Intraoperative cholangiography revisited.

The charts of 1351 patients undergoing cholecystectomy at our institutions from 1985 through 1989 were reviewed retrospectively to evaluate the indications for and the success of intraoperative cholangiography. A total of 800 patients underwent intraoperative cholangiography. They were divided into two groups based on the absence (CR-) or presence (CR+) of clinical and/or operative criteria suggestive of the existence of common bile duct stones. Intraoperative cholangiography in CR- patients was of limited benefit, being negative (normal) in 95.7%, true-positive (abnormal) in 3.3%, and false-positive in 1%. False-positive intraoperative cholangiography resulted in unnecessary common bile duct explorations. Intraoperative cholangiography in CR+ patients proved useful, avoiding unnecessary common bile duct exploration in 55%. In those select CR+ patients with palpable common bile duct stones or cholangitis, little additional information was gained by the intraoperative cholangiography. We conclude that routine screening intraoperative cholangiography in CR- patients be reconsidered, as should the use of intraoperative cholangiography in CR+ patients with a palpable common bile duct stone or cholangitis. Intraoperative cholangiography in the remainder of CR+ patients proved beneficial and should be continued.     

Selective intraoperative cholangiography. A case for its use on an anatomic basis

The routine use of intraoperative cholangiography has vastly improved the results of common duct exploration by reducing the number of negative explorations. The controversy surrounding the use of routine versus selective intraoperative cholangiography has centered on the incidence of unsuspected common-duct stones. A prospective study was designed to examine both preoperative clinical data and intraoperative anatomical information to determine criteria that would identify patients who would not require cholangiography. One hundred consecutive patients undergoing cholecystectomy were included in the study. When considering patients without preoperative clinical data suspicious for common duct stones three anatomical conditions were identified in which common duct stones would not be present: cystic duct less than 3 mm; smallest stone size greater than 6 mm; a single stone. Using intraoperative criteria as a basis for cholangiography, 44 per cent of patients without clinical suspicion of common duct stones would be spared an intraoperative cholangiogram. It is the authors' opinion that the addition of anatomic findings to preoperative clinical data can further reduce or eliminate the risk of unsuspected stones while sparing a large number of patients the risk and expense of routine intraoperative cholangiography and possible negative duct exploration.     

The role of endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography and cholangiography in the laparoscopic era.

OBJECTIVE: The authors reviewed the results of endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography (ERCP) and intraoperative cholangiography in a series of patients who underwent laparoscopic cholecystectomy. SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA: The indications for preoperative and postoperative ERCP and intraoperative cholangiography as adjuncts to laparoscopic cholecystectomy are evolving. The debate regarding the use of selective or routine intraoperative cholangiography has intensified with the advent of laparoscopic cholecystectomy. METHODS: The authors reviewed the records of 343 consecutive patients who underwent laparoscopic cholecystectomy during a 1-year period. Historical, biochemical, and radiologic findings for the patients who underwent ERCP and intraoperative cholangiography were analyzed. RESULTS: Three hundred forty- three patients underwent laparoscopic cholecystectomy during the period reviewed. Preoperative ERCP was performed in 42 patients. Twenty-seven of these patients (64%) had common bile duct (CBD) stones, which were cleared with a sphincterotomy. Intraoperative cholangiography was performed for 101 patients (29%). Three cholangiograms had false- positive results (3%), leading to two CBD explorations, in which no CBD stones were found, and one normal ERCP. Six patients underwent postoperative ERCP, three for the removal of retained CBD stones (0.9%), all of which were cleared with a sphincterotomy. Fifteen patients had gallstone pancreatitis, six of whom had CBD stones (40%) that were cleared by ERCP. There were 33 complications (10%) and no CBD injuries. CONCLUSION: The use of routine intraoperative cholangiography is discouraged in view of its low yield and the significant rate of false positive cholangiogram results.     

