with the cost of treating one child who has developed TB.     

Tuberculin reactivity in a population of schoolchildren with high BCG vaccination coverage.

OBJECTIVE: To investigate the influence of BCG vaccination or revaccination on tuberculin skin test reactivity, in order to guide the correct interpretation of this test in a setting of high neonatal BCG vaccination coverage and an increasing BCG revaccination coverage at school age. METHODS: We conducted tuberculin skin testing and BCG scar reading in 1 148 children aged 7-14 years old in the city of Salvador, Bahia, Brazil. We measured the positive effect of the presence of one or two BCG scars on the proportion of tuberculin skin test results above different cut-off levels (induration sizes of > or = 5 mm, > or = 10 mm, and > or = 15 mm) and also using several ranges of induration size (0, 1-4, 5-9, 10-14, and > or = 15 mm). We also measured the effects that age, gender, and the school where the child was enrolled had on these proportions. RESULTS: The proportion of tuberculin results > or = 10 mm was 14.2% (95% confidence interval (CI) = 8.0%-20.3%) for children with no BCG scar, 21.3% (95% CI = 18.5%-24.1%) for children with one BCG scar, and 45.0% (95% CI = 32.0%-58.0%) for children with two BCG scars. There was evidence for an increasing positive effect of the presence of one and two BCG scars on the proportion of results > or = 5 mm and > or = 10 mm. Similarly, there was evidence for an increasing positive effect of the presence of one and two scars on the proportion of tuberculin skin test results in the ranges of 5-9 mm and of 10-14 mm. The BCG scar effect on the proportion of results > or = 5 mm and > or = 10 mm did not vary with age. There was no evidence for BCG effect on the results > or = 15 mm. CONCLUSIONS: In Brazilian schoolchildren, BCG-induced tuberculin reactivity is indistinguishable, for results under 15 mm, from reactivity induced by Mycobacterium tuberculosis infection. BCG revaccination at school age increases the degree of BCG-induced tuberculin reactivity found among schoolchildren. This information should be taken into account in tuberculin skin test surveys intended to estimate M. tuberculosis prevalence or to assess transmission patterns as well as in tuberculin skin testing of individuals used as an auxiliary tool in diagnosing tuberculosis. Taking this information into consideration is especially important when there is increasing BCG revaccination coverage.     

BCG vaccination of children against leprosy: fourteen-year findings of the trial in Burma

The value of BCG vaccination in preventing leprosy among children was studied in an area of high leprosy endemicity in Burma through a controlled trial; one group of 13 066 children received BCG and another group of 13 176 served as controls. The overall protective effect of BCG, which was only about 20% over the 14-year period, was found to vary with the batch of vaccine, as well as age, sex, and contact status of the children. BCG protection was found to be independent of the initial tuberculin status of the children. The protective effect of BCG against the lepromatous type of leprosy could not be measured because of the low incidence. Protection was observed throughout the fourteen years of the study except for the first year. The results are compared with those of three other major BCG trials in leprosy. The trial has shown that BCG provides only a very modest level of protection and that BCG vaccination is not likely to be an important solution for leprosy control.     

Safety and reactogenicity of BCG revaccination with isoniazid pretreatment in TST positive adults

Rationale

Global tuberculosis (TB) control may require mass vaccination with a new TB vaccine, such as a recombinant bacille Calmette Guerin (BCG) or attenuated Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MTB). The safety profile of live mycobacterial vaccines in latently infected adults with prior infant BCG vaccination is unknown.

Objectives

Evaluate safety and reactogenicity of BCG revaccination, with or without isoniazid (INH) pretreatment, in adults with latent MTB infection (LTBI).

Methods

Eighty-two healthy, HIV uninfected, South African adults, with a BCG scar and tuberculin skin test (TST) diameter ≥15 mm, were randomized to receive 6 months of INH, starting either before, or 6 months after, intradermal revaccination with BCG Vaccine SSI (Statens Serum Institut, Copenhagen). Safety and reactogenicity data are reported through 3 months post BCG revaccination.

Results

Baseline characteristics were similar between treatment arms. Mean baseline TST diameter was 20 ± 4 mm. Seventy-two subjects received BCG revaccination. Injection site erythema (68%) and induration (86%) peaked 1 week after revaccination. Ulceration (76%) peaked at 2 weeks, and resolved by 3 months in all but 3 subjects. Diameter of ulceration was >10 mm in only 8%, but a residual scar was common (85%). No regional lymphadenitis or serious morbidity related to BCG was seen. Reactogenicity was not affected by INH pretreatment.