Technique and results of routine dynamic cholangiography during 528 consecutive laparoscopic cholecystectomies

With the advent of laparoscopic cholecystectomy a trend toward more extensive preoperative diagnostic study of the biliary tree by intravenous cholangiography or ERCP has been observed. However, both exams have technical limitations and are not without risk. We report our experience with 500 consecutive routine dynamic intraoperative cholangiographies during laparoscopic cholecystectomy, 97% of which were successful. No lesions from cholangiography were observed. In ten patients clips on the cystic artery appeared on intraoperative cholangiogram to be too close to the hepatic duct and were removed. Anomalies of surgical importance were discovered in 11 patients (2.3%). Unsuspected stones were found in 18 cases (3.7%) and suspected stones confirmed in 12 (2.4%). In our experience routine dynamic intraoperative cholangiography provided important information in 51 cases out of 500 (10.2%). We conclude that routine dynamic intraoperative cholangiography is extremely useful for safer laparoscopic cholecystectomy and cost containment.     

Does routine intraoperative cholangiography prevent bile duct transection?

Background The role of routine intraoperative cholangiography is controversial. The aim of this study was to assess the impact of routine intraoperative cholangiography on the incidence of common bile duct injuries, and to evaluate the operative outcome of laparoscopic cholecystectomy carried out in a major teaching hospital and review the literature.Methods Prospectively collected data on 3,145 laparoscopic cholecystectomies performed mainly by surgical trainees in the period 1990 to 2002 using routine intraoperative cholangiography with fluoroscopy were reviewed.Results The mean age of the study sample (65.6% male, 34.4% female) was 54 years, and 16.9% of the patients had clinical acute cholecystitis. The conversion rate to open cholecystectomy was 4.3%. Intraoperative cholangiography was attempted for 90.7% of the patients with a 95.9% success rate. Five patients (0.16%) had common bile duct injuries. Four injuries had occurred in the first 5 years. One injury (0.06%) had occurred after 1995. This injury was identified intraoperatively and repaired laparoscopically. Routine intraoperative cholangiography prevented one definite common bile duct transection.Conclusions In this series using routine intraoperative cholangiography, there was a low rate and severity of common bile duct injuries, with a high intraoperative recognition rate. There was no bile duct transection or major injury requiring common bile duct reconstruction. Although intraoperative cholangiography helped in the immediate identification of injuries and the institution of appropriate therapy, injury was not completely prevented.     

A cost-effectiveness analysis of intraoperative cholangiography in the prevention of bile duct injury during laparoscopic cholecystectomy

BACKGROUND: Recent population-based studies have demonstrated that the use of intraoperative cholangiography (IOC) during laparoscopic cholecystectomy (LC) is associated with a decrease in the rate of common bile duct (CBD) injury. The cost implications of a management strategy involving routine IOC use have not been adequately evaluated. STUDY DESIGN: Decision analytic models were developed to analyze costs and benefits of routine IOC use during LC. The models were used to calculate the cost per life saved, cost per CBD injury avoided, and incremental cost of IOC when used routinely. Transition probabilities, costs, and outcomes were derived from published sources. Sensitivity analyses were used to account for uncertainty in these estimates. RESULTS: Using base-case estimates, management of patients undergoing LC with routine IOC would cost 100 dollars more per LC. Routine IOC would prevent 2.5 deaths for every 10,000 patients at a cost of 390,000 dollars per life saved (13,900 dollars per life year saved). The cost per CBD injury avoided with IOC use is 87,143 dollars. The cost per CBD injury avoided is less for procedures done in high-risk patients (approximately 8,000 dollars) or by less experienced surgeons (approximately 61,000 dollars). CONCLUSIONS: These models describe settings where the cost of IOC and the reduction in CBD injury rates make routine IOC use cost effective. Routine IOC use among less experienced surgeons and in high-risk operations is the most cost effective, but the cost implications of routine use for the general population should also be considered cost effective.     

Is laparoscopic intraoperative cholangiogram a matter of routine?

BACKGROUND: Intraoperative cholangiography during laparoscopic cholecystectomy reveals the anatomy of the biliary tree and any stones contained within it. The use of intraoperative cholangiography may be routine for all laparoscopic cholecystectomy. An alternative approach is a selective policy, performing intraoperative cholangiography only for those cases in which choledocholithiasis is suspected on clinical grounds, or those for which the anatomy appears unclear at operation. The literature pertaining to both approaches is reviewed, to delineate their respective merits. METHODS: Relevant articles in English were identified from the Medline database, and reviewed. RESULTS: The literature reviewed consisted of retrospective analyses. Overall the incidence of unsuspected retained stones was 4%, but only 15% of these would go on to cause clinical problems. The incidence of complete transection of the common bile duct was rare for both routine and selective intraoperative cholangiography policies, and did not differ between them. Rates of minor bile duct injury did not differ between groups, but was more likely to be recognized in the routine group than the selective (P = 0.01). CONCLUSIONS: Routine intraoperative cholangiography yields very little useful clinical information over and above that which is obtained with selective policies. Large numbers of unnecessary intraoperative cholangiography are performed under routine intraoperative cholangiography policy, and therefore a selective policy is advocated.     

The utilization of cystic duct cholangiography

The patient records at two hospitals were reviewed to ascertain the incidence of unsuspected common duct stones and to evaluate the patterns of utilization of routine and selective intraoperative cystic duct cholangiography. The incidence of unsuspected common duct stones discovered only by cystic duct cholangiography was 4.3 per cent. Unnecessary common duct exploration was performed on 5.3 per cent of patients undergoing routine cystic duct cholangiography because of false-positive cholangiograms. The use of routine and preexploratory cystic duct cholangiography was significantly different at the two hospitals studied. Choledochotomy without preexploratory cystic duct cholangiography resulted in unnecessary common bile duct explorations in 44 per cent of patients. Although routine cystic duct cholangiography will identify unsuspected common duct stones, it is associated with an equal incidence of unnecessary common duct exploration. Preexploration cholangiography is an essential procedure which diminishes unnecessary choledochotomy and facilitates accurate demonstration of biliary tract pathology.     

Intraoperative cholangiography during laparoscopic cholecystectomy

An audit of routine intraoperative cholangiography in a consecutive series of 496 patients undergoing laparoscopic cholecystectomy has been performed. Cannulation of the cystic duct was possible in 483 patients (97%). The use of portable, digitized C-arm fluorocholangiography was vastly superior to the employment of a mobile x-ray machine and static films in terms of reduced time to carry out the procedure and total abolition of unsatisfactory radiological exposure of the biliary tract. Repeat of the procedure was necessary in 22% of cases when the mobile x-ray equipment was used. Aside from the detection of unsuspected stones in 18 patients (3.9%), routine intra-operative cholangiography identified four patients (0.8%) whose management would undoubtedly have been disadvantaged if intraoperative cholangiography had not been performed.     

Routine cholangiography reduces sequelae of common bile duct injuries

Background: An effort was made to determine whether a policy of routine cholangiography affects the incidence, morbidity, and cost of bile duct injuries. Methods: A retrospective review of consecutive 3,242 laparoscopic cholecystectomies was performed. Most patients had routine intraoperative cholangiography. Results: There were 12 bile duct injuries (0.37%). All injuries were Bismuth levels 1 and 2. Eleven of 12 injuries were recognized intraoperatively. Ten were repaired primarily and one required hepaticojejunostomy. All repairs were successful. Average hospital charges were $26,669. One of 12 patients had delayed recognition of a bile duct injury and underwent primary repair over a T-tube on postoperative day 7. Hospital charges were $43,957. Conclusion: Routine cholangiography did not appear to decrease the absolute incidence of bile duct injuries compared to previously published reports. Injury severity, morbidity, late sequelae, and costs were reduced by a policy of routine cholangiography.     