Conclusion

BCG revaccination of MTB infected adults is safe, well tolerated, and reactogenicity is similar to that of primary BCG vaccination. Clinical trials of live recombinant BCG or attenuated MTB vaccines may be considered in latently infected adults, with or without INH pretreatment (ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT01119521).     

BCG vaccination in leprosy: final results of the trial in Karimui, Papua New Guinea, 1963-79

The efficacy of BCG vaccine in preventing the clinical manifestations of leprosy in a tuberculosis-free area of Papua New Guinea is reported. Between 1963 and 1966 a total of 5356 subjects, randomized to receive BCG or saline inoculations, were examined for leprosy before the vaccination and surveillance was continued until 1979. BCG afforded 48% protection against clinical leprosy, being most effective against borderline tuberculoid leprosy and in children vaccinated when under 15 years old. Protection was evident within 12 months in those vaccinated between the ages of 10 and 15 years but was delayed in other age groups. There was evidence for accelerated manifestations of tuberculoid leprosy in children vaccinated when under 5 years of age. Tuberculin sensitivity was more likely to be sustained following multiple BCG inoculations; vaccinees with sustained tuberculin sensitivity had the lowest incidence of leprosy, but protection was also evident in tuberculin-negative vaccinees. These results may have implications for ongoing trials of leprosy vaccine incorporating BCG.     

接种乙型肝炎疫苗无应答儿童复种后5年效果观察

目的评价乙型肝炎(乙肝)疫苗无应答儿童复种远期效果并比较小剂量皮内与常规剂量肌肉复种效果。方法自2000年10月开始,40名经筛检获得的无应答健康儿童随机接受3针肌肉(17人,10μg/针)或皮内(23人,2μg/针)复种,定期采血检测至复种后5年;80名应答儿童不复种,作为同期观察对照。在第5年,评价HB-sAg特异性淋巴细胞免疫水平;对抗-HBs阴转者加强1针(5μg),12-14 d评价抗体回忆应答。结果仅1名皮内复种者抗-HBs未达到10 IU/L;在第5年,50%的肌肉复种者仍保持着抗-HBs≥10 IU/L(尽管该指标显著低于应答对照者的85%)。抗-HBs阴转者(肌肉、皮内复种和应答对照分别为8、18和11人)再加强1针后,除2名皮内复种者外,均产生了强劲的抗体回忆应答(抗-HBs滴度分别平均上升至208、105和549 IU/L);超过70%的无应答儿童外周血单个核细胞可检测到HBsAg特异性白细胞介素(IL)-2和IL-5的分泌。用抗-HBc阳转作为感染指标计算乙肝病毒人年感染率,皮内复种者为8.9%(8/89.9人年),高于应答对照者的3.6%(12/337.2人年),而肌肉复种者为4.3%(3/70.2人年),与应答对照者接近。结论无应答儿童3针肌肉复种效果虽达不到应答儿童初种的水平,但确能发挥重要的免疫保护作用。小剂量皮内复种效果不如相同针次常规剂量肌肉复种。     

Repeated exposure to an MF-59 adjuvanted quadrivalent subunit influenza vaccine (aQIV) in children: Results of two revaccination studies

BackgroundPediatric adjuvanted seasonal influenza vaccines induce higher immune responses and have the potential to confer better protection against influenza among young vaccine-naïve children. Limited data describe benefits and risks of repeated administration of adjuvanted influenza vaccines in children. Two revaccination studies assess the safety and immunogenicity of repeated exposure to an MF59-adjuvanted quadrivalent influenza vaccine (aQIV; Fluad®) compared to routine non-adjuvanted quadrivalent influenza vaccine (QIV).MethodsChildren previously enrolled in the parent study, who received vaccination with aQIV or nonadjuvanted influenza vaccine (TIV or QIV), were recruited in Season 1 (n = 607) or Season 2 (n = 1601) of the extension trials. Season 1 participants remained in their original randomization groups (aQIV-aQIV or TIV-QIV); Season 2 subjects were re-randomized to either vaccine, resulting in four groups (aQIV-aQIV, aQIV-QIV, QIV-aQIV, or QIV-QIV). All subjects received a single-dose vaccination. Blood samples were taken for immunogenicity assessment prior to vaccination and 21 and 180 days after vaccination. Reactogenicity (Days 1–7) and safety were assessed in all subjects.ResultsHemagglutination inhibition (HI) geometric mean titer (GMT) ratios demonstrated superiority of aQIV revaccination over QIV revaccination for all strains in Season 1 and for A/H1N1, B/Yamagata, and B/Victoria in Season 2. Higher HI titers against heterologous influenza strains were observed after aQIV vaccination during both seasons. Mild to moderate severity and short duration reactogenicity was more common in the aQIV than QIV groups, but the overall safety profiles were similar to the parent study.ConclusionThe safety and immunogenicity results from this study demonstrate benefit of aQIV for both priming and revaccination of children aged 12 months to 7 years.     