Laparoscopic cholecystectomy and management of biliary tract stones in a freestanding ambulatory surgery center.

OBJECTIVE: We conducted a retrospective 4-year study of patients undergoing laparoscopic cholecystectomy at a freestanding ambulatory surgery center. Data on rates of hospital admission, conversion to open surgery, bile duct injury, postoperative bile leakage, and incidence of choledocholithiasis were analyzed. The success rate for dynamic fluoroscopic intraoperative cholangiography was computed, and outpatient laparoscopic common bile duct exploration and anesthetic management were reviewed. METHODS: Patient charts from the ambulatory surgery center, office, and hospital were reviewed over a 4-year period commencing in October 1999. All cases were performed by 1 of 3 surgeons who are experienced with outpatient laparoscopic cholecystectomy and practice routine dynamic fluoroscopic intraoperative cholangiography. RESULTS: A total of 338 laparoscopic cholecystectomies were performed. Dynamic fluoroscopic intraoperative cholangiography was successfully performed in 89% (n = 302). No instances of bile duct injury or conversions to open surgery were reported. A 0.89% (n = 3) incidence of postoperative bile leak occurred. Six patients were admitted for inpatient care for a rate of 1.78%. Choledocholithiasis occurred in 2.0% and was managed successfully in the ambulatory setting. CONCLUSION: Laparoscopic cholecystectomy can be adapted to the freestanding ambulatory surgery environment with very high standards of care and very low complication rates.     

Hilar cholangiocarcinoma: resectability and radicality after routine diagnostic imaging

Background/Purpose En-bloc resection has contributed to the improvement of long-term survival in patients with hilar cholangiocarcinoma. In addition, attenuation of intraoperative traumatization of the tumor may decrease tumor spread. The objective of this study was to assess the importance of a routine diagnostic workup for the surgical strategy, radicality, and results in patients with hilar cholangiocarcinoma.Methods Between September 1997 and December 2002, 82 patients with hilar cholangiocarcinoma were treated at our department. Preoperative diagnostic workup included endoscopic retrograde cholangiography (ERC), percutaneous transhepatic cholangiography (PTC), computed tomography (CT), and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). The results of preoperative and retrospective (blinded) assessment of diagnostic data concerning the tumor growth along the bile ducts were compared with the results of surgery.Results The resection rate was 75%, and the hospital mortality, 7%. The prospective assessment of the resection to be performed was correct in 81% of cases. In ERC, magnetic resonance cholangiography (MRC), and PTC, tumor assessment was precise in 29%, 36%, and 53%, of cases, respectively. Overestimation occurred more frequently than underestimation. The 3-year survival of patients with formally curative or palliative en-bloc resection was 61% and 15%, respectively. For the 9 patients with hilar resection, the 3-year survival was 25%. Survival of patients was comparable, regardless of whether their tumor had been correctly assessed or over- or underestimated. In the multivariate analysis, R0 resection was the only significant prognostic factor (P = 0.011).Conclusions Our routine diagnostic approach led to high resection and survival rates. Obviously a sophisticated diagnostic workup is not an absolute prerequisite for adequate surgery.     

Preoperative selective endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography and laparoscopic cholecystectomy without cholangiography