乙型肝炎疫苗无应答儿童复种五年效果观察

目的评价乙型肝炎（乙肝）疫苗无应答儿童复种远期效果并比较小剂量皮内与常规剂量肌肉复种效果。方法自1999年9月开始,40名经筛检获得的无应答健康儿童随机接受3针肌肉（17人,10μg／针）或皮内（23人,2μg／针）复种,定期采血检测至复种后5年;80名应答儿童不复种,作为同期观察对照。在第5年,评价HBsAg特异性淋巴细胞免疫水平;对抗-HBs阴转者加强1针（5μg）,12—14d评价抗体回忆应答。结果仅1名皮内复种者抗-HBs未达到10IU／L;在第5年,50％的肌肉复种者仍保持着抗-HBs≥10IU／L（尽管该指标显著低于应答对照者的85％）。抗-HBs阴转者（肌肉、皮内复种和应答对照分别为8、18和11人）在加强1针后,除2名皮内复种者外,均产生了强劲的抗体回忆应答（抗．HBs滴度分别平均上升至208、105和549IU／L）;超过70％的无应答儿童外周血单个核细胞可检测到HBsAg特异性白细胞介素（IL）-2和IL-5的分泌。用抗-HBc阳转作为感染指标计算乙肝病毒人年感染率,皮内复种者为8．9％（8／89．9人年）,高于应答对照者的3．6％（12／337．2人年）,而肌肉复种者为4．3％（3／70．2人年）,与应答对照者接近。结论无应答儿童3针肌肉复种效果虽达不到应答儿童初种的水平,但确能发挥重要的免疫保护作用。小剂量皮内复种效果不如相同针次常规剂量肌肉复种。     

Present knowledge of immunization against tuberculosis

This is a selective review, which, after recalling some immunological aspects, analyses the present knowledge on the protective efficacy of BCG vaccination, the vaccination reactions and complications that may be observed, and current methods of vaccine production and control. As regards the application of BCG vaccination, particular attention is given to dosage and vaccination techniques, direct and simultaneous vaccination, and revaccination. Finally, the evaluation of BCG vaccination programmes is briefly discussed.     

BCG vaccination and tuberculosis in Japan

This paper summarizes Bacillus Calmette-Guerin (BCG) vaccination and revaccination policies in Japan, its cost-effectiveness, side effects, proposed selective vaccination strategy, and present tuberculosis situation in Japanese perspectives based on Medline database and other published reports. Universal BCG vaccination in infants and revaccination among children were not found economically justifiable. Overall tuberculosis incidence in Japan is higher than that of other developed countries. Trend of decline in tuberculosis incidence is similar to that of the countries where universal BCG vaccination has never been implemented. In the recent years, the number of tuberculosis group infection has been escalating. Since BCG revaccination program has already been discontinued, a consensus on universal BCG vaccination is also essential based on social, political, and economical factors. Side by side, more pragmatic strategies such as well-defined tuberculin test, selective vaccination policy based on tuberculosis incidence in each administrative zone, and early vaccination of high risk groups, should be formulated.     