The aim of this study was to show that laparoscopic cholecystectomy can be performed safely without routine intraoperative cholangiography. We performed a retrospective analysis of 1750 consecutive patients (1170 females and 580 males with a mean age of 51 years) who underwent laparoscopic cholecystectomy between January 1991 and January 2000. In all, 193 patients (11%) were selected to undergo preoperative endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography (ERCP) on the basis of several criteria for risk of stones. No patients underwent intraoperative cholangiography. ERCP allowed us to make a diagnosis of biliary stones in 62.7% (121 cases). Extraction of the stones was successful in 96% of the cases. In 12% of cases ERCP findings were normal; in the remaining 26.3%, useful diagnostic information was obtained. There were three complications (bleeding and pancreatitis) after endoscopy (complication rate: 1.5%). Laparoscopic cholecystectomy was successful in 92.7% of patients, with a postoperative morbidity rate of 3% (0.5% of major complications). There were no deaths in this series. During a mean follow-up of 60 months (range, 12-120), 7 patients (0.43%) were found to have residual biliary stones (5 had not had preoperative ERCP). The study confirms the hypothesis that laparoscopic cholecystectomy can be safely performed without routine intraoperative cholangiography, with selective use of preoperative ERCP.     

Is routine intra-operative cholangiography in laparoscopic cholecystectomy truly unnecessary?]

The introduction of laparoscopic cholecystectomy as method of choice for gall stone treatment reopened the question whether to continue with routine intraoperative cholangiography or to switch over to a selective indication. In order to set an accurate indication for selective intraoperative cholangiography it was our goal to develop a tool for preoperative identification of patients with a high risk of common bile duct stones. A preoperative score, indicating the risk of common bile duct stones, was designed. A history of jaundice, elevated levels of bilirubin, alkaline phosphatase, amylase (serum), ALAT (GPT) or ASAT (GOT), a common bile duct wider than 10 mm or containing concrements and multiple gallstones smaller than 10 mm were valued as risk indicators, whereas normal wide bile duct, large or solitary gallstones were valued as decreasing the risk of common bile duct stones. The retrospective screening of 289 consecutive conventional cholecystectomies (1986-1990) for these risk indicators demonstrated a good correlation of the risk score with the occurrence of common bile duct stones. A prospective application of the score, with improved ultrasound examination and routine preoperative intravenous cholangiography, mandatory for laparoscopic cholecystectomy at our institution, will define the high risk group definitely and allow an accurate selective use of intraoperative cholangiography.     

Choledocholithiasis

The diagnosis and management of choledocholithiasis has improved greatly in recent years. Newer diagnostic techniques, including ultrasonography, computerized axial tomography, transhepatic cholangiography and endoscopic retrograde cholangiography have been developed. There have been operative improvements, including the use of the Fogarty catheter, choledochoscopy and image amplifiers in the operating room for more precise intraoperative cholangiography. Nevertheless, choledocholithiasis remains a major problem. Choledocholithiasis increases the mortality rate of gallstones as compared to mortality rates resulting from stones in the gallbladder only. Furthermore, retained stones still occur in 4 to 10% of patients operated upon in whom stones are found in the common bile duct. The majority of these, however, can now be removed nonoperatively.     

The Impact of Intraoperative Cholangiography on Recurrent Pancreatitis and Biliary Complications in Patients with Gallstone Pancreatitis

Introduction

Although gallstone pancreatitis is initiated by the presence of stones in the common bile duct, the benefit associated with routine intraoperative cholangiography at the time of cholecystectomy in these patients is unclear. The purpose of this study, using population-based data, was to determine the impact of cholangiography on clinical outcomes after cholecystectomy for gallstone pancreatitis.

Methods

All patients who were admitted to hospital from January 1, 1997 to December 31, 2001 in Nova Scotia, Canada with pancreatitis who underwent cholecystectomy during the same admission were identified. The rates of recurrent pancreatitis and biliary complications after surgery were compared between patients who underwent cholecystectomy with intraoperative cholangiography ± common bile duct exploration and those who underwent cholecystectomy alone, using three linked administrative databases.

Results

Three hundred thirty-two patients were identified, 119 had cholangiography at the time of cholecystectomy and 213 did not. After a median follow-up of after 3.8?years, there was no difference in the rate of recurrent pancreatitis or biliary complications between those who had cholangiography ± common bile duct exploration at the time of surgery and those who did not; 13.4 versus 10.8?%, respectively (p?=?0.55).