西安市未央区流动儿童免疫规划7种疫苗接种率调查

【目的】 了解西安市未央区流动人口聚集地区儿童免疫规划 7 种疫苗[卡介苗(BCG)、脊髓灰质炎疫苗(OPV)、百白破疫苗(DPT)、含麻疹成分疫苗(MCV)、乙肝疫苗(HepB)、乙脑疫苗(JEV)、流脑疫苗(MPV)]预防接种现状。 【方法】 采用单纯随机抽样法随机抽取居住 ≥3 个月的1~2岁流动儿童和常住儿童各758 名,进行免疫规划7种疫苗的接种率调查。 【结果】 调查儿童建证率 100.0% ,建卡率99.9 %。7 种疫苗BCG、 OPV、 DTP、 MCV、 HepB 、JEV、 MPV的基础免疫接种率分别为 99.5 %、 99.4 %、97.8 %、 92.5 %、 98.4 % 、90.9%、93.1%,7苗合格免疫覆盖率为90.9%。但流动儿童的 7 种疫苗合格免疫覆盖率(86.8%)显著低于常住儿童(95.3%),差异有高度统计学意义 (P<0.01);DTP加强免疫和MCV复种接种率分别为94.0%和94.4%。与常住儿童相比 ,流动儿童的7种疫苗基础免疫接种率除MCV、JEV基础免疫接种率为 89.7 %、86.8%外,其它疫苗的基础免疫接种率均高于90 %;除BCG和HepB首针及时接种率外其它各项指标流动儿童与常住儿童之间差异均有高度统计学意义(P<0.01) 。另外,7种疫苗针次中以超期、未种接种较多。 【结论】 在流动人口聚集地区 ,做好常住儿童免疫接种同时 ,还要加强流动儿童的预防接种工作。     

Immunogenicity and safety of a second administration of 13-valent pneumococcal conjugate vaccine 5 years after initial vaccination in adults 50 years and older

BackgroundVaccination effectively reduces invasive disease and pneumonia caused by Streptococcus pneumoniae. However, waning antibody titers and the ability of revaccination to boost titers in older adults have been concerns. A study to describe antibody persistence after vaccination with 13-valent pneumococcal conjugate vaccine (PCV13) and response to revaccination 5 years after the initial dose was conducted.MethodsPneumococcal vaccine–naive subjects aged 50–59 years were randomized and vaccinated with PCV13 plus trivalent inactivated influenza vaccine concomitantly or 1 month apart, then revaccinated with PCV13 five years later. Antipneumococcal polysaccharide opsonophagocytic activity (OPA) geometric mean titers (GMTs) and immunoglobulin G (IgG) geometric mean concentrations (GMCs) were determined before and approximately 1 month after each vaccination. Targeted local reactions and systemic events were collected for 14 days, adverse events (AEs) for 1 month, and serious AEs (SAEs) for 6 months after each vaccination.ResultsOf 1116 randomized subjects, 727 were revaccinated at year 5. Between the time of initial vaccination and revaccination, OPA GMTs and IgG GMCs declined but remained higher than levels before initial vaccination for 12 of the 13 vaccine serotypes. One month after revaccination, OPA GMTs and IgG GMCs were comparable with, or higher than, levels observed 1 month after initial vaccination for most vaccine serotypes. Local reactions were mostly mild. AEs were reported by <5% and SAEs by <1% of subjects at 1 and 6 months after revaccination, respectively. No SAEs were vaccine-related.ConclusionsRevaccination of adults ≥50 years with PCV13 five years after primary vaccination was safe and immunogenic. Additionally, antibody titers were maintained for at least 5 years after vaccination. The vaccine stimulated a memory response as shown by enhanced responses that were maintained or enhanced by revaccination.ClinicalTrials.gov registrationNCT00521586.     

Duration of vaccine efficacy against malaria: 5th year of follow-up in children vaccinated with RTS,S/AS02 in Mozambique

A primary concern for the RTS,S malaria vaccine candidate is duration of protection. The ongoing Phase III trial reported evidence of waning efficacy within the first year following vaccination. Multiple Phase IIb trials demonstrated early waning of efficacy. The longest duration of protection for RTS,S recorded to date was in a trial of a cohort of 1605 Mozambican children age 1–4 yr at the time of immunization (C1), which showed an overall efficacy against clinical malaria of 30.5% over 43 subsequent months of surveillance. A significant reduction in parasite prevalence in RTS,S vaccinees indicated that the vaccine continued to protect at the end of this period. Although follow-up for recording incident cases of clinical malaria was stopped at 45 months, we were interested in evidence of further durability of protection, and revisited the cohort at 63 months, recording the secondary trial endpoint, prevalence of asexual Plasmodium falciparum parasitemia, in the RTS,S and comparator vaccine groups as a proxy for efficacy. As a comparator, we also visited the contemporaneous cohort of 417 children (C2), which showed waning efficacy after 6 months of follow-up. We also assessed anti-circumsporozoite antibody titers. These results were compared with those of other Phase IIb trials. Prevalence of parasitemia was not significantly lower in the RTS,S/AS02 group compared to comparator groups in C1 (57 [119%] Vs 62 [128%]; p = 0.696) or C2 (30 [226%] Vs 35 [276%]; p = 0.391), despite elevated antibody titers, suggesting that protection did not extend to 5 years after vaccination. This is in contrast to the earlier assessment of parasitemia in C1, where a 34% lower prevalence of parasitemia was observed in the RTS,S/AS02 group at month 45. Comparison with other Phase II trials highlights a complex relationship between efficacy, age and transmission intensity. RTS,S/AS02 provided partial protection from clinical malaria for at least 3.5 years in C1. Duration of protection may depend on environmental circumstances, such as changing malaria transmission, and special attention should be given in the Phase III trial to identifying factors that modify longevity of protection.     

Measles vaccination in the presence of maternal antibodies primes for a balanced humoral and cellular response to revaccination

Early or low dose antigen exposure can prime the immune system for subsequent responses; the so-called "prime-boost" effect. In the context of a Sudanese measles vaccine trial, we assessed whether or not such early exposure could influence the response to revaccination. Children received either Connaught high titer vaccine (CN: n = 53; 10(4.7)pfu) or meningococcal A + C vaccine as a placebo (MEN: n = 58) at 5 months of age. At 9 months of age, all received standard titer Schwarz vaccine (SCH: 10(3.9)pfu). Neutralizing antibodies were measured before initial vaccination and at 9 months of age (plaque reduction neutralization assay (PRN)) and again at 5 years of age (syncytium inhibition assay (SIA)). Lymphoproliferative responses to measles virus (MV) antigens were evaluated at 5 years of age. Eleven of the 53 CN-SCH children (21%) had sub-protective neutralizing antibody titers prior to revaccination (log PRN 1.5 +/- 0.03 versus 2.9 +/- 0.07 in the remaining 42 children; P < 0.004). Maternal antibody titers at the time of initial vaccination in these 11 were high (PRN 2.44 +/- 0.12 versus 1.9 +/- 0.04; P < 0.0001). At 5 years of age, neutralizing antibodies were comparable in the 11 CN-SCH poor responders (log SIA 2.1 +/- 0.09), the remaining CN-SCH children (2.2 +/- 0.06) and the MEN-SCH group vaccinated only once at 9 months of age (2.25 +/- 0.06). In contrast, 7/11 of the CN-SCH poor responders (64%) had stimulation indices (SI) > 3 in response to MV antigens at 5 years of age (SI 3.1 +/- 0.6) compared with only 14% in the remaining children of the CN-SCH group (2.0 +/- 0.3; P = 0.05) and 8% in the MEN-SCH group (1.4 +/- 0.2; P < 0.0003). These data suggest that early measles vaccination in the presence of maternal antibodies can sometimes prime for a balanced humoral and cellular immune response to subsequent revaccination.     

Frequency and cost of live vaccines administered too soon after prior live vaccine in children aged 12 months through 6 years, 2014–2017

ObjectiveTo identify number of children who received live vaccines outside recommended intervals between doses and calculate corrective revaccination costs.MethodsWe analyzed >1.6 million vaccination records for children aged 12 months through 6 years from six immunization information system (IIS) Sentinel Sites from 2014–15 when live attenuated influenza vaccine (LAIV, FluMist® Quadrivalent) was recommended for use, and from 2016–17, when not recommended for use. Depending on the vaccine, insufficient intervals between live vaccine doses are less than 24 or 28 days from a preceding live vaccine dose. Private and public purchase costs of vaccines were used to determine revaccination costs of live vaccine doses administered during the live vaccine conflict interval. Measles, mumps, rubella (MMR), varicella, combined MMRV, and LAIV were live vaccines evaluated in this study.ResultsAmong 946,659 children who received at least one live vaccine dose from 2014–15, 4,873 (0.5%) received at least one dose too soon after a prior live vaccine (revaccination cost, $786,413) with a median conflict interval of 16 days. Among 704,591 children who received at least one live vaccine dose from 2016–17, 1,001 (0.1%) received at least one dose too soon after a prior live vaccine (revaccination cost, $181,565) with a median conflict interval of 14 days. The live vaccine most frequently administered outside of the recommended intervals was LAIV from 2014–15, and varicella from 2016–17.ConclusionsLive vaccine interval errors were rare (0.5%), indicating an adherence to recommendations. If all invalid doses were corrected by revaccination over the two time periods, the cost within the IIS Sentinel Sites would be nearly one million dollars. Provider awareness about live vaccine conflicts, especially with LAIV, could prevent errors, and utilization of clinical decision support functionality within IISs and Electronic Health Record Systems can facilitate better vaccination practices.