Conclusions

These data suggest that intraoperative cholangiography does not improve outcomes after cholecystectomy for gallstone pancreatitis.     

Cholangiography: a routine test in elective cholecystectomy?]

A prospective study to evaluate the selective or routine use of intraoperative cholangiography on elective cholecystectomy was performed. 178 patients were studied, listing criteria to explore the biliary tract with the cholangiographic aspects. The criteria showing choledocholithiasis were the alkaline phosphatase and/or bilirubin increase, dilated common bile duct, large cystic duct, small stones and pancreatitis or jaundice on the past history. The patients were divided in 4 groups: 1) No criteria: 61 (34.3%); 2) One criterion: 53 (30%); 3) Two criteria: 22 (12.3%); 4) More than two criteria: 42 (23.4%). The false-positive was 1.6% to the first group, 3.8% to the group 2 and 0% to the other groups. We concluded that the intraoperative cholangiography must be achieved on patients that have at least one choledocholithiasis criterion.     

Die Spiral-CT-Cholangiographie ist für die Routinediagnostik vor laparoskopischer Cholecystektomie nicht geeignet

INTRODUCTION: The purpose of this prospective controlled study was to evaluate the diagnostic potential of spiral computed tomographic (CT) cholangiography in patients undergoing laparoscopic cholecystectomy. METHODS: 60 patients (17 men, 43 women, mean age 54.5 years, range 15-84 years) with symptomatic cholecystolithiasis were included in this study. After infusion of meglumine jodoxamate, all patients underwent upper abdominal spiral CT. The results of the spiral CT scan were then compared with endoscopic retrograde cholangiography (ERC) or intraoperative cholangiography. RESULTS: In 53 patients (88%) CT cholangiography was considered to be technically adequate for interpretation, but was suboptimal in 4 patients (7%) and nondiagnostic in 3 patients (5%), respectively. CT cholangiography showed a stone free common bile duct in 51 patients which was correct in all cases. CT cholangiography predicted a common bile duct stone in 6 patients which proved to be correct in 4 patients but was found to be incorrect in 2 patients. CONCLUSION: Spiral CT cholangiography is useful for the diagnosis of common bile duct stones. Because of the low positive predicting value routine use before laparoscopic cholecystectomy is not justified.     

Laparoscopic cholecystectomy without operative cholangiogram: 2038 cases over a 5-year period in two district general hospitals.

The place of cholangiography in laparoscopic cholecystectomy is debatable. This retrospective study reviews the outcome of 2061 patients operated upon for symptomatic gallstones in two district general hospitals. Intraoperative cholangiography was not used because all patients were submitted to a policy of selective preoperative investigation of the extrahepatic ducts. The conversion rate to open cholecystectomy was 3.1% and 88% of patients were discharged home within 48 h of surgery. No major duct injuries occurred and only 12 patients have presented with a proven retained stone after operation (0.7%). This policy of preoperative investigation and treatment for extrahepatic bile duct stones without intraoperative cholangiography has been employed in over 2000 patients and is at least as safe as published results using routine intraoperative cholangiography.     

Asymptomatic lithiasis of the common bile duct: diagnostic difficulty and essentiality of intraoperative cholangiography]

Biliary lithiasis is a widespread pathology the diagnosis of which, following the introduction of ultrasonography, is increasingly easy. The frequent possibility of association between gallstones and choledocholithiasis, demands pre- or intraoperative recognition. The inadequacy of ultrasonography in excluding lithiasis of the common biliary tract with certainty, notwithstanding its other unquestionable advantages, and the disproportionate costs and risks of other investigations (cholangiography, ERCP, ecc.) which are such as to discourage routine use, confirm the role of operative cholangiography in the diagnosis of asymptomatic choledocholithiasis, so permetting its treatment. Personal experience of 100 consecutive cases of gallstones which showed fully 10 of them to be negative to preoperative investigation were found to have lithiasis of the common biliary tract.